ML20148T011
| ML20148T011 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Allens Creek File:Houston Lighting and Power Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 11/13/1978 |
| From: | Newman J LOWENSTEIN, NEWMAN, REIS, AXELRAD & TOLL |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7812040274 | |
| Download: ML20148T011 (6) | |
Text
,
- 3\\
/* e %.
s 'O
',,,,'g.
,-Je t f f n W'
N ^ : s~
!.,)
/
~r c.
<V.
n.;r
.a t,
J.
l,,.,4 J.
r, O A d. r S 0.7 n'.M.r R a" v* n'
\\
a w
i
. ~. C NUCLEAR REGULATORY COD 1ISSION s
a g
V@g,. >'
r
,e
'r
-e e
.e,. e n: ; s r
- I C r". S a~'.'. G " OARD
-.. r. o. -
- e..ti.r n. r.M. '. C
.'.1. 7 7.". '.'
A.'.".]
7 s
r
---3
,,k
~,
cw S.is i e
.n a.
.u. a.
)
r m..
)
HOUSTCN LIGHTING AND PO?TER COMPANY
)
Docket No. 50-466
)
(Allens Creek Nuclear Generating
)
Station, Unit 1)
)
)
APPLICANT'S RESPCNSE TO " STIPULATION B.e.m. rL. p r sI v.. e. ~<,
e-,
A n.D.,, v. s.
r.
RE,.,m. e..On
~. n.r.r
^a
.u I.
The Applicant files the following response to the "Sti.culation Between the NRC S taf f and Wavne E.
Rentfro" filed on Sepr. ember 29, 1973, in this proceeding.
T_ T.
The subject stipulation should be re 'ected by the 2 card for the following reasons.
1.
Neither centention is based on changes in the design of the ACNGS or "new infor nation" or "new evidence" as required by the Board's Order of August 14, 1978.
2.
Contention 2 is supported only by reference to a proceeding before the Pennsylvania Public Utility Cc=:ni s s ion (PUC).
There is no showing that the facts of that proceeding are relevant in any way to the situation in this case.
78?2040c179'
2-III.
The stipulated contentions do not meet the Board's threshold requirement of being based upon "new information" or "new evidence" or " changes in plans for the ACMGS".
- p. o-
. _, c.. *_ a_.v 4 m-n _', i.
_4 - 4.. d _4 - - " * = " ' a_
- "a*
' k. a..out_in c.
e or_
1
.. ~...
of transmission corridor 1-A has 10: changed since the earlier hearings in this proceeding. / To the extent that the routing of transmission corridor 1-A of fends the asthetic concerns of Mr. Rentfro, that consideration remains u...=.# _# a c ~_ a_ d_
o _4.. _ a_
. ". = _ ~ 4.. e
^v."
- k. a_
a_ =. _1 _4 a_ _- k.a. a.ri..c, s i.n this matter.
To the extent that he seeks to raise concerns based upon the increase in the number of hcmes in the area, the concerns go f ar be.v. ond :4r. Rentfro's interest.
Applicant is not aware that Petitioner has even alleged that he is authorized to represent the interest of others in this proceeding.
Accordingly, contention 1 should be disallowed.
As to contention 2, information on the subj ct o:_ _.u. a_
- u.. a_ n,. s.
a_ _c _c _ e, - c.e
. u. a.
.-, a. a u_.tc,,
o_:
.a n _ n h,v.o _1._ a,y e e
3
._. _. e, c... _: o
.4,,
. 4._. m_ =_ u.., -. b a_ a..
, 'm' " ' _4
_',/
a_v_=.41_abla_
lo..c
_ ~.
before 1975.
Centention 2, therefore, is not based on..new information.. or new evidence.. as required n
by the Board's Order and should be rejected.
Contention 2 appears to be based on the relevance of atter before the Pennsylvania PUC in the case of one
-< u,
.3__,
4 e_
4
_._,_e_,.
4 m.e._ w.. e_,_ p. - :. =_ - +, c#
e ~_ _4 ~_ _4 m_. a.
4 u
_3 s
. c a::ecrec,y tn..is transmission corridor.
Petitioner c.oes not identify tr property and Applicant doe s nct understand that it is part of his residence.
i 1
i w.
e wrm-e-w e--
--w-m
=
- 1 "Winfred Higgirr".
There is nothing in the stipulation to suggest that the Pennsylvania PUC proceeding is at all relevant to this case.
