ML20149H165
| ML20149H165 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Three Mile Island, 05000000 |
| Issue date: | 11/01/1984 |
| From: | Connelly S NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTOR & AUDITOR (OIA) |
| To: | Kammerer C NRC OFFICE OF CONGRESSIONAL AFFAIRS (OCA) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20149B626 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-87-728, FOIA-87-853 NUDOCS 8802190156 | |
| Download: ML20149H165 (25) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:, i..
,, aseg UNITIO STATES
+f k e NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION YvASHINGTON, D. C. 20945 0 '
4 k.....,/ November 1,1984 MEMORANDUM FOR: Carlton C. Kammerer, Director Congressional Affairs
^
FROM: Sharon R. Connelly, Director /r#- Office of Inspector and Auditor
SUBJECT:
RELEASE OF 0FFICE OF INSPECTOR AND AUDITOR DOCUMENTS TO CONGRESS Reference is made to a telephone conversation on October 29, 1984, between Fred Combs of your staff and Mark Resner of my staff. During the telephone conversation Mr. Combs made an inquiry on behalf of Dr. Henry Myers, Science Advisor, Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs, concerning the whereabouts of notes made on March 28, 1979, by Donald R. Neely, a fonner Region I, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission (NRC) employee. According to Combs, the notes were obtained by the Office of Inspector and Auditor (OIA) during a May 2, 1979, interview of Neely. A review of our files has identified an October 27, 1980, interview of Neely with exhibits, which appear to be responsive to Dr. Myers' request. More specifically, exhibits A and B represent all the notes Neely made on March 28, 1979. The first page of Neely's October 27, 1980, interview wherein these exhibits are referenced has been attached along with the exhibits. In consideration of the Department of Justice interest in the events related to the Three Mile Island incident, please coordinate any release in this matter with the Comission Office of the General Counsel and the Office of Investigations to ensure that release of these documents would not jeopardize any action by the Department of Justice. Attachments: 0 IAd
- 1. Pg.1. Rpt of Interview - Donald R. Neely. 03 g(g s M7@g p -
- 2. Exhibit A to il above. W pc3 W c s q '*~
- 3. Exhibit B to #1 above.
C A ( t}..t %, ,'p' g .u g ( Y CONTACT: Mark Resner, OIA W" < @ g\w l 49-24452 \
~ ~ , . ,
l REPORT OF INTERVIEW Donald R. Neely, inspector, Performance Appraisal Branch, Region I,
- Office of Inspection and Enforcement (IE) was interviewed on October 27, 1980, by Roger A. Fortuna and David H. Gamble of the Office of Inspector and Auditor (OIA). Neely was advised of his right against self-incrimination as required by the Attorney General's memorandum of June 4, 1980. Neely then consented to being interviewed.
Neely was advised that IE had expressed a concern to 0IA that the notes j he sent to IE Headquarters via telecopy may not have been exact copies 1 of his original notes taken at Three Mile Island (TMI) on March 28, 1979. When requested Neely imediately retrieved a somewhat battered f gift box from the two-drawer file cabinet in his office. Neely removed 1 the following documents from the box and provided them to 0IA: A small green bound book (Exhibit A). j A stapled set of 15 pages of notes on white, lined paper 1 (Exhibit B). l A stampled set of 19 pages beginning with a fonn entitled "Facsimile Request". (Exhibit C). Neely said that Exhibits A and B together represent all the notes he took i on March 28 and he has made no deletions, additions, or other changes to I them. Neely believed it was when he moved from the Unit 1 to the Unit 2
! control room that he disconti.,ued taking notes in the bound book (Exhibit A)
- and began taking them on a pad of paper in a vinyl notebook (See Exhibit B).
I Neely pointed out that Exhibit C includes photocopies of Exhibits A and a D, together with the adninistrative form used to telecopy material from the regional office to headquarters. Neely said he pa91nated Exhibits
- A and B consecutively without regard to the pre-existing pagination on Exhibit B. He said this was to assure that all copies were received via the telecopy process and to provide a point of reference in case anyone wished to call him to discuss the notes. Neely said he performed this pagination at the same time he wrote "Sent to Moseley" on the first page l of the notes. DIA noted that both such markings were made by a red, '
felt-tipped pen. Neely said the only one he has provided these notes to was Gregory Yuhas ! who was working on IE's "NUREG-0600" investigation of the TMI accident. I Neely believed that, in addition to Yuhas' own interest, Yuhas was {
- obtaining copies at the request of Oliver Lynch who was working for the j Special Inquiry Group (SIG).
