ML20133F497
| ML20133F497 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | North Anna  |
| Issue date: | 12/20/1996 |
| From: | Belisle G NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION II) |
| To: | Ohanlon J VIRGINIA POWER (VIRGINIA ELECTRIC & POWER CO.) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9701140228 | |
| Download: ML20133F497 (34) | |
Text
..
Decenber 20, 1996 l
Virginia Electric and Power Company ATTN: Mr. J. P. O'Hanlon Senior Vice President - Nuclear 4
Innsbrook Technical Center 5000 Dominion Boulevard Glen Allen VA 23060
SUBJECT:
MEETING
SUMMARY
- NORTH ANNA PERFORMANCE NORTH ANNA DOCKET NOS. 50-338, 50-339
Dear Mr. O'Hanlon:
This refers to the meeting conducted at your request at the NRC Region II Office in Atlanta, Georgia on December 18, 1996. The meeting's. purpose was to discuss North Anna performance.
It is our opinion that this meeting was beneficial in that it provided us with a better understanding of North Anna's performance. Specific topics discussed i
included an introduction, historical regulatory trend, action plan and current performance, and closing remarks.
A list of attendees and a copy of your handout is enclosed.
In accordance with Sect-ion 2.790 of the NRC's " Rules of Practice." Part 2, Title 10 Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this letter and its enclosures will be placed in the NRC Public Document Room.
Should you have any questions concerning this letter, please contact us.
Sincerely, Original signed by George A. Belisle George A. Belisle, Chief Reactor Projects Branch 5 Division of Reactor Projects Docket Nos. 50 338, 50 339 License Nos. NPF 4, NPF 7
)
Enclosure:
- 1. List of Attendees
- 2. North Anna Performance
(
December 18, 1996 i
cc w/encls:
See page 2 t
140082 9701140228 961220 PDR ADOCK 05000338 P
PDR g5
m__..._
1 l
VEPC0 2
l CC W/enCls:
M. L. Bowling, Manager Nuclear Licensing and Operations Support r
l Virginia Electric & Power Company Innsbrook Technical Center 5000 Dominion Boulevard l
Glen Allen, VA 23060 l
W. R. Matthews, Manager North Anna Power Station l
P. O. Box 402 l
Mineral, VA 23117 l
D. A. Christian, Manager l
Surry Power Station Virginia Electric & Power Company 5570 Hog Island Road Surry, VA 23883 Executive Vice President Old Dominion Electric Cooperative 4201 Dominion Boulevard Glen Allen. VA 23060 Dr. W. T. Lough Virginia Corporation Commission Division of Energy Regulation P. O. Box 1197 Richmond, VA 23209 William C. Porter, Jr.
County Administrator Louisa County P. O. Box 160 Louisa. VA 23093 Michael W. Maupin, Esq.
Hunton and Williams Riverfront Plaza, East Tower 951 E. Byrd Street Richmond, VA 23219 Attorney General Supreme Court Building 900 East Main Street i
Richmond, VA 23219 l
l cc w/encls:
See page 3 l
1 i
3
VEPC0 3
cc w/encls continued:
Robert B. Strobe, M.D., H.P.H.
State Health Comissioner Office of the Comissioner Virginia Department of Health P. O. Box 2448 Richmond, VA 23218 Distribution w/encls:
B. Buckley, NRR R. Gibbs, RII P. Fillion, RII D. Jones RII W. Stansberry, RII C. Payne, RII PUBLIC NRC Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission 1024 Haley Drive Mineral, VA 23117 NRC Resident Inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Surry Nuclear Power Station 5850 Hog Island Road Surry, VA 23883 l
0FFICE Rf f OR9 n
$tGNATURE NAME LGdberhit DATE 12 / d/%
12 /
/%
12 /
/%
12 /
/ 96 12 /
/%
12 /
/%
COPY?
