ML20135F789
| ML20135F789 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Point Beach  |
| Issue date: | 03/03/1997 |
| From: | Gundrum L NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9703140105 | |
| Download: ML20135F789 (160) | |
Text
.. -
@6C/60
,f..g&
UNITED STATES g
g j
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 2008H001 i
~%*****/
March 3, 1997 LICENSEE: Wisconsin Electric Power Company FACILITY: Point Beach Nuclear Plant, Units 1 and 2
SUBJECT:
SUMARY OF FEBRUARY 24, 1997, MEETING ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION 4
0F EQUIPMENT BASED ON REVISED CONTAINMENT RESPONSE INCLUDED IN i
1 CHANGE REQUEST 192 On February 24, 1997, NRR staff members met in Rockville, Maryland, with representatives of Wisconsin Electric Power Company (WEPCO) and GLS Enterprises, Inc., to gain a better understanding of the licensee's basis for concluding that the ability of environmentally qualified equipment inside containment to perform its function following a loss-of-coolant accident is l
not affected by the revised containment profiles. A list of attendees is i
included as Attachment 1.
l i
The licensee discussed the concept of degradation equivalency (Attachment 2) and presented its evaluation of equipment qualification impact resulting from 1
the revised containment temperature profile (Attachment 3). Degradation i
equivalency was presented as a method of equating a design-basi: equipment test profile to a design-basis equipment requirement. The concept of degradation equivalency as expressed in the presentation is not defined and was not accepted by the NRC staff. The staff stated that the Arrhenius methodology is acceptable. However, during transient conditions, the staff contended that no basis exists to correlate tests at lower temperatures to
- onditions at higher temperatures for a shorter period of time.
In addition, the staff stated that acceptable criteria for documenting that equipment may i
not be needed for the entire duration of an accident should be based on criteria specified in NUREG-0588, " Interim Staff Position on Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment," Revision 1.
/
e WEPCO's presentation provided sufficient information for the majority of
/
equipment. WEPC0 agreed to submit further information on Gems level transmitters (Item 15); Rome cable (Item 28); and containment accident fan j[j/
l motor bearings, motor cable and cable splices, and lubricant (Items 37 and l
38). WEPC0 stated that the lubricant similarity will be based on the chemical composition of the original lubricant used in the qualification tests as compared to the chemical compcsition of the manufacturer's currently
. recommended lubricant.
9703140105 970303 PDR ADOCK 0500 6
i
7 March 3, 1997 If there are any questions regarding the information presented in this meeting summary, please contact Linda Gundrum at (301) 415-1380.
Orig. signed by Linda L. Gundrum, Project Manager Project Directorate III-1 Division of Reactor Projects - III/IV Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Docket Nos. 50-266 and 50-301 Attachments:
1.
Attendance List 2.
Degradation Equivalency 3.
Evaluation of EQ Impact cc w/att:
See next page DISTRIBUTION:
Docket File (2)
PUBLIC PD31 Reading OGC (w/o att)
ACRS (w/o att)
J. McCormick-Barger, RIII (w/o att)(JWM)
)
L. Gundrum E-Mail:
S. Collins (SJC1)
F. Miraglia (FJM)
R. Zimmerman (RPZ)
J. Roe (JWR)
E. Adensam (EGA1)
D. Ross (SAM)
S. Saba (SNS1)
H. Walker (HXW)
G. Hubbard (GTH)
D. Thatcher (DFT)
F. Ashe (FSA)
J. Knox (JLK)
J. Hannon (JNH)
B. McCabe (BCM)
DOCUMENT NAME: G:\\WPD0CS\\PTBEACH\\PTB96741.MTS To receive a copy of this document. Indicate in the bon:
'C" = Copy without attachment! enclosure "E" = Copy with attachment / enclosure "N" = No copy 0FFICE PM:PD31 C
LA:PD31 lC SPLB EELB l 6' D:PD31 NAME LGundrum:lgWy CJamerson D V HWalkeWfd SSabaGeb JHannon 7W/u DATE 02/A 9/97 02/t9/97 //
3 /3 /97 s / 3/97 a,/1 /97 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY k
a
1
. If there are any questions regarding the information presented in this meeting summary, please contact Linda Gundrum at (301) 415-1380.
d Linda L. Gundrum, Project Manager Project Directorate III-1 Division of Reactor Projects - III/IV Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Docket Nos. 50-266 and 50-301 Attachments:
1.
Attendance List 2.
Degradation Equivalency 3.
Evaluation of EQ Impact cc w/att: See next page I
?
4
Wisconsin Electric Power Company Point Beach Nuclear Plant Unit Nos. I and 2 cc:
Ernest L. Blake, Jr.
Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge Mr. Richard R. Grigg 2300 N Street, N.W.
Chief Nuclear Officer Washington, DC 20037 Wisconsin Electric Power Company 231 West Michigan Street, Room P379 Mr. Scott A. Patulski Milwaukee, WI 53201 Site Vice President Point Beach Nuclear Plant Wisconsin Electric Power Company 6610 Nuclear Road Two Rivers, Wisconsin 54241 Mr. Ken Duveneck Town Chairman 4
i Town of Two Creeks 13017 State Highway 42 Mishicot, Wisconsin 54228 Chairman Public Service Commission of Wisconsin P.O. Box 7854 Madison, Wisconsin 53707-7854 G?gional Administrator, Region III U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 801 Warrenville Road Lisle, Illinois 60532-4351 Resident Inspector's Office U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 6612 Nuclear Road Two Rivers, Wisconsin 54241 Ms. Sarah Jenkins Electric Division Public Service Commission of Wisconsin P.O. Box 7854 Madison, Wisconsin 53707-7854 December 1996
l s
ATTENDANCE LIST George Hubbard Plant Systems Branch, NRC (part time)
Harold Walker Plant Systems Branch, NRC Saba Saba.
Electrical Engineering Branch, NRC Dale Thatcher Electrical Engineering Branch, NRC John Knox Electrical Engineering Branch, NRC Frank Ashe Electrical Engineering Branch, NRC Linda Gundrum Project Manager for Point Beach John Hannon Project Director, PD 3-1 (part time)
Tom Malanowski WEPC0 John Hinck WEPC0 James Gleason GLS Enterprises, Inc.
1 t
a d
e 1
.f 4
ATTACHMENT I 1
GLS Enterprises, Inc.
Degradation Equivalency It is necessary to utilize De isdatui Equivalency for many reasons, such as :
v a Original Qi4R4R-i Test was i;es'umed in two transents. IEEE 323-74's appendix showed DBE Test profile with two transents.
Thus many qdr-MR-i tests were performed with a high temperature, pressure and steam transient, followed by a cool down penod and a repeat of the transent e Original Quahfication Tests had more than two transients. In some cases test sibiia;ies caused the DBE sirrulabon to be repeated more than twice, typically due to anomalies in tesbng Generic quahficabon testing has been performed in which a specific plant requirement was demonstrated by testing to worst case a
DBE's representing many nuclear plants and the test DBE does not exactly follow each plants DBE requirements.
Postulated Plant DBE's have changed since the original qualificabon requirements. Plant requirements change due to tech spec a
r J.ges, These often result in new postulated DBE requirements. Since 10CFR50.49 allows partial type testing to demonstrate qualification, rather than requiring new testing, Degradabon Equivalency allows comparisons to the new requirements.
Degiadai;0ii Equivalency is a conservative approach to univacing DBE requirements to DBE test conditions. Example i shows a two transient test for Namco Limit Switches (OTR-155). The first transient was over after approximately 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> and the cool down penod was approximately 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> prior to the start of the second transient Thus the penod between 3 and b hours appears to not envelope the DBA requirement A better depuui of the DBE simulation is to use the " Cumulative Time at Temperature" technique. In this technique, the transient at the 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> point is not plotted and instead, the continuation of the second transient is plotted after the first transient and the penod of the cool down period is subtracted from the elapsed time. Example 2 shows the same graph with the total Time at Temperature technique.
Example 2 is conservative since it removes the cool down penod and the resulting line moves closer to the requirement, as can be seen from the check point noted on Examples 1 and 2. The check point in example 1 is at the 11 hour1.273148e-4 days <br />0.00306 hours <br />1.818783e-5 weeks <br />4.1855e-6 months <br /> point and shows that the terrperature is approximately 340 P. In Example 2, the same 11 hour1.273148e-4 days <br />0.00306 hours <br />1.818783e-5 weeks <br />4.1855e-6 months <br /> point now shows that the temperature is approximately 275 T. Thus the cumulative time at temperature technique provides a more conservative representation of the DBE Test Profile, when the profile contains cool down penods which are less than the requirement Therefore, the graphical representation of Degradabon Equivalency, using the Total Time at Terrporatore technique allows compensons between DBE requirements and DBE simulations. When the Degradation Equivalency shows that the test DBE envelopes the DBE 3,,
requirement, it is demonstrated that the testing exceeds the requirement d
'f M
i S!
ts)
GLS Ernterpriser, Inc.
Degradation Equivalency Example 1. PBNP-DBA Temperature m.--
350
,i II 300 y
u.j l
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS 3
off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
E 200
-G-Namco Limit Switch (OTR 155) 150
-er-Check Point s
gg 100 50 e
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
GLS Enterprises Inc.
Degradation Equivalency
,~,
350 ll 300 C
7
... _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _. Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS j
off at 1 hr)(SGRP) g 200
- Namco Limit Switch (QTR 155) a 150
-e-Check Point 100 50 n
0.00001 0.0001 0 001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
Example 2. Total Cumulative time at Temperature.
.... -. _ _. - - - ~ _. _.. _.... ~. -
I WE PSNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION l
GLS Enuiiryrises, Inc.
A l
I Evaluation of EQ Impact of Wisconsin Electric Power j
CompanyTechnical Specification l
Change Request 192 1
i l
l GLS Enteryr ises, Inc.
1819 Cross Creek Road Huntsville, AL 35102-3972
(
i j
Ph 205-881-9868 i
Fax 205-881-4498 l
Email: gisinc@ traveller.com t
i
[r 2 Y-77 l
James F. Gleason, P.E.
Date: 2-24-97
'{ztr' y John A Hinck, Wisconsin Electnc Date : 2-24-97 OLS ENTEJtPJtJ8ES, DC.
1 ATTACHMENT 3 i
I 1
i WE PBNP TsCR 192 EQ EVALUATION Wisconssi Electric Power Company has identrfied changes to the Design Basis Accdent Conditions that are postulated based on the imp'amentaticn of Technical Sr+#-:4:-i Change Request (TSCR) 192. The change results in a change to the DBA profile utilized in the Point Beach Nuclear Plant Units 1 and 2 Envronmental Qualificabon (EQ) Program, which is required to meet 10CFR50A9. It was recognized by Wisconsin Electric that the change to the DBA Profile could impact EQ equipment and an evaluation was performed A Condition Report, CR 97-0242, was insbated The CR documents the operability d,/. i.isuori and establishes achons for final resolubon.
4 l
CONCLUSION All EQ equipment required to be reviewed due to changes in the DBA conditions as a result of TSCR 192, at Point Beach Units 1 and 2, has been evaluated against the new DBA requirement The original qualification has been enhanced with new EQ reports and has been shown to exceed the new DBA requirement Thus, there is no impact on the Point Beach EQ program due to TSCR 192 and all EQ equipment is qualified to the new DBA requirements
..a..
i Evaluation 1
j The major elements of this evaluabon were :
1.
Identificabon of EQ Equipment to be evaluated for this change.
2.
Evaluabon P'rocedure 2.1 Maximum DBA Temperature Evaluation 2.2 Maximum DBA Pressure Evaluation 2.3 DBA Temperature Profile Evaluabon 2A PBNP EQ Program Enhancement in the evaluabon, additional Qualification reports for similar cable to the Rome cable were located and are being ircipe.i.d into the PBNP EQ prograrrt a Wyle Report 17740-1 a Wyle Report 17732-1 m Wyle Report 6110 GEA ENTEJtPJtJBES, D4C.
2
WE PeNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION
- 1. m W M W h he 6 for m W The Point Beach EQ program identifled that the following EQ equipment, Table 1, is i
required b be neviewed in this evaluation This equpment list consists of all environmentally qualdled squement located inside of containment at PBNP.
Table 1. EQ Equipment Being Reviewed for TSCR 192 Evolustion som No.
Manulocamor item Appilcetdo TestNaport Descripson 1
1 Wasinghouse Elmettel PEN RLK-3-16 01 Peneeston Assemth 2
Pd h Frowel111 N 91055 W ofTW XLPE Cable Reporte 5804 & 5805) 3 Conex Elodncel IPS-1420 Penetrebon Assemth and Peneesbon Spilaos 4
Roychem WCSF-N Wyle 58442-1 Sokee 7
Westmghouse Fan Cocier WCAP 7829 j
- Motor, Thermelsebe W/
Insulebon.
oplice end kJbncente 8
GermwMetri::e d Flux Report No. 010 Monitoring Syenom 9
Lkutongue Lknikmque WA Report B0058 vesve Aduetors 10 Kartta Cable Kartle HTK KerbeIF12A10 Report ineuhdad FR 61A RNTERPRERo, DiC.
3
_ - _... - -. - -.. - -..... _... - -... ~.
~
. _.. -... - ~
.. -. ~.
.... ~,
i WE F'8NP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION I
l Ewiusilon item No.
Beenudemurer item Appucetdo Test Re,$wt i
Descripoon
)
i Jacketed Cetdo 10A Karte Catdo Norte FR Neste 9/1240 a.amrt i
hieulated FR Jedeeled Cetdo 11 Namco Namco EA 180 Nemon Report No.105 Lknt Swikhee i
12 Namco Namco EA-100 Namco Report No.156 i
Lkntsandse i
a 13 Crostry Velve Crosby tJt Crosby Report 4245 Indiceano i
Swik2 A
l Assemtdy 1
i 14 Foxboro Fauboro NE 10 Wyle Report 455024 i
sense Pressure Trenommers 15 Transemence Transemence Wyle Report 45700-2 '
Delevel DelevelGame Level Trenameer i
16 Conex Electncel Conex IPS 409 Conductor seal Assernbees 4
17 UmonVeem and UmonVeem Veem test report pJrformed American BOA Connecsorand by the Component Teetng Amoncen Boe DMeen ofloomedoc.Inc, NN Noverrter1978 d
18 Terget Rod Terget Rock Terget Rock Report No.2375 Model 77CC-001 Solenoid 4
Velve 19 Exo Sensor Hydrogen EOSensor Report EXO-Montonng Q1R-101 4
t k
20 Exo. Sensor CEC Pressuro Exo Sensor Report EXO-Treneducer and QTR-119 GLB %,'
, hic.
0
.~
-.. -. - ~.-
WE PSNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION l
Evoluellon item No.
Idenudectume item agyne.haa Test Report W
{
Teyco RTD 21 hwn Uman-Veem NTS Report 5561654 Thermocouple Conneders 2
22 Anecende Anaconde Frankin Report F44969-1 Cable 4
23 Anaconde Anaconde Frenidin Report F-C48362 3
Flame Guard FREP Inerument.
3 CordrolCabie 24 Roychem Roychem Wyle Report 17859-02P i
Nudeer Grade Cahie Spices 25 Pu*h=ah=
P~*haan=
Rockbestos Report 5804 Fireweg lit
- in d W;3,4u Cabios 25A P~*ha*=
Rod @eetos P~*ha=*= Report 5805 q
Firewet til Irmdiobon Cross knked W,=,'.
4 f
Ch 4
\\
26 Automebc Swech ASCO NP-1 ASCO Report AQR47368 j
Ca g eny soienoid vowes i
27 P~*haan=
P~*ha*=
Rockbestos Report QR4002 CommelCable 28 Rome Rome m Report 3/19771ond newWyle mporte 17740 1,17432-1 j
and 6110 29 Rosenant Rosemount Rosemount Report Tronommer D6400102 1
Model1154 li h
5
_ _. _ _ _... _. -. _ _ _. _ _. ~., ~. _ _ _
WE PONP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION l
Evoluellon llem No.
Aisnu2ecturer item Appucaldo Test Report i
a Rosemount Rosemourt Report 7/2342 Model1154 w/
l 1150 Remote Seal j
I Rosemount Rosemount Report Transmaler D8300200 i
Conduit Connector Seal Model353C j
30 CortrolProducts incose ISA MC96.1-1975 Thermocouples 1
31 GeneralAtome General Alomic General Atomic Report E-l Hgh Range 254400 Redemon Morear RD 23 32 Gamme4Astnes Genwne-Garrme4Asincs Report 040 Meinos CeMe 33 1 -_1 4 aee Wesenghouse Weebnghouse Report PEN-Penetrebons TR-7749 j
34
/ _ _ _ J----
Limmorque Weebnghouse Report MOVE WCAP-741R 35 J
MOV h
' - 1 N'*ase Report
.-__- a WCAP-74104.
36 Wesenghouse Engmessed Wesenghouse Report Seisty Features WCAP-741M, Vol. ll Catwes end Spikes 37 Wesenghouse Contenment W Report Acadent Fan WCAP-7722 Motor Beenng Lubncent 38 Wasimghouse Contenment Wesenghouse Report Acadent Fan WCAP-7722 Liencent 30 Okonte Okonde CeMe Frenidin Report F-C3694 GLB L L,'-. bec.
8
d 1
WE PeNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION
- 2. Evaluation Procedure i
TSCR 192 results in the iblomng changes to the postulated DBA, which need to be i
addressed:
a The Maamum postuished DBA Temperature ricreases from 278 Y to 280 T.
i j
The Maamum paah w DBA Pressure increases frorn 53 poig to 53.5 poig.
e 5
a a
The postulated DBA Temperature Profile (Temperature vs. time) increases the
{
temperature after the one hour point for a durabon of wMi" ?/10 hours.
1 l
2.1 Maximum DBA Temperature Evaluation:
i in the evalumbon, the QuaMcabon data for PBNP was remowed for each of the potenbally 1
impacted EQ equpnent to determine if the Quahficabon data envelopes the new requirement for Maomum paah w DBA Temperature.
2 PBNP is required to meet the EQ requirements of 10CFR50.49 and DOR Guidehnes Thus Maomum DBA Temperature is met when the Test Data Maximum exceeds the postulated Maamum DBA Temperature. Temperature Margin is the difference between the postulated Maamum DBA Temperature and the documented quahlied Temperature.
1
==
Conclusion:==
I All EQ equipment required to be timewed due to changes in the DBA Temperature as a result of TSCR 192, at Point Beach Units 1 and 2, has been evaluated agenst the new l
DBA requirement. The original qualificabon, has been enhanced with new EQ reports, and has been shown to exceed the new DBA requrement. Thus, them is no impact on the j-Point Beach EQ program due to TSCR 192 and all EQ equipment is quakfied to the new 4
DBATemperature Each of potenbally impacted EQ equipment was found to be not impacted by the change to postulated Maamum DBA Temperature.
I Table 2. Medmum DBA Temperature Evaluation.
I k.
1 som No.
Poeladeled Madmum Test Report 4
DEA Temperstwo i
Isadmum PF)
Temperature m
1 200 340 60 EisekelPeneeshon PEN-RLK-3 AssemtWy 1641 i
1 i
OEE NM E i
7 a
s j
. - -. ~ -...-.....~. -. ~.
WE PSNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION 1
)
Evaluneen New QuellAed hiergin (T) llem Deectlp6cn Applicable item No.
Poeluteled IReuimum Test Report DBA Temperatum 80selmum (T)
Temperature (T) s 2
280 341 61 Ph Fimmed til N-91055
{
XLPE Cable (Analysis of Test Reporte 5804 & 5805) 1 3
280 445 165 Conex Elecancel Conex IPS-Penetremon Assemedy and 1420 Penetremon Splicoe l
1 j
4 280 432 152 Conex RTDe end Conex iPS-ThW 875 t
1 5
280 432 143 ConorRTDe Conex iPS.
796 f
6 280 442 162 WCSF N Splicoe Wyle 56442-1 7
280 324 44 Fen Cooler Motor.
WCAP 7829 Thermalesec Epoxy insulanon, senos and hericarte 8
280 460 180 Gemme44stncz Neutron Report No. 010 Flux Montonng System 1
9 280 315 35 Lknitorque Velve Actuatore Limmorque Report B0056 10 280 340 60 Kertin HTK insulated FR Kertie W12A10 Jacketed Cable Report 10A 280 300 20 Karte FR Ire.seted FR Karte W1240 Jacketed Cable Report 1
M M
s
WE PSNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION Evolustion New Que80ed 18ergin m item Descriptkm Appkable t'
Item No.