- Neely was asked whether he was intarviewed any time in addition to the j following: May 2 and 5, 1979 by IE; August 22, 1979, by Senator Hart's j staff; September 25-26, 1979, by SIG; O m ber 12, 1979, by SIG; and i
ki ENCLOSURE 1
. ........4.. .
- e
- e g.
l t
)
I Exhibit A l i
. . i i
4 1
.1
'I el u
i M ( 4 l 1 N . CL., d g,
; 4 g 3
MJ a4 fe I '- ii ktn m o b r-h N f
~
L Y g i l , 1N j ' i 0: i . l M 1 i<
, Ii m i
I i < t
. C'*
eer i 1 % 1 4 l
.s. .yr,::. .T '
n y -. ., -n-e , " 1: . .; l . ;n,'a,praf . ;- .. sg.s.c. . .
..m .
- . . : s . . .+ - . 3 s 7 s;an.c L.
- p~N "i n r't3. ., W.w r... v . ...,1,. s. .
-4 g -
i u ,e ,I2 i.T.r
. Is. 4 e w ea t
_ =_ _ _ , . _ _ _ _ _ - , _ - - _ - _ ._- _ . ____ a Wi
75".
' ' : * '. ~
.._m .
1 a a f - 1
+
(. f ( A w c-
% '[
- i k Y
- gN E Q *U 4P
]#*, *5 h 8n:4 m
l W
- V I
O (P S- m* g msg 6 - t 1 m _d 1 o) ep . *s I h.
-E ,,
[g/ Ig J 'N *
=P j A xgdh hkb5 '
4# { E . . . T
= _ . . _ . . . , _ .
i' 8 r
- h, !
3 M j f .
- 3 -
- l
,1
'{[}Ay*LZ 4 .
g .e, = u{ e 1 4 , 24
._ s y
& n
.gmy.y.. . . ..+ .= w . ,. r..t . 3 ,. ; 3 y y ...
m, g.. . . .; m , ; .; . .,4.: .m 1 M
. -. ._ . _ _ _ . - _ - - - _ -3l
a - --_a - ,-- a u -,_--.aam-_~ -.- a .- - m- -n,- m.-- --a a.,,a_. l~ b d ( 4 ; _, _ * * ' *
' 4..6m., s--' .s%. . . .
**;.......,,-e.a Jj,. M,
-_u *
.. ..y, .. .....
y %.,.,. R -
=
s s 5 $ ' k a h , , y 5 Y k bg a l
! t
.n 7, 4
te. %
- , , , ~.
hh<@as,ki(f . h, kh n 5 l s ~, l - - -
, a o
g , s s - 3 9 0 9 e J j J f. gym { Z
/ [ 9'..?'E7. *.a'a J tj.r.U .aP...,a b .f.T..r. M *. retS2[ b h 4 74.M4h dkI-) [
~
* .c V
l l _. b i* . k. * * 's 'u _ *
- l
,bY l
\ c 4, 4
- y t u *{ c i).
4 - g *L
- 44n, 4 s v .
% ~
k w lp t") j) ,7 4 R.s. 4 -(4 4 _
- m. 4, I3 '4.
$ C ,: k : 4 #M d D h i
i i 1 l . . _ _ i l i l
.e ; q; mz w m r.= W' """" * "I' '__' _5 - '_' ~ ^ t '"'
- 5 = "~~
l , .
~=1
.g......_... . . . . . . . . . . . . .
..;.,--=
. b + s N
. t i 9 l
y b
.4l Q,,
p
.& N
;s>
ke,Yok hM, .t_ l 4 Y 4 l k I
, u i h1 <
f wl i g T L 9t *
=
; g
] ok U i
.,4 ,? ,,Y.=g T QY k, ~~
~**
^
===- - ' ' "
h. n .
. , _ _ . . . . - - - - - - - - - - ~
,,,,4,, s - " - *
g O e a l I J i .d ') l i
! N i
I E
- r-k' e,, d t
1 g i < l
( o
- l
\
)
I 1 l l I i Exhibit B l l
. I S
A (.- v' g - (, _ , _ s/z? ' ' 4/d O W &~ ~ A t 4Lal , NN Rd h/ %4-) HR BJj z.%_ y U5 014 V 4),y{ *Y
<.I .x,y g'NLX 4" i
J. u k ' * \ 5Ax z .u,d .1 . . JZlk k $ c-+1% % , % . .
. xup & . ..
cpm .3 /e ' tof . n44
- s. Af A w 44 p t - M A w --Y
-9 cd2 L,-
io n 4 .L~~1h4L n.m ss :l .R nL w = .-4 =; \ rn % 1 k mb . k ~(cl%. (' m . 9.* ( A e c 4- j',. -
6U .