- h No VES NO YES N0 YES NO YES NO YES NO l
OFFICIAL REEORD COPY DOCUMENT WNE: G:\\NANTG.5JM
{
. _ _ _. _ _ _ _ _. _ _ _ _ - _.. _. ~. _. _ _.. _ - _. _... _ _. _ _.
l LIST OF ATTENDEES NRC Attendees:
E. W. Herschoff, Director Division of Reactor Projects (DRP)
J. P. Jaudon, De>uty Director, Division of Reactor Safety (DRS)
G. A. Belisle, C11ef, Reactor Projects Branch 5. DRP R. D. McWhorter, Senior Resident Inspector, North Anna Power Station C. A. Casto, Chief. Engineering Branch (EB) DRS C. D. Payne, Licensing Examiner, Operator Licensing and Human Performance Branch, DRS P. J. Fillion, Reactor Inspector, EB, DRS Licensee Attendees:
M. R. Kansler, Vice President, Nuclear Operations W. R. Matthews, Station Manager, North Power Station (NAPS)
D. A. Heacock, Assistant Station Manager, Nuclear Safety and Licensing, NAPS M. S. McCarthy, Director, Nuclear Oversight, NAPS l
l l
l I
l l
l l
ENCLOSURE 1
l, i
c VIRGINIA POWER North Anna Power Station i
December 18,1996 i
i ENCLOSURE 2
a.-..
s h.a m Mm4m4n.ai..-
mw.-.4%a.i.4esu m
.. - -. _-a4
.a&#
..Asmaa.,ap-4.
--hm i emAh4--,.me..,Am_a4 A
m.wmdd.4m._.i.a.p_.m.-J m.E a
_(
.h-anes
- m. m4.mhani u me d.dr e M 4_e.J,_a gh wc_,ma.A4a.a42
- .Au J
J t
i e
n:<,x o
+%
i
/
s m,
e
$)
- %w!
- m t.-es
/
y, N&
8TMdhhi@hh,w!hMh V
,q kh r
b i
Q G
t a$r$5&nsteanwe5%
kn
~
W l
hh ??in M. W=-ht$
m 1
g r~:r'
>,n j
g s,
a w*.n w
...<e i$
t 1
K Bel _y H. _s@,; e,h g: 'e, 'g'i4 ~ $
k e
e ;.-.
, - - - *~ y.w a v$1fGE[i b,! -tM...Ja.+.!
w
-w sm j
c.
u yM,NA4+s4 w$ $ @e m@w%
w-m,m 3
D I
s y 7,,
W f
b"#f,/,
i sy e
r./ \\
>t w n.
l fp Yf,
fT Q"
4 I
s~~~
I I'.% s lx %,I N s.s
,I s
5 A
y
?x e
Mi.:
i y-N,,a?( 'i g.,
W
^
l lb.,. n%.,s. ie#e%2. ~= u, ?_
- U
.a n
V Y2l. f lMW w.m..f,s$.a. 5
~,+ #- %
)v JM 645hm iCh
,m 6yl.76.w$.,2:cn k
e%
4 s\\
w
%y h.NJ@7 N
T' ow s%p p&e
- is I y l%
4 mNye.,
N
~.x+N w, %,
).
l j
i lI I b, k,{
sfIi1 a
i. -,
s l~.,,
l f
! _ I.
l
? i-
~
b i
i 4
e i
AGENDA i
h i
Introduction M. R. Kansler Historical Regulatory D. A. Heacock Trend i
Action Plan and Current W. R. Matthews Performance l
Closing Remarks M. R. Kansler
VIRGINIA POWER t
t i
4
{
INTRODUCTION I
M. R. Kansler Vice President - Nuclear Operations j
t f
f L
?
i l
r VIRGINIA POWER i
f' I
I e
i i
HISTORICAL REGULATORY TREND i
i D. A. Heacock Assistant Station Manager i
i
i I
?
