ML20127L234

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Amended Petition for Leave to Intervene.* Finally Licensee Contend That Possibility of Physical Damage Resulting from Wind or Seismic Loading of Spent Fuel Storage Facilities Has Not Been Adequately Evaluated
ML20127L234
Person / Time
Site: Monticello Xcel Energy icon.png
Issue date: 04/06/1970
From: Burnett G, Dzugan K, Pepin T
NORTHERN STATES POWER CO.
To:
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
References
NUDOCS 9211230464
Download: ML20127L234 (10)
v • d • e


Text

'

Pi40. Vist, l AG. 50' D3

.' fv

,S sp\\

k

. 81070 u- '!)!

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA N

APR

.A w a w.n,

~

'k " ',"4 j

ATOMIC E1;EROY COMMISS10N

+1 1[%_DO, t 01.-

NSD F

In the Matter of

)

)

NORTHERN STATES POWER COMPANY Docket No. 50-263

)

(Monticello 1:uclear Gonora ting

)

)

P] ant Un.lt 1)

)

Amended Petition for leave to Intervens We the under,igned are graduate students at the University of Minnesota who for over one year have been concerned with the Monticello Generating Plant, Ne are also concumers of electric power generabed by Northern States Power Company and reside with our families 34 miles from the plant, downstream on the Mississippi l

River.

We and our families drink water from the Mississippi River.

Our interest in the matter aricos out of a dooponing professional concern for the safe operation of the above mentioned facility.

Wo sincerely hope the commission will cc,rrect deficiencies and errors existing in the proposed design of the facility such as will be indicated in our testimony.

Spocif3 cally we will 9211230464 700406

'[R ADOCK 05000263 PDR

t

~2-will-concern ourselves with the following matters, i

We are concerned with the operation of the emergency coro cooling system as detailed in the Final Safety Analysis Report in the event of utilisation of tho ' abovo system in an emergency situation.

No are concerned with provisions rer handling tho explotive mixturo of hydrogen and oxygen in the reactor core resulting fro: radiolytic decomposition of wa;cr.

We contend that the applicant has presented conflicting.information regarding operation and design

.of the radiological waste system.

We are-concerned by-the conflicting information presented by the applicant in regards dilution of radiological wastes betueen the above montioned facil.ity and-the Minneapolis - St. Paul wator supply intake.

We contend that adaquate inspection-proceduros are not available to insure the integrity of the containment system.

Wo are concerned with the integrity of the calculations used to compute the allowed maximum i

stack release rate.

Wo contend that-this computation

-noglects important safety considerations.

Finally we

--.________._.-_.-_m.._-m._.____-___._

3_

contend that the possibility of physical damage resulting from wind cc seismic loading of the spent fuel storage facilitica has not been adaquately evaluated.

v)d/ Q Ld%

i Kenneth Dzugan i

e

/

T1... adore Pepin 1

/O IbT s

Geor

B. Burnott III Da.,t e,_d,, t h._. i, s.. 6.. t. h..d a y.f April 1970

,y 0..-.

.v l.

...:.. i s.#. ;..

OS C, 3 1,-..

's n,

u L e.,.1

~1

)

'l0 ' 'i. C C:d ' ! !1.,JC 0

].C S t.'d D; U gC ;1

".., '- Q ;

  • c

,5 c. a ' a,

c:,t'h, ht3te]g y p[q.

3 9

O.

."'JriC I D ~T I, D'f.1".5 '.r c t ci til;' micy n-G

.,(

, li g e t'.. ' '-

'.c nl... v c etiti
n ic true ',mi cerrcet e;:cc t '.c tn

..t*

-.,,,c..a,.,-

a

.t.

... e,. c, _....,..,,,,,.,,,.

,t

3., e.,.,,...c,,

2.,.,..

1

t. z.

3'DGCr:SO C'.d SUOrn 10

',;+C f C r C-

'3 L f.? t D P," G'bl10 i *, t ',,1 -

3 M.'

f C T 3 C L. n c,,* CC"^.t"3

!'irn.c - d: ; t ',13Y( ', '.

ef lc,71;,, 1{ 7 a, 7

Gkn 2

t :: a.. a :. m.. ; (/

~

l s i s

'l'.

