ML20141E977

Rev 1 to DCP Unit 1 Cycle 16 Colr

ML20141E977
Person / Time
Site:	Cook
Issue date:	05/31/1997
From:	AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER CO., INC.
To:
Shared Package
ML17333A897	List: ML20141E977
References
NUDOCS 9705210163
Download: ML20141E977 (12)

Text

. _ . . ._ .. . _ . . __ _

i t

N DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT (COLR)

Revision 1 May 1997 )

9705210163 970514 PDR ADOCK 05000315 P PDR

, .,. COLR for DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT l CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997 i

1.0 . ' CORE OPERATING LIMITS REPORT I This Core Operating Limits Report for the Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant Unit 1 Cycle 16 redesign has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of Technical Specification 6.9.1.9.

The Technical Specifications affected by this report are listed below:

3/4.1.1.4 Moderator Temperature Coeflicient 3/4.1J.1- Movable Control Assemblies Group Height 3/4.1.3.3 Rod Drop Time 3/4.1.3.4 Shutdown Rod Insertion Limits 3/4.1.3.5 Control Rod Insertion Limits  !

3/4.2.1 Axial Flux Difference 3/4.2.2 Ileat Flux flot Channel Factor 3/4.2.3 Nuclear Enthalpy Hot Channel Factor 3/4.2.6 Allowable Power Level i

r

+

t i

i  !

1

. i Page1 ofi1

, Revision 1 i

, , COLR for DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997 i

2.0 - Operatine Limits ne cycle-specific parameter limits for the specifications listed in Section 1.0 are presented in the following subsections. These limits have been developed using the NRC-approved methodologies specified in Technical Specification 6.9.1.9.  ;

2.1 Moderator Temocrature CoefTicient (Specification 3/4.1.1.4) r 2.1.1 ne Moderator Temperature Coefficient (MTC) limits are:

The MTC shall be less positive than the value given in Figure 1.

The ARO/RTP-MTC shall be less negative than -4.54E-4 Ak/k/ F at a vessel average s temperature in the range from 553*F to 557 F.

where: ARO stands for All Rods Out RTP stands for Rated Thermal Power 3

2.1.2 The MTC Surveillance limit is:

The 300 ppm /ARO/RTP-MTC should be less negative than or equal to -3.84E-4 Ak/k/ F at a vessel average temperature in the range from 553*F to 557'F.

i Page 2 0f 11 i Revision i

'

• E

( , _, COLR for DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - M AY 1997  :

J

' 2.2 ~ Rod Droo Time Droo Height (Specification 3/4.133)

{

~

2.2.1 - All rods shall be dropped from 225 steps.

?

j. . 23 Shutdown Rod insertion Limit (Specification 3/4.13.4)- l

.23.1 - The' shutdown rods shall be withdrawn to 225 steps. '

l 2.4 Control Rod Insertion Limits (Specifications 3/4.13.5 and 3/4.13.1)  !

2.4.1 The control rod banks shall be limited in physical insertion as shown in Figure 2. j 2.4.2 Successive Control Banks shall overlap by 97 steps. He sequence for Control Bank ,

withdrawal shall be Control Bank A, Control Bank B, Control Bank C, and Control j Bank D.  !

.i . I 2.5 Axial Flux Difference (Specification 3/4.2.1)

• 2.5.1 De Allowable Operation Limits are provided in Figure 3.  ;

2.5.2 ' The AXIAL FLUX DIFFERENCE (AFD) target band during base load operations is +3%,

-3% (not applicable for this cycle). ,

i 253 The AFD target band is +5%,-5% for a cycle average accumulated bumup > 0.0 MWD /MTU.

4 i

1 I

l l

l l

i Page 3 of i1  !

Revision 1 -

.i

~ . . - . .. . . . . ..

^

,. , COLR for DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997 .

l t

2.6 : Heat Flux Hot Channel Factor-FQ(Z)(Specification 3.2.2)  !

i Fo(Z) s CFo p

• K(Z) for P > 0.5 y Fg(Z) s 2

• CFg

• K(Z) forPS0.5^  :

THERAML POWER l where:

P = RATED THERMAL POWER  :

2.6.1 CFQ = 2.15 for Westinghouse fuel 2.6.2 K(Z) is provided in Figure 4 for Westinghouse fuel l e

f i

l l

Page 4 of 1 I Revision I  ;

'. \

, ., COLR for IX)NALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997 2,7 Nuclear Enthalov Rise flot Channel Factor - FN agj (Specification 3/4.2.3)

N Fy, S CFm * (1 + PFw * (1 - P))

TilERMAL POWER where: P = RATED THERMAL POWER 2.7.1 CFA}{ = 1.49 for Westinghouse fuel 2.7.2 PFAl{ = 0.3 l

i I

l

)

i l

l l

Page 5 of 1 i  ;

Revision 1 l

-. - . . . . - . ... - .- . _ _ _ = .. ..-. . .- . ..

