ML20147C107
| ML20147C107 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 12/08/1978 |
| From: | NRC OFFICE OF STANDARDS DEVELOPMENT |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20062F378 | List: |
| References | |
| TASK-EM-705-5, TASK-OS REGGD-01.141, REGGD-1.141, NUDOCS 7812180158 | |
| Download: ML20147C107 (3) | |
Text
....
te.6A.L.
ji O
VALUE/ IMPACT 6TATEMENT I.
The Proposed Action
~
A.
' Description - The proposed action will provide guidance to -
i applicants in meeting the minimum requirements for containment isolation of fluid systems.-
4
~
8.
Need for the Proposed Action -
The SRP gives cudsnt staff
..; q. : *,,,...
practices.
For this important topic, it would be desirable to
^
issue a regulatory guide in order to afford a wider public review of this topic.
A national concensus standard has been developed which could provide the technical basis for this guide.
I n.
C.
Value/ Impact of the Proposed Action 1<
NRC operations
'Since the guide reflects current licensing 3,..;.,.
-a practice, no impact on NRC operations is anticipated.
2.'
Other Government Agencies - Not Applicable.-
3.
Industry - Same as for NRC operations.
s 4.
Public - Not Applicable 7812180)G i' ' 1 6b
d
- ~
D.
Deci sio,n..on the Proposed Action Guidance should be furnisfied on containment isolation of fluid systems,.i....
.. A. 4.. ;w.
.... v.:.. <.... r.-v...
-.L v,,..v < v...........
.... ~w
. ~...,.
.m..
.m.
. ~.
< W.*f.;,m._.; '1*:*-a, * :mC.. ',.:,;. s.i.* ** * %, ;.,
.4,
~
.:.?.. *..
.1.. :.
? u... ;., r,,,. ?.. n, ' '. a.
- .
- .. * ;,.,.:.., r.
W e a.....
.n r
s y-
~-
3.
4..
II.. Technical AFproa,..ch
,, l.: ; :..:.;c t.. ". :
. ~ -
.. :,...:. y.:s.<.,...:/,,.:.
..~.c.;
Technic.a.l.y.l.ternatives ;..Jf..//.?.'.G,.
A.
A
,.,.,... ;4.
....v.. :..
.m..
r;:.. u.
. :.a Since the' guide gives the current methods used to meet the
. :. p...,,...a.. u..,.. ~..
,..:... n.. :.:..t.: n.
regulati' ni,',no technical alternatives are 'now being considered.
o 2.:gs.n.,W' w
%. ; 33 4".;"w.to..n~t..r. -ire. c w.y..:m.. M.r...,..s'-
m
..T.h..M.c..
.. u M. s.:a.a.l.t.. 'r..C..
'v-C:,
W
-m.s.'.*..
- ',n. * '.. : :'* ; ; ; a!
.w 3'.
u
- ~,.*: 3:s ::nt. ~;
,v.. :
~.:-v.-.y.a :. c. 's :.,,..... &.:.:.y:.,
.. n..s. n.. a..;,.
.y......
r,...
m.......:
-t B.
. Discu.ssion' ind Comparison of. Technical Alternatives y:...e.u....... s..
-.e :..m...., w... a
..w.......a.....-
.... w.r..
m..
- w.,
G. a. n w,.a#
ot PP Ca
.e.
. ~.. ; ; *.. M....n. ~8 5 *', *'
' ' ~ ~ ~
. t. ".
.. M.. ::
.. %.....db. a. g.;. 4.)..,4 *.". :;. :.,
..f.-
?,*
.- ~.
- 1.
,, l%.,l5 :".":%'.? W."'..,,}.. :
,.. ' "..T. s;
.... :., s,.n... '..
... g. <. ;,
.. ~.r
- 3. s.....a...
.D i.,s..,
.;.s..:, g
. ion of Te.chnical Ap;proach,..
C.
cu.ss..
1
.,. ~...
.;;. r.x,.: n.
a..
Not Applicabl e' '.'?
r.v.y.::. i.;... ;.,
- ' ' ' '..;.J...
i
.......m..~.s....~.;....__........
o.
a..
.,.:.......... e.s.. n. w - w...--, p..g ~
. c.,..
s.
.:'.o.2
.,. ;....~.: m.,, ;~..,;y...,....,. :: :..........
r~
't.*,..-
.x C i 's. -
,..:.7 4.. y. k*
III. Pracedural Approach r W.,; p.,,... -,,... w :.. ~c..,,.d....: ": W. ' :. '.:.
..s.
~
.-- w.. w..
Procedural. Alternatives. g,,, u.
- ,n f4
..s A.
g.....
Potential SD procedures that~may be'used to promulgate the
.;;.:.p. 6.'. n-,.
- 7..... L.. -
propose'd action and technical approach include the following:
l
.. R09U1ation x
o ;...
Preparation or Revision of Reg. Guide I
.... :... ~.. ~.. g y
ANSI Standard, endorsed'by a Reg. Guide
}
NUREG Report....
e.
. ;.o.
i
~
- n... c 6..
1
- . y2.
.?. ~..,_. n.. ;
j Branch Position
- l 3
. a.'
n
~
i
). c i
.S 2
.. =.
2
,l
..,,.......t.
4 O
I I
o B.
Value/ Impact of Procedural Alternatives The endorsement of the'sfandard is the most efficient alter-native.si nce.r.,W A..v..s..
