ML20133M055

Summary of CRGR Meeting 295 on 961112 Re Review of Proposed Rulemaking on SD & Operations Involving Fuel Storage Pools at Nuclear Power Plants.Identified Comments Re Scope & Technical & Policy Issues Needing More Consideration

ML20133M055
Person / Time
Issue date:	01/10/1997
From:	Ross D Committee To Review Generic Requirements
To:	Thompson H NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
Shared Package
ML20007E557	List: ML20133M055
References
NUDOCS 9701220240
Download: ML20133M055 (3)

Text

--.. -.

van p*

'4 UNITED STATES g-j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION g

WASHINGTON. D.C. 2008H201

,e January 10, 1997 MEMORANDUM TO:

Hugh L. Thompson, Jr.

Acting Executive Director for Operations FROM:

Denwood F. Ross, Jr.. Acting Chai Committee to Review Generic Requireme

SUBJECT:

MINUTES OF CRGR MEETING NUMBER 295 - PART I The Committee to Review Generic Requirements (CPlaR) met on Tuesday, November 12, 1996, from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.

A list of attendees is provided in Attachment 1.

At this CRGR meeting, the Committee was brieTed by the staff on the status and schedule of the ongoing rulemaking on Shutdown Operation and Operations Involving fuel Storage Pmis at Nuclear power Plants (10 CFR 50.67).

Part I of the minutes of the CRGR Meeting No. 295 covers only the Committee's review of this rulemaking (Attachment 2). The Committee made several comments on the scope of this rulemaking and identified several significant technical and policy issues which need better consideration (e.g.. need for critical peer review of PRA and PRA results: need for backfit analysis: use of objective, measurable or calculable, and enforceable performance criteria: and appro)riate configuration control considerations). A memorandum, dated Novem)er 27, 1996, from Chairman, CRGR to Director DSSA/NRR consolidated the Comittee's recommendations.

Additionally, during CRGR Heeting No. 295, the Comittee reviewed the general Regulatory Guide on proposed PRA ap)lications (DG-1061), and the Standard Review Plan (SRP) associated with tie general Regulatory Guide.

Previously, at the CRGR Meeting No. 294, the staff had briefed the Committee on these documents and the five proposed PRA Application Regulatory Guides and their related SRPs, and also discussed the proposed schedule for rMmittal of the documents for CRGR review and publication for comment. Subsequently, the Committee reviewed some of the other PRA applications regulatory guides and the accompanying SRPs at CRGR Meeting No. 297 held on November 26, 1997. The CRGR staff, with the a> proval of the Acting Chairman. CRGR, plans to issue combined minutes for CRGR Meeting No. 294, No. 295 (Part II) and 297 (held on i

October 26, November 12, and November 26, 1996, respectively).

The combined minutes will only discuss the Committee's review of the PRA applications i

regulatory guides and the associated SRPs.

gi) i In accordance with the ED0's July 18, 1983 directive concerning " Feedback and-Closure of CRGR Review." a written response is required from the cognizant

)

office to report agreement or disagreement with the CRGR recomendations in these minutes. The response is to be forwarded to the CRGR Chairman and if j

i there is disagreement with the CRGR recomrer.dations, to the ED0 for decision making.

g Cn-7 O d O k NRG R

'}/ O 004 N MEETINO295 PDR g

3

~

• Hugh L. Thompson Questions concerning these meeting minutes should be referred to Raji Tripathi

~ 415-7584).-

(

Attachments: As' stated i

cc:

Commission (5)

SECY i

J. i.ieberman. OE E. Halman. ADM H. Bell. OIG x

K. Cyr.-OGC J. Larkins. ACRS Office Directors Regional Administrators. RI/RII/RIII/RIV CRGR Members G.,Holahan NRR W. Hodges. RES t

l l

t f

i I

I 4

d

o 7

,4 Hugh L. Thompson Questions concerning these meeting minutes should be referred to Raji Tripathi (415-7584).

Attachments: 'As stated cc:

Commission (5)

SECY J. Lieberman. OE E. Halman, ADM H.- Bell. 0IG K. Cyr, OGC J. Larkins ACRS Office Directors Regional Administrators RI/RII/RIII/RIV CRGR Members G. Holahan, NRR W. Hodges, RES Distribution of CRGR Minutes 295. Part I

-Central-File w/att.

PDR (NRC/CRGR) w/o att.

CRGR SF CRGR CF S. Treby E. Jordan J. Mitchell J. Conran R. Tripathi A. Thadani J. Shapaker M. Cunningham R. Jones M. Rubin J. Jones J. Johnson, OCM/CM A. El-Bassioni M. Virgilio K. Desai G. Hizuno S. Jones W. Lyons-M. Cheok G. Parry T. Hsia. OCM/ND M. Fleishman. OCM/KR J. Beall, OCM/EM B. Holian, OCM/CM J. Sorensen OCM/KR J. Flack M. Pohida T. Tjader B. McCabe E. Weiss C. Berlinger G. Hubbard J. Monninger S:\\CRGR\\MINUTESI.295 CRGR:AE004-D :A RTrip/97athf71 D

s 1//o 1/

/7 210052 9211