Text

Request to Institute Proceeding to Modify,Suspend or Revoke License Held by Util for Unit 1 & for Cause Would Show Commission That Primary Place of Registration for Organization Is Fort Worth,Tarrant County,Tx
	ML20127K814
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	05/19/1992
From:	Dow S; DISPOSABLE WORKERS OF COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC
To:	; NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
Shared Package
ML20126G588	List: DD-92-06, Advises of No Adequate Basis in 920519 Petition for Taking Action Requested.Directors Decision DD-92-06 Responding to Petition Encl; ML20126G603; ML20126G610; ML20127K814;
References
	2.206, CPA, OL, NUDOCS 9211230253
	Download: ML20127K814 (130)
	v • d • e

.

. 3

18. r.

. <y-.,

' 41

-UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGUI.ATORY COMMISSION COMMISSIONERS:

Ivan Selin, Chairman Kenneth C. Rogors James R. Curtiss Forrest J. Remick E. Gail de Plangue

.m'

'g1 I

j\\

l l

m.

In The Matter oft VI TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC COMPANY I

Docket'Nos. 50-445-OL 9

50-446-OL (Comancho Peak Steam Electric Q

50-445-CPA-Station, Units 1 and 2) 0 0

REQUEST TO INSTITUTE PROCEEDINGS TO MODIFY, SUSPEND OR REVOKE THE LICENSE HELD BY TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC COMPANY FOR=

UNIT 1 0F THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION Comes now Sandru Long Dow dba Disposable Workers of Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, and R. Micky Dov,' hereinafter petit!oners,'and file this, their request, pursuant 10 C.F.R. 52.202, and 10 C.F.R.

Q2.

P96, to institute a proceeding-to modif y, suspend. or--.* evoke the lic-ense held by Texas Utilities Electric Company'for the Unit 1 of the Comancho Peak Steam Electric Station, located at Glen Rose, Texas,fand for cause.would show the Commission that, I.

The primary. place of registration for the organization Disposable

.r Workers of Comanche. Peak Steam Electric Station.(hereinafter:Disposa.

ble Workers) is Fort Worth, Tarrant County, Texas.

The Board of Dir-

.ectors for Disposable Workers consists-of. Ronald Jones, a resident of Tarrant County,LTexas; Yvonne Wilkinson,1 a_. resident:of Hood County, Texas; and, Doble Hatley, a resident of Travis County, Texas.,1The-President ~of Disposable Workers is ThayronLHatley, Jr., a resident'ofj REQUEST TO NODIFY SUSPEND 0R REVORE LICENSE -1 k

EDO --- 007781 2H%3 w o vmm c

u

t y

0 Somervell County, Texas.

Petitioner R. Micky Dow is a property owner of flood Count y, Texas, and has donated that property to Disposable Workers for the main offices, and principal place of business for that organization.

II.

Texas Utilities Electric Company was given a license, in the a-bove-styled and numbered matter, for low-power operation on February C, 1990, and full-power operation on Aptil 17, 1990, by the U.S.-Nuc-icar Regulatory Commission.

Since that license was granted, petitioners have filed, with this Commission, multiple petitions, motions, and requests, to have the record of the original license proceedings reopened, alleging, among other things, lack of character and/or capability of the licensee; as well as numerous safety and construction concerns, of past, present and future impact.

Petitioners' Second Motion To Reopen The Record is currently in the jurisdiction of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Col-umbia Circuit which has issued its order to show cause, and vill hear argument on reversal of the Commission's ruling dismissing petition-era motion.

Petitioners' Third Motion to Roopen the Record, as well-as Peti-l tion For Leave To Intervene Out-of-Time, and Request for-Oral Argu-ment is cuirently pending decision before this Commission.

III.

Petitioners' vould allege and aver that they have standing to bring this request, pursuant 10 C.P.R.

52.206(a); and, that they have L

standing in all previous and pending matters before the Commission, by virtue of the transcript of the original hearings by this Commission REQnEST TO MODIFY SUSPEND OR REVOKE LICENSE _

r i

t, in 1973, wherein the Commission ruled that, to establish any schedule for further actions in the proceeding." (transcript at pg.

9, lines 4-5) any person may come in at any time for good cause and file a petition after the date specified in the notice. (transcript at pg. 16, lines 14-16)

Mr. Shattman's original interpretation of the rules was correct.

Unless you file in a-timely

fashion, absent the showing of good cause."

(transcript at pgs. 16-17, lines 23-25 and 1)

"The Appeal Board found that all a Licensing Board had to do to determine whether a party was granted intervention status was find one contention that met the requirements of 2.714.

We are prepared to stipulate to that." (transcript-at pg. 21, 1 lines 19-21) and petitioners' did not see the notice in the Federal Register, and had no conceivable need to see that notice, as petitioner R. Micky Dow van recovering from illness and hospitalization in the State of Georgia at the time of the notice, and did not return to the State of Texas until June, 1900, still in the recovery process, and unable to function in a day to day atmosphere.

IV.

Petitioners would allege and aver that they are representative of a group of cititens within a 50 mile radius of the Comanche' Peak Steam Electric Station who have expressed a written. concern about the safety of the operation of this facility, and are unable to bring an action on their own.

Attached hereto and incorporated by reference,'the same as if fully copied and set forth at length, marked Petitioners' Exhib-it A for identification are requests. relative to the hereinabove.

V.

In April, 1991, petitioner R. Micky Dow, provided to officials of CPSES the testimony of one Melvin Albright, who was employed as a lab-eier on the Unit 2 construction area, who testified to the failure to label, and mislabeling of pressure valves and limit switches on that l

REQUEST TO MODIFY SUSPEND OR' REVOKE LICENSE i

r 1

4 y

\\

unit.

When asked if he had knowledge of the same in the Unit 1 area, he replied that yes, this was so, there as well.

Petitioners, herein, made two formal allegations to Region IV of the NRC, and, in their re-port dated August 22, 1991, as well as their report dated February 12, 1992, which are their response to those allegations, it states, quite clearly, that no inspection was conducted on Unit 2, the subject mat-ter of petitioners' allegations.

Copies of those two reports, marked Petitioners' Exhibits B and C, respectively, are attached hereto and incorporated by reference the same as if fully copied and set forth at length.

VI.

Since November, 1991, as an indication, only, there has occurred:

1) A leak in a pressure tank causing 100 m.p.h.+ winds in the access tunnel between units 1 & 2 resulting in a woman employee being b'.own into a radiation area, so hard that she bent welded piping on the walls, was injured, terminated during sick-leave, but was ruled an unreportable incident by Region IV.

2) During the outage of October +, 1991, due to personnel error and misalignment of valves, resin was spilled into the core, the spill unmentioned after repeated request to Region IV.

3) March 12, 1992, a " hot" valve, in Unit 1, was cut in two caus-ing a radiation release and exposure to several individuals.

Region IV, although conducting an exposure investigation, refuses to make a comment, saying specifically to inquiries by petitioners, that they have two conflicting stories on the matter, and don't know which one to believe.

4) Of-the sample weekly reports, submitted herewith, there are 26 documented "reportablo incidents", as well as numerous areas showing direct concern by Region IV, as well as, at least 6 reactor trips, these reports marked Petitioners' Exhibit D, are incorporated herein by reference the same as if fully copied and-set forth at length.

5) Proposed violation fines nearing $100,000 for 1992 to date.

6) During the week of May 11, 1992, alone, because of personnel error, using undertrained personnel, yet another reactor trip was caused, and withing 48-72 hours of this incident the spent fuel pool for Unit 1, went without cooling water for approximately 20 hours2.314815e-4 days 0.00556 hours 3.306878e-5 weeks 7.61e-6 months which caused an abnormal rise in temperature, and if not for the un-timely awareness of an NRC inspector who " happened" to " notice" the temperature rising, and point'it out to control room personnel, there WOULD HAVE DEEN A MELTDOWN.

The reaction of the control room person-nel'in a described "near-panic" situation, was to pump water from Un-it 2, which is uninspected and unlicensed, to affect a cooling input.

HEOUEST TO MODIFY SUSPEND OR REVOKE LICENSE,

L.

0 A

This is tatamount to grabbing a bucket of liquid to put out a fire without the knowledge of whether that bucket contains water or naptha, and is a clear violation of the license; and to do so in front of an NRC inspector, without his ordering and immediate shut-down is a mal-feasance of his office, and indicative of duplicity.

Attached hereto and incorporated by reference the same as if ful-ly copied and set forth at length, marked Petitioners' Exhibit E, are notes reflecting item #1, hereinabove, which can be corrroborated by testimony from one Thayron Hatley, and both a newsphper article from the Dallas Morning News and the Region IV press release, with regard to item #6, hereinabove, marked Petitioners' Exhibit F.

Attached, hereto, marked Petitioners' Exhibit G, and incorporated by reference the same as if fully copied and set forth at length, is candid photo-graph of the control room personnel, that was the subject, and still is the subject of in-plant humor, widely circulated, showing the con-trol room staff to be asleep, as it is known to be the common man-ner for control room personnel.

VII.

Petitioners can provide the proceeding with the testimony of Dr.

Jay Gould, Ernest Sternglass, and Ron Jones, experts each; and all of whom will testify that there is no possible way that the incident i-dentified in item #6, hereinabove, could have happened by accident, nor could it have happened without varning, or the control room per-sonnel's knowledge, had they been doing their job.

Petitioners fur-ther submit that this is an ongoing problem, with the licensee using under and/or improperly trained control room personnel, and-that this is not new but something which has been the concern of the NRC for some time as evidenced by Petitioners' Exhibit H, a copy of which is REQUEST TO MODIFY SUSPEND OR REVOKE LICENSE i N

a

a 1

e attached hereto, and incorporated by reference the same as if fully copied and set forth at length, which is a letter from Christopher Grimes, Director of the Comanche Peak Project Division to William Cahill, Jr.,

Executive Vice-president Nuclear, Texas Utilities, com-plaining of the licensee's failure to provide the NRC with proof of t.he capabilities of control room personnel.

V17' s

Petitioners can also pl orh d: zoo tsion with the transcripts of 16 reels of audio tapes, whi ch atain ccnversations between the licensee and individuals indicative of duplicity between Region IV and the licensee, as well as testimony of a witness to the conversa-tion between A.D. Scott of Texas Utilities and members of Region IV discussing not disclosing 573 fire-vatch viciations.

WilEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, petitioners would ayer, that, un-t less the license held by Texas Utilities Electric Company for full-power operation of Unit 1 of the Comanche peak Steam Electric Station, located at Glen Rose, Texas, is immediately modified, suspended, or revoked, they will suffer immediate, and irreparable harm to their property located within 50 miles of that facility, members of their I

immediate families, who live within 50' miles of that facility, and-the lives and' property of others who are unable to bring this action them-selves, and that by virtue of their own press release, and although required by law to take action, Region IV of the NRC is doing nothing to effect the termination and/or operation of this facility, although clearly having acted contrary to the provisions of its license in the.

presence of.the NRC, and that they have no plans for action for the.

immediate forseeable future, leaving these petitioners with no alter-native but to request the modification, suspension or revocation of l

REQUEST TO MODIFY SUSPEND OR REVOKE _ LICENSE ~6-1 1

..z.-

..i

8 s

that license, in the interest of the public well-being and safety.

l Petitioners would respectfully remind the Commission that charac-ter and capability are the primary foundationry factors to be consid-ered for licensing, and this licensee has failed, in every respect, to show the barest attention to these factors, Petitioners would also aver that they have shown a continuing downward spiral in violations, reportablo incidents, and concerns, in a regular and continuing pat-tern, including instances of clear perjury on the part of this licen-see, as well as probable criminal misconduct.

A near tragedy of mon-umental proportion was averted by a chance occurance, yet the regional offico continues to allow this licensee to operate what is obviously a disfunctional facility, even with a clear violaticn of license oc-curing during their observation of the licensee in operation.

If the public is to be protected, as this agency is mandated by law to do, it must convene a proceeding wherein the revocation of this license can Ise placed in public hearing for examination, testimony, and the submission of evidence.

Petitioners' request the Commission order the immediate shutdown of Unit 1 of the Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, located at Glen Rose, Texas and order the initiation of proceedings to determine if the license of Texas Utilities Electric Company should be revoked.

Petitioners' further request the suspension of that license pend-ing the initiation and completion of those-proceedings, in the inter-est of the public safety, and in the absense of this licensee's con-corn for the same.

Petitioners also request suspension of-any further discussion and/or application for extension / modification of the construction per-mit for Unit 2 of the Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station located at REQUEST TO MODIFY SUSPEND OR REVOKE LICENSE,

Glen Rose, Texas, pending the init.iation, and resolution of any pro-regarding the license for the Unit I at that facility.

Petitioners pray for such other and further relief, at law, or in equity, to which they rnay show thernselves to be justly entitled.

Respectfully submitted, k

^

- CLA O

Od SA4DRA LONG DOW dbo 1 3POSA11LE WORKERS OF COMANCi!E PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, pro se 322 Mall Divd. #147 Monroeville, Pa. 15146 (412) 056-7043 Petitioner

~

k k

R. MiCKY DOW, hro se 322 Mall Divd. #147 Monroeville, Pa. 15146 (412) 056-7843 Pet.itioner CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE This in to certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was delivered by courier to the parties listed below on this the 19th day of May, 1992.

\\

Affiant ' '%e

\\

Robert A. Woolridge George Edgar 2001 Bryan Tower 1615 L Street, N.W. Suite 1000 Dallas, Texas 75201 Washington, D.C.

20036 Charlos Mullins Office of the General Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 11555 Rock Pike Rockville, Maryland 20852

'u REQUEST TO MODIFY SUSPEND OR REVOKE LICENSE 1

g\\MNeg A

EXHIB\\1 April 6,1992 l

I Hon Jonomy was an Electrical Quality Control Inspector at Comanche Peak Power Plant from approximately Feb. 1903 to approximately May 1984; during at which time I found numerous non conforming discrepancien thru out the Reactor 1.

After reporting thene I van harassed, bullied and eventually let go, because I would not ignore or pretend thene problema did not exiat.

i At the first License hearing I was prepared to tuntify on the utill existing problems, when a settlement and an agree-ment van made, I did not believe this settlement then and do not believe it now and I am utill prepared l'o testify on the non conforming conaiutencies and harassment, bulling tactics that vore perpetuated upon honest Whistle 1110wers at Comanche Peak Power Plant.

RON JON 'S I understand that any false statements or misrepresentation vill subject me t pentalities of purgery.

SIGNED:

6 1(

WITNESS:

p

,,g r

WITNESS:

v); & n f.j?C W 5 /l l

l l

l t

A ENHIB\\1

"*-**-'~=.%..a_mu

^"-=-**-eam.u%

0 NYT Ab 6 - t e u t a n a w e a L> b ^ r) C A & wa s%

W ni vat. w-p~ n y +m r + u n aa azau g m x n_;

. n n d 1 6 e ai s w d,B\\L L sittk,

Edil Ml b~M.

wh.Lpq ujw

$p,A p

usp% /

g.

A

, _f AJLAA "}y* "yese LO; xL %

s~l ksau,,as e&m A dini

< an' a g &ywq, W u d a u n $ & a K C A p. a. s M J p s 4 / a d.

widA% L& "*Edl *A A"E t

teLdduew&

M /#Lt h m

> beag,8 Mo

$d M c.7A d k

}nw an xjapaea' w n&

[ "d 'en~wLar&M wha 4Asd4u,+~una A w h wk 17 & swa w i Ga.vfd fb' dpwA a.:ul OJCd4L Q$2SAau-l }

pas.h % aak u da mknq6,~ ~ w ~

s pr m p a _ f pry $; " m"^ m alA M LM4&2s)dm y

x n

a stat.a u u ut o s t e y & w h ;

c. a n anmfu).u.wOblqh

6. AdWar q

4 4 GA

,On uarb

%%qn~xL ug;,s' w

Lu Odsaa.itap i Q

% muo.a4 we/2L AdLa.,g &y &

4

%A%Jutu d

%vs%

& L%

,ca&

n

~ w a.

j

gt\\TlONgg A

t m a c A m -r of Egylgg p> l 7swa e.

W a rt.4 -r r e.,

.I p_ei,es i.a ru E.

c. l T-f op

(-l E4

/to S E.

ea r a z.

a n,c s o n ru t psi.u s a.,via, l, rem

Fi sc M i t c s 5 ev-r.4 op c eu wc-Peere. s. e, s, 1

lr we<u a o ar rdos fuiu +a re,n <. on n ws astene a sl.vi-sistosofee.

1. wea.eeo Co. (N V M C--),

App /Lo y l N r' Fe /L B AHae5 64 S E/- 8 t.4 l 9 tAtt Fon S #-Ovec f A. cot ( F[L <>> E WCE < 5) j wan Aa..ns~we sn~: rou.n v, c o a,n w l MOJE\\

s~./ Cot.r

'-T'l vu19st b A CA LLLA. I e) 'H&vro)L.

t

. Tb b PEA P'-TC C.P.S.E.~5.)~.

2. ru ca we Av.-Lo APPt--eY I; e os new us on-c sa ve.m s u vs c a s, wssro-1 a s ss, u

e e wv,,~ co,.wt. usr 3scus o g -, u 4

r ~u 4 sv %,4.A L

ruc o c ces o_o-,ve.

i

1 n < no w uonne.,sesr< m,as e,,

Pcue>

mn o.c c o,u w, w s.

suz r,

-r. v.,~s c u sc~<-e joP rAsi 4. --ro s E. E. -r G v0 8-6 T Bv c u rv I-; o v_A.

9 o n roe a.

r~ tn r.,

y r etcruc: w,' r << ^> o

~

p;

, (Lt.b d e ~Te o A 0F w g /t,. Y

) C CPE, Z L sR$

h t s t'C 4 6.o s

u o F-F-c er_.

5 T A ~ o i 4 V /* ' A~' O 5/P1/ ut w E.

bcsT MvE

. es, a w e s a u n. - re aec on e us,1 esit van.

4 av w hvwir,'t s ge. rg$\\MONeg

+

A g>

pae w.

no w s,,

.A-i

~

ENHIB6

\\

w -

t

/

g\\TIONg

'o'-

g 9

c A

%HIB\\T 7" L MA$ TC L D ib % /b4 /SA bMM T YO IA/ L/ 7 V[

o d

't gg

. MOT TO C4e/C W T5tJ WIT 8t IT, NOVA -24 TM d a$

h Y

b $ US L4 h (

YA Y.$

$4f f$ Tb_

l *$ A FL*T f.-M h~ r ~! O A

b f.g* Alt ~r m w

& F-L.pn cit.

o

.;,.o

, kh SN bhTM i

bb lM MTi h N h b

s

.?O$8-in s J. 'T~A &M o w Cs.E.4 N C.

A b w 0 7eo J Mb h -r 's

> A ~t we.'s c n.t. PA 0 Tb - n4+e t--

'fc te avt

s ver eit c.'+ m. r-a do e v.. S a b. o. L. sukcor j

't^'Llos To s' >

lh A LK.. A +A) m P A VG S. ~77.s E-.) Tu a.

l

m e _ s e_ -, t r. A m e s v o<e-, #-cre e-c r r -<-

.Fl<vio CO,00o 8Y T~A rJ./2.-C.

Fert-10EC t t N w et Jl b

lh A.).$ 3. [^evcu p,.A (L-

. c+f A - WE.