A. i.f' C [tDia b9

,,WW

(~ ~~ ~

'[

f x

J,V..

u.

u. 11 9 c 111

/

.e*

L AW Pl* r,'.E 0. 001439.

b

\\ ,, '

Notary Pe* "

M. u y cow /, Minn,

'?

3

  • i My Comm..'.hn F: 6 es Oct. t ). ' /C) v-

.?

e c,

i

.t

~

Y rp Y '

m.

(-

, y.

s te, 5 w.

j

,, g..m x.m %,

h M h g M (y
l:gM y h p u g W 3:w y%); @% m..

.:W %:g ",;p G; w;rse W :" Mh m ^ >.4MMMMk [&gh, g;; :dI[

W p

PdWd59b

' ;; p ; ~ m g &:,: % @ml[&y,@ 7 m p*<WJL 4

.^

m EW

~

y mm ny,+ ups r wy g,,

. a.. w.y.m w,,w w

ME M

_ _ g, r never annur een e W name,sname,mean estet mock 3D. BMD to 1 M W W 8 ben Bee.

angsteen,inges,se asses to ses stoomastes et amhess) est (3) stE 'esen musst 4. Fitsgetrielle 0$ty of ents6 punt uuttaa essomsense sa the emptsames matter tsee been en tem fullmedag nr espeelt la the asttet Stabes am&L, first class er ear unil, this M est et Ayrt11MD:

thamme F. h.eathmeek, Esb Venentene 3. Denne Esg. thshame tags 1.ter, te Atesse Soesty ama 3 esse 20gL caussettsut Asesse, 5. W.

5. 5. Aeamaa anesw coastseien suite ps4 inuadsstem, s. c so545 umstdastem, s. c. soo36 Gesmaa w, anb Ammes F. shamsen, nog., Altsemate muss, Mttesa, poets, trguerides casesman

& Insetum A4ede as9Mr set I&esmolag Boast N0 Besenteenth L%

sof - sm ma ua.,

aktesumen,s.s.

3855 E Steest, 5. %

IIssedmeten, D. S. 30005 thr. Damate R.

T1eo Poesteemt est Osmemet Dr. Admi S.

, massima psytessstehesposerOngssy et est man MeeBast leek

" O-alimensgates, Inameseta $$st, enAAmeEngktesad,wsseht an34Bmuse,Iturtsat M84 m'. S. F. Munser, Time puestaeus -

Bestmeestas ar. mesmo esemuns per t sen states neuer casear Pseemseer of aputes e m stessant anta asks theretty namnessesse, passeesta $$st, Datum, Berth OmeeHan ef186 asserubae aeroaa s. zeenmase nr. as&t u sassen essesser state et samassets Deposennut of Oldt sagtmeertas St. Want,, Islanaesta $53AL stamene thessatr stemesse, C=MM $319

^

n

4

{A,"

,s i '

.ey',

s'

't 4

j y

f i;t

,, ~.ow u n_.w ~ Oa ~,).w n s, n:;n L*

y3

~ m ),&+lj@-$$'ljf !,;;i & {ll_QU]>lldh,h % ${ Q Q:\\Q@UJ:yllCOSb,l.

,S.

? ;t.

u.=:

a

} y,";l O'

&frA!.

3 p

v.

a.

.mg

^

p I

I l

l i

$ [. A

$}dh

      • Der. Denas I

ar. sessanset i

Ibr. Tsue E, 30md i

N. must i

P l

l i

4

._..._.__.._._-.......--._..._..__._.__....._....--..._..__-._...___._.....-.x.m._._.,___,.

m.

.r3 g,.

j

+.s

+.

~,

(

j i'h::

I v.,ii,

M

  • Td " Fr'fv b li" "# W 77 i

W a

\\

~ 4' p y '&unt

+V i

..a.ut L.~.

W J

21

.['b l rw/

m.y j

4G

~

.. m

,g

.m.. i 4 Wff e

f"'.'f!

loc5_p. w n

';f.5,.yvDY:

'kgInd i,

gg,4 f.mg

..;;_c a

0 6,4

..-+._.

<+

W

.-+e m-.*

r 9

'J s

'd b

d\\

)

s e

k't4

.4 4

N q

W

.st N

1

%r b

A.lD ~j. m) j d*

t t ',. s y yw

, t r u$

l me]

3 q..m ydi a

g, y

s v

~.

iI

% [g T- [

I

'l q 1

. j

% ja.

s g

A.

i ! $

h ' (j ).-

d' d44 h g

2.

4.;

e r

,,-c,

.-wr,-n,------,,,.-~,.-,r.

,w-,

r

w+

w

.--,,-,,,.-,-,-.--.--..,,....---,.r.n

"T 9

l

<j, y,, f V

st g Nt BL1O e;

j q

1. y -

j WCKET huMBER e.,3 N

. T" c

y g~

. PROD. & UIll!. @ M 1

,J.

~. i,

. R.

.ggy g g2ygf24 ;.-

9. l.d-R., ' ' * [+Y, Eh'/.

~

~

j USACC HQS uTWN

~

.m U.S. ATOMIC ENERGY Cg'MM.,,

T LAA0h TL40d3 (09)CTA048 MA043 1WX UNIT.,'

- ;j -

1,

+

A

t. L J N 7 CY NL P0d MINNCAPOLIS MINN
/. ;

- 1 J J5fP t a d 0TTS JR, DLY *Ib P J,LIC tM JC i:.v a,vu ud4NCd 0FFICE OF TdC, SECRETARY UNITED STATES

.w 1 ifJAIC 29{NdY COM4ISSION WASHUC i

fiAN< YOU FOR YOUR RESPONSC GRANTING US LEAVC TO I N T E RV E'N E I

IN rd :. AATTER QF THE APRIL 28TH dEARING'ON A PROVISIONAL PCRATING I

l L ICiNhi F OR Tdi N ARTddRN STATIS POWCR COAPANY '(MONTICELLO NUCLEAR l.

d di ATING PLANT UNIT 1)

.2{CUAdi UF THE DELAY.IN THE MAILS WC HAVC,JUST RECEIVED YOUR Cv.AUNICATIvN. WE w CLCOMC _ YOUR SUGGCS TION "TO DISCUSS ALL' MATERS.

N vTdo dr'rtd!N AT TdE PdidEAHING CONFERCNCE." PLEASE INFORM IMjEDI ATELY IN SUFFICIENT DETAIL WHAT OTdCrt ACTION MAY BE. REQUIRED BY US.

A T THIS TI AC

.s divFddN0 PAUL ENGSTROA PRESIDEN' MINNESOTA ENVIRONMENTAL g

CuvTHOL CITIZdNS ASSOCIATION.26 EAST EXCHANGE STREET ST PAUL

~

t AIN9dSJTA.

i 6144 IST +

(b o,

. c DOCIITED i

U S ACC -tOS GTWN,

-,+

gg 2

APR. S;97p C.

.. p.

', Gib tfik t:.4g

.)y

. NA:imat;n:

_l

. - {

y

-p f-

'01 s

p.,

y.

/ 4 a

e

(

l T

/'

l i

i

\\

1- -. - -.

//

~1 x, fr$?

> - - ~

j unrien summa or Aignaca 77 g.

Annac asser onesasses H

H j

zu t w sentter er D

I k'A 1

annemer setens sonst omeaur nesteet as 3M63 (usettea13e maa h - esserettas V

1 F3amt mit 1)

Q.

1 e

cagganass_wmmes I hereby sort 1% that assise et (1)) April 6, Aff0 3etter fmum MLh Deme 1

l mammaing petition to intervues (e

Amsmentsettien Sur 3 move to Inter-vene from Messrs. sammeth neuena, Theatene Peyta, see Geerse Duseett, j

dated April 6 19p; (3) Regnested Amamane petitles for Insve to Intervase from Rev. Fund Engstres, 35004, dated April 6,1970; est (4) 3etter from Donald W. AmArcus, Chairuse, MLanesoth anvireemental Defsmoe Council, Amted April 5,1970 requesting limitet appearemos in the sayHM matter j

have been servet on the following by esposit in the thitea states mail, l

first class or air mail, this 8th Aar of April 1970:

i j

Valentine B. Deale, Esq., Chairman Thomas F. Engelhardt, Eng.

i Atomie Safety and Ideenstag Domed Megu3 story Staff Ceumeel l

2001 Connecticut Avesmo, N. W.

U. S. Atente Energy c==4 maim l

Buite 504 Weskhagten, D. c. 20545

}

Washington, D. C. 20036 Gerale therweff, Bog.

James P. Gleese, Esq., Alternate show, Pitteen, Potte, Treebridge Chairman

& Moones Atemic Safety eat Licensing Board 9110 Sevasteseth 8tswet N 805 cammmuealth nat34 tag Washingte, n. c. s0008. W.

j 1625 x street, N. W.

[

Wanainstem, D. C. 20006 Donald E. Delsen, Esq., Vice l

President & Osmosal Cetreal l

Dr. Jeten c. Osyur, chairman Earthern States power Cesyssy Departuset of geogregtr est 4 3 Nieel3et un11 1

l Enviremmental Englasering wimammya m, M1ameesta 55401 The Johns Boykins-tativersity Daltimore, Mary 1mmi 21218 Mr. m. F. McElrer, Viee President -

Bestseering I

Dr. musene oreuling sorthern stmees poner canoner l

Professer of Physics A M Micellet Mall Duke thriversity Miseneapolis, Minnesota 55bol Iktsbest, North caralina 27106 Dr. R. R. Barr, Seeretary amt Dr. Dolf 1E19mamen Esecutive Officer i

Departammt et civil Engineering State Beqpertment et Nemith l

stenfore tamtversity thiveretty census stenfest, california 94305 ut 7m, saanesota 55440

(

l 1

1 l

l

'~.~m

,,,.. -.. _ -, _. ~. _... ~ ~

.-..,,._m_.

.. sr..-

m

4 W3 ynge t l

t ektet, InAustrial commissian Bev. Punt E. Bagstren, Poestenut t

137 sta6e office Bu1Miss Minnesets arviremmastal Oestsel

54. Fual, Islamasene 95181 Cittasse Assosamties i

af anot Bushamps stsest caustasiemar et conserva%en st % Islamesets 95381 l

state of Ittaneeste Departenut et conserouties IIr. Ishe temshee st. Paul, Minnesota 95101 R. R. 3 Elk Ittver, Blianosote 95333 Namessble massM R. Iavanaer l

oevernor, state of Minnesota neeers. Benneth Deuses, theo6ere l

st. Paul, Minnesota 55101 Foyta, and energe Burnett l

Departaset et Phystes uomareh3m L. J. marthel, w m an taatversity at Minnesota i

l Wrfdt County Board of Commissioners Minneapolis, Minneeota 5A55 j

sutrale, m % $5313 i

i' t

l

/hlt<. n Al/in A LL.

orrt e c e se.,eterr i

i ect Mr. Deale Mr. Engalhardt Mr. Yose l

N. Blunt E SmL6 l

1 i

l l

t i

i'

DOCYLT NUUULR

)

kmj Mt00 & UHi, f&

s

'604 0

~

R.R. #3 3

Elk River, Minnesota I.

April 6,1970

{

\\

0)

Q r

W 00CKE1ED 9

ClifC Chairman of the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 9;

APR 81970* I2 Monticello Hearing 0**"f th Inte.'m

~~~

r, PMc Pr:c esign

t. nn y

Gentlemen:

C129 4

g I am writing this letter to petition for permission to intervane in the hearing concerning the Monticello Nuclear Generating Plant, which will take place at Buffale, Minnesota, April 23, 1970 s

I am a sophomore at Elk River Senior High School and am making a study of the field of nuclear power plants and the prob-lems they generate. I live approximately fifteen niles from the plant site at Monticello and with in a few hundred feet of the Mississippi River, which my fami.h of ten uses for recreational purposes.

I believe these two factors, as well as the fact that I wish to be an active concerned citizen of my state and nation, qualify me as an " interested party".

My main areas of concern are the aspccts of radioactive vaste and thermal pollution and the effect they have on aquatic 9

life, wild life and recreational activities. As pollution of any nature is a major concern of the American people today, my interest is whether or not this concern is more emotional than logical.

Too of ten I have found that more emphasis is placed on new industry that has already established pollution control standards than on those induntries now in existance which have produced and are i

producing more pollutants per day than those new industries could l

hope to produce in a life time.

i I hope my concern justifies my petition to intervene at the forthcoming hearing. Yo.tr nonsideration is appreciated.

1 Sincerely, llb

~

ey<

Mike Donahue M,

1 5 hereby certify that the petitioner is known to me and that the signature appearing bove is his own,-signed this sixth day of April,1970.

fr//[h((hbrF,Me Notary':public l

min ve, set,eme ccWy, Mmn.

1 g (oryptn%)ft t y #c' #dW N. A Nb 3.

4

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20127L234&oldid=4265458"