Possuisted IAndmum Test Report DSA Temperatum temdmum m
Temperstwo m
11 200 370 90 Namco EA 180 Umit Namco Report Swllches No.105 12 280 372 85 Namco EA 180 Limit Namco Report Sweches No.155 i
13 280 430 150 Crosby LRIndcoeng Swech Crosby Report Assembly 4245 4
14 280 420 140 Foxboro NE 10 Sense Wyle Report Poseurs Transmeets 45592-4 15 280 412 132 Treneamence Delevel Wyte Report Game LevelTregemmer 45700-2 16 280 350 70 ElectncelConductor Seal Conex IPS-Assembine 409 17 280 340 60 Laton Veem Connedor and loomedoc Nov
?
Amencen Boa Flex conduit 78 18 280 385 105 Target Rock Model77CC-Target Rock 001 Scionoid Velve Report No.
2375 19 280 310 30 Hydrogen Monitonng Em> Sensor System Report EXO-QTR-101 20 280 306 26 CEC Pmesure Transducer Em> Sensor end Teyco RTD Report EXO-QTR-119 ets ENTsJtPJtJsss, DC.
9
.._____.._.....m_
WE P9NP TSCR 182 EQ EVALUATION i
h New W
WM kW AW j
leem No.
Poehdoted Meidmum Test Report DBA Temperature Madmaavi m
Temperature (9) 21 280 415 135 Leon Veem Thom==@
NTS Report Connectors 558-1654 d
5 22 200 385 105 Anscxinda Cable Frank 8n Report F.
C4969-1 4
23 280 385 105 Anaconde Flame. Guard Franktn FREP Instrument, Control Report F-Catne C4836-2 e
1 24 200 365 85 Roydem Nudeer Grade Wyle Report Cable Sphoes 1785942P i
25 280 341 61 Par *hameaa Feowellil Par *h=aans Chemcody Croep Linked Report 5804 PC,r~ '.. Cetdes i.
25A 280 342 62 Par *h==ean Fsowes m Par *hamens irredubon Crose Linked Report 5805 Polyethylene CatWes 26 280 450 170 ASCO NP-1 Solenod ASCO Report
?
VeMe AQR47368 '
4 27 280 346 86 Rodesstoe ComuelCable Par *hamaan I
Report QR-6802 28 200 300 20 Rome Cable Report 3/19F/1ond newWyle reports 17740-1,17432-1 and 6110 4
29 280 450 170 Rosemount Trenommer Rosemount Model1154 Report 4
10
WE P8NP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION i
Evoluenon New Queu8ed Margin (T) hem Descripuon Applicable hem No.
Poemdeled Aleximum Test Report 4
DSA Temperature temdmum (V)
Temperature PF) 08400102 29A 200 420 140 Rosemourt Model1154 wt Rosemount 1150 Remote Seal Report 7/23512 i
298 200 446 186 RosemountTrenemnter Rosemount 1
Condut Connector Seal Report Model363C D6300200 i
J 30 280 1800 1420 incore Thermompes ISA MC96.1-1975 t
31 280 320 40 General Atomic Hgh Range General i
Redubon Montor RD 23 Atome Report a
E-25MI60 t
l j
32 200 420 180 GemmeMetrics Neutron Gemme.
Montonne System Cable Metncs Report 040 33 280 347 67
'. ^ GmPonstrobons
't _ _1-6m Report PEN-TR-77-59 M"
34 280 307 27 Lhdorque MOVs Report WCAP-l 7410-L 35 280 307 27 MOV Lubricant
/ _ ^_ Gm ReportWCAP-7410 L l
(
36 280 296 16 Engmoered Safety Features i _ _1-im i
Cabies and Sptoes ReportWCAP.
j 74104, Vol.11 i
37 280 324 44 Contanment Acadent Fan
/. _ _ L-4 m Motor Beenng Lubncarit Report WCAP-7722 a arma,a.,,c.
11 1
I
. -.. ~.
- - -..... - ~.
WE PeNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION Eweiustion New QueNAnd tiergin (T) hem Descriptkm AW aem No.
Peendeled RAmelmum Test Report DBA Temperenn IIsolmum
(?)
Tempemeuro I
M i
36 200 324 44 Contenimers Aoddent Fan
/ 4,,,me
}
Lencant Report WCAP.
22 l
30 2eo 345 66 Olente Cable Frenidin Report F-cased i
l 2.2 Maximum DBA Prosaure Evaluation:
j in the evalumbon, the Quancahon data for PBNP was timewed for each of the potentially impacted EQ equipment to detemine if the QueMcabon data envelopes the new j
requirement for Maxrnum postulated DBA Pressure.
PBNP is required to meet the EQ requirements of 10CFR50.49 and DOR Guidehnes i
Thus Maxrnum DBA Pressure is met when the Test Data for Maxrnum Pressure exceeds the rnatidated Maximum DBA Pressure. Pressure Margin is the deerence between the postulated Maxrnum DBA Pressure and the documented quair6edPressure.
==
Conclusion:==
i All EQ equipment requred to be timewed due to changes in the DBA pressure as a result of TSCR 192, at Point Beach Units 1 and 2, has been evaluated against the new DBA requirement The original quaMcabon, has been enhanced with new EQ reports, and has been shown to exceed the new DBA requirement. Thus, there is no impact on the Point Beach EQ program due to TSCR 192 and all EQ equipment is quaded to the new DBA pressure.
?
Each of potenbally impacted EQ equipment was found to be not impar *ri by the change to postulated Maximum DBA Pressure.
Table 3. Maximum DBA Pressure Evaluation.
Evaluenon New Possuished Queuned hiergin hom Description A M Test hem No.
DBA biedmum beeximum (paig)
Report Pressure (Pelo)
Pressure Poin) 1 53.5 60 6.5 ElectricalPenetrebon PEN.RLX.316 01 Aceomth GEA L :,,,,, " ^ bec.
12
1 WE PsWP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION i
Evoluelion New Postulated QueNRed Itergin leem Descetpdon A & Test them No.
DBA RAmelmum timolmum (smig)
Report t
Preneum (Peig)
Preneum (Pels) 2 53.5 107 53.5 Fe'ssed HiXLPE Catdo N-91455 (Analyes of Test Reports 5004 &
5805) 3 53.5 80 26.5 Conan Eisancel Conex IPS-1420 Penetreten Assemtdy and Penstemon Splicom 4
53.5 70 16.5 Conex RTDs and Conex PS475 Thermoco@ss 5
53.5 70 16.5 Conex RTDs Conex IPS-796 6
53.5 86 12.5 WCSF N Splims Wyle 58442-1 e
7 53.5 80 26.5 Fan Cooier Motor, p 7g Thermalesec Epoxy insulebon, aplico end hencents 8
53.5 70 16.5 Neutron Flux Monitonng Report Na 010 System 9
53.5 81 27.5 tmtorque Velve Actuators Limmorque Report a0058 10 53.5 105 51.5 Kette HTKInsuteted FR Karte W12/80 Report ww Conde 10A 53.5 105(Note 2) 51.5 KeHle FRinsulated FR Korte W12/80 Report
.locketed Catde ers z#rsatPAasas,58c.
13
. ~...-
h
(
i a
4 WE PONP 78CR 192 EQ EVALUATION i
avehagen New Poehested QueNAnd 80mgir ham Descriphon Appucetdo Test tem No.
DGA temdmum temdmum (poig)
Report Puseure(Peig)
Pmeoum (Pala) 11 53.5 76.4 22.9 Namco EA 180 Umt Namco Report No.
Sweches 106 1
5 12 53.5 76.4 22.9 Namco EA 180 Umt Namco Report No.
Sutchee 156 i
)
13 53.5 72 18.5 Crosby LRindumeng Crosby Report 4245 S m Amesmedy i
14 53.5 90 31.5 Fauboro NE 10 Series Wyle Report 456024 PneeumTrenameters 4
15 53.5 70 16.5 Traneamence Doisval Wyte Report 45700-2 Game LevelTransmitter i
4 1
16 53.5 180 126.5 EiedricalCondudor Seal Conex IPSM00
~
Assembles 17 53.5 106 51.5 UllonVeem Connedor and loommex Nov 78 Amencan Bos Flex condut
?
18 53.5 66 12.5 Torget Rock Medei 77CC.
Tmget Rock Report j
001 Solanod Velve No. 2375 i
d 19 53.5 67 13.5 Hydrogen Montonne Em>Seneer Report System EXOCTR-101 1
M
$3.5 58 4.5 CEC Pressure Transducer Em>Seneer Report and Toyco RTD EXOCTR-119 GB Lev ' ~ ^, bhC.
14
WE PONP TSCR 192 E2 EVALUATION Evoluesion New Poshdened Quaillied 80ergin hom Description AW Test item No.
DSA BAmelmum 10selmum (peig)
Repon i
Preneum(Peig)
Pmesure (Pein) 21 53.5 06 12.5 LAton VeemTheee NTS Report 558-1654 Connedors i
22 53.5 88 12.5 Ansoonde Coldo Frenidin Report F-C490Eh1 1
23 53.5 O6 12.5 Anaconde Flame Guard Frankin Report F.
FREP Instrumert, Control C4836 2 Cable i
24 53.5 58 4.5 Reyeom Nudeer Grade Wyle Report 17859--
Cable Spicas 02P j
25 53.5 107 53.5 Par *hanaam Frewel111 Par *h== nan Report Chemraty Cross Linised 5804 Polyethylene Cables e
25A 53.5 107 53.5 Par *h==aam Frewellli Par *h==aam Report irradacon Cmes Linked 5805 rT,r.i Cables b
I 26 53.5 78 24.5 ASCO NP-1 Solenod ASCO Report AQR-Velms 67368 J
27 53.5 122 68.5 Par *ha=aa= Coaxial Cable Par *h Report QR4002 i
28 53.5 58 4.5 Rome Cable Report 3/11W71and new Wyle mports 177401,174321 and 6110 29 53.5 110 56.5 RosemountTronometer Rosemount Report Model1154 D6400102 a amm== me.
15
... ~ ~
i 4
3 l
WE PSNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION i
Evolustion New Pmh QueNAed Itergin item Descripson A M Test hem No.
DEA blesimum RAndmum 4poig)
Report j
l Pressure Paig)
Pressure
~
j Pein) i d
2in 53.5 110 56.5 Rosemount Model1154 m/
Rosemount Report
}
1159 Remote Seal 7/2Ml2
?
j j
298 53.5 110 56.5 RosemountTransmiter Rosemount Report Conduit Connector Seal D6300200 j
j Modelsb3C l
a 30 53.5 Note 1.
Note 1.
Incore Thermocouples BSA MC96.1-1975 i
P 5
4 31 53.5 76 24.5 General Atamic High GeneredAtome Range Rathebon Monitor Report E-254-960 RD 23
?
i 32 53.5 70 16.5 GemmeMolncs Cable GammeMotrics Report 040 l
i 1
33 53.5 106 54.5 Weetnghouse Penetretpns i _ -4m Report PEN-TR-77 50 i
5
)
34 53.5 60 6.5 tJmbosque MOVs
't.-_1.4m Report 1
WCAP-7410-1.
a j
a j
35 53.5 60 6.5 MOV Lutwtoont
/
_1 Gw.me Report WCAP-74104.
i
)
36 53.5 60 6.5 W
- - 1 M -" M
(
Feelures Cables and WCAP-74104., Vol. Il t
i Spices 1
3 37 53.5 60 6.5 Conleinment Acadent Fan
! _1.4m Report i
Motor BeennD t.ubncent WCAP-7722 i
36 53.5 60 6.5 Contenment Acoldent Fan Wesanghouse Report i
Ladwtcent WCAP-7722 4
4 4
4 i
GB L.:,, '^ -, bec.
it a
~
--~ -
..._~
WE PeNP TsCR 192 EQ EVALUATION l
Evalueton New Poohdated QueNAed RAergin hom Descripson Appucetde Test horn No.
DBA Atestman tiedmum (poig)
Report i
Pmesure(pois)
Possum train) 30 53.5 115 61.5 Okonte Caldo Frenidin Report F.
case 4 i
L Note 1. For item 30. A six inch portion of the inom----Pa cable extends above the i
reactor vessel head This stamiess steel sheathed, mineral insulated it Tc.uaspie cable is designed Ibr the incore envronment (1800*F and 2500 poig) and routinely operates at 600*F and 2nona=w The portion of the ;t.e,rg wf a cable aW to the contammerf.
i almosphere is unalfacted by the small increase in contamment pressure (0.5 psig) paahdatart in TSCR 192.
Note 2. Kante FR Malenal was tested as a jacket to 105 psig in a one hundred day test and as an insuisbon to 52 poig in a 25 day test.
2.3 DBA Temperature Profile Evaluation:
in the evaluabon, the Qualdicabon data for PBNP was revowed for each of the potentially irW EQ equipment to determne if the Quahficabon data envelopes the new requrement for the new postulated DBA Temperature Prollie PBNP is required to meet the EQ requirements of 10CFR50l9 and DOR Guidehnes Thus DBA Temperature Proflie is met when the Test Profile envelopes the peak cordbons, which was documented above and when the degradabon caused by the test proflie was more severe than the equivalent degradabon of the new postulated DBA Temperature Profile. Thus this sechon addresses the Degradabon Equivalency of the new DBA Temperature Profile to the documented proflie in the PBNP EQ program.
Degradsbon Equivalency is performed in two methods : graphical and analyncal First, each item's EQ test proflie is graphed on the same chart as the new postulated DBA Prollie The Degradabon Equivalency is acceptable when the cumulatrve time at temperature of the EQ test profile is above the new postulated DBA Proflie once maxrnum temperature condibons have been met.
If a porton of the cumulabve time at temperature of the EQ test proflie is below the new postulated DBA Prollie after the peak test condibons have been rnet, then it is necessary to srs.lf.4y compare the area under the new postulated DBA Profile to the conservatism where the test proflie exceeds the new postuisted DBA Prollie to vertfy that the Degradation caused dunng the time under the new postulated DBA Proflie is less severe than the Degradabon caused by the area of the test proflie that exceeds the new pnahdatari DBA Proflie Degradabon Equivalency is an acceptable method for deTni-L.6,@ the equmsience of DBA prollies and is acceptable since it is a method which utilizes 10CFR50.49 Queirlicabon Method (f) (2) 'Teshng a similar item of equipment with a supportng analysis to show that the equipment to be quairfied is acceptable," and / or 10CFR50.49 Qualificebon Method (f) (4) *Analyss in comboabon with pertal type test data that supports oss smzarassa, sc.
17
~ - - -.. - ~ _
3 a
WE PeNP TsCM 102 EQ EVALUATION i
the analyncal assumptons and conclusons* Smler partial test data per 10CFR50.49 l
paragraph (f)(4)has been used.
For most equipment in this evaluebon at PBNP, the graphcal method W Degradaten Equivalency demonstrates that the new panhdahwi DBA ProRie is withm the already estabbshed EQ program at PBNP.
)
Only two equipment items, the Delevel Gems Level Transmitter and the Rome Cable e
required the supplemental Degradabon Equivalency Analysis. This analysis showed that the degradsbon caused dunng the time under the new postuished DBA Prome is less severe than the degradsbon caused by the area of the test profile that ** the new
]
postuished DBA Prollie, by a mergn d over 60% for the Delaval Gems Level Transmitter and by a margn of over 130%, for the Rome Cable For these equipment items Post j
Accident Operabliity was also reviewed to assure that long term post DBA was not affected
)
==
Conclusion:==
i i
All EQ equipment required to be reviewed due to changes in the DBA proflie as a result of j
TSCR 192, at Point Beach Units 1 and 2, has been evaluated a0anst the new DBA requirement. The original qualincebon, has been enhanced with new EQ reports, and has i
been shown to exceed the now DBA requirement. Thus, there is no impact on the Point l
Beach EQ program due to TSCR 192 and all EQ equipment is quairfied to the new DBA The Table 4, summarues the evaluation of the new pnah daisw1 DBA Prome at PBNP.
]
Table 4. Evaluation of now pa=hh DBA Profile at P8NP.
Ew:uemon Degrademon hem Descripson Appucatne Test neport hem No.
8-t _ i 4
IAsthod j
1 Graphcel ElectricalPenelneon Assembly PEN 4HX-3-1601 i
j-l 2
Graphcal Fimwei M XLPE Cetde N-91065 (Analyes of Test j
Reports $804 & 5806)
I 3
Graphcel Conex ElecancelPeneiraton Conex IPS-1420 J
Assemedy and Penetremon j
spame i
1 4
GrapNoel Conex RTDs and Conex IPS-875 Thom=~ e==
2 I
i M B E. L., _'^^. hac.
18 4
__m_.
I i
WE PSNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION 1
i i
Eweiumelon W
leem Description AW Test Report hum No.
w1i teethod 5
Graphcel Conex RTDs Conex IPS-798 6
Graphcal WCSFW Spkee Wyle $84421 1
7 Graphkal Fan Cooler Motor.Thermainete yg i
Epcey inedston, spilos and hertcents 1
4 8
Graphcel Neubon Flux Montonng Report No. 010 l
Gyelem i
9 Grenhcot umaanius Velm Adueurs Lmborque Report B0058 10 Graphcal Kette HTK insulated FR Karte 9/12/80 Report
.indeled Cable 10A Graphcal Keres FR insulated FR Karine 9/12/00 Report Jeested Cabte 11 Graphcal Namco EA 180 Limit Swasee Namco Report No.105 12 GrapNeel Nemoo EA-180 Lime Swechos Nemoo Report No.155 13 Graphtml Crosby LJt Indicenne Swech Ceceby Report 4245 Assembly 14 Graphical Foxboro NE 10 Sertos Wyle Report 455924 Pressure Trenemulars GL3 RNixEPJtans, DIC.
19
. ~..... _.
. _ -..... -.. - ~. -
-. ~ -. _ - ~... _ _ ~ _..
4
}
WE PSNP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATON l
Evaluellen Degradallon ihm Descripeon AppuceMe Test Report mom No.
Equivalency i
Molhed
?*
15 Graphicaland Trensemerica DelevelGems Wyle Report 45700 2 Analytool LevelTransmuter i
\\
1 i
16 Graphical EleceteelConductor Seal Conan IPS 400 Assem was I
I J
j 17 Graphumi LeonVeem Connectorand loomedet Nov 78 i
Amancen Boe Flex condut i
3 s
i 18 GropNcal Target Rock Model77CC001 Target Rod Report No.
Solenoid Velve 2375 i
I l
4 19 Graphcal Hydrogen Monitanne System Exo. Sensor Report EXO-QTR-101 l
20 Graphcal CEC F,eesure Transducer and Exo Sensor Report EXO-Teyce RTD QTR-119 l
21 Graphcal LimonVeemT W e NTS Report 558-1654 4
C-2 1
0 22 Graptuced Anaconde CeNe Frenidin Report F C4969-1 a
i 23 Graphcal Anaconde Flameouard FREP Frenidin Report F-C4836-2 inemument, ConociCeNe 4
I 24 GrapNeal Reymem NuclearGrade CeNe Wyle Report 1785942P sphes 4
E EMyr
,M 20 i
i j
_. _ _ _. - =. _ _..
l i
f WE PSNP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION j
Evalueelon Degradegon ihm Description Appuceble Test Report I
Item No.
em IIsthod i
25 0 ephical N FbewelXI N Report 5804 Chemicety Csees Unhed Po8selhytne Cebus 1
j 25A Graphumi N FeemelIN N Report 5805 Irradisson Cross LHed I
4 i
Polyelhyisne Cables i
26 Graphumi ASCO NP 1 Scionoid Velves ASCO Report AQR47368 i
i 27 Graphumi Ph ComaelCable Ram Report QR-
{
1 28 Graphreiand Rome Cable Report 3/19711ond new Analytcel Wyle reports 17740.1, 17432-1 and 6110 29 Graphcel RosemountTrenominor Model Rosemount Report 1154 D6400102 1
29A Graphcel Rosemount Model1154 wt Rosemount Report 7/2342 1159 Remote Seal 298 Graphicei RosemountTrenomalerConduit Rosemount Report ConnectorSeed Model353C D8300200 a
30 Graphumi inczeeThermocouples ISA MC96.1-1975 4
31 Graphical General Atomic High Range General Atomic Report E-3 Radleton Montor RD-23 254900 i
GLS EJffEEPARES, DGC.
21
- ~ _ -. -. _
WE PeNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION 4
mweiusson oseressman man Demo 4 eon AppmoshesTest Report hem No.
Equivalency asseiod 32 Graphumi GemmeMeirtcs Cable GammsMetus Report 040 i
33 Graphumi Wesenghouse Penstemone Wesenghouse Report PEN-TR-77-se 1
34 GrapNemi ummaque MOVs
/ __14-me Report WCAP-74104.
35 Graphcal MOVLdwicant i _1.4~me Report WCAP-74104.
as Graphumi E - - J Safety Feekses
/ J__@~me Report Cables and Sphoos WCAP-7410L Volit 37 Graphcal Containment Acddent Fan Wesenghouse Report Motor Beenng Lutwicant WCAP-7722 36 Graphcal Contenment Accedent Fan
/ __1 G~me Report bencent WCAP-7722 39 Grapheal Chonite Cable Frankin Report F C3094 2A PSNP EQ Propam Enhancement:
in the evalumbon, the addebonal Qualdicabon reports for smiar cable to the Rome cable were located and are being h W into the PBNP EQ program.
m Wyle Report 17740-1 m Wyle Report 17732-1
)
e Wyle Report 6110 ata n.:,:_-,Inc.