c.e,,) v. h c. Tio n 5

-r'o

sare uu c s cu,'e.e s ). wen mo nwu-r.'~s c

~

{54Lh'< 0C 0 4 A.I i T H U S A-t' 'b 5M D

~~~)$ 0 ' PfA. I'l0 U/1-

. ^> c PE4 b i%, /J6 S f-cJ E 8 iT3.

A S /4 L (%E $ vL T

.'L O '? L 0 f L C-Ib cLa b a,st M E.

i+ A D ~T~o _ $ E.L. V

. o ra s.a.

n e t c < m r. N e.

owa : n ;~rc ~rn s.- :o+

.. 33;.u w SEAft4 L / P f+ s %%

A '7'

' C 7' S E.5 -

TH

, Ar J f l'd cc A-0 L C 5AT-4-f-/

f.. d u PL -r-1l. M C-cst-O.

fld 61 k,E s-rl~k Hs a se 60 As.'s-rm - A cNio F-vex esa r +wAn.

ou,ees0 e a rx',c s v oie n u.a > e. )

93.log c

r'u.- ev sf-w e A,.t v s F-oaoT5 A.>ost k l AT L P S E 3 hot lPfofct w0 k u YMb e,

= e4=n 4.-

y%,

+-

e

iw

- tur

asc

.e

,nn-.

w,

.,1,.

,r,,..,,

,+ue

.,w a.. n e n,,,,,.

1';

J 41\\TIONgg Q

A A-l ENHIBiT t'# 3 vr n, w d a ~z.a it-c-a.

i T-It A v6 A

'6 Lt% v7 s tc vL sJn F E.

AHD 3

,Aas-EGsc h 6 0 t HTCit s ll, 3 ssub d

M LA-st. $

.o F Ah-C, u,op s e e pit.4 H L e ??al~ m c ~rb G-s.'T fM f M l G Q kWh NWW NO LCA VL eV$ Wl0 ibtA L w17 H.pst6 ve m I a f clu-rhoJ~r ~Tb /^ E "ntu s HAvE s o, A r-c e,ic.e.r <J 5 - e . r H A v t. st E ct.a-ru 4 .T o a s.O h $ P c s A-15 v6 Gcs-nu s oe. nasa wte - Ir is a> l ~ j o <'ha-> e t 2-+ri o a. Tsav s s. 'Fu g, L o f. C4te < 'l-, Yl N l d'mh .Gs E. LG.A v2. O V6-F v ~r v /t C. 6-CWEA.o*T"'s o o a S, ArJ b .N s t t. Nof Le r p+c B.iL i3 s 5 t,va s s 5 E c To(2-yevk ex.- e vP-<t-as. l.) ~ T'e+. C. A.; G +s5 L& T* rest.. 7 p.,5vT5 osT N Y h O f ~ fhh e . Loc 0 ev646 9 6c<t-tv ova.1) Al5o r6 LL A/t o vT . A rv-t i ~k TnA-T tr-0 6 Y L.J lt.c e # l f. ~To it c us+ S YL .bm es,e-uc,oit ne, rs a-~n ~n < -ne -1 . s e e m s, c ~ r ~ ~ e,a ~. r r u s e m, ru e. o Wu 2 s-r c.w & F I % P e,JT r= J E L. A-ovh ~ f4p J '

t.e-u uc wice rova. To Juc 4,r g l7 fff0Neg b

c

r c. c' 4 r sees o,s: u w. mq 3,,.s_

o-m _ s 44

t\\TIONg A i l E.NHIBd.

4 V$ I rJFO/L+^ h-T' C N,50T Q.f 1*r s H S.-

lH l' 0 A.*.A br T* 9 e o , 5 u,,, evuu.._.c ac~s. ree -rs. ww vs.-r oe-c . r a-1 -r m, a re mc.ve.~uo a ee i,.,e w rie- . A Aev-f rH-E PLAe.eT 4 c) W f_. W r~ M< E. D E c t 54 e's s ,hR0vT U Vtt. LiFG u G-r>+L IL Te L vE t+C CA. WDT. .VG MAJ& A VW H5 V-H f-AT 6 Of* M Vt'.-O C 6, 5 U * 15 Eg f.4 r3o og 5 t gcot,) ( -c.s v >,,A 7- [ ire.k 6 / . Aw A ce c&t. T n~u ~eseon ees wun. w -r. v. h n s-.00 a . o a u,. e se n -m as wsuu rau. us r,- e u a o u e ~ u e _A I # f 0 $ 6 6 LE.. W d N i O f'" CI I.bb a ~ Ml *I N _ W6 b_O 8 b.$ _~[*+'E. Yl ILb"1" OlLC H0?Tl OtJ 'T'H A T W6 t L . TH L i hJb L eJ F o n L.h b F 'Ti+L I=A L~r$ - T H e r "T." (i. + ,; 1>O f 6 r~ !Y

Uh-~' Y U A

'~~TD WO&. '2 ) *:C wc tJ L.b b /vE A hl /e. dD Cr de/ b s ev ( F<< r.1 . r v 3 wA,u + ~_s sls mouc~ s-r4ATco i 71+1 s HLEA Eacaosc cn ruc.Y-upoJ ru Ore. is.a s e-c e.o. n,,. -ra s, '.,e. a s s m,- e me eas w e t.c i - wu.s - o < -r e s, s o; e vua <. s a s rn n w -r u ! p s vt r s. - we 3.)

.T. wc v Gb - L.l H. E 'TH E L b EsLs I e N, HPi et A <!* 6&T,.

t . A-wb b % Powt cF T't.* P A &~r c.? 8.E.%. % S -rop. s% ~~1h G-n N L E.c, -rb Havc Voc 0 M vb s E.wC.e.~r, A r o l~ w o-E.*J TH 6 9 _ HAv1* ; A Lo N A L: E.M rio w C C T,.u -T. j !M4 5 40,J C WS 'I'e+ E.-4 fvE E b _ _"Tb

5EA-(

p' %ge. Tre. e n s, s creau m~~. or j lT o/LL (- 6.r vE iT. e 5 $.%HIB6 e y .--,-,,,-.-,,1...-,-.._...-- 1.-...

,,. -.1,, l goTIONe9 ~ 9 S, 1 A i 4 ENHIB\\T p s-w e. a t co r'~ c re t >,* o s E, Fa-u d, ~I Nb C. L t L -M c L t Aw }) f-E.e-1< o-l, , C 6 ft A v P ~T* o *~

y y

,%t.AAAufa rT, CCf.4 C o& 5 *T*C J Ml e L. CCM W C++C. b 1 . PME c.9 e a e, G. < i'* e bD h'T ca> " D 4 tL s & OwM. .m 4. r e vu d u. r a r. c me rco -r o p,2 4 - e e,e. , 'T7+ t-I 'l.- hru.At-b c L LM C4 VW VP '7 M*~f I'S so" nML P CA-k'. l 1 N f.k C I d _ A.b.T.~. OVN b p Pl / --. P ?.- 1 / g _ w. .. ~. - i i NA> /.<> I P on this J $oy or r. AND $ t, Yare h.y TAa <// o >1 ( "~~ sw ro $ ud.a ~ ~ 19 1 Q, ' TMm

AlpNy )%jyc;

%#w?.$??,*,;.- $tAti 9YYSEAS ..L L gSTIONg i 9 L . e,. A L l 2%HIB\\T 1 'zq-*Y g'ums)ts dw g-m .e n,- e-a vyc!!-

w waes.---+

or y -rt', y-we, e.- p cew.- g-u-er-se-

M c4MyaV

-+rr-gr-n .a.

--_n---,--v_-,, l e e, e 1\\T\\ OlVgg e$ a A / 29 % [ X H l $ h U r b Y A vs toAset M?u Apri yr go. @ :z /nwg. &wuu, O hv.t . A a 4 4 1).24,c }&a.c Aus) .xL < pre %~ mL ./u9 ea so nay aw.zt.xdopaus 1174. J.semu mw 25 4 a-yy'eAtMa,D.As edd)y 24w swhx0 &m iv dduM) anl . a m.

K hiuAo Vwihn s,a A~ SprA.>.ozm

.m 6hn w u v hM ld h nt) S.AcS11 >.. bas 14tsb' pznx>L M n/ - n s,Lr e n ,ao va 4 u, asy ygg my 4 /s -s,asnua n 4 A s nwjlA'e-w w w ; c A c.)7 .Awd )ed e my '.ctvd n'y and sna / p xha> A nw>& cjaZL .w /oor>v xw f&- &4 se 1 Eg A ~ E#HIB!T

l i .. -m. 4pHOQ9 g -A ENHIBd 4 h t 4 t 4 State,, of T,exas 4 .._ =. 8 'I C.ou..nt.y of S.o.merv. ell.. v._ + m. Thi.s i.ns trument w. a s.a.cknowled,ge.d before m.e.o.n 29 th.da.y of Janua.ry, 1992, s, ~...... m, u - - i 1-~A m. 4-a.-_. s. i by Marilyn.IIelms. N f etnn,) AAL .... _.. _. L... 4, ...._. M,.,..o? Jo d ' w'a l l " ' - - '" " 7 -- - " My commission expires .M 9 -2 ' - / I .r.. ..., e e e- .J .!.r ,,.L...', A, - y d. ,. s..w m... ..s. 4 \\ "* 44 kS 43, i ,s a r. i.c= =. =, t+f

s

.s..-

g

,e 0 g g . i *=e t. 4 g e.vg me < g N,.Jgg - ,g., 4 ~,,,. 4, . w en.e.. s -w. e + g '~,( l 'Y.M 'M .4 h I $ g. .O U k 8 % i s '4 m. ' 4 4, 44 - 6 L6 ?

- 4

' % J n.*

e 4 e

we o - se

b. * = 9 4

b 4 !q e e f e e -e +

t.

'. g" ,e -..... 6 = . 8 5 + 4 4' h 4 T. F 4 9 r t e, .a .S. w $ 4 g g. Tl ONg d .+ wg 4 - e ' .me <5 +, , *-, '. g 4 j s g 4 ', % 4 = i ** t

W-a 't g

g NNH1B3% g'. G' O k 9 ~ g .!1 4- -.r ~ + 4 .e-+ v e e s-r e-- wv c- --ee--.-s o w-e- e-- r-.- e <-e-e,--

vv,4-=

e-e

g\\TIONeg k P.M., Box 1712 A alen nose,Tx. 76043 ENHIB\\11/27/92 To Whom it may concern, I'm a resident in Su cvell, Co., Glen Rose,Tx. and I'm concerned as to whether or not any other companies or peoples have done any checking out and checking up on the Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant to see if what has been said is being'done, IS what IS being done. And if so, was their report on the up and up. You see, when you live and work with people who see, heap and know things that are going on some what contrary with what TU says publicly, IT DOES kind of make you wonder! This is not an accusation but a concern and when it was brought up to me about writing this letter, which just might not get just cast aside, I quickly said, "'kESl" To often we (people) just sit and let the chips fall where they may, which is a shame. One-reason we here in America are taught 111 story, is so that we HOPEFULLY will learn from past mistakes and in doing so, not let them happen again, or be the reason they happen again. As a Mother of seven (7) young children, (all whom call Glen Rose, "llome Sweet 1(ome") I am concerned with the issue as a whole from toxic waste, leaks, our water, rumora, etc... -I believe that people that do live here wonder, "Do we REALLY KNOW7 Will anyone have the integrity to tell us, i_f. there IS something to KNOW?" The questions could go on'and on, but I'm sure you've heard them ALL. The Question IS: Are we getting the PROPER ANSWERS?_ t Sincerely Concerned, M A J z:t m fq 41\\TioNeg. e, an- -sr-, A e -a - 13 ^ ,wmn o,a EXHlB\\T

41\\TIONgg 9 e A P.O. Box 7235 Glen Rose, Tx. gNHIB\\T i 26043 1/29/92 j s To Whom it may concern, As a former 5 yr. resident of the " Love Canal landfill homesites", I am DEEPLY concerned about where and how any chemicals, radio-active materials, or ANY trash *is disposed of. Let me ask you a question: How many of the investigators and those involved in safoty or those-in charge in disposal of these materials actually live here in Somervell County or within 50 miles of Commanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant? Or are they "just doing their job?" I am a victim of "Salk Vaccine Abuse" so I can testify that 3 when these " unfortunate incidents" hit you or your loved the "f acts you learn on TV or read about in tha

ones, papers are seen from a whole different perspective.

Sincerely, tdW44L 4 State of Texas County of Somervell This instrument was acknowledged before me on this 29th, A.D. of January, 1992, by Barbara Paul. ) c !m Ano ( Joyc[Wan , YA My commission expires 44 g\\T1ONg4 9 A ESHl.B\\i L

A

.s- _.9 _~ - .s.A 1_-4 n_, 9,OTl ONg4 q' G. A i H [Q4b_ d fM [_ A L . ~. r w e6-e equa.m. ^ M ^ cFLkJJazia- //m i 9.'1/. / A ian.9 a 29/J .---..-_e} Laao.-.u$c cd 44 da-ceA.-afwla y _ a o a c A y Ata. A u d o - ,wda>AEnak-s(A s Ap p & d AoaLuaAq hoJds.d A4 x ad Luco - Lis9m(Ses.ucwl 04LLaM. h .fsx L & s J w - c --._..mp'ewus ac-en 3%9 A.wuD nd.a -9xcsp dahJt$9f.2s%rL& Lek.lesc.$kyntMy1*(lL .g,- Dda R>a.!buu9end. d& 6 du L _ _ _. -.a a e.d.d M J._JA.i -cd/4& Jwm & - S L.,.a. lao L ~~.,jd.n;il s.1 i f ,&>hiAm A_nkidyn ~ ' $L x Lld/s ym, A uAaxsurn w,. g 4.u. A L a6s:.usan,-.y e m un.k -zAd. _.. Soc.-.auma+,. unu..-L 4 A pr n D.LI $bb.L h $34 Y 4ayk -..dw%.dAdmQmud anL dJLyLvs.ecx'tL- ... - 4L J a y e p & gf,a. m cw>u.t..an d ~ ~ ~ c .A .... e n p a n s . _.AuA%& 12 m cyAndd..tah.._ .a.. ),VA.A.u-y.m u s tx 4 LA., alm d k .y.ZZ.ay. Jutua.-$a&Muza. At. dea / .a,dw. J. icas. :/)uakud la L..&cmws.AL4cm..-- d.h.t.ax&A kmAm syd/m9 tLeaux 'ua&<Aku J h' / Sa QL as_.d L a p,3 dwh-tu; uke maA p e h k o w -.e w ST - -..gnA' ad.Asy1. hut.cmI.].- 5b fo b > & p _6aws,f_aoutomA g w ;w..:....... 9,9,,:. "~~ p14n A. - n... z ui. a n ~ -~ j au.wec% y;w r l

g\\Tl0Ng4 e. q A -- e au ki-ear ~ utp<c u p p g gs n= a - -. 9 % L + A.c,a _ ns.a n t - snL u u u..Aesk.so w mL.g( Xu.,.u.hs G..af swzhu.upm AduM, ~...Avd<.;np<.catAX hedsad&&iLenph-U_ a Mv'Q 3fA..AaAau umlug cbar.a.mW2t+b:--.... s Ay d w ~19ew A. e.yn1

d. orb L s L t< M a J < L t.- a.c.-. a t. g 4 c. h th 4 9 c ag 1 6 ~ $.:.th GA 4.-.qc L a n a n.sd<.d m W-.s va A 4 n'~ n.. 1_/d d & M m-wula a

a m- / / / s s _AA./. I'1 -. /] Alt 1 - 1-Y o hY (rg j&,f AWh1.AsLcAy eLwd Ael.cf-.f44ut'aJh. A'- h a u.u y - y at A 6 x & n -. A. b. w - -..- - - Acha fm.hxceut..f r.1.udd.kiv.itJ. d p a.< A h g.c e y. m. x a A < 9M e).e.w w w 4. s u btLS:Jaa n a. ac k y 4.t. k.a. B a u s d &.. Amd4swwum1LA.L u vs-uaa.-. NX!eL.AASI 4 JL<.cztkcch d.:dt*d$j.t WAs.fAdaef.J/ e6 6/ -. A. f a L a.a w u a n A A Q e u J' g.. A9 dmo - --..- - - ta u k A A n 2 % w.a. ~dyL./semK.fmwumazf. .._.tv/w.fuejuLau pA.d.4/u mM h>waanuJ. ....nfm y. W.enm..A.u S w 4 k m YN~b... -. A.J 2.a. x c w a., 6,. A m b a.a _ % n co m ;... -. .. -.. phaJalp A: D.Lapna.u,. 4.kJ.L/., f,c.t%wd< -. - ..A J. % cL e sta w aky. A c - J ...--.-.. eJ.Cpd-.am: tad r >.xap xy.sa.,.- y .--.-.a u -.O w ta J m d t 5.R..f A <2 m n d. C d & b b h g-..-.. - y m w.dkan4c--/' % W = 9 - r~MTv _t wmm_. A_. ~ _hjyl$",.' - mZao>ud4-pyH lR g-g- ,g. , ppg. _ y. , 29 _._._... dtd h.fv.e. mp_

gt\\TIONgg 1 9 A i A E g-(3- . n mx A b>k M ?ry em; AAp 4.4.4 A A M, l a~A _ % A 4 16 m f - ja G .ehw Ap44g. j 3 s A % s zas y q wn . AA 24h & y.6 4A+ 6Ls J+, JLC a q m,~4g .4 - M M L .Mn A e aw-v s b 6, l !.4_.9.-.4A 4,E w &. , au4t ~ ' h, a Ae & A o. <>~A M w AL~ Ap 1.4 ~ J i ALL oJ~l JL %~p.. &m %, o~J h Q ' ' 2 % ls y .-~C~ J LJ. to:A w A x0a n61 4 m du 4 4 A L a. w A p As x 4% .ma e .JJa M,m u of,s LC m 4 6 a A u u A A. L A e. b, ' J 4ira y o a p M 4 i muk, Jk JJ .&i .zorfAv and & m h a 4% i (AA 6 m

a..pA q w-k'y, l

O R A n A b Ag B\\g e

'. T,. ", gy\\TIONp A- .k Ow d .$s 0% k oo Q WA % m & wa .y 9 4.D q lea 4. .s xt~ A %ua 8.br E p ~t a sk.. . A.y A at Amesg A p Q b A q A> ul J .e . c A.1 4 7 9 4 J 4 4 3 4 J J AL & oma6 g,4 c s-9 g& M n vu _A _a Ap AL ..M w S A M.AaL m,as, _.34 A _ 4. M A. % u &.# %Ma~tM.. 2 dew. Q L'AA .+, J_ a m..n j4u-A 3+d g-r p. 2A g I4s.a a anzw. w a .: @ 4 n y. g w p 4 .' J p ha a-4:xd& y y. ud.x.J < A . Q dh p _ __ __ __. _ a .h.c//.?h&' . -... -.- [ [' 6t##.t - # g a n & %,.) pw 76op ~~~. 1 \\110N .s..u ., :_. _ u :_....: _._ : c ns,.a. v.e.__ : :., c._.:_.2 v , i..v..~~

~~1... _.~~
~~s. . _ s. w,. :_ :, :_ r.: .s.~~
~~m, e :~~
~~4_..s.._~~
~~r....~~
~~.c --v- =c:-:_--. . c m :_.si _s i,4 - . _ - _ y. w e : r. s. ;r_. C C Pc_. ~, i n_ N :. c'. '. '. N/ :_ :..:. _ _ 3.: :_TY, 4 _ s. s,..:~~
c-
~~..m m i,. i. :.< e.. s.. - c,s., v. =. c,: i._.:_ : :_ c. :,_ = o,,c :,s.c ._ : :._._. =- ii .e. ..<_i.e:_: : :- s : i _,- _- _.: : 7. :_ ,.o. : :, : . : v.. HIB\\,\\ i _ _ _ _~~
~~...._.. _ c x. i......;.. _..~~
~~_.,e_ _ s., .m/. u:..~~
~~::-::v t.~~
.,.. s.. s w =: _ Ap g / /st>_ _ _,P _ c,..x.e S _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.. _ _._ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ DO:ESS: _p_od.o.__..._2 2 f A_________ S -4_v ____.4'.;~. [O . i- . I,! [. t ;,,s,0 '. _( I rN C '. : : : ~*
i. _i_ "s"U..1."'

t_:: u..w,:_... :.- -.--- d:-:.:- : C u;::ni... iC F. ; F ;.- A : 12.... :

;---.r
~~,-__sgi _. _ - -.,U s _,_ C,: : _r L :.:. : _ siF 1: A r. Ur " ' : : i_.: :_ N :. '.-~~
~~t c. i i t. 4s -' x 10 r c.. s,~~
I NI I. r'. 1.1 1 U.<.0 t 0 IL> C - _'i: :^ ^ u i n iw u,. : i a c_. 2./s :. :. c.N m cJ -' ** :v i i t _N w L". ;; 7 0',(.1.s.. 0 v.. ) iss ii I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: 4hA/3/d AM) '//*8 OC ed- ,11,onn 17 ~ A % > J 4_, _ now ,1 sr e 9,1 \\ T I O N c. g 4 9, A NHlB \\T

~~m-_~~

.VOLWi! T!, ?1L* M ? E R 4 THE REACTION 8ANU_ARY J5, 1994 V/:1L YOU P:2ASE M AKE A ,,,, h,, r)- m s YES! I AM A C'TiEEN WHO LIVES NEAR THE COMANCHE .m a, M ELEOTRIC STAT:C N, IN GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I AM CONCERNED AEOUT 4 THE CONSTRUC~:ON, WORKING CC'NDITIONS, AND OVE..ALL SAFETY. OF THIS PLANT NOT ONLY FOR THE FSOPLE WORKING THE:E FOR THE CIT ZENS, LIKE MYSELF, YlHO UVE NEAR THE FACILITY. I WANT TO SEE 2.E RECORD ON THIS MATTE:. REOPENED NOW! NkME: }}ff)$f]- }__ QQjft_f._ ADDRESS: __,_/__(2_j _d_M /d V CITY, TEXAS: ((,g/____ 9_$_f________74_________ ZIP: 2(ff.,7 TELEPHONE: f/7 fG 7 7Mff I SUFFO.: ALL THAT THE DISPC,SAE_E 97 EKYSI~6f~6 MANDI~f~P5AK STEAM ELECTRIC ~ ~-~- STATION IS DOlNG IN THElR ATTEMFTS TO GET THIS RECO:D REOPENED FOR THE WO:,KERS AND CITIZENS C'F TEXAS. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TE7AS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINADOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: 66 hM f D 7 4 u r,, N." 4. dlAUl eviv Y' i WITNESS
/
~~WITNESS ~ ~ ' ' * ~ ~ A~~
~~%HIB\\T~~
w:s t. 11,. n : 42 :3 2 ts: 9ExCTron n m: A p.y.n, m - 71L1 '0U P~._3 ASE M A' E A ~ ,)_ $ n iofy& L 1 .a i .m ..... r - _ =_,.i v/.:u m :.. :: v :. : - _ =_ _t_, m< < e. v ~r. =_ = =.:. s : =:.t. e s<:. . i u. .. ve
~~P-.~~
~~,s.a~~
~~c... i s v i w =_ =.~. =._~~
~~.:._r.,s. _ C_a :.u e .,, e n s.c r-n __i....e-s.. e y. _,i_....,. i sj. v,,:A.s e_ cLw n.i :c_s.: c.. Oa O./ :_:..:. _~~
~~.:. : : i f.~~
~~. _ C.r_x. w..:. c - m s e a o-. 4 ... r, s...y r - i..:_ ::_,. : :_ o c. :.Ku r _ :: :.. _. =_iiT~~
~~u..,i., c i_.:. s, -~~
~~u ..ren o.. m i~~
t.. ~ d'y 7 g g7

vs, =..... _ _.. y. u. r..: =_ v. =..:. : i.. = =.:. -
~~.w:: : u m :.. i _.. =_ v <..e.--=_.~~
~~: :.r :.v =_ _~~
~~x. ,e ;. v.-. _ : :_ : _. :_ :.. :_..-. :. -v - _ :..:. no o.. __ )_t y" D___.2.1._.(E.1.K116.b D_____..______________ J.M ~ ;~~
Jn==

e.
~~.t 0_ ~_ .c_Y__-.].$.d. 6 M _?_f1____ Q16_' _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _ _ _ a ~ ; _g*_ _ 3 a,! 7, _t p' r C., _____ 1 r TS. w.t_W.. m 7. = ~: :=...< $U : ': ~ : '_' ~i "'2 2 ~ ' C~~
uCf i

1..s.. : =
~~. O. a. ' ~f '55 ~ ~ ~ ' UT 7 D L :..=_ _ r :F. A:: ~~- i. _om _. ~ u Iwr. c :- u.lvc : : -,, : _~~
~~.,. ; ; V -~..L.~~
~~F_ r N ^ hNI 1..r;: i i \\u'.: I :,. u..... -"~~
~~1,2. i IC NI l u w.~~
+ i-u. un,:../ ::s... c.N.:7 r.<l l1/.r1%:.- F T. r y 1.w. -e 0 .J M l a it w I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE CCMANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE 1 TEXAS. 1 REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: do 8 , #_/ M~# .,i.p A~u GA J~ > mnnu A0n ~~ ~ ~ ~ WITNESS WITNESS % 01 ONeg@, 4 Q' A EkHIBd
opm r II, 'n:n ? ? ? 4 Tut ntAcTron _ nmRy m ign 7-T, 7 T-1 q,A rA T, d A .u.u v... a.u _a .L 2. .u
~~e Q~~
~~.1 \\T l 0/vp p,, r-1 1,,, q,, / g m / i .u 1 V.a g' .. A~~
S! ! AM A Ot7 ZEN WHO L!VES NEA?iTHE COMANCHE P EA.' STEAM p*
~~. ECTF.lO S~A- ^ N. IN GLEN F.OSE, TEXAS. I A.',1 CONOE:NED ASOUT U.E CONST:UC DN, ViOFXING CONDITIONS. AND OVE: A'_L S AFETY g8 hlb~~
THl3 FLAN NOT ONLY FOP.THE ;SOFLE WOFXiNG - -E

.E. EUT

,., i._. :_
~~.,+ :,:_ i~~
~~> v. :_i_:. ru.r. i.<,~~
~~.._.3.:... _.:_ :.3. _ n. mi _n yrc v, 4.-~~
n. : :_ :_ - : ::r_ o :.n r.> N T u... :_ u..,.s. i 7 :.~:. : :_c,

._v. < =_v.. v, p.
t 4AM_:: _ _ 9_51 _ _ _ J tCs_C _4_._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _.__ _ _ _ _ _ D -::c. s un _ _'_(th _ _ _ _ __t_.7_ I _ _ _.. _ _ _ _ ___ _ E P :'e ]I.O N__ -~(_ '.,iT(, TEXAS: TELEPHC'NE: $_L~]- M1_,Q.161_______ l SUFFC:-~ ALL THAT THE DISPOS AE_E WOFXE.S Or COMANCHE FEAX STEAM ELECT:lO
~~: ~ ^ : '_ : : r. ~ :, N :_'.~~
kc r '_l. <4. I N ~i..:Fn.a. i i :_K.n' ~i v: i C C :_ t'u..'i r u ri e t 8 i i O Ni FOR THE ViO:XERS AND CITIZENS OF T:_XAS. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAR STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINADOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. l .J es, "~ / Mc.- / WITNESS d WITNESS g W lO/Veg& Q, A t~X H lB\\T
, VOLUME T.I, M t* M 3 E R 4 THE REACTION .TAMtJAR*f J5, 1992 'W:::2 YO1 P:2ASE M AK3 A 3,H H,,s o l,jG -.a,/ L.. ...a -. 1 bq \\q l Oj,bS YES!1 AM A C:7 ZEN WHO LIVES NEAR THE COMANCHE FEAK STEQ ELECTRIC STA ON. IN GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I AM CONCE:.NED ASOTJT E. THE CONST:,UC :ON, V/ORKING CONDITIONS. AND OVE:ALL SAFETY A OF THis FLANT, NOT ONLY FOR THE FEOPLE WORKING THE:.E. EUT FOR THE CIT'ZENS, LIKE MYSELF, V/HO LlVE NEA: THE FA:lLITY. &#HlBIT I WANT TO SEE -;E RECORD ON THIS MAii n n:OFENED NOW! NAME:k_Mq.xta.t ___h.C3_ % ____________________________ __ _, _ _Q_ A _4.2.1. _ _l_$_ ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ __ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _____ _ ADDRESS: ^ ClT(, TEXAS: _6_?_th_3Mr____d_____________Zlh : ~2iOM_J / TELEPHONE: _3.l_. __.9_9_2__MQ_2____1 SUP.:0:~ ALL THAT THE DISPOSAELE i ORKERS OF COMANCHE FEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION IS CO!NG IN THElR ATTEMPTS TO GET THIS RECO:.D REOFENED FOR THE WO:KERS AND CITIZENS OF TEXAS. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAR STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN. RDSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESE!!TATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: Ol O/71 l A L'ZA mmj 0/ WITNESS ~ ~ WITNESS ~ + g1\\TIO/vgg Q e, A ~ C #HIB\\T i
'. *!M E.. * *, A ' M? M *1 E ? 4 THE REACT *^Al 7 \\'!U A ?s*f ',2 5, 1.992 l-T y m y a fn a ,.i t. H d I .L J .L J J.L L
~~l..L~~
~~.d J - N '-*\\""~. -t r'- f & DA l ) i .a .1 2 a.L . i, _ t t.i..;.y,- y r,,,..;,,/ 1 1..\\.q~~
~~f\\~~
~~.., j si ; * - ' r y La/.u, j it ' :/ N':I l ,10_ L g e- . lu. \\ _.4 . wi p.'. r,r s.:e :..:_ <a : C-~~
~~- 1 :m. : ;. -~~
~~.. g v.. m.. =_ v 2. 0.0 :~~
~~'s'.:.:,..~~
~~m ,i _s .4. 1.%G,V/:.;.~~
.

.: II
~~\\'~~
~~9 4 .: ^ ^ %.' t i. ' ' -~~
N. j. ',/ /.. : '.(. A' r F r. N.'".".\\ { l { { Y

^
~~.4 v 54 vs. s < : *4' v r = : =....),.,F '.;. s. - e:v t.v. : v.. t._.: ::_.~ ;i : = I a. ,,., i 4 i u.tu.r t p i t s,:_.:.:.. l :., : : i v. u r m . :. Lg: v...v. e ri : e. ,t~~
~~i. _~~
~~s. v_.. %HIB\\T - - = -_:i. a. u.... i =. ::,,,::v s . /.. s. - - _ = :. :. : -, x. 4 i. a>. .,i. l U.'t;'. _l7_1_gc/ r/~l L 1.f__rr_____.b.,/~__________ ~~~
r. 0. 0 0 -

CJ..:.____@aL_ ___ ~/N 7 i
~~'e rg'_____ F_________ I U'. -,.j_(._0_@s .!U.I"XS3'. [ h, _ _ _ _ _,/7,2s .. _ D. N. :h. :('~") j: s: -] Or,Q,, d, rN -:.:.: sX. 'y :.2, '"", _. ' ' ' ~. 'j' u"~~
~~j' t c~~
~~" : -- 1 1 u l-QL ':1 : ' '" y :- - Cu n:~~
~~r';c.- :_~~
~~m -. n: r :.- i :.. g~~
_:si-

m, :- u.i: ::_
~~==,m.F ver~~
~~7.1, :i w. 4e v :c r c, s ly.u._ :.2.Ii: v.t.:.~~
11 1v,. Iw h + .m i-c y, C., _, _ h. - - - _ _,,, _. s iU i '. i ! t e Ur 12s. ; N.. n.. : i / V -A I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMEUT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY.
~~///~~
-. t /u SIGNATURE: ,A / / ~~ ~ v t ^ s, r.' s .* h (l?Yth., d _i__ s s-z WITN2SS WITNESS I e A EXHIB6
MOLUME II, MU'G E R 4 THE REACTION J ANU Aay,2 5, 1992 ' VIE.1L YOU P13ASE M AKE A gT \\TlogSp ~ r/ q I 1 H H H l u -. I p' .a e .c YES! I AM A C!T; ZEN WHO LIVES NEAR THE COMANCHE FEAK STEAM 4 ELECT:.lO STAT:ON, IN GLEN ROSE. TEXAS. I AM CONCE:NED ABOUL THE CONSTRUCT:ON, WORKING CCNDITIONS, AND OVE:ALL SAFETYC '<bl8 O. OF THIS PLANT. NOT ONLY FOR THE FSCPLE WORKING THE:.E, EUT -FOR THE CITIZENS. LIKE MYSELF, V/HC LIVE NEAR THE FA:lLI.TY. I WANT TO SEE -"'E RECORD ON THIS MAi i nn neur:NE: NOW! ' NAME: _____ d_.Q1&__6_t) A D A)_Of[___1_h_f_p______ __ _____ ADDRESS: _3_0__@_M_ \\ n 4 5 s CITY, TEXAS: __(!_f_'g__2656 M Zl?: 2df17 TELEPHONE: _6_\\') -3_T'] _ DADA ___ l SU:.:O:,T ALL THAT THE DISPOSA5LE WORKERS OF COMANCHE FEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION IS DOiNG IN THElR ATTEMPTS TO GET THIS :.ECO:.D REOPENED POR THE WO:.KE.S AND CITlIENS CF TEXAS. I LIVE WITHIN SO GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM' ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: . - 4.M. v YYiMA 00ith Osuf m WITNESS ' JITNESS t gTOiONp% 9' l A l eNHIB\\\\ l l I t i
~^- , ^..,,. - 7 N........,,U V O ' D= FJ.L 3,, Vf.,J.a.hm.7 ^ " " " A" b1 _ J. _J l .L .J. -,.J J J. y n.m % m 7 ~ s-s1 \\TI ONg4.O, e .,,.,e i .x .1 s.~. ..1I .d_.. -..,,,g j ; y a
~~/ OO ii o,~~
~~4.... e s.. T.l... I v /,y - i n/ :0 y:;; i,._ .}...l..i !, ; - - ~. ;_ g ti t e .. m - _ _.v. a : _.. = n. - _m c_e r. =_.=, _ c _ -.: u- .s .: 4:- :._ =- A 2,~~
~~:=_i(,~~
~~=_ v_. i<. :. :. _- _ t...,~~
~~x.,s..n c c._ m-c. :~~
~~c ::. r .s .. < _ i i s. ~ f ht l g },e\\ _ =.._. .t~;~~
~~. y.;~~

...n,;._ - __,. -.._..c:_- ~- 5.7 : i y; ~ . s., -.....-.,.;, ,, N. _ - ...3 .. -,. _.i. .i.sv. ,..a . l .s --.g =; tEru.t & M. C.z_ - _ --. _. - - - - --- -- - -- _ _ _. _ ------ f ---,n: /. /A hM U r".C.O C T[,I~_XA3 .?"/) gg,

~~_I =~~

~-..I .. s. -.,.... _. N 'A.~.,~-,['; y .~.~ ~O[ls 'E 5 "_. C.. g._. u<.,, .. 3.,..... or _ ...% w- >v;s..<_ 1,. .a. ..w _. \\. . s, t i.,.._._.s.-_.,. .,I.N.,-_....,, s. . -.. i 1... .L.. a . ts ... :. I i. s i .e.e-.,. g.* *=,.j,=. .,.,_1..,%n,, _ s,. .-._.,~.. \\., _: g 6 s.n i t
a. r,

s... s
.., n. .s_. a. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAX STIAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: .f//* 43 / kwA em W/rcrnf WITNESS WITNESS ~' %\\T \\ ONEg 9, 4 A EXH!B\\ \\ / 1
~ "7.{'{"Y0U PI[E55 M AKEI~ gt \\TIONpQ a,,, r-) q i, .1+ \\. 1 A .u _
m.
~~, :. e.. :. _ - _ : v, s.. u. : 'i / = =. N :.:..:. i.. = rr..,:e..v,.. :_ : =_.u.. : i :_.:..1 A u e n t _.,1 c c v., :: s. :_. c = ,s-~~
~~. - _... r.,._:s1.:.v-::-,_.:,;:~~
~~_ s... .2 . _ _ =.=..=. g, h, i B i. - _. v...:, :.<w, m. n c. v. :i a c, v.a..,.. v., m. c / =_.=.. .... e =_ ?.v.= i.=._,c - o v,. v : c :. i : : :,..,_ =_,., c. :.K. v.n _. :_ : _. 2, x~~
~~21. :_. _....~~
~~. _ _.. _ i_.,. . v. e z, :-_.,..u-... i_ r. i~~
~~v. =_.3.:..._ = : :. -......v.~~
~~e. u: ~ .__-.,..,.y<..._s_.._-... __v__. .._.s. M:E:..E unx s~ L'Sf O---_-_ L U H.2ll.Y C L ---_ _ _- _----_-- d x =Ess: _ _8_,- __- iz oY 7 2_6 ~2 - n ---- v 7t.o..s'.T~~

~~_ c e2--- u/~~

~~=0 s -- - T.2 -- - e~~
~~v. i :y~.2~:..~~
o @n) _.,, _._. s. _._.._ n ___.. . t. - l. ... i -. =_m_..,_: =. : :. = _ =_ w, e..d =.=. ~ C, = C L ;.w.... < Cu. =. r =-.2. .:. = v...,. =. =_. l =... A ..s.. s., w.. i i i -..- _'. = N "'- !s. :::: A.16 K.'. l_ IV. (.: ? u.!.: : : * ^ 2 -' . -. i... -e
7 s -.. Y ! 2. c s

:

i
~~+ ....L.4a _.. _,,. ! - AC.- C.,,y i L,l 11 ! th. - - - -.s.n -~~
~~V -' :~~
se. i.: e l' I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF.THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT !N THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES-FOR PERJURY. 9 ~ C / SIGNATURE: \\ d,4A-feg/ / d 780 v y 4C # >,dd-m% ,aa WITNESS WITNES7 gt\\Tl ONgg O E A EXHlB6
3.......,.c.u.,.,. -.,. .3....,.,
~~m...,-. A e...~~
~~,m r y V 'Q D '.a.L N.;c r 1;Y. 2 2 PA..a 2 aA~~
~~5. q 7 n z~~
~~1 O.L r ..a V r- -i i 3 m I 2 1 L\\t1 _1 .>. s i -,.___,..._.,m s u -_.___ 1 04/& _, _ C,J _. -, _ y, _ u - _ _.... _ c, =_ =. _ _ 2 1.. =_ i Q,& .s ,s : a z n., t. c s.~~
~~1.,,~~
M ..,, c. :X. < r..e _ _., _.. n_ v. o C,,,., :_ i :. y .n 4, - a._v.. : = >_... -. c w, _v, : - : _ : : :. :, =_.,.. :..s. _. :: :..._.=i_- - A ,s. .,, _,, v..: :_..., ~_ -..i...:._ ., t._..: _.i-, _... E ._..,,,___._.___s,.___,._.__.,_a, s- _ s.. d 3 _ gi_g_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _M_ _ _A_ _C__ _9_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ M5: __ v. A y __________g____j __g /Z_ - -, ~ _ - - v T{, 75%.2.5 : 6M _ _03_E_ _ _ _ __ _ ____ __.Zi= .2_ /_1_0.23 ._,_.s_ s.___. __...i n._. _ _ _ s ~ __._. s._. _ _ _ _. __,,,s _ _ _ i _.i _ ~ s _.___,,v_.,_.~ _.., _.,.._i...,. _. _- _ _ _i u. __ - _,_,y._.._._._s____,,___,,,___._-.__._._.__.__y,__ _ s _n. c.s. .m. v4 m _ _. .s- . s 'v-,i i i i. :. 'i C v.- ;~,vsc. vi, %
~~..4U J., i I LIVI WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS.~~
I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL-SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR' PERJURY. 77/I/e". E.+-,/ SIGNATURE: /?t':>"N.- LV Ab Nn . alw D f(/ ' WITNESS / dITNESS A
~~%HIB \\T~~
~~, +. -... 3,3,.f.,-e.. . sr ,9 .........<..o.. 4 T u.. v_~~
~~e.. r.g r, s s g h ~ (m 3".Q_; 3 [ [s r/ '.Q I~~
~~'W,I.I b. 3_I OU .t .a 1v.t.c sa vi 2 i 7l-r -r--t 9 am m n~~
~~p..\\T I ONego m~~
~~L ii 1 \\.i 4 _;.m .u 2 ~... y... _.-.1/.__ip/=. v~~
~~_:. L.,. -.:.s.,,,, _ :_ : =.:.., :, I _~~
~~.vs I1... Y "; L' w :~~
~~'.f.;. :~~
i
~~.* :. s4,' :~~
~~1. ,,1 s* A 2-:'~ { \\.. a. g 1.. is s s.. _.m... : _ - _ v.. e......<w n:. i m C r s,m_. -~rx4 :.~~
~~f. s, - c.. _ :.:. _ _~~
~~. C HIB\\T - _ -.i _ : _._. -..,. s, _ v. L :.. i _. :_ : :_ _ :. :_.... 7. s.,. r- _ i -.- . w :: :.. _ -..;: s,:. :~~
~~._..:_-__. i, /,:_... _.,~~
~~. _. _., _ _ s, _,w~~
s:
~~s.. - - _ : :~~
~~.n ex. <._. : v..;.~~
_h_u /ANo. _ _./.d.rA _E__ .01._Y/c_3____ .--- 8 Sa_ v 7 ..d.<2C_ i ; e._X. s : : Cr a Al _ c5E_ _ ___ _ AE___ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ C - : . _. _. - _ _.. i _. _, s _ ._. _ s _ ..v:... c _....'._~.':.- (s' m.'..;.s. < n'i, _, 2 2.'./ :
n i A'.

:. q n:

Nm : e.

; ;_ s','r

L .v L, e se w. '1., - _ : 'l :..A.-). =_\\..'i;. T.n,.:.._. ' 0 : :_. ~ :: - ::\\.'_ v ._i ., IL- %.a' :is: -.,: i. v,. ~ i _ C,t l l i. ;h - _. _. _:.,.s :. _.._,..--__ss,_. .s.. n.- -N I LIVI WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE CCHANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN "HE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. d A )) SIGNATURE: a vs (, r (~L e 0 sw fwGus WITNE 7 ' " ~ ~ WITNESS 4 0 m ofve 9 m& A tv6 HlBO
, m. m. Y7 5T l ' O J P [ 5 7 m,mS 2 M A KE I~,., _.~, ~ g \\TIONgg g..,,,k- - y ,_) q p# 1 .1. b1
~~2. 1-~~
~~) _s i A~~
~~_.... ~ ! p< :_ : s :_.:..:~~
~, i.a. ; w.,.. : : =.;./ ,...,rs.. ,s s... ,. _.__._.s,. .,.. i 3 s. ,_..s. q 4. ,5,,. g s ,,,,. _.. _ -._._.__._..s _ s i., .,. s s,., ...s. ~ ,_,.w, 3.:, _. : e -. : y s. ;; ---.,-.~.t. s..- .s _..,si. .s. r-~
~~0. 5. -~~
h<_ W- )_--- Y-__f d / h------ $$ k h_----_------ ap.a. V40 - --.c.y---_[_Q.S.e.. -_---- e_. f- -- ----- _ E = : -----.g3 5/ Ti. Ex.15: i-. .: ;: T.,.;. s --_. .. ' '~, ' _. i, -. '._ Z._ !." ' ' = ., -... ' ~ ~_'.'~ C~' re_3 v' s i,. ...-..--A-._.., _s ,.. ~, i -., t. I s. Iv .i,1.,. ,4. .. u ..s.4 i--,# ,- - - v. - --, s y Vi i i 4 ;.NC L r 1 M.C. ., - A r. C,... I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. s~~~~~ d d* M* SIGNATURE: </ #2/ a/.se - OOA 0 n A4-v On i .WfTNESS ~ ~ ' ~ WITNESS q'OTI ONp 9' G, A ~ '^vHiBiL ~ i
-VOLUME YI. MUM 3ER 4 THE REACTION TAMUARY 35, 1992 V m ' TY 1? A C l? '1Y.L.h fi.l? AE A T/ A T T ..? ~ .]r 1 V v.r a.u M 0.a
~~u M a.u.u l7p,< l(>,_; r)- 6T1TIo/1/~~
1 l' 17 T' 1 ,7 ~ H H m p@, .t .c .L .,_J 2 1 f i YF.S! 1 AM A C'T ZEN WHO LIVSS NEAR THE COMANCHE FEAK STEAM 4 ELEC~F.lO STAT:ON, IN GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I AM CONCE:NED ABOUT THE CONSTFJJC '.ON, WORKING CC>NDITIONS, AND OVE ALL SA~ - OF THIS LANT. NOT ONLY FOR THE PEOPLE WORKING THE:E, E i h//g lT FOR THE CIT'.ZES.S, UKE MYSSLF, WHO LIVE NEAR THE F ACILlTY. ,u--- ": RECORD ON THl3 MAiinn n: OPENED NOW! IWAN: i Y NAME: ____.Ag_/S_L___h_m____ naio_.S_______________________ ADDRES' ___/__.__O____L3__8Y. / @ R______________________ ___d__e__v -_.D__s e // _7__(o_o V__3____z$: '7_6_o__7__3 6 2 clTY, TEXAS: TELEPHONE: _/ _3_/_7;_j_22 )f &&____ l SU:FO:,T ALL THAT THE DISPOSAELE WORKERS OF COMANCHE FEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION IS DOlNG IN THElR ATTEMFTS TO GET THIS :.ECO:D REOFENED FOR THE WC::KERS AND CITIZENS OF TEXAS. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAR STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. [ SIGNATURE: wa, n% WLza. nw WITNES'S WITNESS d g1\\TIONgg 9 e. A DHIB\\T l
W)LUMT I I', ?!UM3 E R 4 THE REACTION 7 A NU A R Y.'15, 1992 i ' ' VILL YOU PLEASE M AKE A 9.T \\Ti o/Ve'n ,,1,a,H / i. r)- 5 i s .._L ., J L I a. ry' (ES! I AM A CITIZEN WHO LIVES NEAR THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM A ELECTRlC STAT C N, IN GLEN ROSE, TEXAS.1 AM CONCE:NED ABOUT W THE CONST:UC-'.ON, WORKING CONDITIONS. AND OVERALL S AF NOT ONLY FOR THE FEOPLE WORKING THE E, EGIdNl8 {T ')F THis FLANT
~~OR THE CITIZENS, LIKE MYSELF, V!MO LlVE NEA: THE FAC!LITY.~~
i WANT TO SEE ".E RECORD ON TH!S MAi inn c.:vr:NEZ NOW! OX b ?- E-l NAMW-.,lc ~ w-------------------------S-------------------- I nmb 8 . __ _ _ _0_ _ _mGoY__- /W 2_ ADDR==S. s CIT (, TEXAS: b d 6 IU - Of E N ---- -- Zl?; 2 b_O b = TELEPHONE: /--f/7-2 9 7-D 2 2_ i Su??cRT ALL THAT THE DISPOS AT~MVORKERS OF COMANCH5~F5XK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION IS DO!NG IN THElR ATTEMPTS TO GET THIS :ECO:D REOFENED FOR THE ViORKERS AND ClTl2 ENS OF TEXAS. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WIL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. A / SIGNATURE: WZ A- < o 6-ma n <d uw a WITNESS WITNESSl g1\\TI O/Veg 9 e. A EkHIB\\1 1 1
'C' g gT y} Q ;\\"110NQ. __v..-,,,,,, ). ,A!
)
m Q p, _). - 2;.. J _ 4 e.3.. ; n. - _ =_,,.. u.., L1v/ _ :_ y : : ._ :.,_ c.,c,s.. ; s,c y : : : 3 f e. i :e..s 1 _A.- s u.... s.._ I.. u.. _. r m.. = =,. :_ - 3.: O i.>.- =_ c :.. :.. ;. .. n., e
v. 4.:... :....,:.._e,.

c..
s. s. .c-c,.s.:.. :.,er -... -.. i. r..<i. o C u C, s.mi. i c v :s. w...v,.C <,_.:.:. ~e.3.:: - Es H l 8 \\I y _e s.,y_ c.. i..:. :....,_ ;_ 1.-- -...s. _.: :. _ _.. U.. -u - _ u..:- -...s. v. ..s. ms. m.u.r m< _ v.=_..:..._.:_ =.3 _... v.. ,: -2: . -, :. : _.,.< =_ u..v. e _ : s. ..u_ m..-o._ ...... v.. t..e s 2... :_:...: :. : : v, a., - -:y,- -
~~: :.. e,:..~~
w m.. 72- ..k. : _ i/C-. f M._ c.5-- tJfa - - _ _ -- - --- - _ _ _ - _ __---_ _. -, r, =. ~= = :. _ (j. g & [-- e/g g a T(, T:XAS: _f'/._6f/___ff ff------_ ___ --- _-_ _Z :Y,7_4.,4_t'.3 ...._____.,i_i._.,- . _ i_ __ __._. s,. _ , +.-...- _.i _ _.. ~ _. ~u.:. r. ;.: :. _ :_,,r. :..<:_:. ~: C> : CO 1.2..V r. 'r'.:_ :, :_.r..< :. :_.1 '..'. _' :_ "i :.I n, - 4 . r r s *:. I v. i 1.,r'l..1-1 -).'n'. l : tL> g:. ui:.6 : :. _- ^. =.;_, s.::\\j r u
~~. ; A - ;., v. 4.~~
4 u a ..ra .-_N.. X..s-se. !, - i F. : ' i i ' '. A C - ...\\s U,, Cl_il4: c vr :: I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL HILES - OF THE' COMANCHE PEAK-STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED'AT. GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. 1 I REALIZE;THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: // cmg - r W p l 1 2 WITNE 'WITN16S -Q#- e b q.T\\T10N g ; q p A DeterT -l ..J m 4.....
wm -.. = m, em m c,I,,s .m .c.u m,,I +..t. a.e.7 10 E P ~. a*.. A S'.;x V... 2^. xKR 3i . _s .,.,.,-_s .A - 37lgg.. r).
).
~~_l p) .~. a a. a2-4 4 4.. .- r s1_.. - _. _ C c,,,:.,.N.C.._ _ _., _ _.,1- ,le...-,n/:,:~~
~~z. : r re v w i~~
~~.n i n: sc~~
~~c :c.., e i ce...~~
