ML20133K318
| ML20133K318 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 10/15/1985 |
| From: | Crutchfield D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Thompson H Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8510210179 | |
| Download: ML20133K318 (25) | |
Text
.
00T 151985 MEMORANDUM FOR:
Hugh L. Thompson, Jr., Director Division of Licensing j
FROM:
Dennis M. Crutchfield, Assistant Director for Safety Assessment Division of Licensing
SUBJECT:
MONTHLY STATUS REPORT ON PLANT-SPECIFIC BACKFITTING i
ACTIVITIES - SEPTEMBER 1985 i
Enclosed is the Division of Licensing's monthly report on plant-specific backfitting activities current through September 16, 1985. Section 1 l
includes the status of active issues by responsible NRC management level and a summary of resolved issues generated by our data base system on the IBM PC.
Information on backfitting issues handled according to draft.
Manual Chapter 0514 along with outstanding issues covered by our previous procedures has been entered into the agency-wide tracking system and is shown in Section 2.
Backfit determinations were completed for issues concerning TMI-I and all TVA units.
In addition, Maine Yankee withdrew its backfit claim and agreed to submit Technical Specifications on the LCOs for the turbine driven AFW pump.
The staff is awaiting licensee response on issues at Beaver Valley 2, Maine Yankee, and Farley 1 and 2.
Eeaver Valley's plan to use CO, as the main fire suppression system in the cable spreading room along with a fire brigade
[
backup has been accepted provided the applicant justifies that its systems will function satisfactorily in a congested area of the room or provides plans for a n'odification.
Presently, the staff has no indication when to expect this justification. Also, the staff is uncertain when it will receive Maine Yankee's evaluation.of an updated SER concerning installation of redundant level indicators and low level alarms on the DWST. However, in the case of Farley, the staff ' expects to receive the licensee's submittal concerning testing intervals for containment purge and vent valves by September 30, 1985.
Dennis M. Crutchfield, Assistant Director
[
for Safety Assessment Division of Licensing
Enclosure:
As stated cc: see next page
Contact:
P. Tremblay, ORAB X27952 I
DISTRIBUTION MCentral-File E I 8510210179 851015 l/
ORAG Rdg PDR MISC j
l f)D[ E PTremblay 8510210179 PDR l
/
U, JHannon g
GHolahan
[
h g
PDR g
J i
p.3.pl (f )k t
ORA :D ORAB.DL AD R:DL A
L f
PTrem y:jc JHannon GHolahan GL nas vakG D
1Tield
/y
' Q; g
9/2f/85 9/g/85 l9/g/85 g/3 /85
/85 jev// /85 4
5 to su 8
UNITED STATES
'g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION r,
E WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 OCT 151985 MEMORANDUM FOR:
Hugh L. Thompson, Jr., Director Division of Licensing FROM:
Dennis M. Crutchfield, Assistant Director for Safety Assessment Division of Licensing
SUBJECT:
MONTHLY STATUS REPORT ON PLANT-SPECIFIC BACKFITTING ACTIVITIES - SEPTEMBER 1985 Enclosed is the Division of Licensing's monthly report on plant-specific
~
backfitting activities current through September 16, 1985. Section 1 includes the status of active issues by responsible NRC management level and a sumary of resolved issues generated by our data base system on the IBM PC.
Infonnation on backfitting issues handled according to draft Manual Chapter 0514 along with outstanding issues covered by our previous procedures has been entered into the agency-wide tracking system and is shown in Section 2.
Backfit determinations were completed for issues concerning TMI-I and all TVA units.
In addition, Maine Yankee withdrew its backfit claim and agreed to submit Technical Specifications on the LCOs for the turbine driven AFW pump.
The staff is awaiting licensee response on issues at Beaver Valley 2, Maine Yankee, and Farley 1 and 2.
Beaver Valley's plan to use CO, as the main fire suppression system in the cable spreading room along with a fire brigade backup has been accepted provided the applicant justifies that its systems will function satisfactorily in a congested area of the room or provides plans for a modification.
Presently, the staff has no indication when to expect this justification. Also, the staff is uncertain when it will receive Maine Yankee's evaluation of an updated SER concerning installation of redundant level indicators and low level alarms on the DWST. However, in the case of Farley, the staff expects to receive the licensee's submittal concerning
[
testing intervals for containment purge and vent valves by September 30, 1985.
b qDennis74 c/
~
. Crutch iel, ssis ant Director for Safety Assessme t l
Division of Licensing
Enclosure:
As stated cc: see next page
Contact:
P. Tremblay, ORAB X27952 l
l
Hugh L. Thompson cc:
H. Denton, D/NRR D. Eisenhut, DD/NRR R. Bernero, D/DSI J. Knight, D/DE G. Lainas AD/0R T. Novak, AD/L R. Bosnak, AD/CSE F. Cherny, MEB W. Johnston, AD/MCET V. Benaroya, CHEB J. Kudrick, CSB L. Rubenstein, AD/ CPS
- 0. Parr, ASB W. Houston.-AD/RS
SECTION 1: STATUS OF ISSUES
( '
l l
9 4
." s.2 e.
a
. t. b.'*
-ie b.
e
.,T f.*'."*
.***.. ~. ~. ~ -'.. 'g~
F....
