ML20135F952
| ML20135F952 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 03/13/1997 |
| From: | Racquel Powell NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM) |
| To: | Binder N DEBEVOISE & PLIMPTON |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20135F953 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-96-485 NUDOCS 9703210066 | |
| Download: ML20135F952 (4) | |
Text
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ ___ __ _. __
. . - n n s o m., ... . . . . . . . . ,_ . . , , , , .x,,,,,
i p
g'l l ,
S b*" F OtA 96-485 KESPONSE TYPE
{ l RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF I n=4L [ x[ eantiat (1Ith) j i
..eee ) INFORMATION ACT (FOtA) REQUEST o^'t ggp 9 3 3997 DOCKE I NuestE R(58 tir pywasacast s
3 8tEQUESTE R l Neil S. Binder
! PART 1. -AGENCY RECORD 6 RELEASED OR NOT LOCATED fSaw checkedbones/
No agency recorth subsect to the request have been accated.
No addetsoned agency recortes subpect to the request have boon located.
{ Requested records are avestable ihrough another pidsisc destribution program. See Comtreats esction, i
i Agency recortis seject to the request that are identified in Append.s(es) are already avsetable for pubiac inspection and copyeng et the j NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC.
- Ass. icy records subrect to the roguest that are identified in Appendiales) are bemg made available for public anspection and :coying et the NRC Putslic Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Wahington, DC, en a folder under thes F OIA number
{ The nonproprietary version of the proponelfs) that you agreed to accept in a te4ephone conversation with a enember of my staff is now bems made available for public inspection and copymg at the N RC P41 c Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC, in a folder under this FOl A number, j Agency records sepect to the request that are 6dentifsod en Appemise(es) may be snspected and copied at the N RC Local Public Document i Roosr identified in the Comments sectnon.
l f ncacced es mformetson on how you may obtaen access to and the chargrs for copying recorth located et the NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N W., Wouhington, DC.
Agency records espect to the request are enclosed.
j Records subject to the request have been referred to another Federal agencylies) for review and direct respome to you.
. Fose You anti be belled by the NRC for fees totaling S ,
You will receeve a refund from the NRC en the amount of S 4
l In view of N R C's response to this request, no further actaen es beeng taken on appeel letter dated , No.
PART ll. A-INFORhtATION W5THHELD FROtt PUBLIC DISCLOSURE Certain information in the roguest,ed records is being w6thheld from public disclosure pursuant to the esemptions described in and for the reasons stated in Port it, g. C, and D. Any reteemed portions of the documents for which onty part of the record is being withheld are being rnede evellable for public I lnesection and copying in the NRC Putdic Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W.,Washingson. DC in a folder under this FOIA number, COMMENTS Copies of the releasable portions of the records identified on Appendix BB are enclosed.
s p.p\
.i
/
of 1
T URE. DIRE , 6&a08OFFREE INFORetAisON AND PUBLICATIONS 5E3V6CES
< c
' f [,f[.[, ', did ' '
' N .*i, ffj###*' #:fP,I I,W 9703210066 970313 b-- mm m.
DEh 485 PDR
- N h Nh .
. ,,c , l d ipart ii n.n u,,,, _... ~e n .- . .
a
, . ,,.,....a,.,m.., ,,,.. .....~. . . . . . . . ,,s, l
.[
?
/g*g# ; RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF FOIA l*ihat 96-485 xiseO=se im l xI r^aTIAL (17th)
WFORMATION ACT (FOtA) REQUEST o^'t 4
(..ee.f MAR 131997 ooCae r nuwee nise riren=m
- asavest:R i Neil S. Binder i
PAR T I,-AGENCY RECORDS RE LEASED OR NOT LOCATED (See etwcA ed bones /
l a
No aymcy records sepsct to the request have been located.
No adduional agency records adbrect to the request have been located, Requested records are seestable through asother pelic detribution program, See Comr".cnts sectlon, Agency records e4 ject to the request that are identitreiin Append.sfes) are already available for pelic inspection and copyeng at the
, NRC Pelic Dacianent Room,2120 L Strert, N.W., Washington, DC.
Agency records subsect to the request that are identified in Appendiales) are being made available for public snspection and :opying 4
et ten f6RC Pelic Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC, en a folder under the FOIA number
! The nonpropnetary verison of the proposetts) that you agreed to accept in a telephone conversation with a member et my staff is now being made avaitable l for pelic inspection and copying at the NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC, in a folder under this F Of A number.
4
- W records subgect to the request that are identifwd en Appendiales) rney be mspected and copied at the N RC Local Publec Document Roose identified in the Comments section.
Encicsed e informetoon on how you may obts n access to and the chargrs for copymg records located at the NRC Public Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washingten, DC.
j Agency records adbpect to the roguest are enclosed.
l Records subject to the request have been referred to another Federst egency(est for rowsew and direct response to you.
Fees You onll be t>lled by the NRC for fees totalmg $
l j You will recorve a refund from the NRC et the amount of S .
4 j f n view of N RC's response to this request, no further actson as being taken on appeel letter dated , No.
PART 11. A-INFOR4AAT8ON WITHHELD froes PUBLIC DISCLOSURE f Certain information in the roguested records is being withheld from public disclosure pursuant to the esemptions described in erms for the reasons stated j in Port 11, B, C, and D. Any released portions of the documents for which only port of the record is being withheld are being made oveliable for public j I inspection and copying in the NRC Putdic Document Room,2120 L Street, N.W., Washington, DC in a folder under this FOIA nurnber.
i consaaENTS l Copies of the releasable portions of the records identified on Appendix BB are enclosed.
,/ *
.i [
l
(',b Oll 4
f uRE, DIREC OR, 854088OffREE INFOfteAAtsON AND PUBLeCATIONS EE RVICES s ,*
.g y ' i f ,' af.' 3 , , 0 ,M & E !$
g#S-M *i . !% : ,l C'?
~#
9703210066 970313 -
'Mf7 NTE a G -J . ,
l DE b 485 PDR hhhhhNhM f.*.i p5hb m owsc, *= w i
6 n_w m ..m._
C ,.R d f,.rt li if. )
.....e
. .. . -- -- _--. -- - . - - ~--
e
- 701A 8sVtietAts: DAtt
' RESPONSE TO FREEDOM OF
=
(CONTINUATION) l PARr E s- Arrucasu Exsasenoess 2
Mecords sesect to the request that er e Jaectibed in the enclosed Appendinfest A A RR are twing withheld in their entirety or in part under the Esemption Nedal and for the reason (s) given below pessuant to 5 U.S.C. 562(b) and to CF R 9.17(a) of NRC reedstions.
1 The wahPead eseovmetion a propedy cteenshed purevens to Emeanthe Order.(Emempreen tl
?
i 2 The we' coed m8ermetion seestee acesey to the vitemet moreermet # west and procedures of IsRC (Emernatuen 21 l 12 the -eve.d -feren.t.se, e specusey .ae pted ro - .ectoo,,e ., sistwie e..ceisd. iE- ,2i l
Seceasse 14 f.148 of the Afonme Enoryy Act, which prehensis the d 7 et Restreeted Deta er Fe- _4 Restricted Deta 142 U.$.C. 218 2106).
j __ ._
j -
Sectsen 147 of the Atomac Energy Act, ehese prehetpsts 19e 1-f_ -e of Uncsounded t^ gds In", c ;en (42 USC. 2187).
4 The wemend eformaten e a teade neceet or commerc at er fmancias esformaton that es toreio e,vrhreid for the re**oniss ind.osted. (Emerroten 4)
The e*8ermeten a conessered to tse confusent.as buesnese opropnetaryl mformeeen 4 _
f The edermeren a coneseered to be propnetary snformesen pursuess to 10 CFR 2 790tdit ti 4
The edesmatam mee ondametted and recorwed et Confesence purs. ant to 10 CTR 2 790tdH2s 5 The sessemoed snformerson cerasste of interage ic, er nitraegenre socores that are not e.edatse erwovgai desco e,e owning 61. eat.cm (Enemptson St. Apps. cable Prm 6eos:
i i Deeensestare Procesa Desceaewre et preance.ones edermeten woued tend to emstne the open and t< ann en.hange or .deas essentnes to the desee< dime /pocess i
Where recarce me swouheed as them enteety. the f acto me eiestncate r electeined even the credeces.onae eftwmation The.e aeso are no reesonatdv sapegaese factwad l ] )' porteene becawee the eseesee of the f acts wound poemet an andeoct ensue, esto It .m s :a a' r-*** ne sh* ao*aev Attorne, evers product on..arve 4Doewn . eats preoa ed D, an ertoenee si contempiain** es '.e.gavea e I
Attamey < font servilees. (Contdential communecotens between en ettomey and het9see steent.)
! 6 The est'ewed advematen a esempted from putpuc ereceoswee because as absclosure newed 'esw s t en a caean, n u wanantedv in asen of portonas pn.acy IEnemp'en fu s e j 7 The eastetoed adormeten coneests wf escords compded for tem enforcenwnt purposes and es Deeng wahhead for the reasontal edicated (Ememptlon 7)
' - I Decsoeure cowed reasonseay be espected to enterfere math an enforcement proceeding becaves a cowld revest the scope, dweetion, and locus of i
' ordertement efforts, and thws cowed pons.twy anow rece ents to take acten to sheed potent.ef wrongdoing or e eetaten of NRC reeuwements 1
) M -
i Decapewre wowed ce, seawee an unwarranted etwas.on of personas pnvecy. (Enempton 7tCH
, f The snformation cons.sts of names of eso...eswass and othee *dormee.on the d sciosu er os ash.c n cou so easonabs, de enoected to ee.eae . der $ ides of coMeensias owress.