.. i

c. -

, g. COLR for DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997  !

i i

i 2.8 Allowable Power Level- APL (' Specification 3.2.6)  ;

APL = mm. over Z for CFo

• K(Z) r Fo(Z)

• V(Z)

• Fr i

2.8.1 - V(Z) is provided in Table I for15% AFD target band , >

2.8.2 CFQand K(Z) are provided in COLR Sections 2.6.1 and 2.6.2, respectively 7 2.8.3 The following table shows Fp values which correspond to FQ margin decreases that are {

greater than 2% per 31 Effective Full Power Days (EFPD). These values shall be used to f!

adjust APL as per Surveillance Requirement 4.2.6.2. A 1.02 penalty factor shall be used at i

all cycle burnups that are outside this range. '

, Penalty f3urnup hiultiplier [

c  ;

t 4

775 1.0200 i 900 1.0231 '

• 1025 1.0229 t

, 1150 1.0227  :

1275 1.0225 *

, 1400 1.0229 1525 1.0238 1650 1.0243 1775 1.0235 1900 1.0222 i

2025 1.0210  !

2150. 1.0200 i

The burnup range only covers where Fp exceeds 1.02. Linear interpolation is adequate for  !

intermediate cycle burnups, f i

f 9

I i

. Page 6 of 1 I

[

Revision 1 t i

.- .I

~

. COLR for DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997 FIGURE I MODERATOR TEMPERATURE COEFFICIENT (MTC) 1.00 g .c g,.

,_ -

• l'

_a .,

y; bf a_ i { ' < :, a

, '" "J h #

0.90

' Wn if 4 "i n: -

., n ..

w- y

.f.

.a '. -

0.80 0 * * ~ '

.-+,- -

m 0.70

' ' U 'N J,q " j UNACCEPTABLE OPERATION ,

~

0.60

' E""*""""' ~ ~  !

IN .) p

- L'; .ll t .

, g, , , ",5

' C 0.50 qu 'Q;)

a:- , s hjj q w' . -

0.40

'

• _" > -2*

• 1-ISI v .. .

4 t <. ..

,,,.y-6 -' ( o .. . .

) ..}.-

0.30 C J*i w y .

I m 0.20 *

. d ... s e .  :."3 .&

0.10

, fAbdbh AblEbh'kRATION y",; m

.r ,

s.

C 0.00 n' 4 ..

s

~

c.,

o -

y{y.

.e yw ,,

',p l

^" *

l 6'..

a

.' R l

• -0.10 1 U ar ~

t\

. :i .

H . , l w

<- -0.20

"("'

.9:.

M

..b t. .

l.py , i A: "'

' i.

~

-0.30 , , . v, .- % .

, , . o.' .j,. 6 ,

T

-, f '

"I

+

- ^' " "

'j

-0.40 ,

g ., .l-. ; p 9 l 3._ ..

-0.50

'd ' '

3h d.

$ 4,, ,

, t g- 7.(; y

-0.60 1~ >

d.,i.

-0.70

• " '~

' ^

,  ?!? -%

> . ., c . ,

1. A  ;

. i 3,( ',j. a ,e 3

W i

'? ' ' ; ' %-

' ' & c

-0.80

-- u .

r E I b

g... 4 s -

-0.90 m

-1.00

't ,

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 PERCENT RATED TilERMAL POWER 1

Page 7 of i1 Revision I

l I

l . .

COLR for IX)NALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997 \

FIGURE 2 ROD HANK INSERTION LIMITS VERSUS TIIERMAL POWER FOUR-LOOP OPERATION 250 l

~.

/ 9:l, E t^ .1

_. . v  ; y e' a !, .m

~bc?  ;

. %C 8 < 'm '

+

225 N, 9 ai a-- o

. p ;m - -

-.;S

- ; ,e ,

c

' i(51.3,225) 97 STEP OVERLAP !!

4-- - -

~

.i- .;; f -

..:r n,-

3 .c.

>r,<.. .

~ ,

+- a. -

a 200

• D '

yg ,T ,

Jd hl ',

']' (100,189) ,

I Q: i . np l '

e' 175  ::}~ " " ' "

z

, 7; . . - ~ . . ~ .

m. (

r -1(BANK C) [f ~'

o  : '-

W

% mg.g ,L .

l

1. - t i

" ~

w 150 r ft) ' '

.z .n

~

r ,,

s _.

1 l

,. V4 (' y -  !

W <(0,128) .:o M._ r-m >

g 125' a 4

. j p

. . > 3

.. g < . e

~ ' ' '.

o A

'V s;;b '*'  ;

g"'fn & :

g u .; >

+  :::;n w. l 0

c

- ) -

n.m m g 1 pm '

w <;w n . ,

&r . A ?,p yV y

!^ ,- . c ,

o

^

2 '

i(BANK D) %^ < L ';~

4 - ,s

^ ~ ' ' " ' ~

75 w : s  ::

w' , 0a >

s' w

3 # ,

' I # '

50 e.n ....

.c er j. e

'p 4, j, .

-.'ti J pq y}4. ' i< 3 - m r

F,. 5 p. y - 4 .. f3

, x >wvq. - ,

en o, ,

s -

25

(>1 ." 9 4 n; 4 1

l (0,0) f.

. =

[;z 6<-

' i 1

).<

ifi?

a g, N

~

,1 J. ,

0 ,

0.00 0. !0 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 0.80 0.90 1.00 FRACTION OF RATED TIIERMAL POWER 4

l l

l 1

4 Page 8 of I I Revision i

. i 1

4 l

l COLR for DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997 l 1

1 r

i l

FIGURE 3 )

AXfAL FLUX DIFFERENCE LIMITS AS A FUNCTION OF RATED TIIERMAL POWER 100

, :) ?. ,

.+ ,

Adt .

~

kw tl I ~ '

,,.- .,  :-11.90 IU

~ # ' 111.900-

~

4 .? '

90 >v >

,+,;

ee v.

i

.~.

m.

',s>- , ,.

n g #; UNACCEPTABLE?; . r <-

UNACCEPTABLE

$a 80 -j OPERATION ,,

OPERATION g fi . , , ~ , ,. .

l: ,it  ; .

p 70 w:

, ,,-:. (,;s, --

y o ,

4

-4 ACCEPTABLE ;-

g -

y-- , 'y OPERATION i.

a: it  ;

H ' ' '

2 60 I

, c. . . .

>P y :l , ,

'\ .t t 50

$ -31.50 1

'31.50 # -

g pp , -:1 ,

w - ' 44 ,

• 4 40 f  ;;

s-

v. -

r .j :,,

m m,9 t-t

, ~; .

s w<

, 7

& J

, , 6 I y

> ? ': -

l f, 1.: , ,

, 1

- 30 ,

E L + 1- > F -' ' '

p 4 > l 3

s '

o g ,

4 ji 20

<g & 8  !: ; '

. k .- <

t 4 s , _

, _ o

, s >

v. c) 10 l

- . ~ ;; p , .,

< , 1

.- y g

~

t 0

-50 -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 Flux Difference (Delta I), %

I l

Page 9 0f i l Revision 1

e

, , COLR for DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997 FIGURE 4 K(Z)-NORMALIZED FQ(Z) AS A FUNCTION OF CORE IIEIGIIT FOR WESTINGIIOUSE FUEL 1.2 - -

?-y < , .;

'Y- __

z *

> "y - -:- _

, , ,_ _ ., , s 4 +

'[ d .,,f "[

T ,I. 4

,{4:

', { ;p. , y v,,

. n: ,

%Q '

c , ,,

V 7'i ,' ,

j(0.0,1.0) o. (6.0,1.0) i ,

c., ,

i , . .w + , ' g?, s ,.

+ i: -r

.2, g .. >

.-41 e

i q , s .; , >.w

~ , *'r, w. .

f h (' 1 ,~

1 /

f 9

.s s ,'( k , . u. . .-

f, g'

,: j (12.0,0.925) 6 - ; 6 <

,.n .

,m tc 0,8 ' ' '

a v u -

.t . ,

7 -

ini g a it ;r. --

y .

.s: , ,

'+ l C

g ' '

w 0.6 "

N.

2!~

) < > \

e

. ,4 f, .,

.-v ,c . g; 4

! jaisi; t; a: -

o

. . w:. .:n -

y,

.; , ,,  ?:rer:

~ " ~ ' '

0.4 4 n- ,,

4 .

[j:  ; r

, .-- .., 4 4 ,-

,r;. n

,'/. 3 '-

,y,-

- i & 's r . g

~

I; ;

5.

9 , , . .

r '

0.2 -

y s ,-

4

p g l .

1  ;

we V- ,<..

_ j( ,v

-. 4'

.,J_- ,

p___

7 u

.L ~

j

.'e

$ l 1

~ l' 0

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 l

CORE 18EIGIIT (FT) l i

1 1

l 1

i 1

1 1

Page 10 of 1 I Revision I i

l

,.o*

T

, . COLR for DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT UNIT 1 CYCLE 16 - MAY 1997 TABLEi DONALD C. COOK UNIT l CYCLE 16 REDESIGN V(Z)I' UNCTION llEIGitT llURNUP (M%TXMTU) g . M0 1000 2000 3000 # 00 6000 8000 Im00 12000 14000 18160

1. 00 1.0000 IS000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 10000 1 0000 1 0000 1.0000

2. OJ 1.0000 1 0000 10000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 ID000 1.0000 1.0000

3. 0.4 1D000 10000 1.0000 1D00( 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 '

4 06 1.00)0 1.0000 1.0000 1.0001 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 IS000 1.0000 1.0000

5. 0.8 1.0000 1 0000 1 0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 10000 1.0000 1.0000 10000 1.0000 6 40 1D000 10000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 L0000 1.0000 10000 1.0000 1.0000

7. 1.2 10992 1.0994 10999 1.1006 1.1015 1.1038 1.1070 1.1109 1.1158 1.1214 1.1324 8 f .4 12988 th991 1.0996 1.1002 1.1011 1.1033 1.1063 1.1100 11845 1.11 % 1.1298 9 1.6 1.0983 ID986 1.0991 1.0997 1.1005 1.1026 1.1053 1.1087 1.1128 1.1175 1.1268

10. 1.8 1.0977 1 0980 1 0984 1.0990 1.0997 1.1015 1.1040 1.1070 1.1106 1.1148 1.1230

11. 20 1.0969 12971 lh975 10980 1.0987 1.1003 1.1024 1.1050 1.1081 1.1116 1.1186

12. 2.2 lh959 1.0962 ID965 1.0970 1.0975 1.0988 1.1005 1.1027 1.1051 1.1080 1.1137

13. 24 ID948 1 0950 1 0953 1.0956 1.0961 1.0971 1.0984 1.1000 1.1019 1.1040 1.1082

14. 26 12934 1.0936 1.0938 1.0441 1.0944 1.0951 1.0960 1.0971 80983 1.0997 1.1024

15. 2.8 1 0919 1.0923 19922 1.0923 1.0925 1.0929 1.0933 1 0938 ID944 1.0950 1.0962

16. 3.0 ID902 1 0903 1 0904 1.0904 1.0905 1 0906 1.0906 1.0906 ID905 1.0903 1.0900 17, 3.2 1.0885 1.0885 1.0885 th885 12885 1.0883 I.0880 1.0876 1.0871 ID865 1.0854 )

18 3.4 1 0875 1.0872 1,0869 1.0866 1.0864 1.0860 1.04 % l.0854 1h853 1.0852 1.0850 i

19. 3.6 1.0870 1.086.3 1.08 %  !.0850 12845 12840 1.0840 1.0846 1.0857 1.0873 1.0903 l 20 38 1.0864 1.0855 IS847 1.0841 th837 1.0834 1.0839 1D853 1 0875 10904 1.0959 l

21. 40 14815 1.0846 1.0839 1.0834 1.0832 1.0833 1.0844 ID865 1.08 % 1 0935 1.1011 j

22. 4.2 12851 1.0843 10837 1.0833 1.0832 1.0837 10853 1 0880 1.0917 th965 1.1057

23. 4.4 ID852 1.0844 1.0837 1.0833 1.0833 1.0840 1.0859 1 0891 1.0936 1.0992 1.1100 24 4.6 10853 1.0844 ID837 1.0833 1.0833 1.0842 1 0864 1.0901 10952 11015 1.1137

25. 48 10853 t.0844 1.0837 I.0833 1.0833 ID844 10869 1.0910 1.0965 1.1035 1.1169 26 5.0 1 0852 1.0843 1.0837 1.0834 1.0835 1.0847 1.0875 1.0919 1 0977 L1051 1.1192

27. 5.2 14850 1 0842 1 0836 1.0834 1.0835 1.0849 1.0879 1.0925 1 0987 11064 1.1211

28. 54 1.0846 1 S 838 1.0832 1.0830 1.0832 1.0848 1.0880 1.0928 1 0992 1 1072 11226 29 5.6 l.0840 1.0832 1.0826 1.0825 1.0827 1.0844 1.0876 1.0926 1.0993 1.1075 1.1233 j

30 58 1.0831 1 0822 1.0817 1.0816 1.0818 1.0836 1.0869 1.0920 1.0988 1.1071 1.1232  ;

31. 6.0 1.0818 10810 1.0805 1.0803 1.0806 1.0823 1.0857 l.0909 1.0977 1.1061 1.1224

32. 6.2 1.0803 1.0795 1.0789 1.0787 1.0790 1.0807 1.0841 1 0892 1 0960 1.1044 1.1207

33. 64 1 A784 1 0775 10769 1 0767 th769 1.0785 1.0818 1.0869 1 09 % 1.1020 1.1181 34 6.6 1.0761 14753 1.0747 1.0745 1.0748 1.0764 1.0796 1 0844 1.0909 1.0990 1.ll44  !

35. 68 1D733 1.0732 1.0732 1.0736 1.0742 1.0763 1.0795 I0839 1.0894 10959 1.1087 1

36. 7h I0701 1 0709 10720 1.0731 1D744 1.0771 1.0803 10838 10877 1.0920 I1007

31. 7.2 1.0663 1.0682 1.0704 12724 12744 lb780 1.0813 1 0842 1.0867 L0888 1.09 6 38 7.4 1.0640 1.0665 1 0693 1.0718 1.0742 1h783 1.0817 1 0843 1.0861 10871 ID899

39. 76 1 0668 1 0690 1 0714 1.0736 1.0756 LO790 1 0816 10833 1.0842 12842 1.0850

40. 7.8 1.0695 1 0714 1.0734 1.0751 1.0767 1.0792 1.0809 1.0817 1.0817 1.0808 1.07 % l 41 80 1.0715 10728 1 0741 1 0754 1.0764 12782 1.0795 1.0802 1 0803 1.0799 1.0795 j 42 82 10734 1.0740 10746 1.0752 l0757 1.0768 1.0779 ID788 1.0797 LO806 1.0823

43. 84 10748 4.0750 1 0753 1.0756 12759 I.0767 1.0776 1.0787 1 0799 1.0812 IS839 44 86 I.0757 LO760 1 0764 l.0769 lA774 1.0785 1.0799 1D814 1.0832 1 0851 1.0890

45. 88 1D779 iD784 I0790 1.0797 10804 Ib820 1.0837 10857 iD878 10902 1.0949 46 90 1.0818 10824 1.0832 1 D840 10848 1.0866 10885 1.0906 1.0929 1.0953 1.1002

47. 9.2 1 0865 ID872 1 0880 1.0889 1.0898 1.0917 1 0936 1.0957 1.0979 1.1001 1.1047

48. 94 1.0910 1.0914 I W27 1.0936 LO946 1 0965 1.0984 1 1004 Il025 1 1045 1.1088 49 96 ID957 10965 1 0974 10984 12993 1.1012 1.1030 1.1049 1.1067 1 1085 1.1123 50, 98 11003 1 1010 L1019 1.1029 1.1038 1.1056 1.1074 f.1092 11110  ?.1128 1.1165

51. 10.0 1.1046 41053 11068 1.1070 1.1079 1.1096 i1114 1!!32 1.1151 1.1870 1.1209 52 10.2 1.1087 11091 11101 1.4109 1.1187 1 1834 1.1151 11870 I1189 11209 1.1251 51 1ill; l

10 4 till5 11838 1.1146 1.1153 1.1169 1.1186 11204 1.1223 1 1243 1.1284 i 54 10 6 l.1159 1.1165 il172 1.1179 1.ll86 1.1202 11218 f.1235 1.1252 L1271 1.1309  !

55. 10 8 1.1190 11896 11202 1.1209 L1216 1.1231 1.1246 1.1261 11278 11294 1.1329 I 56 11 0 1.0000 1.0000 10000 1.0000 1.0000 12000 1.0000 L0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000

57. ill 1.0000 L0000 10000 ID000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 10m)0

58. 11 4 1.0000 10000 1 0000 10000 1.0000 14000 10000 10000 10000 1.0000 1.0000 )

59 11.6 10il00 lA000 1 0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 1.0000 60 iL8 10000 l0000 10000 10000 1.0000 10000 10000 10000 10000 1.0000 1.0000 61 12.0 1.0000 1.0000 1 0000 1 0000 1.0000 L0000 1 0000 1 0000 L0000 10000 1.0000 Top and butsom 10% of con enluileil as per Techmcal Spectamns.  !

1 Page1Iof1I Revision i

. -