A.E S.m..* eI
$@g
.e S Q
.h>
e, 4
b.] I g oeL.
v..
..,9 pat **g m...
.e..
.gg g.
4.
.'h....
.*...... -g..,,e I.'"
- r N 0 N E.
B b
E
,f g
,G..I
' O 2
g gta s.*
-~
44 eeW bSe e-w e
e.9g.,
,4%99 9
- 4.,[ ff*
G
.$ 9. h w g
- f ygg
>pq$q$gge e..
v-pL,w
.g
- e. e.
ee.
y s A.=
seeeme
.e
. s e w
- j, s p o e s,. e e, +.-~ ewp-a
.e.. pee
.+
s.
s m.
L g,-......
Of4*
8
.P& S
.e.
6,g h &.
D.e pegh p q
h e k m.
e m 4s
- ewoe, e
a e
e.m
-8, b eae%
38 pg9 W99 p p. P S )'m
'e p*y e*gh" 6
b
.,t-
),. e..ee 4
p..,. e..
.i.ee smg.,
r.,....a
, - be 0
'g
. o.
e e..
.pw
,a *e
/.
..h*.
O m,3, wap
&W
- ee De...,-
,,I.le.
I b
.e
,., = = -, =,,..,
go ee.
.e.,
e
,a e e em,s m.
s.
m e
me e
D
4 4
0 I ;I M i
.s.'.S*.
%h b
g D
4.
Oe
=.,. -.tp...)..,..,.-
...af,,...,.,
..,,.,-..,,.,.,i 4.
b.......
p.....,>...('w,.
p..
to e..e
- e*
9 C,.s g 9.**
1...
ha'**
i*Je P. i.T.8g P
TM T
am9
. i se
.e.
4.
D' " [#gt*g...
h"P;e.
N0NE I
6 t
I f
a l-I e
6 i
l t
1
--~----n....-.
~
.. -. -.~-
f
+
f
]
s f
Sa;e t.
., eg.;t.
t
=
- ..+.
- 4i f. e. PI (*f.fyC 19.* b f
- y (
- f f j!. ' !. C.f. *. f
- C " * ".? ! *
- 4
.. -....s P. = ; g * *16*g a; e t 't;l g *;
. f. * *,a. ' g a, i
.t t.
i
..v.....
L I
t '. a -
- . ; p-
?:: :
. ; t. e. "..
gg?
A.- f.*=;
- t t. ;.*; r t *
- t. t
- r ai.-.k.
4
.. ; g.},-
- t. *. : T. L. '3';..'??
>LL..? C'** C}CC. :;'*
f t..* !., f. ;
l l
- ?. E*05 6
E
^
C 1
I t
l l
I I
a i
i i
I e
i l,
P t
6 i
e f
I P
e l
b 6
I t
h I
I b
f 4
i 6
d I
i t'
i i
s i
F I
I
- - ~v v we,
+wm* s r +r m wwww
,*v
.ww -
.=
e
.*i'5 M, y :,, ;., : e.
r s.
7,...1.'.'
2,,,"'.
...d.......,
4-La., :... :,, *
- r*.,.... \\.. 'J.
- 1%
..t *
- g * *..'
- g ';.. &,6 '. -
-e..
.. 7
,hg,
.g(,.
p r e,pg.
M.S9
.6,,'
Dee.
..*g gl I3) yp ye fD
- =2.'
, *
- f *. g -.
1 N0NE i
4 a
I I
I i
1 i
1 4
d I
f f
f I
(
1 h
i i.
I I
l 7
c__
..m
.m.., _ _
m.,
..m_.,,,.m
.,m..,y.7
a
[ r...* 4 s
.e
.9.e..,
y.
in..
.,.g.
...e9.
..S
(
+,e E.e eI,,...
6 g,.9+.
- 7.gye.,
6......e p.
,9.p*......i'.*.
g.
,...* k'.*.
- 4*
h b =. ~.
4.....g.
h..
.E....
\\^
......... 9 4
o.
p
=t 6
..y
..'t*.=
s.
...i.,.... *......
=
...e
.g...
g
+.
d......
b.-...
- p....
.g
..e.
...p.
=k
.h.
......,, g.
..p..me..g s., a.e...
..E..
(.......\\
e
.L..
...*. I.
...,..e j
. g r..,.
