ML20129A057

Advises That Commission Approved Issuance of Order to Review Upcoming Decision If Judge I Smith Denies Motions for Recusal.Collegial Commission Correspondence Response Sheets Encl

ML20129A057
Person / Time
Site:	Three Mile Island
Issue date:	02/19/1985
From:	Chilk S NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY)
To:	Plaine H NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC)
Shared Package
ML20128R135	List: ML20128R133 ML20128R177 ML20128R205 ML20129A025 ML20129A057
References
FOIA-85-122 NUDOCS 8507270157
Download: ML20129A057 (5)

Text

/ 54 UNITED STATES E

//- $, NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION j WASHINGTON, D.C. 20555

-3

%g ...../ February 19, 1985 OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY

?1EMORANDUM FOR: Herzel H. E. Plaine, General Counsel FROM: Samuel J. Chilk, Secret

SUBJECT:

SECY-85 MOTIONS TO QUALITY JUDGE IVAN SMITH IN TMI-1 RESQA T PROCEEDING This is to advise you that the Commission (with all Commissioners agreeing) has approved issuance of your order to review the upcoming decision by Judge Smith if Judge Smith denies the motions to disqualify himself, cc: Chairman Palladino Commissioner Rcberts Commissioner Asselstine Commissioner Bernthal Commissioner Zech

(. OPE 8507270157 850606 PDR FDIA 4 BERNABE85-122 PDR .,

[

F .

I

j. 1.d j (j,,j,(, ' h. 1

.. (kj,, J,j j.kJ ,hd(((((((((((

(((;(g(d((((c(g(

- - - - - - . . . . . . . . . . (;((( (

g _

c: c= <

', .CR-84-78 CR-84-78 g

c_

=: , l h!' COLLEGIAL COMMISSION / 5 l h

gj Correspondence Response Sheet yi $

e di - F -

h=.- 'Date: August 17, 1984 -

h h

6:

FOR ACTION:

Chairman Palladino FOR INFORMATION:

OGC h 'O Ni Commissioner Roberts j SECY '

2 Yi 6:

Comissioner Asselstine' Comissioner Bernthal 4

g; g

Comi'ssioner Zech

, OPE OCA h

h 6 @:

e-: .e=

6 .!

- , < =

6, FROM: Samuel J. Chilk, Secretary of the Commission . .

SUBJECT:

Proposed letter to Senator Arlen Specter responding to concerns E cA regarding possible restart of THI-1. 3:

b 50 d

sNj R. Levy, 4-1465

. g GC

Contact:

3=

2:: SECY

Contact:

-T'. Cembs , 4-3317 Q:

,Ji C '

Your Response Must Be Received In gj The Office Of The Secretary By:

d- Comission-Level Offices Ccmissioners 6

T! Time: C.O.B. C.O.B .

N.,

c Day: Wednesday Friday m 6: Date: August 22, 1984 Auoust 24, 1984 5:

=r:: G:

=A 2 c.

6 ,: -

30 dj VOTE: (Initial and Date Appropriate Vote Characterization) @

% Gy' q fo r y  % :;=

2:i APPROVE: -W DISAPPROVE:

d' Mi. ABSTAIN:

fb V 2 NOT PARTICIPATING: .  :%

p 5:: -

's=

%-i REQUEST DISCUSSION:

g C::  %

7:i COMMENT: :g cd!

S 6 i s=

EN.}5ff)T)@P8Sf!)97.)7?y()97t)A)h)$Q7f.)l)).)$yi))yyyy.);yy))yyT7Fy.)yh)!)))

e

.i r

I-

't

-3 Commissioner Asselstine adds: I agree that the Commission itself should not conduct any further hearings that may be required in the In addition to the amount of the Commission's TMI-l restart case.

time that would be required for such an effort, I suspect that the Commission itself is not the most capable group to conduct an ad-judicatory proceeding. However, the Commission should make a prompt decision on the need to reopen the record and should direct that any further hearings proceed as expeditiously as possible, consistent with the requirements for fairness. It would be in-excusable for the Commission to take another several months to p.

decide whether further hearings are needed.

