ML20135C687

Forwards Slides from 970206 Meeting Presentation to Discuss Results of Recently Completed Plant App R self-assessment

ML20135C687
Person / Time
Site:	Calvert Cliffs
Issue date:	02/27/1997
From:	Ruland W NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
To:	Cruse C BALTIMORE GAS & ELECTRIC CO.
References
NUDOCS 9703040215
Download: ML20135C687 (26)

Text

b.

l

.[

i February 27, 1997 l

[

Mr. Charles H. Cruse Vice President - Nuclear Energy Baltimore Gas and Electric Company i

Calvert Cliffs Nuclear Power Plant 1650 Calvert Cliffs Parkway Lusby, MD 20657 -4702

Dear Mr. Cruse:

On February 6,1997, we met with your staff to discuss the results of your recently completed Calvert Cliffs Appendix R self-assessment. You had committed to perform the assessment as part of your corrective action for an Appendix R Violation earlier last year.

The slides you presented during the meeting are attached.

Based on what we heard, we believe that you performed a successful assessment as evidenced by the number and extent of your findings. While we applaud you for your effort, the more critical work remains. That is, completing the required corrective actions to bring your plant into full compliance with Appendix R. Until then, we note that you gave us assurance at the meeting that the combined effect of all deficiencies would not prevent you from safely achieving safe shutdown in the event of a fire. This statment made by you considered the compensatory measures that you have in place until you j

complete the ne::essary modifications. We intend to inspect your corrective actions.

Thank you for your cooperation. If you have any questions or clarifications, please call me at (610) 337-5376.

Sincerely, h}

/

r William H. Ruland, Chief i

Electrical Engineering Branch Division of Reactor Safety Docket Nos. 50-317,50-318 l

l l

Enclosures:

1. Slides from presentation j

2. Attendees at meeting yj l

nannoo 9703040215 970227 SE%%%%,E,ll DR ADOCK 0500 7

r t

f f

Mr. Charles M. Cruse 2

cc w/encis:

T. Camilleri, Director, Nuclear Regulatory Matters (CCNPP)

R. McLean, Administrator, Nuclear Evaluations J. Walter, Engineering Division, Public Service Commission of Maryland K. Burger, Esquire, Maryland People's Counsel R. Ochs, Maryland Safe Energy Coalition l

State of Maryland (2)

Distribution w/encis:

D. Screnci, PAO Nuclear Safety Information Center (NSIC)

{

P'UBLIC i

NRC Resident inspector Region 1 Docket Room (with concurrences)

R. Correia, NRR D. R. Taylor, NRR W. Dean, OEDO (WMD)

S. Stewart - Calvert Cliffs S. Bajwa, NRR l

A. Dromerick, NRR G. Vissing, NRR M. Campion, RI inspection Program Branch, NRR (IPAS)

W. Ruland, DRS DRS File DOCUMENT NAME: A:\\CC. REC Ta,ece% e copy of this document. Indicate in the bos: "C" = Copy without ettech,nent/ enclosure "E" = Copy with attachment / enclosure

'N" = No copy 0FFICE RI/DRS 16 RI/DRP n

/

l l

l NAME WRULAND /Aj&X LDOERFLEINN7V DATE 02/18/97/A 02/a l/97 '

02/

/97 02/

/97 02/

/97 0FFICIAL RECORD COPY

.,a2, m

A d_

es-4.-.m.._ue.

-~A2a_A-....>

W*dJ--

d.

A 4A24A8ph 4-M44-h*m446-~*d---ad hw-"

-ra*

+A 3h"e 6'F*A8--

• rd'--^

- - - '-'-*M" "dA--N"4' e

0 F,

I H

l i

4 4

i 4%%

H

-d c.

j u

(

w V,

O

~

-8Y h

L D

~

1

![ >

@x

+

j H

<"d g j

<y W

r s

I

~

W I

e f

9

AGEXDA l.