3 22
~-
WE PeNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION Attachments
- 1) Pronie Graphs item 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9,10,10A,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 25A, 26, 27, 28, 29, 29A, 208, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39 i
i
- 2) Degradsbon Equwalency for Transamerica Delaval Gems Level Transmmer Wyle Report 45700-2, Pages A8 A10 4
- 3) Degradabon Equiv.Wency for Rome Cable Wyle Report 177401Pages C8 C11 i
4 T
i j
\\
i 4
1 4
d 4
i au surssn = =,mc.
as
Item 1.
PBNP-DBA-T-W-Can-PEN-RLK-31601 PBNP-DBA Temperature
'n 300 l
1 E
200 -
1
--+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at I hr)(SGRP) g 150 -
-e-Westinghousehe-PEPHtLK-3 p 01 100-50 -
t 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 340 Met Yes Graphical Margin 21.4 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 3.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Conax PenlPS-1420 l
PBNP-DBA Temperature l
4 I I
300
-u
^^^
g f
--+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP) 200
[
--G-Conax Electrical Penetration and
{
Penetration Spices (IPS-1420) 100 50 e
7 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 445.00 Met Yes Graphical Margin 58.90 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 4.
PBNP-DBA-Temp ConaxRTD (IPS875)
- ~. -
PBNP-DBA Temperature
'E2 400-3 1
-u 300 g
e_
m g
+ Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at I hr)(SGRP) 200 g Conax RTD (IPS-875) 150 100 50 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 432 Met Yes Graphical Margin 54.4 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
_ _. =.
--~
Item 5.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Conzx RTD(IPS798)
PBNP-DBA Temperature 150 400 l
3 I
300 C
^
i B.=
B
-$--Temperature (2 CFCs O 75%.1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
' Conax RTD (IPS-798) 150 100-50 -
l 0
i 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1003 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 432 Met Yes Graphical s
Margin 54.4 %
WE-PBNP-T/S-192 EQ Evaluation
ltem 6.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-R:ychem(58442-1)
PBNP-DBA Temperature
=
ll 400-l l 1
I 300-g l
s I
l,I
--+--Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%.1 CS I
off at I hr)(SGRP)
-G-Raychem Sptce (58442-1) 150-100 -
50 -
0 O.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
,10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 442 Met Yes Graphical Margin 57.9 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
ltem 7.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-West-Fan-C-Motor PBNP-DBA Temperature r:
L C
200-
- +-Temperstwo (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP) 150-
-e-Westinghouse Fan-cooier44ator-space Lutwicant(WCAP-7829) i 100-50 O
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr) i PBNP Temperature Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 324 Met Yes Graphical Margin 15.7 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 8.
PBNP-DBA-Temp GM Monitor (010)
,-.... ~ -. - -.
PBNP-DBA Temperature 5^^
450 400-
-u g
Q
~
1
-+--Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS O
off at 1 hr)(SGRP) g Morutor(010) i
,g 100
^
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
P8NP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method l
Qualified Temperature (F) 460 Met Yes Graphical Margin 64.3 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
ltem 9.
PBNP-DBA-T-Limitorque B0058 PBNP-DBA Temperature 250 ll-El
- po T
11 L
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%.1 CS off at 1 hr) t50
-.- ~ em
- @pendix C 100 50 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 Time (Hr) 1 10 100 1000 i
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 310 Met Yes Graphical Margin VE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
[
ltem 10.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Kerite (9-12-80) l PBNP-DBA Temperature T
I 350.
.300
^
g 1 Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75% 1 CS 200 Mr at 1 hr)(SGRP) g Kette HTK/FR Catdo (9-12-80) r 150 100 50 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 10000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 340 Met Yes Graphical Margin 21.4 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
1
)0 5
8 7
-2 1 -
s 9(
C F) le CP b
R a
2(G C
wS R o(
F h )r
/
sh R
r F
e1 pt e
me t
eN e
r To K
0
=
00 0
1 08 d
2 o
1 h
t 9
0 e
R_
e 0
M r
1 F
u y
t R
a cn F
re e
la e
p
?
la ih c
it m
v e
r e
o iu p
t T
q a
4 E
r p
A G
n m
it B
o e
D T-a
_ P d
A c
a B
1 r
s T
0 0
0 0
0 g
r 0
D t
_ P 0
5 0
5 e
5 e
3 2
2 1
1 D
PNB
)r P
H 00 e%
s
(
1 80 m
23Y 1 0 e i
7 T
)
^
1 F
0
(
0 tne me riuF
)
1 0
q n
0 e(
o 0
Re it r
a u
et u
r a ur la e
v tap E
1 r
0 em Q
00 pe 0
mT E
e 2
d Te 9
=
i n
1 Pf ig R
i N lat r 1
0 B uea C
0 0
PQMM S
0 T
0
-P A
0 g~ g gg N
B 1
P m
e E
W t
I
=
Item 11.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Namco (QTR105)
PBNP-DBA Temperature m
11 350 I I ):
300 ll
-u
^
1
- +-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75% 1 CS 200 off at 1 hr)(SGRP) g
-G-Namco Limit Switch (QTR 105) p 150 100 50 O
o 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr) l i
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 370 Met Yes Graphical Margin 32.1 %
i WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 12.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Namco (QTR-155)
PBNP-DBA Temperature i^^
EE
~
350 1I 300 2
+ Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS 200 off at 1 hr)(SGRP) g
-e--Namco Limit Switch (OTR 155) p 150 100 50 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 372 Met Yes Graphical Margin 32.9 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 13.
PJNP-DBA-Temp Crosby LISA(4245)
.. _... _ - - ~. _. _ _ _ _ _.. _.... _ _ _ _.. _..._.
PBNP-DBA Temperature
^1c i
i i
PO I
-u C
- ^
--+--Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP) g
--m-Crosby USA (4245) 150 100 50 i
e 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 430 Met Yes Graphical Margin 53.6 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
ltem 14.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Fcxboro(45592-4)
PBNP-DBA Temperature
^52 Il 1
1: 50 300
- ^
l l
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%.1 CS
["
off at 1 hr)(SGRP) g
-G-Foxboro Pressure Transmitter (45592-4) 100 50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Ting (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 420 Met Yes Graphical Margin 50.0 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 15.
DBA-PBNP-Temp-Gems _(45700-2)
PBNP-DBA Temperature i50 400 I I 350-I
?^^ :: :.
v -
e
'l
/.N
--+--Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 g
200 CS off at 1 tw)(SGRP) s 150
--G-Transamence DelevelGems Levet Transratters (45700 2) 100 50 c
000001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 412 Met Yes Analytical Margin 47.1 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
ltem 16.
PBNP-DBATemp-Conax ECSA(IPS409)
PBNP-DBA Temperature t
=
l Ib 300 -
~
- =
==
E l
+Temperstwo (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS 1B 200 -
off at I hr)(SGRP)
-G-Canam Electrical Conductor Seal 150 -
Assemides(IPS-409) 100-50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 10000 Tkne (Hr) i PBNP Temperature Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 348.00 Met Yes Graphical Margin 24.3 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
I s
d c
na 1
ro) s.
t 8 c7 s
e 7
n v n o oN e.
cx c
ad oe r) cP Bm R
n os 2<G aI c(
.S rm i
r (
e u u )r md seh n
A. C r
o e1 pt m
- m. fa m xe f
el To vF 4
=
do 0
h t
00 e
=
M 1
yc 8
n 7
e 1
l l
1 a
a d
u i
ic 0
v ix e
0 r
h 1
u p
e t
q a
m a
E r
r o
e n
G s
p I_
m io ta m
e u
O d
a T
_L J
a e
r V
A ge B
I~
-p D
D m
e P
T N
s%
1 00 B
=
0 0
0 0
o 84 e4 A
P 0
0 5
0 s
23Y1 B
s 2
1 1
D 2
-P
)r N
H
(
B 1
F) e P
0 m
(
-u i
t T
ne me r
^
1 iuF
)
0 0
q(
e e Rr u et r a ur e 1
t 0
ap r
0 em n
0 pe o
mT i
t s
a ed Te lu n
a if Pi 10 l
i v
0 Nat g E
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM Q
E 29 1
1 00 R
00 C
0 ST Eg{
g
-PN 7
1 BP m
e E
W t
I
Item 18.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Target Rock SOV PBNP-DBA Temperature
=
450 -
400-Y E'
- ^
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
-G-Target Rock SOV 77CC-001~a75) 150-100-50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 385 Met Yes Graphical Margin 37.5%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation l
Item 19.
PBNP-DBA-Temp EXO (QTR-101)
PBNP-DBA Temperature 4~~
350
.[
=
s
+ Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS 200 off at I hr)(SGRP) g
-G-EXO Sensor H2 Monitor (EXO-QTR-p 150 101) 100 50 -
^
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 10000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 310 Met Yes Graphical Margin 10.7%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 20.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Tayco(ExoOTR119)
PBNP-DBA Temperature sse N
- ^
C
~
200
--$-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP) t50 CEC Pressure Transducer & Tayce
[
RTD of Exo Sensor H2 Monitor b
(EXO-QTR-119) 100-50 t
c 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 10000 Time (Hr)
P8NP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 306 Met Yes Graphical Margin 9.3%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
t I
u S
e C
c e
1 n
n o
5 C
7 lp e
u) s c4 c5 C
o6 F) m1 C P r
R e8 2(G h55 eS T(
ms r (
u)r e e tah eM re1 v m pt n e ma t
s o
ef t
s f
To uA 0
=
d o
0 h
t 00 e
=
M 1
ycn y
e s
l l
s a
a A
e 0
c v
i r
0 n.
u i
h 1
u p
t q
a o
a E
r r
C e
n G
p o
m m
i ta a
e 0
d T
1, a
V r
A g
-p B
e m
i D
D e
T-P u
A N
s%
1 05 B
B 0
0
=
0 0
0 0
0 81 e2 M
D P
5 0
0 5
0 5
24Y8 4
4 2
1 1
-P 4
NB I
)r 1
e P
p
^
1
)
e F
0 m
(
T i
tne me r
1 i) 0 uF 0
q(
e e Rr u et r a ure 1
t 0
ap r
0 em n
0 pe o
mT i
ta ed u
Te Pi in l
i a
f 1
v 00 Nat g l
E r
0 Buea 0
PQMM Q
E 29 1
1 00 R
00 C
0 ST
$ $E e
-P 1.
N 2
B m
P-e E
t W
I
i S
C 1
)
1 5
7 96 94 sC C-F)
F C P
(
R e
2(G N
eS aC r (
u )r e
tah d
re1 r
pt oc ma e
eff n
To A
do 0
h t
0 0
e 1
M yc
)
n 1
9 le l
a a
r 0
v ic 6
e 0
94 u
i h
1 u
p t
q
(
a a
E r
a r
d e
n G
n p
io o
m t
c a
_1 a
e 0
d n
T 1*
a A
A gr
-p B
e m
D D
eT P
N s%
A B
O 0
0 0
0 88 e5 1
05 B
P r'
s O
0 5
0 5
23Y7 D
.W 2
1 1
3
-P
=
N
)
B p
P 10 =
F) h
(
T t
=
ne m
e r
1 iu F) 0 0
q(
e e Rr u et r a ur 1
t e 0
ap r
0 em n
0 pe o
mT ita ed u
Te Pii n
la f
1 v
l ig 00 Nat E
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM Q
E 29 1
1 00 R
00 C
0 S
G T-P 2
N 2
B m
P e
E-t W
I
- t
,l tI
, +
SC 1,
)
5 2-7 63 4
s C
C-F)
F C P
(
R e
2 G h
i (eS a
C r (
tu) r e
ah d
re1 n
pt oc me a
e5 n
To A
~
0
=
0 00
)
1 2
d
-6 o
3 h
t 8
e 4
M
(
e 0
a r
0 y
d u
1 c
t n
n a
o r
e c
e l
l a
a a
p v
ic n
A m
i h
u p
e q
a 0
p T
E r
m
_h 1
A n
G e
o B
T-it D
a A
d B
P a
D N
rg B
e 1
-P P
=
0 u
0 0
0 0
D 5
0 5
0 5
N 3
2 1
1 BP s%
)
05 r
ep 88 e5 1
23Y7 e
0m 3
iT
)F
(
1 t
0 n
0 e
me n
r
)
o iuF i
t q(
a 10 e
0 Rr lu e
a 0
u et v
r a E
ur t e Q
ap r
E em 1
0 pe 2
00 mT 9
0 ed 1
Te R
n i
Pi ig f
C l
S Nat r
1 Buea T
00 PQMM 00 P
0 N
3.
C B
e 2
P m
e EW t
I
i>
l t'
l L
se i.ss
)
7 P
2 e.
99 3
c 7
r) 1 cP
(
R e
2 G e
t.S p
N
(
w) S r
wh m
e 1
pt hc ma y
f o
.f To R
d o
h t
0 e
00 M
1 yc
)
n P
e 2
l l
9 a
a v
ic 5
e 0
i h
8 r
0 u
p 7
u q
1 t
a a
E r
1
(
m e
n G
r e
p o
h m
it c
a y
e 0
d C
T 1
a r
R A
7-g e
p B
D m
D-eT PN s%
1 05 A
B 86 e4 B
P
=
0 m
0 0
0 O
0 0
5 0
S 23Y0 5
D 3
a 2
1 1
3
-PN M
B P
)
P
~
0 e F
1
(
m i
t T
ne m
g re 1
i) 0 uF 0
q(
e e Rr u et r a ur t
e 10 ap r
0 em n
0 pe io mT ta ed u
Te l
0 l
in a
i Pif 1
v 0
Nat g E
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM QE 29 1
1 00 R
00 C
0 S
E E#
T-P 4
N 2
B m
P e
E t
W I
- i l
S d
C h
1 nE) e4 s
5 o0 7
r8 C5
(
ye s
d l ab C
ca F) imC C PR el i 2( G ht eS Csa sw r (
u) o e t r t
r ah si r
eF e1 pt b
k E ma cP i
eff oL To RX 0
d o
0 h
0 t
0 e
0 M
1 ycn
)
e 4
0 l
l a
0 0
a c
8 e
0 v
i 5
r 1
i h
(
u u
p s
t q
a o
a E
r t
r s
e n
G e
p b
0 o
k m
0 t
i 1
a c
e d
o T
a R
r A
g
-p B
e m
D o
lD e
t T-P N
s%
A 01 B
B 84 e8 D
P 23Y1 2
P 1
N C
0 0
0 0
0 r
)
0 0
5 0
5 H
B 3
2 1
1
(
P F) e m
(
i s
T t
1 n
0 e
m e
riuF
)
q(
1 e e 0
Rr 0
u et r a ure tap rem n
100 pe o
0 mT i
ta ed u
Te l
i n
Pi i
a f
l v
0 Nat g E
1 r
0 Buea 0
PQMM Q
0 E
29 1
1 00 R
00 C
0 S
T-E e
P 5
N 2
B m
P e
E t
W I
S ee C
w 1
e r
F i
5 E
7 P
L X
s n
C o
it F)
C P le R
d 2
a)
(G r5 r
i 0 oS s8 w )(
o5 tsh s e r
t (
re1 el pt bb k a ma cC f
o ef l
To Rt i
0 d
o 0
h 0
t 0
e 0
M 1
yc
)
n 50 0
le l
0 a
a 8
e 0
v ic 5
r 1
i h
(
u u
s t
p q
o a
a t
r E
r s
e n
G e
p b
0 io k
m 0
t c
e 1
a o
T d
R a
A r
g p
B e
m D
D e
0 T
P 1
A N
B B
=
02s%
D P
84 e1 23Y2 P-2 N
0 0
0 0
0 0
1
)
B 0
0 5
0 5
3 2
1 1
p P
F) e m
(
i t
T 1
n 0
e me r
i)uF q(
1 e e 0
Rr 0
u et r a ur t
e ap rem n
1 00 pe o
0 mT i
ta ed u
TPiie l
n a
f v
0 Nat ig 1
l E
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM_
Q 0
E 2
9 1
1 00 R
00 C
0 S
E s
T-
.A P
5 N
2 B
m P-e E
t l
W
S C
m 1
57
)8 63 s
7 C
6 F)
C P R
R Q
2(G A
(
eS r(
V u)
O tah S
r re1 pt O
ma C
S f
ef To A
000 1
do h
t
)
e 8
e
~
0 M
6 r
0 3
u y
1 7
t c
6 a
n
(
re e
O p
l la a
c C
m v
i iu h
S e
A T
0 p
q a
1 E
r
-A A
B B
o lI n
G D
D io t
a P
P d
N N
a r
B B
g 1
P P
=
on
=
0 0
0 0
0
^
e 0
0 5
0 5
D 3
2 1
1
)
s%
rH 00 1
85 e7
(
0 e 24Y0 m
6 iT F) 1
(
0 t
0 ne m
e r
d iuF n
)
?0 q(
e i0 0
e 2
0 Rr M
u et u
r a l
ur a
t e
v ap E
r 10 em Q
e 0
pe 0
0 mT E
a i
e ed 2
Te 9
Pil in 1
f Nat g R
1 r
0 Buea C
0 0
PQMM S
0 T
h 0
-P 6.
s N
2 B
m P
e
-E t
I W
m L
ltem 27.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Rockbestos(6802)
PBNP-DBA Temperature
=
300-200-
-+-Tempersen (2 CFCs @ 75%.1 CS off et 1 hr)(SGRP) 150 Rockbestos Coedal, Twimudal, p
Triedel Cable (6802) 100 -
I So -
e o.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to
, 100 1000 10000 The (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 346 Met Yes Graphical Margin 23.6 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 28.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Rome (31971)
PBNP-DBA Temperature
^. ^
2 a
- ^^
--G-Rome CaNo (31971)
E
+ Carol PVC (6110) 200 -
-M-Rome Cane Wyle 17740-1 150 -
100-50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0001 o_01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 300 Met Yes Graphical and Analytical Margin 7.1%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
ltem 29.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Rosemount 1154 PBNP-DBA Temperature
=
450 -
400-l 350-I
~
^
- - Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
-G-Rosemount 1154 Pressure H
200-Transmitter (D6400102) 150-100-50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0 001 0.01 0.1 1,
to 100 Tkne(Hr)
WBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 450 Met Yes Graphical Margin 60.7%
WE-PBNP-T/S-192 EQ Evaluation
Item 29A.
PBNP-DBA-Hr-Rose-1159 PBNP-DBA Temperature
^t?
s 400 350-300 u
m 1 Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at I hr)(SGRP) 4
-G-Rosemount-1159 100-50 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10
- 100 1000 Time (H4 PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation E iva ncy Method Qualified Temperature (F) 420 Met Yes Graphical Margin 50.0 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 298.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Rosemount Con 353C PBNP-DBA Temperature l
450 -
g.
ll a.
l=
g 300 -
^
-+= Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off et I hr)(SGRP)
--G-Rosemount Condut Seal 353C H
200-(D8300200) 150-100 -
l 50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Reouirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 446 Met Yes Graphical Margin 59.3 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 31.
PBNP-DBA-Hr-Garm-Test 3 PBNP-DBA Temperature 250 300
"~
50 -
c
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs @
200-75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)
(SGRP) 150 General Atomics High t-Range Rachetton Monitor RD-23 (E-254-960) 100-50
?
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Time (Hr)
J PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 320 Met Yes Graphical Margin
_14.3%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 32.
PBNP-DBA-Temp GM Cbl(040)
PBNP-DBA Temperature 150
=
400 250 4.
300-l
- ^^
2
-+---Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP) 200-g
-G-Gemme Metrica Neutron Flux g
Monitor Cable (040) 150-J 100 50 e
0.00001 0 0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Rmuirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F; 420 Met Yes Graphical Margin 50.0 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
ltem 33.
PBNP-DBA-T-West-Pen (77-59)
PBNP-DBA Temperature
^^^
=
^
--+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS 200-off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
[
.". ;.46a Penetratkm (PEN-9g.
TR-77-59) 100 50
^
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10' 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 347 Met Yes Graphical Margin 23.9%
r r
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 34.
DBA-Temp-PBNP-West-Lim (7410L)
PBNP-DBA Temperature 250 M
I
, %,f
^
k
~
--6 --Temperature (2 CFCs @
200 75%,1 CS OR at 1 ir) 1 (SGRP)
- a.;;m Limitorque MOV WCAP g
150
- 74igy, e-100 i
r 50 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 307 I
Met Yes Graphical Margin 9.6%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation Page1
Item 35.
DBA-Temp-PBNP-West-Lub(7410L)
PBNP-DBA Temperature
?50 E
I
??^
al 50 A
~
g
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs @
200 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)
(SGRP)
= r.ta;..sw Mov Lubricant WCAP 7410-L 100 50 l
?
0.00001 0.0001 0 001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method 1
Qualified Temperature (F) 307 Met Yes Graphical Margin 9.6%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation Page1
Item 36.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-West-ESF-Cables PBNP-DBA Ten.perature Or 450-400 -
350-4
^w
^
g 300 -
g
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
-G--Westinghouse ESF Cables (WCAP-200-7410 t-VoNI) 150-100-50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0 01 0.1 1
,10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 296 Met Yes Graphical Margin 5.7%
WE-PENP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 37.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-West-Motor-Lub PBNP-DB A Temperature
=
1 A
=
- =
~
-+--Temperehne (2 CFCs O 75%,1 CS on at 1 hr)(SGRP)
E 200
-G-Westighouse Containment Acddert 1l
. b l
Fan Mohr Bearirg Lubricant (WCAP-M
--dr-Wesenghouse Farh-Motor-
).
150-space-Lubricard (WCAP-7829) 100 -
L 50 -
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 y
10 100 1000 10000 100000 PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 324 Met Yes Graphical Margin 15.7%
Westinghouse WCAP-7829 is bounding.
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 38.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-West-Fan-Lub PBNP-DBA Temperature
=
A
=
=
--+ -Teriparature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
E 200-
-e.-Wesenghouse Fan-Bearing-Lubricant
- g' (WCAP-7722) 150 p
-er-W888nghouse Farh-Motor-Space-Lubricant (WCAP-7829) 100 -
50 -
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 Qg to 100 1000 10000 100000 PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 324 Met Yes Graphical Margin 15.7%
Westinghouse WCAP-7829 is bounding.
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
[
6 i
S C
F-1 (e
lb 5
a 7
C re s
b C
b F) u P
R C R e
2(G n
eS oc r(
u) 5 t r S
ah r
e) e1 n4 pt n9 ma a8 f
k3 ef To oC e
0 d
o 0
h 0
t 0
e M
1 y
cn
)
e 4
l l
a a
9 0
c v
i 6
e 0
i h
r 1
3 u
u p
C t
q a
F a
E r
r n
G
~.
(e e
p o
t i
m it n
a o
e 0
d kO T
1-a r
A g
-p e
B m
D D
e T-P A
N s%
B B
1 05 0
0 0
0 0
0 84 e2
=
D P
0 0
5 0
5 23Y3 3
2 1
1 2
PN
)
B r
P H
(
)
1 F
e 0
(
m i
t T
n e
me r
iu F) 1 0
q(
0 e e Rr u
et r a ur t
e ap 10 r
0 em n
0 pe io mT ta ed u
Te l
i n
a Pif v
1 l
ig 0
Nat E
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM Q
0 E
2 9
1 1
0 R
0 C
00 S
T-0 9.
b p
PN 3
BP m
e EW t
I
FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 Analysis R! port, Pcg31 Print Dato: 02/04/97 Tims: 17:39 TEST VS REQUIREMENTS CALCULATION ltem
Description:
CALCULATION INPUT Activation Energy: 0.7800 Aging Temperature: 200.00 F
&Q.QlDENT REQUIREMENTS T
Plant Name: POINT BEACH 2ND Zone Name: CS OFF @ 1 HR STARTING ENDING TIME UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS 150.00 S
221.30 F
223.60 F
250.00 S
223.60 F
226.20 F
250.00 S
226.20 F
228.40 F
250.00 S
228.40 F
230.30 F
250.00 S
230.30 F
231.90 F
250.00 S
231.90 F
233.30 F
1000.00 S
233.30 F
237.50 F
1000.00 S
237.50 F
240.00 F
1000.00 S
240.00 F
241.30 F
1000.00 S
241.30 F
241.80 F
1000.00 S
241.80 F
241.90 F
2000.00 S
241.90 F
241.60 F
2000.00 S
241.60 F
240.60 F
2000.00 S
240.60 F
239.00 F
2000.00 S
239.00 F
237.00 F
2000.00 S
237.00 F
234.60 F
2000.00 S
234.60 F
232.10 F
2000.00 S
232.10 F
229.80 F
2000.00 S
229.80 F
227.50 F
2000.00 S
227.50 F
225.30 F
2000.00 S
225.30 F
223.20 F
ACCIDENT TEST Test Name: GEMS-DELAVAL (PART)
Report Number: WYLE 45700-2 STARTING ENDING TIME UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS 3880.00 S
300.00 p
300.00 p
PAGE 4 r of /b
i FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 An lysis Rtport, Pegs 2 Print Data: 02/04/97 Time: 17:39 3
ACCIDENT TEST... Continued l
Test Name: GEMS-DELAVAL (PART) l Report Number: WYLE 45700-2 STARTING ENDING TIME UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS 20.00 S
300.00 F
225.00 F
22500.00 S
225.00 F
225.00 F
CALCULATION RESULTS:
63.76 %
Prepared By: MA er 8
Nxem Date: 2 -// -ff Reviewed By:
u[
Date: /3//d7 as/
e p
s' g l, R 4 o f I o
i a
i 4
350._.-,. Fulcrum Group. Inc. System 1000 Revision 15.2
...,......___._,_,..,_,__..y.7.y_,..,,,,...,..,__,_y..___,_,.,_,,._,,
!!?
?
t t-a ?
?
!?!
?
?
i
?
..t y.
om
.?
, i t.
!, {
l tHJV
. i
<is
,.i
. p5, ie ++._==+.,._w-+=9.=..m
!.
- i t.i
.i Y..,- e! i. k. !. t. i. i.
1, i.
!, i. ?. '..f "
!.i.i
,?
i
?
Y.i
.? 4'.? !.!.!
.?
i
' t
?
! ! ? ? !!!
?
f ?
?.? ?!.*?
t f f
!*t
! ? ?'*!!
? ?
??
?
? ?
?
l
?
- ??
?
? ?
? *
.. ?. !. !.
t.
?. **?it
?
? ?
' W
?
g e
p
.t 1
.7._,._,.._.?..c eq - _ _. _., _ _7.
7...tpy.,,,,._....,..3_,.,_.,.9 9y__.y._,_,,,._.y,q i
q-.q..c 3..r y,.,..
r.___,
3 d) r i ; i i ii i
'M
....ii66 6
i. i. i,
. Y.
i i ; ; ;
i; i
w 1
i i i.i...ii iij
- )
(
i i4iie 1 A: -
3
- T. 9'-'t tt t.- " '.
t..
.,9 i
4 i.
4, i
NT'..
i
)
iie i..
y.
i.. i....
Y i..
e
- t. i.iii 200 e
i ii
,ii
..i...i i i.
i.i
...ii
- ii 4 i. ii 64 i
i.
i i
.. i i;
4J
_.___5__.i._.
i I
ei...
i i. i i 4.
.. 4 i i.i P9*PitTP*"""T""1 9"T*"PP9"""""P**P"T"PT977t****9--""*P*t*PitPF**"*t*"i*1"t i
.9 i
O i i 'is.i
'.ii4.
i i i iii.4 i
1 ;
iei..
i i
. i...i i.
..is
......ii i.,.
i...
ijii.i i i i
...ii
...ii.
k-
<iii.
i i i i
h i i i ii e
i e......
i
. iiii.
. i iiii.
i i i i iiii i
? f.? ?.? ?
.?
?..t !. ! ) *
?.,.
- ?i.i
?
- i. t t.t i
.t 9
.. t g
q.p;++p____4 4.q_4
,_ _ _ _ _p.p _ + _4 9.... - _ _ _4_ _ q._p q.;_ t + p _ _ _. + _4_ q + : ;, -
E 3..
.?
....i.
@100
.__. a?
i !
i iiti
?-
i r tiii
_ _ a..
u a L 4 w_ _ _ _ _4..
- 2. a. 4. a...w,._ _ _ _ u... 4.,u, 2,2, n,,.....i.
a._ u a. u. w. n_ _ _.
- 4. _4...r_4 a w F
?.
i
?. ?...!*
.?.
?.
?
8
?. ?.t ' !
?
?
.? ! !.!
?
9. ?
9 7
9 t 9 y
? * '
?.?
.*?.?
.?
!!?'
?
? !
??!?
.?
. 9. 9 999,
9 9
.. 9 99
- 9 999-9 9
g.
g999 9
.e e
. 9.... -
. 9
., ww
._.._s.__s,..,us 6 m.??._ _ _4_.4,.s.4 s.ww....w.. u.4.u. aa n.___a.s,_.us.u mw_ _ _. 4._4_a_4 s._?.
?
? -
?.?..
? ?
!t?
? e
? !
- t!!!t
.?
! * ?
- ?'
f f.
?. ?. !. !.
t.
- t. t * ?. '
't t'
?
't 8
't
/ !.?.??
- ?
, t
...t.
?
? ? *
- ttit t
- ?*?
- ?
??!?.
???!
?
! ? '
!?*?!
f
' ? ? ?'?!'
f !
?!!!?
!???
?
?
0 f
f t ! ! ! ?.?.?
?
?. '. ? ?. ?. ? !.
? ? ? ?.! ' ?
t.
.?.?.?.?.?
.?
.t
, E2
..,l E3 I
.lEl I
.lE4 Plant Post-Accident ProGe c o Time (Seconds)
Test Post-Acc. dent Profile].O Datei 02/04/97 i
Time: 17:44:52 Minirn urn Margin: 63.76 %
ltem
Description:
YAGE # 10 offo
FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 An:lys:3 R: port, Pcge 1 Print D:ta: 02/14/97 Time: 14:48 TEST VS REQUIREMENTS CALCULATION ltem
Description:
Rome Cable in Wyle 17740-1 CALCULATION INPUT Activation Energy: 1.3700 Aging Temperature: 200.00 F ACCIDENT REQUIREMENTS l
Plant Name: POINT BEACH l
Zone Name: FIRST 26.22 HR STARTING ENDING TIME UNrTS TEMPERATURA TS TEMPERATUFUNITS l
0.25 S
161.20 F
161.20 F
0.25 S
161.20 F
193.80 F
1.00 S
193.80 F
244.90 F
1.00 S
244.90 F
265.30 F
1.00 S
265.30 F
272.20 F
2.30 S
272.20 F
274.60 F
1.00 S
274.60 F
278A0 F
1.00 S
278.40 F
279.00 F
12.50 S
279.00 F
279.80 F
160.00 S
279.80 F
279.80 F
7.00 S
279.80 F
273.90 F
10.00 S
273.90 F
273.60 F
200.00 S
273.80 F
268.90 F
200.00 S
268.90 F
264.70 F
653.00 S
264.70 F
264.70.'
F 250.00 S
264.70 F
248.70 F
1500.00 S
248.70 F
248.70 F
250.00 S
248.70 F
224.20 F
350.00 S
224.20 F
221.30 F
150.00 S
221.30 F
223.60 F
250.00 S
223.60 F
226.20 F
250.00 S
226.20 F
228.40 F
250.00 S
228.40 F
230.30 F
250.00 S
230.30 F
231.90 F
250.00 S
231.90 F
233.30 F
1000.00 S
233.30 F
241.90 F
8000.00 S
241.90 F
241.90 F
2000.00 S
241.90 F
239.00 F
2000.00 S
239.00 F
237.00 F
2000.00 S
237.00 F
234.60 F
2000.00 S
234.60 F
232.10 F
10000.00 S
232.10 F
232.10 F
2000.00 S
232.10 F
219.00 F
fAGEss of II --
FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 Analysis Report, Page 2 '
Print D:t2: 02/14/97 Time: 14:48 ACCIDENT REQUIREMENTS... Continued Plant Name: POINT BEACH Zone Name: FIRST 26.22 HR STARTING ENDING TIME UNITS TEMPERAllJRJNITS TEMPERATURJNITS 10000.00 S
219.00 F
219.00 F
1.00 H 219.00 F
208.16 F
1.00 H
206.16 F
203.15 F
1.00 H
203.15 F
200.24 F
1.00 H
200.24 F
197.44 F
1.00 H
197.44 F
194.73 F
2.00 H
194.73 F
189.60 F
3.00 H
189.60 F
182.56 F
4.00 H
182.56 F
174.26 F
ACCIDENT TEST Test Name: ROME EQ TEST (PART)
Report Number: WYLE 17740-1 STARTING ENDING TIME UN!TS TEMPERATURJNI7S TEMPERATURJNITS 6.00 S
150.00 F
210.00 F
4.00 S
210.00 F
250.00 F
5.00 S
250.00 F
310.00 F
5.00 S
310.00 F
315.00 F
3.00 S
345.00 F
328.00 F
5.01 S
328.00 F
347.00 F
2.00 S
347.00 F
350.00 F
4.00 S
350.00 F
334.00 F
8.00 S
334.00 F
350.00 F
3.00 S
350.00 F
346.00 F
6.00 S
346.00 F
336.00 F
4.00 S
336.00 F
330.00 F
4.00 S
330.00 F
350.00.'
F 1.00 S
350.00 F
320.00 F
5.00 S
320.00 F
336.00 F
5.00 S
336.00 F
328.00 F
5.00 S
328.00
.F 322.00 F
10.00 S
322.00 F
338.00 F
10.00 S
338.00 F
330.00 F
15.00 S
330.00 F
330.00 F
60.00 S
330.00 F
338.00 F
120.00 S
338.00 F
320.00 F
240.00 S
320.00 F
320.00 F
70.00 S
320.00 F
310.00 F
l l
[
_ b9 Oh l
~.
i FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 Analysh Report, Pago 3 Print D:ts: 02/14/97 Time: 14:48 ACCDENT TEST,,, Continued Test Name: ROME EQ TEST (PART)
Report Number: WYLE 17740-1 J
STARTING ENDING l
TIME UNITS TEMPERATURJNITS TEMPERATUFUNITS
?
230.00 8
310.00 F
300.00 F
420.00 8
300.00 F
300.00 F
800.00 8 300.00 F
280.00 F
1 1800.03 8
280.00 F
230.00 F
1.00 H 230.00 F
230.00 F
30860.00 - S 230.00 F
190.00 F
1.00 H
190.00 F
185.00 F
l 1.00 H
185.00 F
185.00 F
j 100.00 8
185.00 F
178.00 F
{
40200.00 8
170.00 F
178.00 F
1 j
i i
CALCULATION RESU130.88%
1 1
4 i'
1 i
Prepared By:
Date: 2-/4-97 e
2<,u:4 Reviewed By: !bA sw Date: d52 49>
/
/
'//
i
[Mf f b ch )\\
~
s W
i 3
- p..
.5 7 4 -
r
.p
~ w n
+:
+
n.
..y.-
- z, a 4 6. & n ? p ix x. = n s; 4 m w :~ + 5 c d % g u m =
xm.,
%...x, i.s;,,a,gg.,. 3,.o n.4. u... n.+,1.n y,.. w%g:;p. n s.
n
-AW. s, si...
x.
G 1.
s
.s m#
..1 e u.-
c
.,. _. q.,,,..
p.#,. w...
r
.g. ;.7 gg,..,.., v,, g..p %,, p..,s._,.
,r,.. 7, _
M 7;; : '-
yv: y; p :qga,' gl, n's - r M*y W q.
y y
y.
w.m
. 4 y4
+ w n
g v.250 e rFulcrum Oroup,.tInc.14ystem 1000 Revision 15.2 y
i y,i 0 ;j, 4;.i.
ic i
c,j 4
.j..
t4 i, ;,
y..
i 1
... i s
.i
-, - j 4[a
- i i -.,, -
i 4
i
- 3 i
em4.
>v i
j
. q s..
w r
.. ;. J.,, 3, w,, p
- a. -.
I g,
l
-.4, 4 3
- h. 3..
~ s o
4; r
. i..
i i
t i
i l
"3 gi+. '
e t
r
- f. *. }
A * ' r' '
' l 'G t9 s ll i
'l.
-r 1,'
i 200 j
~
l O
ii; ii i
i i
i i
i i j!
i i;
j i
ii i
i i
i '
i ii i
'i t
i
)
i
!e i
<i I
si r
.-,. _t -:z r i !
i 4.w
,a.4,4 i
1,.
t p.i :
, ii
-)150 I!
~ '
.4 !'
l '
I-q!!
i i
r i!,!
L 1
N _.' '
-r
~
.g
- i i
o, i ; is a_
i,, 1so i
i
,i i i
- o i; 4
i i ii:
s ji q-
- i i t-i i
- i e
i
- i r-l if
! ', ' l h:!
O
- y. d., E i
i 9--M, J !. 4 l
j' L
j.
i.
i i;
i i
3 00~
i 5
i f.-
, i. ', : '
i -
i.
e,,-.
-p' ig;'
1 tW,.filiji 9
43 ij iw$.4 i
'!j i
i..
,2: i i
i.:
i i
i, iii E-.:
,.~.;rii, i
i:
it r. ::
5 i
ie i ;
i 5
L c..r...A.,3,..M.
(1) i
.i !2 i i
ii i
i : !
.i i ' ' iii i
l +-* '
r+
h
~!
! t.
- i t
!6 i !
!*!i
_. _ _._.p.,__p.,_ q...i.i _._ _...; _.. I;'
!j 50 l
l a
__ _ w _,,i.i __,_.p!.,;..p! ljj-j I
r
.7_,_,_,
4
.., n ;
7_._,.__._
.p i
i i.
i:i!
i.,i i i s.
.i i,i i
i
- : i ili; i
- i
- i i
i L
i i!-
i, i i it:'
i i
l I'i l'
i
- i i
i i
i
[
I
^
e i !
!i if-l 3 I i
'I i
0 it i
i i
i
! !. i.
i.
i i
1 jj i
i i
i i
i
.i i
1
'1El
~1E2
' 1E3
'1E4 r
. Time (Seconds)
Pe-: Post-Accidert Drfle,w.
r 7.'.'Date: 02/14/97 s
..g.,
,s _-or,,.-::em w=. P'a-a se a
q..
,...e
- e pa Time
- 14:50:30 9' Minimum Margin: 130.86 %
~ItemDescriptioniRomeCable!. inkle 17740-1
~
g
,.7 e
f 1-y i
yu p(4-J.VN,
. g --
3 g,
S.:,.' g p 6 i s.
92 1 * * '9.
. % 3 x.
i-4
.,. m -
....... m 4. 4, vy 4
- St
_ i,
}"' " *f C T :'D ':
Lt m"
- P"
.3','
- f/$ir%'d 'N"
- N*
t y
- s..,.
,.~smEj-wa<-.. ! AlOQ. M U 4 s. ~ <.',v.e
' M p $.'M.
.s g
.'.',f,+*
i,, 4 s..e-O '
9 Y%
'f s
e
[ 'I f
e
^^[
4 t
4
.s O
I 4
'N
'S y
I
}
i Y
J
N
t March 3, 1997.
i If there are any questions regarding the information presented in this meeting summary, please contact Linda Gundrum at (301) 415-1380.
Orig. signed by Linda L. Gundrum, Project Manager Project Directorate III-1 Division of Reactor Projects - III/IV
[
. Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Docket Nos. 50-265 and 50-301 4
Attachments:
1.
Attendance List 2.
Degradation Equivalency 4
3.
Evaluation of EQ Impact
- cc w/att:
See next page 4
)
' Docket File (2)
DISTRIBUTION:
i-PUBLIC i
- PD31 Reading j
OGC (w/o att)
ACRS (w/o att)
J. McCormick-Barger, RIII (w/o att)(JWM)
L. Gundrum j-E-Mail:
S. Collins (SJC1) i F. Miraglia (FJM)
R. Zimmerman-(RPZ) i
'J.
Roe (JWR)
E. Adensam (EGA1)
' D. Ross (SAM)
S. Saba (SNS1)
H. Walker (HXW)
G. Hubbard (GTH)
D. Thatcher (DFT-),
F. Ashe (FSA)
J. Knox (JLK)
J. Hannon (JIIH)
B. McCabe (BCM)
DOCUMENT NAME:
G:\\WPDOCS\\PTBEACH\\PTB96741.MTS To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the bos: "C" = Copy without attachment / enclosure "E" = Copy with attachment / enclosure
- N" = No copy 0FFICE PM:PD31 C
LA:PD31 C
SPLB EELB lt D:PD31 r
NAME LGundrura:1pn CJamerson D V HWalke&N SSabassb JHannon 'W&k,-
DATE 02/A n/97 0249/97 ff 3 /3 197 s / 3/97 A /1 /97 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY
r s
c j
[%
p 1
UNITED STATES l
g
}
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS810N 4
WASHINGTON D.C. 30e064001 l
}
j March 3, 1997 f
LICENSEE: Wisconsin Electric Power Company FACILITY: Point Beach Nuclear Plant, Units 1 and 2 i
SUBJECT:
SUMARY OF FEBRUARY 24, 1997, MEETING ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION i
0F EQUIPMENT BASED ON REVISED CONTAINNENT RESPONSE INCLUDED IN CHANGE REQUEST 192 On February 24, 1997, NRR staff members met in Rockville, Maryland, with representatives of Wisconsin Electric Power Company (WEPCO) and GLS Enterprises, Inc., to gain a better understanding of the licensee's basis for i
concluding that the ability of environmentally qualified equipment inside i
containment to perform its function following a loss-of-coolant accident is not affected by the revised containment profiles. A list of attendees is included as Attachment 1.
l-The licensee discussed the concept of degradation equivalency (Attachment 2) and presented its evaluation of equipment qualification impact resulting from the revised containment temperature profile (Attachment 3). Degradation equivalency was presented as a method of equating a design-basis equipment test profile to a design-basis equipment requirement. The concept of i
i degradation equivalency as expressed in the presentation is not defined and was not accepted by the NRC staff. The staff stated that the Arrhenius methodology is acceptable. However, during transient conditions, the staff contended that no basis exists to correlate tests at lower temperatures to i
conditions at higher temperatures for a shorter period of time.