%+' ,

s -

_I {((((,(l(l I (I(((l1(( (((( (T ( ( ( ( ( ( ( i -( I( [(ff( (( z d'

=C 'j :-!

I "M

~

CR-84-84 CR-84-84 he'

3-2 6

i =

s' ,

COLL'EGIAL COMMISSION , %s::

Correspondence Response Sheet -

C6

Date: August 30, 1984 h

s==

FOR ACTION: FOR INFORt1ATION:

Chairman Palladino SECY -

Comissioner Roberts '~

NComissioner Asselstine Comissioner Bernthal

' Comissioner Zech 0PE, OCA .-

h FROM: Samuel J. Chilk, Secretary of the Comission h

~;=

SUBJECT:

Letter from Senator Heinz requesting the Comission not P to make a decision on restart of TMI-l until cleanup of TMI-2 has been completed. -

li!

5::

Contact:

Trip Rothschild, OGC, 4-1465 - 5:'

SECY

Contact:

Sandy Showman, 4,3317

~=

Your Response Must Be Received In C=

The Office Of The Secretary By: @

'Comission-Level Offices Comissioners , {==

==

Time: C.O.B. C.O.B. C#

Friday P Day: Wednesday Date: September 5, 1984 September 7, 1984 h

g==

- - . jg_3 N' i;5

p VOTE: (Initial and Date Appropriate Vote Characterization) :g::

7. 7-?Y APPROVE: DISAPPROVE: . i[ ,

ABSTAIN: Il0T PARTICIPATING:

• b_.

l<

IC:: -~

REQUEST DISCUSSION: l COMMENT: 78/SMDES TO N ,' ' ~ ~

C' 4--rA e g 7// ( o 7R D L E o d A(. A 0 - 77 2---  ; --

C: C

ff) ) ))ff)h'fff)If)hf)f)hyyjf}iff)1){]) . ij i)

( ,

k(I( 1 ((T( k(( k ( k Th(I k(I((f((hdT('dk(((ihd'(hdI(j(j(i(I(('(h(j(,

7 ( ((({,%

d-  ::E ,

y CR-84-83 CR-84-83 (5

%' IN a.

COLLEGIAL COMMISSION

$::, Correspondence Response Sheet  !!-2

. M. !N

~==

Date: August 30, 1984 i:p

?

g FOR ACTION:

Chairman Palladino SECY FOR INFORMATION: i%

.:p 5 Comissioner Roberts  ::-l=

NComissioner Asselstine !T-Comissioner Bernthal k Comissioner Zech

. OPE,

' h s-

@N

p

p FROM: Samuel J. Chilk, Secretary of the Comission i"-

SUBJECT:

Letter to John Minnich, Chairman, County Comissioners of  ![

Dauphin County, Pennsylvania, re Comission vote on !c=

, TMI-1 Restart g S

"7 3

Contact:

Trip Rothschild, OGC, 4-1465 SECY

Contact:

Sandy Showman, 4-3317

[  ::=

Your Response Must Be Received In 3 The Office Of The Secretary By: 1: ~-

3 Comi.ssion-Level Offices Comissioners t:---

3 G

3', Time: C.O.s. C.0.s.

Friday

!!!=

Day: Wednesday ,

• jg Date: September 5,1984 September 7, 1984  ::-=

P

- .  : r-

=

N VOTE: (Initial and Date Appropriate Vote Characterization) fh APPROVE: ,

DISAPPROVE: ,

ABSTAIN: f p 2/ NOT PARTICIPATING: !c'~

C:

i:':=

REQUEST DISCUSSION: 'j$

G COMMENT: c:

5 . i:

=:::- ig

n. .......- 6 1a9PPFFPvTip999yvmnnnnnTwwirimnnemann ummnmedme,

!