y iv : . e. I N C,_ _:.yi nu, e,t, _ _.... I..,, C O S _ _,. _,. -s 2. a s < e.: i :.se.: - i...: v, yjr :p.. v n - r Cx n_ ' i in Y O, c'.Y,D 0"s :_.:. 2.'_'_ e* c'.::_'i bI3 IT-r, v,: :.4... 4 ms ai .o ',e. r!is:.'[ : L :.. l..: F n :! = _ m e.= v v4 -c -,_: :: :.. -.. =i L.ir '
~~- n..: :....:. -~~
~~v u e i t f i,, +. N - + .,=.=.=_..c, - _ =_ =. m_., =_.w. _e =, =, m,. u. e, u = v,=_.1.=..._.=.=.:. _ ci.. v ,e ~. _ _ e /*. I ** O N :s _ _ _ _ _ _ V I" " s. .'t,/i. ~. : t. b V.~ d V Y, i.~. O 41~~
~~d /," ', ' e,~~
_O~- ~ t .:.x Ei ___ n__ u_ ____e_i__s__c_o_____l_ h_1 _.e _c_ s_________ _ ___ ______ a c: = g s s ; e _. &_a'____f__e__r___________________ ____ ______._ - Jr_/_6' s/____.L_ GEL ____.r_e__ 'd _________z N _7__9_ VJ_ 7
~~rrv. tex.2.s:~~
~~Ic.._____ .,, _..s_i n'_:rnt y _: u r r,..- .._ _ i n e. .4 _., _,u. - _ - . _ :_ g,,,v, n_ K_:_ S O r_ CO s., NC,. _ .4 X, :_ _I :...~~
~~_ =v i.I v.~~
~~_se,_._,__ n: er+c : n ai.. n: r: _____m.-- ,_ s _. c' y. l y 1 :: n r.1 i : s___,N,_,__ C.__;_IOlO IVw'-" 'n:U 204:' PIC lU I r.. l w. 4 :C V W t4-s< -i-Nw L n e,w.~~
~~r, : *\\"._:,:. c.h pe Vil"lu,_.'O~~
~~,r 1 v s~~
~~v^,.~~
te._ I LIVE WITHIN 50' GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF-THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM-- ELECTRIC-STATION LOCATED.AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMEN'" F.EREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY.- ~ } fL -WITNESS ' WITNESS. [V_ G q T\\Tlogg q .e P NHisIT
.,. *. r.5 ATTACHMENT 4 g \\TIONgg g G. Q APPENDIX _ g U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY C0m1SS10N REGION IV { q fiRC Inspection Report: 50-445/91-32 Unit 1 Operating License: NPF-87 50-446/91-32 Unit 2 Construction Permit: CPFR-127 Expiration Date: August 1, 1992 l Dockets: 50 445 50 a45 Licensee: TV Electric Skyway Tower 400 fiorth Olive Street Lock Box B1 Lallas, Texas 75201 Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2 Facility Nare: Inspe: tion At: Glen Rose, Texas Inspe: tion CenducteC: July 3 through August 13, 1991 W. D. Johnson, Senior Resident Inspector Inspe: tors: D. N. Graves, Resident Inspector n 8 OE-4I b Reviewed by: u Late L. v. gancertain, unlet.wroaect dection b Division of Reactor Projects
~~r.s:e: tion Surrary 13, 1991 (Report 50-445/91-321 inspectier Conducted July 3 through August Unannounced resident safety inspection of plant status,-~~
foiic%p on previously identified items, followup on Three Mile Island ( Areas Inscetted: action items, operational safety. verification, onsite followup of events, r.aintenance observation, and surveillance observation. Within the scope of this inspection, no violations or deviations were The The plant labeling program was being implemented effectively. Results: Equipment and icentu ted, last three open TM1 Action Items for Unit I were closed. the partial personnel responses following the initiation of the reactor trip, Maintenance icss of of fsite power, and the seconcary transient were proper. and surveillance activities observed were properly per g1\\TlONg pe rsonnel. 9 p, B 91062700sF910822 ~ DQR-ADD 0r, 0500g5 5-i l R b
j ' "' ' gi\\TIONeg$, A 2 B bgg jgj% L'ekknesses were noted in the following areas: The inspectors identified several minor discrepancies, such'as valve-packing-leaks and a flange leak. which did not have work requests. initiatea (no work request tags attached). There was operator miscomunication leading to ope. ration of the wrong component in the turbine building in response to a heater drain tank high level condition. The licensee's response to a finding of water in the instrument air _ system was slow and initially ineffective. Instettien Conducted July 3 throuch Aueust 13,1991 (Report 50 446/91-32) Arear !rsoected: No inspection activities were conducted on Unit 2. Results: Not applicable. ~ l 1 g1\\T10Ngp ^ L 9 G. 8 ENHIB6 i i
[... ATTAClufENT 6
~~aJ g\\Tfotvq APPENDIX k~~
g C U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION REGION IV NRC Inspection Report: 50-445/91-70 Unit 1 Operating Lice e r 50-445/91-70 Unit 2 Construction Permit: CPpR-127 Expiration Date: August 1. 1992 Licensee: TU Electric Skyway Tower 400 North Olive Street Lock Box 81 Dallas, Texas 75201 Counche Peak Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2 Facility Name: Inspection At: Glen Rose Texas Inspection Conducted: December 20, 1991, through February 1,1992 W. D. Johnson, Senior Resident Inspector Inspectors: G. E. Werner, Resident Inspector J. I. Tapia, Senior Resident inspector C. E. Johnson, Project Engineer hdk h \\2. M L Reviewed by: Date L. A. Yancell, Chief. Project Section 5 Division of Reactor projects I_nscection Sumary_ Inseettien conducted December 20, 1991, through February 1,1992 pieoort 50 445/91-70)_ Unanriounced resident safety inspection of plant status, Areas Inspected: operational safety verification, onsite followup of events, maintenance observation surveillance observation, special report followup, and followup on previously identified items. One inspection followup No violations or deviations were identified. Results: item and one special report were reviewed and closed. Strengths were noted in the following areas: Comanication during performance of surveillance and maintenance activities. Label upgrade program, and \\TIogg Q g The equipment clearance program. C ENHIB\\T O g9 W h i . -,.. u,,
g\\TIONe9 2 C Xbl8k1 Weaknesses were noted in the following areas: Control of equipment within safe zones; Secondary plant performance, housekeeping, and minor steam leaks; and Control room operators' knowledge of main turbine generator auxiliary systems and associated trip setpoints. Inspection _ conducted December 20, 1991, throuch February 1,1992 (Repor W-445/H-io) Areas Inspected: No inspection activities were conduct,ed on Unit 2. Results_: Not applicable. 9 1 g \\TIONeg q e. C EXHIB\\T
pvvg-A EXH \\B6 April 6,1992 I Ron Jonesr was an Electrical Quality Control Inspector at Comanche Peak Power Plant from approximately Feb. 1983 to approximately May 1984; during at which time I found numerous non conforming discrepancies thru out the Reactor.1. After reporting these I was harassed, bullied and eventually let go, because I would not ignore or pretend these problems did not exist. At the first License hearing I was prepared to testify on the still existing problems, when a settlement and an agree-ment was made, I did not believe this settlement then and do not believe it now and I am still prepared to testify on the non conforming consistencies and harassment, bulling tactics that were perpetuated upon honest Whistle 51 overs at comanche Peak Power Plant. RON JONiiS I understand that any f alse statements or misrepresentation vill subject me t pentalities of purgery, f SIGNED: Q~ 'h WITNESS: L g WITNESS: d@% yQ //dyf e A [XH \\B6 l l
Y- ~ AA) M ' b g k,yk. A-G b &w w ; M.
~~m. bet aizh ewtw e~~
wu nns a m. A J cMN14,<u3g Q y y l. % u cat x a % e M 7 M fNa.J h^ a~ ma To cAdLL& sat Am 6 a ~ .As mwAna=+. a,,, >>t.y w h acAc %ku',bliva O.wru eYA l 'ALRL wl 6 sawta ensd d44 "O Mu M rj z h yi./E L %.4 p $ L u&tal pu. -y%'pd YTwuf%b W o.a m Ed ' mt tbuca cup-fd tic.$ &&f fllHA' whea9.N%b.A7bcJA$dA a 0 4 s W0ikewv w / .n;sja p a e.,,, 4 a g w f Ae~ wL ae &m,%&L 71x, A+a'dL 4Achd' @ "~h wlb?& da~ r]asAcf hy ' a.: h6" Ou'dtL Qs26 Aff d puu 20 1% aa k a p ma.n9 %w, yr_ smL& J M Ladd & Ea)clmfe )w d ad d W /ac/fo p %n u. a a a c s a y' w p e
~~0. a p _ x pawumag97 gwc s~~
~~e w w3. A bab ~%a h.a.gg '7 "d Ec gg @ #M an 5he p ~ w& kendL pwuuo. B Ao MdzJik c.gA,:s-rch. PEL u~~
~~) %~~
On-- %f0hn9;r &y k d n ~k-d a ~.
r p g\\TlONg & g 9. A ma cad ~ oF RgylgG y ( 7s w e. Wa ruc-t r a.. I. fuEsoDE ta Ta E-c-t-r-1 o p. ?-L M Jta s E. [64;.o+s 0 J ' "rH E-CkH4% o F. ' T*H E. PALv & IL o vt n, - ~ ,Fsv'E M e ut S s e v ~T" cF C r u M +M. PE.A t-. 'S. L S, T Wc/t44D A~t* 'THF5 F o+ C It I $ / & ~ To '~r a l. OF - //. t NCAtt.s 3sFci t E F 4 8-h i sto s E.1) of. T-wcit.wG.s t Cnvne.), inmv I,n. n a was s.J sen,a c.o. j l 'f E.An Fo /t. S /Jv4 + 7-ooT ( 'F-ic t.4 Edi~cEe 5), I 'in44 F = a._.___ p m J A d - r o t.d (. y, ( ja n.t _ T s. s. c e. MOJE% w Cot.L. % *vMA b /+ CA A,.E.f A IrJ 14 6 vt' r.J L Tc b Pf A P~TE C. f. 5. F' 5.). 'L % M we it.4C.43 JAPPR-eY ~ l6-<e.u-s F-ca-i+8 0M av< van s nsvo a s, ws.n~I av ss, _
~~AN D A>vs & C0, "Ti+C. L.A S "r 3 w EA x.$~~
~~e f. y 9, es~~
~~r wns A s vtot.<cv i s it t.a rH-c b & cen t~-tu u/.~~
~~o f. v f:d' t Go M AL ', 6 & F-E ~i'-( _ /H Wb E.r) ?E/~ 4 0 *~.)~~
~~5. w & 4 t~~
N ,A6 s -t S.E c osL9 5 /Je vs $. DVE.lTo-F. V NE 4.L /(,-Eu c-E 0F ~TR.-M $ - 4 'Tb M E. E. T il V D W G ~T~ '6 C.v"TT **l-0 uJt-W -c. Ms esoeue s'r~ w o .O n c.me.c.e n . St;b d t **T"l 0A 0P W g jt. W., 8 C C f E, .T. U R $ ht s t'C 4 6 0 , c F-T-c a S 'r4-I V P. ^~' D S & 4 ' JL ' ~ w E. bc 7 OE- . t*J 0 V W rr ?E c P L.F. To Ac.c cM to t )s /-f. CV tt[ WOP-N 9 m 4s auc v. A ENHIBn
f' fc, TlON A Aky;953 7p h 8I % h _ M hN h M y [ 1 - o ,MDT TO_ c4 A/c Y52 # WiTit IT, N o e/ A.ca.J Te d - 8 N3 bl h k ON N ' [h Q-g l 6 AFL-r W A-ed b n btrAir. rm w &F L p n ciL-4 s- ! L /Ir.,) 5 V f7" A f-TEA., Td. E GT+ t iJ J A T"*OeJ O F A4 -- l Pose-r.'s-.). T% E~< owCM NL P. ' b w oTeo.J % b~ V ,_lM Nh.! b h 4 8 9 Y -~ S Vff Cit.T_ons. M sg, y4 p g g, y. _ *T~u~.g. b. O, L., G v h j-0 i- ~ M. ec :zu.s' a..JsA cx.swo..m. PA t e s. t.,o c ) u. ~- 1 o ws_ve_ -,u_ a_a ees ve~
~~w s-crr.~c A~~
~~-["iec id p q... F ces. t o t c Ls. w e t ' F HE.D CO, oc o 8H il M *T7+E F'/WWe<t F-i A 5 e o. T~ps v : D E c.i o e,o 7 cr , ce -- NE. c.ca r,we. ro u s _ n:. w.s.s. (u vcau e_ ::~~
$ v PP o(L~r sEsvsc.ES).'T*"L-4-

P s <-O - n m a;. c.-ro ~%-
e h . N o _ PE.,:. b i % ;, : p.4 l & ScJ E h3. A5-'A W 6vI.r c.tL./ d a b) ME. H AD ~~T~o - 5 E J V._ 2O PE.crL.T. I Q o ._M.. w MFA M L~f t w o ~we<. ' P Y ' G 7'S E.,S - YT v F e.) s fE c.c.p-0 L E $ & % ~f-f & l Du Pt. T -t - (L6 LC& O e
~~(ds,wes-c:-w.m em',-rw a d. ww e.~ r-mn~~
~~. o,v or ro u racs vo,c 6 3c.)x t\\T-lONg c u o c e< -4 r v. ovsr wa-rs re-e cers det ' Aws3~~
Av e.-. f. s. e. s A r Pro t'4 e

wwo
~~_y,7y w --9we -w- --c-4* * - - -= e==- eph~~
~~HIB\\T'~~
n a Q\\T10h-4 2 9 e - A E#HIB\\1 e+ 3 i l UP To 'rHp)It ^Jf. Ir-L i (e.Es c E. T MAv6 A buv7sFvL sJ$FE. ArJD 3. . A r ste L L.i L b & J te HTSrt. L Il, '1 &Hb H M LA-rt. S i e,+. Atti. H. ELF [s) M E, T6 (.,. 6.-r !oF A(r.C, - Ls ',~74tt-o u k H ' rnbi 3 9 (r-t v 4 S t u E' 5 pe e s(.TN. I / t N !FA,. sic, wb we sc ts4 vs o vA - c He ec~ 76 - lDT.AG vrr4 P it i V EA ~1 js.rPo/L'r&r.J'7~ to AA E ~Ts"tu s ,T ' H A vi s o,A r C. o r
~~t. 6r~~
~~) $. e '1" . H A v t It E cr e.iTLY.To e.sS.b b-5Pch Affv.6. We A,cEA. 5 o(__ gag g, cs-E. f 5,A k. I 'T lg . A,J .,; o /L '- 4.* 'l M ~ff 0 A T*+6 -r~~
~~& 'Fu4L oF CAM i ~' L-.,~~
~~, h vs hl ? E-Of' GG CC )<. WLa F-cit. ~7"a & L 6 t,-F & ,\\a C. L.6+% vf O v t<- Fviv e '~ (,e.WE 17 4-1*s o e.* S,_ Ar I b .W.i$ t L r eoY L E. t'~~
~~"D+ E d I (a-~~
/3 J S M A $ 5 - % E C.Tc (2 / .YP% k A LL 4 pr&& V$. l.) T+ E. N E w3 < E.TrEet-T U. ?vTS 'ouT-u FFi -< 2. A +JLsL. H-6 oF- 'Tc n 2 o G H IL o (L i$A t l.- o c 0 rv $ e s. H 60 st-.k.i oun b h-L.S o ~ TG LL AR. o v~~r Arv-r Td ~ L TeT~ te-o 6 d> LJ /t-o,s 6.-, ~ . o x i c. w A 5 T E.! ., dv - e s, ce-rett -r te, es 4--n e n.e -i-a r aF tu s e s.-.c < t, ru F. . l te e sr. c o, to ~ rn.-. w Wu E " s-rc;t.-. s F % P t rJT FvEL 12.r.s h. +4-c 4 I. f h k b t
~~,w. & r 0-c e + os n.sa ca. r y w a~~
- _. m 4 e y,,o _ I EXH186 ~.
m, g&M% A 1 l. E.# HlBd M
~~vs, ~.r.e w, e ~, a. o r w,-c. ~ +~~
<~ r am r. ~ .,5 c,,, evuu.~u sc~s w -rw. wt,. wu-r sw M S. Y IW TY Ylb $ e.N$ fmd & _~h R ~ l & f 0lS= W h *YS O m .AAev~f D+E~Pu~*T~ 4o w C.- c.4,a r~ M< K. D E c I se e c.,5 ,bRovT O V A. L i FL u t-p+E It-7"g, ' L v & ~ ' I4Cf d OAlWOT* t . we H+ s e A vn n' s u rs on vanocysancone, . A rv 6 c,a-,~ c.7 A (t ~ c_ t.v >,, 't. 2 in. e 4. ' l ~ f4 no us :sc8cok t
~~6-00 O A-M b PJOOCOM MdS lAl H 4..~~
~~( "f" T". V. t % - tar .~ 4 s son w as raw us ra c ha ous m,ut L. jwrc a-L.-rnt. J-o oh. ;b s s t e s s-s ue; we w s c F : I c t.S L-S. a~~
~~.n ra na-s-c:os-e-m.u-n enwr w,a r-se e ra.~~
~~]JS O t. h ov F-c(L+. L.h o F Ti+ C T=A c ~r$ -TVA ~r ~i"~ L,~~
~~pcesr r su A~. ' T 0 3 -r0 Y~0&.~~
A r.J + NI~D cr es b s,.xl Fsee e. t 2-) ~r w-u uh Ls kE - . ru.-) w w w ss;s mow s wrco :, ~ -rs s s-a+ s a suas cc e wv e y~o ~ a ,w<c: s V A-$ ~f'*i nam 0? $. $ 'f CNP.T C.$. "f h I sI-le,JC.L. V_) E,$' y ei es w a <cs ws - o 4 -r e c,1s c. wzuua s s a s rn n ne u., e-a s vu. r s;. I s.Y.t we v w c.i s.c re c e u.s, o ~, w <-e,sr, .p-~s is e o s we a F n-o p a e r 1.7. s. n. s. re :s-rc p; T73 E M N E E.o ;-TD N4vC G-0CO 7 v04Ea 6,~Fi A.-av 4L W4 OJ : ~TH.6 4 HAvt1 A Loy4L E M r% o. 4 Cd i NTl .MA S Lo eJ c ts o-':- ~iu c -< NG. 6-b ~Tb htA { c m v ;~ s e-esesn-resu m ~m $or %s A
~~ITon- _~~
G S-e v a er :. ?%H[BN I
~ 1\\Tl0Neg& 4 -9 A 1
~~HIBC p c c-W 6. dLL co a-r[a v r Tc-E. >. foo%6 F/2.4v 0,;~~
~~j j fve G L t kGM, L. Aw ;3 Mr.4.re. s L, c e it p.v p -r. c i v 4 Mi c - c c y w cc+ C. e c Ef c e a E rv , 4 ee / A u SLs T, t (Mo-r-C 9 o * *> 2 < -[~o bD l T" o a - T~~
~~U tt.' O w 9.~~
~~w t.~~
he UL.b Ng-r 4 c. t y rr c 77.o -rb Ps4-< 'FcA J 6-l*L h ou.A e - D c L L.n st-Cc VG+ vi' TrJW'T. l'S - .-. $O A &"WL P&K. 4 e 5 I G.5 P A A -r_,E a t, L N c v g. 5, I '[, ..._ /._- 2. 7..,- i_._f ~t y IN A M/"MAI / /Atl M on this SWORN TO and ubscr ore ' 7 '["' 477 Lay of 3 A/# 19 s ( t 4 .L 5 :"',*; S tarh ' if1&rB [ j gt\\TioNg 3 9 g u g A-u 4
~~%HIB\\T c~~
1 ~
41\\TI ONgg 9 A A. p 2 S-m C y l @$ D H 9' 4 X . 06. 7u $9ae., X)/ 74cK+ - p,'ty &.:1.nwg6xavs a-) &.A40.4 A<>.44it )de:u S . /969 a -> u l 4 e> W bu i 3.d. /'t 74. J.km <6 des.e>q& A.26 >,6 aux 2 s.umu.).A h w y'chsk%D au 4A)f' 2%% a ~ MiLO e ww.edo dau./k> M 4 .- _. dA uv.. .JNi~$..1Ah..f,s.... A ca.214 4.-r M S& Aud Jbo-no & XAoru-me& a-r s. J-r m C.A af u b>>ur Q pdtas jear>w o.- A'oneaw A. -77+ s& w aa-swpa 4y% gggnoam%L qu a-r e A.s>o a-rol coumd. J&
==. 4-M Wx l . d O #7 ad a My ( m s?x 9 -r>u nsuu s-nd Mded.) h 7 Y, " " WQ l 1 Ng4 LA-RXy gg6
- _ _ _ _ _ ~ _ - _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ g \\TIONe9 g a e A ENHIB\\1 ~.. k State of. Texas [ Cou..nty of Somer.vell... This instrument was acknowledged before me on 29th da,y of January,1992, ~~. . ~,, / by Marilyn llelms. Ag e. ...c_ a. a = - _s.w b.N., A/I -.~ ..uu - yo g,.g y 7 : _. M d My commission ex? ires / I s.. e h th k.
p
~~= qr g h 6"% en.- w =N tuas +~~
~~4 g~~
~~t N \\ g L,4 e t .s in*** g'. k es%.~~
~~= we 4. w e~~
===e.e., w d4 *e - arma== *
~~me M 4~~
~~m = me g e.s &+%. b q,. e '94 %=r q, g g e W... gime e ___,.A_ me w %e J, =~~
~~e 4~~
.mw. e ,e e e e a.y ag! "mee ama, o* W 4 A 4 4 48 g + s 6 k w'
== 6 +. g3\\T10NeR <*.4.-...i = 9 g y A 1, s %HIB\\\\ t e
m g \\TlO/Vgg g L k P.M., Box 1712 - A clan nose,Tx-76043 ENHIB\\11/27/92 To Whom it may concern, I'm a resident in Somervell, Co., Glen Rose,Tx. and I'm concerned as to whether or not any other companies or peoples have done any checking out and checking up on the Comanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant to see if what has been said is being done, IS what IS being done. And if so, was their report on the up and up. You see, hear and know when you live and work with people who see, things that are going on some what contrary with what TU says publicly, IT DOES kind of make you wonder! This is not an accusation but a concern and when it was brought up to me about writing this letter, which just might not get just cast aside, I quickly said, "YESl" To often we (people) just sit and let the chips f all where they may, which is a shame. One reason we here in America are taught History, is so that we HOPEFULLY will learn from past mistakes and in doing so, not let them happen again, or be the reason they happen again. As a Mother of seven (7) young children, (all whom call Glen Rose, "Home Sweet Home") I am concerted with the issue as a whole from toxi,c waste, leaks, our water, rumors, etc... I believe that people that do live here wonder, "Do we if REALLY KNOW? Will anyone have the integrity to tell us, there IS something to KNOW?" The questions could go on and on, but I'm sure you've heard them ALL. The Question IS: Are we getting the PROPER ANSWERS? I Sincerely Concerned, MA ism M 'q41\\TI 0/Vgg.g nowv u n s run s A 4 - n> - e.s antan we NXHlB\\1 1
A P.O. Box 7235 Glen Rose, Tx. b!b 76043 1/29/92 To Whom it may concern, As a former 5 yr. resident of the " Love Canal landfill homeaites", I am DEEPLY concerned about where and how am chemicals, radio-active materials, or ANY trash is disposed of. Let me ask you a question: How many of the investigators and those involved in safety or those in charge in disposal of these materials actually live here in Somervell County or within 50 miles of Commanche Peak Nuclear Power Plant? Or are they "just doing their job?" I am a victim of "Salk Vaccins Abuse" so I can testify that when these " unfortunate incidents" hit you or your loved the "f acts" you learn on TV or read about in the
~~ones, papers are seen from a whole dif ferent perspective.~~
4 Sincerely, alvtot ~ ~ Stete of Texas County of Somervell This instrument was acknowledged before me on this 29th, A.D. of January, 1992, by Barbara Paul. 1 c g,n~ % c JoyClMaY My coc: mission expires J IA / l g\\T1ONg & 9 Q A DHIB6 l
i.........., g CTI O/Vg 9 e, t A d p/ N _! d, d a di 22? % E g pg4_% _ _ ,,im g6LJJacin /p u i w & n w s n m y) e L.u a a.-.s s >c c.cd A A do-es & d a : - dw)1.c4&Owak 44 asut.Qa6m h %Ms.s, . d a._.t y b p a J d w s .y_ x4_ alm L - f e q d L.h ) J f- // m A ndaLD-34 __ _ n. pm Ly -_ _..Q ddasa m m/Gc4Ay. g t a/ J A Ra 17s a y a,_.d k.. L s_. e eah.&EcM._,slu -m J AL h A~ _ n d6 S L amhao. da avwh $ n3] mNd ~ ML x x s o l,a 4 1 L M S Z o.p.y A x &. ztAna._ y( m m. k.rA d. y_.. Lb):.Ag, _ - - u k./ L s L s: n.. p oc.,a.w w a y.- m ca,4 ~ A A 4 -... -.- ^ % & h T/I M bkb4bf _.rb8 U / w_ ...eLi,%.dLd m u nswA sad _. dug /<aL&s.R.-._ -.._ . J.A aa y. 4 _}g4 y m M a ~ m e & wq/ a A am h & A4 p t ...y A dw & w M ( k A i M
~~p. m y &m asa J.. J. m 4 u A u 1. A 4 s m a J a n e - _ _ -~~
4 }p.axLA &*nl<aylla,7 tacaud. f Q -. - 3 p a 4 9 4 m-n d w.a t n .-. _ _.ma 2un ox9:nLCah anns am qh J__m D -. sum.L m d 3b & -w.ek _y HapalA_oma g ./N ub w/ kad om dl m.a.L. m m.O hk.~...... k. W ..y ine = 4 umw,n s.n.2
QMNEg,, A -- E,v - &y%ur_.ds pok g_'sk A, o iBe,t UA as 4 J 44s +4&~L -.namd sad a rau1s12-as-Q 1d Q x.e6 apu d d<_.ea a Om d4 s e A &' J-te A ~ 3' sd&A mwh<v t A AaA+ M kutd : a,e M U z4 4 l _ad w m mp n s>-gu-urim Lua.h.c y s gs.huj.w a n f./4ess,&em3 JL4 vb_eL4_ w,A us'in,a/9 19ga r ~.. A_a W _,411s n3 mul'a - .a su, ansa L x nas M - .AQf'J_ M.L& A t' A Ad d__,01m/sw& . - A f 2 n_ og4s~fA6 mLKm A hw Ass +t.f, at tkscwet.. k+As pyn $et toddo.- <2u,MJ /w an u s.d u._. wM e.w-W M_azung__Ates 6 _. _... .$ d A8SA4_p educeL d-d a M U.Sx4.a 6 s... Af&~. som .tA> & A g lag.ua ko..-.. auc tL.A&2-4M.swnwder w.ep-pm Aamunuaw. n19. hk &su..A.ud..wAnw?'S~b. --. .._._ A.Jt_.a 4 = k L. 4 h _.4 A w c2* -._ _ &w.Adp 2414 cad-6 D&..y led _... _....._._&AAlue A h m h dmpn e % A._... . a Q i n. 4 d A g. A # w p.h s ~. _._._ _. ~- eas.as-.a--h.1.a.isama&'.MQLTA9hl2p.. -p q r gi xmmrwxn-b W. Q ~ - 0-b wam 4 e m.x w m -f"'gsp-p tri-h, in si _ _. m w -.m M - Is ~^ .h__ Qm/j[. n g
L 4t \\Tl ONp9 9 e. A g YQm 1 .sgfr7x \\ A M/- M hg' a x s% s 6 & a J4 %~ .L. A m p .Q .tha-JQ A.Lp. J A AL LLA y y m w .M .ZLe & y b.4 lcm, n. 1C u 9m de w alt $ ; cfw-w A h./Jan A c._ A _.o.,_ M re re L&-....e(A. &, m, A . L, a.tLe. 6.a a As - A J M& w.L~ &. um J .44L M .AL Q owt. .a n, a 4E %.a ' ' is k.'~ h wa . A J LA. v2 J -s6A r161..%. a.un. ' py 89 nsA .w1A ms a. .AA m p AA tr y. .JA M p .446 A.J.y wk, y a (~n u A;4.Q LL AA ad. A AAL th a Jk A 4 .wfA> & & eur h ~. 6 p u - ~ p 4;gEer, ag _.c.n a L+. HIB\\f p. m
ciDMNE4 q e. -v A l A .a. && A Je $2AM\\12/a w AqW%' 46 a A.s Al, . &cL. A.. % q 9 .A s u a. n.b r .4 & A M M, S Ae erp & y Q.L A q A> el a2 n .chlk 79J , J.ht J &J J Lt~ A A 42, JL 9 .ALeW J ._ %p._ A (_ a A p 1 n n Ak .%c-_W_% h AA ,al, A& A M M% 2 ..b LJ a M, 2A +)gM ~3 QM .J n.... a. w s..n. - .fA A Az
~~e. u.p.h a M A :~~
. -...xh+~. J zh A ..:pA,4 ' J k & y.o ff. L A. w & f L 1..a r 9 -...- --. k. a a _ &.s & y f ud...es.J < A .$d h.?8k.2 db t% ,i 6Ltit.t- % on ...J.-. & Gm J+r nos.s EM-F17 -?S5 0 ~
n2 u. v ~ Ir - - n - w., .,,,:m n. au w " " Y O"J .F P'J J.LA S U f 'A4. K E A. N1 ...J.) .,J i g-r)- T- ,7,-- L i ,.-4 L J* 4 .s e 010 ~ .6
~~...,. 2~~
=. m/. v...-.. / = :. l =.... . = Cn,m....v. :1 s t._.= =....,. : 1 =. 4 i i s. e =_ =., =_ _ ~= m v t o. ~_ =_<.. :.co= =., =_.:. : i -... c = :. - -. 8 .s... e.3..= =JY c. u _:.. v..,., _. : 7.. s.c c c u -. c v. :.. e. s. _ c s/ =_ =.. = s s i s 4 c_. m, _ = - =. i =.. =_ = =-. :.,_ =,,., c - s., c.. = =.. =. e u i u, = =, :. s - ~
~~.i_=~~
~~- =_, : i... =_ o...n :,_,., u. o..,. =_ < =... :~~
~~u.. =_.. -~~
~~.i.. HIBL~~
. s.. i

. =. =_. = :. = c. :
. s, n. :.. 2. . = =.. = =.. : = v., =_. _. . i,. s. '.;E: AD.g/ aS Ca------------------------- D=.E55: p-.o e. ap--.2.2 29 -_------. --------------.----- ) =X.< ~e. A./.E.A) 2.%$.6-Tb-.---------------- '.. :. 749$3-s-
==

. i J,u a i 1. ;.,2= r v :.
~~i :...,'. :,.'.T L ',~~
~~2. =- _-, C=-A..c.:- C.- CO z,T N C r.= c.:. < :. :~~
~~= = v i..es u c - t., :. = : <<~~
=
~~4 -. s.v,i,.~~
~~i. s< l.. = :. :. 1. t 1 = u.,,=. i :. T. '+, (n :..~~
~~a : =..= =.=c:=N4= - - e s, u t .,1 t.,,, a i J :.- 1.. = o~~
~~s =....v..J u d 4 th4 -e V. 1 :.A..c.~~
~~-~---, e~~
~~eV i~~
I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALI2E THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATICN OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SU3 JECT ME TO PENALTIES--FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: .4hA/3/d S/$ # 8' P WIT!tpMF ~'- ~ WIfRES'S~ -t 'A NHIB6 m. ~ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ f S w c .6, e m.w& x+- .,-.rmn,.e - w.. -.e +n.., _,.,,_,.,.m.wg,. c-y, M.,.-,_...,m,,,i.,m-m 6m wi,, ,,;,,,,,.y
i '~ N!UYOU PI55El! M AKE I" q, pa q, ; / l i lr, r. rj L_ u.a, 41\\T 10Ng 'E5! I AM A C:TiZEN YlHC u NEAF THE COMANCHE FEAK. STkM iLECTRIC STAT',C N, IN GLEN ROSE. TEXAS. I AM CONCE:.NED AEOUT p' 'HE CONSTRUC :ON, VlORKING CCNCITIONS, AND OVE.:ALL SAFETY ?F THis FLANT. NOT ONLY FOR THE PEOPLE YlORKING THE:.E, EUT
~~OR THE CIT!ZENS, LIKE MYSELF, ViMO LNE NEAR THE FACILITY. gNHlB \\T YlANT TO SEE HE RECORD ON THIS MAi ic,..:OPENE: NOYl!~~
NAME: f]//)d_E/d__ dLd'_{___________________________,,,____ _[.(2_ MI_ 7A/d ADDRESS: CITY, TEXAS: _[d,u_ Cf__f_______74_________Zl?: 2df_f] TELE: HONE; @7 N 7 Nf9 i SUPPO: ALL THAT THE DISPOS AELE Yl0RKERS OF COVANCWi P9.K STEAM ELECTRIC STATION IS DO!NG IN THEIR ATTEMPTS TO GET THis REGO:D REOPENEC FOR THE viO:XERS AND CITlIENS OF TEXAS. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINADOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: 64 hM / ()- D7an~, _ &?sk, dl< mal l e, AJ k' 0 WITNESS ~ ~ ~ WITNESS 6 / i 41\\TIONp A
~~%HIB\\T~~
__----_---___a-.---_--___---_-_-_--__----------- -.---J
n u. w m tr a ,n nxe, m m.:n.:.u.. m u'y b r 1,4 r -- 7 7 7' 3 Ii.i.a :a u, .a m 1x .a p -, r/ p[ -m,, q s 9-v 4 i ..., :.. s, : : _ =_ _- u.s -._ :m _ : :_.:, _ q...4 n loge 4 .m s. um s m : i.. e..... c. -
~~.,w._~~
~~. 7 :.. : _.-~~
~~y..,i... : s :. ;_:.~~
~~.=_.u..:. . 1. c. ry.. _ : =_ _.. _ c. e. e. . c.,,,, s N: i :.c-s. J. s,,. : m.... c c, s.,. -m4 :. 3.,. 4, cy = =..:.~~
~~.:.:=_,l~~
~~.s w-w n- ..o.c _===_.=g g y;9;z s... cs..v. r :, : :~~
~~, :_.. r. :..~~
~~.....s,- w: s .:-.=:. =. : : m..:. .s. e. :. : .... m. ,. =... s. w. ...s.-,. : :_ :_~~
: : - - : r r s i.....:.
: :,. : :_ v. e _
~~e.!gv L tt. -- 2_,--.(P-_t-@Jr f /)--..----. ----------- ~ L'::: 20 9 )(---} pf 1......-- b e. _g--- 3~~

~~.ki----~~

~~-Q3 C---- -------- I : o T'l, T:XAS '.~~
~~: : :c.s :-~~
c,;. 5.: ~0 ; F. Y_ ~,~ E l..s f f ~c{,~ W T I..E..~^ f Y..;.' a -h_.';..Ii : ~ ~~ T . _ - _.. n .. I i :_\\... :. i. 7.. r :- -'.;l O : : - : : c. :. : v.4 .c.iis. Y.ai:. r'_ lNl T.':::: s : e. t s-s. s . i ,.j r. 1.. : e r < s. L I. - v.1 C ' F---.<.,2. ._.._g._- i i i. : I LIVE WITHIN 50 GE0 GRAPHICAL MILES OF THE CCHANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SU3 JECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. 1 1 SIGNATURE: dd/ w V ' ' %r 8
~~#/ f+T~) > jp W~~
1 L2 _ {e_ $ ' Y, WITNESS WITNESS '~ ~ e @ lONeg q" e. A EXH \\B\\1 1 4
..:n,,. w:um a m mewN .wm T n, a n
~~q.,.~~
~~q -4 H I !4 I d I .s.s _a .a ...a.a s - w / c/ p \\TIONp& Q . a 1 .._.e 5! 1 AM A C~~
~~ZEN YiHO LIVES NEAR THE COMANCHE FEAK STEA.'.1~~
~~'q ECTRtc STA :^ N. IN GLEN ROSE,7:3A3. I AM CONCE:NED AEOUT E CONSTRUC :ON, ViO: KING CONCiTIONS. AND OVE:A'_L SAFETY~~
~~THIS FLAN-NOT ONLY FOR THE FSOPLE WORKING TH.E:E. EUT g8H~~
~~, m< <.. Lp / =_ i. :_.1, i..=.:.:. _ i. :_ i, i y. u.:_ Ct..m =_s.: yys:_.,1v.gri: v u i. i. .p...v-i,, : :_ :_ -_.:_~~
~~_.m_ u:.D O N T'..'. :. 'ni.. T:_:. : :_v^ : :s. 4 :_ _ v. ^ ", i'.~~
~~4. n 4 'o=*** 1.ME: dp_si_3.__MCs.c_E_______________________________ ,n_ :~:c._ Q Q__$_ _QX__ _]_ $ ____________________________ _n IIY, IEXAS: b_hh_'L. _ _ L T' _[.L._ __ _ _ _ _ ___ __ _ _ E~~
~~2[o~~
~~'ELEPHONE: f10_S92d1Bl______ I SU::O A'_L THAT 'HE DIS:CS AE_E Y/ORKERS Or COMANCHE EAK STEA.'.'. E! ECI lC iTATION 18 COiNG IN THElR ATTEM?T5 TO GE-' THIS :EC O:D.EOFENEC~~
~~OR THE '//O:KE:S AND CITIZENS OF TEXAS.~~
I LIVE WITHIN 50 GECGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATICN LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAf ANY MISRIPRESENTATION Ok FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. b_/ /'341 SIGNATURE: f ) 2-<2 N E
~~GAus-r-)~~
WITNESS d WITNESS ~ p \\110/Veg 9 e. A ENHIB\\T
N1Y01 d.3555 Y AK[5~ ~ lV.a.p,, r)- 1, , im - { I A 4 % ~ ....2. 2 1 \\1 I ON~ ES! 1 AM A CITIZEN V/HO LIVSS NEAR THE COMANCHE PEM STEh 9 iLECTRIC STAT ON, IN GLEN FOSE, TSXAS. I AM CONCE:NED ABOTJT E, 'HE CONSTRU; '.ON, WORKING CONDITIONS AND OVE:ALL SAFETY A ): THl3 FLANT, NOT ONLY FOR THE ?SOPLE WORKING THE:.E. EUT
~~OR THE CIT ZENS, LIKE MYSSLF, YlHO LIVE NEAR THE FACILITY.~~
&#HlBiT WANT O SEE "E RECORD ON THIS MAiice, r. OPENED NOW! N AM E: k_Mca taft___b.C3_r_?L.____ ___ _________ ___ ________ ADDRESS: ___ __O 3_ _0 1._J_7 @ '__________________-_________ CITY, TEXAS: _b_l_E,h_3@_C ___D,_____________Zl R : ~2bO_Y_3 / TELEPHONE: _8]_. __9_9.2__iQd_Q_2,____ l SUF:0: ALL THAT THE DISPOS AELE Y ORKERS OF COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION IS DOlNG IN THElR ATTEMPTS TO GET THis RECO:D REOPENEC FOR THE YlO:.KERS AND CITIZENS CF T:'XAS. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAR STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. O)[. O/7d, SIGNATURE: dbzz2Aaw O/ WITNESS WITNESS g \\T I ONeg 9 e, A 2#HIB\\\\ 4
~~.n -....:.n t, a m arse-w w:m v. un T77 7 7 T F~~
T p* y 4 r T,< u u. .-..u.a _ _, m .o m . _/ Lr4; ,-) T 1 .L J 1 \\ ).u i L - _=.,4s. =.r ; =_ i 1 =.. = t =_ i..... v, = = =.., = 4 _.m.. - n) l npy = ....iv,. \\ V - - - _ _ _........ c. c.J.. s =, 4 =. r"C e v___ .,ls.. _.:. s.1 .L ;. \\.. O c./= =..
=,
~~_s,,e.,.: p..c cc,..,..l x.4. c 4 s.. .4 w.. A c w. :.. n._ =_.= __ :. =_.. =..<. v~. r _ =_ = =_. =_ u_ i _ m.. : _... -~~
~~m.. :_. v. :_.~~
~~. : =. . c., =_ s.. =_._ :. _i _. =_ =.. ._.=_ -=_ :~~
~~s%HIB \\T~~
~~_ =_ t :_,, :. _ ~_. a i... n....~~
~~_ =. =~~
~~s. 4~~
~~-.,a .,,=_=_ .': 5; 4fl_}_f.el~~
l
].sOf_.M ____ b.,l_.____ _________.__-__ ____ 4 .:.d..:. __ _4.:LC.,/______ [______.__.__ o =. = :- +:... 3' $3'. _[, j,,-*_____g.2,f"____ k__ _______2 . 0. _ 7. e Y_ H_. &.. ; = :. _ =].,, s rA =_ = = c = t~._.m......m... _ = G_... u =_.b.'.. = ~=_': : =, 7 -]- gQ L O ' ; :
~~, t R~~

=OU \\ u = h:. 1.-l i = \\. <i : :,. c. :- ul : : = - =. =. ' ; = v =.. m .. r_s c c, s Iv,4 Iw Iv 61 i.w .w - - _. - _ N. , _ _ _I. s -.- 0. n.. i t, - lN =.; e.s. ' L,i '.14 : C v" :: I LIVI WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE C0HANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: 134/// - - vu ' y f A t]h.[ ,f((_ s?.YV WITN8SS WITNESS e a A I EXHlB\\1 4 n. .s--ri. u ii.r-
YC)U NAE 5 M AKE 5~ g1iTlOAj2 1~,,~,~ 4 \\, \\n,, e) q 4 .,_.) 1 G.a y' .a ES! ) A.',1 A CtT; ZEN WHO LlVES NEA? THE COMANCHE FEAK STEAM 4 .LECTRIO STA~:ON, IN GLEN ROSE. TEXAS. I AM CONOE..NED ABOU g 'HE CONSTRUC-'.ON, WORK!NG CC NCITIONS, AND OVERALL SAFETY < gU l8 )F THIS PLANT. NOT ONLY FOR THE :EOPLE WORKING THERE. EUT
~~OR THE C!T!ZENS, LIKE MYSELF, ','iHO LIVE NEAR THE FACILITY.~~
WANT TO SEE W.E RECCRD ON THIS MAi it.. c. vrcNE: NOW! NAME: ____ d ).o.s r _ S _ e.s e u m _ 1.o_ m ________ _ _ _ _ ________ ADDRESS: _ 3 _0 _ _@_of _.1_ W 5___ ____ __._________________ CITY, TEXAS: __fG M A C LE _ 3 ____________ZlR: _2dff3 TELEPHONE: _h_l]:_B_T']__f_LjlOA____ I SUFRO:.7 ALL THAT THE DI5?OSAELE WORKERS OF COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION IS DOlNG IN THElR ATTEMPTS TO GET THis REOO:0 REOFENEC FOR THE WO:XERS AND CITlZENS CF TEXAS. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GECGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINADOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJtTRY. SIGNATURE: . MM /-{. v '1Y1aALc 700nt Wut bzw WITNESS ' JITHESS '~ g3 Fi I OA/',e9 9 9, A NHlBlT l
f - 4 A. e 4. e,o e, =. =.r. i,. f, - y t. f. *.P "J ?.g e,. e.=
g g.

t. *. } t.e g g e.r
~~.S T, # rp.~~
~~a..~~
..e p m ~m y x r 7m. ~'h ~ p5. y ' T 7 ,4 u -4 NI ...6.J o s.J L ,J l. C.t. .n. .a m. ,m am am - 9-m fa L t J / a \\. / 9,1 \\T I ONp4@, .a r, : $ 1,'.) _.... y i n/::. 3. :_.:.: _: - . t.;.s, _: : : : : u 4 . i 4 .O_s. 4 :, v,a : :. _, ../.1. *.
...' f,. ^s *. *

: ' T '" /. = ~ V '"4
~
v.
~~A a i~~
~~,.ign.~~
~~s L,,*~ 4 M. e ' t* /.= L .=L2='-'{ . y,,,. N,:;. ~.,, s.. ee e.:.y '. \\.R * (.*. \\ ',' ***t.'+.*.~~
~~= =, "O,'w [ y w~~
~~s ,...,<6.* t.:. c' Ps..'/:iv..". ^ i. .....;..='.......f~~
~~4 a~~
g .;*,, O **
8.
~~.. T 6 4,t/. w. ;. '5 .e O7 "1, :., "" * " W er~~
=
~~_=: --:,~~
~~v. _.:...~~
=.=. = = - : : <. = - 2 12 a h & a.re... .:=; gn-- Q L_ A* ^ .====. - - c.-~~. d W)_.z.54,..T _.__ _ _ _ _ __ ___ _ _ _ I : T_ __ '( T XA: W a.,>.n _:,s,.= g,.q q-c =.y~7 91 - ~~_~.i i =.9. =_ _ =_'. = {..n 1 : :: r ! u y_
~~-m :~~
~~vis , < = _. ~ ~ *T ~n...F. r = = = A e = -~~~
~~t. s. u. : 'l :,,r. #~~
~~U... : :. I L..:,-. '. : --:- :: * ::v:. 1 a s -"I w, y 'i :. N a:~~
~~e. 4 t~~
~~4 e i : :' : v.t:., :~~
~~'.(..;...~~
.%'::.:. 1.y a 1 u. s *ii vt t w_ I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE CCHANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED A"' GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISRIPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT. IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SU3 JECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR ' PERJURY. y SIGNATURE: .#v' s N ONh D YD h WITNESS WITN~2ss %o n 0NEp&< Q .A EX H15U. -9 4__ _ d %v.-m
~~,-.-..ev e~~
.-..ywy. w-w 1 i-i-e + .-v.- -r, ..'v-- 6+-e yv e, r er e c reryy
7 51 .a.u v .a.a 2 .u 'l a 2.i. _ _e g t \\TI ONgS r/ q r, --( ,..v._J.a s O, .1. s s .a _ =_ c ., s.... _ =_ = =_.u.. =. i =_.:.. < A ...__.,=_.v=_...=. w, : =_ v.,.. n l,... e c,. - =. =.,. =._ __ c. i. _ . _, 4 w: :.,. :.s... .s o r . v - c,, / _.:,;,,. _ _ s 1..: 0 .s.._: :. -, s.,. . :X*. v e, r , s.., i s,.s :4.
~~c. 4 _.~~
~~<.4~~
~~4 c V C~~
~~-. : :. :. O_ '_ - ..s - ..., s. v : :l: :: O.i: a c O. r _4 ...u 4 4 ., =_.. ' v. e r _.,. u -. i ;i / =_ v. =.;.:.. : : _ '. - /. / i~~
u
~~-:, - - =_ 6 : : y - '.: i.a;.~~
~~v,=_~~
~~t,-_..?.! t s. .o.. Q-E: _ I _r 21. x _s:_ d.s a _____ L 2 !_ m c r_ e.1 _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ __~~
of
~~~7 2 6 ~2~~
~~Ess:~~
~~__8__. ____L7___.____-___________-___._________ s ;l.~.; '. _ _ 1_ _ _ _2_A_ _ _ _ _ a! _ __O__ _ _ _ _O_ '_ Q ..__.s. hl~~
~~. i u l-~~
~~. ::1., a._S q qrA _.:= c= v;.-...Li.= i _. A sg = = -- =- - -6 1 ; =_.:. '.. =_ =_' ; ;1 =.~~
~~u s':~~
~~= _=_ i< v.~~
_ -