In addition, the staff stated that acce'ptable criteria for documenting that equipment may not be needed for the entire duration of an accident should be based on criteria specified in NUREG-0588, " Interim Staff Position on Environmental i'
Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment," Revision 1.
i WEPCO's presentation provided sufficient information for the majority of equipment. WEPCO agreed to submit further information on Gems level transmitters (Item 15); Rome cable (Item 28); and containment accident fan motor bearings, motor cable and cable splices, and lubricant (Items 37 and 38). WEPC0 stated that the lubricant similarity will be based on the chemical composition of the original lubricant used in the qualification tests as i
compared to the chemical composition of the manufacturer's currently j
. recommended lubricant.
j
a,
... If there are any questions regarding the information presented in this meeting sumary, please contact Linda Gundrum at (301) 415-1380.
4A sh-Linda L. Gundrum, Project Manager Project Directorate III-1 Division of Reactor Projects - III/IV Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Docket Nos. 50-266 and 50-301 Attachments:
1.
Attendance List 2.
Degradation Equivalency 3.
Evaluation of EQ Impact i
l cc w/att:
See next page 4
1 1
i j
i l
Wisconsin Electric Power Company Point Beach Nuclear Plant Unit Nos. I and 2 cc:
i Ernest L. Blake, Jr.
Shaw, Pittman, Pctts & Trowbridge Mr. Richard R. Grigg 2300 N Street, N.W.
Chief Nuclear Officer i
Washington, DC 20037 Wisconsir. Electric Power Company 231 West Michigan Street, Room P379 i
Mr. Scott A. Patulski Milwaukee, WI 53201 i
Site Vice President I
Point Beach Nuclear Plant Wisconsin Electric Power Company 6610' Nuclear Road 4
Two Rivers, Wisconsin 54241 Mr. Ken Duveneck i
Town Chairman Town of Two Creeks i
13017 State Highway 42 j
Mishicot, Wisconsin 54228 Chairman Public Service Commission of Wisconsin P.O. Box 7854 Madison, Wisconsin 53707-7854 Regional Administrator, Region III U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 801 Warrenville Road i
Lisle, Illinois 60532-4351
)
Resident Inspector's Office l
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
]
6612 Nuclear Road Two Rivers, Wisconsin 54241 j
Ms. Sarah Jenkins I
Electric Division Public Service Commission of Wisconsin I
P.O. Box 7854 I
Madison, Wisconsin 53707-7854 4
]
)
Doomsber 1996 l
1 l
~
ATTENDANCE LIST l
George Hubbard Plant Systems Branch, NRC (part time)
Harold Walker Plant Systems Branch, NRC Saba Saba Electrical Engineering Branch, NRC Dale Thatcher Electrical Engineering Branch, NRC John Knox Electrical Engineering Branch, NRC Frank Ashe Electrical Engineering Branch, NRC Linda Gundrum Project Manager for Point Beach John Hannon Project Director, PD 3-1 (part time)
Tom Malanowski WEPC0 John Hinck WEPC0 James Gleason GLS Enterprises, Inc.
4 Iw i
a I
a e
ATTACHMENT I
)
GEA Ernkipitees, Irac.
I Degradation Equivalency i
It is necessary to utilize Degradabon Equivalency for many reasons, such as :
Onginal Quahfication Test was performed in two transsents. IEEE 323-74's appendoc showed DBE Test prolue with two transients.
l a
Thus many qu4a Eni tests were performed with a high temperature, pressure and steam transient, followed by a cool down penod and a repeatof the transsent.
Onginal Quahlicabon Tests had more than two transients. In some cases test anomates caused the DBE simulabon to be repeated a
more than twice, typecally due to anomohes in teshng a Genenc qt4&o&,i teshng has been performed in which a specdic plant requrement was demonstrated by teshng to worst case
[
DBE's represenhng many nuclear plants and the test DBE does not exacdy follow each plants DBE requrements.
e Postulated Plant DDE's have (fianged since the onginal qualificahon requrements Plant requrements change due to tech spec
' I di g These oRen result in new paahed DBE requrements. Since 10CFR50A9 slows partial type teshng to demonstrate qtskokii, rather than requaing new teshng, Degradabon Equivalency aHows compensons to the new requrements-l Degradabon Equwalency is a conservahve approach to companng DBE requrements to DBE test condibons Example 1 shows a two
[
transient test for Namco Limit Switches (QTR-155). The first transsent was over aRer approximately 3 hours3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> and the cool down penod was approxvnetely 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> prior to the start of the second transient. Thus the penod between 3 and 5 hours5.787037e-5 days <br />0.00139 hours <br />8.267196e-6 weeks <br />1.9025e-6 months <br /> appears to not envelope the DBA requrement. A better depechon of the DBE simulabon is to use the *Cumulabwe Time at Temperature" technique in this techruque, the i
transsent at the 3 hour3.472222e-5 days <br />8.333333e-4 hours <br />4.960317e-6 weeks <br />1.1415e-6 months <br /> point is not plotted and instead, the conhnuabon of the second transient is plotted aAer the first transsent and the penod of the cool down pened is subtracted from the elapsed time. Example 2 shows the same graph with the total Time at Temperature techruque Example 2 is conservahve since it removes the cool down penod and the resulbng line moves closer to the requrement, as can be seen from t
the check point noted on Examples 1 and 2. The check point in example 1 is at the 11 hour1.273148e-4 days <br />0.00306 hours <br />1.818783e-5 weeks <br />4.1855e-6 months <br /> point and shows that the temperature is approxrnately 340 T. In Example 2, the same 11 hour1.273148e-4 days <br />0.00306 hours <br />1.818783e-5 weeks <br />4.1855e-6 months <br /> point now shows that the temperature is (,,,v
- ,,e 275 T. Thus the cumutabwe time at temperature techruque provides a more conservabwe usina,,..iouvii of the DtsE Test Prefile, when the prollie contains cool down penods wNch are less than the requrement.
Therefore, the ya/ Aid representabon of Degradaban Equivalency, using the Total Tirne et Temperature technique aRows compensons between DBE requirements and DBE simulabons.. When the Degradabon Equwalency shows that the test DBE envelopes the DBE
[
requrement, it is demonstrated that the teshng exceeds the requrement.
l l
d M
i i
!2 N
1 I
. ma a
GLS Enterpriseo, Inc.
Degradation Equivalency
~
Example 1. PBNP-DBA Temperature t
350 ll ll 300 C
l
{
[
l
--$-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS 3
L oN at 1 hr)(SGRP)
E 200
- -Namco IJmit Switch (OTR 155)
,5 150
-e-Check Point ll 100 50
?
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Time (Hr) l a
k I
i
GLS Enterprise:, Inc.
Degradation Equivalency
~
350 II 300
--4-Teiriperature (2 CFCs @ 75515 off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
)
200
--g-Namco Limit Switch (OTR 155) g Check Point 339
... - ~. -
100 50 e
000001 0.0001 0.001 0 01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
Example 2. Total Cumulative time at Temperature.
h
l
" " * " " ' ' * " ^ " "
GLS EntsuyuMs, Inc.
l I
i Evaluation of EQ Impact of l
Wisconsin Electric Power CompanyTechnical Specification Change Request 192 3
l
\\
GLS Entaayi ses, Inc.
1819 Cross Creek Road i
Huntrville, AL 35802-3972 Ph 205 881-9068 i
Fax 205-881/A98
{
Email: gisir.c@ traveller.com I
i r-2 Y 77 j
Jarnes F. Gleason, P.E.
i Date : 2-24-97 a(Q John A Hinck, Wisconsin Electne i
4 Date : 2-24-97 i
1 i
'f OLS ENTERPRIBES, DC.
i 4
i a
ATTACHMENT 3 l
)
wE PeNP TsCR 102 EQ EVALUATION l
4 Wisconan Electnc Power Company has identified changes to the Desen Basis Accident Condibons that are postuished bened on the implomontabon d Tedinical Speedicabon Change Request (TSCR) 192. The change results in a change to the DBA proflie utilized j
in the Point Beach Nuclear Plant, Units 1 and 2 Envronmental Quahlicabon (EQ) Program,
)
whch is requwed to meet 10CFR50.49. It was recmpnized by Wisconsin Electric that the
)
change to the DBA Pruflie could impact EQ equpment and an evaluabon was performed A Condibon Report, CR 97 0242, was inibated. The CR documents the operabihty l
determnaban and estabushes achons w innel resolubon 4
4 -
i 9
1 AN EQ equipment required to be reviewed due to changes in the DBA condebons as a
~
result d TSCR 192, at Point Beach Units 1 and 2, has been evaluated agenst the new i
DBA requrement. The ongenal quahficabon has been enhanced with new EQ reports and has been shown to exceed the new DBA requrement. Thus, there is no impact on the Point Beach EQ program due to TSCR 192 and au EQ equipment is quablied to the new
{
DBA W i
The major elements d this evaluabon were :
1.
Idenolicabon d EQ Equipment to be evaluated for this change
- 2. Evaluabon P'ocedure r
2.1 Maamum DBATemperature Evaluabon a
2.2 Maximum DBA Pressure Evaluabon 2.3 DBATemperature Profile Evaluabon 2.4 PBNP EQ Program Enhancement in the evaluabon, additional Quahficabon reports for similar cable to the Rome cable were located and are being ricorporated into the PBNP EQ program.
s Wyle Report 17740-1 e Wyle Report 17732-1 m Wyle Report 6110 1
j aus ErrsJtrJtassa, mc.
2 1
y
.m o
VWE PSNP TsCR 102 EQ EVALUATION 4
ii l
- 1. klerdNIC dien d M W te be M $0Ftids Ch W g e.
The Point Beach EQ program identified that the following EQ equement, Table 1, is mquesd to be revowed in this evaluenon This equipment list mnests of an i
envronmentasy queued equement located inade of contsinment at PBNP.
1 k
Table 1. EQ Equipment doing Reviewed for TSCR 192 f
Evolusson item No.
Menduceumr
' Item AppecetdoTestReport i.
Descripelen i
1.
Weehnghouse Eisetcol PEN 4tLK41641 Penseeman i
j 2
h Mlu M41455(Analysis oftest XLPE Caldo Repons 5804 & 5805) 3 Conex Electrical IPS-1420 i
Ponoiremon t
j Penseenan 4
m.
5 Conex RTDs IPS-796 i
6 Raychem VWCSF-N Wyle 58442-1 i
seeces l
7 Wesenghouse Fan Cocier VWCAP 7829
{
- Mott, 4
The,mmes.c Epony
- innvanon, i
opfrJo and habncante I
j 6
Gamme Moeks Neuimn Flux Report No. 010 4
Monnering i
1 3
9 Lkteonque Limeonque Lsvitostgue Report B0056 vesve Amuseers d
j 10 Korte Cable KerneHTK Kerto IW1240 Report i
insuiseed FR
)
OIA KMTEAPAESS, flec.
3 J
i 5
1
t d
i WE PSNP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION i
Evoluselon ham No.
beenutscheer item Appuceble Test Report Descripson i
M i
10A Norts Cabk Norts FR Norte 9t1240 Report insuleled FR l
,lechsted Cabis l
11 Nemon Namco EA 180 Namco Report No.106 tht satches t
12 Namco Nemon EA 180 Namco Report No.186 l
Lht Swedue i
13 CrosbyVehe Crosby tat Crosby Report 4245 hk=8'W 14 Fosboro Fosboro NE 10 Wyle Report 456024 Piessure Transmeers 15 Traneamorton Transemetics Wyle Report 45700 2 '
4 Deiswei Deisveloeme
\\
Lani Trenomaner
{
16 Conex Elecincel Conex IPS409 l
Conductor Seed i
Asseneten 1
e 17 IJeanVeem and Lbon Veem Veemtest report performed
}
Amencen 80A Connectorand bythe CorgonentTeseng Amancan Boe DMeen ofloomedoc. k.
Fiox condut November 1978 18 Target Rock Target Rodt Target Rock Report No. 2375 Model 77CC-001 Solenod Vefve 19 Emo Sensor Hydrogen Emo Sensor Report EXO-MontorWg QTR-101 System 20 Emo Sensor CEC Piessure N Report EXO-Transducerand QTR-119 Gls Ersterprises, bec.
4 I
3
.o.
WE PSNP T8CR 192 EQ EVALUATION j
4 i
Ewelustion item No.
Idenuiscewer Item Appucebte Test Report
]
osecripson 1
Toyon RTD
}
i; t
21 Ullor>Veem Labor >Veem NTS Repon $681664 Ti..
o Connectore
)*
22 Ansoonde Anaconde Franidin Report F449001 4
3 Calde i
23 Anaconde Anaconde Frenidn Report F44836-2 j
Fiammouard FR EP Consolceme t
24 Reymem Roychem Wyle Report 16 j
NudeerGrade Come Somme 1
a 25 Rockbestos Pm Rodsbestos Report $804 1
Firewellel Chemico8y Cr.es =*ed
,mm.,--
25A PN Pm Rodtestos Report 5806 Fimmeilli irradiaton Csoasbeed i
m m.,.
/
Cables 26 Automenc Swech ASCO NP-1 ASCO Report AOR47368 i
Cogeny Scioned i
t l
27 Rockbesene Pm Pm Report QR4002 CoedelC A 26 Rome Rome Catdo Report 3NIV71end newWyte vaporte 17740 1,17432 1 and 6110 1
4
{
29 Rosemount Rosemount Report TronomIber D6400102 Model1154 1
1j eld ENTIAFABES, JNC.
5 i
i 4
4
)
WE PSNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION i
Evoluemon hem No.
Menulacewer hem Appucetdo Test Report Descripern 4
)
M N
Rosemom.t PAmemount Report 7/DB2 Madmi tts4 W 1150 Remote sesi 4
298 Rosemount Rosemount Rasmount Report i
Trenommer D0300200 Conrut i
Connector Seal Modst 363C 1
30 ContalPiedude incom ISA MC96,11975 T;..
31 GeneralAtomic GenereiAtome General Atomic Report E.
High Range 2%G80 Redubon
}
Montor RD 23 32 Genwns Metrice Gamme.
Gammo44stnee Report 040 Marice Cetne 3s Wasanghouse i _ __ J- -
Wesunghouse Report PEN-Penevanone TR.77 se 34 Wesenghouse Urnitongue Westrql house Report MOVE WCAP-74104.
36
/ _ : s~me em 7 --.14,me Report WCAP 74104.
l 36 J.__4-me Engneemd
. __16,me Report Safety Festume WCAP-74104 VolIl Conses end Spkan 4
37 7
4-me Corte;renerd Wesenghouse Report AcadertFen WCAP-7722 Mokr Beenng Lubncert 36 Wesenghouse Cortenment Weetnghouse Report Anddent Fen WCAP.7722 IJestcart 30 Okonte Ohonte Catdo Frankin Report F C3694 ma Enterprises, bac.
s
j l
wE PoNP TsCR 192 EQ EVALUATION l
l 2.Evatisation Procedure i
j-TSCR 192 results in the fotomng changes to the r=*w DBA, which need to be addressed:
e The Medmum postulated DBA Temperature increases from 278 Y to 280 T.
i a The Maximum postulated DBA Pressure increases tom 53 psig to 53.5 peig.
i i
e The postulated DBA Temperature Prollie (Tempersiure vs. time) increases the J
temperature alter the one hour point for a durabon of wwd,r '; 10 hours1.157407e-4 days <br />0.00278 hours <br />1.653439e-5 weeks <br />3.805e-6 months <br />.
l 2.1 Medmum DBA Temperature Evaluation:
j in the evalumbon, the QusMcahon data for PBNP was revowed for each of the potentiaNy
[
impacted EQ equipment to determne if the QusMcahon data envelopes the new l
requrement for Maximum postulated DBA Temperature PBNP is requred b meet the EQ requrements of 10CFR50.49 and DOR Guidelines Thus Maxrnum DBA Temperature is met when the Test Data Maximum exceeds the i
!=* dated Maximum DBA Temperature. Temperature Mergin is the deerence between the postulated Maamum DBA Temperature and the documented quaMed Temperature 1
4j.
==
Conclusion:==
i AN EQ equipment requred to be reviewed due to changes in the DBA Temperature as a result of TSCR 192 at Point Beach Units 1 and 2, has been evaluated aganst the new.
DBA requirement. The onipnal quaMcabon, has been enhanced with new EQ reports, and has been shown to exceed the new DBA requirement. Thus, there is no impact on the Point Basch EQ program due to TSCR 192 and al EQ equipment is quaMed to the new l
DBATemperature
]
Each of potenbaly impacted EQ equipment was found to be not impacted by the change i
to r=*w Maximum DBA Tempensture Table 2. Madmum DBA Temperature Evaluation.
j i
Evalumon New Queused Margin ("F) hem Desedpilon ap asm No.
Possuished Manknum Test Report dea Tempommme 1
Itamimum
('F) l Tempemene l
M 1
2eo 340 80 EiseumiPeneeston PEMtLK-3 l
Asewnbay 1601 i
j 1
f i
are ansare==== me.
7' 4
1
. ~
I i,
ME PONP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION i
h New Queblied Margin (T)
Item Desortpdon ap j
lhem No.
Postulated tendrman Test Report 09A Tangerature l
tiedmum (7)
Temperature PF) l i
2 200 341 61 Rocitestne FhemeINI N 0146 j
XLPE Calde (Analysis of
{
Test Reporte 5004 & 5006) 1 4
3 200 445 166 Cena Eischkal Cona IPS.
l Pensteban Assemtdy and 1420 Penstaban Splices i.
4 200 432 152 Conex RTDs and Conex M j
Thumocogies 875 l
1
?
3 j
5 200 432 143 ConexRTDs ConexNT.
7es i
6 200 442 162 MCSF N Spilone WWe 58442-1 1
4 7
200 324 44 Fan Cooler Motor, yg i
Thermaleste Epoxy Insulebon, spice and I
hent8nie 4
l.
8 200 400 180 Gemme.Mstncs Neutron Report No. 010 Fhm Montonrg System i
s 2s0 315 as umamque vow Aaustwo ummarque l
Report 80068 a
10 200 340 00 Marte HTKInouisand FR Marte W12/90 4
j h Coldo Report i
4 h
.locketed Oetne Report a
l GLS Erlierprises, bac.
L s
1 Y
f
.i.S_d2.4L.,.442.4-ah-44mi+4.'.
MJ.JAA-
-des *A4-.
A
.a4_,4.aAe
,J
-Eea med.W Js..iJa.4 Ja_4_.uw.m.g.m5.44 mue+ 3 -
.J.e.e-..b,4.**h-m ade.u a. u
.e..
,,sy,4.A J.4s
.hg, s,.
-.4m 3.um g,s.
,em.ee-,,e, e
e WE PONP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATM)N 1
f tem No.
Postulated IAudmum Test Report
=
dea Tempersewo temdman (T)
Tempestse i
N
{
11
!!AD 370 00 Nemon EA-180 Ltnt Nunco Report 8.tches No.106 1
i l
12 200 372 86 Namco EA 100 Umt Namco Report s.wme No. is 13 2o0 430 1s0 CrosnyLaindemens seech Creeny Repat AssemMy 4 ass 14 200 420 140 Feeboro fHE 10 Series Wyle Report Pmesure Transmeers 456024 15 200 412 132 Trennemenos Doisval Wyle Report Game LevelTragemmer 45700 2 16 200 360 70 EinecelConducsor Seal Conex IPS.
AssemNes 400 17 200 340 00 LeonVeem Connedor and loomedk Nov Amencen Bos Flex condut 70 18 200 305 106 Target Rock Model 77CC.
Target Rock 001 Solenoid Velve Report No.
2375 19 200 310 30 Hydrogen Montoring Emo Sensor system Report EXO-QTR-101 20 200 306 26 CEC Poseure Transducer Emo4ensor andTayce RTD Report EXO-QTR-119 4
GIA RNTEAPABBC,MC.