I I
1 t
Cited Violations i
l
?
l I
14 12 l
10 j
8 E
e i
3 z
6 g
j o
b-4 1
l 2
0 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996*
i l
- Through November 2,1996 i
i 3
)
l r
- ,'k!
I'! I'!'.i!il;itl!tt' i bi; iiIlt
,hll>
- I if!i s
- 6 9
n 9
1 o
i t
6 a
5 9
9 9
l 9
1 1
o 2
i r
V e
b m
4 e
d 9
v 9
e N
o 1
t h
i g
u C
or 3
h 9
9 T
1 n
o N
299 1
4 2
0 8
6 4
2 0
1 1
1 EDE z W oH s
I' ll!,ili!
i!'
i i
Licensee Event Reports I
35-30-i 25-l i
wj 20-5 i
e
(
15-l s
V 1
10-5-
i 0,
i i
i i
1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
- Through November 2,1996
.l l
l
ll;
!l
.!'lIiI!!!!
\\i lf t{ii l3l
[:!l;Iik k
69 9
1 2
R r
E e
L s
b t
m n
ev e
o N
vl
)
Eta hg o
d u
e nT itC or 4
n o3 h
o N
t i(
t 69 a
9 t
1 S
1 y
r d
a e
u itC n
a J
4 2
0 8
6 4
2 O
1 1
1
$Eaz 3N 1I lll li
\\
b
l l
t I
r i
Total Number 8
8 O
N o
m Crystal River St. Lucie Watts Bar h
Vogtle Farley h
a n
t g
Sequoyah f
k E
Hatch i
H m
t Catawba f
o 8
"M O W.
,E g
summer t
gQ McGuire h
?
Brunswick
- o 2
@6 O
w.
Brown's Ferry gQ l
h Turkey et.
M
- w. $
M North Anna
(
Suny M' Robinson E l
Harris E Oconee 4 l
r O
P r
.... ~ -
. - ~ -. -... -...., - - -
l i
i I
Total Number 8
8 I
o m
Crystal River i
St. Lucie i
Watts Bar Sequoyah M
6 I
h Hatch Farley M
N l
Catawba h
numu M f
Brunswick
- Brown's Feny o
Vogtle g
W W
North Anna h
(
Summer d
Q McGuire Ne (f)
[
Harris Oconee Robinson Surry Turkey Pt.
I f
t l
l h
t
i f
Events by Inspection Period (34 Total) i 6'
I 5-i l
4-I Oi i
i i
i 4
i i
1/13/96 2/24/96 4/6/96 5/18/96 6/29/96 8/10/96 9/21/96 11/2/96 I
i E Cited E Non-cited E LERs l
i i
i 1
Events Actually Occurring 1996 (22 Total)
I s
4' 3-
~
L Il n
i E
e o
2-2 E
l O
t-l 0>
1 i
i a
i a
i t
l 1/13/96 2/24/96 4/6/96 5/18/96 6/29/96 8/10/96 9/21/96 11/2/96 f
r l
l l
i E Cited E Non-cited E LERs f
i r
l l
l I
i h
i
,--------,,_-----=.,_,,--m.--~u,m_-aw
,,_,m.
,,m,m4%4e,m
.,,u a y ; a m as.
m,g,pem4 mess. m asum _a4mmuaa AA 4 g we.- A em _w am,.A 4 4.
fsa _W
--A, i
i i
1 e
A e
O e
be 3
o y
a i
e o
a s.
4
%w n
k!0}l0 l
t,, 2, i
U l
4 gm
- -pfJy
' 1; /;lp,yj 1
bll: (kk,$.
..+ nays J
[k 9
b1ggj
- j hh w%e
- e ;,
-au M
, Ulh@l?n.$f, mm n
rYl %('Yl:y; w
s.za Q
l P
m 4"
O
- M
%N m
l C
y em W
Y5 S
eM J
a j
I 4
1
P l
h i
1 Personnel Error Causes (Cited Violations)
Improper Labeling Failure to Follow I
Inadequate Procedure Tracking &
Q f,,,
- /
5.