. i
....t.
s.'
- f..
...gf....
2....
...e..
- e e
s
..*e....... a g.
....g
,4..,e
,4.
.......... n a
...i....
.we 4.h H,
e t....... ).
- c... \\. r...=.. r.
.....g.
.9.,.
g
.......,.,.g p
r
...e.
(,..
4 4,.
s..
i..
7 f.,.g i.
4 8
...I....s.
. g,. )
g
.f....
..f
.al...
.--6.&
t.. g.-..
- a -
.g e..
.a e
.*e e
e I.
+..e.
n
.6 g
........g 3.....
e....
e9*
=,aw
- e... e 4 e.
e g
+..
,a g
3
....e.
u..I, W(.
C.....,
(,g
...4.....
...,9
.... g
...b.
e.
.p,i.
.o g
..e....
..g
.3 e
p+
e...
.d f
a
.... p
,9
......D
.,.. ; *+ g
.*..k g....
5.
........t.9**4 l
o e.,
y t
9..
+
.. i.
..4.
.. 9.
...D
..fr.
ge.
..s g...
-h*
- d
.4g w..
....p,,.
.l,......
,..,.pp
- b.....
8.
.*=e*.
6
.p
.c.
,..s g i,.
g
.....s........
4...
...d
...g
.. *.....-* y p.
.a ei.
.\\
t
.. 6 t;
e
%.....e
.e..
..."'F,
..Wd
- T.
'-**4 t
..e
..W
..g g..
..... g..
p.*,
.w
,d..
.... 3..,,,..a.
K.6
......g..
. e..
e.
I
...C.
4 h
r
.4 *......
,,,....e E.......
I....
6 9
...I
- r.,..- r.
...E.*
.t**
\\.*
1 p,
..g.9.
r..
,.g
,e4>>*g
.....-... 9.%
i',
+
p.
.,.,.s...,....
I e.2.
g..
... r e.-
e b,...*
p e I 18..
s.,
g p.. 4....,.. =,..
F C.
e.
e t
i b
c'*.
g
... r.. r.
+.*..
e..
e.
r.-
.- r
- .t*.,
.9
. \\.-..
em I
4 P
k p.
...ja
,e,...
4,. *. e C.
.g,g 4 g.9
....,,, e%_
g e..,
. a.
. g
..b
.....,er, p,.
..p.
. is i
.n..
,.il,.
. g.....
,t.
...c
-.7 p..
3 el t
.t.
..g.,..
........o
.......r
..p.-
e-e.
-->s r
- w, g
.r..,,
- p......
t s.
p 2
4
.p C.....
6.,
t ee.,
.)
g.
..p 4 !.,
}.
j
,...... I.....,..
e 9..,
..q
..g
.o
)
e 6.
g 4
g
......,,,.t*
,t.
s.. *,....
s.
s....
..... T.., r. 3
\\,
i r.
6 r
e.
...,g,
.,C.
e.-.,.
......6 45,
\\.
. j...
.g
.q.y t.
-l
..4 t
o.,
.a.....,.
, I 6,...........
,f
.c j
I l
.o.
T.
g pyw,..
, g...
.a
+
g.
.g
.s 7
4 g.
g.
8 t
g.
s.
i
...r.
p
- p*.
..g..'.t g g, e. t
%...4jg.
- g.
).
...i..
g a
... 4 t
9 4
6 g
e*g 0'.%
g
'E q
n f
h f
i l
9
,.,,---n n..
.,-.,,--..,.mn,w, c
--,.a
--. - _. ~
s
- +
o o
i s.g 6
.e m
k
%e gee es DDee..mt
&gB
=
9, o+
p
=ey 9-
==
b eO eo he e=='9
, qq,9 9
m epgD P
e p*
ep qD.**
=
feoe.
4.gg
.h.
.h.-.
ID6e
>h g$
6g.
..e a
w w
e 9 ~. e. o e
4 4' t o e
...w=
e ~
e.*
ese.r
,e
=
.eeea e
us
>WW e
g '
,a.
.s e e.6-s i...
.4...-
4 1.p
.ee...
yp*
=
e ew=
g( pg ye T.e a..*
a _u e
oe g
.. v.. g. >,,
t..
- s...-...
i e
M.
- e e.
o.
c., %. t
...s..-.
s
,I.
E *....
.g h'.
..- 9
.s e
g
..=
s.
5 e
9
.-,-won.,-w.w,,-,-
-w----,,~.
