ML20149M116

Advises That No Need Exists to Notify Purchasers of Damaged Namco Controls Contact Block Kits EA749-20036.Records Give No Indication of Damage Prior to Shipment.Blocks Damaged Either in Handling or at Installation.Part 21 Related

ML20149M116
Person / Time
Site:	Vermont Yankee File:NorthStar Vermont Yankee icon.png
Issue date:	04/16/1986
From:	Swanson N NAMCO CONTROLS
To:	Murley T NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
References
REF-PT21-88-027-000 PT21-88-027-000, PT21-88-27, NUDOCS 8802250335
Download: ML20149M116 (2)

Text

.

A .% .

NAMCO S CONTROLS Namco Controts F.vison, 7S67 Tyler Boulevard, Mentor, Orvo 44060

• Phone:(216) 946-9900

• Teen 241566 April 16, 1986 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Office of Inspection & Enforcement Region i 631 Park Avenue Kir.g of Prussia, PA 19406

'att ention: Dr. Thomas E. Murley Regional Administrator h.hject: Vermont Yankte letter dated 3/28/86 Namco Controls' contact block kits fEA749-20036 (not iEA749-20043)

Dear Sir:

This letter is in response to the notice sent to you by Warren P. Murphy of Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power Corporation dated March 28, 1986. (Copy to Namco Controls).

Namco Controls' position, after investigating the matter, is that there is no need. to notify other purchasers of these ki t s , nor does it appear to us that it was necessdry to report this damage under 10CFR21 Our records indicate that the contact block kits in question were shipped to Vermont Yankee in June of 1983. Our records of inspection of completed contact blocks and assembled kits sent to Vermont Yankee, give no indication of damage prior to shipment. .

It is our belief that the blocks in question were damaged either in handling after packaging, or at installation. Regardless, it is the responsibility of ,

a user to visually check component parts before making an installation, and to set aside any with obvious damage. (This is essentially what Vermont Yankee l has done.) We would be interestd to know the procedure and criteria used in  :

1983 by Vermont Yankee at receiving inspection, which apparently did not reveal l 15 of 35 kits allegedly received with broken or chipped contact blocks.

We have not received any reports or returns of damaged blocks in kits from other customers. We believe this to be a case of damage from mishandling, not of 1

I olg 8902250335 860416 PDR i P

ADOCK 05000271 DCD

a. u w a r v r i ,wo cow wo

[I C O- [ j

\

.M *k'

• NAMOO CNnot_s U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission April 16, 1986 r

i product defect, although we are not able to say where the damage occurred.

Please advise if you require any additional information from us.

Ver t fy yours, g/

[L' fr/nw+ -

N. E. Swanson  ;

President l NAMCO CONTROLS NES/kg cc J. DiGiacomo E. Laskowski B. Pettrey E. Roob James O'Neil, Yankee Atomic Electric  :

!