,a
, .1 ,
WiJ * ,,,, y
)y ncl)sA. . + = (A" ofyk.k j%l hv p } u d).. dQ .gJcmD Vt.k.c k fy , D '
JL yLJ 4]vdus .y A
- LAr FAkt . H z ,g l
f , , ,,. s
-n oo L .
4 Mm
> 1 w. An i
. u : rr .
AnR tz <~ MN . l c. t - -Ju w . . u oi . ya
< nw . F4n .- t . Qw o/ ,
. -W 7 1
- j. 2- Yt. e ' ' A . W .. Y . .
M i Leff/ -
U' 7% gg b} +'$ Adjb j e D " \ )j-??ltsurc 5040b i l - l
.. p.sta !
D
\
'%du14))
c .
.I t _
i
' i
.k .
n d L. J. n Jt..h d FaL L 44 d w n n a w w 3 l T Le & u arcacyM#vF ha' T-]& ,f .
b
. .i
, . - -l:
^
g e-; _ l ka p% %94 0 A wo _ - up-
>ws '
= (. l.1 . p 4 y ,/ot-JlA,-
J - ZdtJ -e r W (Ls -
/
1
&k ^
~f 0 0 '7c> <>
m & J Zux J ,.~ J . bW AObh (Wp0 if. ,e. c y, 9x
% /L g m
. .4--f'
.s l
i
)
W j .
- bJ. Br JQ .2 .
l . 9 us 4kc , L- -m .
~ ~
4de e p A . eff m L . . 1 l
(} I A. '
\o fE - v s.
a eS. foA
~
t.__. - w l
. . . . . . . . . . .. .. .. l e%
% ,L
~ r:.. w LA -
z-
=
74Q2 \ 6 AA% MD
- 7*M j
4 st % ,-i -p. I fMAm Y .L^ Y. ~ i l
. . . g.
1 *an % %r ! M"98 PSm 's- Q ELT _
'l l
C,,a c 4 k o. I k. 0.t
. E e. C~y2W?t~l r boa,1+lL) tr.
- % . x 9e J Q e~ % ,e.-2 4 fass o./ s of5e m
r ..< a %m
= 4 % eqe ' . L ,ar -<u9;us r, W ,qk~' s i.r
& g,
= has a4 .s+ e asaw en a\
- CAA n, o v Im h /
. p.(
- Sn.,<k 4 & 'p s. - f,W e> ,n
foo
.A ;
Gud 4Ww;4e c auJQ f8 8. % q M~ Ly Aur f&c
..~4AL M my, pw m m$u/
, co. sm /.mf()
&&. & sus 1&&t . 9e .m .k 2 .. .
~
Ilu M .9 $ .A k r. Se Rl itt h .
. -. N.b
=u mals eas e a wwq,y
) . .. .. . . . . . . . .
.. . . . . . . . I l ]
L
O . . . . y
. 1 L
,p ,
~
W a, W :^ r
- 93 e n aJ P" ~rM k~ ah P~ > 1 Q, A .Ls .w% - m -
M 4. ' c-0 *) Y c) uf ' T A- ) ,, Ye. Ce
- f. /fo m E4 Pfo o }/.fo 4p ' '
Z ,x
\gnitra
; c;.
~ ~
- . . : h 1; M .d? . .
W . ....
^ ~
~
l
. L. . . . . . . 1 nw .in x_yu
. . ?
4 . . . g AMe2<~e -e+n' &makW.a
~
IPws A+
- /Lg 4/4 4 b 16$ t wr %>- Ao n ,
s _ , , , g ..n.-- -
. u
. c l
k h g . 4. < <o - 7 + 5p v d h -
' p/ 4. j l
b "W .~ c. Z ehl.& we-W j aMce . l troo ' hL h .
<l &At . fv<tra.2 wh' /7K c .-
1 l
& O .
& m
).n.o.. LJ a...f' w y . &7 .
1 5 - - . 4 % . . a & Q s f ,fW. ..
.r i Mf.xGl.4- 7
. . ... / ~. 6 m qm. . kx .,A, hM. (ydc . , z ., , ,
-T @ w .
~LA-Y, Wll/19ff.
Q Q .k.&- UG & . Xe's . .
