ML20141J749
| ML20141J749 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 08/18/1997 |
| From: | Joshua Wilson NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Matthews D NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| PROJECT-669 NUDOCS 9708210187 | |
| Download: ML20141J749 (33) | |
Text
_ - - _ - _
s August 18, 1997
(
HEMORANDUM TO:
David B. Matthews, Chief Generic issues and Environmental Projects Branch Division of Reactor Program Management, NRR FROM:
James H. Wilson, Senior Project Manager Original Signed By:
Standardization Project Directorate Division of Reactor Program Management, NRR
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF PUBLIC MEETING HELD ON JULY 31, 1997, WITH THE ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE (EPRI) TO DISCUSS EPRI'S C0ATINGS PROGRAM On April 22, 1997, the staff held a public meeting at NRC headquarters in Rockville, Maryland with representatives of the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), National Electric Institute (NEI), and the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM)iatives being undertaken by the participants at the meeting D-33 Committee. The purpose of this meeting was to exchange information on init in order to coordinate future actions in this area.
A list of attendees and their affiliations is provided as Attachment 1.
Members of the ASTM D-33 Committee described some background on the history of this issue.
The handouts used in the ASTM presentation are provided as.
EPRI described its efforts to develop a coatings guideline. The handouts used in this presentation are provided as Attachment 3.
EPRI also presented a draft
. outline of its nuclear-related coatings control program (Attachment 4).
EPRI will hold working meetings September 22-23 and in mid-November to review and revise the draft of the guideline. The staff will meet with EPRI/NE! immediately after each of the industry working meetings.
NEI will provide versions of the draft guidelines to the staff a week or so in advance to facilitate meaningful exchange during the meetings.
The NRC Office of Research will be timing the development and release for comment of its Reg Guide 1.54 in order to take advantage of insights provided by the utility efforts.
Project No. 669 Attachments: As stated cc w/ atts:
See naxt page C a:,5 gqgy L. DISTRIBUTION w/ attachments:
h PUBLIC Docket PGEB r/f BSheron RHerman ASerkiz TTMartin MSlosson JStrosnider ESu111 van JDavis RElliott RLobel LCampbell 6g 505 Document Name: G:\\JHW1\\MEETSUM.731 I
4 3
0FC PGEG14)
(A)SC:POEB C:.EMCB
,n C: G R /
h
[#
g NAME JHWi1[n:sw MJCas @
YStrosnN DBM4ws u
DATE 08//f/97 08/NI/97 N 08/16/97 08/Y/97
(
OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
[
gg g2Gp*r$Qh[
~
yyggtygpig swegnon%
f
[
UNITED STATES
' *j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION s*
WASHINGTON. D.C. 20b5l@001 q*****,d s
August 18, 1997 MEMORANDUM TO:
David B. Matthews, Chief Generic Issues and Environmental Projects Branch Division of Reactor Program Management, NRR FROM:
James H. Wilson, Senior Project Manag r hg Standardization Project Directorate Division of Reactor Program Management, 4RR
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF PUBLIC MEETING HELD ON JULY 31, 1997, WITH THE ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE (EPRI) TO DISCUSS EPRI'S C0ATINGS PROGRAM On April 22, 1997, the staff held a public meeting at NRC headquarters in Rockville, Maryland with representatives of the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), National Electric Institute (NEI), and the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) D-33 Committee. The purpose of this meeting was to exchange information on initiatives being undertaken by the participants at the meeting in order to coordinate future actions in this area.
A list of attendees and their affiliations is provided as Attachment 1.
Members nf the ASTM D-33 Committee described some background on the history of this issue.
The handouts used in the ASTM presentation are provided as i
t.
EPRI described its efforts to develop a coatings guideline.
The handouts used in this presentation are provided as Attachment 3.
EPRI also presented a draft outline of its nuclear-related coatings control program (Attachment 4).
EPRI will hold working meetings September 22-23 and in mid-November to review and revise the draft of the guideline. The staff will meet with EPRl/NEI immediately after each of the industry working meetings.
NEl will provide versions of the draf t guidelines to the staff a week or so in advance to facilitate meaningful exchange during the meetings.
The NRC Office of Research will be timing the development and release for comment of its Reg Guide 1.54 in order to take advantage of insights provided by the utility efforts.
Project No. 669 Attachmenti:
As diated cc w/ atts:
See next page
LIST OF ATTENDEES AT MEETING ON EPRI C0ATINGS PROGRAM HELD IN ROCKVILLE. HARYLAND ON JULY 31, 1997 NAME AFFILIATION J. Strosnider NRC
-T. Sullivan NRC J. Davis NRC R. Elliott.
NRC R. Lobel NRC A. Serkiz NRC L
E. Woolridge NRC J. Medoff NRC
- L. Campbell NRC M. Marshall NRC K. Battige NRC J. 18 Wilson NRC F. Rosch EPRI D. Hill ASTM /WPPSS J. Butler =
NEl G. Dolderer FPL/NUCC R. Howard TVA/NUCC L. Waggoner Duke /NUCC D. Zabala SNOC/NUCC M. Carr BGE-rCNP
~
J. Caturano comed /NUCC K. Fry:
-Southern-Nuclear-J. Adrian Southern Company-S. Crawford Consultant T. Sutter
-Bechtel W. Houston Sequoia Consulting Group G. Spires Advanced Corrosion Engineering K. Kunert NAC International I
s_f
VN.fr r.hkb
(' fx'3 TIMELINE OF NIICLEAR COATING STANDARDS 1972 - May ANSI N 101.2 DBA Testing / Radiation /Cuives
- Oct.
ANSI N 5.9; 512; 5.12 Protective Coatings for Nuclear
-Nov.
ANSI N.101.4 Quality Assurance 1973 D 3276 Standard Guide for Painting Inspectors 1973 - June R. G.1.54 ANSI 45.2 ANSI N.101.4 ANSI N.101.2 1974 D 3363 Film Hardness.
1975 NUREG 75087 DBA Conditions - Unqualified Paint:Not Significant "Small Machinery and Equipment".
l 1979 ASTM PCN-03 Manual for Coating Work.
(Top Coating of Cured Coatings; Zines; Inspection; l
Maintenance and Painter Qualifications)
19'80 D 3842 Guide - Coating / Methods Level 1 Applications.
D 3843 QA to replace ANSI N 101.4 1983 D 3911 Testing To Replace ANSI N 101.2 i
D 3912 Testing-To Replace ANSIN 5.12 i
D 4082 Gamma Radiation Testing 1985 D 4541 Adhesion - Using Pull Off Gauge j
1990 ASTM MN1.8 Maintenance Manual 1991 D 5043 Test Method for Field Identification of Paints.
j D 5064 Standard Practice for Conducting j
Compatibility in Shop or Field.
D 5139 Prep of Samples for.DBA Testing.
D 5144 Use of Standards in Nuclear Power.
1996 D 5%2 Maintaining Unqualified Coatings.
1997 D
33.10T Proposed Maintenance.
. Standard.
Don Hill -July 31,1997 i
PROPOSED STANDARD:
D 33.10 (97.1) T FOR:
MONITORINO AND MAINTENANCE USE:
ASSIST THE OWNER IN PREPARATION OF A COATING SPECIFICATION OR WORK INSTRUCTION FOR LEVEL 1 AREAS.
ACTIONS:
- 1. Do a Sun'ey.
l What Should Be in the Survey.
Qualification of the Person Doing Sun'ey.
+
Qualification of the Evaluator of Survey Must Be Done Every Two (2) Years.
- 2. Identify Present Materials in Use.
- 3. Find Qualification Data of Materials - Both Existing and That to Be Used for Maintenance.
- 4. If Unqualified Coatings Are in Senice Level 1 Areas - Go Evaluate Them.
- 5. Diving Team Suggested for Inspection and Undenvater Repair.
- 6. Detennine Surface Preparation.
- 7. Detennine Application Methods and Equipment.
- 8. Determine Compatibility - Suggests ASTM D 5064.
- 9. Be Aware of Effects Upon Stainless.
- 11. Allows for Commercial Grade Dedication in Keeping With 10 CFR, Part 21.
DonIhlt July 31,1997
PRE R.G.1.54 PLANTS:
l l
- 1) Liner Plate: Vinyl 2)
Dre.sden Tests
- 3) All " UNQUALIFIED" - Vinyl; Alkyds; Vinyl Alkyds; Epoxy Esters.