s (Enempten 71011 1
Of tet.H
+
PART 5. C-DENYEWG OFFICIALS Pweiuant to 10 CF R 9 25fbl and or 9 25fel of the U $ fewcnese Repeatory Comm.eien rep tatens. et has teen determined that the informaten m'thheld .e esempt froan pro-ducten or d.sces.ee. arms that .es producten oe d<ece wre es contra , to the puht4.nterest The persons eesponiene for the den asa<e those off. cia *s dentif.ed besow as deny.no i,
eff.c.een e*id the Dwertoe. D e s.on of Fevedom of informaten sad Putnatens Se wees. Off4e of Adm.nritrat.on. for any den.ais that may be appealed to the Earcutwe Dweetor I for op-aven. ie Doe
' ~
)
l DOrysNG Of F#CIAL Tif tf OFFtCE i PtCORDS D(Nit 0 APPELLATE OFFICIAL I Acting Directore Office for i _ sm !== a
{ l Denwood F. Ross Analysis and Evaluation of l App AA.BB X!
! Operational Data i I i
i i
t I
1 1 1 l
) l PART 5. D- APPEAL R8GHTS .
1 ne den ., .ech den,.n. .mc .enided .n rei si C mey me e.pe.w i. the Aptm 1 et i, . ,eepon.e. A.pe.= mun ne addre ed. . .pw .ete. . the E asevi.e o.,m.. .am on , eentmed o, op-men.. i. ore. An, is t,e semmy of .uch th. appe, n.vn ne m.oe . we,i.n ..ihm x d.v of rec..pi 4 rep,setaryr r'2 2 . wrashesten. DC 20%5. and s%ved e6serfy state on the savoops and a the nouse that itkom es en ensnet.se
- Appe,Conwn.s..on.
FotA Deers.on." or io ihe inspector cen
- NRC FORM 464 (Port 2) (1911 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS$40N l
1
l .
- l 1
l l Re: FOIA 96 485 l APPENDIX BB 1
RECORDS BEING WITHHELD IN PART i
E 08IE DESCRIPTION /(PAGE COUNT)/ EXEMPTIONS
! 1. 11/8/95 Memorandum for R Cooper et al.. from S Mays.
Subject. Request for Comments on the Latest Performance Indicator (PI) Data (1 page) Release attaching Analysis of the Performance Indicator Data Through Se)tember 1996 (198 pages) EX. 5
} AND OUTSIDE SCO)E
! 2. 11/9/95 Memorandum for W Lanning et al.. from S Mays.
Subject:
' Recuest for Comments on the Latest Performance
' Incicator (PI) Data (2 pages) RELEASE attaching Analysis of the Performance Indicator Data Through September 1995 (176 pages) EX. 5 AND OUTSIDE SCOPE i
j i
i l
)
.i 1
I
i f
m Re FOIA-96-485 4
{ APPENDIE AA RECORDS BEING WITEHELD IN THEIR ENTIRETY t
1 ML. DATE DESCRIPTION / f PAGE COUNT) /EYIntPTIONS i
- 1. Undated Draft, Analysis of the Performance Indicator Data i
Through September 1994 (200 pages) EE. 5 AND OUTSIDE j SCOPE 4
1 J
4 I
4 . 4"~
'DEDii:Vol0E & PLIMPTON j s75 THRD AVENUE ses istn stanut.se = as avosua onome v i csumo count. s Luonafs eeu. l
! 6 % NY 10022 vaamsom aan"aE taanosca>U ra:: taamwow sNu'w"e one c212)9094000 vnacopeiaan assesse tascopeaas uerao soer vascopenses v u usosso 4 198 ENTawTasemente m eumans aoao cewfa suu.mso ione an w est OO tWLapHow eBam 3Blo 7 te gae t iesas j veLacorsa saa assoseas veLacopen sas-u im Fuss
- November 14, 1996
! Russell Powell F
! Otief of the FOIA/LPDR '4me No fa-M .86 --
- Nuclear Regulatory h isaion Dale Rec'd //-/f- 94 geop Mail Stop T6D8 gg Washington, D.C. 20555-0001 j
Dear Mr. Powell:
i
{ This is a request under the Freedom of Inforination
. Act, 5 U.S.C. 5 552. I request that a copy of all records
- and other documents that fit the following description be sent to me:
- 1) All records or other documents from January 1, l 1993 to the present that are not currently in the '
public documents room and that relate to Florida !
Power and Light's St. Lucie Nuclear Power Plant (Unit 1 and/or Unit 2). 1
- 2) The number of inspection hours (by quarter) devoted by the NRC to all licensed nuclear plants in region 2 since January 1, 1993.
In order to help determine my status for the purpose of assessing any fees, you should be advised that I represent a company, and I am seeking information for use related to the company's business.
. Please advise me of any fees associated with processing this request.
Sincerely,
_ , , - - 1 Neil S. Binder !
e m / ) s M N ;>
W I VIJ i W G I
-n.oi
, . , , , ,,