SECTION 2: MASTER LISTING OF CURRENT ISSUES O
e
_ - -,~...~.._
-. - - _.. ~. - -. -
I NRC-1215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC 8ACKFIT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.*
1 MASTER F ILE LISTING ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01 TO 85/12/31 BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCRIPTION:
BACKFIT ID: RL8EAV28500T REOMT~TDENTTFTED'IN 02/fi'SER
- 05/20/84 APPLICANT BKFT CLAIM 10/05/84 MTG; 11/06/84 STAFF MSITION 11/20/84 APPLIC LTR 01/10/85 STAFF POSITION DOCKET NO.: 050-00412
-09/26/84 AD LEVEL MTG.i!NG REQUEST 02/13/85 APPLICANT MEE FACILITY:
BEAVER VALLEY 2 02/28/85 DO MEETING 03/13/85 DD SITE VISIT FOR DD POSITION DETERMINATION BACKFIT ISSUE SUBSTANCE!
THE7PPETCANTTDESIGN-"TS A DEVIATION FROM THE SRP (SECTION C.T.C OF BTP CMES 9.5-1) WHICH THE APPLICANT HAS NOT JUSTIFIED AS REQUIRED BY 10CFR50.34(G). APPLICANT BELIEVES ITS CO2 FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM IN THE CABLE SPREADING ROOM
~
MEETS THE INTENT OF BTP-CME 8 9.5-1 AND COMPLIES WITH 10CFR50 DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED):
REQUIREMENTS.
DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED):
REF. DL CODE : L-84-10 BACKFIT DETERMINED:
DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE:
DETERMINATION ORG:
DETERMINATION OFFICIAL:
REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
i APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTION /STATUSl APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/0i/11 CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION-CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED): 85/DT/11 DD'POSITIOCACCEPTE!FTRE~ APPLICANT *S USE OF CO2 AS THE MAIN FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEM IN THE CABLE SPREADING ROOM ALONG CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION: NRR/DL WITH FIRE BRIGADE BACKUP.IN ORDER TO CLOSE THIS ISSUE. THE t
APPLICANT MUST PROVIDE JUSTIFICATION THAT ITS SYSTEM WILL CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL: THOMPSON, H FUNCTION SATISFACTORILY IN A CONGESTED AREA OF THE ROOM OR PROVIDE PLANS FOR A MODIFICATION.
-., - _ _ _ _ - ~. _, _ _ _. _.. -.. _.
-..._--,m_
1 NRC-1215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKF IT TRACKING SYSTEM HASTER F ILE LISTING PAGE NO.
8 ALL FACILITIES 85/01/01 TO 85/12/31 RUN DATE: 09/24/85 BACKFIT ID: RLMAINE85004 BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCRIPTION-06 /04/84 ~ REQUIREMENT ~TDENTIF IED DOCKET NO.
050-00309 09/28/84 - LICENSEE APPEALED BY LETTER 11/08/84 - NEW INFORMATION PROVIDED AT AD LEVEL APPEAL MTG FACILITY:
MAINE YANKEE 05/14/85 -
UPDATED SER SENT TO LICENSEE 06/11/85 - LICENSEE LETTER CLAIMED BACKFIT 07/16/85 - DSI BKFT DETERM COMPLETE;08/14/85 DST REVIEW COMP BACKFIT ISSUE SUBSTANCE:
THE STAFF ~HAS~ REQUESTED'AN LCO ON THE TURBINE DRIVEN AFW PUMP NOT TO EXCEED 7 DAYS.
IS NEEDED.
THE LICENSEE MAINTAINS NO LCO ADEQUATEl. (CURRENT LCO*S ON MOTOR DRIVEN PUMPS ARE DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/08/30
~
REF. DL CODE: OR-84-25 DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED):
BACKFIT DETERMINED:
DETERMINATION ORG:
DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE:
DETERMINATION OFFICIAL:
REG. ANALYSIS CCMPLETE DATE:
APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTIONf_ STATUS:
~
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/08/26 CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED): 85/08/26 CLOSTNG ACTION DESCRIPTION-MAINE ~VANXEE~ LETTER"WETHDREW BACKFIT CLAIM.
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION: LICENSEE INPUT BROM STAFF, BASED ON NEW SPECS LIMITING THE TIMELICENSEE AGREED TO SUBMIT PROPOSED TECH MAY BE OPERABLE IN ACCORDANCE WITH STAFF POSITION.THAT CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
e
l NRC-1215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKF IT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.:
8 MASTER F ILE LISTING l
ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01 TO 85/12/31 BACKFJT/ PETITION DESCRIPTW BACKFIT ID: RLFARL185002 II/7s EETTEW70'~ ALE LTCE;eSEES AND PRIOR STAFF POSITIONS SRP 6.2.4, BTP CSS 6-4 DOCKET NO.: 050-00348 04/19/85 - LICENSEE LETTER CLAIMED BACKFIT I
06/13/85 - DETERM LETTER COMPLETED THAT NOT A BACKFIT I
FACILITY:
FARLEY 1 07/24/85 - LICENSEE TELECON RESULTED IN HOLD ON NRC RESPONSE 09/30/85 - LICENSEE TO SUBMIT ALTERNATIVE TESTS FOR REVIEW BACKFIT ISSUE SUSSTANCE-CONTATNMENT VENT ~A F PUWGE OPERATION IS DONE CON 1INUOUSLY THROUGH 3 IM. MINI-PURGE VALVES.
LICENSEE PERFORMS LEAKAGE TESTING OF THESE 8 IN. NORMALLY OPEN VALVES AS WELL AS 48 i
IN. NORMALLY CLOSED VALVES WITH RESILIENT SEALS AT 18 MO.
l INTERVALS. THE STAFF BELIEVES THAT THE 8 IN. VALVES SHOULD DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/06/30 BE TESTED EVERY 3 MOS, AND THE 48 IN, VALVES EVERY 6 MOS.
DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED):
REF. DL CODE: 04-85-07 BACKFIT DETERMINED:
DETERMINATION SUSSTANCE:
DETERMINATION ORG:
DETERMINATION OFFICIAL:
REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
l APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS:
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
I CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
l CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION; l
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
l CLOSING ACTICM CRGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
l l, _.. _ _, _, -. _ - _ _ -
- ~.- - - - - -
= - -.
- - - ~.
(
M I
NRC-1215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKFIT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.:
T MASTER FILE LISTING ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01 TO 85/12/31 BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCR PT ON:
BACKFIT ID: RLFARL285D01 11/75 LETTEW701LTET EE5 AND PRIOR STAFF POSITIONS SRP 6.2.4, BTP CS8 6-4 l
DOCKET NO.: 050-00364 04/19/85 - LICENSEE LETTER CLAIMING BACKFIT l
06/13/85 - DETERM LETTER THAT NOT A BACKFIT COMPLETED FACILITY:
FARLEY 2 07/24/85 - LICENSEE TELECON RESULTED IN HOLD ON NRC kESPONSE 09/30/85 - LICENSEE TO SUOMIT ALTERNATIVE TESTS FOR REVIEW BACKFIT ISSUE SUBSTANCE?
CONTAT15ENT VENT AMFPURGE OPERATION IS DONE CONTINUOUSLY THROUGH 3 IN. MINI-PURGE VALVES. LICENSEE PERFORMS LEAKAGE TESTING OF THESE 8 IN. NORMALLY OPEN VALVES AS WELL AS 48 IN. NORMALLY CLOSED VALVES WITH RESILTENT SEALS AT 18 MO.
INTERVALS. THE STAFF BELIEVES THAT THE 8 IN. VALVES SHOULD DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/06/30 BE TESTED EVERY 3 MOS. AND THE 48 IN. VALVES EVERY 6 MOS.
DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED):
REF. DL CODE : OR-85-07 BACKFIT DETERMINED:
DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE:
DETERMINATION ORG:
DETERMINATION OFFICIAL:
REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
i APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS:
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
1 APPEAL ORGAMIZATION:
CPPEAL OFFICIAL:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
CLOSING ACTIM DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
i
,.-.--c..
--,.w._rw
___-,-%,_+-.--,.-.,,-ye-wv.,-.,
,y-y-y.
.v.
-m.
-~.3,,
-,.w..,,..---+
,-.4-3
..<_y...---,,v, w-
l l
s NRC-I215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC
'8 A C K F I T TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.:
9 MASTEW FILE LISTING ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01 10 85/12/31 BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCR{TDENTTFIED IN SER PTION:
BACKFIT ID: RLMAINE85005 06/04/IT ; ROUTRDENT 09/28/84 - LICENSEE CLAIMED SACKFIT DOCKET NO.: 050-00309 11/08/84 - AD LEVEL MEETING 05/14/85 - UPDATED SER SENT TO LICENSEE FACILITY:
MAINE YANKEE LICENSEE EVALUATING SER 8ACKFIT ISSUE SU8 STANCE:
THE 5TATFRE00ESTED~THAT THE LICENSEE INSTALL REDUNDANT LEVEL INDICATORS AND LOW LEVEL ALARMS ON DWST.
THE LICENSEE MAINTAINS THAT THE CURRENT SYSTEM IS ADEQUATE e
SINCE DWST IS DEDICATED TO THE AFW SYSTEM.
DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED):
REF. DL CODE : OR-84-26 DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED):
BACKFIT DETERMINED:
I l
DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE:
DETERMINATION ORG:
DETERMINATION OFFICIAL:
REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
1 APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS:
OPPEAL DATE (CCMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
n--.
,--v.---.
-.s,
o NRC-12I5302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKFIT TRACK ING SYSTEM PAGE NO.:
12 i
MASTER FILE LISTING 1
ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 35/01/01 TO 85/12/31 BACKFIT P TITION DESCRIPTION-l BACKFIT ID: RLTHREIS5002 10/27/8 ENTITTED TC ETAFF REVIEW OF IST 07/10/84 - LICENSEE UPDATE OF 2ND 10 YR IST i
DOCKET NO.. 050-00289 10/23/84 AND 12/11/84 - STAFF POSITIONS 03/18/85 - LICENSEE APPEAL REQUEST FACILITY:
THREE MILE ISLAND 1 04/20/85 - STAFF LETTER TO LICENSEE l
BACKFIT ISSUE SUBSTANCE:
THr5TATT DENTED THE LICENSEE'S REQUEST FOR RELIEF FROM TESTING OF BORIC ACID PUMPS AND NON-PIVS AND INCLUSION OF THIS IN T/S FOR BOTH THE FIRST AND SECOND 10-YR IST PROGRAMS FOR PUMPS AND VALVES.
THE LICENSEE BELIEVES THE REQUIRED TESTING IS IMPRACTICAL AND EXCESSIVELY COSTLY.
THE LICENSEE l
DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/07/15 MAINTAINS THAT STANDARD LANGUAGE IS INCLUDED IN THE T/S l
AND THE STAFF'S REQUIREMENTS WOULD SERVE NO USEFUL PURPOSE 1
DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED): 85/08/16 AND WOULD DETRACT FROM SAFETY.
BACKFIT DETERMI';ED: NO REF. OL CODE: OR-85-06
)
i DETERMINATION SU8 STANCE?
DETERMINATION ORG: NRR/DL APPLICABLENEUULATORY 5TAFF POSITIONS WHICH HAVE ALREADY BEEN IMPOSED UPON OR CODMITTED TO BY A LICENSEE ARE NOT DETERMINATION OFFICIAL: DENTON. H BACKFITS. ALSO. 10CRF50.55A HAS AUTOMATIC UPDATE FEATURES.
THEREFORE LICENSEES CANNOT CLAIM BACKFIT BECAUSE THESE REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
AUTOMATIC UPDATE FEATURES REQUIRE PLANT CHANGES.
APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS:
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
- ~
4
~ htC-1315302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKFIT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.:
I3 MASTER FILE LISTING s
ALL FACILITIES 85/01/01 IO 45/12/31 RUN DATE: 09/24/85
~ BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCRIPTION-BACKFIT ID: RLWATTI85002 REQUININDITIDENTITIEFTCGd83-28 04/23/85 - STAFF REQUESTED ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DOCKET NO.: 050-00390 05/31/85 - LICENSEE LETTER CLAIMED BACKFIT FACILITY:
WATTS BAR 1
~
BACKFIT ISSUE SussTANCE:
TVA-~ CONTEND 5 PAT THE STAFF'S REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON GL 83-28, ITEM 2.2 (EQUIPMENT CLASSIFICATION AND VENDOR INTERFACE) APPEARS TO REQUIRE M3RE THAN REQUIRED BY NUREG-1000 AND GL 83-28.
DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTEDI: 85/06/20 REF. DL CODE: L-85-08 DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED}: 85/08/I9 BACKFIT DETERMINED: NO DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE-DETERMINATION ORG: MRR/DL CL73 21 WAS REVNEY BOTH THE CRGR AND THE COMMISSION, i
THEREFORE ANY REQUIREMENTS CONTAINED THEREIN WERE PROPERLY DETERMINATION OFFICIAL: DENTON, H ENDORSED FOR GENERIC APPLICATION PRIOR TO ISSUANCE. PLANT-SPECIFIC REQUESTS FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DO NOT CONTAIN REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
ANY NEW POSITIONS BEYOND THGSE ALREADY DETAILED IN GL 83-28.
APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS:
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
i-CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
i CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
l:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
l' t
?
6
.,, -, -, - - - - -. ~
-n, r.
y I
l l
NRC-1215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKFIT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.:
14 MASTER FILE LISTING ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01 TO 85/12/31 i
BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCRIPTION-BACKFIT ID: RLWATT285001 REQUIRNKT TDENTIFIEU~TN"GL"83-28
'l 04/23/85 - STAFF REQUESTED ADDITIONAL INFORMATION I
DOCKET NO.
050-00391 05/31/85 - LICENSEE LETTER CLAIMED BACKFIT t
FACILITY:
WATTS BAR 2 8
I BACKFIT TSSUE SUBSTANCE-TVA CONTENDS THAT THE STAFF'S REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON GL 33-28 ITEM 2.2 (EQUIPMENT CLASSIFICATION AND VENDOR INTERFACE) APPEARS TO REQUIRE MORE THAN REQUIRED BY NUREG-1000 AND GL 83-28.
DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/06/20 REF.'DL CODE:OR-85-08 I
DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED): 85/08/19 i
BACKFIT DETERMINEO: NO t
DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE:
DETERMINATION ORG: NRR/DL GMF287A57EVIEWED BV BOTH THE CRGR AND THE COMMISSION, l
THEREFORE ANY REQUIREMENTS CONTAINED THEREIN WERE PROPERLY DETERMINATION OFFICIAL: DENTON, H ENDORSED FOR GENERIC APPLICATION PRIOR TO ISSUANCE. PLANT-SPECIFIC REQUESTS FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DO NOT CONTAIN e
REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
ANY NEW POSITIONS BEYOND THOSE ALREADY DETAILED IN GL 83-28.
t APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
i APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS:
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
4 APPEAL OFFICIAL:
j f
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
1 CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
i 1
)
l
};
~
~ _,
~
NRC-1815302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKFIT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.:
10-MASTER FILE LISTING ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01 TO 85/12/31 BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCRIPTION'*
BACKFIT ID: RLSEQU185002 REQUIR M NT~TDENTIFIED IN GE 83-28 04/23/85 - STAFF REQUESTED ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DOCKET NO.
050-00327 05/31/85 - LICENSEE LETTER CLAIMED BACKFIT FACILITY:
SEQUOYAH 1 BACKFIT ISSUE SUBSTANCE-TVA CONTENDS 7 HAT THESTAFF *S REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON GL 83-28 ITEM 2.2 (EOUIPMENT CLASSIFICATION AND VENDOR INTERFACE) APPEARS TO REQUIRE MORE THAN REQUIRED BY NUREG-1000 AND GL 83-28.
DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/06/20 REF. DL CODE:L-85-09 DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED): 85/08/19 BACKFIT DETERMINED: NO DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE:
DETERMINATION ORG: NRR/DL GLT3 28 WArltEVIEWEU BFBOTH THE CRGR AND THE Cope 4ISSION, THEREFORE ANY REQUIREMENTS CONTAINED THEREIN WERE PROPERLY DETERMINATION OFFICIAL: DENTON, H ENOORSED FOR GENERIC APPLICATION PRIOR TO ISSUANCE. PLANT-
' SPECIFIC REQUESTS FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DO NOT CONTAIN REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
ANY NEW POSITIONS BEYOND THOSE ALREADY DETAILED IN GL 83-28.
APPLAL DATE (PREDICTED):
- a APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS:
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
w' E
NRC-1215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKFIT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.-
II MASTER FILE LISTING s
ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01 10 85/12/31 BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCRIPTION 83-28 BACKFIT ID: RLSEQU285001 REQUIREENT TDENTIFIED TN' GL 04/23/85 - STAFF REQUESTED ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DOCKET NO.- 050-00328 05/31/85 - LICENSEE LETTER CLAIMED BACKFIT FACILITY:
SEQUOYAH 2 BACKFIT ISSUE SUBSTANCE?
TVA CONTEND 5'THAT7HE 5TAFF'S REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON GL 83-28, ITEM 2.2 (EQUIPMENT CLASSIFICATION AND VENDOR INTERFACE) APPEARS TO REQUIRE MORE THAN REQUIRED BY NUREG-1000 AND GL 83-28.
DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/06/20 REF. DL CODE: L-85-09 DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED): 85/08/19 BACKFIT DETERMINED: NO DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE?
DETERMINATION ORG: NRR/DL GE 3372I~RA5 REVIEWED BY BOTH THE CRGR AND THE COMMISSION.
THEREFORE ANY REQUIREMENTS CONTAINED THEREIN WERE PROPERLY DETERMINATION OFFICIAL: DENTON, H ENDORSED FOR GENERIC APPLICATION PRIOR TO ISSUAr4CE. PLANT-SPECIFIC REQUESTS FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DO NOT CONTAIN REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
ANY NEW POSITIONS BEYOND THOSE ALREADY DETAILED IN GL 83-28.
APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS;_
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
I t
e NRC-1215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC
'B-A C K F IT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.-
2 MASTE&
F ILE LISTING ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01.TO 85/12/31 BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCRIPTION:
BACKFIT ID: RLBROW185002 REQUTMMRT TDENTIFIEU~TN 'GE 83-28 04/23/85 - STAFF REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DOCKET NO.. 050-00259 05/31/85 - LICENSEE LETIER CLAIMED BACKFIT FACILITY:
BROWNS FERRY 1
^
BACKFIT ISSUE SUBSTANCE TVA CONTENDS THAT THE~~ STAFF 'S' REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION.ON GL 83-28, ITEM 2.2 (EQUIPMENT CLASSIFICATION AND VENDOR INTERFACE) APPEARS TO RE WIRE MORE THAN v.
REQUIRED BY NUREG-1000 AND GL 83-28.
DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED):.85/06/20 REF. DL CODE: OR-85-10 DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED): 85/08/19 BACKFIT DETERMINED: NO
^
DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE:
DETERMINATION ORG: NRR/DL Gl.739FVASlEVIEWED' EV CRGR AND THE COMMISSION, THEREFORE ANY REOUIREMENTS CONTAINED THEREIN WERE PROPERLY ENDORSED DETERMINATION OFFICIAL: DENTON,H FOR GENERIC APPLICATION PRIOR TO ISSUANCE. THE PLANT-SPECIFIC REQUESTS FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DO NOT CONTAIN REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
ANY NEW POSITIONS BEYOND THOSE DETAILED IN GL 83-28.
APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS:
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
s
NRC-1215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKFIT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO.:
3 MASTER FILE LISTING ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01 TO 85/12/31 BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCRIPTION"-
BACKFIT ID: RLBROW285001 REQUIRNNT~TDENTIFIED TM'GE 83-28 04/23/85 - STAFF REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFDRMATION DOCKET NO.
050-00260 05/31/85 - LICENSEE LETTER CLA1MED BACKFIT FACILITY:
BROWNS' FERRY 2 BACKFIT ISSUE SUBSTANCE:
TVA CONTENDS ~7 HAT THE STAFF'S REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON GL 83-28 ITEM 2.2 (EQUIPMENT CLASSIFICATION AND VENDOR INTERFACE) AkPEARS TO REQUIRE MORE THAN REQUIRED BY NUREG-1000 AND GL 83-28.
DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/06/20 REF. DL CODE: OR-85-10 DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED): 85/08/19 BACKFIT DETERMINED: NO
' DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE:
DETERMINATION ORG: NRR/DL
'GL 83 28" RAS REVIEWEU BY BOTH THE CRGR AND THE COMMISSION, THEREFORE ANY REOUIREMENTS CONTAINED THEREIN WERE PROPERLY DETERMINATION OFFICIAL: DENTON, H ENDORSED FOR GENERIC APPLICATION PRIOR TO ISSUANCE. PLANT-SPECIFIC REQUESTS FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DO NOT REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
CONTAIN ANY NEW POSITIONS BEYOND THOSE ALREADY DETAILED IN GL 83-28.
APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
pp p
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL:
1 9
r--
., ~...,, ~.,.,,
,-.__.,,.y
,_.n..-
.m.._
._.--...e,--
.w.-
y
0 NRC-1215302-001 PLANT SPECIFIC BACKFIT TRACKING SYSTEM PAGE NO..
5 MASTER F I.L E LISTING ALL FACILITIES RUN DATE: 09/24/85 85/01/01 TO 85/12/31 BACKFIT/ PETITION DESCRIPTION 2 BACKFIT ID: RLBROW385001 REQUIRMNT TDENTIFIE5 TN~CL 83-28 04/23/85 - STAFF REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DOCKET NO.- 050-00296 05/31/85 - LICENSEE LETTER CLAIMED BACKFIT FACILITY:
BROWNS FERRY 3 BACKFIT ISSUE SUBSTANCE-TVA-CONTEND 5 THATN 5TAFF 'S REQUEST FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ON GL 83-28 ITEM 2.2 (EQUIPMENT CLASSIFICATION AND VENDOR INTERFACE APfEARS TO REQUIRE MORE THAN REQUIRED BY NUREG-1000 AND GL 83-28.
DETERMINATION DATE (PREDICTED): 85/06/20 REF. DL CODE: OR-85-10 DETERMINATION DATE (COMPLETED): 85/08/19 BACKFIT DETERMINED: NO DETERMINATION SUBSTANCE:
DETERMINATION ORG: NRR/DL GE~87;28"WA5 REVIEWED BV BOTH THE CRGR AND THE COMMISSION, THEREFORE ANY REQUIREMENTS CONTAINED THEREIN WERE PROPERLY DETERMINATION OFFICIAL: DENTON, H ENDORSED FOR GENERIC APPLICATION PRIOR TO ISSUANCE. PLANT-SPECIFIC REQUESTS FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION DO NOT CONTAIN REG. ANALYSIS COMPLETE DATE:
ANY NEW POSITIONS BEYOND THOSE ALREADY DETAI!ED IN GL 83-28.
APPEAL DATE (PREDICTED):
APPEAL DESCRIPTION / STATUS:
APPEAL DATE (COMPLETED):
APPEAL ORGANIZATION:
APPEAL OFFICIAL:
^
CLOSING ACTION DATE (PREDICTED):
CLOSING ACTION DESCRIPTION:
CLOSING ACTION DATE (COMPLETED):
CLOSING ACTION ORGANIZATION:
CLOSING ACTION OFFICIAL: