ML20135C626

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comment on DSI-2 Re Strategic Assessment.Option 1,supported
ML20135C626
Person / Time
Issue date: 12/02/1996
From: Dragoun T
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
To:
NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY)
References
DSI-2-00024, DSI-2-24, NUDOCS 9612090017
Download: ML20135C626 (2)


Text

.i DS3 -2 4

From: webadmin <webadmin@nrc. gov > g 10 To: WND1.WNP2(secy) 4 Date:

Subject:

12/2/9610:02am Strategic Assessment forms submission) ~

gg 'tg'\3 C.)

k DEC 2 1995 b Your name: Thomas Dragoun gg E-mail address: tfd@nrc. gov

  • g \g Affiliation: NRC Region I Full Mailing Address: 475 Allendale Road y,g%

~~~'

King of Prussia, PA 19406 Number of the issue Paper: 2 Topic: 1 (omissions)

Thomas Dragoun sent the following comment via the WWW server:

Issue paper 2 does not fully address the economics of the various proposals. I observed the presentation of the results of a study by Bechtel Corporation, under contract to DOE, that compared the costs of regulation at the Brookhaven research reactor (under DOE) with NIST (under NRC). The study demonstrated that overall costs at NIST were dramatically lower, by about a factor of 10, than at Brookhaven after adjustment for programmatic differences. This data would strongly support implementation of option 1 A.

Furthermore, discussions with contractors involved in decommissioning at both NRC and DOE facilities indicate that NRC oversight results in more thorough remediation and timely completion. This again lends support to option 1 A.

Server protocol: HTTP/1.0 Remote host: irm12.nrc. gov Remote IP address: 148.184.200.31

\\9 9612070017 961202 PDR NRCSA E 2 PDR DS /3 a

I

e 1

) ,.

( ,

l Received: from igate.nrc. gov by irm12 (5.x/TMD1.7) ,

id AA20470; Mon,2 Dec 199610:02:48 -0500 l Received: from nrc. gov by smtp-gateway with ESMTP? id KAA07212 for

<secy@nrc. gov >; Mon,2 Dec 199610:03:02 -0500 (EST) i Received: by nrc. gov (8.8.3/8.8.3) id KAA26560; Mon,2 Dec 199610:02:49 -0500 1 (EST) l Date: Mon,2 Dec 199610:02:49 -0500 (EST) )

Message-Id: <199612021502.KAA26560@nrc. gov > {

X-Authentication-Warning: www.nrc. gov: nobody set sender to webadmin using -f l From: webadmin <webadmin@nrc. gov > j To: secy@nrc. gov l Reply-To: tfd@nrc. gov (Thomas Dragoun) i

Subject:

Strategic Assessment (Forms submission) i