ML20151B888

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Licensing of Nuclear Power Plants Where State &/Or Local Govts Decline to Cooperate in Offsite Emergency Planning
ML20151B888
Person / Time
Site: 05000000, Shoreham, Crane
Issue date: 03/07/1987
From: Barnes J, Barnes J, Barnes M
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:
NRC
References
FRN-52FR6980, RULE-PR-50 52FR6980-00205, 52FR6980-205, NUDOCS 8807210149
Download: ML20151B888 (3)


Text

M BULE gg FEB f3 I9 C f800 SkPM6976 00LMETED USNRC

'87 NAR 11 P6:38 0FFICf c.

-Jy 00CKETI'..

-? s;Cf.

p 4.,.4

&+. ? /ff?

/

..g i> Kjaw.

. w:

?

%, p.. /. m.r

~.

p~ L:.

9 s a & 1. w : x i u L ;./

+

Y 24,,4 '

! & ta j

5

_M pqp 4a' Mh

) sW W. %

L..A~,.A

.z,a % % Y.

wmyyref u -

% 4 y a= Q f4 M '_e ww-y y 9a co E54~em, t

%L:

A. M"

" "'" " ^ W A b

( m )

hd$((

8807210149 070307 PDR PR 50 52FRb9BO PDR

9 E

4 8

4

+

@)

n =

.- x g.

r m A M /' k k p

Lay 4 p,1

,y.3% >->1ey A $ us 4 4.e -

4 1 " ~ p - A _. w w ma n s -.

hf 9" M 1A* h.,0 W

.>. M a.

U gOW

^

~

qW ' _

s-y Ju-~s w

.ji&-

~

y/

e,---

,-,,,.,,-----,e

~. -,

....6

.........,...a.....

I tism, all $4.6 billion worth, sits idle, its fate uncertain.

1 I

HE NRC IS SCRAMBLING TO RECOUP. It has ten.

Ttatively adopted a new rule allowing it to waive thelocal-coo the door for Shoreham, plus a reactor in New Harnpshire.

..The rule change, if it is given final approval this spring, would serve the economic interests of just about every.

i body, since it would save Shoreham from being the biggest i

white elephant of all time. But it would be wrong in terms i

of public trust in safety.

i No situation short of war would panic the populace like a nuclear accident. even a tiny one. Thr ee Mile Isla.:d proved that If nukes are to operate, a workable evacuation plan must be ready, with trained personnel on the scene to carry it out. Even then, the potential for mass disarray exists.

Licensing Shoreham without a valid plan is, therefore, unthinkable. And pay no attention to the folks who argue that the NRC's issuing such a license would force Suf7olk and state oiTicials into coooerating on an evacuation plan.--

That's an irresponsible game of chicken, with people's deepest fears-perhaps even their. lives-as the stakes.

All this leav as Shoreham and similarly perplexed reac.

ton in limbo-an unhappy, e.tpensive fate. But the NRC was right the llrst time when it laid down its locally based.~,

evecu'ation plan nild, Reve.k!ng it would be an blunder /.

'.'rm u

.w.. u.# v :u...u. w,, -

.,4,,.

s 4

n--

--m,,,

.,n-_.

yn

,,,,