y : _
~~, _.y4 : _ c_,,.,., i s..,, : :... 3.i i : g..:. : t 6, e, - - _e : i ._..e i .4 ,s 1, , _... N. -. _ _ _.X.,. :.~~
~~e (,~~
'N =. ;.. y. Li: I !. i I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL HILES OF THE CCMANCHE PEAX STE AM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. \\7 0 / SIGNATURE: /\\ -4MMMM./) \\ TL980 s 3 j /K2 dL maow . ae WITNESS WITNES7 g t \\TI ONg &, g Q A l CXHiB6
sr -. ...:. n t,.: - m m e -..: n.v: n..u u.: P Ta YO'm. F SwaF i"ta uA ' '.;a A i p, r, x- ,, c i j s l t 1 \\ 1 11 i u t. .m -. =_ c..... _ =_ = =_.., .=_.... .... :. - - _ =_.... : -. ; =-.=. . =. _ _, _ ::. =_ _.: = c., g1 i T l oN ~ - _ : s.. : _ :. =_., n_ C ....... :. Q ..s..:- c-s.. .-.. s. e - s. -. _ a.. .. _ c,. : :. ,.7,.. 2, ..-s......f : : _: -- :,=_ A i__: ..:_.:.. <..w:: : .y_ -. :: C' s. =. _ _. hy n..). -- --- --- M A.C. _R 0... - - -..... - - - -- - -- 8c ]-- _ _L'y../ y_ - - . D. = = = =. r =ns. _ _6f_f_ ____-_ _ R.M------ M------ E * ; E # U s, - ,j' ~ [, ~i ~ ~~~ -T I 4. =. ....~r f.~~.~~ / : 1.s.i :-_..-__.:- s ~~ _., _.,,:_~s.. t: :~; C a r-
u:
~~i... 1.,, c. : -~~
,-::s,:-

s : :
~~i . 4 i s, m - -. ~.., - .s. 3.. E :. 'i ! ~. ' s.~~
~~i.*". ~. f.~~
~. s ". i I LIVI WITHIN 50 GIOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSI, TEXAS. I REALI2E THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: N MA'~'2 ' (./ / Whohuybe-b' [ g V. ] n WITNESS f_ WITNESS g1\\T10Ng 9 e. A N'HIBiT
' d. ! '"'*!!? 4 TM2 ?? ACT:TI
~~i* " 1J Y,'If 117.-~~
~~V7:LL YO 1P'. 3ASE M AKE A r, T .) r-) u 4$ \\T I ON$g@, I .i .._;. s.~~
.a i

-Q.

;u/ :.:. v : :. :
~~i-... u.....- m-- . i <..:..v .v : :. :... : e.: 4~~
~~ic s...~~
~~,:A., s< c e c v.~~
x. :.

.s.
~~e. =_ =.:.~~
~~x. -::~~
~~i .w .,. ~.- ( e : - :.:= - =,... i.. _ =_ = =_. : E .u.. : em.t..-. .. < :_ s. =_.;..:... :_ :.:. ...c H \\1 i-u :_ ?. <. = t.v. e. :: :, o,, u,. i ,ai... i u. i -.= = : : : : e, s. <c/,.~~
~~- : : :. :..r. r,.v - : :~~
,: Ea./Alia.--../.a.c c.s-lC.<------------_ _---_----- -- .= .a.lL. Y6 $'---- .IEXA:: 6.ctJ. c.rE----- 9.E--_ -- ---- _ _ E :.7.4.cf 3-000 ow =...r. - -i u.:.. .., u,,, s. ~ j p_ Z,,L. [jf _ . -.1'.' -.; $.i O ' _ - _ e. F :.< :.: [$. v (,",O.. ;..\\, * ' : ^- .".N.. :.: :* 0 ; 0 * .e - -,,. - -. :,. = = - a. : =..=. : :.v. s. .. l v... ; '1:, A l 1 :..s..t.: a :
~~C,,st i~~
..w i ,w ..i . s - e i -. - -. 6.- : s, ~.N L i i ll. :N C L.. :.(. c. 3.. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GECGRAPHICAL MILES 07 THE COMANCHE PEAX STEAM ' ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED'AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT-ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEEZINABOVE WILL SU3 JECT ME TO' PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE: 2 A b~) w - 0R0 d/' >Q ** W f WITNEQ V ' ~ ~ WITNESS q,1 \\TI ONp g&, A M H-lBIT-
?I
*! * '. 2 I ?
~~Til 2 ? ? A C'? ! O ?! 7 * *t" ? ? ?~~
~~i. M -~~
~~vrr'.J.i.a 'O W F.a :A S E Mis.:.A "t% w ^ bt 1 .u x a gT O.l ONeg@, ,g- { q gn-, r/ 9 ~ ~ w -( : 1 s _ _).a e~~
~~.i A~~
~~.ii::. :... :, s., :.. ' e, ._ _. _,1 - ..i , :. =~~
.t.; <s-,. ' -