In fact, with minimal research, Applican has been able to determine that the controversy I
involves a 500kv transmission line rather than the 345kv transmission line which is the subject of this proceeding and Mr. Rentfro's interest.
IV.
For all of the foregoing reasons and others specified in the Applicant's Response of September 29, 1978, the stipulation should be rejected and Mr. Rentfro's petition to intervene should be denied.
Respectfully submitted,
(.
)
i A.b-
- . Law s
~ Jack R.
Newman November la,,
1,7e,
/
Rober H.
C u., 9 1025 Connecticut Avenue, NV Washington, DC 20036 J.
Gregory Copeland Charles G.
Thrash, Jr.
3000 One Shell Plaza Housten, Texas 77002-Attorneys for Applicant HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER CO:IPANY OF COUNSEL:
LOWENSTEIN, NEUMAN, REIS, AXELRAD & TOLL 1025 Connecticut Avenue, NW Washing ca, DC 20036 EAKER & BOTTS 3000 One Shell Plaza Houston, Texas 77002
=
g.....-=
amamar np n.u e, 1 o v.... C.)
b.naLD vs
'LE.
Cv.s. I. S,..p sJ m
7 -,.... - n, m..
.,.C
..gn!.
g L cis c:v naw51 y
?a* L
.'O **.*s/"
. O t*..D
.e***
...'..T.1.*(.**.
.C.* T *"r'9 V.
n i. ?.
M*
- m^
4 Oe""'*A.,".'..T.
"."* T.J. ?
e.
. v w
..,..m o..
)
1.,.
)
HCUS C:: L"GH"-':G & PC ;ER CC:'PA::7
)
Docket No. 50-466
)
.., -.,,,, - c e.. o..,. 4.. :
)
( n.,.,,._. - C m, m.
a S,. 4.,
L.. 4 1)
)
)
.= =.. J. e. r.a
.w -
e
.m -, - c..~.. v n
s......
v6 h e.- a.'. "; - a. *. 4 3. v.
- "..w"-
cop 4.eo-o #. ny y'. 4 a.*v ' s. e n yo..s e *wo r
- A v.
ti.q 4 4 -, 1 3 p.f n...
h, e. 3 m p.
sqgg ca34.c ggA g. 3 7 3. g p P e ".*.#.".o" W a.." o
.y v.-
i m.
da-a. s.*. i.'.
'w.ha.
U r. 4
- e d S * =.a. s.*. 4.',
4 s a -". a d o.n '.".a.
- o.' ' 'v' '.f i.". "; " V, w
y
' ' o ". a...." a..
o a- *" '". C. D '"a.
a.4 A, o " by" h a..d d e.'.' " a..- "y
' 5. 4 - 13
- k.. da"; o #.
a a
4
...,. y y
1m/O:
1 i
.c, %. m *
- v. -
..m..C.,
.?..=,.*;.
[.L.s4 n
p 4
~e. ', a *mqg s,
7.=*;.
V.
.o
.w.
v.
.'. 4 e.-'...4.. ~
n' - = 4 s ' '. ". A *. o.-. = ;" G $.". a.. * '.
3..
4,
2,.3.
y a.
.=.,..a 0., m.,
e,-
.w c
o.
. e.... -... a 1
...e
.e..3 e..e.
.,.,,,,2.2-e.m.~..,,.,.....
... 4.=. 4..
P.O.
e.c, l.9. a,i 8
.m..
s
.s. a
.=.4"..
. ;.,.g....~ ~.~..,
D.
C.
.:.:5 C,= ".4 *,'.
7 e e,..,
2 A,m, a-. 4
,. e,, s
,.a c u.. m.,.....
r.
v
.m
..c m e 3, Sc:: 350A Hon. Jerry Sliva, Mav.er
~',' 3 a-qa-... 4.3 a-..., o, cs e. m.- ~ 4,-
30e~~e~i C.4 " "j o t.v a.'.' 4
't' e.'..e. s e
s/
o
\\J A e..n.
'./. C.r 4. d.b. *
- 1 m.
^
- .1..
n.~.4,.
c a " $. ;r
<'..A.
- 7. 4. a.. a.4. 7",
G.. a q ^ -j u*. K a.i.. a.-
.. 4.,.,r...C o ma
. v,.- a e,.1 3.,.,,.,.o a.
..v H o ".., ~ ~..,
'1"e r. = s 7 W. v. 4 U....
".~"+.'a.=-
c..o. "..' a...- ";
C.' c..... 4 - - 4aa on
... a =. 4. m-,,,
D.
