ML20128H174
| ML20128H174 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/26/1985 |
| From: | Moran D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Thomas C Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8507090440 | |
| Download: ML20128H174 (9) | |
Text
, _. ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
June 26,~1985 MEMORANDUM FOR: Cecil 0. Thomas, Chief Standardization F. Special Projects Branch, PL THRU:
Herb Berkow, Section Leader Standardization & Special Projects Branch, DL FPOM:
David H. Moran, Project Manager Standardization A Special Projects Branch, DL 4
SUBJECT:
SUMMAPY OF ltAY 15, 1985 MEETING WITF THE GErlERAL ELECTP,IC COMPANY TO DISCUSS PROSPECTIVE PEVIEW 0F NEDO 30638, "PR00t'CT DEPARTitENT QUALIFICATION METHODOLOGY" On May 15, 1985, the Equipment Qualification Branch net with GE personnel in the Phillips Building, Bethesda from 9:00 am until about noon. A copy of the attendence roster is included as Enclosure 1.
The agenda and selected viewgraph handouts are included as Enclosure 2.
The staff stated they would consider the material presented in support o' GE's argument that fled 0 30638 should be reviewed as a topical report.
Original signed by David H. Moran, Project Manager Standardization & Special Projects Drar.ch Division of Licensing
Enclosure:
As stated DISTRIBUTION:
ICentral' Files a-33pg~ pjp
.1_
Ditoran HBerkow RLaGrange PShemanski HValker
- r),
,f ' V AMasciantonio g6e HGarg PR T4D B.LMW SS%fQ n:dk HBhrh w e
f1 gg/85 6/p/85 8507090440 850626 PDR TOPRP ENVQEff.
C PDH
(.
g/
N'^
UNITED STATES e
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION n
j j
WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555
.e[
June 26, 1985 MEMORANDUM FOR:
Cecil 0. Thomas, Chief Standardization & Special Projects Branch, DL TFPU:
Herb Berkow, Section Leader-Standardization & Special Projects B'ra FROM:
David H. Moran, Project Manager Standardization & Special Projects Branch, DL
SUBJECT:
SUMM/PY OF MAY 15, 1985 MEETING WITH THE GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY TO DISCUSS PROSPECTIVE REVIEW 0F NED0 30638,
" PRODUCT DEPARTMENT QUALIFICATION METHODOLOGY" On May 15, 1985, the Equipment Ovalification Branch met with GE personnel in the Phillips Building, Bethesda from 9:00 an until about noen. A copy of the attendence roster is included as Enclosure 1.
The agenda and selected viewgraph herdouts are included as Enclosure 2.
The staff stated they would consider the material presented in support of GE's argument that NED0 30638 should be reviewed as a topical report.
s Lav d H. M r ro ' t Manager %
Standardization & Special Projects Branch Division of Licensing
Enclosure:
As stated l
1
Erclesure 1 TOPICAL REPORT NEDO 30638 14EETING WITH GENERAL ELECTRIC PAv If, laES Nere Oroanization F. C. Garg NRR/DE/EOS.
R. C. LaGrence NDR/DE/E0B P. Shemanski flPR/DF/ EOR N. Shirley GE/ Safety & Licerrivo H. Walker NRR/DE/F0P A. fiasciantonio NRR/DE/EQB R. L. Fisher GE/0ualificetien Analysis F. E. Hatch GE/0ualification Prograns A. Lee NPP/DF/EQP B. Bosnak NOP/DE L. D. Test GE N. G. Luria GE
r PRODUCT DEPARTMENT QUALIFICATION METHODOLOGY MEETING OF MAY 15, 1985 o.
INTRODUCTION N. C. SHIRLEY o
BACKGROUND AND SCOPE F. E. HATCH o
QUALIFICATION METHODOLOGY R. L. FISHER o
SUMMARY
N. C. SHIRLEY
?
NC: pes /104A-1 5/2/85
WHY-PRODUCT DEPARTMENT QUALIFICATION?
GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY HAS SEVERAL HARDWARE o
MANUFACTURING DEPARTMENTS AND EACH HAS BUSINES (PROFIT / LOSS) RESPONSIBILITY IN 1982 SOME DEPARTMENTS DETERMINED THAT SUPP o
PARTS TO NUCLEAR FACILITIES UNDER 10CFR50 AND WAS NO LONGER COMMERCIALLY FEASIBLE GE-NUCLEAR ENERGY BUSINESS OPERATION (SAN J 0
TO CONTINUE TO SUPPLY CERTAIN HARDWARE TO NUC FACILITIES BY ASSUMING 10CFR50 AND 10CFR21 RESPONSIBILITY GE-SAN JOSE HAS BEEN ACCEPTING ORDERS AND o
HARDWARE FOR SAFETY RELATED APPLICATION SIN l
1983 l
i 5 8 85
WHAT IS PRODUCT DEPARTFIENT QUALIFICATION?
PRODUCT DEPARTMENT QUALIFICATION IS THE o
USED IN THE SUPPLY OF HARDWARE TO NUCLEA o
SAFETY RELATED
" COMMERCIAL GRADE / EQUAL T0" o
0 NON-SAFETY 6
FEH 3 5/8/85
SAFETY RELATED PRODUCT DEPARTMENT QUALIFICATION IS THE SUPPLY OF o
SAFETY RELATED HARDWARE WITH QUALIFICATION BY DEDICATION OF CERTAIN GE MANUFACTURED HARDWARE HARDWARE IS PURCHASED COMMERCIAL FROM GE PRODUC o
DEPARTMENTS (N0 10CFR50 OR 10CFR21)
QUALIFICATION OF THE HARDWARE IS CONFIRMED BY o
AND TRACEABILITY TO TESTED HARDWARE, FORM, FIT, FUNCTION, MATERIALS AND MANUFACTURING PROCESSES ARE CONFIRMED GE-SAN JOSE DEDICATES THE HARDWARE, ASSUMES 10CFR50 o
AND 10CFR21 COMPLIANCE, ISSUES A CERTIFICATE OF QUALIFICATION AND SHIPS PARTS TO NUCLEAR FACILIT AUDITABLE DESIGN RECORD FILES ARE RETAINED BY o
GE-SAN JOSE Sh88h
1 BASIS OF QUALIFICATION p
y u
u
=
PERFORMANCE ENVIRONMENTS INTERFACES EQUIPMENT DESCRIPTIM f
1 l
j!
~
EVALUATION OF INPUTS
=
=
n i'
GENERIC SPECIFIC QUALIFICATION STATUS j
4-FEH85.21
~
4 GENERIC o
BWR NSSS APPLICATION (ORIGINAL REQUIREMENT ASSUMED)
~
o NON BWR NSSS APPLICATION (EQUAL TO VENDOR SPECIFICATIONS AND SOLE RESPONSIBILITY OF END USER) l~
I l
FEH85.21