ML20136C061

Site Problem Rept 152,Revision 1,re Failure of Makeup Pump Gear Oil Cooler to Meet Spec CS3-113 Paragraph 3.5 of Tubular Exchanger Manufacturers Association Stds.Spec Incomplete & Will Be Revised.Supporting Matl Encl

ML20136C061
Person / Time
Site:	Three Mile Island
Issue date:	01/06/1978
From:	Culberson D, Rise D, Rogers L BABCOCK & WILCOX CO.
To:
References
TASK-TF, TASK-TMR 152-01, 152-1, PROB-780106, NUDOCS 7909140338
Download: ML20136C061 (7)

Text

- .. . . - . . . ~ . . . . _ - - _

c+ -* a **-e e s wa-

> Ame ...w.

t.

,.-.,.g, , i O. ,

7 O

SITE PROBLT>i RCPORT TRANSHITTAL 1

~.

9

• **** CLEARED ****

FILE: 13 6 2 - o/

TO: caAme eo r/Poe For Distribution CONTRACT NO: 620-00 04 S . Jl. Klein - Ouality Assuranec SPR /r2-o/ ,

Central Enrineering Tiles TITLE m J. per m? 6140

4. Se>% ,- fa - Task Enciticer 62/L coesIn L .47. Be Fre r - Proj ec t !!a na r er DATE: /-9-7F fl

- STATUS CODE <

E. L. Logan - FLORIDA g.p.tum noa3fg L. C. Rogers - MET. ED.

F. R. Taist - TOLEDO J. R. Bohart - Inti. Support l

J. L. Donnc11 - 0FR B. A. Karrasch - Plant Integration l Attached is one copy of Site Probics Report No. /52- o / __ vhich was processed Future contracts have been reviewed for the  :

. on Contract 620-00 />4 .

1 I

potential of a similar probics. This probica is/1s not considered applicabic to other contracts 1

REMARKS:

L

/

, 2 Ab NUCLEAR SERVICE SUPPORT ENGINEER 7 9 0014 033<5 l A ] ? eb. re,Jsr? C i ,i l

ak P $2 b biPadb /

t I. _. .ss . e.e - , es. . mW

@ py PDS-21091 S( 8 -7 6 )

• (. -

.. ' SITE PROBLEM REPORT- ,, _ BABCOCK & YlILCOX a_m wwomeurue===sumsnx=:mne=mem=mwm_._

DOC.ID. CO=f no. SPR h0. k E Y . M O. i CUSTOHER O A i G i kgGW ' Gi! 152  !

620-c006 13 ol Jersey Central L. ac:m /&/77 PART MO./IASK h0. GMGUP MO. 5EQ. ev. l P.A. M0.

[ ~

YENDOR Bingha: 021661 35-033-001 PROSLEN CONTACT .g ..,.

TITI.E (MAI 30 CHARACTERS) L. L Le e 's * .h M ey . , z. 3 --- c, e n . mi DESCRIPTION OF PROBLEM:

Resolution to SPR 152-0 stated that the correct specifict. tion to be applied to the naheup pump gear oil cooler is CS3-113. Spec CS3-113 paragraph 3.5 states that, "Where oil ecclers e.re required they shall be designed in I accordance with the standards of the Tubulcr Fxchanger Manufacturcrs Association. '

E The Customer has been infereed by heat exchanger manufacturer, EASCO, that 3 the originally supplied coolers and replacement coolers do not meet this i i

h* spec. i "z

l 5

a l

y STATUS-ACTION TO DATE. INCt.U0lelG PERSONS CONTACTED:

R. P. Willia son and S. P. Funk. houser contacted. It was noted that the spec, as written with no specific TEM standard designated, is ineceplete and should 4 be revised.

FURTHER ACTION RECOMMENDED BY SITE PERSONNEL:

Revise spec C33-113 to 1) clarify which TEG standard should be applied or 2) eliminate any reference ,o TEM standard so that the Customer can

s. order a replace =ent heat exchanger.

RESOLUTION: .

