ML20127H598
| ML20127H598 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 10/10/1984 |
| From: | Srinivasan M Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Butler W, Parr O, Sheron B Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20127H500 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-84-942 NUDOCS 8505210340 | |
| Download: ML20127H598 (1) | |
Text
L Iho$ Cof'l oMo'u0e5 g
+n c n~ "
- e UNITED STATES I(
g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
.c WASHlWGTON, D. C. 20M6
- p**OT October 10, 1984 MEMORANDUM FOR: Olan D. Parr, Chief Auxiliary Systems Branch, DSI Brian W. Sheron, Chief Reactor Systems Branch, DSI Walter R. Butler, Chief Containment Systems Brant:h, DSI FROM:
M. Srinivasan,, Chief Power Systems Branch, DSI
SUBJECT:
SHOREHAM PROPOSED FSAR REVISION DIESEL GENERATOR LOADING Enclosed is a copy of a submittal from LILCo dated July 3, 1984, which proposes the deletion of several automatically started pumps. These pumps include:
1.
one of four Reactor Building Service water pumps, 2.
one of three RBCLCW pumps, and 3.
one of two spent fuel pool cooling water pumps.
We have been reqpested to review and prepare an appropriate SSER input with respect to LILCo> proposal to derate the onsite diesel generators.
In order to complete this review, the acceptability for the removal of the above listed pumps from the automatic start category to manual start must be i
determined. We, therefore, request your evaluation of LILCo's proposal for any impact on the performance of system (s) in your ares of responsibility in writing by October 15, 1984. If you have any further questions, contact j
J. Knox, x24568.
WN M. Srinivasan, Chief Power Systems Branch Division of Systems Integration j
Enclosure:
As stated cc:
L. Rubenstein R. Caruso W. Houston A. Ungaro A. Schwencer J. Knox C. Berlinger E. Tomlinson 85052go340850116 B
AIR 8 -942 PDR Q
n t
f f,/gg@ Af LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY L;u SHOREHAM NUCLEAR POWER STATION p.o. sox sie, womrH couwrmy noAD. WADINe RIVEN. N.Y.11799 Jown o. ulON ARD.2.
wies enesesen.asuctaam opeaanoes July 3, 1984 SNRC-1065 i
f Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director
)
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
%A U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
\\/ $
washington, D.C.
20555
'O t
N O
Emergency Diesel Generator Loading N
Shoreham Nuclear Power Station - Unit 1 Docket No. 50-322 r
\\'
Dear Mr. Denton:
i > v
,l The purpose of this letter is to provide you with the technical guidance and methodology LILCO has used in reducing the emergency diesel generator loads presently shown in the FSAR (Table j
8.3.1-1).
fy A review was performed of FSAR t_ahle 8.3.1-1 (revised table 3
attached), which resulted in the following additions and or deletions.
1.
EDG 101 and 102 loadi ould include the fuel pool cooling VM pumps, 1G41*PO23A&B, on of which will restart when the bus r
is loaded.
'[his corre inn results in an increase of 24 kw for EDG 101 and 102.
~
2.
EDG 103 loading should not include the RBCLCW Pump, IP42*
'9. #
POOSC which is locked out for 10 =4nn+a=-
This results in a reduction of 8D Rw zor wG 103 during the first ten minutes j
[
' following an accident signal.
I 3.
An analysis was performed to assess the feasibility of I
deleting the auto-start logic from one of'the two Reactor l
Building service water pumps powered by EDG 103.
The results j
indicate that in the 10 minute interval following an acci-dent, one pump per system train will adequately provide the required system flows and pressures without affecting any currently approved safety analysis.
Y0 0\\
65 4o7o3 0
[3 PDR~ Abo W osooosaa A
PDR N
-..-- _ _- C.. 4, _
'I ' ',SNRC-1065 Pcgs 2 As a result, EDG 103 loading will be reduced by removing one service water pump, 1P41*PQQ3C or D from auto-start on an accident signal.
This change results in a reduction of 358 kw for EDG 103.
The loading sequence is shown on table 8.3.1-2 (Revised table attached).
The station procedures will be revised to incorporate a manual start of the fourth pump if necessary prior to initiating RBSW flow to the respective RER Heat Exchanger.
Since RER Heat ~
Exchanger flow initiation is also a manual operation, this additional. operation of manually starting a RBSW Pump is not seen as a significant departure from our current operational philosophy.