: -

s
~~...s. ._ _ -.. _q Y H 1 B il _.i .,._c_,_ .s ,. _ _ s....~~
~~f. s. y n_~~
~~, 3, , _ _ s s...v : _: : : :. : ; a, c,,. :../~~
_.
~~= = =. : :, -- s. /it',00: ', _; -~~
~~v. r.i..:. _. : 2 1., _. /~~
~~_: e 4 '. :. i '.;.~~
v:
..,t.. '. ~; _,/f/) )u l /_ ) ___, _C___./ )_d2____ _Q A _C. 5- ___ _ ___ ___ O.X _ a__ .t., ::. _ _ p.5_e_._ _ __ _ __d_ __________c.-:-. _ I_4_ 6_f_e$ L .4 _ _ '... _$?/ _] / \\C-- .~. _...,..._.se.___.,.,i._._._.. ( _ _ v, _ .,..- i. __\\.4_ ...,___._.l-____._.- ,___s.,.____ , a.,. s. . N. _i.-.. i..- iw e__-.,.- .N ..._ w:. 4 ;.10 L '. : s. 0. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE CCHANCHE PE AX STE AM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SU3 JECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY. SIGNATURE e /N4f - d-- M a D 0A ~ W }) W A ~ .1#fTN ES S WITNESS g1\\TIONg A ONYHiBi\\
~ N3!UYOL 5555MAKII~^~ ~ U 7 C' L\\ T (u' T' ")9.T IT I oge, g ......a.. 2.t _ L, 1ES! I AM A O!TIZEN WHO LIVSS NEAR THE COMANCHE FEAK STEAM S-SLECTRIC STAT;CN, IN GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I AM CONCE:NED ABOUT THE CONSTRUC~".ON, WORKING CC+N01TlONS, AND OVE. DF THIS PLANT. NOT ONLY FOR THE 'SOPLE WORKING THE:.E, EU POR THE ClT!ZENS, LIKE MYSSLF, WHO LlVE NEA:.THE FACILITY. .1 WANT O SEE -""E RECORD ON TH!S MATTE:. REOPENED NOW! l NAME: ___51g/.O_L____G_m___- _at.c_-S_ _ _ ___ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _____ P 3 ____m a_t e z N/A____________________________ i ADDRESS: Cm, TEXAS: _h__d__e__v____hp_f_e. 7 __7_6__O V.._3____Zl:: 7dQ_7_J = TELEPHONE: _b_3]_7;_.8_f_~' 2f_!_&____ l SUPPORT ALL THAT -THE DISPOS AELE WORKERS OF COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELEOTRlC STATION IS DOlNG IN THElR ATTEMFTS TO GET THis REOO:.D REOPENED FOR THE WO:KERS AND CITlIENS OF TEXAS. I LIVE WITHIN 50 GEOGRAPHICAL MILES OF THE COMANCHE PEAK' STEAM ELECTRIC STATION LOCATED AT GLEN ROSE, TEXAS. I REALIZE THAT ANY MISREPRESENTATION OR FALSE STATEMENT IN THE DOCUMENT HEREINABOVE WILL SUBJECT ME TO PENALTIES FOR PERJURY.- i SIGNATURE: ,a Wr ill e, r GAN '$. M aett) ~ MITNf83 ~ WITNESS _ d ? t g t \\TI ONg p 9 e. -A
~~%HIg\\T l~~
- ~ ~ ~ - - - _ - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ S. 4 ATTAClu!ENT 4 1\\TlONgg 4 Q e, APPENDIX _ g U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY C0m:5510N REGION IV p hRC Inspection Report: 50-445/91-32 Unit 1 Operating Licenses NPF-87 50-446/91-32 Unit 2 Construction Pennit: Crfk-127 Expiration Date: August 1, 1992 Dockets: 50 445 50 446 Licensee: TV Electric g Skyway Tower v 400 North Olive Street Lock Box B1 La11as, Tt:xas 75201 Coranche peak Steam Electric Station Units 1 and 2 Facility Nar+: Irspection At: Glen Rose. Texas Inspe:tien Lenducted: July 3 through August 13, 1991 W. D. Johnsen, Senior Resident inspector Inspectors: L. N. Graves, Resident inspector _8 OE"4I b 'v Inte Rede ed by: L. v. Q)emcerietn, L,ntet, droject section b Division of Reactor Frojects r1:e: tion Surrary 13, 1991 (Report 50-445/91-321 Inscec*.ier Conducted July 3 throuch Aueust Unannounced resident safety inspection of plant status, foiic%p on pre'viously identified iterrs, fo11cwp on Three Mile Island-(TMI) Areas ir.seetted: action iter.s, operational safety verification, onsite followup of events, r.aintenance observation, and surveillance observation. Within the scope of this inspection no violations or deviations were The The plant labeling program was being irnplerented effectively. Results_: Equipment and ~icerm f ie d, last three c;en THI Action Items for Unit I were closed. the partial personnel responses following the initiation of the reactor trip, Maintenance icss of of f site power, and the seconcary transient were proper. end surveillance activities observed were properly perf personnel. g1\\ ONeg 9 e. B -91QBD700E3 9 5002D PDs -ADDen 05000445 a"L w4_
,p 'J./. g\\TIONeg& v. 4 2 B 4 bkHlBIT kraknesses were noted in the following areas The inspectors ider,tified several a11nor discrvpancies, such'as valve packing leaks and a flange leak, which did not have work requests initiates (no work request tags attached). There was operator miscomunication leading to operation of the wrong component in the turbine building in response to a beater drain tank high -level condition. The 11cer.see's response to a finding of water in the instru.Mnt air system was slow and initially ineffective. 1rtsteetion Condu_cted July 3 throuch Aueust 13,1991 (Report 50 446/92 32) Aren !nspected: No inspection activities were conducted on Unit 2. pest;1ts : Not applicable. 4 6 g \\TIONe9 Q B 2%HIB\\1 \\ l
I j NITACHMENT 6 g1\\TIONg9 APPENDIX k g U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION C REGION IV NRc Inspection Report: 50 445/91-70 Unit 1 Operating Lice e 50 446/91-70 Unit 2 Construction Perttitt CPPR 127 Expiration Date: August 1, 1992 Licensee: TV Clectric Skyway To er 400 North Olive Street ~ Lock Box 81 Dallas, Texas 75201 Facility hare: Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2 Ins;ection At: Glen Rose, Texas Inspection Conducted: Decen,ber 20, 1991, through February 1,1992 W. D. Johnson, Senior Resident inspector Inspectors: G. E. Werner, Resident Inspector J.1. Tapia, Senior Resident Inspector C. E. Johnson, Project Engineer ClujLEN. % \\2. h '2. Revie<ed by: UIe L. A. Yancell, Chief, Frgject Section 5 Division of Reactor Projects Inscection sumary Inscettien conducted December 20, 1991, throuch February 1,_1992 TieTo7ft Tb.445 / 91-70)_ Unantiounced resident safety inspection of plant status, Areas Ins;ected: operational safety verification, onsite follosup of events, rain previously identified items. One inspection followup No violations or deviations were identified. Results: item and one special report were reviewed and closed. Strengths were noted in the following areas: Comunication during perfomance of surveillance and maintenance activities. Label upgrade program, and (Tl Q k g The equiptent clearance program. C -QNN7 &#H B\\T
en
g \\TIONg 2 C XNl8b l Weaknesses wert noted in the following areas: t Control of equientnt within safe zones; Secondary plant performance housekeeping, and minor steam leaks; and-Control room operators' knowledge of cain turbine generator auxiliary systems and associated trip setpoints. Insee': tion conducted December 20,1991. through February 1.1992 (Fepor; K.G5/sl.70] Areas Inste:ted: Pio inspection activities were conduc(ed on Unit 2. Results_: fiot applicable. i i i + L .L g\\TIONeg e n C ENHIB6: 1...._....-. __3..... ~. m.
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIg i he LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST g 92/03/22 - 92/03/28 D - 1 PACE 270 t'ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Prod @ts,g9;96"rvices and DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, Ut4IT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9203250207 Responds to NRC 920218 lte re notice of violation frem Insp Rept 50-445/91-62 & forwards civil penalty in amount of $25,000. Corrective actions:RER crosstie valves opened & surveillance data base reviewed te proper valve lineup. CARILIo W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/19. LIEBERMAN,J. Ofc of Enforcement (Post 870413). 14pp. 48X:61099:068-61099:081. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9203240159 Forwards interim Part 21 re defect in check valve P/N 72543 (swing arm) on Borg-Warner Model 75510 swing check valve. GODWIN,G.C. BW/IP International, Inc. (formerly Byron Jackson Pump Division). 92/03/16. Dccument Control Branch (Document Control Desk). Ip, 48X:61161:005-61161:006. --9203240165 Interim Part 21 Rept P21R-92-001 re defect in check valve P/N 72543 (swing arm) on Borg-Warner Model 75510 3-inch,900 lb swing check valve. Defect reported by util to vendor on 920ll6. Evaluation will be completed by 920616. BW/IP International, Inc. (formerly Byron Jackson Pump Division). 92/03/16. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 1p. 48X:61161:006-61161:006. N 9203240213 LER 92-005-00:on 920218, operator misinterpreted procedure step & inadvertently unblocked actuation signal causing ESF actuation. Caused by personnel error. Event reviewed. Personnel trained.W/920319 ltr. BUSCHBAUM,D'.E., CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/19. 8pp. 48X:61120:219-61120:226. b p D-1 EXH \\S6 \\ l Y
t UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY. COMMISSIONT\\TIONg LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST 92/01/19 - 92/01/25 k PAG M90 - ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, nl ervices t ((b!.bb~f .bb b-b.!5b _ bbb!!f.b5I!b$ '._ b!. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9201240158 Part 21 Rept P21R-92-002 re bolting -mati connecting bcnnet to yoke on Copes vulcan valves supplied to util by Westinghouse w/ lower yield strength than grade specified.- Next rept will be submitted by 920213. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/16. NRC - No-Detailed Affiliation Given. Ip. 48X:60375:098-60375:098. V. Operator Examina*ior.s 9201210199 Advises that NL Terrel (Senior. Operator License SOP-43104-2) no longer performing licensed duties. Operator license 4 discontinued. CAHILL,W.J., WOODLAN,D.R. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/13. Document Control-Branch (Document Control Desk). 1p. 48X:60341 005-60341:005. B a ? q e D-1 ((XH \\$$ .+,,, _ _ _.... _ - _, m._. _m ..j,
j'{ l g(f ) UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS, LPDR DEEKLY ACCESSZON LIGT 4 92/02/02 - 92/02/08 PAGE SOS- ), ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services ~.h# ' R h J DOCKET 50-445 CCHANCHE PEAK STLM4 ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9202040218 Forwards summary of 920117 enforcement conference conducted on 920117 re safety sys misalignments discovered upon entry into Mode 3 in Dec 1991. List of attendees also encl. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/01/28. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utiliti'es Electric Co. (TU Electric). 23pp. 48X 60449:005-60449:027 R. Periodic operating reports & related correspondence 9202040292 Forwards Rev 7 to " Quarterly Plant Performance & Other Indicator Data" for fourth quarter of 1991 & " Gross Heat Rate Data Form" for 1991. CARILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/27. Institute of Nuclear Power Operations. 23pp. 48X:60483:204-60483:2 26. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9202040320 Initial Part 21 Rept P21-92-001:en 920109, discovered that swing arm on Borg Warner Model 75510 not completely interchangeable w/ original part.Part also had dif ferent geometrical configuration.Next rept by 920213. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/14. NRC - No Detailed Affiliation.piven. 1p. 48X:60521:331-60521:331. 9202040083 Supplemental Deficiency Rept CP-85-034 re adequacy of conduit supports to perform design functions. Initially reported on 850930. Unit i bolt hole spacing talerances conservative.Reinsp of Unit 2 clamps unnecessary. CAHILL,W.J., WALKER,R.D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/27. Document Cont:ol Branch (Document Control Desk). 3pp. 48X 60543 008-60543:010. c m o%en. <2 () - 1 w ' Jflil E3 i'i l l
dCbT 0/Ve UNITED STATES CCLEAR REGULATORY COMM LPDR WIEKLY ACCESSION LIST q 92/04/12 - 92/04/18 O - j PAGE 331 .LE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regula ed Nuclear Facilities, Products, a.d Services gXH \\B6 DOCKET 50-445 COMANCEI PEAX S!!A.M ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 .......................... - -.... - -............... - -... - ~. Q. Inspection reports, II Bulletins & correspondence 9204140013 Forwards insp repes 50-445/92-07 & 50-446/92-07 on 920202-0314.Ho violations or deviations identified. Weaknesses noted in self-verification area by both maint & operations personnel f ailing to use proper techniques. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Pos: 820201). 92/04/07. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X s 61308 :15 2-61308 :17 5. --9204140017 Insp repts 50-445/92-07 & 50-446/92-07 on 9 20202-0 314.No violations or deviations identified. Major areas inspected: NRC bulletin folicwup,LER followup, operations safety verification,maint observa: ion & safety sys vertication. YANDELL,L.A. Region 4 (Pest 820201). 92/04/01. 20pp. 48X:61308:156-61308:175. 9204170192 Clarifies 920326 response to violations noted in Insp Rept 50-445/92-04. Corrective actions:util will perform. inservice insp program audit w/ emphasis on procedural implementation of inservice insp contractor. CAHILL,W.J., WALKER, R. D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Ele :ric). 92/04/16. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). lp. S. Reportable occurrences, LOs & related correspondence 9204150127 LER 92-006-00:en 920311, discovered that two surveilla::ce work orders failed to include calibr instructions for P-9 interlock, channels N41 & N43. Caused by personnel error. Event reviewed by all maint personnel.W/920410 ltr. BUSCHBAUM,0.E., CARILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TC Electric). '92/04/10, 7pp. 48X: 61376:122-61376:128. (& Q D-1 E#HIB6 1
UN2TED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSg }} g(p LPDR WEEKLY ACCESS 80N LIST 92/01/05 - 92/01/11 D PAG 334 'ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services
~~H iBi,\\~~
DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9201060027 Forwards fuel integrity & reactor subcritically (FIRS) insp repts 50-445/91-57 & 50-446/91-57 on 911028-1101 & 1118-22. No violations or deviations noted. Confirmation re specific vital-to-vital area barrier requested. BEACH,K.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 91/12/27. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 3pp. 48X:60172:028-60172:057. --9201060029 Insp repts 50-445/91-57 & 50-446/91-57 on 911028-1101 & 1118-22.No violations noted. Major areas inspected: regional initiative, licensee in-core fuel loading / fuel storage configurations & core component performance. GAGLIARDO,J.E. Region 4 (Post 820201). 91/12/17. 27pp. 48X:60172:031-60172:057. 9201080014 Forwards insp rept 50-445/91-62 & 50-446/91-62 on 911030-1219. Violations noted & being considered for escalated enforcement action. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/01/03. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 5pp. 48X : 60 215 : 049-60 215 : 07 2. --9201080015 Insp repts 50-445/91-62 & 50-446/91-62 on 911030-1219. Violations noted. Major areas inspected: plant status, operational safety verification,onsite followup of events, maint observation & surveillance observation. YANDELL,L.A. Region 4 (Pest 820201). 91/12/27. 19pp. 48X:60215:054-60215,:072. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9201090026 LER 90-037-01:on 901105,undervoltage relay actuation occurred due to personnel error. Memo issued to electrical-maint personnel discussing event.W/920102 ltr. BUSCHBAUM, D.E., CAHILL,W.J., GULDEMOND,W.G. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 91/12/30. 8pp. c W10Nyg qv . e, cm t?gy 3; ; ~
Y UN8TED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION. LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST \\V ONE l 335 92/01/05 - 92/01/11 ILE LEVE S - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities,kroduct JjdServices-q f DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 ....................................................... g.g 9 ; g 6 S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence. l ~ t 9201080263 LER 91-030-00 on 911204, discovered two mispositioned RHR crosstie valves in ECCS. Caused by failure to position valves following filling of portien of RER sys. Valves opened & survei'11ance test performed.W/920103 ltr. = BUSCHBAUM, D.E., CAHILL,W.J., GULDEMOND,W.G. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/03. 7pp. 48X:60282:280-602821286. l 9201090018 LER 91-029-00:en 911204,handswitch positions. for stea::t suppl,; valves left in pull-to-lock after entering Mode 3, defeating automatic function of valves,per TS 3.0.4. Caused. by personnel error. Personnel counselled.W/920103-ltr. BUSCHBAUM, D.E., CAHILL,W.J., GULDEMOND,W.G. Texas Utilities.E* ectric - Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/03. 8pp. 9201090031 LER 91-031-00:on 911206, containment ventilation isola-ion automatically _ occurred due to overconservative radiation - - - monitor setpoint. Alarm setpoint recalculated & p/920103'ltr. rocedure for radioactive effluent releases will be reviewed.W BUSCHBAUM, D.E., CAHILL,W.J., GULDEMOND,W.G. - Texas Utilities Electric. Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/05. _7pp. r. D-i ~ f;_ _ = _ _. +2 w.,- _s.,,w.
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COM qW l O LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION L2STe> e 92/03/29 - 92/04/04 {}. ] PAGE 337 .LE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services EX H lB D-DOCKET 50-445 COKANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9204030002 Ack teceipt of 9 20319 lt r & check for $25,000 in payment for civil penalty proposed by NRC in 920218 ltr. BAKER,E.T. Ofc of Enforcement (Post 870413). 92/04/01. CA3I1L, W. J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TV Electric). 1p. 4 8X 6 L208 : 002-6120 8 : 002. S. Reportable occittrences, LERs & related correspondence 9203300199 Part 21 rept re potential f ailure of Elmwood/Fasco Definite purpose contactors mfg by Fasco Industries. Initially reported by util on 911010. Vendor advised to replace all affected contactors. Replacements available by Apr 1992. PATTERSON,L. Nutherm International, Inc, 92/03/26. Ofc of Enforcement (Post 870413). 14pp. 48X 61209:198-61209:211.
"'. Operator Examinations 9203300126 Forwstds response to NRC 920210 request for licensed operator matis to support June 1992 exam dates. Documents consist of index of exam ref matis, delivered to Region IV ofc on 920320.
CAHILL,W.J., MARSEALL,J.S. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/23. PELLET,J. Region 4 (Post 820201). 63pp. 48X 61198:211-61198:273. H E)-1 DHlBN
hs\\TlONE UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY CO ION LPDR WEEKLY ACCESS 20N LIST 92/01/26 - 92/02/01 PAGE 350
~~LE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Prodp a~~
ervices DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence --9201290210 Rev 0 to " Augmented Inservice Insp Plan, Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station." Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 90/10/12. 43pp. 48X:6,0449:240-60449:284. 9201310015 Forwards partially withheld insp repts 50-445/91-68 & 50-446/91-68 on 911209-12 (ref 10CFR73.21).Noncited violation noted. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/01/24. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 6pp. 48X 60413:124-60413:131. --9201310018 Partially withheld insp repts 50-445/91-68 & 50-446/91-68 on 911209-12 (ref 10CFR73.21).Noncited violation noted. Major areas inspected: licensee physical security program. MURRAY,B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/01/21. 2pp. 48X:60413:130-60413:131. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9201290094 LER 91-030-01 on 911204, Unit 1 entered Mode 3 w/two mispositioned valves in emergency core cooling sys. Caused by personnel error. Review of surveillance database was performed to identify potential for similar problems. BUSCHBAUM,D.E., CAHIDL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/24. 9pp. 48X:60414:074-60414:082. 9201290101 LER 91-032-00:en 911206, incomplete calibr of four channels & nonconserati've indication of reactor power noted. Caused by error in wording of work order instructions. Steps have been revise ~d in surveillance database.W/920124 ltr. BUSCHBAUM,D.E., CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/24. 8pp. 48X:60414:089-60414:096. g \\TIONg 9 e. D-1 ENHiBD
l UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM3SS ((/p l LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION L3ST 92/02/09 - 92/02/15 Ik PAG 351 D Services 'ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, ant UNIT 1#HIBd DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9202130026 Forwards insp repts 50-445/92-01 6 50-446/92-01 on 920106-09.No violations or deviations identified. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/07. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 3pp. 48X:60546:250-60546:269. --9202130027 Insp repts 50-445/92-01 & 50-446/92-01 on 920106-09.No violations or deviations identified. Major areas inspected: implementation of OA & QC programs for ongoing design activities for Unit-2. Unit i not inspected. BARNES,I. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/01/28. 17pp. 48X:60546:253-60546:269. 9202140179 Forwards insp repts 50-445/92-06 & 50-446/92-06 on 920127-30.No violations or deviations noted. BEACH,A.B. Region 1 (Post 820201). 92/02/10. C AHI LL, W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). Spp. 4 8X : 60 57 2 : 075-6 0 572 : 084. --9202140183 Insp repts 50-445/92-06 & 50-446/92-06 on 920127-30.No violations noted. Major areas inspected routine, unannounced insp of instrument component & sys procedure reviews, work observations & record reviews. WESTERMAN,T.F. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/07. 5pp. 48X 60572:080-60572:084. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9202120170 LER 90-024-01:en 900824, discovered that testing activities were not being performed on Staggered Test Basis,per TS. Caused by p'ersonnel error. Review of surveillance activities w/ Staggered Test Basis requirement performed.W/920207 ltr. BUSCHBACM,D.E., CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/07. 8pp. ,g\\t 0 Wryp, <1 F3 4 i EX H \\Sb l ~
1 UNITED STATES NUCLEAR. REGULATORY COMMISSION-: a n LPDR WEEKLY: ACCESSION? LIST i 92/02/09:L-92/02/15 .352i ~ '.ILE LEVELS -: DOCKET) RegulatedL Nuclear Facilities, roduc , 41d Servicesi -l 11 - DOCKET 50-44 5 COMANCHE --PEAK - S*'EAM ELECTRIC STATION,- UN S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence ' 9202120181 LER 92-001-00:on 920108, reactor. tripped -due_ to hi'gh: ptimary water temp. Caused by personnel error _while taking manual ' T i control of generator primary water sys. Intensive-training conducted for crew involved.W/920207 ltr. BUSCHBAUM,D.E., CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/07. lipp. V. Operator Examinations 9202140167 Informs thatL administration of licensing. exams scheduled for wks of 920622 & 29.Ref matl requirements for1RO/SRO licensing exams requested by 920323 to meet above schedules. BEACH,A.B. Region 4.(Pos t 820201). 92/02/10. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 12pp -48X:60572:018-60572:029-I Q\\TlOly.$c. q D9 s I Q **' t 4ri;b(t?..1-m
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISS20N LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST 92/03/01-92/03/07/T01ONe/h PAaE 366 nXk w ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Faciliths, Products, and$kervices {),, DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 m relatedcorrespondendfdlE)k.eI R. Periodic operating reports & --9203030157 " Semiannual Radicactive Effluent Release Rept for Jul through Dec 1991." FLOYD,E.T., KAY,D.C., PRINCE,R.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 91/12/31. 42pp. 48X:60828:194-60828:236. --9203030159 Rev 7 to "ODCM." Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 91/12/31. 175pp. 48X:60828:237-60829:093. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9203020184 Interim Deficiency Rept CP-86-41 re effect of small break LOCA during Mode 4 operation. Initially reported on 860528. Util reviewing Westinghouse topical rept to determine plant-specific actions. Update will be submitted by 920828. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/27. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 2pp. 48X:60783:137-60783:138. 9203030180 Part 21 rept re swing arms for Borg Warner check valves. Initially reported on 920ll4. Lack of 2 iterchangeability led to reinstallation of old swing arm (number 72543) & backflow test on valve (model 75510). CAHILL,W.J. Texas 0,t,ilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/28. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 6pp. 48X:60802:089-60802:094. V. Operator Examinations 9203030056 Advises that DV Workman (Operator License OP-42387-0) will no longer be performing licensed duties & license should be discontinued. CAHILL,W.J., WOODLAN,D.R. Texas Utilities Electric,.Coe(*Uggdait Electric). 02/02/21. Document Control Branch dQdmbd C Desk). 1p. 4CX:60800:358-60800:358. ( D-1 ~ CA'Hisli 1
9( \\ l i b/ J V R / UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY CO ISSIO!(!_) " l LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST 92/02/16 - 92/02/22 PAGE 373 b, Services ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Pro DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 O. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence --9202200033 Insp repts 50-445/92-05 & 50-446/92-05 on 920127-30.No violations or deviatione noted. Major areas inspected:insp of pr.ocurement, receiving & storage. BARNES,I. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/12. 6pp. 48X:60610:073-60610:070. 9202190216 Final Deficiency Rept SDAR-CP-91-010 re transf er of matis from util investment recovery warehouse into controlled warehouse. Initially reported on 911230. Corrective actions implemented per Insp Repts 50-445/91-66 & 50-446/91-66. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/14. Document Control Branch (Decument Control Desk). 1p. 48X:60679:360-60679:360. R. Periodic operating reports & related correspondence 9202180267 Monthly operating rept for Jan 1992 for Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Unit 1.W/920214 ltr. THATCHER,G., CAHILL,W.J., WALKER,R.D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/31. 5pp. 48X:60626:053-60626:057. 9202190206 Forwards fitness-for-duty performance data for Jul-Dec 1991 & summary of mgt actions. CAHILL,W.J., MARSEALkgJ.S. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/10. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 5pp. 48X:60679:350-60679:354. S. Repor table ' occur rences, LERs & related correspondence 9202190055 Special rept 1-SR-90-002-01:on 900221,RCS transient resulted in automatic actuation of PORV. Caused by insufficient letdown C',ow. Repetitive step of dif fering plant responses expected el1 1nated. 9 /13. g {ph. { p{f'gpOf)@ CAHILL,W.J. ' Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electrke Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). y 48X: 60678:358-60678:360. 'J - 1 e +
g4\\ 0Nekg UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMI LPDR UIEKLY ACCESSION LIST l k PAGE 374 92/02/16 - 92/02/22 ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK S2EAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9202190070 Part 21 rept te yoke to bonnet bolting matl in Copes Vulcan valves. Deficiency not reportable per 10CFR21. CALHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/13. 3 Document Control Branch (2ccument Control Desk). ~ pp. ^ * - 48X:60662:346-60662:348. 9202190146 LER 92-002-00:en 920115, discovered that surveillance requirement for area temp menitoring not performed in TS required interval of once per 12 h. caused by personnel error. Control over assignment improved.W/920214 ltr. BUSCHBAUM,D.E., CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TC Electric). 92/02/14, 7pp. 4BX:60680:283-60680:289. h q %.g \\ B O W% n.. :
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST g} { Q 92/03/08 - 92/03/14 (Q P(yg 381 FILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Producb),'$nd Services f ! b Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9202110056 Suppl 1 to NRC Info Notice 92-002, "RELAP5/ MOD 3 Computer Code Error Associated W/ Conservation of Energy Equation." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411), 92/02/18. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:60871:182-60871:185. 9202190038 NRC Info Notice 92-015, " Failure of Primary Sys Compression Fitting." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/02/24. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:60962:181-60962:184. 9202190371 NRC Info Notice 92-017, "NRC Insps of Programs Being Developed at Nuclear Pcwer Plants in Response to Generic Ltr 39-10." AOSSI,C.E. Division of Ope:ational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/02/26. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 11pp. 48X:60392:001-60392:011, 9203110181 Provides response to NRC 920210 ltr re violations noted in Insp Repts 50-445/91-67 & 50-44 5/91-67 on 911209-13 & 920106-09. Corrective actions: manager of startup placed administrative hold on approved preoperational test. CAHILL,W.J., WALKER,R.D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/09. Documea,t Cont:ol Branch (Document Control Desk). 4pp. 48X:60897:037-60897: 040. S. Repor table occur rences, LERs & related correspondence _____________7__________________________________________ 9203090031 LER 92-003-00:on 920203,OA surveillance identified invalid boron dilution event analyses. Caused by inadequate inputs & methodology by vendor. Design basis of boron dilution sys to be revised & deficiencies addressed.W/920304 ltr. BUSCHBAUM,D.E., CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/04. 7pp. 48X:60871:218-60871:224. g \\T 10Ng 9 G [)-1 dI ' file 31"i A
_.m -UNITED STATES NUCLEAR = REGULATORY COMMISSION: q - LPDR -- WEEKLY-: ACCESSION -LIST i h ~\\ T 1 0 N fG S : 382L 92/03/08 .92/03/14.Q s, iTILE LEVELS ~; DOCKET,-Regulated Nuclear Facilities,' Prod t p and' Services- -1 1 ' DOCKET'50-445 COMANCHE-PEAK STIAM ELECTRIC STATION,'. g j g[.- & relctedi. correspondence-S."_ Reportable occurrences, LERs1 9203130262 LIR 92-004-00 on 920206, discovered.that-920130 surveillance-of Class 1E; battery performed w/ battery in EQUALIZE-rather than FLOAT. Caused by personnel error. Personnel' involved was counseled. Battery declared operable.W/920309 ltr. BUSCHBAUM,0.E., CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU-Electric). 92/03/09. 6pp. 48X:60948:328-60948:333. -V. Operator. Examinations 9203110086-Informs of 920324 regional meeting to discuss + _requalification exams. ECOLLINS,S.J. Region '4 - (Post 820201). 92/02/28.. CAHILL,W.J.. Texas-y Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 3pp.- 48X:60849:159-60849:161. ? g-T ? .}- vi3T4 OA/,&. F M'g O-; .Qg;gp;; =
y UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY QTkyb -LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION L Q_ .y fAGE L420i
~~92/04/05=- 92/04/11'~~
~~,3, 4~~
~~.s s~~
~~i FILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, -and Services g,~~
~~10) ! $ l,\\~~
.. DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION,-UNIT'1 -Q. Inspection reports-IE Bulletins & correspondence 9203270028-NRC Info Notice 92-026, " Pressure Locking of Motor-Operated Flexible Wedge Gate Valve." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411).! 92/04/02. _ Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, ^Inc.- 6pp. 48X:61269:029-61269:034. 9204100031 Forwards SALP Repts 50-445/92-99 & 50-446/92-99 for-910203 .920201 period. MARTIN,R.D. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/04/03. CAHILL,W.J.- Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Ilectric). 9pp. 48X : 6127 6 : 055-61276 : 09 6.. ---9204100041 SALP repts 50-445/92-99 & 50-446/92-99 for 910203 - 9202C1 period. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/04/03. 33pp. 48X:61276:064-61276:0 96. em 9204100043 Forwards insp repts 50-445/92-09 -& 50-446/92-09 on 920210-0319.No violation ncted. BIACH,A.B. Region 4-(Post.820201).- 92/04/03.- CAHILL,W.J. Texas-Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric)..3pp.; 48X:61276:108-61276:118. --9204100048 Insp repts-50-445/92-09 &z 50-446/92-09 on 920210-03'9.No violations noted. Major areas inspected: reactor-coolant-sys-hydrostatic. test,cp,nsisting of procedure-review &1 test titnessing. GAGLIARDO,J.E. Region 4 (Post 820201)~.: _92/04/03.-l8pp. 48X:61276:lli-61276:118. S fReportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence-9204100317 Supplemental deficiency rept CP-84-27;re designed f ailure' modes of certain primary _ plant ventilation sys. exhaust dampers & related: issues. Initially reported on-850306. Unit 1-' corrective ahtions completed; & Unit' 2 status listed.: 'i CAHILL,W.J.- Texas Utilities Electric Co.-(TU Electric)._.92/04/06. .DocumentsControl' Branch (Document Control Desk). -2pq f8X:61326:347-61326:348. D-i N hlb \\1 0 4
i UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION LPDR WIEKLM ACCESSION LIST {Q 92/02/23 - 92/02/29 (g (%DE 420 'ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Produc)d" and Services bb b _ _b b _ bb bb '.,_ b P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence 9202270117 Forwards marked-up first draf t version of plant combined TS, for review. Recommends that meeting be scheduled for wk of 920413,to discuss plant combined TS. FIELDS,M.B. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/02/19. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utiliti,es Electric Co. (TU Elect-ic). 2pp. 48X:60718:307-607'8:308. Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9201160195 NRC Info Notice 92-008, " Revised Protective Action Guidance for Nuclear Incidents." CUNNINGEAM,R.E. Division of Industrial & Medical Nuclear Saf ety (Post 870729). 92/01/23. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 7pp. 48X:60680:256-60680:262. '201310062 NRC Inf o Notice 92-011, " Soil & Water Contamination at Fuel Cycle Facilities." CUNNINGHAM,R.E. Division of Industrial & Medical Nuclear Safety (Post 870729). 92/02/05. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 4 8X : 60716 : 212-60716 : 215. 9202250341 EN-92-013:on 920214, notice of proposed imposition of civil penalty in amount of $25,000 issued to licensee. Action based on f ailure to properly align two RER crosstie valves prior to entering Mode 3 during startup on 911204. LUEEMAN,J., LIEBERMAN,J. Ofc of Enforcement (Post 870413). 92/02/11. lp. 48X: 60735 : 2S 2-60735 : 282. 9202240092-Forwards insp repts 50-445/92-03 & 50-446/92-03 on 920108-0201 & notice of violation. Excellent communications demonstrated between operations & startup personnel during conduct of dynamic motor-operated valve testing. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/14. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X:60655:139-60655:158. / \\Tl ONp D-1 e. h
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY CpW}W' /y/(f ) LPDRWEEKLYACCESSIONLqe]o \\l v 92/02/23 92/02fk9
~~PAGE 422 47 - 1~~
'ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Pf6dudts, and Services DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATIO ih O. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9202240087 Discusses insp rept 50-445/91-62 & 50-446/91-62 & forwards notice of violation & proposed imposition of civil penalty in amount of 525,000. MARTIN,R.D. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/18. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 6pp. 48X:60654:272-60654:281. --9202240089 Notice of violation & proposed imposition of civil penalty in amount of $25,000. Noncompliance noted: licensee placed unit in mode 3 & did not verify that control switches for RER train A & B crosstie valves in open position. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/18. 4pp. 48X:60654:278-60654:28 1. 9202250328 Discusses licensee 911220 response to NRC bulletin 82-009, " Thimble Tube Thinning," for plant. Staff concludes that actions taken by util for plant, fully respond to issues in bulletin. BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-1. 92/02/18. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU E3.ectric). 2pp. 48X:60690:315-60690:316. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9202250187 Supplemental Deficiency Rept CP-87-59 re improper application of const aids for cable tray fittings. Initially-reported on 870921.P'ittings replaced in Unit 1. Mod of fittings will be performed at Unit 2 prior to fuel load. WOODLAN,D.R. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/19. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 2pp. 4 8X : 60749 :17 3-60749 :174. gT10lveg 9 e
~~)-1 ENHIBM~~
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION LPOR NEKLY ACCESSION LTST 92/02/27 - 92/02/29 -PAGE 423 'ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilitie h uc s aN h, vices D-1 DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs -& relatedcorrespondp _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _k H 9202250330 LER 91-025-01:on 911029, component cooling water stop check valves inoperable due to less than adequate preventive maint. Caused by accumulation of corrosion products. Preventive maint procedure developed.W/920219 ltr.- BUSCHBAUM,D.E., CAHILL,W.~. Texas Utilities' Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/19. 8pp. 48X:60764:065-60764:072. d q\\t 0NE,9 R D ,i Exs s6
C gT'l0Neg UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISS a LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST 4 .g <t-91/12/29-- 92/01/04 g g LPAGE. 214-WE = LEVELS - DOCKET, - Regulated - Nuclear -Facilities, - Products, and Services DOCKET 50-445-COMANCHE = PEAK STEAM-ELECTRIC STATION,~ UNI? 1 P.' Operating license stage documents & correspondence ~ ~ 9112310223 Notification of 911224. meeting w/util in 'Rockville,M3 to discuss license amend submittals for facility.1 BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 91/12/24. BLACK, S. C.- Project Directorate IV-2. 3pp.. 48X:60163:316-60163:318. Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9201020277 Responds to NRC 911121. ltr re violations noted in Insp Rept 50-445/91-56 on 911028-1101. Corrective actions: review of preservice insp data continues _to be performed & exams performed in second direction on reactor vessel nuts. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). _91/' 2/18. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 4pp.. 48X:60182:185-60182:188. 3.12300035 Ack receipt of. 911122 response to 921010.ltr & notice of violation in insp reptc 50-445/91-41 & 50-446/91-41. _. BEACH,A.B. Region _4 (Post 820201).. 91/12/20..CAHILL,W.J. Texasi Utilities Electric Co.- (TU Electric). 4pp. _48X:60120:065-60120:073; _9112300062 Forwards: corrected-cover for _ insp repts. 50-445/91-54-& 50-446/91-54, changing date f rom 911224 to 911204._ _ BEACH,A.B. Region 4 ' (Post - 820201)..91/12/20..CAHILL,W.J. ~ Texas Utilities Electric Co. '(TU Electric). 'Spp. 48Xt60120:138-60120:143.; --9112300064 ~ Corrected cover ltr for11nsp ' repts ;50-445/91-54 > & 50-446/91-54 on 911015-18. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 91/12/04. _CAHILL,W.J. 1 Texas. Utilities' Electric Co. (TG Electric). lp. 48X: 60120 : 143-60120 :143 ' @\\0NEgg q D-2_ ExH\\s? 4
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY.COMM kbH h LPDR WEEKLY ACCESS 20N LIST g dd, 91/12/29 - 92/01/04 C)-2 PACE 215 sE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, ProCucts, and Services [)
{
DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9112300258 Suppls 891102 response to NRC Bulletin 89-008, " Thimble Tube Thinning in Westinghouse Reactors." Detected wear for thimble tube locations J-14 & L-10 below 20% (first action level for thimble tube wear). CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 91/12/20. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 3pp. 48X:60174:073-60174:075. 9201020126 Forwards corrected replacement first page of notice c* violation from insp repts 50-445/91-56 & 50-446/91-56. B EACH, A. B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 91/12/20. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 3pp. 48X : 60152 : 29 8-6 0152 : 301. --9201020130 Corrected page for notice of violation from insp repts 50-445/91-56 & 50-446/91-56. Region 4 (Post 820201). 91/12/20. lp. 48X : 6015 2 : 3 01-60152 : 301 9201020048 Notification of significant licensee meeting w/util on 920117 to discuss two examples of failure to meet TS requirements prior to entering hot standby operational mode. YANDELL,L.A. Region 4 (Post 820201). 91/12/26. Region 4 (?ost 820201). 3pp. 48X:60152:020-6nl52:022. h 9201020104 Forwards team insp repts 50-445/91-47 & 50-4 46/91-47 on 911118-21.No violations or deviations noted.NRC noted that licensee staf f participation in emergency exercise showed that licens,ee program & staff prepared to protect public. BEACH,A.B. ' Region 4 (Post 820201). 91/12/26. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 3pp. 48X: 60152 : 27 4-6 0152 : 288. g\\0NEg <t D-2 ExH \\s6