9
e i
i WE PONP TSCR 102 EQ EVALLMTION i
Ewelustion New QueNAed
{ Hargin (T)
Item Descripeon aW leem No.
Postulated Meannum Tat Repost i
l DBA Temperekse Mammmen rF) i Temperature M
i 21 200 416 136 LaonVeemThennoomete NTS Report Connecente 568 1664 9
22 200 306 106 Anaconde Cable Frenidin Report F.
4 C49691 23 200 385 106 Anaconde Flame Guard Frenidn FR4P insbument. Control Report F-i Cable C4836-2 24 200 365 66 Roychem NudoorGrade Wyle Report Cable SpP.as 1785642P 25 200 341 61 P-Fuenelill Ph ChemumsyCreep Lhted Report 5804 re,ci. Cabies 25A 200 342 62 Rodbestos Flowed 111 Pm Imdaten Cross Linked Report 5005 Polyethylene Cables 26 200 450 170 ASCO NP-1 Solenosd ASCO Report Velves AQR47368 27 200 346 06 RockbeMos CamdeiCable Ph Report QR-6e02 28 200 300 20 Rorne Cable Report 3/19771end new Wyle reporte 17740-1,17432-1 and 6110 29 200 450 170 RosemountTrenomater Rosemount Model 1154 Report MS Ersterprises, hac.
10
1 WE PSNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION Em New QueNAed Mergin m llem Descrip6on AM f
i tem No.
Poehdeted timelmum Test Report OsA Temporesure 1
IAmesmann m
Temperesure M
D6400102 29A 200 420 140 Rosemourt Model1154 af Rosemount 1150 Remote Seal Report 7/23A12 1
I 298 200 446 1M RosemountTronometer Rosemount CondutConnectorSeal Report Model363C D8300200
?
30 200 1800 1420 ince.s Thermosospies ISA MC96.1 1975 i
31 200 320 40 General Atomic Mgh Range General Reduton Montor RD23 Atome Report E 254060
=
32 280 420 180 Gamme44eents Neutnm Gemme-Montonng System Cable Metnce Repcvt i
i 33 2e0 347 67
. _ s = Penetronone wesenshoue.
Report PEN-
}.
m-na 34 200 307 27 Lkneorque MOVs
- E dd ReportWCAP-i i
741 R 36 280 307 27 MOVLutwicent
'. _ _1 ga ReportWCAP-741 R A,
l 36 200 296 16 Engineemd W h
." ___ sm
^
Cables and Sp6ces ReportWCAP-741%, Vol.11 i
37 280 324 44 Contenment Acadent Fen
. __14 eme t-Motor Beenne Lubncent Report WCAP-1 7722 i
QL3 RN73RPRBR8n EM'=*
11
^
i o.
i WE PeNP TSCR 182 EQ EVALUATION i
auhmalen New QuesAnd temgin M hun Descripeon AW j
nun No.
Peendeled 80sehnum Test Report DBA Temperahme aamdmum t'F)
Temporutse t'P) i as 200 324 44 Conlanment Anddent Fan Wesunghouse Ladulcant Report WCAP.
7722 i
se 2eo ses es okonae Catde Franken Report F-i 2.2 RAnximum DBA Pressure Evaluation:
4 j
in the evaluston, the Qualdicabon data for PBNP was rumswed for each of the p@ntially W EQ equipment to determine if the Qualdicabon data envelopes the mm requirement for Maximum paah w DBA Pressure i
PBNP is requred to meet the EQ requrements of 10CFR50A9 and DOR Guidehnes Thus Maxmum DBA Pressure is met when the Test Data for Maximum Pressure exceeds
{
the rashw Maximum DBA Pressure. Pressure Margin is the dWorence between the l
paah w Maomum DBA Pressure and the documented qualdledPressure i
j
==
Conclusion:==
AN EQ equipment requwed to be reviewed due to dumges in the DBA pressure as a result of TSCR 192, at Point Beach Units 1 and 2, has teen evalushed against the new DBA j
requrement. The original qualdicebon, has boon enhanced with new EQ reports, and has been shown to exceed the new DBA requrement. Thus, there is no impact on the Point
{
Beach EQ program due to TSCR 192 and al EQ equipment is qualdled to the new DBA i
pressure
?
i Each of potenbally impacted EQ equipment was found to be not impacted by the change to paahw Maxrnum DBA Pressure.
Table 3. Maximum DBA Pressure Evaluation.
Evaluamon New Postuteted Quenned Itergin hem Descripton A W Test tem No.
dea RAndmum Ilmtnum tpoig)
Report PressureiPois)
Pmesure (Polo)
}
1 53.5 e0 s.5 ElectricaiPeneeston PEMRLK-3-1641 Ff 12 1
1 p
,,_,.r
. ~. _
- - - =... - -
... ~.. _ _...,
4 o
e WE PONP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION J
Evehanon New Postulated QueEAnd temgin hem Descripalon Appuceble Test hem No.
DBA Maulmum Maulmum (poig)
Report a
Pressum(Peig)
Pressum l
trew 2
53.5 107 53.5 FireweililXLPE Cable M41055(Analyes of Test Reporte 5804 &
5805) 3 53.5 to 28.5 Conax Eindmal Conan IPS-1420 j
PenstehenAsservedyand Peneousen spense i
{
4 53.5 70 16.5 Conor RTDs and Conex IPS 875 Thermocouldes i
a i
5 53.5 70 16.5 Conex prde Conax IPS-798 6
$3.5 OS 12.5 WCSF N Spiese Wyle 58442-1 j
7 53.5 80 26.5 Fan Cooler hkdor, W 7829 j
ThermalmebeEpony insutomon, space and hencenia 8
53.5 70 16.5 Neuten Fket Montomg Report No. 010 system 9
53.5 81 27.5 Lkneongue Velve Accumors Umtorque Report e0058 10
$3.5 105 51.5 Morte HTKinnuieted FR Karte 9/12/00 Report
.lassend Cabis 10A 53.5 105(Noes 2) 51.5 Karte FRinsuieted FR Norte 9/12/90 Report
.inessed Come 13
.._..___-._m..
l e
a 4
5 WE PONPTSCR 192 EQ EVALLMTION Eweiuollon New Posedstad Quetted tiergin learn Desertplion Appucetdo Test i
Item No.
DSAtienknum tienimwn (poig)
Report Pneeum(Pole)
Puseue (Pain) 11 53.5 76.4 22.9 Namco EA 180 Lknit Namco Report No.
Setese 105 12 83.5 76.4 22.9 Namco EA 180 Uma Namco Report No.
Seemes 155 13 53.5 72 18.5 Cmeby Lutindumen0 Crosby Report 4245 SelleAssemedy i
4 14 53.5 90 31.5 Foxboro NE 10 Series Wyle Raport45502 4 3
J Pneeum Trenemators l
1 15 53.5 70 16.5 Trennemarim Doisval Wyle Report 45700-2 Gems LevelTrenemator i
i 16 53.5 100 126.5 EindriceiConductor Seal ConexIPS400 Assemtdes i
a 4
17 53.5 105 51.5 LatonVeem Connedor and loomeder Nov 78 Amenen Bos Flex condut 4
i is 53.5 es 12.5 Tervet Rom uodeinCc.
Target Rom Report J
001 SolencalVelve No. 2375 i
~
19 53.5 67 13.5 Hydmgen Montoring EmSensor Report System EXO QTR-101 20 53.5 58 4.5 CEC Pressure Transducer Exo-Sensor Report and Teyco RTD EXOCTR-119 N
u
_ _ _...... _. _... _. _., _ _. _ _.. ~ - _ _.. _ _.
WE PONP TSCR 102 E3 EVALUATION Evolustion New Posedated QueNRed Margin hem Descripuen A M Test tem No.
DBA Masimum Masimum (peig)
Report Preenwo(Pois)
Pmesure i
(Pals) i j
21 53.5 88 12.5 Lann VeemThermosospio NTS Report 5661654 Connectors e
i 22 53.5 OB 12.5 AnacorukCable FrenMn Report F-C40061 1
l 23 83.5 06 12.5 Anaconde Piems4used Free Report F.
)
FR-EPinstrwnent, Contal C4836 2 1
24 53.5 58 4.5 Roychem Nudeer Grade Wylelieport 17859--
j Ceine sonnes cap I
25 53.5 107 53.5 Ph Fbewel111 Rodibestos Report ChemmeSy Croce Unhed 5004 j
Polyethylene Cables 1
4 25A 53.5 107 53.5 Rodsbestos Fbewel111 Rectibestos Report i
irredemon Crose unked SeOS l
Polyethylene Cables
}
l 26 53.5 78 24.5 ASCO NP-1 Scionod ASCO Report AQR-i Velvee 67368 i
)
?
i l
27 53.5 122 68.5 Ph Condel Cabis Ph Report QR4002 l
26 53.5 58 4.5 Rome Cable Report 3/19f71ond new Wyle ropode 177401,17432-1 and 6110 29 53.5 110 56.5 RosemountTrenommer Rosemourt Report Mor8el1154 D6400102 eMA RNTEEPEEEn, DC.
15
.~
4 4
l WE PONP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION Evehandon NewPesadmind Quented tiergin tem Demostpuen Appuceble Test Item No.
05AIAeshmen RAembmen Quig)
Report 3
Pieseum(Pois)
Puseme 1
(Pola) f 29A 53.5 110 56.5 RosemourtModel1154 m/
Rosemount Report 4
1190 Remote Seal 7/D92 1
298 53.5 110 l 56.5 RosemountTransmilar Rosemount Report j
Conduit ConnectorSeal D8300200 j.
Modsi363C 30 53.5 Note 1.
Note 1.
IncomThommoogles 13A MC96.11975
)
i
~
31 53.5 78 24.5 General Atmc High GeneralAtome j
Range Ret.ietion Montor Report E 254 000 i
RD 23 i
f I
32 53.5 70 16.5 Gensne44elns Cable Gemme Metrts l
Report 040 l
i i
33 53.5 108 54.5 Weemghouse Penseelpns Westmghouse Report l
PEN TR-7740 i
4 4
i I
l 3
i 34 53.5 40 6.5 Urrdtorque MOVs Westmghouse Report WCAP-7410.L i
35 53.5 00 6.5 MOV Lutetent Wesenghouse Report WCAP-7410 L 1
36 53.5 00 6.5 Enlpnoemd W
/ me Report i
Features CeNes and WCAP-7410 L Vol H Spilose 37 53.5 60 6.5 Contomment Acament Fan Wesenghouse Report Motor Bearing L2rtant WCAP-7722 i.
38 53.5 00 6.5 Coreanment Aoddent Fan
/ _ __ G~as Report L2rtoont WCAP.7722 i.
}
j GLS L ar _:_, bac.
se-1 N
a
. _ _-. _ ~ _... _ _ _ _. _. _ _. _. _ _ _ _ _ _ _. _ _ _ _. _. _. _ _... _ _ _ _ _ _ _.
l 4
f WE PeNP TsCR 1s2 EQ EVALUATION a
Evolusson NewPosedstad Quenced Iterein hem Descripeon a MTest r
j hem No.
DBAtteshman temdman (poig)
Report Passes (Pete)
Passes b
l 3e 53.5 115 61.5 Diente cabis Frankin Report F.
caem l
Note 1. For item 30. A six inch portion of the ;; mwwuple cable extends above the j
reactor veneel head. This stamises steel sheathed, rnineral insulated the via cable is designed for the incore armronment (1800*F and 2500 psig) and routinely operates at 600*F and 2000psig The portion of the thermocouple cable exposed to the containment 4
i almosphere is unaNacted by the small ncrears in contenment pressure (0.5 psig) postuished in TSCR ig2.
l Note 2. Kerite FR Malenal was tested as a jacket to 105 psig in a one hundred day test j
and as an insulation to 52 poig in a 25 day test.
i t
i l
2.3 DBA Temperature Profile Evaluation:
In the evalumbon, the Qualificebon data for PBNP was reviewed for each of the potenbally i
rnpoeted EQ equipment to determne if the Qualdicabon data envelopes the new requrement for the now f=* w DBA Temperature Prollie j
PBNP is requred to most the EQ requirements of 10CFR50 9 and DOR Guidehnes j
Thus DBA Temperature Profile is met when the Test Profile envelopes the peak j
condsbons, which was documented above and when the degradabon caused by the test proflie was more severe than the equwalent degradabon of the new postulated DBA Temperature Profile. Thus this sechon addresses the Degradabon Equwalency of the new l
DBA Temperature Prollie to the documented proflie in the PBNP EQ program.
4 l
Degradabon Equivalency is performed in two methods : y.,42.1 and analyncal Frst, each item's EQ testproflie is graphed on the same chart as the new postulated DBA l
Proflie The Degiadabon Equwalency is acceptable when the cumulative time at temperature of the EQ test prollie is above the new postulated DBA Proflie once maximum temperature condstons have boon met.
if a porbon of the cunulabve time at temperature of the EQ tesi profile is below the new i
postulated DBA Profile afler the peak test conditions have been n et, then it is rww. mary j
to miwtyikey compare the area under the new [=*W DBA Prof 4 to the conservabsm j
where the test proflie exceeds the new postulated DBA Prolife to verify that the Degradabon caused dunng the time under the new postulated DBA Profile is less severe l
than *he Degradsbon causW by the area of the test proflie dist avraarie the new 3
postulated DBA Profile i
i Degradabon Equiva'ency is an scapa rnetnod for demonstratng the equwalence of i
DBA profiles and is accorable since it is a method whch utilizes 10CFR50.49 j
Qualdicebon Method (f) (2) Toshng c sanitor item of equipment with a supporting analysis to show that the eq#,41ent to be qualified is acceptable,' and / or 10CFR50.49 1
{
Qualificebon Method (f) (4)
- Analysis in wist6sisv6 with partial type test data that supports i
oss smzaramas, me.
l 17 2
s.
l wE PeNP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION i
the si-4/M assumptons and conciumons* Smler partial test data per 10CFR50.49 paragraph (f)(4)has been used.
For most equipment in this evalumbon at PBNP, the graphical method of Degradabon i
Equivalency demonstrates that the new paahw DBA Pronie is within the already j
estabished EQ program at PBNP.
J j_
Only two W h, h Delaval Gertu Level Tre and the Rome Cable required the supplemental Degradsbon Equrvalency Analysis. This analyms showed that 1
i the degradsbon caused dunng the time under the new paahw DBA Prone is has severe than the degnadsbon caused by the area of the test p Ullie that avanaria the new paahw DBA Prollie, by a margin of over 60% for the Deisval Gems Level Transmitter and by a margin of over 130%, for the Rome Cable For these equipment items Post -
3 Accident Operability was also reviewed to assure that long term post DBA was not affected 4
l
==
Conclusion:==
AH EQ equipment required to be reviewed due to changes in the DBA proflie as a result of.
l TSCR 192, at Point Beach Units 1 and 2, has been evaluated agenst the new DBA requwement. The onginal qualincahon, has been enhanced with new EQ reports, and has been shown to emmed the new DBA requiremeest Thus, there is no impact on the Point Beach EQ program due to TSCR 192 and all EQ equpnent is qualded to the new DBA prone The Table 4, summenzos the evaluabon of ttw now paah dam DBA Pronie at PBNP.
Table 4. Evaluation of new f-hd.e.,e DBA Proflie at PSNP.
avukanon poyodemon hem Descrapson aeTest neport tem No.
Equivalency asenhed 1
Graphcal Elec*tosiPensenton Aasently PEN 4tLK 3-1641 2
GrapNcal Fbewel m XLPE Cable 401055(Analyes at Test Reporte 5804 & 5805) 3 Graphced Conex EleancelPeneirebon ConezIPS 1420 AssameWyand Peneeston speone 4
Graphumi Conax RTDs and ConorIPS475 Therma-e WA Eraserprises, Inc.
1s
.._._._._____._.___._..m_.
i A
INE PSNP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION 1
I i
f h
Degradation hem Descutpean aMTest Report bem No.
Equhalant,y asalhed j
5 Graphkal Conas R1De Conex IPS-798 l
l i
i 6
Graphool WCSF N Spices Wyle 68442-1 1
i k
4 1
2 1
i 7
Graphual Fan Cooler Motor.Thermelsele W 7829 Epoxy inemen,aptoe and 4
j' lututeenes i
[
8 Grupnual Neuben Fhet Monsonng Report k 010 syneem i
l 9
Graphcel Limeonque Vehe Adusters Lrntorque Report B0068 2
1 1
1 10 Graphcol Keres HTKinsulated FR Karas W1240 Report L
Jeokseed Catdo iM Grghcol M FR M FR h W12/M Report 4
Jessend Cahie i
l 11 Graphcel Nemoo EM80 Lime Swames Nemoo Report No.105 I
j 12 Graphced Nwnoo EA 180 LMt Swames Namco Report No.156 i
13 GrapNeal Crosby Laindesmo Swech Crosby Report 4245 Aseema4 i
i l
14 GrapNced Fauboro N410 Sense Wyle Report 45602-4 Pressure Trenommes 2
m 1
19 4
f r
6 o
. ~.
.i i
WE PSNP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION Ewiustion Degredagen item Description afi** Test Report Ilom No.
";n. j Insthod j
15 GrapNceiand Transemortce DetevelGame Wyle Report 457042 Analytcel Lmet Transmaler 4
16 Graphical ElecincelConductorSeed ConesIPS 400 Assentine j
i 4
17 GrepNcal LJean Veem Connectorand loomsda Nov 78 Amencen Boe Flex condut i
j 18 GrapNcal Target Rod Model77CC 001 Target Rock Report No.
]
Scienoid Velve 2375
.i 19 GrapNeal Hydrogen Montonng System Exo4ensor Report EXO.
4 QTR-101 0
20 GropNml CEC Pressure Transducer and Exo4ensor Report EXO.
j Teyco RTD QTR-119 21 GrapNcal deon VeemThermocouple NTS Report 558-1654 i
Connecnors I
22 Graphced Anaconde Cable Frankin Report F C49691 23 Graphael Anaconde Flameouard FREP Frenidin Report F C48362 instwnent.Corect Cable Sptme i
i ao 4
... ~ _ _..
l WE PONP TSCR 102 EQ EVALUATION Evmiustion Depademon mem osecropson Appuostdo TestRepost
- nom he.
squivalency asenhed i
)
1 25 Graphael Rochbesene Remas M Rosbestos Report $804 Chemiamey Case unhed j
Polysehylene Catene l
25A GrupNoel Roemessos neues M N Reportseos kvedisson Crose LHed Palvelhylene Catdes 4
28 Gmpmael ASCO NP 1 Solenoid Velves ASCO Report AQR47368 27 Gephcal Roebenene CommelCatdo N Report QR-6802 28 Graphtmland Rome Cable ReportStiertiend new Analyecal wyie reporte 17740,1, 17432-1 and f110 29 GrapNoel RosemountTrenemator Model Rosemount Report 1154 D6400102 21W GrapNcel 4tonomount Model1154 af Rosemourt Report 74W92 115e Ramose seal 208 GrupNeal RosemountTrenemalerCondut Rosemount Report Connecaer seal Madeias3C Desco200 30 Graphced kuore Thermocogies ISA MC96.1-1975 31 Graphical General Atomic High Range General Ahmc Report E-Redamon Monsor RD 23 256400 GES ANTEAPAJESB, st:.
21
.-. ~.- - -..
.__ ~..
4 WE PeNP TSCR 192 EQ EVALUATION 4
2 4
Evolustion Degradstion lism Descripton Applicatdo Test Report hem No.
Equhelency atalhed
{
32 Graphumi GemmeMcDice Calde GammeMemos Report 040 i
?-
33 Graphual Weetnghouse Penstmeone Washghouse Report PEN.
j TR 77-ee 34 Grephumi Liredsonius MOVE Wesunghouse Report WCAP-74104.
i 36 Graphcol MOVLahricant Wesenghouse Report WCAP-74104.
i 36 Graphical EngemJd Safety Featums
/ J_ sm Report Caldne and Spions -
WCAP-74104,Vol N I
37 Graphcal Conlanment Acadent Fan Wesanghouse Report Motor Beerme Lutztoont WCAF 7722 1
i Contamment Acadent Fan
! -_16 no Report 3g g,,,g,,,
i 1.aencent WCAP-7722 4
i 39 Grephumi Ciente Caldo Frenidn Report F C3094 j
i i
i, f
2A PBNP EQ Program Enhancement:
In the evaluabon, the additional QusMcabon reports for smier cable to the Rorne cable were located and are being irwpe; d into the PBNP EQ program.
e Wyle Report 17740-1 m Wyle Report 17732-1 a Wyle Report 6110 M B L :,..,.:-^^ bec.