INTRODUCTIONS II. BACKGROUND i

Ill. SELF-ASSESSMENT PROCESS IV. SELF-ASSESSMENT RESULTS i

V. ACTION PLAN i

VI. QUESTIONS 2

i

i i

IXTRODECTIONS 1

i

_ s., _ & m r 7 7

z.m m e _zm, 4

._ m m o C.H. CRUSE -

VP, NUCLEAR ENERGY l

e P. G. CHABOT -

i 1

MANAGER, NUCLEAR ENGINEERING l

e T.J.CAMILLERI -

DIRECTOR, NUCLEAR REGULATORY MATTERS e G. L. DETTER -

GENERAL SUPERVISOR, DESIGN ENGINEERING o R. B. SYDNOR - PRINCIPAL ENGINEER i

APPENDIX R/HVAC PROJECT MANAGER e C. R. SINOPOLI - SENIOR ENGINEER FIRE PROTECTION PROGRAM MANAGER J

t

.l t <

BACKGROEND 8E.a654.5 erfw EmintNaW:

E- '~'

'h 1$ O A 7+,'ATC's C 'E". M,' 0,8 5

[

e June 96 Pre-enforcement Conference (Switchgear HVAC) e Appendix R overview evaluation L

(completed June 14,1996}

i e Committed to a full Appendix R i

Self-Assessment in October 1996 l

t b

i I

4

SELF-ASSESSMEXT PROCESS

'~

~

~ " ^

....;=-;.,...._

o Conducted from 1C/10/96 to 11/1/96 i

o Team Leader - CCNPP QA Supervisor Senior CCNPP QA Engineer e Team Members -

r

1. Senior CCNPP QA Engineer j

2. Five Senior Consultants from Engineering Planning & Management, Inc. With extensive experience in Nuclear Power, Appendix R, Fire Protection, and Self-assessment.

5 4

)

n ASSESSMEXT TEAM

?

L EXPERIEXCE l

l u

m m__

Robert Kalantari - Senior Consultant J

Licensing / Systems. Over 16 years Nuclear Power Engineering, Fire Protection Engineer. Worked on App R at 7 different Nuclear Plants.

Paul Ouellette - Mechanical Systems / App R Licensing.

i 15 years Nuclear Power Engineering, QA Auditor.

Extensive App R and self-assessment expenence.

1 Albert Melikian - Electrical Systems / App R.

j 15 years App R technical expertise in the area of Electrical Engineering compliance with APP R and self-assessment experience.

6

e' e

f ASSESSMEXT TEAM i

EXPERIEXCE i

.s a.a.eu.q:

7,um.2wm i

Frank McGinnis - Technical Consultant, Fire Protection.

Over 12 years experience fire protection engineering, 8 in nuclear. QA Auditor. Experience in fire protection audits at several different plants.

Mark Crompton - Technical Consultant, Fire Protection.

Masters Degree in Fire Protection. Experience in fire l

protection programs at four nuclear plants.

i 7

l

SELF-ASSESSMENT PROCESS

~_

e SCOPE - Overall CCNPP Appendix R program compliance with:

10CFRSC,50.48, Appendix R sections Ill.G - Fire Protection of Safe Shutdown Capability Ill.J - Emergency Lighting Ill.L - Alternative Shutdown Capability j

lll.O - RCP Oil Collection (excluded) e Method - IAW NRC InSp. Proc. 40501 &

64100 8

l

SELF-ASSESSMEXT t

CHECKLIST (IP 64100)

[

mm m,

~ w m c __.

~

l

1. SAFE SHUTDOWN ANALYSIS & REGULATORY CONFORMANCE

1. Exemptions or Deviations

2. Compliance with Generic Letters and I &E Notices

3. Evaluations, Analyses, and Compliance Strategies j

4. Functions and Performance Goals

5. Systems, Equipment, Cables, and instrument Sense Line Analysis

6. Electrical Distribution Systems Evaluations and Use of Offsite Power j

7. Plant System Automatic Functions

8. Associated Circuits, Spurious Operations l

9. High/ Low Pressure Boundary Analysis j

10. Alternative / Dedicated Shutdown

11. Licensing

12. Fire Protection, Fire Suppression Effects and Fire Area Separations i

13. Habitability and Equipment Operability Environment 9

i i

j SELF-ASSESSMEXT CHECKLIST (IP 64100)

.a.-

~

.a.

11. QUALITY ASSURANCE AND CORRECTIVE ACTIONS

1. QA Program

{

2. Databases 111. DESIGN REVIEW AND CONFIGURATION MANAGEMENT j

1. Calculations and Documentation l

2. Long Term Conformance Maintenance and Procedures

3. Raceway Routing Information

4. Raceway Fire Barrier Wrap Use IV. Operations and Maintenance

1. Repairs, Operating Procedures, Manual Actions, Maintenance f

V. SURVEILLANCE AND TESTING

1. Tech Specs, Surveillance Requirements

2. Emergency Lighting, Communications, Fire Protections Features 10 i

i SELF-ASSESSMEXT FOCUS o Specific areas of review were based on:

Recurring industry issues Relative safety significance Previous NRC Inspection and Audit i

Findings in the industry Comparison to current practices at Other Utilities k

6 11

i SELF-ASSESSMEXT RESCLTS

=_

i e Our Basic Appendix R Program is sound n Fire Detection and Suppression i

n App R Interactive Cable Analysis Operations Safe Shutdown Procedures Surveillance Procedures Design Process and documentation e Awareness of industry experience was Good e Identified Concerns warrant increased attention i

12 l

m

i 1.

nil (

'^[

's,

[,1 *2 [.h' f

.-:-W ;. $, f.'

g;,'f

M.i~:, p; g

,, ~ M -: a

, <..yp ;

w;

-%g','

. e.f, '.S, ! y: m.

4 on.

an-

. y:w _ :

p.

n+ t.:

.~ 7..y9. _ =y u, ;C..L +~' ; $,._

ti#,m'_s ' sTfiia,xsis'b~

y ::, v,.:--

. _ % ^;

^.<-

p 9%Intsrsd.x.~ sl v

r,, <

u,.-

+

4 mm

. h.e i

y nf.2:, ;

=, WE., M-

R f~,:w yW

+4 s

x. :

+

+

m

.. r I

?

l i

• r I

v 4

i i

f l

i l

1 i

t 1

t w.wwwlter.natem..

xA unnw n w$n ww~

i

!D0tenti6ri/Siip,p;*Qms w

1r.em m -C w.

. Meryp..w 5-..c a,.. a

.ya w_(

f ud e -s: %1 p-N W c._

W:w+afe]Shhidv:n iessioit S

6wnFr

=

=

W w-m n

e

,.w ay O. W-: - ;, s:m-mxe y

?ystemSWNa

+

~

u.. ~. = c Mv.

c s

n ~:~

c. w;roce ureSW, i

S i

- m w w;--

l 1

i i

.3 v.u;w:m

n,W..

i

..v a

n:.

7

. n, ".

>y. L ;.

4..%en s '< e :: m +.w,.g,u ; & Wk. - NL Y

-.w. %.,

l a c;:.

39

.., u :1:;r

.v,

w@ M N.urVel anCOM;ER i

wa v enx.u;x x.>n u,,;m e

.mx; c :.

-.ma w :n.

t n +. ~, w- _g.+s ( ;, #8 a,._,c..

g~ p

g, m4 y

,,y

.j 3

,,s.

[

E t

I 4

4 I*

SELF-ASSESSMEXT RESLLTS

-7

_ 3, g.. -

e 19 Concerns identified 7 Group I concerns - recommended corrective action be taken/ upgraded 12 Group ll concerns - corrective action in progress e 14 recommendations for improvement (Group lil) e All concerns will be addressed through our corrective action process e We have completed action on 11 items 13 l

l i

f SELF-ASSESSMENT L

KEY COXCERXS

/

o Ventilation Systems-analysis and mods i

e Motor operated Valves 'IN92-18}

e Dual fusing of alternate S/D circuits 1

/IN85-09',

t e Electrical Analysis l

> external hot shorts j

> spurious operations o EDG circuits /1997 RFO'l 14 l

l

SELF-ASSESSMEXT KEY COXCERXS g;_ _ _=g-e Emergency lighting e Various fire protection analyses l

Raceway enclosure qualification j

Large fire area analysis o Instrument Air system fire effects 1

o Self-induced Station Blackout i

e Reportability of Appendix R issues e Manual actions requiring tools

{

15 i

i

~

i L

ACTIOX PLAX

...e%..-..+.....w :As wrr

~: v _._ mum.m.s

..m e Created the Appendix R/HVAC Project Team l

and assigned a full-time Project Manager o Appendix R ownership consolidated in i

Engineering i

e Complete Analysis - 1997 (90% confidence) e Complete currently identified Plant Mods -

i non-outage 1997-98, outage related 1998 l

and 1999 RFO's i

e Appendix R Training - Complete j

i 16 I

i i

i APPEXDIX. R PROJECT 2n__.______=_==____________

o Overall Project Manager-Russ Sydnor 1

o Project Team -

t Five Electrical Engineers j

Two HVAC Engineers Two Fire Protection Engineers i

Operations Liaison Modification Project Managers i

i 17

.l e

APPEXDIX R PROJECT GOALS mc.m.-...aamma-

~mm,m ca_m ~:-

i e Resolve Current Concerns Complete analysis identify modifications early Modifications approved and scheduled Communicate status to Management and the NRC i

i

?

l i

18 i

APPENDIX R PROJECT GOALS

_;;;g ;,

-~ -

o Establish Framework for Continued Compliance Process improvements Ownership Training Self-assessment / Management oversight I

19

i MAXAGEMENT ISSUES 1

i

. ~

- _-- - m & mr-

..-..,__m-l e Appendix R level of knowledge

> Initial training complete j

4 o Challenge and validate assumptions Determine the issue vice being defensive

> Addressed by Engineering Department Manager and General Supervisors t

e Consolidate Management responsibility for i

Fire Protection Programs and Appendix R

> Done j

e Enforce Action item commitments

> Improved, continuing l

I i

SUMMARY

,mn_a==w,m= ;;e=c=w n _

i e Self-assessment thorough and credible

}

o Findings o Corrective actions and compensatory actions e Safety is first priority e Responsibility i

21 i

l t

t ISSUE ACTION ACTION IN COMP.

COMPLETE PROGRESS

_ MEASURES Ext. Hot Shorts E

No Emerg 1.ights E

Yes EDG Circuit E

Yes Reportability E

SelfInduced SBO No Raceway Enclosure No

_ Manual Actions, Tools Dual Fusing, IN 85-09 E

Yes MOV, IN 92-18 E

Yes Spurious Operations E

No Large Fire Areas No Instrument Air No Functionality Air Bottle, CV-517 Inst. Sensing Line Mult. High Imped Fault No Ventilation Systems Yes Manual Action Feasibility No Embedded Conduits Fire Suppression Effects Process Monitoring A

Fire Barrier Evals A

App. R QA A

FHA A

Fire Damper Operability A

Communications A

ICA Format A

Report on Alt. S/D A

Comp. Equip. List A

Electrical Dist. Systems Breaker / Fuse Coord.

A C. T. Analysis A

High/ Low Pressure A

Long Term Compl. Proc.

A a Potential Noncompliances: Potential plant / documentation deviations from Fire Protection regulations / license basis.

e General Concern: Plant condition appears to deviate from guidance documentation or documentation is not available to support compliance.

A General Observation: Conditions that appear to be inconsistent with other compliant nuclear stations or areas for improvement.

I

ENCLOSURE 2 ATTENDEES AT MEETING Licensee Peter Chabot, Engineering Manager Terry Camilleri, Director, Nuclear Regulatory Matters Clifford Sinopoli, System Engineer, Fire Protection Russell Sydnor, Principle Engineer, Fire Protection Gary Detter, General Supervisor, Design Engineering N.R.C James Stewart, SRI, Calvert Cliffs Larry Doerflein, Projects Branch No.1, DRP 1

William Ruland, Chief, Electrical Engineering Branch, DRS A. Randolph Blough, Deputy Director, DRS Alex Dromerick, NRR Steven Adams, Reactor Engineering, DRP Thomas Mostack, Project Engineer, DRP l

>