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM kht LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST 4 92/03/22 - 92/03/28 D-2 PAGE 269 .:ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and,S rvices gy 9;y DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence 9203240352 Requests authorization for use of Code Case N-496 to repair steam generator manway bolt hole threads in ASME Class 1,2 & 3 components. CAHILL',W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/19. Document Control Branch (Decument Control Desk). 2pp. 48X:61084:346-61084:347. 9203240387 Notification of 920323 meeting r/util in Rockville,MD to discuss proposal to delete requirements for boron dilution mitigation sys f rom Tech Spec for unit 1. BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/03/19. MURLEY,T., MIRAGLIA,F., RUSSELL,W. NRC - No Detailed Af filiation Given. 3pp. 48X:61068:220-61068:222. '203270148 Forwards draft version of plant combined tech specs for review. Meeting recommended for wk of 920413 to discuss combined tech specs.W/o encl. FIELDS,M.B. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/03/24. CAHILL,W.J.- Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 2pp. 48X:61121:ll3-61121:ll4.- Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9203250196 Ack receipt of 920309 ltr informing NRC of steps taken to correct violations noted in insp repts 50-445/91-67 & 50-446/91-67. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/03/19. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Co. Spp. 48X:61071:016-61071:025. --9203250202 Responds to NRC 920210 ltr re violations noted in insp repts 50-445/91-67 & 50-446/91-67 on 911209-13 & 920106-09. Corrective actions:startup mgt has initiated comprehensi've corrective action program. L WALKER,R.D. Texas Utilities Co. 92/03/09. Document Control-Branch (Doc}: ment Control Desk). 5pp. 48X:61071:021-61071:025. g\\T1ONQp e D-2 L EX HiW ~ l
bgSON\\T1ONg UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY'CO LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION L2ST ve '()
~~9 92/01/19 - 92/01/25 PAGE 289 Pro & bets. pp.d \\ ervices ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, S~~
% KFfl g5 \\ DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9112190286 NRC Info Notice 91-085, " Potential Failures of Thermostatic Control Valves for Diesel Generator Jacket Cooling Water." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 91/12/26. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 3pp. 48X:60356:060-60356:063. 9112300138 NRC Info Notice 92-004, " Potter & Brumfield Model MDR Rotary Relay Failures." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/01/06. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 10pp. 48X:60373:021-60373:031. 9201240099 Ack receipt of 911218 ltr informing NRC of steps taken to correct violations noted in insp repts 50-445/91-56 & 50-446/91-56. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201)..92/01/17. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X:60357:093-60357:100. R. Periodic operating reports & related correspondence 9201220114 Monthly operating rept for Dec 1991 for Comanche Peak Unit 1 Steam Electric Station.W/910115 ltr. THATCHER,G., CAHILL,W.J., WALKER,R.D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 91/12/31. 5pp. 48X:60359:ll6-60359:120. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9201210230 Part 21 Rept 159 re potential defect in power cylinder liner in diesel engine of DSR-48 & DSRV-16-4 Standby Diesel Generator Sys. Investigation continuing & expected to be complete on 920301. GUNTRUM,B.C. Cooper Energy Services. 92/01/15. Of fice of Nuclear Reactor Regglation, Director (Post 870411). 6pp. 48X:60339:341-60339:346. \\T\\ONE D-2 EX H lS\\ \\
UNITED STATES WUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMC$ L\\ r p# (g '# LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST 92/02/02 - 92/02/08 PAGE 304 /ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, RegulatedNuclearFacilities,Producq,s,jJ.{,(g4 an Services DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9201080305 NRC Info Notice 92-006, Reliability of ATWS Mitigation Sys & Other NRC Required Equipment not Controlled by Plant TS." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/01/15. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:60486:077-60486:080. 9202050235 Forwards configuration mgt insp repts 50-445/91-202 & 50-446/91-201 on 911118-1213. Deficiencies noted.NRC concerned w/ failure to verify or check adequacy of design. BOGER,B.A. Division of Reactor Projects - III,IV,V (Post 9 01 T_6 ). 92/01/27. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X:60480:045-60480:107. -9202050242 Configuration mg insp repts 50-445/91-202 & 50-446/91-201 on 911118-22 & 1202-13. Deficiencies noted. Major areas inspected: design & const attributes of CPSES to assess adequacy of design control program. WILCOX,J.D., GRAMM,R.A., IMBRO,E.V. Special Inspection Branch. 92/01/27. 59pp. 4 8X : 6 0 480 : 0 4 9-60 4 8 0 : 107. 9202030028 Forwards insp repts 50-445/91-66 & 50-446/91-66 on 911120-920107. Violations noted but not cited.Geveral strengths identified, including strong mgt support, excellent oversight & completeness of p.esented packages. BEACH,A.B. Region 4%(Post 820201). 92/01/28. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TC Electric). 3pp. 48X:60421:263-60421:283. --9202030032 Radiation safety insp repts 50-445/91-66 & 50-446/91-66 on 911120-920107 No violations noted. Major areas inspected: previously inspected items, followup on const deficiencies & preoperational test program implementation. YANDELL,L.A. Region 4 (Post B20201). 92/01/22. 18pp. 48X:CC421:266-60421:283. g\\mONg 41 [) ,4 L_m____ _ _ _. - _ _ _ __-m ___m._____._.___________.m.___.______.m--.___-
~~UNITER STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY LCollMIS LPDR-- WIEKLY-- ACCESSION. LIST 7~~
e .92/04/12 -92/04/18 D - 2PAGE : 330; LE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Produc s, and Sepices: y, H !E W DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, -UNIT 1 G. Adjudicatory correspondence 9204140021 Application to secretary for hearings & oral argument in support of motion for leave to intervene out-of-time & motion to reopen record submitted by SL-Dow dba' Disposable Workers? of Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station & RM Dow.* DOW,S.L.', DOW,R.M. Disposab'.e Workets -of Comanche Peak Steam ' Electric Station.
~~292 12782.~~
92/04/06. Commissioners (Pes: 750119). 7pp. 48X:61309:lli-61309:117. I. Financial information 19204130017 Forwards final SEC Form 10-K for FY ended 911231.. CAHILL,W.J., WOODLAN,D.R. Texas Utilities Electric Co. '(TU Electric).1 92/04/08. Occument Control Branch (Document Centrol-Desk). 70pp. 48X:61331:207-61331:276.
~~h. Utility Final Safety Analysis Report (FSAR).& amends 9204150147 As~~
.nce FSAR for-Cesanche Peak Steam Electric Station. Change revLas change previcusly submitted ;in Amend' 79L to FSAR. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric).- 92/04/10.- lipp. 4 BX : 61360 : 298-61360 : 308. P. Operating license stkge doctments &_' correspondence'- 9204150005L Forwards listing of fsmall break LOCA peak cladding temp changes / errors greater than 50 F. Limiting: transient ifor c Unit - 1 changed f rom large break - LOCA to small-break LOCA. Unit-- 2 transient remains as noted in util 910731-ltr.
~~CAHILL,W.J.~~
Texas Utilities Electric Co.= (TU_ Electric). 92/04/07. Document Control Branch (Dccument Control-Desk). : ;3pp. 48X:61353:199-61353:201. 4 g\\TIONg 9 A D EXHi&G ~
1 \\ P O /V g UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY !SSION LPDR WIIKLY ACCESSION LIS. n^-2 92/04/12 - 92/04/18 PAGE 331 ,,LE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, (bh::::s acd Services n Ehibn* DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHC PEAK STIAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence-9204140013 Forwards insp repts 50-445/92-07 & 50-446/92-07 on 920202-0314.No violations cr deviations identified. Weaknesses noted in self-verification area by both maint & operations personnel f ailing to use proper techniques. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/04/07. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU I'ectric). 4pp. 4 8X: 6130 8 :15 2-61308 :3.7 5. --9204140017 Insp repts 50-445/92-07 & 50-446/92-07 on 920202-0314.No violations or deviations identified. Major areas inspected: NRC bulletin followup,LIR followup, operations saf ety verification,maint observa: ion & safety sys verfication. YANDELL,L.A. Region 4 (?cs: 820201). 92/04/01. 20pp. 48X:61308:156-61308:175. 9204170192 Clarifies 920326 response to violations noted in Insp Rept mm 50-445/92-04. Corrective actions:util will perform inservice insp program audit w/e:phasis on procedural imple:sentation of inservice insp contractor. CAHILL,W.J., WALKER,R.D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/04/16. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk), 1p. S. Reportable occurrences, LERs & related correspondence 9204150127 LER 92-006-CO:on 9:0311, discovered that two surveilla.ce work orders f ailed to include calibr instructions for P-9 interlock, channels N41 & 542. Caused by personnel error. Event reviewed by all maint personnel.W/920410 ler. BUSCHBAUM,D.E., CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TC Electric). '92/04/10. 7pp. 48X:61376:122-61376:128. $ \\H ONE D-2 [XHlSD i 9
UNITED-STATES NUCLEAR REG 01ATORY COMMISSION .LPDR WEEKLY ACCESS 20N LI Q \\ Q/\\/ 92/03/29 - 92/04 8, PAGE 334 .LE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, PbcTu2ts, and Services $!E(53_Ib2 I_bbb b bb.55 _5b5b5$b!_!!I$I [ F. Security, medical, emergency & fire protection plans 9203300186 Forwards trip rept te 920?03 request for addl technical info re Thermo-Lag fire barricrs. Technical rept providing addl details will be provided in two weeks. THADANI,,A. Plant Systems Branch. 92/03/18. MARION,A. Nuclear Management & Resources Council (NUMARC) (formerly Nuclear Utility Manage. 1p. 48X:61122:018-61122:077. --9203300245 Trip rept.of 911'04-05 visit to Comanche Peak. Uni: 1 to obtain facts on use of Thermo-Lag fire barriers. Summary of technical issues encl. PLISCO,L.R. Performance & Quality Evaluation Branch (Post 890101). WEST,K.S. Division of Reactor Inspection & Safeguards (Pos: 870411). 91/12/24. MIRAGLIA,F.J. Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Director (Pos: 870411). lipp. 48X:61122:067-61122:077 204010284 Submits results of review of emergency esponse data sys implementation plan submitted via 911028 ltr.Exe:cption request,w/ justification mus: be submitted to allow implementation after required date at Unit 1. BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/03/31. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 3pp. 48X:61222:207-61222:209. G. Adjudicatory corresp,ondence 9204020005 Forwards affidavits formerly attached to 920323, "NRC Staf f Reply to Petition of RM Dow & SL Dow dba Disposable Workers of ComanchesPeak Steam Electric Station for Leave to Intervene Out of Time & Motion to Reopen Record." ZOBLER,M.L. Office of the General Counsel (Post 860701).
~~292~~
~~12757, 92/03/31.~~
CHILK,S.J. Office of the Secretary of the Commission. lp. 48X:61200:026-61200:039, $ \\Tl ONg D-2 EXH156
~ -. - .~- UNITED STATES NUCLEAR -REGULATORYT COMMISSIONI - [-l Q -LPDR WEEKLY ACCESS 80NJLIST'. 1 92/03/29' -92/04/0'4 k ---3351
~~ILE LEVELS - DOCKET,- Regulated Nuclear'. Facilities, Producth,'abd Services-E**?_5 :!!! c *^"c"" "E^* SE^*_EMcT"!E ST^?2 "> ""k_dH I E 6 G. Adjudicatory correspondence~~
--9204020009 Af fidavit.of RM; Latta re nonconformance rept E-84-0079,rev 1.* Affidavit of RM Latta describing issues associated - w/nonconformance rept. LATTA,R.M. Region 4 (Pos: 820201). -92/03/27. 2pp. 48X:61200:027-61200:028. --9204020011 Affidavit'of WD Cohnson re 911006-event.* Affidavi: of WD Johnson describing 911006 event & evaluating-significance. JOHNSON,W.D. Region 4 (Pest'820201). 92/03/24. -3pp. 48X:61200:029-61200:031.
~~--9204020014 Af fidavit of RM Latta re seismic restraint compression -~~
fitting crimps.* Af fidavit of. RM Latta. describing nature & purpose-of seismic 1 restraint compression fitting crimps explaining why deficiencies did not pose public threat. -LATTA,R.M. Region 4 (Post-820201). 92/03/27. -3pp. 48X:61200:032-61200:034. --9204020016 Af fidavit of TE) Johnson re. plant labelling.* Affidavitlof - WD. Johnson describing plant labellingfdeficiencies.& adequacy of licensee corrective actions. JOENSON,W.D. Region 4 (Pcst 820201). 92/03/24.- 5pp. 48X:61200:035-61200:039.- N P. Operating 11icense stage documents & correspondence 9204010006 Forwards ? "RER Line Summary-Rept,"' containing - supplemental evaluation of RER line thersal' stratification L&-- leak-before-break qualification.RRR line' monitored 1& data collected during firstioperating-cycle. CAHILL,W. J., - MARSHALL,'J'. S. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU ~ Electric). 92/03/23. Document Control Branch (Document l Control -Desk).- 2pp.,48X:61210:284-61210:306. q r ' 0o c/p, R D-2 EX HiBN a-Gs
I UNITED STATES NDCLEAR: REGULATORY 'COMM LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST h 92/03/29 92/04/04(& PAGE >336 0-2 ILE-LEVELS - DOCKET,; Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services bNIb\\__\\ - ______________ COMANCHE PEAK SOEAM ELECTRIC STATION, DOCKET 50-445. P. - Operating license stage documents & - cor respondence - --9 204010007 "RHR - Line' Summary Rept. " Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/23. 2'pp. 48X:61210:286-61210:306. I 9203310108 Informs that T Bergman will continue to be acting < Project: Manager for plant until 920626. BLACK,S.C. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/03/25 - CAHILL,W.J.- Texas-Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 2pp. 48X : 6119 4 : 010-61194 : 011. -9204010250 Forwards control room temp analysis in response to request for addl info presented in NRC 920227 ltr issuing station blackout safety evaluation for Unit 1. 'CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric).= 92/03/31.- . Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 3pp. 48X:61222:095-61222:097. t O. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9203300099' Responds to NRC 920225 ltr re violations noted-in (Inspf Repts 50-445/92-04 & 50-446/92-04 on 920121-24 & 0210-11. - Corrective actions: operations notification form issued to: ' document exam of weld-TBX-1-4103-1. C AHILL, W.' J. - Texas Utilities-Electric Co. (TU_ Electric). -92/03/26. Document Control Brknch-- (Document Control Desk). 3pp. ~ 48X:61164:349-61164:351. 9203310290~ Responds to_NRC 920127.ltr-re deficiencies-noted.in 3 Configuration Mgt Insp Rept 50-445/91-202 & 50-446/91-202 ) on 911118-1213. Corrective actions:util instituting; training-discussing! design: verifications provisions in. calculations. ~ CAHILL,W.J. Texas ' Utilities. Electric Co. (TU Electric). -92/03/27; Document Control Branch (Document-Control Desk).. 15pp. 48X:61207:037-61207:051.. g p\\nONego 9 D.- 2 EXHiSW
DNITED STATES' NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST {Q 92/01/26 - 92/02/01 ( 348-n (ILELEVELS-DOCKET,RegulatedNuclearFacilities,Produch.7 add Services S**T "-!!" '?"^"C"* f" SIf^* *'! '"' SI^'!?"' _""$2 H I B 6 F. Security, medical, emergency & fire protection plans 9201310015 Forwards partially withheld insp repts 50-445/91-68 & 50-446/91-68 on 911209-12 (ref 10CFR73.21).Noncited violation noted. BEACHrA.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/01/24. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 6pp. 48X:60413:124-60413:131. --9201310018 Partially withheld insp repts 50-445/91-68 & 50-446/91-68 on 911209-12 (ref 10CFR73.21).Noncited violation noted. Major areas inspected: licensee physical security program. MURRAY,B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/01/21. 2pp. 48X:60413:130-60413:131. H. General correspondence 201280208 Requests new name/ address on NRC mailing labels as listed. BLEEKER,D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/28. NRC - No Detailed Af filiation Given, lp. 48X:60418:069-60418:069. K. Utility Final Safety Analysis Report (FSAR) & amends 9201270079 Forwards advance FSAR change re accident monitoring program, reflecting that remote manual containment isolation valve position indication on emergency response facility computer not-required,in ref fo NUREG-0797, "SER," Suppl 23. CAHILL,W.J., WALKER,R.D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/17. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 28pp. 48X:60397:264-60397:294. P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence 9201290029 Informs that 920110 meeting to discuss general status of Unit 1 operations & 1991 expenditures, beneficial to understanding current status. MARTIN,R.D. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/01/22. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 2pp. 48X:60393 0,5 - 0 2 hr E)-2
s UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY C ..h-=1CN)*/p LPDR WEEKLY ACCESS 3ON LI ' k.e 92/02/09 - 97/12/15 g PAGE 349 ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, [ Products, and Services DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT'l*~ ' M. Antitrust correspondence 9202100227 Forwards response to Reg Guide 9.3 which updates activities that have occurred since a..titrust operating license review, por 911205 request. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/05. BL ACK', S. C. Project Directorate IV-2. 54pp. 48X:60560:188-60560:241 P. Operating license stage dccuments & correspondence 9202100128 Summary of 920109 meeting w/util to discuss licensing actions & commitments for plant. BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/01/30. Project Directorate IV-2. 3pp. 43X:60519:172-60519:174. ( '202110163 Responds to Generic Ltr 91-11, " Resolution of Generic Issues 48, "LCOs for Class lE Vita) Instrument Buses' & 49, " Interlocks & LCOs for Class lE Tie Breakers. '" CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/03. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). OR A-48, 3pp. 48X:60576:050-60576:052. 9202120038 Discusses issues which affect development of Unit 2 Inservice Testing (IST) Plan for pumps & valves &' to some extent impact existing Uni: 1 IST Plan. Encl relief request is re preservice teAting of stated valves for Unit 2. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 9 '!/02/0 3. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 4pp.. 48X:60584:187-60584:190. 9202110139 Forwards proposed changes to technical requirements canual, incorporating Unit 2 manual into Unit 1 manual.Section 3.2 re station svc water sys will be revised, based on util response to Generic Ltr 91-13. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/04. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 3pp. 48X:60575:3d3-60576:020. W l O.^/ e 9( g.a D-2 E%HIB6
I@&l 0.4g. UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY CO LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST 92/01/26 - 92/02/0 ' D-2 "^
~~4' RILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services~~
[NHis n. DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence 9201300185 Staff requirements memo re affirmation / discussion & vote on 920117 in Rockville,MD re SECY-91-413, " Motion to Reopen Record in Comanche Peak Proceeding." Commission approved order denying request,by 5-0 vote. CHILK, S'. J. Office of the Secretary of the Commission. 92/01/24. PARLER,W.C. Office of the General Counsel (Post 860701). 'lp. 48X:60413:327-60413:327. O. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9112190328 NRC Info Notice 91-086, "New Reporting Requirements for Contamination Events at Medical Facilities (10CFR30.50)." CUNNINGHAM,R.E. Division of Industrial & Medical Nuclear Saf ety (Post 870729). -91/12/27. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 19pp. 48X:60407:001-60407:019. 9201090188 NRC Inf o Notice 9 2-007, " Rapid Flow-Induced Erosion / Corrosion of Feedwater Piping." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/01/09. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:60407:020-60407:023. 9201280290 Forwards interim change requests ISI-RO-001 & 002 to-update inservice insp progrqn plan. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/22. Document Control Branch (Dccument Control Desk). 26pp. 48X:60417:029-60417:055. 9201290208 Forwards Rev 0 to " Augmented Inservice Insp Plan, Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station," in response to NRC 911004 telcon request. Westinghouse Technical Bulletin NSD-TB-75-1 re reactor coolant pump thermal barrier also encl. CAHILL,W.J., WALKER,R.D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/24. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 2pp. 48X:60449:238"60449:284. Q \\ ONp%- 9 D-2 EXHlB6 J
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST \\Tl Ol/gGE \\ 350-92/02/09 --92/02/15 ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities Qroducts, and Se M ees D-2 '---~~~~~~~ DOCKET 50-443 COMANCHE PFAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence H l g j\\ --9202110144 Proposed TS Section 3/4 re LCOs & surveillance requirements during operational modes & TS Table 1.4.1, " Seismic Monitoring Instrumentation." . Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/04. 76pp. 48X 60575:306-60576:020, 9202110263 Advises that util has completed performance review of N16 transit time flow meter (TOFM) during_first operating cycle of Unit 1. conclusions re installation of subj detectors apply to Unit 2. Azimuthal uncertainty term discussion encl. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilitjes Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/04. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 8pp. 48X:60584:051-60584: 058. 9202120057 Forwardc meeting summary of 920123 meeting re activi-ies ( authorized by NRC const permit CPPR-127 for facility. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/05. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Co. 64pp. 48X:50523:293-60524:038, 9202120065 Requests NRC review & approval of supplement--I to RXE-88-102-P to provide for use of Westinghouse fuel through Unit 1, Cycle 3 & to reschedule original Siemens fuel design for cycle 4. Approval requested by Dec 92. CAHILL,W.J., WALKER,R.D. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/05. Document Con.rol Branch (Document Control Desk). 2pp. 48X:60584:191-605841192. Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9201020171 NRC Info Notice 92-005, " Potential Coil Insulation Breakdown in ABB RXME2 Relays." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/01/08. Consolidated Idison Co. of New York, Inc. 6pp. 48X:60514:003-60514:008. g GlOypp'e 9 D-2 EXHiBG
UNITED STATES' NUCLEAR REGULATORY-COMMISSION LPOR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST .-1 \\T ! OtyCpAGE n L 351 92/01/26 - 92/02/01 r'_ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products,,cand S tices u t, DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STIAM ELECTRIC STATION, T T. Hearing transcripts on non-antitrust matters-9201290277 Transcript of 920117 affirmation / discussion & vote public meeting in Rockville,MD.Pp 1-4.Related info encl. Commissioners (Post 750113). 92/01/17. 8pp. 48X:60400:166-60400:173. s d p;; oo:gO s Q' .M w l EXHiB6 l
I UN8TED. STATES NtiCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION: LPDR' WEEKLY /ACCESSZON. LIST ~ A_ \\TVONg 92/03/01 - 92/03/07-g- 3601 LE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Product @y.a7 Services-DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNkg] \\ $ F. Security, medical, emergency & fire protection plans 9203030111 Revised Emergency Plan Procedures, including Rev 0.to-EPP-215, " Corporate, Support during Emergencies," Rev 11 to EPP-304, " Protective Action Recommendations" _& revised + indichs.W/920226.ltr.- WOODLAN,D.R. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/26. 31pp. 48X 60805:088-60805:119. 9203030194 Forwards Rev 13 to " Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Emergency Plan." Rev in ref to corporate ofc emergency response & support, departmental reorganization & emergency response facility computer sys & digital RMS. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric-Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/28.. Document Control-Branch (Document Control Desk). lipp. 48X: 60801:043-60801:ll5. -9203030199 Rev 13 to Emergency Plan.. Texas utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/03.- 62pp. -\\ 48X:60801:054-60801:115. 9203050237 Forwards Physical Security Plan,Rev 12 (copies 13,14,15 ' &
~~16). Copies withheld ( ref 10CFR73.21).~~
CAHILL,W.J., WOODLAN,D.R._ Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/03.- Document Control Branch (Document Control. Desk). -lp. 48X: 60852:095-60852:095. V G.-Adjudicatory correspondence 9203050038 Petition for leave. to ' intervene out of _ time.
~~Requests that L petition for leave to intervene out of-time be granted for listed reasons.W/ Certificate of Sve.-~~
~~DOW,S.L., DOW,R.M. Disposable Workers-of' Comanche Peak-Steam Electric Station.~~
~~192 12619.~~
92/02/21.. Commissioners (Post-7,50119). -22pp.- 48X: 60791:085-60791:106. ~ p\\1.lONeg 9 - a D-2 2%HlBG m L,-
UNITED-STATES' NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION -LIST 92/03/01 - 92/03/07. q \\T i O Ajg, --- 3611 JILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear -Facilities, Producp and Services
+
DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC-STATION, UNQy ; 5 \\ y G.' Adjudicatory correspondence 9203050029 Motion to - reopen record.* Requests that NRC-reopen record s - . suspend OL for unit-1 & CP for unit 2,pending-_ reopening-& final decision.W/Certifica:e of Sve. DOW,S.L., DOW,R.M. Disposable Workers of Comanche Peak Steam. Electric Station.
~~192 12520.~~
92/02/24. Commissioners'(Post'. 750119). '64pp. 48X:60791:009-60791:073. 9203050234 Change of address & telephone number.* Informs _ all parties to action that address & telephone number of Disposable Workers of -Comanche Peak ~ Steam Electric Station has been changed as listed. DOW,R.M. Disposable Workers of Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station.
~~192 12641, 92/02/27.~~
Ip. -48X:60803:058-60803:058.. 9203050004 Order.* Licensee should file consolidated response to SL Dow & RM Dow petition for late intervention & motion to. reopen record,by 920316.NRC should file same response by.' 920323. W/ Certificate of Sve. Served on 920228. CHILK,S.J. Office of the Secretary of the Commission.
~~192 12630.<~~
92/02/28.- Of fice of the' General Counsel -(Post 860701). 2pp.. 48X:60790:281-60790 282. K. Utility Final Safety Analysis Report (FSAR) &-amends 9203030182 Forwards A"dend 84 to Comanche Peak Steam 1 Electric : Station, L Units 1 &-2 FSAR.W/o encl. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU_ Electric). 32/02/28. Document Control Branch - (Document Control Desk). 2pp. H 48X:60802:087-60802:088. o Q( \\T I Ofiq c g r D-2 1 ~ 1 N%HIB\\T
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISS ON \\/ /(( l LPDR UEEKLY ACCESSION LIST ,{ \\ 92/03/01 - 92/03/07 (k PAS'E 362 n-? ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, ProducF, and Services HiBf5 DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UN K. Utility Final Safety Analysis Report (FSAR) & amends 9203030286 Forwards detailed description of changes proposed in amend 84 to FSAR. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/28. Docucent Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 90pp. 48X:60821:289-60822:018. P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence 9203040277 Forwards safety evaluation & requests addl info re station blackout analysis for f acility. BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/02/27. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Co. 3pp. 48X:60806:258-60806:269. --9203040282 Safety evaluation accepting licensee responses & proposed method for dealing w/SBO analysis for facility. Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Director (Post 870411). 92/02/27. 9pp. 48X : 60 806 : 261-60806 : 269. 9203030151 Forwards " Semiannual Radioactive Effluent Release Rept for Jul through Dec 1991" & Rev 7 to "ODCM." WOODLAND,D.R. Texas-Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/28. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). lp. 48X:60828:193-60829:093. s --9203030159 Rev 7 to "ODCM." Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 91/12/31, 175pp. 48X:60828:237-60829:093. 9203030353 Application for amend to License NPF-87, consisting of License Amand Request 92-001, revising TS 3.3.1, Table 3.3-1, Functional Unit 6.b, " Boron Dilution Mitigation Flux Doubling," in ref to Generic Ltr 85-05. CAEILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/26. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 17pp. 48X:60820:101-60820:271. -g O 1 ONg& q D-2 EXHIB6
'l UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 1 LPDR WEEKLY. ACCESS 3ON. L2ST y}Qg 92/03/011-92/03/07 UN8TED STATES NUCLEAR REGULA'SORY CO %,h LPDR WEEKLY ACCESS 80N LISh a 92/03/01 - 92/03/07 PAGE 364 .O, u,) ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services E% hli 5 \\,,\\ DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNZT I Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9202190037 NRC Info Notice 92-014, "U Oxide Fires at Fuel Cycle Facilities." CUNNINGHAM,R.E. Division of Industrial & Medical Nuclear Safety (Post:870729). 92/02/21. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 9pp. 48X:60838:215-60838:223. 9203020121 Forwards insp repts 50-445/92-04 & 50-446/92-04 & notice of violation. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/25. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X:60731:163-60731:175. --9203020123 Notice of violation from insp on 920121-24 & 920210-11. Violation notedsinservice ultrasonic examination performed on 911022 of Weld number 1 on sketch TBX-1-4103 of safety injection sys was not conducted in both citcumferential. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/25. 1p. 48X 60731:167-60731:167 \\ --9203020127 Insp repts 50-445/92-04 & _50-446/92-04 on 920121-24 & 0210-11. Violations noted. Major areas inspected:insp of licensee action on previously identified insp finding & unit 1 inservice insp data review & evaluation. BARNES,I. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/21. 8pp. 48X:60731:168-60731:175. N 9203030239 Forwards "ISI Summary Rept - First Interval,First Period, First Outage." C AHI LL, W. J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/27. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 1p. 48X:60834:1'57-60837:195. T \\) ! ()'lR'h)e IS '/ Q D EXHISYi W=
UN8TED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM85 "I O N g't[DE LPDR WEEKLY ACCESS 80N LIST 92/03/01 - 92/03/07 <k 365 ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Produ s, and Services DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, O kj@b Q. Inspection reports, IE Eulletins & correspondence --9203030242 "ISI Summary Rept - First Interval,First Period,First Outage." Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/01/31. 600pp. 48X:60834:158-60837:195. 9203040043 Forwards sys entry retest insp repts 50-445/92-02 & 50-446/92-02 on 920113-17.No violations or deviations noted. DEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/27. CAHILL,W.J. Texts Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X t 60767 : 09 2-6 0767 : 107. --9203040048 Insp repts 50-445/92-02 & 50-446/92-02 on 920ll3-17.No violations noted. Major areas ittspectedtsys entry retest including mods, temporary mods & maint activities. GAGLI ARDO, J. E. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/25. 12pp. 48X:60767:096-60767:107. R. Periodic operating reports & related correspondence 9203030117 " Annual Operating Rept 1991," including annual 10CFR50.59 info for 1991.W/920228 ltr. CAHILL,W.J.- Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 91/12/31. 124pp. 48X:60801:177-60801:299. 9203030151 Forwards " Semiannual Radioactive Ef fluent Release Rept for Jul through Dec 1991" & Rev 7 to "ODCM." WOODLAND,D.R.. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/28. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 1p. 48X 60828:193-60829:093. 9(-9 t 1 O?: /P A O-2 E#HIBd
UN!TED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM8S 8% { Q \\/{ LPDR WEEKLY ACCESS 80N L85T k PAGE 367 92/03/01 - 92/03/07 D7 ILE LEVELS - DCCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services DOCKET 50-445 CCMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT I V. Operator Examinations 9203060064 Notifies of 920324 Region IV Operator Licensing Section meeting w/all Region IV f acility licensees to discuss requalification exams. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/21. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 3pp. 48X 60803:237-60803:239. \\ i ] '! [p h s R \\e k Y. e D-2 ~ i.$ &
E1 ! ()[/,f p UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY CO N LPDR UEEKLY ACCESSION LIST pg 92/02/16 - 92/02/22 ()" 2 PAGE 370 ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Pro u ts, and Services p,, g 3 DOCKET 50-445 CORANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 F. Security, medical, emergency & fire protection plans 9202190353 Forwards Rev 5 to " Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Fire Protection Rept." CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/14. Document Control Branch (Decument Control Desk). 3pp. 48X:60678:008-60678:032. --9202190357 Rev 5 to " Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Fire Protection Rept." Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/14. 22pp. 48X 60678:011-60678:032. P. Operating license stage dccuments & correspondence 9202210358 Forwards response to NRC 920114 request for addl info re Topical Rept RXE-91-002, Reactivity Anomaly Events Methodology." Responses to two remaining questions will be provided by 920331. CAHILL,W.J., WOODLAN,0.R. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/14. Dccument Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 33pp. 4 8X 60714 : 0 61-60714 : 093. Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 5 9112200262 NRC Info Notice 91-087, " Hydrogen Embrittlement of Raychem Cryofit Couplings." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post =870411).- 91/12/27. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:60656:107-60656:110. s Y
~~I D-2 Ey s. r 6 L~~
a ms. UN8TED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM <t (, 'O y T LPOR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST 3. ] PAGE 371 92/02/16 - 92/02/22 ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services )(, j ![ \\ E DOCKET 50-445 COKANCHE PEAK S*EAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports IE Bulletins & correspondence } 9112270125 NRC Info Notice 92-001, " Cable Damage Caused by Inadequate Cable Installation Procedures & Controls." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/01/03. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:60656 sill-60656:114. 9112300071 NRC Info Notice 92-003, "Memote Trip Function Failures in GE F-Frame Molded-Case Circuit Breakers." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/01/06. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 6pp. 48X 60656:115-60656:120. 9201280345 NRC Inf o Notice 9 2-010, " Brachytherapy Incidents Inve'.ving Ir-192 Wire Used in Endobronchial Treatments." CUNNINGEAM,R.E. Division cf Industrial & Medical Nuclear Sa"ety (Post 870729). -92/01/31. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:60656:121-60656:124, 9202190135 Submits final response to NRC Bulletin 88-008 re thermal requests that stresses in piping connected to RCS & requirement to record data be suspended. Summary of Analysis performed by Westinghouse on subj encl. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/07. Document Control Branch (Occument Control Desk). 15pp. 48X:60679:128-60679:'142, 9202040079 NRC Info Notice 92-012, "Ef f ects of Cable Leakage Currents on Instrument Settings & Indications." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/02/10. Consolidated-Idison Co. of New York, Inc. -4pp. 48X 60656:125-60656:128. g\\ ' OM?p T . iP, <g n. _? a
l l b,D 'JN2TED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM 2 LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST (Q ' gf! 92/02/16 - 92/02/22 [) '.2 PAGE 372 ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Pr du) cts, and.. Services (p4 ;7, $, DOCKET 50-4 4 5 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9202180170 Advises that response to NRC Bulletin 89-001, suppl 2, "Pailure of Westinghouse Steam Generator Tube Mechanical Plugs," acceptable. BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/02/10. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 2pp. 48X:60601:062-60601:063. 9202200030 Forwards insp repts 50-445/91-67 & 50-446/91-67 on 911209-13 & 920106-09 & notice of violation. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Posc 820201). 92/02/10. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X 60610:233-60610:247. --9202200086 Notice of violation from insp on 911209-13 & 920106-09. Violation noted eight unit 2 preoperational test procedures found to contain numerous format & content errors & determined to be inadequate & inappropriate. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/10. Ip. 48X:60610:237-60610:237 --9202200090 Insp repts 50-445/91-67 & 50-446/91-67 on 911209-13 & 920106-09. Violation noted. Major areas inspected: review of preoperational test procedures for unit 2 & QA audit of unit 2 startup activities. GAGLIARDO,J.E. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/03. 10pp. 48X:60610:238-60610:247. 9202200030 Forwards insp repts 50-445/92-05 & 50-446/92-05 on 920127-30.No violations or devia-icns noted. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/13. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Ilectric). 4pp. 48X 60610:069-60610:078. Of Q n p 2;c.g.'i .m_
) UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COv.q#H O h ) LPDRWEEKLYACCESSIONLIST<kb %.C' (9, 92/03/08 - 92/03/14 {},j PAGE 380 FILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services ht@\\\\ N,_ DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNI E. NRC Safety Evaluation Report (SER), suppis & correspondence 9203100163 Forwards proposed TSAR change to remove requirement for in-line, independent review cf operations notification & evaluation forms (nonconformance documents),per SSER 22 (NUREG-0797). CAHILL,W.J., WOODLAN,D.R. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/03. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 10pp. 48X:60897 266-60897 275. G. Adjudicatory correspondence 9203120242 Advises that unless individual takes prompt steps to be in compliance w/NRC order of 910620,NRC will request DOJ to seek order enforcing subpoena. LONGO,G.M. C2fice of the General Counsel (Post 860701). 91/07/23. >OW,R.E. Dow, R.E. 3pp. 48X 60887:332-60887:334. K. Utility Final Safety Analysis Report (FSAR) & amends 9203110103 " Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Final SAR." Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/28. 1,000pp. 48X:60913:215-60917:034. 9203120071 Provides' add 4 info on FSAR Section 3.10,in ref to NRC Aug 1989 SQRT audit & Pump & Valve Operability Review Team Audit at plant. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/06. Document Control Branch (Dccument Control Desk). 6pp. 48X:60918:3Sl-60918:356. gi \\l10%~'E g <2 g D-2 DHiBil