2" e
WE PeNP T8CR 192 E3 EVALUATION Attachments i
- 1) Prollie Graphs hem 1, 3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,10A,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20, j
21,22,23,24,25,25A,26,27,28,29,29A,298,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39
- 2) Degradsbon Equwalency for Transamence Delaval Gems Level Transmeer Wyle i
Report 45700-2, Pages A8.A10
- 3) Degradabon Equivalency for Rome Cable Wyio Report 17740-1Pages C8 C11 1
4 h
i e
i i
I l
i i
l a
4 I
i i
(
i l
I 1
GLS EAFFEAPARES, DdC.
23
_ _. =..
Iten11.
PBNP-DBA-T-W-Can-PEN-RLK-31601 PBNP-DBA Temperature
'*c_
[
300 t
iI E
200 1
- +--Temperstwo (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP) g 150-
--G- 'l- - _.! _ - - "MNJtiX-3 6-01 100-50 I
~_
0 00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr}
PBNP Ten,pciatore Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equidancy Method Qualified Temperature (F) 340 i
Met Yes Graphical Margin 21A%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluaton
Item 3.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Conax PentPS-1420 PBNP-DBA Temperature l
l f
3 t
I 300 i
g 1 -Temperstwo (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS d at 1 hr)(SGRP) 200
[
-e-Conex Elsetcal Penetration and F
Penetrabon Spews OPS-1420) 150 100 50 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 445.00 Met Yes Graphical Margin 58.90 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
?
C item 4.
PBNP_DBA-Temp ConaxRTD (IPS875)
PBNP-DBA Temperature
-~
ec 400-3 1
300 E
^
g 15.-
a
- +--Tergerature (2 CFCs @ 75% 1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP) 200 g
-m-Conax RTD (IPS-875) 150 100 50 t
0 0.00001 0 0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 432 Met Yes Graphical Margin 54.4 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
O ltem 5.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Conax RTD(IPS798)
P8MP-DBA Temperature 50 400 -
3 I
L
-s 300 E
l6--
E 0^~
g
--+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP) 200 g Conor RTD (IPS-798)
/
i.;
100 50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
260 l Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 432 p
Met Yes Graphical Margin 54.4 %
V.E P9NP-T/S-192 EQ Evaluation
1 l'
i O
! eC 1,
57
)
1 G
2 4
s 4
C 8
F) 5 C P
(
R o
2(G c
E eS p
r (
u)
S r
tah m
re1 e
pt hc me y
ef o
f To R
0 do 0
h t
0 e
0 M
1 ycn
)
1 le l
a a
-2 0
v ihc 4
e 0
4 1
iu r
8 u
q p
t a
5 a
E r
(
r m
e n
G o
e p
h m
i ta c
0 d
y e
a T
1, a
r R
A i
I V
D g
i 1
I e
p B
m D-e T
P 02s%
N 1
A B
0 0
0 0
84 e9 B
P
~.
40 0
5 0
24Y7 2
1 1
D 5
-P
)
M r
B H
(
1
)
P e
F 0
m
(
i t
T ne m
^
e
^
r 1
^
iuF
)
0 0
q(
e e Rr u et r a ur 1
t e
0 ap r
0 em n
0 pe o
mT i
ta ed u
Te l
l in a
i v
Pi f 1
00 Nat g E
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM Q
E 29 1
1 00 R
00 C
0 ST PN 6.
BP m
e EW t
I
[
i j
('
l S
C
-r o 9) 1 o2 t
5 M7 8
7 r-eP 9
loa oC e
C CW F) r(
C P et R
Fn 2
e (G
ec eS si w
ut r (
u) ou t r hL ah g-re1 n
pt ee me sc e a en p
To Ws 0
0 d
0 o
0 h
e 1
t M
y s
c r
n o
t 0
le l
o 0
a a
v ic M
e i
h 1
r u
u p
C t
q a
a E
r n
r a
e n
G F
p io m
t t
0 a
s e
1 d
e T
a W
r A
g
-p B
e m
D D
e
-P T-N s%
A B.
1 04 0
0 0
0 82 e7 B
P.
0 5
0 5
23Y5 D
2 1
1 1
PNB
)r H
P
)
1.(e F
0
(
m i
t T
ne me r
iuF
)
1 0
q(
0 e e Rr u et r a ur t
e ap r
0 em n
1 0
pe o
0 mT i
ta ed u
Te l
Pii n
a f
l i
v Nat g E
r Buea 1
PQMM Q
000 E
0 29 1
RC 1
0 S
00 T
0 0
P E
N 7
B m
P-e E
t W
I
O v
Item 8.
PBNP-DBA -Temp GM Monitor (010) k PBNP-DBA Temperature 5^^
450 400-
-n E
~'
g 1
-+-Tanperstwo (2 CFCs @ 75% 1 CS I
os et 1 tw)(SGRP)
,00 r
Monitor (010) 150 100 50
^
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Thne (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 460 Met Yes Graphical Margin 64.3 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation l
O.
8 1
5 2
0
( % )r 0
e h
B r 5 C
u71 e
ta ux e@t t
r a
qd mCo" to n psW r
e eFS smp p
TCCI UA 0
i 000 1
00 1
d o
8 0
h 5
1 t
0 e
0 M
B y
e c
u n
e la q
[
o la ihc v
it iu p
1 WT4 q
a L
0 0
0 0
0 g
E r
5 0
5 0
5 r
)
G 2
t 1
T-e H
n
(
o r
A u
e it B
t m
a a
r i
d D
T a
e r
P p
g N
m 1
e 0
B
- e D
P T
AB 00 s 81 e D
23Y
-PN 1
B 0
0 P
)
.T F(
t ne m
1 0
e r
0 i )
0 uF q
n e (e io Rr t
u a
et u
r a la ure v
tap E
1 r
00 em Q
0 pe 0
mT E
ed 2
Te 9
i n
1 Pf N i ig R
lat r B uea C
1 0
PQMM S
0 T-0 0
P 0
N 9
m E 1!"
B P-e E
t W
I
Item 10.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Kerite (9-12-80) i PBNP-DBA Temperature 350
.300
- ^
g 1 Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS 200 off at i hr)(SGRP) g
--G--Kette HTKER Catdo (912-80) p 150-100 50 -
0 0 00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 10000 Thne (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 340 Met Yes Graphical Margin 21.4 %
l WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 10A.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Kerne FRFR_91280 m
o
-o m PBNP-DBA Temperature T
E i
=
^
-4
+Tergerature (2 CFCs O 75%,1 CS I
200 -
off at 1 hr)(SGRP) g
-G-Kerte FRtFR Cable (9-12-80) g 150 100 50 -
a 0.0%)1 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 i
Tkne (HQ i
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 300 Met Yes Graphical Margin 7.1%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
O Item 11.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Namco (QTR105)
L q
PBNP-DBA Temperature
=
11 350 l l 'b i 300 ll 6
^^
^
E I
-$-- Temperature (2 CFCs O 75%,1 CS 200
=
off at 1 tw)(SGRP) g
-G--Nemco Limit Switch (QTR 105) g 150 10t 50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0 001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 370 Met Yes Gra >hical Margin 32.1 %
i WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation I
Item 12.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Namco (QTR-155)
PBNP-DBA Temperature P
350 1I 300-
^ ^ -
'O q:
E
--+-Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS 200
- b
=
o# st 1 hr)(SGRP) g
--G-Namco Umit Suritch (QTR 155) g 150 100 L
50 t
0 00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
__ _._]
P8NP Teirperature Requirement (F):
280 lDegradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 372 Met Yes Graphical Margin 32.9%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 13.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Crosby LISA(4245)
PBNP-DBA Temperature Me i
P i i 10 0 g
- ^
+ Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at I hr)(SGRP)
-G-Crosby USA (4245) l 150 100-50 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0 01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
P8NP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 430 Met Yes Graphical i
Margin 53.6 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EO Evaluation
Item 14.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Foxboro(45592-4)
PBNP-DBA Temperature 15e ll 1
i: 50 300
^ '
~
+ Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%.1 CS
[
off at 1 hr)(SGRP) a 200 I
--G-Foxboro Pressure Transmitter (45592-4) 150 100 50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Tinw (H4 PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 420 Met Yes Graphical Margin 50.0 %
WE-P8NP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
O Item 15.
DBA-PONP-TemM_(45700-2)
PBNP-DBA Temperature 15e L
400 1
1 i I
n-E
[.
-+--Tempershwe (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 200 CS off et 1 hr)(SGRP) 150
--G-Transamerice Delovel Gems Level Transmitters (45700-2) 100 50 0
0.00001 0.0001 0 001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 412 Met Yes Analytical Margin 47.1 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
m O
ltem 16.
L PBNP-ORA Temperature
=
un i
300-1
- =
==
E
+Temperehee(2 CFCs G 75%,1 CS 200-off et 1 hr)(SGRP) Canax Electrical Conductor Seat
,50 100-50 -
0 0.00001 0 0001 0.001 0.0f 0.1 1
10 100 1000 10000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 348.00 Met Yes Graphical Margin 24.3 %
1 WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation I
Item 17.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Veam_Isomedix1178 r
PBNP-DBA Temperature
=
~
P l
300 -
I l
l t
--+-Tempereswo (2 CFCs G 75%,1 CS e5 et 1 hr)(SGRP) l
/
150-
- e-Veem, American Doe Connector and e-Flen Conduit Geomedk Nov 78) l 100 -
50 -
h 0.00001 0.0001 0 001 0.01 0.1 1
JO 100 1000 Time (H4 6
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
283 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 340 j
Met Yes Graphical Margin 21.4 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation t
t
~. _ _
._.._..~.
l Item 18.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Target Rock SOV i
i PBNP OBA Temperature I
=
l 450-
[
l
{
-s E
3"-
+Temporudure (2 CFCs 9 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
-4 Target Rock SOV 77CC-001(2375) 150-100 -
50 -
i 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 i
Time p*)
i PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 385 Met Yes Graphical Margin 37.5%
L 1
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation l
i
O ltem 19.
PBNP-DBA-Temp EXO (QTR-101)
PBNP-DBA Temperature m
350 5
s 1 Ternperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS 200-c#st 1 hr)(SORP) g EXO Sensor H2 Monlior(EXO_QTR-p 150 -
101) 100 50
^
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 10000 Tiene (Hr)
L PBNP Teirperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 310 Met Yes Graphical Margin 10.7 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluabon
~
O item 20.
PBNP-DBA-Temp Tayco(ExoQTR119) l PBNP-DBA Temperature C
~
200
-+-Tempersewo (2 CFCs @ 75%.1 CS oW st 1 hr)(SGRP) 150
-G-CEC Presswo Transducer & Teyco l
RTD of Exo Sensor H2 MonNor k
(EXOCTR-119) 100 L
50 l
e 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 10000 Tkne(Hr)
PBNP Tenpmatore Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 306 Met Yes Graphical i
Margin 9.3%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
}
r S
o e
C te m
1 e
5 C
7 e
e 9
pu) s c4 c5 C
o9 F) m1 P
C r
R e8 2(G h55 eS T(
ms r (
u) t r e e ah ed re1 vin pt n e r
me as ef ms f
To tA 0
do 0
h t
00 e
M 1
ycn y
e l
s a
la s
0 A
e 0
iv ic r
h u
u p
1
.n t
q a
o a
E r
C e
n G
r p
o m
m i
ta a
e 0
d e
T 1,
a V
r A
g
-p B
e m
D D
e T-P A
N 1
05s%
B B
81 e2 0
0
= "
0 0
0 0
24Y8 D
P 5
0 0
5 0
5 4
4 3
2 1
1 4
PN 1
)r B
1 H
P 1
)
(
e 0
F m
(
T n
i t
e me
^
r
^
1 iu F) 2 0
0 q(
e e Rr u et r a ur t
e 1
0 ap
^
r 0
em n
0 pe o
mT it a
ed lu Te 0
l in a
i v
Pi f 1
0 Nat g E
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM Q
E 29 1
1 00 R
00 C
O ST E
-PN 1
2 BP m
e EW t
I
SC 1
)
1 5
7 98 94 s
C C
F)
F-C P
(
R e
2(G N
eS a
s(
C h )r a
sh d
rei n
pt oc ma a
e5 n
Tc A 0
do 0
h 0
t 0
e M
1 yc
)
n 1
e l
l a
9 a
9 r
0 v
ic 6
e 0
h i
~
4 u
1 u
p
(
t q
a a
a r
E r
d e
n G
-i p
o i
u m
it c
a 1
a e
0 d
n T
1 a
A A
rg
-p B
e m
D D
e P
T-N s%
A B
1 05 B
P
=.
m 0
0 0
0 0
88 e5 0
0 5
0 5
23Y7
. i 2
1 1
D P
3 N
M B
F P
1 F) e 0
n
(
k t
T ne m
e 1
r iuF
)
0 0
q(
e e Rr u et r a ure 1
t 0
ap r
0 em n
0 pe mT io ta ed u
Te l
i n
a Pi v
f 10 l
i 0
Nat g E
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM Q
E 29 1
1 00 R
00 C
0 S
T-P 2
N 2
B m
P e
E t
I W
ltem 23.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Anaconda (4836-2)
PBNP-DBA Temperature r
350-3 n
E
-+-Te;W (2 CFCs 9 75%,1 CS 200 errat 1 hr)(SGRP)
' -Anaconda Cable (F-C4836-2) s-
+
150-i 100-50 -
0.00001 0.0001 0 001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Tkne (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 385 Met Yes Graphical Margin 37.5 %
i WE - PBNP-TSCR 192-EQ Evaluation l
t I
SC 1
5 7
d w
s ua C
7 F) 1 C P
(
R e
2(G c
I eS p
r (
u)
S t r ah m
re1 e
pt h
c ma y
ef a
f To R
0 do h
t 0
e 0
M 0
1 yc
)P ne 2
l l
9 a
a v
ic 5
e 0
i h
8 r
0 u
7 u
1 p
t q
a 1
a E
r
(
r m
e n
G e
p o
h m
it c
a y
e 0
d a
T
{
a r
R A
_I-g
-p B
eD m
D e
T PN s%
1 05 A
B 86e4 B
P
=
0 0
0 0
0 0
5 0
0 5
0 5
23Y0 D
3 3
2 1
1 3
PN
)r B
H 1
F)
(
P 0
en
(
k t
T ne m
g e
r 1
)
0 iuF 0
q(
e e Rr u et r a ur t e 10 ap r
0 em n
0 pe io mT ta ed u
Te l
C li in a
i Pf v
1 0
Nat g E
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM Q
E 29 1
1 00 R
00 C
0 S
Eg T-P 4
N 2
B m
P e
E t
W I
Item 25.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Rockbestos(5804)
PBNP-DBA Tempersiure C
300 -
-s
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs 9 75%,1 CS off et 1 hr)(SGRP) 150
-G-Rocieselce CherricoBy CroseEnhed p
XLPE Firewelill Cable (5804)
~
100 -
l so 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10
, 100 1000 10000 Time per)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 341
)
Met Yes Graphical t-Margin 21.8 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
O a
item 25A.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-Rockbestos(5805)
PBNP-DBA Temperature C
300 -
4.
b 200-
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs 8 75%,1 CS off at 1 Iw)(SGRP) 150-
-G-Rockbestos irradimikm XLPE Firewee t-til Cable (5805) 100 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10
, 100 1000 10000 Tkne(Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 342 Met Yes Graphical Margin 22.1 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
(
I i
SC 1,
57
)8 9
63 s
7 C
5 F)
C P R
R O 2(G A
(
eS r(
V u)
O t r ah S
re1 pt O
ma C
ef S
f To A 0
0 0
0 1
do h
t
)
e 8
e 0
M 6
r 0
3 u
1 y
7 t
c 6
a n
(
r O
p le e
l a
ac C
m v
i i
h S
e u
A T
0 p
q a
1 E
r
-A A
n G
B B
II D
D li io t
a P
P d
N N
a r
B B
g 1
P P
=
m n3 0
0 0
0 0
e 0
0 5
0 5
D 2
1 1
W 00s%
1 85 e7 0 e 24Y0 m
6 T
i
~
)
F 1
(
0 t
0 ne m
e r
iu F) 0 q(
n 1
0 e
o e
i 0
Rr ta u
et u
l r a ur a
e v
tap E
r 10 em 0
pe Q
0 0
mT E
ed 2
Te 9
Pfi n
1 li i
Nat g R
1 r
00 Buea C
0 PQMM S
0 T
0
-P 6.
g N
2 B
m P
e
-E t
I W
I i
- k O
S C
1, i,
m 5
iu 7
s n
G i
w T, 2 sC
)
im0 F)
C P lu8 2
m6 R
(G o(
eS Ce l r (
sb u) oa t r t
ah sC r
ei e1 b u gt t l iu a
ca r f oi ef r
To RT 0
do 0
h 0
t 0
e 0
M 1
yc
)
n 2
e l
0 l
0 0
a ac 8
e 0
v 6
r 1
i i
h
(
u u
p s
t q
o a
a t
r E
r s
e n
G e
p b
0 io k
m 0
t 1
a c
e d
o T
R ar A
g
-p B
e m
D D
o e
T P
t N
B B
06s%
A D
P 84 e6 23Y3 2
P 1
N r
0 0
0 0
r
)
B 0
5 0
5 H
3 P
1 1
(
)
e F
m
(
i t
T 1
n 0
e m
e riuF
)
q(
e 1
e 0
Rr 0
u et r a ur e
tap rem n
1 00 pe o
0 mT it a
ed Te lu n
a if Pi 1
l v
0 Nat ig E
=
r 0
Buea 0
PQMM Q
0 E
2 9
1 1
00 R
00 C
=
S
's p
T
-P 7
N 2
B m
P-e E
t W
l
I S
C 1,
57 1 -
3 04 e
7 C
)
7 1
F) 1 C P 7
e 9
0) ly R
1 2
1 (G
3 W
(
1 eS 6
r (
e
(
e d
l u )r C
b l
tah aC V
a re1 P
C pt e
e f
ma m
e m
r f
ef o
a o
To R
C R
O O
i lac d
it o
y 0
h l
t a
00 e
n M
A 1
y d
c n
n a
e l
)
l 1
a a
7 e
0 v
c i
r 0
9 h
i u
1 u
p 1
t q
3 a
a
(
r E
r e
e n
G m
p o
o m
i ta R
e 0
d T
1 p
ar m
A g
e B
e T-D D
A P
B N
1 00 s%
O BP
=
0 0
0 80 e1 0
0 5
23Y P
2 1
7 N
BP L
)rH
(
0 m F) 1 N
(
m tn A
e
~
me
^
r 1
iuF
)
^.
0 0
q(
e e Rr u et r a ur t e 1
ap 0
r 0
em n
0 pe o
mT i
ta ed u
Te l
i n
a Pi v
f 1
l i
0 Nat g E
0 r
0 Buea 0
PQMM Q
E 29 1
100 R
0 C
0 S
0 E
T-P 8
N 2
B m
P-e E
t W
I
.. _ _ _ _.._. - ~.... - _..
Nem 29.
PBNP-DBA-TempRosemourd 1154 PBNP-OBA Temperature b
i 450-400 -
1 i
350-i E
1
^
- -Temperature (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS i
onet 1 M(SGRP) t
-G--Rosemount 1154 Pressure p
200 -
Transminor (D6400102) 150-i 100 -
E I
50 -
t i
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1,
10 100 Tkne(Hrp I
l PBNP Teiiipeisture Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 450 Met Yes Graphical MarD n 60.7 %
i WE-PBNP-T/S-192 EQ Evaluation
Item 29A.
PBNP-DBA-Hr-Rose-1159 i
PBNP-DBA Temperature 150 t
400 350-300 E
' -Temperstwo (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS off at 1 hr)(SGRP) 200- Rosemount-1159 150 100 50 -
t 0
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10
- 100 1000 Thne (Hr) 1 PBNP Teirperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 420 Met Yes G;aphical Margin 50.0 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EG Evaluatica
h t
S C
1, C
3 5
5 7
3 la e
s S
C F) d C P d
R n
2 (G
o eS C r (
t 9
u )r n
t u
r o s ah e1 m-y-pt e
ma s a ef o D f
To R(
0 d
o h
0 t
0 e
1 M
y C
c 3
n 5
e l
l 3
a a
o u
0 iv c
n e
h i
r u
p C
1 t
q a
a r
E r
t n
e n
G u
E o
p l
o l
l m
m i
t e
e a
d s
T a
o r
R A
1 g
B M
G a
,3
- 0 0
0 o
e
-p D
C 0
5 0
S D
2 1
1 m
e P
T-NB 06s%
A P
I 24Y9 84 e3 B
D 1
5 0
-PN Q
H B
)
(
e F
P m
(
6 i
t T
ne 1
2 0
m 0
e r
iu F) q(
e e Rr u 1
et 0
r a 0
ur ap t e 0
rem n
pe o
mT ita ed u
Te 1
l 0
i n
a 0
Pi v
f 0
Nat iD l
E r
0 Buea PQMM Q
E 29 1
1 0
0 R
00 C
0 S
E p
T-8 P
9 N
2 B
m P-e E
t W
I
Item 31.
PBNP-DBA-Hr-Garm-Test 3 PBNP-DBA Temperature
- e 300-0^
50 i
200
- +-Temperature (2 CFCs @
75%.1 CS off at 1 hr)
(SGRP) p Rmgo Redietkm M onitor RD-23 (E-254-910) 100-50 -
e o.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
to 100 1000 Time (HQ PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 320 Met Yes Graphical Margin 14.3 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 32.
PBNP-DBA-Temp GM Cbl(040)
PBNP-l'8A Tamperature l
400
?"^
300 I
C
- ^
m E
lp
-+-Temperature (2 CFCs O 75% 1 CS
[
off at 1 hr)(SGRP)
.--_~
g Monitor Cable (040) 150-l 100 50 -
^
0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 420 Met Yes Graphical Margin 50.0 %
t WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
.-._m.-.
Item 33.
PBNP-DBA-T-West-Pen (77-59)
PBNP-DBA Temperature m
i 350-
=
t 300
^^-
1
-+--Temperature (2 CFCs 9 75%,1 CS 200 -
off at 1 hr)(SGRP) g
=
"t"_ _^2..," u _ Penetremon (PEN-e-
TR-77-59) 100 50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10' 100 1000 Time (Hr)
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 347 Met Yes Graphical Margin 23.9 %
WE_PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 34.
DBA-Temp-PBNP-West-Lim (7410L)
PBNP DBA Temperature m
I k
k
+Tecnperature (2 CFCs O 75%.1 CS cR st 1 hr) g (SGRP)
~
MOVWCAP g
150 741N.
100
+
50 0
0.00001 0 0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 Time (Hr) t PBNP Temperature Requiremant(F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 307 Met Yes Graphical i
Margin 9.6 %
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation Page 1
Item 35.
DBA-Temp-PBNP-West-Lub(7410L)
PBNP-DBA Temperature
?'?
E I
- y uI 50 A.
~
E
-e-Temperature (2 CFCs O 200 75% 1 CS off at 1 hr) 1 (SGRP)
= t _ _1., - :Mov Lubricant WCAP 7410-L g
150 100 50 I
A 0.00001 0 0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
10 100 1000 L
Time (H4 t.
PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 307 Met Yes Graphical Margin 9.6%
WE-P8MP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation Page 1 i
~ r item 36.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-West-ESF-Cables PBNP-DBA Temperature 450 -
400 -
350-E am -
at
^
^ Temperskre (2 CFCs @ 75%,1 CS l
cff at 1 hr)(SGRP)
-G-Westinghouse ESF Cables (WCAP-p 200' 7410-L-VoHI) 150-100 -
50 -
0 0.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 1
,10 100 1000
== tno PBNP Temperature Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 298 Met Yes Graphical Margin 5.7%
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
.r i
Item 37.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-West-Motor-Lub t
PBNP-DBA Temperature r
i A
/~ _
.7
--+-TempwWure (2 CFCs G 75%.1 CS off d 1 hr)(SG8tP)
E 200 -
-#-Wee 8nghouse Centenment AcddeM g
Fen Motor Bearing Lutwicent (WCAP-b 7722) i
- t. 2 4. Joe Feh4 Actor-g space-LWwicent (WCAP-7829) 100 -
50 -
I o.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 y
to 100 1000 10000 100000 PBNP Temperature Requirement (F):
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 324 Met Yes Graphical Margin 15.7%
Westinghouse WCAP-7829 is bounding.
WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation
Item 38.
PBNP-DBA-Temp-West-Fan-Lub a
4 PBNP-DBA Temperature i
i A
f_
.7 f
-*-Temparutwo (2 CFCs 9 75%,1 CS cNst I hr)(SGRP) j E
200 -
- e-weseghouse F= -
,Ltdutaant
{
(WCAP-TT22).
f 150
-dr-Wesenghouse Fer><, color.Mator-H
(
Space-Lutwicant (WCAP-7829) 100-i I
so -
h I
o.00001 0.0001 0.001 0.01 0.1 yg to 100 1000 10000 100000 r
5 C."' TeTpciaiure Requirement (F) :
280 Degradation Equivalency Method Qualified Temperature (F) 324 l
Met Yes Graphical Margin 15.7%
Westinghouse WCAP-7829 is M--4;..v.
[
t WE-PBNP-TSCR 192 EQ Evaluation I
i i
t l
1t i
- ' i SC F.
1
(
o N
5 a
7 C
ro s
b C
h F) t C P R
R e
2(G no eS c
r (
u) a t r S
ah r
e) e1 pt d 4 r9 ma o8 ef h3 f
To OC 0
do 0
h 0
t 0
e M
1 ycn
)
e 4
l la a
9 0
c e
0 i
h v
i 6
r u
p 1
3 u
C t
q a
F a
E r
r n
G (e
e o
p t
in m
ita o
k e
0 d
O T
1-a r
A g
-p e
B m
D D
e T-P A
N s%
B B
05 1
0 0
0 0
0 84 e2 D
P
=
0 0
5 0
5 23Y3 3
2 1
1 2
-PN
)
B r
P H
(
)
1 F
e 0
m
(
i t
T ne me r
1 i)uF 0
q(
0 e e Rr u et r a ur t e ap 10 r
0 em n
0 pe io mT ta ed u
Te l
i n
a Pi f v
l i
0 Nat g E
1 r
0 Buea 0
PQMM Q
0 E
29 1
10 R
0 C
00 S
0 T-9 PN 93 BP m
e E
W t
i
FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 j
Analysis R port, Pcg31 Print Data: 02/04/97 Time: 17:39 TEST VS REQUIREMENTS CALCULATION
)
Item
Description:
CALCULATION INPUT 1
Activation Energy: 0.7800 Aging Temperature: 200.00 F ACCIDENT REQUIREMENTS i
Plant Name: POINT BEACH 2ND Zone Name: CS OFF @ 1 HR STARTING ENDING TNE UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS 150.00 S
221.30 F
223.60 F
250.00 S
223.60 F
226.20 F
250.00 S
226.20 F
226.40 F
250.00 S
228.40 F
230.30 F
250.00 S
230.30 F
231.9e F
250.00 S
231.90 F
233.k F
1000.00 S
. 233.30 F
237.50 F
1000.00 S
237.50 F
240.00 F
i 1000.00 S
240.00 F
241.30 F
1000.00 S
241.30 F
241.80 F
1000.00 S
241.80 F
241.90 F
2000.00 S
241.90 F
241.60 F
2000.00 S
241.60 F
240.80 F
2000.00 S
240.60 f
F 230.00 F
2000.00 S
239.00 F
237.00 F
2000.00 S
237.00 F
234.60 F
2000.00 S
234.60 F
232.10 F
2000.00 S
232.10 F
229.80 F
2000.00 S
229.80 F
227.50 F
2000.00 S
227.50 F
225.30 F
2000.00 S
225.30 F
223.20 F
ACCIDENT TEST Test Name: GEMS-DELAVAL (PART)
Report Number: WYLE 45700-2 STARTING ENDING TME UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS 3880.00 S
300.00 F
300.00 F
r*A S E 4 Y J / b
{
FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 Analysis Report, Pcg2 2 Print Date: 02/04/97 Time: 17:39 ACCIDENT TEST... Continued i
Test Name: GEMS-DELAVAL (PART)
Report Number: WYLE 45700-2 STARTING ENDING TNE UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS TEMPERATURE UNITS 1
20.00 S
300.00 F
225.00 F
22500.00 S
225.00 F
225.00 F
i C'ALCULATION RESULTS:
63.76 %
Prepared By: W4c e,-
8 Now Date: 2-//-ff Reviewed By:
uI 43/,/d7
{
w /1 Date:
l i
)
+
l fM A 9 of Io
J x
b i
4 1
350
_,. Fulcrum Group. Inc. System 1000 Revision 15.2
..e...
,.,,.y.....,..,.,..,.
.?.?.*
?
)
.f.t
.?
Ii
=
?
- t. ?
?
.?
e
- m,.v.++H.....+..,.
.-. 9 %.c.y
)
. i.....
... iii..
iiiii i
4
.iii.
. i i i 5 4
. i i i iiii i
i i i iiis.
4 i
iiiii i
i ii i aiiii i
i i i i i,,i
!tt?f
??'??
?
t
?!
{
't
?
l.
?
??'??
t
'?
t
'?
?
W
?
? *?.f?
?
- ?
'?!
t
'?
f f
e...
p i
e i..
..q..g...pS. i i
o i
>a 4
i i..
pyyyr....y.
9 5 9 g.. gen......p. 7 y.-r T 9 9 7 t * -* - 9 *
- 9*
- r* 9 - P f f er** --
- t. --T.
- 9
- t 9-FM..
M i
i i i i sili 5
i e i...
i
. i i i i iii i
N^
(
i 4
..iiii i.
W i
i i i
e i
. i ii i
i i i.it'i
. i. i i i.,
'.. iii
.....ii.
i A
- A, Y
y Vi e....
i j
9, i ;i i i
. T T*t-ttt-t-~ '
...ii.
e i i i i,i i
, i i e iii 4W 9
...,i...e..i i.i,.,...7 7
...t--
r q-t m r.e.,.----.r--r y n..eqit-----i--.- n..etti.-----r--v
- 5. 7.. re.1
,, i....
i i l i ;i
... isiti i ; i c ii c;7 i i ii;ii 0
.i i e.i;
...i.
. e..iii.
i i...
i. i...i,
- i i
i 5 ;i L
6 i i i6.ii 6
e....
6 i., i ii.6.
- 1 1..
- ..i..
- i ;i
. e i.Ei.i
. i. i;iis
? i ??ft
? '
- 9ttit t
- t ? *1???
Q) l50.....?
! t * ?? i*
- ' ' i t !!!
- - e-
+;.+ 44.p....+. 4 +4 - ; pg.....'..p.+.H.y44...
4..+.p +p ++;.p....+. 4 4 + : : : : :
ei e-i E
,....,3, m1M 3,
...,,9 e
e.
r.
?
..t..
,r,,,
,. 3 s e eer e
e i e?!.e W
l... f..L J.. b. 4 4. L. L...
- 4..
- 4.. J.
- 4. J. 6.L'J......L.. L. A. 6 4. J. J. 4 4..... J.
J
.L J.
6 4 4. L. L...
- 4..
- 4.. J.
4 I'
p 7
9.,.
, g.
??!..
! ?
? * *
?,
?
t.'8?.?
- ? ?. !.
t.
t ? !t't' t
.?
t
.?
- ? ?!
i
,. ? ?. !
?
t.i ?
..?...?'
t
? ?
t,..?
t
.! t.P ?
9
...e.
j i......
i
...so
..>9
. e t i J.. J..LJ. be.44..b... 4.. 4..J. 4.J b.k.W.....b.. b.4..b 4 4 4,4 4... 4...J...b d b e. e. k.b....4..
4.
4 44.6Lf4 y
f ; - ;
1
?. ?. $.?. ?.
,J
'. ?. ? '. t t.
t t t.t ',!
?.
t !t?
t
.. g tt 9
.., e.
..t
,, t.,
t t..
0
,....g 1
"IEl
'lE2 "1E3
'lE4 Plant Post-Accident Profde C O Time (Seconds)
Test Post-Acc. dent Profile ].g Date: 02/04/97 i
Time: 17:44:52 Minimum Margin: 63.76 %
ltem
Description:
l'ASE k /0 offo
FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 Analys'a Report, Page 1 Print D:ta: 02/14/97 Time: 14:48 E
l TEST VS REQUIREMENTS CALCULATION item
Description:
Rome Cable in Wyle 17740-1 CALCULATION INPUT i
Activation Energy: 1.3700 Aging Temperature: 200.00 F 4
+
ACCIDENT REQUIREMENTS Plant Name: POINT BEACH Zone Name: FIRST 26.22 HR STARTING ENDING TIME UNITS TEMPERATURJNITS TEMPERATUFUNITS l
0.25 8
161.20 F
161.20 F
0.25 S
161.20 F
193.80 F
'i 1.00 S
193.80 F
244.90 F
1.00 8
244.90 F
265.30 F
1.00 8
265.30 F
272.20 F
4 2.00 S
272.20 F
274.60 F
1.00 S
274.60 F
278.40 F
1.00 S
278.40 F
279.00 F
12.50 8
279.00 F
279.80 F
100.00
.S 279.80 F
279.80 F
7.00 3
279.80 F
273.90 F
4 10.00 S-273.90 F
273.60 F
200.00 S
273.60 F
268.90 F
200.00 S
268.90 F
264.70 F
i 653.00 8
264.70 F
264.70.*
F 250.00 S
264.70 F
248.70 F
}
1500.00 8
248.70 F
248.70 F
250.00 S
248.70 F
224.20 t'
350.00 S
224.20 F
221.30 F
150.00 S
221.30 F
223.60 F
250.00 S 223.60 F
226.20 F
250.00 S
226.20 F
228.40 F
250 00 S
228.40 F
230.30 F
4 260.00 S
230.30 F
231,90 F
250.00 S 231.90 F
233.30 F
1000.00 S
233.30 F
241.90 F
8000.00 8
241.90 F
241.90 F
2000.00 S
241.90 F
239.00 F
2000.00 8
230.00 F
237.00 F
2000.00 S
237.00 F
234.80 F
2000.00 S
234.60 F
232.10 F
10000.00 S
232.10 F
232.10 F
]
2000.00 S 232.10 F
219.00 F
4 3
1 YAGEss a t[-
FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 Analysis Report, Page 2 Print Dat2: 02/14/97 Tim 3: 14:48 ACCIDENT REQUIREMENTS... Continued Plant Name: POINT BEACH Zone Name: FIRST 26.22 HR i
1 STARTING ENDING TWE UNITS TBrERATUFUNfTS TBFERATURMITS 10000.00 8
219.00 F
219.00 F
i 1.00 H 210.00 F
206.16 F
1.00 H 206.16 F
203.15 F
1.00 H 203.15 F
200.24 F
e 1.00 H
200.24 F
197.44 F
1.00 H
197.44 F
1M.73 F
2.00 H
194.73 F
189.80 F
3.00 H
100.60 F
182.56 F
4.00 H
182.56 F
174.26 F
ACCIDENT TEST Test Name: ROME EQ TEST (PART)
Report Number: WYLE 17740-1 STARTING ENDING j
TWE UNITS TEMPERATURJNITS TEMPERATUFUNITS 6.00 8
150.00 F
210.00 F
4.00 S
210.00 F
250.00 F
5.00 8
250.00 F
310.00 F
5.00 8
310.00 F
345.00 F
3.00 S
345.00 F
328.00 F
5.00 S
328.00 F
347.00 F
2.00 8
347.00 F
350.00 F
4.00 S
350.00 F
334.00 F
8.00 8
334.00 F
350.00 F
3.00 8
350.00 F
346.00 F
6.00 8
346.00 F
336.00 F
4.00 8
336.00 F
330.00 F
4.00 8
330.00 F
350.00.-
F 1.00 8
350.00 F
320.00 F
5.00 S
320.00 F
336.00 F
5.00 S
336.00 F
328.00 F
5.00 S
328.00 F
322.00 F
10.00 S
322.00 F
334.00 F
10.00 S
338.00 F
330.00 F
15.00 S
330.00 F
330.00 F
00.00 8
330.00 F
338.00 F
120.00 S
338.00 F
320.00 F
240.00 8
320.00 F
320.00 F
70.00 8
320.00 F
310.00 F
s fASE cA of Il[
i
^
FULCRUM GROUP, INC. SYSTEM 1000, REVISION 15.2 Analysis Report, Pcge 3 Print D ta: 02/14/97 Time: 14:48 ACCIDENT TEST... Continued i
Test Name: ROME EQ TEST (PART)
Report Number: WYLE 17740-1 STARTING ENONG TWE UNITS TEMPERATUFUNTT81EMPERATUfUNITS I
230.00 8
310.00 F
300.00 F
420.00 8 300 M F
300.00 F
}
800.00 8 300.00 F
280.00 F
i 1800.00 8 280.00 F
230.00 F
i 1.00 H 230.00 F
230.00 F
l 38860.00
$ 230.00 F
190.00 F
i 1.00 H
190.00 F
185.00 F
4 1.00 H
145.00 F
185.00 F
100.00 8
185.00 F
178.00 F
40200.00 8
178.00 F
178.00 F
1 i
i CALCULATION RESU130.86%
i i
f Prepared By: MWe m
Date:.2 - / 4-9 7-Reviewed By: [
A sus Date: d52 Mdv
(
(
( (-
r I
l r
i f;
PAGE_r ie 41) 1 w
m
.;; v.; (. e q
,, *[' *
,.; 4l J. sc, a..
.p..
~
, a,
.>..,.e g
..,,.... m.,...~:
4.
., z g:,. g. -
A..,
- .
- . ~.:p~; :n.,,n 3 --
's v.
.~
,,e
~
u:;: -
c
~.;M w.,
u.
.a
..n...
z n w..w
,*k E.,
g-Y y9 q p 2479_ g@j.f, fh*k. m +t[ b kM2' kY _
.W/h*'yQ. -.
W.H.+.+
s.9MkwMgrsw
<r-a:
1
.*'.'%, 3 w ? p p J A,..
v.:. w f a c.:
n y....
y :
=.. a. y@Np,,.14,w w.n. nr= w x%_..
x r
1 t:a m.,
.:- v
_. ggt;g g p.g.+;94;t;@. + ~W$y-Q M*-
s p.9 i,.,;.
i
.: n. &
n'
-o.u,
- sr n,, ~.y mm m, ~.w y e -p.; zm:,,,.
l'250 "'Wme proup,. @c. Aygtem,10AD Revision 15.2 - p ce, ag,. m (T :'
I
.,h,.,7:{W' C2 1....r.'1 A f
[y l6An 5
- i. j m ;g @ o
!l
.o.J j-
.i.p pi t.4
..:4
.r h
.w..c
..,. a -
.;g y.,.fu
.$4'@ p y.gg,$.,:
t, j1 Nj u W r/
I a,f aJ 3..; y#
s.
'11 9
- g...
y.
y
- i. g..w ;
n.m 4,,
p.e,,.m,ac w
.. ~,,...
p.o m
,i tp.x,y
.,e
.,... u
- ,7. ;-p p
.i..i g: i,
e-. y
..m ra 7 q,,.g, i..p, t g
. g. q ; g. o a
y l
3 a
ii, i
O i. i' i s
.i
.i i i, ' i.
e i i "i
l i
l' i
i i..
i i
i i
.t i
.O,
..,i, O
. _+
= -4.,i i
i l
.FT_..I. :
i i !
i i
t
.!!u i
.u.
. [
- ,,9Ji y.1_...... _.I E_' 4
.,1 I
2 m! I i. !I l' w m
.i
-- r L
d
-J
- -J.W. t. i -
r- '-
i 3
150 r ' '.
,-.-4
' i 3
.g i
tu.
i i j '. m i i j, a._
i.
ge, i
L i
- i1e!!
A i
se 4 %j ;!;!l.
. i y
F 0
i i
..r.5 -P L
i ri--
ii L
i t
'.. i
... i i i,
Q,0' I
i-b
! Ii i
0 i^
(kL,j.,N@E !
3 1
10
,p i
i i
ii t-1,c )
r-i Il !!
j j
l l !!! !'
! <' ' i ! ! l i
E i
i l
it i
di i
i i
i 0) i i i
j~
r+
f l 50 t
i i !
ii t
,1,.:
i, i,
--r----t-
-+ rtr r, -+-t-T,
-t-r-+l-
+t- -m--r--*--+ r-tr+
r-e-- r r-j i
i i
i t
i 8
1 i
i
+
i 4-a i
- i
. l' i4 i
i i1 i
!l.
I s
ff f
l
,i i
i i: -
e-i i
i.
ii i
O i,
i i
i
.t.
1
~1El
'1E2
'1E3
~1E4 Pea: Post-Accidert oro'ae M.
. Time (Seconds) m'._,'".
.' M ate: V2/14/97
. ~,4...
m.
. mv -o:s<. cem 3m.a _- t '
' Time: 14:50:30 s
9..- Minimum Margin: '130.86 %
e y
~~ Item Descriptioni: Rome Cable.in Wyh.e 17740-1
._ x 4
g'.
i s
e m.s.,p.'.; O > i. w:n.'g m.~,,,,o s3 x
.,u
.EI
[u k
I g
L
.~
.d vb :-
~
t L
4. e.2 Tr r.uts..
- abad
. FM.
Li -
b2
s554W ' '* b L
p.
g,... ;.
.r......d,', f. i
,r..*Sr, y 8 4f i'#.,,.
.[.[. (<*r.r. -- * ** %.=. * *,,..
.~...Z_-
' g gw{.
...;. ' p p
~
I y..
l
. :)
,,s p
m.
,,, -. +.
.s t
V*.y 6
g r g
- *J
. s. L !' :% *;..
e-
+.
=
-