C.
20::-..a C "...: c a
- S
- c^ ^'. c.~. s V.. c...*.~ ca.* o
- v, a....'*.*....=.4..~:
r.e.,,. m,
- 4... y a.. -.. ' *- d*4.$
.ce ".
- 4 0 '*
n' o,...=.=. ', c.$.. s.
4
..e Q.E..E E m.
Q.#.
- b. b. o.
Q g g**.*= m,
.s... s
.E. g 4-w g
{.}.
- ]H w-l. g n.
.O.e F M. I.S. k. a.-";
l w..
3 C..... 4 - - 4
.....i.4 -
.4 o.n.
aa aa.
"n,. " 1.e.., - v, C s.....$.4
.e.i c..
N, a.e., w...i,. ;,.., D. C.
' 0 :, :,:,,,
)
C..:. ".." ~ '.a = -
a a
7.,J s s: "
d C' S.c. '*. 4... F
- w..,
D.
- Z a-a s
. R.
Gordon Gooch, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Baker & Botts Board Panel 1701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D.
C.
20006 Commission j
Washington, D.
C.
20555 l
Steve Schinki, Esq.
Staff Counsel T.
Paul Robbins U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory c/o AFSC Commission 600 West 28th Street, #102 Washington, D.
C.
20535 Auston, Texas 78705 John F.
Doherty Wayne E.
Rentfro i
Armadillo Coalition of Texas P.O. Box 1335 4438 1/2 Leeland Rosenbers, Texas 77471 i
Houston, Texas 77023 Brenda A.
McCorkle James Scott, Jr.
6140 Darnell 8302 Albacore Houston, Texas 77074 Houston, Texas 77074 Emanuel Baskir Carro Hinderstein 5711 Warm Springs Road 8739 Link Terrace Houston, Texas 77035 Hous:cn, Texas 77025 Steven Gilbert, Esq.
Jean-Claude De Brenaecker 122 Bluebonnet 2128 Addison Sugar Land, Texas 77478 Ecus:cn, Texas 77030 Brent Miller Edgar Crane 4811 Tararisk Lane 13E07 Kingsride Bellaire, Texas 77401 Houston, Texas 77079 John V.
Anderson 3626 Broadmead Patricia L.
Day Houston, Texas 77025 2432 Sottingham Houston, Texas 77005 John R.
Shreffler 5014 Braeburn Lois H.
Anderson Bellaire, Texas 77401 3626 Broadmead Houston, Texas 77025 Rc_
it S.
Framson 4822 Waynesboro Drive David Marke Houston, Texas 77035 Solar Dynamics, Ltd.
3904 Warehouse Row Madeline Bass Framson Suite C 4822 Waynesboro Drive Austin, Texas 78704 Houston, Texas 77035
.m -~,,-
,-n,en--,-
a,-=-.
--s---~
,,---a
+. - - - -
---~--,---s-----
. Shirley Caldwell Mrs.
R.
M.
Sevis 14501 Lillja 7706 3rykerwoods Houston, Texas 77060 Houston, Texas 77055 Ann Wharton Kathryn Hooker 1424 Kipling 1424 Kipling Houston, Texas 77006 Houston, Texas 77006 Joe Yelderman, M.D.
John Renaud, Jr.
Box 30.-
4110 Yoakum Street Needville, Texas 77461 Apartment 15 Houston, Texas 77006 D. Michael McCaughan 3131 Tirmons Ln.
Allen D.
Clark Apartment 254 5602 Rutherglenn Houston, Texas 77027 Houston, Texas 77096 Lee Loe D.
Marrack 1844 Kipling 420 Mulberry Lane Houston, Texas 77098 Bellaire, Texas 77401 Alan Vocacka, Esq.
George Broze Houston Chapter, National Lawyers 1823-A Marshall Street Guild Houston, Texas 77098 4803 Montrose 31vd.
Suite 11 Charles Michulka, Esq.
Houston, Texas 77006 P.O.
Box 882 Stafford, Texas 774'7 Hon. John.
R. Mikeska Austin County Judge P.O.
Box 310 Bellville, Texas 77418
.M-/
,Lsuw e
l J
l l
i l
g vd y
y T
yy y
'w'ey 9-e--+-
7v e-=r y y
.,-Fv-*r--en-v-wp
--w=**y*79 w-r
-6* - ' ' "
-*w "T-Pa----
- "* -