is \\' I ONg UN!TED STATIS NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSI LPDR WEEKLY-ACCESS!ON LZST ( gp, / 92/04/05 - 92/04/11 [;-{ AGE 416 and Services RegulatedNuclearFacilities,Productf,g .z k.uE LEVELS - DOCKET, DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK SOEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 F. Security, medical, emergency & fire protection plans i I 9204060404 Revised Emergency Plan Procedures (EPP), including Procedure Change Number (PCN) PCN EPP-202-R4-1 to Rev 4 to EPP-202, PCN EPP-205-R7-5 to Rev 7 to EPP-205,PCN EPP-214-Rl-1 to Rev 1 to EPP-214 & Rev 7 to EPP-303.W/920401 ltr. CAHILL,~W.J., WOOOLAN,D.R. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU diectric). 92/04/01, 56pp. 48X 61266 299-61266:354. 9204100031 Forwards SALP Reprs 50.445/92-99 & 50-446/92-99 for 910203 - 920201 period. MARTIN,R.D. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/04/03. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 9pp. 48X:61276:055-61276:096. --9204100041 SALP repts 50-445/92-99 & 50-446/92-99 for 910203 - 920201 period. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/04/03. 33pp. 4 8X: 6127 6 : 064-61276 : 0 96. J. Insurance & indemnity inf ormation 9204100133 Forwards endorsement 18,12 & 15 & 9 to Policies MF-131, MW-0190 & M-0090, respective'.y & Endorsement 43 to Policy q NF-274. MARSEALL,J.3. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/10. MURLEY,T.E. Officetof Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Director (Post 870411). 8pp. 48X:61326:0*.5-61326:022. K. Utility Fin,al Safety Analysis Report (FSAR) & amends j 9204060386 Amends 82 & 84 to updated FSAR for Comanche Peak Steam-Electric Station. Amend regards one-h fire rated cable size. W/920401 itr. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/04/01. 12pp. 48X:6(266:287-61266:298. g O \\ C :'I Z Q n-: EX Hl66 i
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST \\hb n7 92/04/05 - 92/04/11 " PAGE 417 Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Prodq{ts,h j g.SMTvices And ) n kiLE LEVELS - DOCKET, o DOCKET 50-445 COKANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence 9204080002 Requests technical assistance in determining adequacy of licensee 10CFR50.59 evaluation in support of reducing RCS level for entering reduced inventory operating restrictions f rom 3'.to 5 f t below reactor vessel flange. COLLINS,S.J. Region 4 (Pos: 820201). 92/01/08. VIRGILIO,M.J. Project Directorate IV-2. 28pp. 48X:61250 004-61250:058. 9203190187 Generic Ltr 92-03. to all nuclear power plant applicants & licensees re compilation of current licensing basis request for voluntary participation in pilot program. PARTLOW,J.G. Associate Director for Projects (Post 870411). 92/03/19. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:61269:015-61269:018. 9704070089 Forwards response to two items in NRC 920114 request for 50sddl info re Topical Rept RXE-91-002, " Reactivity Anomaly Events Methodology." MARSHALL,J.S. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/31. _ Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 8pp. 48X:61261:344-61261:351. 9204060238 Forwards attachment & enc 1 omitted f rom 920227 lt re safety evaluation & request for addl info concerning station blackout analysis for f acility. BERGMAN,T.A. Projeck Diractorate IV-2. 92/04/01. Texas Utilities Co. 1p. 48X:61252:248-61252:289. 9204060148 Summary of 920218 meeting w/util re combined tech specs for facility & other licensing issues. List of meeting attendees encl. FIELDS,M.B. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/04/02. Project Directorate IV-2. 4pp. 48X 6124 2 :158-612 42 :161. c\\O!O'!g <2 sit c4 - 2 ?%Hl56
N1 O/1g UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM S LPDR WIEKLY ACCESSION LIST g f 92/04/05 - 92/04/11 {) { PAGE 418 FILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services DOCKET 50-445 CORANCHE PEAK STIAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence 9204060150 Advises that util 920203 response to Generic Ltr 91-11, " Resolution of Generic Issues 48, 'LCOs for Class lE Vital Instrument Buses' & 49, ' Interlocks & LCOs for Class 1E Tie Breakers'" acceptable. BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/04/02. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). OR 048. 2pp. 48X:61242:156-61242:157. 9204100280 Responds to request for clarification of Relief Reques: V-1 re differences between in-situ testing & shop testing & specific advantages of one method over another. Revised Relief Request V-1 encl. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/04/06. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 4pp. 48X:61326:353-61326:356. es 9204100333 Revised application for amend to License NPF-87 re boron dilution mitigation sys.Util proposes that TS rev have six month validity after criticality following second cutage to research issues & resolution & propose solution. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/04/06. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 3pp. 48X:61327:016-61327:025. --9204100339 Proposed TS rev to Table 3.3-1, " Reactor Trip Sys Instrumentation" re boron dilution mitigation sys. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/04/06. 7pp. 48X 61327:019-61327:025. s Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9203180053 NRC Info Notice 92-021, " Spent Fuel Pool Reactivity Calculations." ROSSI,C.E. DAvision of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). -92/03/24.. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 4BX:61269:001-61269:004. \\ h ! b['I, k. O D-2 P-o, N... \\ # w t ) c3
'i k l (1,I/% C$ p, UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY CO SION LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST g 92/04/05 - 92/04/11 ' 2 PAGE 419 FILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Pro [Jcds, a_nd. Services h4, t; t DOCKET 50-445 COKANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 O. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9203180179 NRC Info Notice 92-022, " Criminal Prosecution & Conviction of Wrongdoing Committed by Commercial-Grade Valve Supplier." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/03/24. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 10pp. 48X:61269:005-61269:014. 9203230070 NRC Info Notice 92-023, "Results of Validation Testing of Motor-Operated valve Diagnostic Equipment." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/03/27. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:61269:019-61269:022. 9203230145 NRC Info Notice 92-024, " Distributor Mod to Certain Commercial-Grade Agastat Electrical Relays."
~~OSSI,C.E.~~
Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/03/30. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 6pp. 48X:61269:023-61269:028. 9204080044 Discusses insp repts 50-445/91-202 & 50-446/91-201 on 911118-1213 & notice of violation. Violations re f ailure to follow procedures of concern to agency due to lack of attention to detail. BEACH,A.B. Region 4g(Pos-820201). 92/03/31. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X:61251:029-61251:036. --9204080048 Notice of violation from inen on 911118-1213. Violation noted:f ailure to implement adequate d'esign control measures. Region 4 (Post 320201). 92/03/31, 4pp. '9X 61251:033-61251:03 6. n gg\\"iO/qg(P. (2 rs _ c_; EkHIBd
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSION LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST $0iONr 92/02/23 - 92/02/29 E 419 'ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Produc.ts,,,gnd Services -) n DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAX S7EAM ELECTRIC STATION, UN _____________________________________________________&'_,g,_1p;;g31 F. Security, medical, emergency & fire protection plans 9202250114 Responds to concerns noted in insp repts 50-445/91-68 & 50-446/91-68 re increased security inf ractions during Unit I refueling outage. Corrective actions training enhanced for outage workers. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/14. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 2pp. 48X 60668:280-60668:281. P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence 9201300217 Suppl 1 to Generic Ltr 88-01 to all licensees of operating BWRs & holders of const pernits for BWRs providing acceptable alternatives to NRC position on IGSCC in BWR austenitic stainless steel piping. PARTLOW,J.G. Associate Director for Projects (Post 870411). 92/02/04. Consolidated Idison Co. of New York, Inc. GL 88-01 S1. 7pp. 9202270049 Discusses motion to reopen record in connection w/ plant licensing proceedings CLI-92-91.NRC will take appropriate action on request within reasonable time,per 10CFR2.206.Fr notice encl. MURLEY,T.E. Of fice of Nuc*. ear Reactor Regulation, Director (?ost 870411). 92/02/18. DOW,5.L., DOW,R.M. Canada. 3pp. 48X:60718:222-60718:238. N --9202270054 Notice of receipt of petition for director's decision under 10CFR2.206. MURLEY,T.E. Of fice of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Director (Post 870411).,92/02/18. 2pp. 48X:60718:225-60718:238. /\\ \\m\\ \\ U ;gl, D } im T %/ <2 e 19, C; - 2 df 9 n h,;, s i i
SgtjQgj('b UNITED STATE 3 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMM \\ LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST C p* v ry PACE 421 92/04/05 - 92/04/11 Q.g r.LE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services b.~ l.'JI DOCKET 50-445 CCMANCHE PEAK $7EAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIA V. Operator Examinations 9204080009 Informs of topics discussed ditring 920324 meeting in region IV ofc re current issues in licensed operator requalification program.Mati provided as handouts at meeting & list of attendees encl. Listed topics also discussed. COLLINS,S.J. Region 4 (Pos: 820201). 92/04/02. DEDDENS,J.C. Gulf States Utilities Co. CARNS,N.S. Entergy Operations, Inc. WITHERS,B.D. Wolf Creek Nuclear Operating Corp. 29pp. 48X 61250:146-61250:230. N sM"\\ 10NE4 9 a D-2 ENHiB6
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST l W ION ~ 92/02/23 - 92/02/2 k PAGE 421 ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Producty, and Services ~< c. DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATIONt* fjjjgi. tT 1 s Q. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence --9202240093 Notice of violation from insp on 9 20108-0 2 01.Vio' a tion noted pressurized spray valves inadequately stored outside. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/14. Ip. 48X 60655:143-60655:143 --9202240096 Insp repts 50-445/92-03 & 50-446/92-03 on 920108-0201. Violations noted. Major areas inspected: plant, action on previous insp findings, followup on corrective actions & licensee action on const deficiencies & NRC bulletins. YANDELL,L.A. Region 4 (?ost 820201). 92/02/12. 15pp. 48X 60655:144-60655:158. 9202240107 Forwards insp repts 50-445/91-70 & 50-446/91-70 on 911220-920201.No violations or deviations noted.Many strengths noted but weakness found in training of control room operators associated w/high risk activities. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/14. CAHILL,W.J. Texas-Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X:60655:216-60655:233. --9202240109 Resident safety insp repts 50-445/91-70 & 50-4 46/9*-70 on 911220-920201.No violations noted. Major areas inspected: plant status, operational safety,onsite followup of events, surveillance & followup of previously identified items. YANDELL,L.A. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/02/12. 14pp. 48X 60655:220-60655:233. N 9202250114 Responds to concerns noted in insp repts 50-445/91-68 & 50-446/91-68 re. increased security infractions during Unit 1 refueling qutage. corrective actionss training enhanced for outage workers. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric)..92/02/14. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 2pp. 48X 60668: 280-60668:281. p\\11.ONg& q' D-2 c'rgjggs
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS." LPDR WIIKLY ACCESSION LIST \\ti ' khc 479 92/03/15 - 92/03/21 Ik R n.. ') ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products,' Sand Services DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, U i-l l h '. F. Security, medical, emergency & fire protection plans I 9109240136 Forwards "1991 Field Exercise," for 911119 graded exercise. WOODLAN,D.R. Texas Utilities Co. 91/09/19. Document Control Branch (Document Control Des 4). lp. 48X:60977:194-60979:301. --9109240139 "1991 Field Exercise." Tennessee Valley Authority. 91/09/19. 773pp. 48X 60977:195-60979:301. G. Adjudicatory correspondence 9203200286 TU Electric answer to petition to intervene & motion & supplemental motion to reopen by M Dow & SL Dow & TU Electric request for admoni:!on of Dows.* Concludes that motion should be dismissed.W/ Certificate of Sve. EDGAR,G.L. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU-Electric). EDG AR, G. L. - Newman & Holtzinger. WOOLDRIDGE,R. A. Worsham, Forsythe, Sampels & Woolridge (formerly Worsham, Forsythe & Sampels).
~~192 12707.~~
92/03/16. Commissioners (Post 750119). 39pp. 48X 60976:318-60976:356. J. Insurance & indemnity information 9203190094 Forwards KAELU Policies 91198 & x92198R & certificates of property insurance / stabilization & decontamination liability insurance. WOODLAN,D.R. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/12. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). 11pp.. 48X 60998:1&7-60998:197. 9, V ; 1 iljyCyp ~ Q\\ a n 3_ D'u to rt m
fJNITED STATES NUCLEAR QEGtJLATORY COMM25S50N LPDR 'dEEKLY ACCESS 20N LIST l @ l0% 92/03/15 - 92/03/21 Q PAGE 480 l Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products}, and rvices
~~ILE LEVELS - DOCKET,~~
) AMIT 1 DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK S7EAM ELECTRIC STATION,C..)g a,,m P. Operating license stage der.uments & correspondence 9106270324 Suppl 4 to Generic Ltr 88-20 to all licensees holding operating licensen & cps for nuclear reactor facilities.re individual plant exam of external events (IPEEE) for severe accident vulnerabilities - 10CFR50.54(f). PARTLOW,J.G. Associate Director for Projects (Post 870411). 91/06/28. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. OR 057. 32pp. 4 8X : 60997 : 001-60997 : 03 2. 9202250311 Suppl 4 to Generic Ltr 89-10 to all licensees of operating nuclear power plants & holders of cps for nuclear power plants re consideration of valve mispositioning in BWRs. PARTLOW,J.G. Associate Director for Projects (Post 870411). 92/02/12. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. GL 89 ' O S4. 4pp. 48X:60997:033-60997:036. '203030209 Generic Ltr 92-02 to all holders of OLs or cps for PWRs 're resolution of Generic Issue 79, "Unanalyzed Reactor Vessel (PWR) Thermal Stress During Natural Convection Cooldown." PARTLOW,J.G. Associate Director for Projects (Post 870411). 92/03/06. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. OR 079. 4pp. 48X:60997:047-60997:050. 9203060147 Rev 1 to generic ltr 92-01 to all holders of operating i licenses or const permits for nuclear power' plants '(except YAE, licensee for Yankee Nuclear Power Station),re reactor vessel structural inDegrity,10CFR50.54(f). PARTLOW,J.G. Associate Director for Projects (Post 870411). 92/03/06. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 12pp. 9203180506 Forwards amend 9 to license NPF-87 & safety evaluation. Amend revises TS 6.2=& 6.5 to reflect organizational & title changes at plant. BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/03/06. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric.Co. (TU Electric). 2pp. 48X 60964:176-60964:192. 4 0 iO y% ,s 5 9 D-2 gh.H15 n
I l UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISETpk1 l () '[ 7' LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST L g 92/03/15 - 92/03/21 {},.] PAGE 481 ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Facilities, Products, and Services E ? )( y * \\*$ ~~~~~~~~~~~ DOCKET 50-445 CCHANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT 1 P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence --9203180507 Amend 9 to license NPF-87, revising TS 6.2 & 6.5 to reflect organizational & title changes at plant. BLACK,S.C. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/03/06.- 13pp. 48X 60964:178-60964:190. --9203180508 Safety evaluation supporting amend 9 to license NPF-37. Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Director (Post 870411). 92/03/06. 2pp. 48X:60964:191-60964:192. 9203160111 Forwards notice of consideration of issuance.of amend & proposed NSEC determination & opportunity for hearing te change to TS to remove ' boron dilution mitigation sys. BERGHAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/03/09. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 2pp. 48X 60919:275-60919:286. --9203160128 Notice of consideration of issuance of amend to license NPF-87_ & proposed NSEC determination & opportunity for hearing te removal of boren dilution mitigation sys from TS. ' BERGMAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/03/09. 10pp. 48X:60919:279-60919:286. 9203180202 Informs that review of rev 84 of QA program descriptien re const & operational quality complete. Changes to QA programs, section 17 of FSAR meet requirements of 10CFR50, app B. BEACH,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/03/12. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 3pp. 48X:60936:294-60936:296. 9203190393 Notification of 920323 meeting w/util in Rockville,MD to discuss reload methodology topical repts-for use on Unit 1. BERGHAN,T.A. Project Directorate IV-2. 92/03/13. BLACK,S.C. Project Directorate IV-2. 3pp. 48X 60976:270-60976:272. i 4 ( <2, \\ % }} rt G s 0-2 5?)(h' lB\\~T
UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION LPDR WEEKLY ACCESSION LIST ...,,-),g/f?% \\ !L - 4\\ 92/03/15 - 92/03/21 NA 482 'ILE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regulated Nuclear Pacilities, Produc(B r.and Services ~ - _.. _ _.. _ _ _... _ _ _.. _ _ _ _ _.. _ _....... _ _.. _ _ _ _. _.... _ _ _.. (. {;, p DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAX STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UN y ,s P. Operating license stage documents & correspondence 9203190298 Responds to request for info related to resolution of Generic Issue 130, " Essential SW Sys Failures at Multi-Unit Sites," per Generic Ltr 91-13. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/16. Document Control Branch (Document Control Desk). OR 130. 4pp. 48X:61060:351-61060:354. Q. Inspection reports,____..._______... __________'.letins & correspondence IE Bu 9202190317 NRC Info Notice 92-016, " Loss of Flow from RHR Pump During Ref ueling Cavity Draindown." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/02/25. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 6pp. 48X:60948:134-60948:139, 202240025 NRC Info Notice 92-018, " Potential for Loss of Remc e Shutdown Capability During Control Room Fire." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Assessment (Post 870411). 92/02/28. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. lipp. 48X:60948:140-60948:150. 9202250331 NRC Info Notice 92-019, " Misapplication of Potter & Brumfield MDR Rotary Relays." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Operational Events Asseasment (Post 370411). 92/03/02. Consoli* dated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 6pp. 48X:60997:037-60997:042. 9202260208 NRC Info Notice 92-020, " Inadequate Local Leak Rate Testing." ROSSI,C.E. Division of Ope:ational Events Assessment (Post 370411). 92/03/03. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc. 4pp. 48X:60997:043-60997:046. g'j [ C'[g'a 9' n ~,L h 1
UNTTED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY CO;8.MISS20N LPDR WIEKLY ACCESSION LIST lg P ({(483 92/03/15 - 92/03/21 (g 2LE LEVELS - DOCKET, Regula ed Nuclear Facilities, Products [)an{ Services .. 3 g t] DOCKET 50-445 COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION, UNIT y O. Inspection reports, IE Bulletins & correspondence 9203160093 Ack receipt of 920214 ltr informing NRC of actions taken to address concern raised in insp repts 50-445/91-68 & 50-446/91-68. Concerns ref significant increase in security inf raction identified during future 1991 refueling outage. BEACR,A.B. Region 4 (Post 820201). 92/03/20. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 4pp. 48X 60906:274-60908:279. R. Periodic operating reports & related correspondence 9203170352 Monthly operating rept for reb 1992 for Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Unit 1.W/920313 ltr. DAVIS,G., CAHILL,W.J., WOODIAN, D.R. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/02/29. Spp. 48X:60981:318-60981:322. . Operator Examinations 9203190250 Requests relief frcm inservice exam requirements. Requirements for exams found in Section XI of ASME Boiler & Pressure Vessel Code.Brief description of attachments listed. CAHILL,W.J. Texas Utilities Electric Co. (TU Electric). 92/03/12. Document Contro? Branch (Decument Control Desk). 20pp. 48X:60998:275-60998:294. n \\'t i O N pg <2"' sFt 3-2 dI)(FiiBf5 e
y.
~~4.,.~~
( ~5 0 -7 L n.- q$\\ "VEg F"* F M t cys, Sw d AA, E#H.IB\\1 H s/-E as 6 o # c-t &70, Her&- sr +-) G L1= S. VJ H &44- ', (0M W U+f ['th l'. S ' O. $. t )M E r ) D v A e v t._ LA4T o d Th4-E wnNT l Pf-Itss A LL i <J "3 J H ArJO bM A C--E 'e 75 Pi ei el. W H Y.' /00 s e e Wisb5 l ug vai r I- -ras eve n ~ C C & TA t M CsJ T &llLL-C L M f> t CAV$ 'C ' TEST lPv/'l.c eF O F' A ? A-C 4 S v t O . V wt r i Co.J TPl~ M L & T. Ev C,,! T f-4.-f 0F~r Co ~rb "D+f-tJ. R ~ <. ? \\d i L.L
~~T~ LI.~~
TE R v.s V'*kT I & t*t* G l* 1) D o b. 6 T H-C PJQ C k r /b s~/ WE b 0 H O k).l.l *' sur5AV46c.A G v s u.Ym oF fico tta J tt E-V o o L4To a ) V \\C K. MhSL4 Aw A N_. s A. > b C-c a b c ~ s w L-FA L s 1 F
~~C 4 -Yr c' >~~
c) F T t it t w ATc.+1 wc(t--*-oAL, PS A 'Jur) oA ?.. P. ~ T E c d Lo (,- $ n o.J F e /_ --rE xa s vTi Li r. l< .m ae wn< b_ s u eutv, s ea sv L <n or ricoccovPe ~ , v i o t A-fi o a j. re o r44.o, z,, e - PEM o -cit 6 Ar-e ry s l j A-c c.P 4.e. s. Q E 46006 140 v'c rF*b By sp yg-fEA dcQ [s
1 C.' l CodfEche Peak mishap investigated Federal officials say malfunction in nuclear cooling system posed no hazard probtein,Mr.Gurnand aafi Srent nuclear fuel conmins em.be smid. Mr. Citt:1mrA said the s+orage By Randy lee Ldtis, A spokemaan for 711 E3ectric of highly radioective meterials. Each pool lacked cooHag for 20 hours %,%, w %,,, DeHas, which owns and operates nuclear plant secres its spent feel ne weser temperature in the poci FM Was are WW ComanchePak,smMthe utultyhas becease the federal government t at ce hanche M made changes in training, supervi-has not bcDt a permanent dwponni rcse ebout 3 degrees but never sp-nuclear power plant this week in slon and the accountsbf1!ty dplant facility for it. Comasche Peek) sole preached a warninglevel,he an w&h a cooung pin fx wt workers since the incident. The completed reactor, Unit 1,has oper-When eperstars learned of the uigits own sted since 19e9 and was refueled for proNess, they switched to enceer noclear fuel was out of service for company is also N d investigation, sold W ~ Dick the first time about seven meeths coonng system ba!!t for the plasti %~ Unit 2 roector,but ths Rmasey. sgo. NRCis, O W M N Mr.. Reactorcyerstors h M part ne plant is near Glen Rose, < a coeUng for- ~ notsisia h opera _N em,, moe. some.em, _ ption 1, r._, ec ene a for ep.-^ Foot wee abut dews for samente.swth 2 a M Wb_ d ~ epokesman Joe On111and. A four-The NRC"ssonder lampecear etCb-m team M MW k @ M W @ syyt Mr. ODIDead sm&d. Det the Mr. Rasasey said the stility gan exarnining_the mishap Prids7 Tuesday in control roosa tadic= tors dM w h eat h soo m e m - w ee-men and will report within 30 days, be. that suggested a problems with the M p also was w working m tWis % wrm coonng d ee spent feel W
~~of a recent pleb'at modifks-the emciniinquiry.~~
WdDe team win examine the plant pool.)fr.Gilinand sold.De poolis. r.aff'r a,W faDure to foucw a lay water 41Ded vet where as-A g procedures anif Anattentionby reno-clear fue1rodsarestoredaher ther control rocat' staff, as weH se are resnoesd frogLtha_remeser esse-7 g j,,an,o.e, m ee.a w w.e_ m h g r m A N x m ^ O T i gj ,O ^ M m -^ ril b h 9 9
a UNITED STMES ~ DN [E \\ NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMis3> Office of Governmental and Public Affaire, M5010N'lV %,,g/ 611 Ryan Plate Drive, Sults 1000, 4tpg)lyg11 1 -m. r-2 i : TOR IMMEDIATC. RELEASE RIV: 92+36 15,1992) (Friday,May$gq}g6 Joe Gilliland
~~Contact:~~
Telephone: 817/06tr 8128 (Office) $pECIAL INSPECTION CHEONG CIRCUHSTANCCS OF SPENT TUEL p0OL COOLING 7 WM13N AT COMANCHE PEAK UNIT,1 The Nuclear Regulatory Commission regional office in Arlington, Tex s, ' to review the circumstances of an has f ormed a special inspecuon tet. interruption in spe~ tuel pool cooling earlier this, week at Unit 1 of the i Comanche peak Steam 7,lectric Mation near Glen Rose, Texas. This incident post 6 no safety hazard to the general public or plant NRC's areas of concern personnel, o 1 did not affect the plant's operation.111ure to follow )rocedurest the interface between Uni t include a. apparent ationni, and Unit 2, witch is not yet licensed to operatel which ,utor inattentiveness to some control room instrumental and-par t. b design modifications.,0f how TV Clectric trains its operators a out l 7tair, jects This matter came to light on May 12 after the NRC senior resident ' inspector, finding some discrepancies in control room indicators, raised' This pool is und questions about the cooling of the Unit 1 spent fuel pool. for underwater storage of spent fuel assemblies removed from the reactor co re during refueling. Comancho Peak Unit 1 completed its first refueling about \\ seven months ago, Investigation by 10 E1octric revealed that the heat exchanger which normally serves the spent fuel pool cooling system was out of service for Another heat exchanger was being used, but -- unknown to a' r maintenanco. reactor operator - that host excunger was not being supplied with component As a result, the sptnt cooling water because of a recent plant modification. fuel pool lacked cooling for 20 hours. The pool temperature rose five degtlees during that time, but temperatures remained far below the temperature limii'. Aftor TU Icarned of this situation, it began using the Unit 2 comp'on9nt' cooling water system to remove heat from the Unit 1 spent fuel pool coolling But NRC raised further questions about that action because the Unit 2 system. system involved has not yet been evaluated and accepted for operational tise. 1he normal Unit I spent fuel pool cooling system is now back in operation.' The four member NRC inspection team, which is beginning work tods (Triday Hay 16), is expected to conclude its duties on site within abodt a week. A report will be issued within 30 days. (Tl g G F-2 exsian j
p k G EX HIBd I -me 1 w,/f*i,'N. ~ .-...-...--..r-.~...--. i'J fff,el,
~~p...~~
~~u m m 4 3 )f d y,["I'~~
~~7 ir~~
~~' ~ v,o.#. 34 oy.pgp ~ ";? utm* y:v y a, q-~~
~
~~7 L r c - l l*:?ct-1 1 ][i 37 y Sg g~~
~~2. m A R,6 "E~~
S
i
~~[g 4, 005 -~~
~~.o000 _.~~
~~es coa. m - ..m,,,,,ooo,a EE-u L tt gg s,,s if H il fi *** ,,,g f,fff y 1 a k,I V.a '~~~
~~.,- c 9.s.g.~~
,. ng n; 7.- ~. ' yns W Sy rf ' r ,y The public is rapidly gaining confidence in the Nuclear Energy Program, largely, in part, to the efforts of tompetant, trained, alert personnel,,,, g \\TIO/Vgg 9 e G NXHIB6 .._._.-__.m_- _ _ _ _ _
e ,< 4. *. n /,.., I' 1 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION iT I ONg. UNITED STATES o, q wAsamorow. o. c. roess g U ', t _.H DHlB\\T Dottet f(os. 00-4% and 50-446 Mr. Villim J, cahill, Jr. Executive Vice President., *citar Twas Ut.t11 ties Elect.r c Company 400 No. 011Ve Etteet., L. B. 81 Dalhs,Tepas 75231
~~Dear tir,~~
C%hilh SuB$CT:- REQWST foR At>DIUOMAL lr#F0WiATIor/ REI.ATED TV PLANT STAFF E#tJtTENCE (TAC #0. It00(cy) staff bits Teviewe<A tk trifor,ptieri you sarittee;by tetter dat %C.ber 26,f the Geognche Peak StenM Electric Station (CPSES) ISBS Wt th Ye9ct to hot cpating eXperterice for'cer,t Octo posit.ichs owe find We Y)eed more informat.ior) to deterintne sf you' meet 't'hV .s ta ff. coppitwnt for hot e,peratirs O(pertence, dapc4, bed, tri Ar letter sifi 7$nr ch 16, 1966. -Th i s l a t.tay S t3te s "... p r i oY to f u e l l oa d i ng, i n b o th plants. Texas Uttitt.ies will havs'an SRO licensed shift supervisor on each shift who has had ai least siX months of hot operating experience on a Kaze type pl3nt, h addition, both the shif t supervisor and as-alttant shift supervisor Will laYe. hac st \\ east six Weeks of hot operating exper'tence at t.cWer ley.els great.er thart 20%- of full pcWer, and each supervisor will have had startup and shutdown experience'. YoVr. letter of October 26,1989 describes the experance of eight itdtvikals with respect to the six icnths of hot operattig eAperience on a same type phnt, but did not provibe information re33rdir3 the shif t. superYteers' startap 2nd. shutdown experience or the slA wt.ek5 of hot cperatig e)certe#per at poter levels. greater tfen 2CT, of full pcVer for tre remaining sh tft. supervisors anc unit supervisors. In order for-the stuff to complete JTs revicW, pinte, provide the following inforwation by Decemoer Q.1899: (.1) % names and. positiens, correhrted viith the dates, plants, ancIndiv vinals ' power level (.59, showing the experteisce for the 1ddit, torr 1 that are recuired to have had at least sif WeKs of het operat143 experience at power levels greater th'an 20% of full poker, and. (2) The nanes,' dates, wd. sower chnts at which the. shift supervise rs behad startup ard.shutdcwr. experante. pTIONegG 9 H $8% mL@ EXHIB\\T L
f,, !* 9 ;... Decentier 16, 1989 g \\TIO/Vggs k M vr. n: ham J. Cahi11, Jr.,# H i ?.e reporting requireernts con {sined in this letter af fect iewer than 10 respondentst therefore, OMB clearance is not required under P. L.-96p]ts is c e, ly. l 5'ncere (original sinned by) Christopher 1. Grises, Director r.omanche Feak Project Division Office of Nuclear Reactor Pegulat, ion cc: Sec next page DISTRlbl/110_N 00CET F1kr-NRC PDR Local PDR ADSP Reading CPPD Reading DCrutchfield 1Guay (Grimes JLyons RWarnick JHWilson malley MFtelds JRoe+ CThomas TGocy MCaruso f A11enspach CVanDenburgh JPartlov [Joraan BGrimes ACRS(10) b D:CPPD:N ~ D: AD:CPP RR PQEB ' W. alloy :cr. -JHWile T-TGod C ClGrir.e s =* I?/H/89 12/f/ 12/;rje9) 1246/e9 t - 4%\\110/Qge s 4 H g + (- F ENHIB6 u i k r a #- _ p --
?[* 6 ....,..'o UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 1\\ Og [ *',, I wuMOTON. D. C. 205b8 S* 7, Q l H 5%HIB\\T Doch:t Nos. 50-W and 50446 Mr. Villism J, t1 hill, Jr. Executive Vnct Presiderit.. IWelent Taras Ut111 ties Elect.ric Ceapany 100 No. 011Vt. Etyest., L. B. 81 DalIas Te#as 7K231 s Cur Mr. C'abillt _ g P.EQMST TCR. Ab01110n' L MFCAthATIod RELATIO TD A 5utJECT:- PLAhT staff E)(ffSJfXCE (TAC #0. R0044f) staff hits tevte.wed the ihf tisei ysu subitted;by leiter da't "Tbt, ber 2fe,f th Octu 131iLT vith Yespect to of operating experience for'cer.t e Com1:nche, taak. Steng Electric Station (CPSES)' plant postt, ions o I We find We %eed more informat.ior) to deterintne sf p(u' pieet t'h'ei 4taff.tsent for bot c.per&WS c(Perishee. dapcobed in tv etter of". 16,1966. -This let.teY states "... prior to fue loading, -in both PjaT pitets, Texas littitt.ies will havs1m SRO licensed shift supervisor on each shift who has had ai least.stX months of hot operating experience on a game type plarit. 2 addition, t>oth the shif t supe visor and as-41stant shift superVf ser '4111 laYe. had st least si)( Week of hot operating experience at poAr ley.els greabr than 20% of full pcWer, and ench supervisor will have had startup and shutdown experience". Yontr. letier of October 26,1989 describes the exper nehce of eight ind1vidipls witn respect to the six Enths of het operattrg eAperience on a same type yhnt, but did not provibe infonnation re33rdir3 the shif t. staperYtders' startap trd. shutdown experience. or the six dets of hot cperating per t ence at poser levels. greater ihn 20% of full pcWer for tre remaining s tft.- superWsors anc unit supervisors. In orcer for the stuff to comp)ete (Ts revieV, ple'are, provide the following infoncation by Decemoer 23. 1399: + ()) The names anOpositicqs, correitted With the datas, plants, and power level (.59, shcwf ag the expertence forthe addit,lerini Indtyvkuals ' that are requirM to have had at-least tiy treeks of heT, operatteg experience at power levels greater th3n 20% of fu.ll peker, 3rst (2) The name s,' date s, WA. power p hnt5 a t whi ch t.hs. shi Ft utipe rv ise r.s hwE.had starTQ 4ed.shutdcwr, expc.rleesc.. j T10Qg H ppcoMh ENHIB\\T P
) 4. '/ r u a n UNITED STATES OF AMERICA h5fC NOCLEAR REOULATORY COMMISSION i COMMISSIONERS: 32 MH -7 P3 :23 Ivan Selin, Chairman Kenneth C. Rogers [. bb-C James R. Curtiss {])5kyf Forrest J. Remick E. Gail de Planque j 0 In The Matter of: 0 0 TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC COMPANY l Docket Nos. 50-445-OL i 50-446-OL (Comanche Peak Steam Electric 5 50-445-CPA Station, Units 1 and 2) Q 0 APPLICATION TO THE SECRETARY FOR HEARINGS. AND ORAL ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR LEAVE l TO INTERVENE OUT-OF-TIME AND MOTION TO REOPEN THE RECORD SUBMITTED BY SANDRA LONG DOW dba DISPOSABLE WORKERS OF COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC STATION AND R. MICKY DOW TO THE SECRETARY OF THE U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION: Comes now Sandra Long Dow dba Disposable Workers of; Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, and R. Micky Dow,-and file this, their Appli-cation To The Secretary For Hearings'And oral Argument In Support Of Motion For Leave To Intervene Out-Of-Time and Motion-To Reopen The Record Submitted By Sandra Long Dow dba Disposable Workers Of-Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, And R. Micky Dow, and for cause would show, that, BASIS FOR MOTION Applicants currently have pending before the Commission their l-Motion For Leave To Intervene Out-of-Time,,and their Motion.To Reopen The Record, with regard to_the above-styled and! numbered matter. 10 C.F.R. $2.772-states, in part-"When briefs, motions or.~other l .Lare submitted to the Commission-itself,... the Secre-papers. APPLICATION TO THE SECRETARY FOR HEARINOS. 9204140021'92 IO6 ADOCK05000gg5 )30 gy - l DR,
i a' 'e (is) authorized to. (j) Refer to the Atomic Safety and tary requests for hehrings not falling under Licensing Board Panel Q2.104 of this part, where the requester is entitled to further pro- "; and the only part of 02.104 which is applicable in ceedings. this case would be (a) In the case of an application which the commission finds that a hearing is required in the public interest. ,.which places the power to grant hearings, for almost any manoner of application, motion, and/or appeal, squarely in the hands of the Commission, and, in this case, the Secretary, directly. More importantly, 10 C.F.R. 02.7S3 shows that "In its discretion the Commission may allow oral argument upon the request of a party made in a notice of appeal or brief, or upon its own initiative.", and while, specifically, these are motions, and not notices of appeal, or briefs, it would seem to be obvious that the pleadings presently be-fore the Commission are, at least, or could be viewed, at the discre-tion of the Commission as appeals of earlier attempts at the same process with the same goal in mind. That it would be in the best in-terest of the public to hold oral argument is self-evident. ARGUMENTS 1. Responsive Pleadings To Motion Wrought With Inaccuracies. There have been two responsive pleadings, the first by the licen-cee, and the second by the " staff", to the pleadings of these applic-ants. They are both ambiguous and convolutant, to the point of being ludicrous. They fail, completely, to address the actual situation at hand, and stray into areas of vagueness and incongruency; are rift with material false statements, and some areas that border if not completely encompass perjury. APPLICATION TO THE SECRETARY FOR HEARINGS....
o-The Secretary is respectfully reminded to review the previous mo-tion filed by these applicants to reopen the record, and the " staff's" response to it. The licencee's position was completely rejected by the " staff", and, more importantly, the " quasi" attempt at intervention by Juanita Ellis, and her organization Citizens Association For Sound En-ergy, was a poorly covered attempt to try ci.N - matters before tne Com-mission, and dotermined to be immaterial t, the matter at hand. The responsive pleading filed by the licensee can be summed up in much the same manner as the intervention of C.A.S.E., in-that what the licensse is basically saying is "Come On, We told you guys everything was o.k. at Comanche Peak, Disposable Workers and Micky Dow are picking-on us, make them leave us alone!", and the questions the Commission should be asking itself is that, if this were, in-fact, true; then why do Disposable Workers, and Micky Dow, keep coming back, with more ex-tensive pleadings, more substantiation, more witnesses, and yet_their direction has never changed? Why, why, does the licensee, and the " staff" not want the record reopened, why do they not want this matter reexamined? ,2. Credability Challenged Of Winesses Whose Credability is Established. If it is true that the testimony of Dobie Hatley, Ron-Jones, and' others is too old. If it is true that everything'they might conceiva-bly testify to has already been identified and corrected--then why, WHY vere each of these individuals, and several others, who will also-come forward, paid sums of approximately FIVE HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS APIECE, NOT FOR THEIR PAIN AND SUFFERING, NOT FOR THE END OF THEIR CA-REERS, NOT FOR THE END OF THEIR LIVES, AS THEY KNEW THEM, BUT SPECIF-ICALLY NOT TO TESTIFY, NOW OR EVER, BEFORE THE ASLB OR ANY OTHER COURT, APPLICATION TO THE SECRETARY FOR' REARING 1... o NOT TO EVER INITI ATE ANY LITIGATION, AND NOT TO ASSIST IN ANY MANNER OF LITIGATION, AND MOST IMPORTANT OF ALL, IF THEY WERE EVER REQUESTED TO DO SO, TO IMMEDIATELY NOTIFY BROWN & ROOT-AND/OR TU ELECTRIC, AND TO RESIST ANY MANNER OF SUBPOENA 7
~~3. WilAT ABOUT DOW SUBPOENA, AND WHY WAS WILKINSON FIRED.~~
Both the licensee and the " staff" argue that the " staff" has come to the conclusion that applicant Micky Dow does not have any material of consequence based on a letter written to him by Chairman Selin,-yet they fail to set out how they reached that conclusion without examin-ing any evidence. The " staff" issued a subpoena duces tecum, served it in the middle of the night, threatened enforcement proceedings which-would mean finaacial penalty, jail, or both, attempted to negotiate financial agreements to pay for the transcriptions of 16 reels of audio tape; and, yet, when applicant Micky Dow steadfastly refused to turn the materials over carte' blanche, but agreed to surrender them if he were present during the transcription process, the staff suddenly, without any manner of support for their move, announced that becauce Mr. Dow would not carte blanche release his materials it was therefor determined that he had none and the subpoena was dropped, yet Mr. Ste-phen Comley had been fined several hundred thousand dollars, is now facing enforcement proceedings which will jail him, for only alleging that he MIGHT have some tape recordings; and, even yet more curious, Yvonne Wilkinson vas threatened with termination at CPSES if she did l not turn these same tapes over to the applicant, and when she said she could not as-they were in the possession of Mr. Dow, SHE WAS TERMIN-ATED FOR THEFT of those tapes, yet the licensee has never filed a theft report with any law enforcement agency, nor have they contested APPLICATION TO THE SECRETARY POR HEARINGS.
I the unemployment claim of Mrs. Wilkinson, and continue to bar her from seeking employment at CPSES because of a theft she never committed. This one item, alone, is sufficient to cause a reasonable doubt as to the viability, the accuracy, and the overall honesty of not on-ly the prior proceedings, but the attempts to deny the current motions.
~~5. The Public Has A Definite Interest In Holding Hearings.~~
The entire Comanche Peak affair has gone on entirely too long, and still holds many unanswered questions. The press and varied med-ia coverage still continues, still in the same doubtful, questioning vein, and the public still continues to ask questions about the safe-ty of this facility. By holding hearings, creating a record, allowing testimony, on the viability of applicants' motion to reopen this rec-cord, these matters could be laid to rest once and for all. CONCLUSIONS The record of this affair is one of the longest in the history of this industry, and allegations of unsafe conditions, improprieties, untruths, mismanagement, and imminent disaster still prevail. People who have been silent for a period, in some cases, of ten years or more out of fear for their lives and the safety of thier families and fu-ture, that were denied the opportunity to testify at the first hear-ings, and still believe this plant to be unsafe, are now prepared to come forvard and give that testimony. For the Commission to vote on the present pleadings before it would constitute the biggest misscarriage of justice in the history of this Commission. To allow two pleadings that are designed to miss-direct the attention of this Commission with their material false statements and poorly misdirected reasonings is a travesty. APPLICATION TO THE SECRETARY FOR HEARINGS.... 1 l
