ML20147C107
| ML20147C107 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 12/08/1978 |
| From: | NRC OFFICE OF STANDARDS DEVELOPMENT |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20062F378 | List: |
| References | |
| TASK-EM-705-5, TASK-OS REGGD-01.141, REGGD-1.141, NUDOCS 7812180158 | |
| Download: ML20147C107 (3) | |
Text
---
te.6A.L. ji O '
VALUE/ IMPACT 6TATEMENT I. The Proposed Action -
~
. A. ' Description - The proposed action will provide guidance to -
i
,, applicants in meeting the minimum requirements for containment isolation of fluid systems.- -
4
~
- 8. Need for the Proposed Action - The SRP gives cudsnt staff
. .; q. : *, , , . . .
practices. For this important topic, it would be desirable to
- . - - :,. ^
issue a regulatory guide in order to afford a wider public review of this topic. A national concensus standard has been developed which could provide the technical basis for this guide. ,
I l
n .
Value/ Impact of the Proposed Action C. '
l 1< NRC operations 'Since the guide reflects current licensing l 3 ,. .;., . -a . .
l practice, no impact on NRC operations is anticipated.
2.' Other Government Agencies - Not Applicable.- * '
- 1
- 3. Industry - Same as for NRC operations. ,
s .
- 4. Public - Not Applicable -
7812180)G i' ' 1 6b ,
d
- ~ -
D. Deci sio,n..on the Proposed Action Guidance should be furnisfied on containment isolation of fluid systems,.i.... . . A. 4. . ;w.
v, .,..
. ~ . ... ,, .. .
. .-.. . v.: . . < . ... r.-v ... -.L v < v .. . . . . . .. . .
.m. ;.
< W .*f.;,m._.; '1*:
.m.. . ~ .
. ... ~w ~
- .
- . .n . * ;,.,. .:
- -a, * :mC W e.. a',.:. ,;. . ...s .i.* ** * % , ;. , .- : ,.: *'*..
.:.?. ..4 * .. ,
. .. . , r.
r ** .
s
..: . . .1. . :.
- ?3. u.. . ; ., r ,,, . ? .. n , ' '. a. y- !
~-
4..
II. . Technical AFproa,..ch , , l.: ; :. .: .;c t.. ". .: .. ..
.~- - -
..... : ,. ..: . y.:s .<. , . ..:/, ,.:. ..~.c.; :. .
A. Technic.a.l A .y.l.ternatives ;. .Jf..//.? .'.G,. - -
, . .,.: .a, . . ... ;4 . . . . .v. . :r;:.. u. . .
.. .m.. .. ..
Since the' guide gives the current methods used to meet the
. : . p . . . ,, .. .a. . u. . , . ,..:... .
. ~ . . n. .
- .:..t.:
.... n. . . -... .. .
regulati' oni,',no technical alternatives are 'now being considered.
2.:gs.n .,W' m w w.y..:m..
. . u W
'v-C:, ; 33 4".;"w.to
.w . .n~t.
- ',n. .r. -ire..
M.r...,..s'-
c ..
. .T.h ..M.c .. '.. :':'* ; ; ; a! 3' .
n . .s . n. -m.s.'.*
- .. M. u s.:a.a.l.t. .y
- ~,.*: 3:s ::nt . ~; ~ .:-v .- .y .a :. c.m..
. .. . . : . ,v.. :
. ... 'r
. ...C.. . a..;, . .
's :. .,,.. . . .....:
. &.:.:.y:., -t r,... .
B. . Discu.ssion' ind Comparison of. Technical Alternatives y:. ..e.u..-.e. .:.. ...m. s ..
. . .m..
.., w .w. .. a, .e.
. .w. . .. ...a.....-
... . w.r. . ..
ot PP Ca G . a... M.. n w:: , .a#
. .. 't.. ". " .'..
. ~ ., .. -;. ;. .*. -,.. M. . . .n.? ,*~8 5 *', *'
..f.- .. *
. . %. .-. .~. . .db. a. g .; :1. . 4.)..,4 *.". :;;*. :. , *
~~~
,, l%. ,l5..;. :".":%'.? -;.. W."'. .,,} .., .: . ' " . .T . s; .
.. . g . <. ;, . ., ~.r
. .. . . . 3. s. .. . .a..... .. .- : ., s , .n .
C. .D.. i.,s cu.ss . ..,.. ion of Te.chnical Ap;proach ,..
.. . , . ~ . .. .. . ,
.;;. r.x,.: n.: ..r .a..
1 .. . .
.;.s..:, g .
.v.y.:: ... . i.;.. . ;., .
Not Applicabl e' '.'?.::' ' ' ' . .; .J. . .
a..s...
. . . .......m..~.s....~.;....__........
- o. ...,,..
i
. ,.:..... ..... ., . e.s.. ;....~ n. w .-,,w. . .--, p ..g ~
. c., . .
..- . .. r~ .. .. .:'.o.2 -
.: m ;~..,
.. ;y.. .,.... ,... :: :'t.*,..- . . . .. . ..x
, .* .:.7 4 . . y. k* .
C i 's. - , * ...
..s. ,.
~ , , , . -
III. Pracedural Approach r W.,; .-- w ..p.,,. . . -.- ,,.. :,,. . w :..::. ~c. .. . , ,.d... .: ": W . ' : . '.:."
. .. . .s .. ;,n f4 . . . . . . . , . .
w.. u. ,
A. Procedural. Alternatives . -g,,, .
. .. .. .. . . g ... . . .
Potential SD procedures that~may be'used to promulgate the .
.;;.:.p. 6 .' . n- ,. .
- 7 . . . . . L. . - . .
propose'd action and technical approach include the following: $.
l o .. ;.R09U1ation
.. .;-' x Preparation or Revision of Reg. Guide - I
. . . . :. .. ~ . . ~ . . g y ANSI Standard, endorsed'by a Reg. Guide }
. ;.o.
- .. . , ... . . . e. ..
. i
~ .
NUREG Report....
- n. :. .. cy2.6. . ... .
j 1
.?. .. ~. . ,_. n .... ; .- : '
Branch Position *
.. l 3
. - . . . ., . a .' _
. n
~
. . , , i
). c i
. .S 2 . . :
..=.
.. - . . ,. ,. ., ,, ........t. . . . . ... .. 2 .. . . . ,,
. ,l
4 O
I I
o B. Value/ Impact of Procedural Alternatives The endorsement of the'sfandard is the most efficient alter-
- . . it requires the least amount of time and effort to native ....,# .si .. nce.r.,W A.. . .v. .s..
. .. . ,. 1, . . m ..
.. ,g ,<..w.. . . . . ,
, ..~~. . . . .- -.
- a. . c..<-.t.,.,,4...
accomplish.the task.. ..s-CN-w,- L..: e .n. v. .n.1c. ; . .
~ ,, ;, , .. . n. : .n. w.*
- ;'. .f,y..;..s... .+a. h . ..s.t f.y***, ,.g .. . .-gy.y ,.. g.. . ,, f 4-* .. ..
. ; . L. f.s . .a . < ,o~5.* e .,a, . "
- ~ . * * :
- g. a. **N.s %'.! 4. . + . t# .%:.t;*.' t.*Q.e.m..~~,W'&. qj /: l* f< t' w.e . .
, . . . , ,, e . ,p . . , ; %,
. .N
. . . ,. . g . g l . ..* . h.f .7.r, . ..w . o*.ig,,L. ,u.,q:, p. .'. . . . , ...t.~.~.m. ; . r., *
,m . .
< . y . * ^ * . .a
.vgn ;, .. s a .. '
s, .~ M . .. ,G . . ;, + ;' t.A.,
.4..r.g . . A...**.O..r..,-+.,r+.'...~, . . , . ~ .
- . . .. ~ .
..e..-* ,
.*.?,,,*.,.".' .
.e .
.1,....p.,.s.
+
\ . .
) , .*os "* . . s ,
..=S*.........i . .. .. w J e , *, .= , - . *. . -
,** + * * ,. 9
) .
y 7 , .
, ,: * '* '.,? * ~.a:,:
9.....t A
~
. ,, +=,., , .1. .
..+.. ..... ,, , ....i. - .
... , n.,, .qw Y.n. 's a":.,. .,: :*b.,IM...,.".,...v.** Aa
- - . .. # .r
. .% 4. , r
. . . . , . . t /,, ,y
. w.p s
.e .
...w. .. . t .t .*.. ,.5..c
.r -, %_. , a . . .
+.
. ' '. .; s
. . *. ,+- W, W
- 4*#.;.,(u,y'g.QW' .
3 '.;
. , g.
~- - vg,. .k. ., g .'.'. . ~=. ,* .
p~ *,*f *,1 .
-3 ,. r s,,y .. , . . , . .
s.. s' .b. ~.e re u,, ,.,.,.n. --
.s.
. ~.,;."*
~
" . 2...
s.%~ ,.> 1 ,,*.: y,.. .;y. .y e,% g %. .;. .Q,. ,,, ,*y..
~ t.
- v. . .w r: , . . n:+n.9. ,. . ,' .. ,, ,
- yr...,,...n.,g....,.,,f,.,,,,.
.= ,e.r 8 .
, ; . s, .s. . _-
. . . . . . - .u ....
., .;. - g;. . a. a . a
. ..,,;r.,
,3-.. .
f,
.r :
.. , ; c .,q . . ,. /.
. . . , s. . ,.. <". r. M, ,
., ., , . . , . . g<,,, t r .s.4. .# .6 ....--
, , . . , . , . % . . t. ; .. :f., . Q.** y. r :,. ,.
- .. ,,.,7.s.. ..
o , . w.. M y.
- n~ *
"a.
... ..m,:. m .%.* f psU j. , r . . h. . . . , , . , . "
.s
. 5"f*%....4.
.*W,,e p . g. ....,,,* .*
s
. .s 4e : s; . ;f.. ,. ,
- c. x.as 11 .
. ** 'n -
' '. .r
.s.*.<,.
?, * .
' ^ * '. ,3.'y.o. *d.'.W F' ?Yj S
lpd . . ' ,} ? .. . .
.s.
. ., 7 .- w. . , , , . , , , , ' .,..
2." X *
- s . .
. .1 u, r%.;s4-..a . ,u4 , . . ., , s.
, , . . ,t 9
f
+-. *% C.
a**.1 M,S ,u.; ,. "' (
,
- g .
e
, , . . . ' . , * , - ,, ..s .. < ; , ? , *. */s .** - p a., .* . ,
. m r ..p .y
- w p.a g,,,,*,..e m .;--.w..
. i
. , -,.. ,, . o .
s,,,, ,.
, . * * . . . , . ; L. , . r .e. , E. ,... . ., p ;.e, . ,g... .a ,w.
V.
- b
- *rm '.,. >, i,,. , Q.
.m 9
- p ?f=:"./..,'*e .,..
. ,. . . , , , , . .. . o.s -
.g.
'**w ....a. .. t g * ..%.+ w. r,...w..* ii.. .f;,#...4.,..{/...,g's,
- 3.,.
.e-
- g. .
, ? ** ' * ,:
.4 .W ., , m '
..w.
- 6.
g g .
, ., , . . - p.. ,+. ... ..e * ;= ~ * ,
s l g ..
. - i - .y . .r
- .. +
, *
- a .je ?
- t. y / a
~ * *; s1.,. .. ig. a. . . . - *s *,
.* . , .., . . . ss .m
[ _. A + ' 4* e ' .***, . , d ? E. .' . , #"
- D.'. '*
' . [* * ' *[ *
, ,, ,,g a . .n . .......;
.. u.-.= '.to** ,
i* ** T 'G
- +
. ,a .
, a. T. ., ...aw.'. .
. ....e.v.
' ,3.. i...* , . , . -
- ( ,, a, ,. , .w * ' . ','y. u . % .g, . < , . r 4 . a .' ' - f. . ' # .- *' , . . .
- 1. * < .'. ave.g w .,..,-.2.. r. n . . ,.
..1 i.?
- ~...r,..
, '. .,*..t. .e.
- e. ,,,,. ,
- ~,
- 1/,,.21.^* * % .';. '.
i- . . - . -
. j .
, . n. g , j '* .I *
, m. ,
s . .-,,***=.-
1
+$ d
. .g
=
e g
.e, * * * .
,p, ,
J d
.W.* 1 .
g' 8,, . s *A l .
g I
9 '# gp e 48 ,
u" i
- .*, , ,* ytt **4,*
- . Q. .*, "'"Y' , + ** .
+
, "._. c,3 ,*; ,4 "T... . i
. ',e + % ;l':.""* $7 *f' ^ %
- y [ g . 4 '( , ;.,
i t. . T * '., j
- _ - _ - - _ - _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ .