ML20148N950
| ML20148N950 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Allens Creek File:Houston Lighting and Power Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 11/08/1978 |
| From: | Moon C Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7811270297 | |
| Download: ML20148N950 (3) | |
Text
_. _ - _ - _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ __-__
.e .,
va afog
,8 UNITED STATEE y '
, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMisslON
$ $ WASHING TON, D. C. 20555
% 4
%, *****/ November 8,1978 Docket No. 50-466 FACILITY: Allens Creek Nuclear Generating Station, Unit 1 APPLICANT: Houston Lighting & Power Company
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING HELD ON SEPTEMBER 20, 1978 FOR APPEAL OF STAFF POSITION BY APPLICANT TO STAFF MANAGEMENT (DIRECTORS)
Representatives of Houston Lighting & Powe'r Cdmpany (applicant) met with Directors for Systems Safety and Project Management of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission staff in Bethesda, Maryland on September 20, 1978 to appeal one position of the staff for Allens Creek Nuclear Generating Station that was stated in the enclosure to its letter of July 21, 1978. A previous appeal on this same matter by the applicant on August 21, 1978 was denied by the Assistant Directors for Engineer-ing and Light Water Reactors (Summary of Meeting October 24,1978).
The applicant again appealed the staff's position that the finite element technique for soil-structure interaction analysis be compared to the lumped mass spring approach as a means 01 justifying acceptable conservatism for the applicant's analyses. An attendance list is enclosed.
The decision of the Directors of Systems Safety and Project Manage-ment was that demonstration of the acceptability of the method proposed by the applicant is needed. Alternative procedures for effecting a sufficient demonstration include (1) definition by the NRC staff of conservative criteria for the applicant's use and (2) demonstration of conservatism by methods other than the comparison requested by the staff, d @ Mtew' Calvin W. Moon, Project Manager Light Water Reactors Branch 4 Division of Project Management
Enclosure:
List of Attendees l
l 7 811270M1 l
l t
~ = ..
LIST OF ATTENDEES ALLENS CREEK SEPTEMBER 20, 1978 MEETING WITH HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER COMPANY R. Mattson, NRC R. Boyd, NRC D. Vassallo, NRC J. Knight, NRC S. Chan, NRC H. Silver, NRC W. Menger, HL&P J. Sumpter, HL&P J. White, HL&P J. Saldarini, Ebasco D. Nuta, Ebasco l
l
4 M %W oo.aston 1.ightin.J o Power Company . -
Ccs:
Mr. P. A. Horn - Mr. G. W. Oprea, Jr. '
Project Manager, Atilus Group Vice President ilouston Li Jhting n Power Coiapany Houston Lighting & Pcwer Company P. O sox I/UU P. O. Box 1700 llous t on , Texas //001 Houston, Texas 77001 l H. Lordon Gooch, tsq.
I Baker & Hol.ts l/01 Pennsylvania Avenue,ii. W.
Wa S h i riglott , U. C. 200Ut>
J. Gregory COPeland, tsy.
daker d Uol,t s l Une Shell Pldza Ilou s t o n , Iexas //002 Jack R. fleuadri, t sy.
l Lowenstein , fleunan, Hei s 6 Axel rad j lu2b Connecticut Avenue,II. W.
Washington. U. C. 200Jb ilr. Hay elatzeIle Project Manager, ACNUS lbasco bervices, Inc.
19 l<ector Street flew (ork , llew (ork ludub Hr. Hay Leore Project Mariager, aCaus General Llectric l /b l',urtner Aveliue hall dose, California 9bl25 Mr. Carlo:, Byars Ihe llouston Chronicle HUl lexas Avenue Houston, lexas 7/002 froy Webb, Lsq.
Assistant Attorney beneral 1.nvironmental Protection Division P. O. Box 12548 Capitol Statioli Austin, Texas 78/11 h
- i. N,h
(($/)
MEETING '. JMMARY ALLENS CREEK Docket file NRC PDR Locri PDR TIC NRR Reading LWR-4 Reading EGCase RSBoyd DBVassallo WGammill JStolz RBaer 0Parr SVarga CHeltemes LCrocker DCrutchfield FWilliams l RJMattson l
RDeYoung Project Manager C. W. Moon Attorney, ELD l MService IE (3)
RDenise LRubenstein Dross ACRS (16)
PARTICIPANTS:
R. Mattson J. Knight S. Chan H. Silver