Applicants, herein, could easily move for the opportunity to res-pond to these ansvers in writing, but that attempt would also be lud-icrous in that it would only serve _tio pile yet more paperwork ~ into the files of this matter and confuse the Commission yet further. To provide an open forum, with the ability to call and question witnesses will preclude further inundation of this record. Material false, statements cannot survive in the open forum, neither vill per-jury when the oath is taken. Litigants cannot stray from the issues whet. there is an immediate ruling available from those presiding. Most importantly, this motion vill succeed or fail upon the dir-ect presentation of the litigants, in full view of the public and the record, and the ghosts of the past will be determined to be just that, ghosts, or spectres of the future. WilEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, in the interests of justice, and, in the interests of the public velfare and knowledge, these applicants formally request the Secretary grant them hearings on their Motion For Leave To Intervene Out-Of-Time, and their Motion To Reopen.The Record, allowing them to argue their motion before the Atomic Safety Licensing Board, and for such other and further relief to which they may show themselves to be justly entitled. Respectfully submitted, 0%)W1 SA8DRA LONG DOW dba DQ)POSABLE WORKERS OF COMANCHE PEAK STEAM ELECTRIC-STATION, pro se 322 Mall Blvd. #147 Monroeville, Pa. 15146 (e12) 856-7843 APPLICATION TO THE SECRETARY FOR HEARINGS....
45 4 b$ 322 Mall Blvd.j#147_ R. MICKY DOW Monroeville, Pa. 15146 (412) 856-7843 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE This is to certify that a true and correct copy the foregoing was sent to all parties to this action listed below, _y courier, on this the 6th day of April, 1992. \\ .'% L }' Affiant United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Offices of Ivan Selin, Chairman 11555 Rock Pike Rockville, Maryland 20852 Janice Moore, Esquire Bill Stryker Office of the General Counsel Office of the Inspector General U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission-11555 Rock Pike 11555 Rock Pike Rockville, Maryland 20852 Rockville, Maryland 20852 George L. Edgar,-Esquire Dan M. Berkovitz Newman & Holtzinger, P.C. Senate Office Building 1615 L Street, N.W., Suite 1000 1st St.-&~ Constitution Ave. Washington, D.C. 20036 Washington, D.C. 20510 Juanita Ellis, President Citizens Association for Sound Energy 1426 South Polk Street Dallas, Texas 75224 Charles A. Mullins, Esquire Office of the General Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 11555 Rock Pike Rockville, Maryland 20852
ej3/63 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 'N NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION COMMISSIONERS: Ivan Selin, Chairman Kenneth C. Rogers ?Y.. ~, .;1s J ' James R. Curtiss Forrest J. Remick E. Gail de Planque 8ERWD U 1 2 S2 l AS ) In the Matter of: ) ) Docket 'flos. 50-445-0i. TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC ) 50-446-OL COMPANY, et al. ) 50-445-CPA ) (Comanche Peak Steam Electric ) Station, Units 1 and 2) ) ) MEMORANDUM AND ORDER CLI-92 _1_2
~~1. Introduction.~~
This matter is before the Commission on a motion for late intervention and a motion to reopen the record by Sandra Long Dow, representing the " Disposable Workers of-Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station" (" Disposable Workers"), and R. Micky Dow (collectively " petitioners"). Petitioners seek to reopen the Comanche Peak operating license and construction permit-amendment proceedings which were closed pursuant to a. settlement agreement in 1988. Petitioners have also filed a motion seeking oral argument on their motions before the Commission. The Texas Utilities Electric Company ("TU Electric") and the NRC Staff oppose all three requests. For the reasons stated below, we find that oral argument is unnecessary in this situation. We also find that petitioners have failed to satisfy-the requirements for late intervention. Even assuming arauendo that those 9208180161 920812 gDR.ADOCK 0500 5.. (; M'
s 4 requirements were satisfied, petitioners have failed to satisfy the requirements to reopen the record. II. Backaround. On November 20, 1991, these same petitioners filed a motion to reopen the record in the underlying Comanche Peak proceedings. We denied-their request, pointing out that only a " party" could seek to reopen the record but that even if petitioners had been " parties'"lo the underlying proceedings, their submissions were not sufficient to meet the reopening criteria. Texal Utilities Electric Co. (Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2), CLI-92-01, 35 NRC 1 ("CLI-92-Ol"). However, we also pointed out that "because the NRC has not yet issued the license for Unit 2, there remains in existence an operating license ' proceeding' that was initiated for Comanche Peak...." Sig CL1-92-01, 35 NRC at 6, n.5. On February 20, 1992, petitioners filed a petition for late -intervention not only in the Unit 2 operating license ("0L") proceeding but also in both the Unit 1 OL proceeding and the Unit I construction permit amendment ("CPA") proceeding. Neither of the latter proceedings now exists. On February.21,- 1991, petitioners filed a motion to reopen the record in all three proceedings, assuming arauendo that they had satisfied the criteria for late intervention. We directed that both the Staff and TV Electric file consolidated responses to the two motions and established a response time which took into account an anticipated supplement to the petitioners' motions. Petitioners filed their supplement-on March 13, 1991. Both-TV Electric and the Staff responded in opposition _ to the two pleadings as supplemented. 2
=. 2 h On April 4.-1992, petitioners filed a motion requesting an oral argument on the other two motions, alleging " material false statements" and " perjury" by the Staff and TU Electric in their responses to petitioners' motions. TV Electric and the Staff have responded in opposition to the request for oral argument. III. Analysis. A. The Unit 1 Proceedinas. Initially, petitioners have disregarded our statement in CLI-92-01 that - only the proceeding for the issuance of the operating license for Unit 2 was available for late intervention and potential reopening. Instead, petitioners seek late intervention in-both the Unit 1 OL and CPA proceedings. However, these proceedings are no longer available to them. The NRC has issued the operating license for Unit 1. That action has closed out.the Notice of Opportunity for a Hearing for both the Unit 1 operating license, 44 Fed. Reg. 6995 (Feb 5, 1979), and the Unit I construction permit amendment. 51 Fed. Reg. 10480 (Mar. 26, 1986). Any challenge to the Unit I license must take the form of a petition under 10 C.F.R. 52.206 for an order under 10 C.F.R.12.202. In fact, petitioners have already filed such a petition which is now under. consideration by the Staff.- Thus, we summarily reject petitioners' request insofar as it requests late intervention in the Unit 1 OL and CPA proceedings. B. The Unit 2 Proceedina. (- 1. The Motion For Oral Aroument. l-. l We are unclear as to what petitioners actually seek in their request for i oral argument. Petitioners use the terms " oral argument" and _" hearings" l: 3 t
= 4 i 4 interchangeably in their. motion. Under our regulations, the terms' clearly-- imply different concepts. " Oral argument" as contemplated by.our regulations is an appellate-style argument; without witnesses. However, under NRC regulations the word " hearings" generally refers.to an evidentiary procedure, which is what petitioners' original motion seeks.- Accordingly, we have treated petitioners' request as a request for oral argument'on the motion for late interve'ition and the motion to reopen the record. Our regulations provide that "[i]n its discretion, the Commission may allow oral argument upon the request of a party made in the notice of appeal or brief, or'upon Its own initiative." 10 C.F.R. 52.763.- Because oral argument-is clearly " discretionary," we have previously _ held that a party seeking oral argument must explain "how (oral argument] would assist us in reaching a decision." In re Joseoh J. Macktal, CLI-89-12, 30 NRC 19, 23 n.1 (1989). We have denied requests for oral argument when " based on (written] submissions (the Commission] fully understands the positions-of the' participants and has sufficient information upon which to-base its decision." Advanced Nuclear Fuels Corooration'(Import of South African Enriched Uranium Hexaflouride), CLI-87-9, 26'NRC 109,- 112 (1987). Petitioners make two_ arguments in support of their request.' First, l-they allege that responses-filed by the Staff and the licensee to.their - motions are." wrought with inaccuracies." Request'at 2.2 _In addition, l ' Petitioners include:other arguments, but in' our judgmentthese arguments _ ~ go to their requests-for late intervention and to reopen the record. c L Accordingly, we will deal with these.other arguments when we address the - merits of petitioners' motions now pending. 4 2Petitioners filed two: pleadings -before u's entitled " Motion. for....." _In p order to develop a convenient shorthand to distinguish between these two l-pleadings when' citing to them, we will refer to the Motion for Oral Argument. as the " Request" and the Motion to Reopen the Record.as the'" Motion." 4 ~ ~., -, -n,
petitioners allege that the responses are " rift (sic) with material false statements... that border if not completely encompass perjury." M.3 However, petitioners do not provide any examples of these alleged statements. We will not accept bare allegations of such statements -- without more -- as support for a motion for agency action. Moreover, as the petitioners concede -- Request at 6 -- they could seek permission to reply to these pleadings in writing. Contrary to petitioners' view, we do not believe that such a reply fo'uld " inundate" the record or " confuse" us. M. Thus, petitioners have failed to demonstrate that they could not counter any alleged misstatements by the Staff and licensee by seeking leave to file a reply and responding to the alleged misstatements in writing. Second, petitioners argue that "it would be in the best interest of the public to hold oral argument...." Request at 2. M ALu Request at 5. However, we do not see how the public interest would be better served in this instance with an oral argument as opposed to a decision based solely upon the written public record. In sum, we believe that we " understand the positions of the participants and [have) sufficient information upon which'to base [our) decision." Advanced Nuclear Fuels Corocration, suora. Accordingly, we exercise our discretion to deny the request for oral argument.' 3Because petitioners' pleading contains this allegation, it has been forwarded to the Office of Inspector General-for appropriate action. 'We reject the Staff's argument that petitioners cannot request oral argument on a petition for late intervention. Because the pleadings before us do not constitute an " appeal," the requirement that a request for oral argument be made in a "brief" does not apply. M oenerally 10 C.F.R. 52.763. 5 l
.O + 2. The Motion For Late Intervention. Petitioners can seek late intervention in the Unit 2-OL proceeding. That proceeding is still open for late intervention because that license has not been issued. However, in addition to the criteria that must be addressed in their petition under 10 C.F.R. 52.714(a)(2), petitioners must also demonstrate that a balancing of the five criteria set forth in 10 C.F.R. 52.714(a)(1)(i)-(v) weighs in favor of their intervention. Sag, gig.. Metrooolitan Edison Co. (Three Mile Island'kuclear Station, Unit 1), CLI 25,18 NRC 327, 331 n.3. (1983); Texas Utilities-Electric Co. (Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2), CLI-88-12, 28 NRC 605, 608-09 (1988) ("CLI-88-12"), aff'd, Citizens for Fair Utility Reculation v. NRC, 898 F.2d 51-(5th Cir.1990), atti, denied,111 S.Ct. 246 (1990). Those five factors are: (1) good cause, if any, for failure to file on time; (2) the availability of other means for protecting petitioners' interest; (3) the extent to which petitioners' participation might reasonably assist in developing a sound-record; (4) the extent to which petitioners' interest will be represented by existing parties; and (5) the extent to which petitioners' participation.will broaden the issues or delay the proceeding. 10 C.F.R. 52.714(a)(1)(1)-(v)'. Reviewing petitioners' Motion for Late Intervention, we find that petitioners have failed to satisfy these five criteria. a. Good Cause For late Intervention. Petitioners allege that they have good cause for the lateness of their filing because [pjetitioners were not involved in this issue when.it first came to light, and/or when the original-licensing hearings were in session. They only became involved in'this matter in January,-1991. [ Subsequently) they received more and more information ... and, then, based on vast portions of their l i 6
evidence, became convinced that the hearings needed-to be_ reopened in order to get this material on the-record, as they believed that it would have-prevented the licensing (of Comanche Peak], had it been brought to the attention of the original Atomic Safety (and) Licensing Board. Petition at 1-2. In essence, petitioners allege that they have demonstrated " good cause" because they themselves have just come into possession of information which they believe would have had an impact on the Comanche Peak licensing proceeding. However, our jurisprudence has specifically held that such an allegation standing alone does not satisfy the " good cause" requirement. The test for " good cause" is not simply when the petitioners became aware of the material they seek to introduce into evidence. Instead, the test is when the information became available and when petitioners reasonably should have become aware of that information.- In essence, not only must the petitioner have acted promptly after learning of the new information, but the information itself must be nnf information, not information already in the public domain. For example, the discovery of information which was publicly available six months prior to the date of the petition has been held insufficient-to establish " good cause" for late intervention. Detroit Edison Co. (Enrico Fermi Atomic Power Plant, Unit 2),'ALAB-707, 16 NRC 1760, 1764-65 (1982). in that case, the Appeal Board rejected the concept that the " discovery" of-information already publicly available would constitute " good cause" for late intervention. Quite simply, [a] subjective test of this kind provides an incentive for remaining uninformed and creates the prospect of collateral factual-contests aimed at ascertaining the-state' of mind of the prospective intervenor. We would not allow a party to the proceeding to press a newly 7
recognized contention... unless the party could satisfy an objective test of good cause. Among other things,... the party seeking to reopen must show that the issue it now seeks to raise could not have been raised earlier.... We see no reason to employ a different and more lenient good caut.e standard for the late petitioner for intervention than for a party who is already in the proceeding and seeks to raise new issues. ALAB-707,16 NRC at 1765 (emphasis in original) (citation omitted) (footnote omitted). In this case, petitioners may have onT9 recently 'become aware of certain information, but they do not demonstrate that this information is only now available for the first time, i.e., could not have been raised earlier. Instead, the information petitioners seek to introduce is extremely dated information. For example, all information relied on by petitioners in their previous motion to reopen (filed on November 20,1991) was over a year old at the time and all but two documents had been in the public domain for.a much longer period of time. Egg CLI-92-01, 35 NRC at 7-9. Thus, that information cannot constitute " good cause" for late intervention. In their request for late intervention, petitioner: name two individuals, Ron Jones and Dobie Hatley, who would be prospective witnesses if l petitioners were allowed to intervene. Egg Petition at 3.5 Petitioners claim that "[t]hese two individuals who... have held their silence, out of fear of reprisal, are now willing to come forward and testify, for the first l l ' time in four years." id. However, as the Staff points out, both persons 1 claim thtt they were willing to testify in the original proceeding. -Sig Jones Statement attached to Petition; Hatley Statement attached to Motion to Reopen. 5As the Staff notes, this--is the only substantive information in the l petition itself to support petitioner's request. Moreover, as the Staff also notes, Mr. Hatley's statement is neither notarized nor made under odh. 8 l l
1 Staff Response at 9. In fact, as the Staff also points out, Ms. Hatley's-testimony was actually filed before the Licensing Board in 1984 by the intervenor in that proceeding, the Citizens Association for Sound Energy (" CASE"). M. Thus, the mere availability of these individuals does not constitute " good cause" for petitioners' late intervention. Furthermore, neither of these individuals states what new information they have to provide that is not already in the public domain. In an effort to provide petitioners whh a complete evaluation of the information they allege supports their late intervention, we have also reviewed the allegations contained in their Motion to Reopen the Record, the Supplement, and the Motion for Oral Argument. However, the information in those documents does not constitute " newly discovered" information which would support a finding of " good cause" for late intervention. In the Motion to Reopen the Record, petitioners allege that_TV Electric attempted to cover-up fire watch violations. Motion at 4. However, TV Electric itself reported those violations to the NRC in October of 1990. M NRC Response at 24; see also Affidavit of Amarjit Singh, Exhibit B to NRC Staff Response. The Staff issued a Notice of Violation on the issue. Jea e Exhibit C to NRC Staff Response. Thus, not only was the NRC aware of the issue, but the NRC has reviewed TV Electric's resolution of the ~ issue and has approved it. M Singh Affidavit, suora. Petitioners do not offer any additional information on this issue that could constitute " good cause" for-late intervention. Petitioners also allege that they have discovered evidence about "on-site and off-site waste dumps for both toxic.and radiation contaminated materials...." Motion at 4. However, petitioners concede that various 9
organizations have had access to this information since August, 1990, including CASE and the Texas Water Commission ("TWC"), an agency of the State of Texas. Moreover, another organization, the Citizens for Fair Utility Regulation (CFUR") has already presented this issue to the NRC in the form of a request for enforcement action under 10 C,F.R. 52.206. In Texas Utilities Electric Co. (Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2), D0-91-04, 34 NRC 201 (1991). In its decision on that petition, the NRC Staff reviewed this information and determined that (1) th'e"information did not raise a " substantial concern... regarding the safe operation of (Comanche Peak)," (2) that no violations of NRC regulations had been identified, and (3) that the NRC Staff would monitor proceedings before the TWC to determine if any other action was necessary after conclusion of those proceedings. 34 NRC at 207. Petitior,ers do not explain how their information could supp. ment the information already in the public domain or why it could not have been presented sooner.' Next, petitioners submit nine Non-Conformance Reports ("NCR") which they allege "show significant errors in the seismic restraint compression fitting crimps...." Motion at 3. However, these NCRs were filed and resolved in 1984. Petitioners do not explain why this issue could not have been raised 1 sooner. Petitioners also allege that other NCRs "were never placed in the l l record or addressed." M. However, petitioners do not provide these NCRs l l ' Petitioners also allege that.they have taken samples from these dumps and that these samples have been tested as radioactive. Motion at 5. In addition, petitioners allege that they offered to provide this material to the Region IV Staff but that the Staff refused to accept the information or even to open an allegation file on the issue. M. The. Staff has not responded to L this allegation other than to point out -- correctly -- that petitioners have not provided any documentation of these tests. Staff Response at 25-26. However, the Staff should contact petitioners to see if documentation exists and take appropriate follow-up action. l 10 l L
which were allegedly " withheld" or offer any other specifics about them. Absent such an explanation, these vague allegations cannot constitute " good cause" for late intervention. In their Supplement, petitioners allege that Ms. Hatley altered the records in TV Electric's files regarding the NCRs and that the NRC cannot rely on those written records for an analysis of the NCRs. Supplement at 4. However, the NCRs were resolved after Ms. Hatley left Comanche Peak.- Igg NRC ing alig Aff' davit of Robert M. Latta, Staff Response at 26-27, 32-33; i attached as Exhibit F to the Staff Response. Thus, it appears that Ms. Hatley could not have affected the resolution of these NCRs and, accordingly, this information does not constitute " good cause" for late intervention.7 Next, petitioners submit an anonymous handwritten note' dated January 30, 1992 regarding an incident at Comanche Peak in which a worker was injured. However, the note itself documents that the incident was reported to the NRC. Moreover, that incident, which occurred on October 6,1991, has long been public knowledge and has been resolved by the NRC. Egg Affidavit of William D. Johnson, attached as Exhibit E to the NRC Staff Response. Again, this does not constitute "new" information which would constitute " good cause" for late intervention. Finally, petitioners submit a group of documents that appear to be related to claims by Joseph J. Macktal regarding a disputed settlement-7Ms. Hatley alleges that she "was asked to falsify records and documents and drawing numbers etc in order to pass audits of the NRC(,]" Hatley Statement at 1, implying that she did so. She also states that she "would like to testify and have my concerns in the record...." M. We direct the Staff to communicate with Ms. Hatley in an effort to obtain whatever additional information she wishes to present. Ms. Hatley can " place her concerns on the record" by providing documents to or meeting with the NRC Staff. The Staff should follow up on any allegations provided by Ms. Hatley in this regard. 11
agreement. However, there is no showing that these documents are "new." In fact, many of these same documents were also submitted to the NRC as attachments to petitioners' November 20, 1991 Motion to Reopen the Record. As we noted then, this "information is simply not timely in any sense of the word." CL1-92-01, 35 NRC at 8. For example, in this group of documents only the legal memorandum is less than two and a half years old. Moreover, there is no showing that any of this information is not already well known. In fact, Mr. Macktal's"$1 aims have been well-documented before the NRC, as reflected by the fact that many of the documents cited by petitioners are NRC' documents. In addition, the Commission reviewed Mr. Macktal's claims as they related to Comanche Peak. Sag, n,-Texas Utilities Electric Co. (Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2), CLI-89-06, 29 NRC 384 (1989), aff'd igh nga. Citizens for Fair Utility Reculation v. NRC, 898 F.2d 51 (5th Cir. 1990); In re Joseph J. Macktal, CLI-89-12, 30 NRC 19 (1989); In re Joseph J. Macktal, CLI-89-14, 30 NRC 85 (1989); In re Joseoh J. tijtcitjLl, CLI-89-18, 30 NRC 167 (1989). Furthermore, both the DOL and the NRC have acted on Mr. Macktal's allegations. For example, the 00L has voided the settlement agreement which Mr. Macktal claimed _ illegally prevented him from testifying before the NRC. Sag Macktal v. Brown & Root, Docket No. 86-2332 (Nov. 14, 1989). Furthermore, the NRC has adopted a regulation specifically preventing the type of agreement which Mr. Macktal alleges-that he was " coerced" into signing. Egg-10 C.F.R. 650.7(f). Finally, Mr. Macktal has explained all his concerns to the NRC Staff during a transcribed interview. Thus, the responsible federal-agencies have reviewed Mr. Macktal's concerns and these materials do not constitute " good cause" for late intervention. 12
- - " ~ " " - - - - - " - In conclusion, we find that petitioners have failed to demonstrate " good cause" for their attempt to intervene in the OL proceeding for Unit 2, thirteen years after TU Electric's request for an operating license was published in the Federal Register.8 b. The Remainino Four Factors. "[W]here no good excuse is tendered for the tardiness, the petitioner's demonstration on the other factors must be particularly strong." Duke Power 1, (Perkins Nuclear Station, Units 1, 2,'and 3), ALAB-431, 6 NRC 460, 462 (1977). "When the intervention is extremely untimely... and the petitioner utterly fails to demonstrate any ' good cause' for late intervention, it must make a ' compelling' case that the other four factors weigh in its favor " CLI-88-12, 28 NRC at 010 (citing cases). As we will demonstrate below, we do not find that petitioners have made a compelling case here on the remaining four factors. The NRC Staff concedes that petitioners satisfy the second and fourth prongs of the test. Assuming arouendo that petitioners have an " interest" in the proceeding, i.e., that they have standing to participate in the proceeding, there is no other means by which that interest can be protected. Likewise, because there is currently no proceeding, there is no other party able to represent their interest. However, these two factors are the least important of the five factors. South Carolina Electric & Gas Co. (Virgil C. ePetitioners attempt to resurrect their claims from their earlier attempt to reopen the record which we denied in CLI-92-01 by incorporating those claims into this petition. However, as we pointed out then, with only two exceptions, those records had long been in the public domain. In fact, many of them dealt with Mr. Macktal's claims and -- as we have seen above -- those have been resolved. Thus, even factoring those documents into the arguments and allegations presented here, petitioners have failed to demonstrate " good cause" for late intervention. 13
l. L*. Summer Nuclear Station, Unit 1) -ALAB-642, 13 NRC 881, 894-95 (1981),-aff'd iqh agm. Fairfield United Action v. NRC, 679 F.2d 261 (D.C. Cir. 1982); tilssissioni Power & lioht Co. (Grand Gulf Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2), ALAB-704, 16 NRC 1725 (1932); Detroit Edison Co. (Enrico Fermi Atomic Power Plant, Unit 2), ALAB-707,16 NRC 1760,1767 (1982). More importantly in our view, petitioners have failed to satisfy the third prong of the tast: that they have the ability to contribute to the development of a sound record. As we noted"in a similar situction, "the Appeal Board has repeatedly stressed the importance of providing specific and detailed information in support of factor (iii)." CLI-88-12, 28 NRC at 611. "When a petitioner addresses this [ third) criterion it should set out with as much particularity as possible the precise issues it plans to cover, identify its prospective witnesses, and summarize their proposed testimony.'" id., cuotina Mississioni Power & Liaht Co., (Grand. Gulf Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2), ALAB-704, 16 NRC 1725, 1730 (1982). 333 Abu Lona Island Liahtina 1, (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1), ALAB-743, 18 NRC 387, 397 (1983). In.this case, petitioners alleged that they-would introduce "a massive amount of evidentiary material... [and) witnesses who had extensive testimony " Petition at 3. However, as we noted above,' petitioners have identified only two prospective witnesses, Mr. Ron Jones and Ms. Dobie Hatley. Furthermore, they have failed to summarize their testimony, except to state that Mr. Jones had discovered " massive wiring violations" and evidence of drug use in the control room. Petition at 3. Additionally, as we have also noted above, the documentary evidence specifically identified-by petitioners or submitted as attachments to their 14 _.J
t -s. -i pleadings and the -information contained therein is already in the publici domain and is generally extremely out of date. Moreover, petitioners have failed-to demonstrate any disagreement with the NRC's resolution of the matters they have raised. Thus, petitioners have failed-to demonstrate how ~ this evidence would create a record that would assist us..in determining-whether we should issue an operating license to-Unit 2. Moreover, petitioners have completely failed to address how their concerns -- many of which date from the 1984 time frame -- would have been^affected-by the extensive corrective programs undertaken at.the plant since that time. Egg, g a., CLI-88-12, 28 NRC at 611. In sum, we find that the-third factor weighs: heavily against granting petitioners' request for late -intervention. Moreover, the fifth factor -- the possibility of delay and expansion of the hearings -- also weighs heavily against granting petitioners' request. "[1]ndeed -- barring the most_ compelling countervailing considerations.-- an inexcusably tardy petition would (as it should) stand little chance of-.succe:2 if its grant ~would likely occasion an alteration in hearing schedules." Lan2 -1sland Liahtina Co. (Jamesport-Nuclear Power Station, Units 1 and 2), ALAB-292, _2 NRC 631, 650-51_ (1975)- (opinion of Mr.' Rosenthal speaking for. the entire Board on this point). In this case, there is currently no formal proceeding at all.
~~Thus, granting-the petition will result in the establishmentLof an entirely new formal proceeding, not-just the " alteration" of an already established hearing -~~
schedule. Moreover, as we noted in an earlier Comanche Peak opinion, "there-will be an inevitable delay while [ petitioner] acquaints itself with_ the-proceedings." CLI-88-12,-28 NRC at 611. As~we noted there "[t]he petition-indicates' that [the petitioner] apparently has no knowledge of the extensive 15 Ee-,-
1 proceedings that have occurred...." id. In that case, we found that because a former intervenor had been absent from the proceedings for six years, there would be an inevitable delay while the petitioner reacquainted itself with the proceedings. In this case, petitioners have never been involved in the formal proceedings involving Comanche Peak and they have only been involved in matters related to Comanche Peak since last spring. At no time have petitioners demonstrated that they are fam6iar with the factual background of the extensive proceedings that occurred from 1979 through 1988. Nor have they demonstrated any familiarity with NRC rules and procedures. Thus, we find that there will inevitably be a long delay while petitioners prepare for-the hearing process. In sum, we find that petitioners' have not established " good cause" for their request for late intervention. Moreover, we find that they have failed to make a " compelling" case on the remaining four factors. While they arguably satisfy the two minor factors, those factors are clearly ' insufficient, standing alone, to satisfy the balancing test required for late intervention. Sfa, p_dL., ALAB-707, 16 NRC at 1767; ALAB-704, 16 NRC at 1730-31. Moreover, petitioners clearly fail to satisfy the two remaining major factors, the ability to contribute to the development of a record and delay and/or expansion of the proceedings. Thus, we find that petitioners have failed to demonstrate a favorable balancing of the five factors required for granting a petition for late intervention and we hereby deny their request.' 'In view of this finding, we need not reach the question of petitioners' standing. However, we have strong doubts that petitioners could satisfy our standing requirements. First, the Dows themselves. live in Pennsylvania while Comanche Peak is in Texas. Thus, it is unlikely the Dows themselves have standing. Moreover, the Staff raises several possibly valid concerns 16 i
3. The Motion To Reopen The Record. As the Commission pointed out in CLI-92-01, a person cannot seek to reopen the record unless that person first becomes a party to the proceeding. CLI-92-01, 35 NRC at 6. Because we have determined above that petitioners cannot become parties to the Unit 2 OL proceeding based on the record now before us, we find that they cannot seek to reopen the record of the proceeding. Additionally,astheStaffcorrectly'iiointsout,petitionershavefailed to satisfy the requirements of our regulations which provide that a motion to reopen the record "must be accompanied by one or more affidavits which set forth the factual and/or technical basis for the movant's claim that the (reopening) criteria have been satisfied." 10 C.F.R. 52.734(b). We have denied requests to reopen the record because of this defect. Lono Island Lichtino Co. (Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1), CLI-89-01, 29 NRC 89, 93-94 (1989). Neither of the attachments to the Motion to Reopen the Record meets this requirement. Moreover, petitioners have again misinterpreted the " timeliness" requirement. The issue is not whether the motion to reopen is filed "within l 24 hours of the petition for late intervention." Motion at 2. Instead, the test is whether the information upon which the movant relies could have been l presented to the NRC at an earlier date. tigtrooolitan Edison Co. (Three Mile l 1sland Nuclear Station, Unit 1), ALAB-815, 22 NRC 198, 202 (1985); Vermont regarding the standing of the Disposable Workers organization. Elle Staff Response at 17-20. S_qg also Pucet Sound Power and Licht Co. (Skagit/Handford Nuclear Power Project, Units 1 and 2), ALAB-700,16 NRC_1329,1333-34 (1982); Duauesne licht Co. (Beaver Valley Power Station, Unit 2), LBP-84-6,19 NRC 393, 411 (1984). 17
rr + k Yankee Nuclear Power Coro. (VermontLYankee Nuclear Power Station), ALAB-138; 6 AEC 520, 523 n.12 (1973). l Here, as we noted above -- and in CLI-92 ~the material telied upon by petitioners has been in the public domain for some time and has -- l generally - -been acted upon either by the 00L or the NRC.- In-those cases where either the DOL or the NRC has acted on the' material, petitioners have-failed to allege some reason for taking additional action,121., they have failed to allege where either agency acted'I~ncorrectly.- For example,.as we noted above, both the NRC and the D0L have acted on the concerns raised by Mr. Joseph J. Macktal.' As another example, TV Electric reported -- on.its own -- 1 the fire-watch violations raised by petitioners and the NRCLhas already acted on that issue by. issuing a Notice of Violation. In'both cases, petitioners-have failed to ' allege any inadequacy in the resolution of these issues. C. F,eauest For Protective Orders. Petitioners request protective orders for!seven (7) named persons;-- including both Mr._and Ms. Dow -- and six (6) unnamed' persons.under 10 C.F.R.- l 52.734(c). Motion at 6. Assuming arouendo that this: request constitutes.a-. request for " confidentiality" status under NRC ManualLChapter_0517, we deny: that request at_this time. Quite simply, such requests should not be granted-on a blanket basis; instead, they are fact-specific and.should be granted only. on a fact-specific showing that the-requesting party meets the. requirements of Manual Chapter 0517.. 4 ~ Turning to the specific _ requests, we are unclear why petitioners request-t a protective order-for known individuals. In a similar situation, we. questioned how a person who was a known critic of Comanche Peak could demonstrate how he could be harmed if his name became associated with 18 ^ f .a ,, u _- _., ~ - _.. -~
F. N e additional allegations. "The purpose underlying a grant of confidentiality is to preserve the alleger's identity from public disclosure where such disclosure could cause harm to the alleger." In re Joseph J. Macktal, CLI 12, 30 NRC 19, 24 (1989). Nevertheless, in that case we pointed out thd d the petitioner could demonstrate that some harm might befall him -- or his sources, for example -- the Staff would be empowered to grant that request. However, the burden was on the petitioner to demonstrate that harm to the Staff. J.d. The same is true of the individuals who are riamed by petituners in this case. Turning to the unnamed individuals, they also can seek " confidentiality" status from the NRC Staff even though we have denied both intervention and reopening of the record. The NRC's guidelines for confidentiality are set forth in NRC Manual Chapter 0517. They -- like the seven named individuals -- should address their individual requests to the Allegations Coordinator of Region IV or the Allegations Coordinator in the Office of Nuclear Reactor-Regulation at NRC Headquarters. D. Reauest For Suscension Of Licensefs). Petitioners also request that we suspend the operating licenses for both Unit 1 and Unit 2 -- presumably during the pendency of the hearing sought by petitioners -- for alleged deficiencies in the labeling of pressure valves and limit switches. Motion at 6-7. However, as the Staff notes, again, this matter has already been reviewed and resolved by the Staff. Egg Affidavit of William D. Johnson. Moreover, this is a matter more properly placed before-the Staff under 10 C.F.R. 52.206. Petitioners currently have a section _2.206-- l We presume that petitioners mean the Unit 2 construction permit. Unit '0 2 does not have an operating license. 19
petition pending before the Staff; accordingly, we deny this request and refer this issue to the Staff for their consideration as an additional issue in conjunction with the current petition under section 2.206. IV. Conclusion. For the reasons stated above, we (1) deny petitioners' request for oral argument; (2) summarily deny petitioners' requests for late intervention in theComanchePeak, Unit 1 proceedings;andh)findthatpetitionershave failed to satisfy a balancing of the five factors necessary for late intervention in the Comanche Peak Unit 2 OL proceedings. Moreover, assuming arauendo that petitioners were eligible to participate in the Unit 2 OL proceeding, they have failed to meet the standards necessary to reopen the record of that proceeding. Finally, we deny the requests for protective orders and for a suspension of the Unit 1 operating license. It is so ORDERED. F r the Commission", [17uaPi I bLs o SAMUEL J.
~~HILK Secretary of thq Commission beq4s Dated at Rockville, Maryland 4u this Q day of August, 1992~~
" Commissioners Rogers and Curtiss were not present for the affirmation of this order, if they had been present they would have affirmed it. 20
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the Matter of TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC COMPANY, Docket Na.(s) 50-445/446-OL/CPA ET AL. (Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing COMM M&O (CLI-92-12) - 8/12/92 have been served upon the following persons by U.S. mail, first class, except as otherwise noted and in accordance with the requirements of 10 CFR Sec. 2.712. Janice Moore, Esq. George L. Edgar, Esq. l Office of the General Counsel Newman & Holtzinger, P.C. l U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1615 L Street, N.W., Suite 1000 Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20036 j R. Micky Dow Juanita Ellis, President Sandra Long Dow Citizens Association for Safe Energy Disposable Workers of Comanche Peak 1426 South Polk Street Steam Electric Station Dallas, TX 75224 322 Mall Boulevara, Suite 147 Monroeville, PA 15146 A i Dated at Rockville, Md. this I 12 day of August 1992 Office of the Secretary of the Commission i --}}

ML20127K814

Contents

Text

_ =. =

s. 4

Contact:

Dear tir,

Navigation menu

ML20127K814

Text

_ =. =

s. 4

Contact:

Dear tir,

Navigation menu

Search