.., h d 4 $.! p R y $.. m@ m j
Review 2% ' @s :,Qiq.xl-2WW.
1 x<Mi i'qj$jU(Ug(j; Afis?{${dQg-A gJ,
<;'((ciW L' pf:I52 fD.E'E ?^IE I?~
r
^
.:.;g~ glM[:
ejggj@i+f,')9%[ pat i
i S._ p iQ7.v A?
l 3
.a e.rr l
0!i?
I c-e t
I i
I i
Misunderstanding TS Requirements Inadequate Procedure Development i
I h
)
i
l l
i Cited Violations (Actually Occurring in 1996) i P
I i
l l
t Plant Support Operations
~ - [,
'F I
j 4
+
. t.
?
<* c f
- i. N.
c' s
. 'a g,'
o,', s_.. ( }t in g
~7 a.p -",Qt,tfy{S$$pl.7%,q.
_1.
- i5-
,,. ?
77 T2 >yy[{*,
weex, q, ucgg., n, v,.w - ;r v>
- 3. V ? +Nun,,hp;;cm,m;,,n+,{y.
j L-
,ua, L
g QNE ~'*r e pp, d2 iN::
i
\\
\\
i l
f
\\
I i
t t
b Maintenance I
n 1
)
1
)
i 1
l l
l f
i i
i i
l l
l Prompt NRC Reports j
5
\\
,/
4 t
b 3
I E
2 O
l t
i i
i i
i I
4/6/96 5/18/96 6/29/96 8/10/96 9/21/96 11/2/96 I
Six Week Interval Ending 1
(
1 i
t
h I
NRC Prompt Reports By Cause 4/6/96 Through 11/2/96 7_
6_
t s.
l m
.o 4
E
- Ew 3_
l i
o V
2_
I l
1.
l 0
I Design Personnel Equipment Procedure Other Six Week Interval Ending i
i J
m---
r!!:!ijrji i i ;a f
- lr!lt fI l
- i:[t l
3
-69 r
l tQ 2
r 6
e 9
s m
p td s
l r
R m
n D
o e 1-pr 6
6 9
4 eT m_
5 l
R
=
e y
~
4 g
5 nl 9
a m
r m.,
r o
e e
v l
i A
t t 3
ar 5
r 9
e i
a m
t vu l
a r
eQ u
Q 2
D
-59 x
i S
l 1
59 0
0 0
O 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
9 8
5 4
3 2
1 1
y e o-l
)
f I
l North Anna Performance Annunciator Panel t
I Third Quarter 1996
[
I i
.,i..
1 ii1 i
i
. = - - -.. -
Personnel E m - a r~.
Operations
- Maintenance s Radiological NSS Engineering Station 3
Performance Protection Support j
5 4 1..+,
7 i
er fo ance r
Program Operations Mainten:nce Radiation Site Services Engineering Security
[
Program Program Protection Program Program Program r
Performance Program r
1 i
%.,. - w;;g, h.
"& Loss E.{ y (a $sessment y'N,
? e Emergencym; b Safety.
.f,:fyds Safety
I Preparedness;-Q. Prevention Program.
Materials Training F
Regulatory
--_c--
Program Program Performance s
- N @;_ Pfogram;, _
Program
- '90 ProgramD91; d N 2t#
j
..- o m
.m,.
p.,
Planning and W Procedure l 's.
Adherence to Significant and
- : Complacency;'(
Scheduling p p Program 4 e?jf Nuclear Safety Precursor ibAvoidance N Program
&E'L';Q A %
Policy Events lht.p, ; Jg@
i RED
- Significant Weakness Legend YELLOV1 1'
- l -Improvement Needed Third quarter WHITE l
l - Satisfactory a
GREEN IN"WI - Significant Strength 4
l l
1 l
t i
Minor Accidents I
d i
t 40 i
l
-l 35 i
30 l
l i
i
\\
25
\\
u as
.o s
l E
a 20 i
z S
i i
$ 15 j
l 10 i
i 5
I I
i 0
j 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996*
4 I
- Through November 2,1996 i
i I
?
e
i Station Safety
?
i i
18 --
I 1
16 "
I, 14 "
_j b
12 "
i m
10 --
s 3
8~
d l
5 i
l-6--
l l
l 4-p..
l l
0 1
1 1
I I
f i
l l
1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 E First Aid E Recordable E LostTime f
I i
_ =.
WORK PRACTICE
- CAUSAL AXALYSIS
.e ww q,g:.-
rh: >...- s ~m.., r.
e,:x m:,u.M.saren--
._.g.._
WORKPRACTICES O Procedure Usage O Briefings
@ Self-Checking
@ Personnel Safety
~
O ToolUsage
@ MaterialUsage
@ Verifications
@ Up,-to-Date Documents Supervisory Proce' dural Presence Adequacy m Field c
w i
Deviation Work Time Continuous Pre / Post-Job Reports Planning Management Improvement Briefings l
l l
l
@ Observed Symptoms SYMPTOM DIRECT UNDERLYING
@ RecentDRs AREAS CAUSES CAUSES
@ Not Observed Jason,Associales Corporation I
i Conclusions i
l i
1 t
Indication of a Performance Decline 1
Procedure Compliance s
Industrial Safety i
i Work Practice Standards
?
I 1
1 I
1
)
i
I VIRGINIA POWER t
l k
i l
3
)
ACTION PLAN i
AND CURRENT PERFORMANCE i
i W. R. :Hattihews
)
Station :Wanager l
4 North Anna Power Station Corrective Action Plan Stabilize Current Organization Enhancement / Evaluate Peer Checks:
Maintenance (Existing)
S Radiological Protection (Evaluate)
Engineering (Evaluate)
Operations (Existing)
Re-institute Front Line Leadership Course:
Maintenance Operations Radiological Protection l
Mentor Program - Department Heads I
i.
North Anna Power Station Corrective Action Plan l
i Increase Industry Benchmarking - At All Levels Rewards for Meeting Quarterly Performance Goals:
Forced Outage Rate j
Safety Dose Quality Performance j
i Shift QC Inspectors from NSS to Maintenance SPS - Commitment on Outage Peers i
First Line Maintenance Supervisor Task Team j
Management Retreat / Team Building l
i i
f 1
Recent Accomplishments 1
i i
Unit 2 Refueling Outage Lowest Dose - 117.394 Man-Rem
~
Lowest Outage Cost - 813.82 Million i
l 53 Personnel Contamination Events?
No Prompt NRC Reports Due to Outage Activities i
Unit 2 Forced Outage Due to High Pressure Turbine Balance Line Leak (10/21/96 - 10/25/96) l No Regulatory Issues Total Duration - 96.1 Hours Conservative Decision to Shutdown
)
t
i i
Recent Accomplishments i
?
Unit 1 Reactor Trip Due to Negative Phase Sequence Relav Actuation (10/24/96 - 10/25/96)
No Regulatory Issues i
i Total Duration - 28.7 Hours i
Conservative Decision to Startup Uhits in Series i
Unit 2 Reactor Trip and Forced Outage Due to Generator Failure (11/12/96 - Present)
No Regulatory Issues
=
Conservative Decision to Maintain Unit in Hot Shutdown until Service Water Work was Completed Aggressive Approach to Service Water MIC Issue
- Ii t
i i :
i!!;
il:t :
!i:
l
,. l f!!i!
R sn K
o i
W t
a r
C,
, e S
e P
K p
R O
r r
A A
e a I
M ls e
E nl N
R a
u c
I K N G
G N
R-R
.t 1
n S
Me I
O d
V L
i C
e s
r P
e c
iV
.