See cdached 4slecopy of oryinal SPR 4e resokHon oncl ctycovd signabres.

x o APPROYED By DATE DATE

PREPARED B

>>! v.fl&.4% 12.//3l91 S v o

REYlEWED BY DATE l

.O c l

COST CATEGORY FIELD CHANGE REQ f.C.A. NO.

SIGNIF. OEFICICHCY ONORs OTHER O OYES NO Q oy. NA OYES NO y DEVIATIOkS:

SITE COMPLETION REP 0ki:

O MOME SPR REV h0. O Ep Ausac.- Heer kada'u. h BMco 8tuw(4: 3 . , ,

'. DATE COMPLETED: i x werw.o. ""

I o .

'e ..>" "<' ~~

COMPLETE BY DATE )

/

jg

\

• • ** 6,8 o > ,y r ;.* ' ~ ~~ -r - t*. -< ( ,

'E .- y... -- ,.. . .< . ,_ _,. ,

u

~~' - . - -..- ---,... _. . . . . _ _ . _ _ .

1 SHEET OF

. . )

1

f_ __,, _ . . . --.-

2 - . . . . - . . . . , . , . ...---y f.

cg 7 g ,,) , y ps -a~ .-

s

- .I <

, t, ~ a

$e t.

, .., .. 3

.~. .. ~. . . ~ .4 . ,.

,m.rN. .a ,,r 4- ..m

,% m

, I.

_~~..m-.m -n e -e- a.n -- - -

,* ww--

.-ma. rrma,mem. N m .w: m.m,M.f.

3 .-r,.,~,<- .* . -. m m.

.- ' Wii&4 M *j N i K*;it  ! % *, .exa.r:: *. D*N , .

.M i ;,m;g; .

.r . *

. . .v. :., : 1 c I s., . ., e, --

., a

. r~ ~

^ - . . , * - - *

- r.- -( <..g - w. ., . - -:

n.~

lW @M

. l %cs .

jr.A. 44. ) j i

W

. l m. .,-

. . un

-e ~  ! .v.:: m.. y t .

aernsus *Ms47 .~ .Q 6 8:6 1

,' .n ,e ,a. U s.1 . Cw.. -+ss... t . ..a r

{e .- . " .

s'."**

.  %.

• E Y. ~ g

"'; . ",.e *=** *'s. r.

• e, w as s._

s,e. p.,.%. :.e'e s..soe ., m me s mac =- - -

-_ _ _ _ _y, o ._j -

7- 7

/ ' 'M3CEIM pCA M P2CMih: -f

• l. "

,.g g *-a. e ..e, .,, .**"*D.

er4 d

y K,,<#5::-v'. e . n?.*..,%,,

a.

,p w ,g. . ..

y,,, q. #,

.a - -

J .H e. **p.

--o ,g . y, MfA - j.

fj . . .

• 7 l s

• M" e'ver.Q.a.".me * , % 2 $ C '

s p..e 2 ,.

. A.*.,. . y 4.a6.%,,,

-~

y y~. ,. ,; . , C,T =. C. ,g gY. y C"o t****s,,a.*=,'t.

w 8 ., vg r.=.m.-* ,.m.m, e er* / ,, ,

...s..,.*"

~

" w.* * *

, q. W .=q{ d .h p .C

• N.- d .+ M ** .(

p.

.. s m.- . e g. c=c....,s. .

k.g.._

g .v

- . v.

• . w C p.e .,

+*

e. . ~sC . c a , F J.,.

.e

=#

.4>..,

• . 5.*a' m.. -i.w.6 1- .i/. ce , c.. 9 c

g. p,.

• • .r.==. *

..e

-- ei g ey # .i *# *.= ' *6 .

Q ".~*.:: 06'.f T.O.P:" *- " b - .. . 'l rM"::-d. by '- --"*; :c:sc'u::{*r L".Or.f C.",:"C:* , E*M [ ^.h'" ~, ' ' 'k #

it ,

'~

. j i ;. . . . ==t 2:==*. ~~ hLs . * . , t.. ' .

• d' Y&Oe,.N=c c:i6:4.~.f F -~;lte:i cocle-t .

w .Q sr.c.