- 4) Thin Film Epoxy Systems
POST R.G.1.54 PLANTS:
QUALIFIED SYSTEMS (DBA/ RADIATED TESTED)
- 1) Inorganic Zinc
+
Phenolic Epoxy
- 2) Inorganic Zinc + Epoxy
- 3) Inorganic Zine No Top Coat
- 4) Epoxy + Epoxy (Thin Film)
- 5) Epoxy Hi Build Mastics I
e
STATE OF THE ART 1997
- 1) D.T.O Formulations - DBA/ Radiation Tested.
- 2) D.O.W Formulations - DBA/ Radiation Tested.
- 3) 95 %/100 % Solid Epoxy Coatings with Low Viscosities.
- 4) Safer, User
- Friendly, Better Performance, Little effect if any on charcoal.
- 5) Advanced Equipment for Prep and Application Answers concerns of ALARA of distance and time.
n NY
- 1) REVIEW SAR to establish your ground rules.
- Change where needed to implement new standard and procedures using 50.59.
- 2) Write a procedure for coating work implementing ASTM procedures and practices; new coating technology and methods.
Seriously consider:
2.1 Surface prep methods that will be " Dose Saving".
2.2 State of the art coating materials to avoid coating failures. Let these new formulations and resins do the work rather than your workman.
- 3) Train and Re-train 3.1 Management Support 3.2 Worknlan using SSPC; ASTM; your procedures and new technology.
a s
- Guideline on the Elements of a Nuclear Safety-Related Coatings l
Program Sponsored by EPRI Plant Support Engineering Program Project Manager: Fran Rosch
- oatingS Guideline e
Background:
NRC Proposed GL
- Requests summary of Class 1 Coatings Control Program
- Compliance with your plant's licensing basis related to the amount and tracking of unqualified ccatings
r
- Evaluate proposed GL
- Provide comments to assist NEl with response
- Attendees included coatings experts and individuals involved in stralner blockage work EPRI Coatings Guideline e Utilities proposed EPRI develop a guideline to:
- Assist utilities in assuring their current programs provide adequate guidance for the procurement, applications, and maintenance of SR coatings
t
)
EPRI Coat ngs GuidelLne e For more information contact:
l
- Bob Howard, TVA Utility Task Group Chairman Ph: (423) 7518208 rihoward@tva. gov
- Fran Rosch, EPRI Project Manager l
Ph: (704) 547-6073 frosch@lawson,epri.com
--_7.-mg--...
.i.,,,,.,,,,
i f
I e
f 4
I I
f i
e i
=
b h
t l
6 I
1 L
a 1
E f
f i
b I,
- i E
4 9
?
f f
f i,
E i
?
t t
?
I e
-f r
.h 4
f 3
i ii i
E I
b I
4 i
l t
4 i
1
'm
+
?
.b I
It
'1 r
8 L a-....
. _.._=_,
oatings Guideline K
e Guideline is to implement and be consistent with existing requirements e Guideline development is being coordinated with Owners Groups involved in strainer / sump blockage issue resolution e Guideline to reference existing industry guidance (e.g., ASTM standards) where applicable Project Status e First meeting held on July 29-30,1997
- Developed a drafi outline for the guideilne
- Meeting attended by 36 Individuals representing 24 utilities e Next Meeting September 22-23 to review complete draft of guideline e Meeting in Mid-November to review second draft o Goal to Publish before the end of 1997
s 4
Culdelines en the Elem:nts of a j
Nuclear Safety Related Coatings Control Program Draft Outline July 29,1997 Application of outside containment coatings Application of touch-up and repair Precautions for surface preparation and coatings application Environmental controls s
Waste Management e
7.0 Inspection of Surface Preparation and Application Types ofInspection
- - Surveillance Inspections Hold Point Inspections - Containment Hold Point Inspections - Outside Containment e
FinalInspections-Containment 3
Final Inspections - Outside Containment 8.0 Condition Assessment Scope of coatings to be assessed e
Prioritization of coatings to be assessed i
e
.. Condition assessment techniques (visual plus others)
Frequency of condition assessment
- Assessment criteria
. Evaluation of data Documentation (paper, photos, video)
Dispositions of observations (evaluate, repair, replace, follow-up) e Guidance for the early identification of failures o
Coordination of condition assessment with other plant Inspections 0 Take credit for other inspections (ASME Section XI) 4 Trending of assessment data and coating performance e
9.0 Personnel Training and Qualification Table of functions and recommended qualification and training
' 10.