- a....
it requires the least amount of time and effort to
.,. 1,..
m
,g,< w..
c..<-.t.,.,,4......
accomplish.the task....s-CN-
,..~~..
.. h... t.y,,.g.-gy ~,, ;,,... n. :.n..
w.*'..
L..:
e.n.
w,-
- v..n.1c. ;.
- s. f ***...
.y,..
- ;'..f y
.s. +a
.,, f
,o~5.* e.,a,. "
g..
4-*
- g. a.
- N.s %'.!
- 4.. +. t#.%:.t;*.' t.*Q. m..~~,W'&. qj /: l* f< t'
...t.~.~.m.;. r.,
. ;. L. f.s
..a
- ~. * *
- e...N
...f.7.r,...w.
.ig,,L.,u.,q:,
p.
...,,, e.,p w. e
...,.. g. g l.. h o*
- .O..r..,-+.,r+.'...~,.vg ;,.. s
..a
,m
~
y s,. M...,G.. ;, + ;.4..r.
. * ^
- a A...
..,. ~.
n
..e..-*
' t.A., g
~
.*.?,,,*.,.".'
.e.
.1,....p.,.s.
+
\\
, os "*..
)
s y 7,...=S*.........i..... w J e, *,.=, -..
9
)
,, * '* '.,? * ~.a:,:
+
- A
. t /,,,y..., n.,,.qw Y.n. 's a":.,..,: :*b.,IM...,.".,...v.** A a
-, %_., a...
~
,....i. -
,.1..
9...
+ =,.,
..t
.. +..
- 4*#.;.,(u,y'g.QW' 3 '.;, g. - vg,..k.., g.'.'.. ~=.,*.
.. #.r. % 4., r
.e.
+.
. w.p s
...w.... t.t.*..
,.5..c
.r
...,+ W W
. ~-
'..; s p~ *,*f s..
s'.b. ~.e re u,,
- ,1
-3,.
r s,,y 1 y ;y g %.,,..w r:,.. n:+n.9.,..,'..,,, *
,.,.,.n.
,,.s.
. ~.,;."*
e,%.; Q,. *y..
". 2 s.%~,.>,*.:
~
v.
,e.r
- t......,..;,
...y
.. ~,,..
yr...,,...n.,g....,.,,f,.,,,,.
8
.=
.u....
, ;. s,.s.. _-
.,.;. - g;.. a.
a. a f,
,3-..
..,,;r.,,q,. /.
.. <.. M,.,,..,.. g,,, t r. 4..#
...r :
.6
,. " r.,
s.
.., ; c...,7...
- t. ;.. :f.,. Q.** y s.
. r :,.,.
M y.
- n~
.....m,:. m.%.* f psU j., r.. h....,,.,. "
"a.
s.
w..
o
. 5"f*%....4.
.s
.*W,,e p. g.
s 4e
- s;. ;f..
.s
?, *. 'y.
- F' ?.. '
c.
x.as 11
'n S
lpd,} ?..
' '..r
' ^ * '.,3. o. d.'.W Yj.,,,.,,,, '., 2." X *
- s.
.s.*.<,.
.s.
w.
. u, r%. 4-..a, 4 7.-
s.
1 ;s. u
,t 9
f a**.1 M,S,u.;,. "' (
C.
e
+ -.
g p.
- w p.a..s.. < ;, ?, * */.
p.,.*.,
. i g,,,,*,..e m.;--..
s ** -
. m r..
,. ; L.,. r.e., E.,.....,
s,,,,
.. o p
a 9
- p ?f=:"./..,'*e.,
- .e,.,g....a >, i,,., Q.
w..
y V.
- b
- *rm
.m
,w.
....a... t g *..%.+ w. r,. w.
s
...* ii.. #...... /.,g o.
.g.
3.,.
.4.W.,, m
.e-
, ? ** '
. f;, 4, {..
's,
..w.
- g..
'**w
- 6.
g g.
+...e * ;= ~ *
,.. - p.
.r s
l g
- i -
+
.y.
- a.je ?
t.
/
.. ig.
- a.... - * *,
. '* * ' *[
- a s1.,.
y
~ * *;
. ss
.m s
e '.***, [* d ? E..'., #"
- D '
[ _. A + ' 4
,,g a
.n........;
u.-.= '.to**
- ** 'G i
T
+
,a a.
T.
...aw.'.
,3..
.....v. i...*,.,. -
,.w
'. ','y. u. %.g,. <,. r 4. a.' ' - f.. ' #.- *',...
e.
- (,, a,,.
i.? * <.'. ave.g w.,.
.,-.2..
- r. n.,.
1.
..1
- ~...
.,*..t.
.e.
e.
- 1/,,.21.^ * %.';.
. n. g, j '*.I i-.. -. -
r,..
- * ~,
j m.
. -,, * * * =. -
s.
1
+$
d
.g
=
.e,
,p, g
e J
d
.W.*
1 l
8,, g' s
- A gp e
g I
9 48,
i
. u"
- .*,,, ytt **
"'"Y'
+
Q..*,
4,*
, "._. c,3,*;,4 "T...
. i
',e + % ;l':.""* $7 *f' ^ %
- y [ g. 4 '(, ;.,.,,,,
i t.. T * '., j
+
_ - _ - - _ - _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _.