ML20147J344

Staff Exhibit S-4,consisting of Tl Szymanski Affidavit Clarifying Record in Proceeding Re Regrade of Question 6.03(b) of Aj Morabito Exam in Oct 1987

ML20147J344
Person / Time
Site:	05560755
Issue date:	02/21/1988
From:	Szymanski T Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
References
SP-S-004, SP-S-4, NUDOCS 8803100090
Download: ML20147J344 (6)

Text

, .S $ - b d'75 5

^*

L/lC7 6- .

4- 00CKETE -

USNEC NUCL AR REGULA ORY C M IS ION '88 MAR -8 P4 i07 BEFORE THE ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGE QFFl;E M HC au uGCKEliNG Vri<v;M BR A th. -

In the Metter of )

)

ALFRED ). VOPABITO ) Docket No. 55-60755 1

(Senior Operator License for )

Beaver Valley Nuclear Power )

Station, Ur.it 1) )

MFIDAVIT OF THEODORE L. SZYMANSKI 1

1, Theodore L. Szymanski, do depose and state:

1. I am Regional Support and Oversight Section Chief in the

! Operator licensing Branch in the Division of Licensee Performance and Cuality Evaluation in the Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulatien at the O Urited States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Headquarters. My professional qualifications are attached.

2. The purpore of my affidavit is to clarify the record in this proceeding cencerning the regrade of question 6.03(b) in Mr. Monbito's

, exarrinetion by the NRR Operator I.icensing Branch in October 1087.

Mr. Morabito'r examination was originally graded by Mr. Silk v.ithout proportioning answers to points per question. in the October 1987 NRR regrade of question 6.03(b), the proportionate grading method was used I

for additional points given for answers given to cuestion 6.03(b).

! Therefore, questien 6.03(b) is the only place in Mr. Morabito's examina-tion where proportionate grading is used, if the original grading system had been used, Mr. Morabito would have received an additional 0.5 points i

for one additional correct answer. NRR used the proportionate grading

% f/4 & 4 56tFA hhot 5 88 R 05 gl>;}f$

1

6 h

O s .

[sJO[.7' .' C2$V Y,IOUtY f.O'''s).1

~

D __

C:

ES~&D~I _)docchlt, _

n. -

' . _. A

.e,*

e ._A _ . __t r: C-. 1 E4 __. . _ _ _ _. _

P' . _ _. ._ _ __ _ R ET E D __ _ __ __ _ _

C' .s C:

Mi E _7 3. _ _ ___ _

w a _ __ _

c- _.

E.,~ b _ Nb. k__

J' .S V

Y N () { $ Nt S) l ,ki e

$f

O method since it is the most commonly used but we did not inquire into

(

Mr. 51lk's method. We have only recently realized that we changed Mr. Silk's grading method for only one question since we did not do a complete regrade of tho entire examination. Since the original grading system did not consider extra answers, we believe it would have been appropriate to give an additional 0.5 points for question 6.03(b) rather than to distribute the 1.5 possible points among the four answers. We regret that this matter did not come to our attention earlier.

I attest the foregolrg is true and accurate to the best of my knowledge and belief.

%Y,eoeoreN ' e- 2 a$

O ris Subscribed and sworn to before me this /~%'h day of February,1988 i *XP /C . . rf N)ota Public p? _

My Commissien Expires : ' fIc ' /, f O

PROFESSIONAL OUAllFICATIONS

( OF THEODORE L. SZYMANSKI Experience:

December 1982 - Present Section Chief, Regional Support and Oversight Section (Previously Pressurized Water Reactors Section Leader)

Supervised and reviewed work of Headquarters personnel in the assigned section of the Operator Licensing Branch, for the development, preparation and administration of examinations to applicants for operator and senior operator licenses for nuclear reactors. Assisted Operator Licensing Branch Chief in managing the audits of regional functions in the area (s) of development, preparation and the administration of examinations by regional and contractor personnel.

April 1979 - December 1982 Reactor Engineer (Examiner) - Coordination and implementation of all activities associated with the examination and the licensing pd of operators for Westinghouse pressurized water reactors and non-power reactor facilities in accordance with 10 CFR 55:

Including preparation, administration and grading of written and operating examinations. Qualified as an NRC examiner on Westinghouse and non-power reactor facilities.

March 1975 - April 1979 Nuclear Engineer (Instructor) -

Responsible for coordinating, developing, implementing and evaluating pressurized water reactor technology training programs for NRC inspectors and other NRC professional employees (le. , NRC examiners).

Conducted classroom and simulator training.

July 1969 - March 1975 Chief Supervisor of Operations / Maintenance for TRIGA pulsing reactor. Possessed Atomic Energy Commission, Senior Reactor Operator's license. Responsible for the operations of the TRIGA reactor. Supervised reactor operations, training, maintenance, research, and isotope production. Periodically acted as physicist-in-charge of the reactor division.

1963 - July 1969 '

Q Plant Operations Supervisor / Shift Supervisor / Instrumentation and Maintenance Supervisor - Certified as shift supervisor in

O the Army Corps of Engineers Nuclear Reactor Power Production

( Prog ram , Responsible for all plant power operations, radioactive waste processing / disposal and on-shift _ operator training, 1 Plant instrumentation Section Supervisor -

responsible for periodic preventive and annual maintenance of all plant nuclear process and radiation monitoring systems. Planned, directed and participated in nuclear plant decommissioning.

1959 - 1963 Technical Instructor Supervisor - Coordinated, developed, and instructed various portions of United States Air Force nuclear weapons program including weapons theory, test, assembly, and maintenance of nuclear weapons - and missile re-entry vehicles.

~

Trainino and Education:

1950 - 1959

- Electronic Technical Training, United States Air Force - Six months O - Nuclear weapons theory and training - Six months

- Calibration standards laboratory and nuclear weapons test equipment - Four months 1959 - 1962

- Missile nuclear weapons systems and. technology courses - Nine months

- Technical instructor course - Two months 1962 - 1963

- United States Army Corps of Engineers nuclear power program - Diploma received - Eighteen months  !

1963 - 1964

- Nuclear power facility equipment and control room operator training - Twelve months 1965 - 1966

- Nuclear power facility equipment operator,  !

control room operator and shift supervisor in training - Nine months

O 1

7 1969 - 1971 l

- Atomic Energy Commission license reactor i operator and senior reactor operator training for research reactor - Eight months .

1975 - United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission ,

Westinghouse Systems Technology - Five weeks i Simulator training - Two weeks Various on the job training at facilities and simulators. Activities include operations, j training, maintenance, Instrumentation and control, technical specification compilance, ,

health physics end radioactive waste. - Twelve  ;

1 months .

f O l i

1 1

f l

l i

O i i

-