Management of Unqualifiea Coatings j
Definition of " unqualified" coatings j
e General guidance on evaluating amount of unqualified coatings in containment Guidance on managing unqualified coatings (may be a coatings e.
l log) 1 4-i i
=
d+
+' -
en N
mur-
- 47-t'W trN=P 4s%w
+ea--%?'*:-
m-v vW g
y e-v 3 e-ers n+m - y g sqm-vt+t PN9--tr-
- - -g y-mwga-wW 4'
P4 wy w'
pr
Culdelines cn the Elem:nts cf a Nuclear Safety Related Coatings Control Program Draft Outline July 29,1997 i
1.0
. Introduction / Background i
2.0 Listing of Coatings Related Information L
Applicable Regulatory Documents e
l Industry Standards 4
i Definitions e
Acronyms e
i l
3.0 -
Safety-Related Coatings Program Scope of coatings programs Program Responsibilities i
e Investigate design basis and program commitments e
0 Inside containment general coatings O Inside containment immersion coatings
]
0 Outside containment general coatings 0 Outside containment immersion coatings i
Discuss sump / strainer blockage and other plant issues related to l
e l
safety-related coatings.
f l
4.0-Qualification / Selection of Coatings Systems Qualification testing of inside containment coatings - general Qualification testing of inside containment coatings - immersion e
j Qualification testing.of outside containment coatings - immersion Evaluation and acceptance of qualification test data e
5.0 Material Procurement and Materials Management Development of procurement specification -
Procurement from 10 CFR 50, Appendix B approved suppliers Commercial grade dedication e
Packaging, shipping, handling, storage, shelf life
. Receipt inspection e Documentation j
6.0 Surface Preparation and Coatings Application Surface preparation for containment coatings - general e
Surface preparation for containment coatings - immersion i
e l-
. - Surface preparation for outside containment coatings -immersion Surface preparation for touch-up and repair (3 categories)
Application of containment coatings e
i i
1 J"-
_,, L _ _ u c =N:' "" U *. ; '. ~ " - ,..., _ _.. _,,,. _
.~.
t 4
j Project No. 669-
-c Electric Power Research Institute-i Mr. Raymond C. Torok Project Manager, Nuclear Power Group
+
l Electric Power Research Institute 2
Post Office Box 10412
' Palo Alto, CA-94303 r
l Mr. Gary L. Vine Senior Washington Representative Electric Power Research Institute i
- 2000 L Street, N.W., Suite 805
. Washington, DC 20036 i
-t h
f a
+
1 s;-
i t
t it 1
+
9 1
4 t
J n
f =
4
=m..-
vv e-
- -p+--vw"gv".g e
9 hy,
w q
,y*ig.p,w e-.yy.--y w.
g,w-u
-re-e-cy--p,-c.w.-*-yvew q
-y%.,
. w w.. p ge- -g r yc-3g-y.
,w a
-.'-y-ve-wg eg.e-4---,-
August 18, 1997 MEMORANDUM TO:
David B. Matthews, Chief Generic Issues and Environmental Projects Branch Division of Reactor Program Management, NRR FROM:
James H. Wilson, Senior Project Manager Original Signed By:
j Standardization Project Directorate Division of Reactor Program Management, NRR
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF PUBLIC MEETING HELD ON JULY 31, 1997, WITH THE ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE (EPRI) TO DISCUSS EPRI'S C0ATINGS PROGRAM l
On April 22, 1997, the staff held a public meeting at NRC headquarters in Rockville, Maryland with representatives of the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), National Electric Institute (NEI), and the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM)iatives being undertaken by the participants at th D-33 Committee. The purpose of this meeting was to exchange information on init in order to coordinate future actions in this area.
A list of attendees and their affiliations is provided as Attachment 1.
4 Members of the ASTM D-33 Committee described some background on the history of this issue.
The handouts used in the ASTM presentation are provided as.
EPRI described its efforts to develop a coatings guideline. The handouts used in this presentation are provided as Attachment 3.
EPRI also presented a draft outline of its nuclear-related coatings control program (Attachment 4).
EPRI will hold working meetings September 22-23 and in mid-November to review and revise the draft of the guideline. The staff will meet with EPRI/NEI immediately after each of the industry working meetings.
NEI will provide versions of the draft guidelines to the staff a week or so in advance to facilitate meaningful exchange during the meetings.
The NRC Office of Research will be timing the development and release for comment of its Reg Guide 1.54 in order to take advantage of insights provided by the utility efforts.
Project No. 669 Attachments: As stated cc w/ atts:
See next page DISTRIBUTION w/ attachmentn PUBLIC-Docket PGEB r/f BSheron RHerman ASerkiz TTMartin 4
MSlosson JStrosnider ESu111 van JDavis RElliott RLobel LCampbell I
Document Name: G:\\JHWl\\MEETSUM.731 C:kGkS) 0FC PGE M )
(A)SC:PGEB C:IMCB
,n NAME JHWils[n:sw MJCas @ IStrosnN DBhhews DATE 08//f/97 08//.f/97 N 08/16/97 08/k/97 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY
[/**%
t UNITED STATES j
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION s
4' WASHINGTON, D.C. 20066 4 001 4****+,tt 4
August 18, 1997 i
MEMORANDUM T0:
David B. Matthews, Chief i
Generic Issues and Environmental Projects Branch Division of Reactor Program Management, NRR FROM:
JamesH. Wilson,SerorProjectManag6
.h M Standardization Project Directorate Division of Reactor Program Management, RR i
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF PUBLIC MEETING HELD ON JULY 31, 1997, WITH TP ELECTRIC POWER RESEARCH INSTITUTE (EPRI) TO DISCUSS EPRI C0ATINGS PROGRAM On April 22, 1997, the staff held a public meeting at NRC headquarters in Rockville, Maryland with representatives of the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), National Electric Institute (NEI), a'd the Avrican Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) D-33 Committee.
The purpose of this meeting was to exchange information on initiatives being undertaken by the participants at the meeting in order to coordinate future actions in this area.
A list of attendees and their affiliations is provided as Attachment 1.
Members of the ASTM D-Il Committee described some background on the history of this issue.
The handouts used in the ASTM presentation are provided as.
EPRI described its efforts to develop a coatings guideline.
The handouts used in this presentation are provided as Attachrant 3.
EPRI also presented a draft outline of its nuclear-related coatings control program (Attachment 4).
EPRI will hold working meetings September 22-23 and in mid-November to review and revise the draft of the guideline. The staff will meet with EPRI/NEI immediately after each of the industry working meetings.
NEI will provide versions of the draft guidelines to the staff a week or so in advance to facilitate meaningful exchange during the meetings.
The NRC Office of Research will be timing the development and release for comment of its Reg Guide 1.54 in order to take advantage of insights provided by the utility efforts.
Project No. 669 Attachments: As stated cc w/ atts:
See next page
LIST OF ATTtf0EES AT MEETING ON EPP.I C0ATINGS PROGRAM HELD 'N ROCKVILLE, MARYLAND ON JULY 31, 1997 l
HAMI AFFILIATION l
J. Strosnider NRC
- 1. Sullivan NRC J. Davis NRC R. Elliott NRC R. Lobel NRC A. Serkiz NRC E. Woolridge NRC J. Medoff NRC L. Campbell NRC M. Marshall NRC K. Battige NRC J. H. Wilson NRC F. Rosch EPRI D. Hill ASTH /WPPSS J. Butler NEI G. Dolderer FPL/NUCC R. Howard TVA/NUCC L. Waggoner Duke /NUCC D. Zabala SNOC/NUCC H. Carr BGE-CCNP J. Caturano comed /NUCC K. Fry Southern Nuclear J. Adrian Southern Company S. Crawford Consultant T. Sutter Bechtel W. Houston Sequoia Consulting Group G. Spires Advanced Corrosion Engineering K. Kunert NAC International l
D%f}
ggwNAs y/ M
(
TIMELINE OF NIICLEAR COATING STANDARDS 1972 - May ANSI.N 101.2 DBA Testing / Radiation / Curves
- Oct.
ANSI N 5.9; 512; 5.12 Protective Coatings for Nuclear
-Nov.
ANSI N.101.4 Quality Assurance 1973 D 3276 Standard Guide for Painting Inspectors 1973 - June R. G.1.54 ANSI '45.2 ANSI N.101.4 ANSI N.101.2 1974 D 3363 Film Hardness.
1975 NUREG 75087 DBA Conditions - Unqualified Paint Not Significant "Small Machinery and Equipment".
1979 ASTM PCN-03 Manual for Coating Work.
(Top Coating of Cured Coatings; Zines; Inspection;
' Maintenance and Painter Qualifications)
L
1950 D 3842 Guide - Coating / Methods Level 1 Applications.
D 3843 QA to replace ANSI N 101.4 1983 D 3911 Testing To Replace ANSI N 101.2 i
D 3912 Testing - To Replace ANSI N 5.12 i
D 4082 Gamma Radiation Testing 1985 D 4541 Adhesion - Using Pull Off Gauge l
1990 ASTM MN1.8 Maintenance Manual 1991 D 5043 Test Method for Field Identification of Paints.
D 5064 Standard Practice for. Conducting Compatibility in Shop or Field.
D 5139 Prep of Samples for DBA Testing.
3 D 5144 Use of Standards in Nuclear Power..
1996 D 5962 Maintaining Unqualified Coatings.
1997 D
33.10T Proposed Maintenance Standard.
Y Don Hill - July 31,1997 1
e
.e
PROPOSEDSTANDARD:
D 33.10 (97.1) T FOR:
MONITORING AND MAINTENANCE i
USE:
ASSIST THE OWNEP IN PREPARATION OF A I
COATING SPECIFICATION OR WORK INSTRUCTION FOR LEVEL 1 AREAS.
l ACTIONS:
- l. Do a Survey.
What Should Be in the Sun'ey.
Qualification of the Person Doing Sun'ey, Qualification of the Evaluator of Sun'ey Must Be Done Every Two (2) Years.
- 2. Identify Present Materials in Use.
- 3. Find Qualification Data of Materials - Both Existing and That to Be Used for Maintenance.
- 4. If Unqualified Coatings Are in Service Level 1 Areas - Go Evaluue Them.
- 5. Diving Team Suggested for Inspection and Undenvater Repair.
- 6. Determine Surface Preparation.
- 7. Determine Application Methods and Equipment.
- 8. Determine Compatibility - Suggests ASTM D 5064.
- 9. Be Aware of Effects Upon Stainless.
- 11. Allows for Commercial Grade Dedication in Keeping With 10 CFR, Part 21.
Don 11i11-My 31,1997
PRE R.G.1.54 PLANTS:
I
- 1) Liner Plate: Vinyl
- 2) Dresden Tests
- 3) All " UNQUALIFIED" - Vinyl; Alkyds; Vinyl Alkyds; Epoxy Esters.
- 4) Thin Film Epoxy Systems 4
Y
POST R.G.1.54 PLANTS:
QUALIFIED SYSTEMS (DBA/ RADIATED TESTED) l l
- 1) Inorganic Zinc
+
Phenolic Epoxy
- 2) Inorganic Zinc + Epoxy
~
- 3) Inorganic Zinc No Top Coat
- 4) Epoxy + Epoxy (Thin Film)
- 5) Epoxy Hi Build Mastics
I iun I
STATE OF THE ART 1997
- 1) D.T.O Formulations - DBA/ Radiation Tested.
- 2) D.O.W Formulations - DBA/ Radiation Tested.
- 3) 95%/100% Solid Epoxy Coatings with Low Viscosities.
- 4) Safer, User
- Friendly, Better Performance, Little effect if any on charcoal.
- 5) Advanced Equipment for Prep and Application Answers concerns of ALARA of distance and time.
.,0
- 1) REVIEW SAR to establish your ground rules.
- Change where needed to implement new standard and procedures using 50.59.
i
- 2) Write a procedure for coating work implementing ASTM procedures and practices; new coating technology and methods.
Seriously consider:
2.1 Surface prep methods that will be " Dose Saving".
2.2 State of the art coating materials to avoid coating failures. Let these new formulations and resins do the work rather than your workman.
- 3) Train and Re-train 3.1 Management Support 3.2 Wor'kman using SSPC; ASTM; your procedures and new technology.
i
\\
Guideline on the Elements of a Nuclear Safety-Related Coatings Program Sponsored by EPRI Plant Support Engineering Program Project Manager: Fran Rosch oatings Guideline e
Background:
NRC Proposed GL
- Requests summary of Class 1 Coatings Control Program
- Compliance with your plant's licensing basis related to the amount and tracking of unqualified coatings
t EPRI Coatings Guideline e For more information contact:
- Bob Howard, TVA UtilityTask Group Chairman Ph: (423) 751-8208 rihoward@tva. gov
- Fran Rosch, EPRI Project Manager Ph: (704) 547-6073 frosch@lawson.epri.com
oatings Guideline 1
e Guideline is to implement and be consistent with existing requirements e Guideline developmentis being l
coordinated with Owners Groups involved in strainer / sump blockage issue resolution e Guideline to reference existing industry guidance (e.g., ASTM standards) where applicable Project Status 1
I e First meeting held on July 29-30,1997
- Developed a citaff outline for the guideline
- Meeting attended by 36indMduals representing 24 utilities e Next Meeting September 22-23 to review complete draft of guideline e Meeting in Mid-November to review second draft e Goal to Publish before the end of 1997
Culdelines en the Elements cf a i
Nuclear Safety Related Coatings Control Program Draft Outilne July 29,1997 Application of outside containment coatings Application of touch-up and repair e
Precautions for surface preparation and coatings application Environmental controls Waste Management 7.0 Inspection of Surface Preparation and Application Types ofInspection SurveillanceInspections Hold Point Inspections - Containment e
Hold Point Inspections - Outside Containment FinalInspections-Containment Final Inspections - Outside Containment L
8.0 Condition Assessment Scope of coatings to be assessed e
Prioritization of coatings to be assessed Condition assessment techniques (visual plus others)
Frequency of condition assessment e
- Assessment criteria Evaluation of data e
Documentation (paper,phoW, video) e Dispositions of observations (evaluate, repair, replace, follow-up)
Guidance for the early identification of failures e
Coordination of condition assessment with other plant Inspections 0 Take credit for other inspections (ASME Section XI)
Trending of assessment data and coating performance 9.0 Personnel Training and Qualification Table of functions and recommended qualification and training e
10.
Management of Unqualified Coatings Definition of " unqualified" coatings General guidance on evaluating amount of unqualified coatings in e
containment Guidance on managing unqualified coatings (may be a coatings log)
_ _ _ = _ _ _ _ - _ - _ _
Culdelin:s cn the Elem:nte cf a Nuclear Safety Related Coatings Control Progra.m Draft Outline July 29,1997 1.0 Introduction / Background 2.0 Listing of Coatings Related Information Applicable Regulatory Documents Industry Standards e
Definitions Acronyms 3.0 Safety-Related Coatings Program Scope of coatings programs Program Responsibilities e
Investigate design basis and program commitments 0 Inside containment general coatings l
0 Inside containment immersion coatings 0 Outside containment general coatings -
0 Outside containment immersion coatings Discuss sump / strainer blockage and other plant issues related to e
safety-related coatings 4.0 Qualification / Selection of Coatings Systems Qualification testing of inside containment coatings - general e
Qualification testing ofinside containment coatings -immersion Qualification testing of outside containment coatings -immersion Evaluation and acceptance of qualification tast data -
e 5.0 Material Procurement and Materials Management Development of procurement specification Procurement from 10 CFR 50, Appendix B approved suppliers e
Commercial grade dedication Packaging, shipping, handling, storage, shelf life ReceiptInspection e
e Documentation 6.0 Surface Preparation and Coatings Application Surface preparation for containment coatings - general e
Surface preparation for containment coatings - immersion e
Surface preparation for outside containment coatings - immersion Surface preparation for touch-up and repair (3 categories)
Application of containment coatings e
Project No. 669 Electric. Power Research Institute Mr. Raymond C. Torok Project Manager, Nuclear Power Group Electric Power Research Institute Post Office Box 10412 Palo Alto, CA 94303 Mr. Gary L. Vine
- Senior Washington Representative Electric Power Research Institute 2000'L Street, N.W., Suite 805 l
Washington, DC 20036 t-e
'.