. . . . . . . l I
1
-A
(
'%ia , a w a ER 6%
ni.' -
&->aty*
N
.)4 m)L 7 ~~ T d a t ,4 tu W A $
1h~Q~dP v (AL'u %uu ex% 4~
- p. % nee -
. 3 -9 J .g /ho n
}&u i Ay A -
,9,,W' & Lst M - #dr,, n' v
/ .
/
ho .p. . f)be e
.DQ.U g.,) W h'%, .
. . . . _ %.. . .Ly
. k .
9/o - 9 ?? 'lfo o
&W, Nkh Colikk N# AQ -
%g) l
i A
. . b L :/ . M a ' ' ' @/_4, ?
/ ENcY no 3 -- & .s [G N X
. h m &e c $~{ M - (3 r& .
)L L L cl mL J W- n o n $ 2 41.g Y l ' %. L $dp / fo s & ou .
l N43 -Y] aA Q . .. 725$. . ... f n d) &' ;c
. ,. . . . . . .o . . . . . ....... . . . . .-.. .. .
. . . . . P+]
\ p . . . . . .. . -.
, ,.,-- , - - - - --- ----- - . - - - - . - - ~ ~ . . . - - .
l
- 6
. 2m L wh% m' ' sn' x
a n w n . p .
- nu1 &- -
\ r
" ~
.~ /,ede = ~ (,,..s Gr &
w
</ - Sp - As (M fM~
es lhhD ~~- y ) [7, , s
~
04*y ~ W S
% ' WN p i 'i s . . .. . .
~ Ma .. . .
g g g m se e G . ee 4 9 . @ W 4 4 WW 4 S . De em W- e. g g g . e e e eW 6 9 4 8 # # # # 9 e
. . W$ .?m . . - . . . . 2/O . o.,
g g g e . g e e e D 6e , g g e
- S *
- e
$ G G e e mee 4 e e
.. .. .. . l
.. . 1
@&dLj 2-7fc mP b Mo u
%s=~ # &~ f..
S
. . . 1
)/
. m . .
a m . . . . m . . . m e . .
,g g a.m e ee6 . . ep eG. e.W . . G . ..@ G
- eu. m. .
4 @ .
. .. . . . . . . . . . G .
8 2 n na ca n,
%d </ smh .
$ Q ..h SAM SQ h M-% 1,~/W.-AsJk ~
, (
't E>y s
~M lM '
A& /
~
- Ts,
- 2a we- dio.rsL %,a 1.
wo oPex. . ., 9g e . *
& .. 8 *O
- Ws . .
y4 . - k& -Md '#t l yA 58 6 1
\0) h -{f *- - - - -
% d. . W '- /3 bt . . ..
s f. .. .. .. . . . . .
.fdf 9p h,.. .
e agyuw. . .. .
~
m. s ..
. 7 L
232.P.-
%.zo & 82.-5 ' 3r ^:a t y---
e ,tr. v e:, w Y t3iL 8& C w.<k & <;::~ 0..;. .
, 2kt*' TMlg i ~ 9 1 f->. d . Y r // sr <-/ ,: .,g. /;7. .
2 5 7J' C : ? U w :.u !.c.e.. w S' . . :: . . s,.% e k ' '. I , q, . ,_ . ?l.7,: ;: '::.,* tj w _
% ?-s 9 m / ,y ,c. Ew - -{. .
l./ ti vs
-- r /. ol. ...c.b s ,7 o
,. m,
(_ \'i.V ' l (.i..A..3 .
- , s
' I. s i# > l i .t* f*
o
'i !
i J . . s b _ _ - . . - , - . , _ , , - ,. ._ --...._y _ _ _ .- _ , _ , _ . __.r_ ___ - . _ _ _ , . . - - - - . . _ . -_
d.
$(%'63 ? ray ,
. A41 k yu rl'. ,&$sy ,$N.' %.':4'
. . s.
L .
\ .
f 9,% n. .. .'. C. Rec)
,.. 1 .
(\ . .
/ $ .$W 3 .p x , ,- 9 a s !ce sa a:Le!r .
J.p c.~-6 4'sc z ' 1.
- i. .! y p 4 < , t.l [c z . .
8v . . .. . i 0$\ DC y & C W '
- Js. r.c h. u ~~
h'Ja} / -~ . N .e sp ~ e ,
.e ese w a . . e
. . * * - *
- 9
.. 4
. . M M
_ _,,-.,_,--,,,_,__._,,__-,-----v.-,,--,--w..,,,__--,w-_.}}