. .. ~

q .m *.&. ch.*K D .

," x ;.'

.O.

fl

,E.

f~.h..,

• f $.. .,.; . . * .. , . .;r,. .

l .*. v .i

.y... - /_(.. ,*. , l y*m.3. :<_e s' m. A.**. .,, :s  ;.y,.. ., n 7 .

..  : . : - i, . . = _ .. . .

. , . . ' .., w .',', .

.*,+., -

.+

• g

.. . p., . . . , . .

, 9. / , i .* .. . .f. ,, . . t .V. . j ;s. ., j. ..... '. , ,. .~., . .;e. s . . S j ? ). , d.

e.= ,.t:

. . ,. : .t . -. . s p. ,,

s .. ,-, .

r .

. . o.. ..

..;-A. M

, . _ ,;;, "e

.: . 4 ,,.,..,.;,.;,.

.r,..:.

4

.. p n..p....r t u , , ,

.,.a s

x., g .-

g,,,,

t e

' ,5,e $. %, . (* .f..-. ,..+,*p(,,.2 * ., ..g;.,#g.g .. 4.,.,

.:, 7. . ..,s- ,.. " ., :: . ..

, . . s.

.~*."s *

. j .d

,(..

., * *=* ",,

g 3*

• - . . = -$ . g ,, .f . . .

L .*.. . . .T r ;, , .

.,,' s. ;...y

• ** ;g*.. , . ,

' * * .,, ,{ -,f g.

, ~*

,1 -~ -

• .-l '/ . * * -

. ...*as . , , ~= . M..  ? _ r: '..3..'.

r

. . R

).

.g i w- "

^

Ul.D$= C ICE 10 U U. ' NUNIN .'*NNE

' C *

. . 2 ;* " . ,. ,' . + . , .

c, . . .

' #* 1 T.'> , . 7: . y* ? A

• e . J. .. ew $ ==. . .,1 .T,,.,. Ls. .n . . ..w.-

. + , ,.+ c 4 w ""4, m- . mtr . L e a. . e----r-,"*'"""),

. -. i. ,

.O d * . t"."*. .'llTi~~h L". 3FMIC N.A G C,d C*d Is.f.*I,N.".*rt'.M y .D ' hW .I.*.f"M *::5 fN.*.~-[a f .- l

• W- . .v. *-

' >. e

-. - .g. .,

, . . . , t .

• 3,

,3 l A G. . . qr-O .- ~ ~.,.. . c" . , ,"'/. ~

, y*

a ..

. t

!.*.'T I C 4 u C4 W :.Mr . R O 4 - h. .*+ . .M. . -*, .

. - -o T u t Ti, G .

., *' .. '. .'} -

r.~ m~. e e + : e. W s.- cA,s -.

. . st: ,,., .s t ,- .y - . r'.~,~*)

. e *

• i.a

.r

.. - , = '1 e= w *% r . a. e

.-- . .- --

.,,. .s.1. ca M a %aJ 4. v A a s

. "j ,., .a.s - J' O w n ., +.. Q- -g C'T*.G -v. r

..s., -u,-~. n.., t u

• t e4n,,;. . E'O .: ,.a...

.i% r.w i.es . a. .

v: .

. w .. . s s

.s :

,t".1", ~**:*' d**

1 C:5 C* h ??. '?. ~.2

• ,C.

WTv **

• Y .*E * .2* a.r .

. .' $ ;h 4.-. g. ,1

.a i

,..r'. *

.,.r... 41 . ' .. .

,, y  !

. .s , .

.. ,4. , -

..~--.

p* *', . g* " , * .

. IT .ti . 6 [ w; E H L M E 2 re w b % . INTO TIOW L To'- A.GmovE .:-.THE

. . ya ;

• ' ~

% < < ' , . LAsT $EN TENC E DW. f M A.G t%*.H *}.5" otN THE _ s f E G D. . h. R E A sig b i

. StVct Fn A TooN C S - S = ll3 ' ' V T .A.. ~c./k 99'*No2.?CW. TH'6 *v4LL ,{

'. : C 5m* L.'f poi-H "TH E CLO'Idm t $ "JRC h EST' TO WW'M *E l lprnr2 m 'l'7. A EF EM INb ' 5 0 . .r E M ^ gr4 x D O Z,5 ,

.s.

f ^. ,

. s ..

I.(.*,

q,. *b. *-

,',.s. ..sg'. *.

- ')'.

? E!P U.'t IT . , I A.H ~I M'. P IID.id h .

E! ~~/ !. <

L ,., - . . 1, ,,*,.J , hb - / 2. - 9 "FJ d -

• l. j; O r2 M D 37I

$T ' . .

• iO * ' j.; .m a -

'i ' . , '. ' U j !l

~ "

),. ^

cl~~ @g V. 2.bN l '* '

'I ' '" i

• I

1. I N, 9 s.~l*l '

• .g' is ' ../ s e . , . s .

.t*. '.

' . . . . ~ . **1

.c r

.. l MI CWLWT j flu.,! pi c r.jp : . F,.r,.1. c, Q;i w T. M, ttlu n !~ ,

. n. .

".. ~ DEI ,Q M  !, pr .

. .a T'd Q y . ! g

- .Q DC *M . t,, ' N h 1.' M ] C . - . . ' m.,. .'

4

. N 75 M#d.IIW $ifDD , .; , i. ." j,' **

. .. .F""'nu Milt Ur C.d a;f.;

g

• f. : ~ *,.- ';1 ,., .

.;,g.

.. - ,. .e ** f , .; . g t*y.,7,

.... . y .

~ . ,,.,,

~,

es~a l eee

. ~

. . . .. ,,.%,,.,.- ' .i. f.. e.,.... ..

p *,.i m. d.-a ' w*, , - *

. . Sr

. . . ., 4., . a.

3

.u. . i.* . .. ,

i

C

.' ,n., *,,4.'" 5

• ** * ~4 *

• d***+- . * ..,.*.l*. '

g se ,t

,,,_< E,,.,,JTyD CT

.I., .

. ........ ' - 4 . . i

. .y . 3 . w . . .. .

.. . 7. . .

> :u r..'.

w . .

,.. - . . . . 9 . , ,

s w . * ~ ~ .' .

4* * *,., . , ; '. . a .; y . .

, ,. {,. 1

. '1 n

j

,g * .

. . .. * ..e

• r

. J.,e-y -

.  %:5

..,g; ,3 e

J Q

=

et y ** :.

. ,., . .;a  : *.c

=.%

.- . .a..

w

. .s .<-'% .f< *. . .... s . s,t ...o ...

.. .y- *f

.c.,,.,. , y j

.. g<. o . ,

, .. , ( . f.

f.

.. m . ,

1-

O

, :i O P-20oa2A-a(>0-7c)

CONTRACT /STAliUARD NO. -;

620 0004 DOCUMENT RELEASE l

,. RELEASE DATE PAGE NOTICE (DRN) l

/2 W.77 I 0F / .

l

"' N O -

PART/IASK-GROUP SEQ.

B&W DOCUliENT NO. DOCU!i:ENT TITLE fQ i

$r*$$!?,1$ -

S2 - 4402 C0 CIM 'YA~ Nh l i

i

- l 1

i I

l I

l 1

1

/

l

\ l i

l l

l 1

1 I

l l

o I l

DISTRIBUTION N0 c0 Pies NO COPIE]RELE ASED BY ORE 00c now Noc jf y.  ?)/77 l fe,ed swement / "q kAHE DATC l 1

Pues iA,n s - TA R,.tL ./ / I

/no, .em>

1. d O<' k/$ - MI f / TCVIEmED By l

. O f b,.1/a .,.. /,' . C sN l s j l

~9.ys;L,,n:ws

..c,g. 7- , @f.py' a.n-17 a= ..,-,

,,u,.. ,,,,

A.T -

1

$.21218-3(l-77) 095 Ul0&Il

. CHAT 4GE It40UIRY/ O vts O "IPPLCiAa0R OExeEoi2E Oi.;uiRr .

AUTHORIZATIOt4 0 a0 wia0R (S*0 rat SAuTn0RizaTio.

g SYSTEH/C0w.PONEk1 KAME TYPE OF CHANGE

/e 4

$ ' p;,// /4 / d A ' "' DESicM

'O C n A ~ g g CODE S b O arG RE9uEsf REQUIREHENT

/f g gk "/' 2 COST REDUCTick OPERATi>G EXPERIENCE LICEkSING o

3i o b gf2/a h %/r, ] PEODUCT

'";0d4ENT

@ CUSTCPER REQUEST INTEF. FACE

] REQUIREMENT TA$r EhG ($1GN) 7g DATE STATEHE AT OF FF.QBLEH/JUST IF ICAT10N

(.l!Sfem te $x-7 / in bkt [S& Y TE///0 FCf' 4//W"

fr-YC ND'T Af4W/y VMbf)" $~-

f/MCs h4 TEMiA 7&4rscl4rcl /f llrn $' hl-  ?~de iOS Womt+ hS yfft'Pf h! E55 'O $fl5'f Yk* S5Y/m/#1 $~ 2"$$

-Che Dd- L vMte- Cco/!rs /,, /u,/& 'te- 2"At -

sk$kh # the 7b 6- 5ee ss ,c n~&4no-s /trsaaL.

SOLUTION /01SFO!ITION dtkht C$t b5 ~$ TCnffAl'o* /% f&s#fJ'y S. V *

( S,pec dt dw" c.r- 3-r3 gec..?!<24d...-99.('~u'A~

~.t f4 , f r :-ry.

N'ytQ9 }; . '2 -

5 bYA f,

w ::e  ;.. . .

..a

. .\ As

'}

g. .,. Ci N ./ 'l *' -

D0C. h 0. REVIEWE0 DATE AFPE0VED DATE 00C. N D. REVIEWED DATE APPROVED DAll 0U

l i 0? l Jhad asa'.

0H1AACT CPR ko.

TAsrs AFFtC1to $ :I

80. Itsr CI/A APPROVALS t -

A o. T15r TITLE lEb, l co n, ur.t t g..t,c,[$ l mr k, C S M ai $

enw i w sn' /fL on, ?

DAM m esm, L,,, / .s. A L x e J ~,e.,

k. kh.4$~;s.khv i

W>!itbd'o!%/b -

DRA REP.

f !LE No.

C1/A mo.

l P,8 - YO2-00 I

C.I. M0.

. - - - ~ ~ ~ ~ '

• l

.y. .

m

. + ..

( f i  !. CHANGE INQUIRY / AUTHORIZATION COST ESTIMATE '

6pGA I/ A;t t oh A LSpon s t B L.E ~ (PRIQT OR VVPE) '

IfR 'f A R ;G E SIGMAIURES -NE AEvi5ED 00GUHLhi5 3

[

Pb~y* 7 A s l Dnns E S T itt A T OR / SU P E R V I S OR RE E5ttHAIE VAllD .

1

" QUIRED

• AT RED Uhift:

Oste Date

~--~ i

~ -"!  !

w0RK EtlGINEERiflG AND PURCilASED EQUIPMEtli COSTS S C tt E O COMIR IA$t PACKAGE EFFECT MAM-E N G I N E E R i tt G

. CURRENT

]' C 0'f rU T E R HAIERIAL TAst ENGINEER no. w . M O. i wts n09Rs C0si T . O . P. T . O. P. T . 0. P.

Est C0si nocc: C0st s0uRCE C0si

~

s GNATURE DATE

!  !  ! 3 I

d.SMh.n 'WO i  ! >

I i i i  !

i  !

l l i

j l '

TCTAL TOTAL 101At I i {

~~

FA3 WORK SCHED NED FABRICATION COSTS (SPECIFY CilAtlGE EFFECT ONLY)

LABOR TAst -KENSE Hi1[RgAL PACKAGE EFFECT lt1H "f cio ne n s oa.+r t t s t on p^ t t s RO. No. 1 DAYS Il00R$ COST ESC TOTAL BASE l ESC TOTAL BASE ESC TOTAL f' 180 t I % % ( Pf.

e e,1 g tt g ] g .2 *

• t S Ii 91 A I 4

'Ite s!*, f 'n*4 9 f:s q 184 t 8 til Q

• tt l ill Al1V ) Si tll %t i t i l'f 't f srieti-ra o < o Ant. ...

O soin u , ,1, n , , on .

o - ..... .

O iurnr:r o

k Pt I DB 1Y DM II

• i A no t. 6 .c ra si p [I F E C T Olt TARGET StttP DATE 1011 tz A t i ti A f f TOTAL TOTAL C

• f TOTAL ', " ;' i.' y" 'e $ ', *,".' *" '-

TA$l2EYt3EDTARGETSHIPCAiE.

FAERICATION APPROVALS NPG TASK ENG U^'U itTLE MED APPROVAL DATE TOTAL T t. M Q TAst TITLE APPROVAL DATE o I,o HGR. NCC , ,,3, g 7 g,41 - is r n e. r n a a av D i re, t i ne i n oi >.r. r n e v e no n v arlo.otAivo rn %cr%) ivrrrns 5 rm , c c .r i e r r *1ns An %.

y h3;g3ggg l n '.t {['DS Q l 7ff ] i A*d D n f1 T A t ra arenovra or ronjire e,.narrn

, .. I P D$ -212 f 9-2 ( 5 -M )

.- . CHANGE INQUIRY /AUTHORIZ ATION CONTINU ATION ] tutvatc ,

(PRINT OR TYPE) goppat

'DOCUMEpi TITLE DOCUMini NO. CnAh0L 5tQuthCL n c. A f

'Jh: $wo C4 l Goret hcn Y/pu yo v U " V,ud Q

• [%HCyvtl. f90 Ay Sem Ardet f, stem CtIA Coni. .

" #8 b

$ Hell / OF /

g g DESCRIPil0K OF CHANGE s .. . .

C3

$/*r $r~cf e g ysyf f. [

t e

,p'~~**~~~~~

~

.. -. . . . . . - . \

L AppBOVEDj FOR Btw tHTERNAL USE ONLY A [ g WOft_ VIND"12 Ail 0M ,

k nagg iffz /,

--- NAME L A A 7- &n DLT('

Kaz /2977 "U. ,u, I' i

DATE g g'; g 1A3r IA$g jiggr Cl/A hC.

8//f f v7f . .

88- 4/02-00

. 78 , _..,, .

. .]

I. ._ ...

Cl/A :,HEtt d Or g'*

j C.n. no.

w ,; .r.

o .

o DWHP-20217 (12-76) *

. .SIfE PROBLEM REPOET ,

TRANSHIITAL FOR ACTION

~

Change Control For Distribution File: 13 / re.-o /

To:

Contract Ho: 620-00 oG S. H. Y.lein For Inf omation -

For Action SPR Number: /CA (Rev. o i 3 To: M f2EiETA Makeup Pu m n G a r-Tor Action

Title:

- Tot t . F. Idi no for Infomatien Oll Ooler .

~

'B. A. F.arrasch for Infor=ation .

Nucicar Service Status Code: 2 I

/2 7 ? Reply Required By: )

Dste of Transmittal: _

Action Requested: L.C. Peews is reouesfec/ 4 Co m plefe -

-4 /5 SA?.

v a l

l P

l eply and Return Thii; Transmittal to: '" M do w Nuclear Service Support Engineer Reply: Picase previde resolution on the SPR Form

1. Is this problem applicabic to other contracts? Yes  ; No A. If yes - identify appifcable contracts

2. Picase provide Disposition on or before the Reply Required date if Resolution is incomplete s ,

(Signed) (pace) s

'. C. C. Plunkett-Contract Administration (1) L. C. Rogers *nfI Site

.. 1 J. - R. Lohnrt - International Support ' '

l

] F. R. Taint TECo Site  :

P. E. Perone-OTR(IE2) (

j- g a m , a 4, - -

\

b *sm-- -- -

• ---,,-7.. _ . , , , _ __ _ _ _ , ,