~
This review and operational change results in the following revised loads for EDG 101,.102 and 103.
Total kw EDG 101 EDG 102 EDG 103 (prior to 10 min) 3433.2 3388.6 3442.7 l
With this load reduction, FSAR paragraph 8.3.1.1.5, Onsite Standby Power Supply will be revised as follows:
The rating of each diesel generator is 3500 kw.
The required load on each diesel generator ir enveloped as follows:
Continuous 3475 kw 2 hr per 24 hr period 3500 kw
$j It should be noted that the accuracy of the diesel loading on g
Tables 8.3.1-1 and 8.2.1-2 has been verified by recent electrical testing of the major components.
As a result it is our intention.
that preoperational and surveillance testing be performed using
- f..
these loads.
(
It is LILCo's position that utilization of these loads during j
-preoperational and surveillance testing will adequately j
demonstrate the load carrying capabilities of these engines.
I We would greatly appreciate a timely review, coaument and concur-j rence by.you and your staff regarding this item.
Should you or your staff have any questions concerning the elements of this load reduction please contact my office.
I very truly yours,
,l -
ee:w j
J. D. Leonar, Jr.
- 1, Vice President - Nuclear Operations i
BRM:ck cc C. Petrone All Parties Listed in Attachment I
. --._..=.--..-..-1....-...-.
V A m CsMenT 1 Lawrence Brenner, Esq.
Berbert B. Brown, Esq.
JAdministrative Judge Lawrence Coe Lanpher, Esq.
f b
Atomic-Safety and Licensing Alan R. Dynner, Esq.
Board Panel Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Bill
.U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Christopher & Phillips Constission 8th Floor Washington, DC 20555 1900 M. Street, N. W.
Washington, DC 20036 Dr. George A~.. Ferguson.
Mr. Marc W. Goldsmith Administrative Judge Enprgy Research Group Atomic Safety and Licensing 4001 Totten Pond Road Board Panel Waltham, MA 02154
. School of Engineering Boward University.
2b9 i
on Earnard M. Bordenicli, Esq.
MHB Technical Associates David A. Repka, Esq.
1723 Hamilton Avenue U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Suite K Commission San Jose, CA 95125 Washington, D. C.
20555 cFor Federal Express Stephen B. Latham, Esq:
7735 Old Georgetown Road Twomey, Latham & Shea 33 West Second Street To Mailroom P. O. Box 398 Bethesda, MD 20814 Riverhead, NY 11901 J
James Dougherty, Esq.
3045 Porter Street NW Fabian G. Palomino, Esq.
Washington, DC 20008-Special Counsel to the Governor Executive Chamber, Room 229 i
Ralph Shapiro, Esq.
State Capitol Cammer and Shapiro, P.C.
Albany, NY 12224 9 East 40th Street New York, NY 10016
-Secretary of the Constission Atomic Safety and Licensing U.S. Nuclear. Regulatory Appeal Board Panel Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Washington, D.C.
20555 Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Atomtic Safety and Licensing Robert E. Smith Esq.
Board Panel Guggenheimer & Untermyer U.S. Nuclear Regulatory-80 Pine Street Commission New York, New York 10005 Washington, D.C.
20555 TDI
' @hsWWp9= M@
"W
ATTACHMENT I I
Attachment I
~Page Two Jay Dunkleberger Esq.
Martin Bradley Ashare New York State Energy Office Attn:
Patricia A. Dempsey, Esq.
Agency Building.2 Suffolk County Attorney
. Empire State Plaza H. Lee Dennison Building Albany, New York 12223 Veterans Memorial Highway Hauppauge, New York 11788 JonathanD..Feinberg,$sq..
- Dr. Peter.A. Morris New York State Administrative Judge Department of Public Service Atomic Safety and Licensing Three Empire State Plaza Board Panel Albany, New York 12223 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C. 20555 i
i o
i c
n i
s
?.
t 9
TDI n
- 'N e==w,
- -e*--
m-eee
+gwe p e = e=-e.
y
- t L
f
- f. '
'T d-y 4
y_.
v L
E i i i:
3 i ; i :;
i id.Ih8;86..
n = ; h
- i ;" S i 2 5..
L i
11
-e 1.1 I :.:
.a n :- a.a. 1, 2 :.n.:
,s..e
-s e
o "5
o
't
- ' F2 C
O'$ I II ! 2 S*3d."l l 2
4 E b U k
- ,,~22 2 3N t
'e s" 3
=
J{*...
~
La
,, j.
s'25
)
~ t 3:
"Jgg e
I 1
22 9:
f T
d35 E'
23 *
[ E'g 2
]%
2
=
I p\\
sI a
+
J" v"
{:
I
[
1g A
2 J A l.
- El
-.I g o I.J q,
y gey Ed
~'
SS9 g
3
- EEE 2 P-I l
= !.
- ! 2l g..A"222g..p2 2-
- 44 X4 2.42))S 2.S4 1
I*
=
at2>.) I2:
a i a i-3 k k s
i 3 W i S.sj;t.
a I
n
- 4 dC d 2
ug=
y L-ga u
i
" I_EG v2*F
'.h k k k!k kEk gk i ii
. 23 2-5 3 1 % 121 1 11.
1 6
-)
!S 512
- 5: ital )2"2'g.)3g*g):
jg] l {
2"*
L :. :. k.5 5.". 3 * :.
- g.g
- 2 j *g**kgssi 3....
2-d i i":
akak5 k-"
}%
o E:1 %,
>1 t 2 2 i
. 2;.3 3k1 1:Tk%
1 535331335383d: II:3%3%:2:* :
$'2.lI" 5 " E
- E E E 2
- E RG " E
- E
- E
- E
- E
- E 2 -
4 25 *2'! E* I*I =I*
3' 2
q a
L
_h, D y ege me W M -
.wg' MmMMM 't NN O
'O'M*****
I
.~~
~
- - ~
~
l
.~
i P.l 5 3 gg 4.
.... 2. 2.
R 2
.T I:1-X n
3 Ep
" 1,. 4 5
.J v.
e K " i244..
2.4
.I 2 l
i-2 2.
-4 446 6 4-g.,
l w
,,A
(,
-5' r
"y.
"o
-i k
...q '1* i..i i
.g 'g P
L j
l 4
.s. s.
s< t
.l-w
- a
),
"21 V
i 3:
e 1.
en
.ls.g"k5 8
I.l J2 3
7 7
2.68=s 9l a
&2
--W 3
ma 2..
e,i1 3
1:
i 888 m:
r; I.,.: -
- --!2 S,,
2.2
':.- 3 4
44-SS 2 2.
22E I
S2 3
P.
it i
3
- 1. *-3I t f,j 2:,
i r
g
,,I I t
i-t1, k-I
.. ti, ; g g I, *l i. j - l.
2, F
- = *;
4.
F-i 6
=Ilg;Ig8o l
g3 g
! 2 : 2 l ps A
a a
8*
.t*
=
't
- -, T8k 22-j: yI 23:%I:ji:2,3 !!
mr 1
e..
.I g I:l i n =
I !ilp'r iv o{p s u s e: t u ta t:,;ble 2
i
- =
g.
t-n 22 e
i
- ! s
.i e a-c c
=
c
-g -} SS:r*hakPttitk G
22 i 3.1 u t e go,% s s.3 hl :.. - X - - >: s.t g
lu!>
- u 8-i s ; ;.m 2-
. j3.3 3-1 g
- u-os : v.g e x - s u. u u. -
c 6
-u m
o i
-g 6
ou dW9 86 # ***
@**6
^l \\.
x r
y
\\
l l ih ho ho h) i
! }ii 6
- El.
3
.t 6 2"
.4
'.I'I.
. ili.jk.
. i g.,,
t 2 ;;g' :
e d t h'* P f oJ$$2':fgP.at a a' Ma h1 8'!*
Eg:
a ;. : ;.
o,t:2 a
. ;.: ;.:.,4 2
- g
- j?}4,
-lAju, j!
I
,!]I;;:
s
.i i M M * *l a g (W.o!p.!p2 o'
a 8 ;
=
aats
- 3'
...a..o 8
x,
,4
.a.
8-
,.o >.
..U {
's,
.~ s s
~
a-Ne fffej-f 'Q> c' j
- j "'
- - ~...
.....o o
t
.: s, e
i om 4
-w ny
= e n m, pip i
x Y $j E. ! -[l g
v, e
o-533 s..
ofwoMF s
yt2 Y
dt o
.....a g H. n>,6+^ o'%,
- $g. t
~
l o
e o.,c,,
~ >-
s a
g s a a
m ig.p n 15 Br >J a
5' s.o k
=
a 2-y
... ;.. g 3
'* C 90@
gj o
.. s e,o ".g c
1 e,
Tln::3-h m
-y c
ai 3
est L
Ars
?
1
. r.
D,.
4 4
a 1l j=g 3 s as ; e.
- e3 es: :lC X."M..
3.
T*
_, t j r. l' :. e r
- 1..
t s.
x rrii
- - _e _e.
ee ila,-
I,....
is:
a et t. a s.
.s i s : g
,.= i i. i.
3
- T M,I ", 8 j [u - ' a s i n i s,* _ " l if !', ; * :.,!
o ti
- s..i s.i n : :
. a,,
_ o g
.-.t a : s r
- t s,_r 1>!;f*A '*,,M ul ! I I 3's,.
s ss g_ _. _..
_,_82
.as
?!ai! IlIl liiii=H-
. <. i. k.a"., e e h e - e g 4 38.'" !;! )?. i..e.i!. 3 3 * :n:!.b }
e t i. t t4t S
s e e e e-e s._ 2.3 e a =
8..
e - : _. :
===f2.- e
.=
6
=,22 Ia... -=._
a -
s a r.:
I e
.L
- ~ ' ~ ~ ' ' ~ ~ ~
^
- 4 ee e
e
=
C
..E. 1's I
s l
g s
rI _s
_3
- g. k.
4 o
o gE]a 4
2 I 22
_I 1
=
j
-*2 b
1 E
[g- := t W
I s
b t
yg g
CO es S
n ia -
1 l
Thi
- . 4 2
q ij 35-i 2
g i;
=
g
]
i.
I i
4..
}
i m
a a
3t e
- I 3
j2 g:
,2
-I :g :
M 8 =g
.4 E
a
,3 l
E g
g.g, 4
2 a
g is s
82 g _E g
.i :
,~ ~.. w
.1
[
.k N o.c.g 1 &
u 6
s>.
-]g 3 =. 3 om,s, s
_4 i
I:g r.
g.
_1
)i g:
im, ~
5ls
- a...
2
{
s g..,3 3 3:
!g g EI.
I a
?!
8 1
j33.
=l e p
,t t a r
i2 co0 2 j!
I g
\\
g; m:
2 3
g;t iIeg
! :I ;.
3,
m i
Ia
- i e-e r
_. - s 2
sm n
.t :.
3 r
sii a
e z
a 2
2
.I 2
3 2-3 3
a
=
g -l4 Ia tr.
- i. !. g 3 2 o
-l d,?cd,
- s *Es23 3
8
~
. _' ! +q '
i
,i 4
s 2
4 ts.:
. i,s s se a_s.
._I.
I.
1_ m =:i a
=
t-s
-e 2
s 5_ 6
-]=
i, k
2 a
s Fe Is:g a[' l ;2 8
r e
3 1 _2 r: 2.
- s t
'l t
4 j' 6
llj52=
{
J 6 h 2:.g 3
=
s - s = s g.:
2
.8
- !Ig sg -
- I_
t i i 1[ i 2
i3-i i
i j
81 t 3
1: !i1 b
=
1 12 [s<
y I
- j g s:
g
- is I :! :s a
+
I t-r ms_g i 22
- a5 t
8,1
[ I a2 n
2 1
2 I
1 a1 2.: a m3. 3 6=
3
,~
y
-j]k i
- 4. :s1 31 2" 2 2 i
- - t 2
- = 3 e
5 baa 32 *to ?
%
- 22
- 1. s 0s e
3j!Ill3g $I I,,:
i 13.
=-
j2 28 t.-*
i ss _1_E 3 8:
3
=
_1. 2
.5 1
je.
<2 g
..i gs :
i
...g.
3 E-4 g
s..
Es$ b $$ $b f$$
y
.. i.
- i. i.
- i. i i. 7 p
$I
~
E i
i
~. :.
a m
J D1 i
1
';f '...
g sh M $
u m
4 5
% m
..~
n.
o
-e 6
5 j
3 4
i 3Q u,.I
.t "o
2 r
t 9e :
t.
ee a l
jg 1
I I 15.s -
i I I I! _i -
C c
c r
{.
p:
a.
.s s.s 3:1
,[
4 a 4.:
,[
44 4.:
c s
R 1 13 8 8 83 a 8 33 k
V 3
e 3
ai
- s. _a. !
!as-i I
!i 8
['
8 E
i k.
ga.
3g lll d
h3I h8g mti a
- a
- 4 l'
E :i
!i-a:
a 1
1 E s 'i
- 1 3.e5
',2 1
asc l,= r l=s;
!=r s
Is?
?:
e
.s 4 2
g a:
g.m
- El:
at
- s-2 h8 *
.t 5
ti.
h j I.t.;h 2
g I' _j I:;n j -'45
-d'=
I 445 23 g
i-e' 1
lg.:. g:Ik E' ysi t mo ;.g:5:=2
.*1 I g, 81_.1,
=
5c.
1:2
_.:1.
e< le. i e n 5
, :, s l. t a.is
=
_ _.: n.
a
-12;
-13 g ark;E a sek:i ks a s a i igi;g I kg *I 3 5j:s s a si i lg:g O
k k %
Zi 52.
st e
aa; aa a a.;
a; S
e
^~'- -
f-
~-g
- ==-*==*=e=*
]
- M"--*
. ~..
...e.
1 s
se s-s rsas jang e.s. e-2 tennt.on fsee sened orshe stoc sne munnene cu-ist ei e ve loosence flest'".
thwoeouvec tapreseewac eve tw hv E19ttLt92 a,est sw7f
.soe-e 6s t.'l
.see-v 4.f7 4 l
s.
initses teed -
O tector lead. Including IIows.Ltg.etc.
1 en 0.000/ 4.333 kWe, 4. 980-400 v. treneformer with 05 laugnedsucce i
2.
5 tert AllR pump 3
'f.290 f.290 5.644 PM
!.-!: ? 1684.4 3.
start SIG Puess 7
g,330 8.290 9.644 see
.s,see-+ limit".w M
4.
5eert+.e.servseeweecpusag e3 *o 4s0
'eco 4,eee ae23.
34e-3sg 9
and Gese DesWs Chillord 584 2.454 410
.3,eet-tr 3 9'f 3 4 l
s.
Isove complete operetton so(appren)
(c.1)
.3,eee-r 3492.7 s.
see seem pp, step e eco-on
%:n.a 2,eee-s 2 2 42.5*
coac and mesvs water chassec (p g 6,: 4 e
siema eseco eux, e.psspoent, esort Tsc ele ceriditioning.
l l
...... Ber.
te,e
.e, 84,e, e.,
.e,e.e e.,-..
. - l.
t.re.
Service teater puages and WesWs chIllere recelse elect algreets free the tsue progress et 92 sea es showes.
i flowever. ether Interloche any delay meter elect tseyend thle pelet.
'" 11s efte showei in tatste to time af ter the diesel generatec tsreehec closes to its essecleted 4 kW tase.
1 o
41-1 1
- = = - -
-. s
~
s t
UNITED STATES
/'
n s
j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION I
wAsnmoTow.o.c.aoser
- ...o*
gylg g4 Docket No. 50-322 MEMORANDUM FOR:
M. Srinivasan, Chief. Power Systems Branch, Division of Systems Integration
- 0. [arr, Chief, Auxiliary Systems Branch, Division of FROM:
Systems Integration
SUBJECT:
MANUAL INITIATION OF SELECTED PUMPS - SHOREHA POWER STATION As per your memorandum dated October 10, 1984, we have reviewed the app cant's submittal ' dated July 3,1984.
of manually starting one out of four (1/4) Reactor Building Service Wat System RBSWS) pumps, 1 System RBCLCWS) pumps,/3 Reactor Building Closed Loop Cooling Water (SFPCWS) pumps is addressed below.and 1/2 Spent Fuel Pool Cooling Water System The SFPCWS is not necessary for reactor safety or accident mitigation.
when the bus is re-energized.The applicant has proposed maintaining 1/2 p anticipated that the pool temperature would take more than one hour reach boiling.
This is ample time to manually start the other SFPCW pump.
Thus, we conclude that the manual initiation of 1/2 SFPCWS pumps is accept-able.
The RBCLCWS consists of three full capacity pumps feeding two redundant loops. Although 2 swing spare pump),/3 pumps are nonnally operating (the third pump is a only one pump-is required during accident conditions.
Thus, we conclude that making the swing spare pump manually initiated is acceptable.
which services the operating loop of the SFPCWS, there would cooling to the SFP.
Our evaluation of this event / failure would be ident-cal to the aforementioned failure of the auto initiated SFPCWS pump.
The RBSWS consists of four pumps powered by three diesel generators.
diesel generator supplies power to two pumps.
One one of these two pumps will not have any adverse effect on our previousThere accident evaluations, since any single failure will not prevent at ler.st two pumps from operating.
However, the Technical Specification 3/4.7.1 should be revised to allow only the manually started pump to be inoperable C ntact:
J. Ridgely X29566 e -
~ --
A
+
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART 1900 M STREET, NI WASHINGTON D.C. 200M C+=T BOSTON PLACE BOSTON, MA C tce nuPHONE cm 45: 20 ggwp 142B BRJCKELL ALINUE TEECOPER CQ 452-705:
MLuc. F1 11111 December-~21, 1984 1100 031F BUILDING PITTSSL1GH. PA 14 22 WPJTUM DIRECT DIAL NL4fBEA g4g> )Nw (202).452-7023-HAND DELIVERED Director.
FREEDOM OF IN!GW.t.hCN Office.of Administration ACI REQUEST U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission FOTA-F-9 %
Washington, D.C.
2055s FreedomofIriormationActRequejted rA ay/g4
Subject:
Gentlemen:
On behalf of our client, Suffolk County, we request pursuant
-to the. Freedom of Information Act, as amended, 5 U.S.C. S 552 l("FOIA"), _and'the rules of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission ("NRC")
^isuued thereunder, 10 C.F.R. Part 9, copies of written materials in the possession or control of the NRC, whether'in the Commissioners' offices, the. Office of General' Counsel, the Office of Policy Evalua-tion,=the Office of the Executive Director of Operations, or any other -.NRC ' of fice, which relate in any manner whatsoever to ' the is-sues discussed in "CLI-84-8" -- a May 16, 1984 Commission order per-taining to exemption requirements in the Shoreham operating license proceeding.*
Without limiting the. scope of this request, but merely to assist the NRC'in its search, the materials that we are requesting may include-the following:
1.
' Transcripts and/or notes of a..y meetings attended by the Commissioners and/or by NRC Staff and/or' by-other persons at which issues addressed in CLI-84-8 were discussed.
- Suffolk County has already obtained copies of the transcripts of the May.7 oral argument before the Commission and the Commission's
'Shoreham meetings of April.23, 24, 26 and 27.
Therefore, copies of these transcripts.need not be produced except to'the. extent that the NRC has possession or control of transcripts hich have handwritten notations thereon.
r L
-, / / n.,
Q) ffYlV"J'
y
~
p r, o.s q
,7f KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART.
[U.S... Nuclear Regulatory Commission 9
k
'Page 2!
{
. December'21,-1984 t
-2.
Any materials relating to the "as safe as"
~
~ standard adopted in CLI-84-8, including any materials which relate to whether the "as safe as" standard will affect the application of the
~
provisions in 10 C.F.R..S 50.47(d) to the Shoreham low-power exemption; proceeding.
3.
Any materials relating 1to whether to replace
.the Licensing Board forclow power matters chaired by; Marshall E. Miller,'Esq., and any materials-relating to the Miller Board's in-
~
volvement in the Shoreham proceeding.
'In the event that access is denied to any part of the re-c
. quested materials', please supply the following information:-
A.
Identify the withheld or deleted material and specify the statutory basis for.the denial, as well as'your reasons for believ-
-ing that an exemption applies, as required-by 10 C.F.R. S 9.10(b).
3 B..
Segregate.the non-exempt from the allegedly.
exempt portions of all materials and release
.the former,-as required by 10 C.F.R. S 9.5(b).
C.
Supply:a detailed statement of the content of the withheld or deleted material, along-with the date on which the' material was written;-
~its title or section heading; its author; the author's title; and'the identification of any persons or entities who_have' received copies of.such material,'as required by applicable case law..Vaughn v.
Rosen, 484 F.2nd 820, 826-27'(D.C. Cir. 1973).
D.
Separately state your reasons for not invoking your discretionary power to release the allegedly-exempt' materials.
10 C.F.R. S 9.9.
The undersigned is willing to inspect the requested material 1 prior to its-reproduction in order to identify specific material for reproduction.
c.
e..,
- 7. ;
- s ; -
+
KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART
'U.S;: Nuclear Regulatory Commission
~
lPagey.3 December: 21,.1984
+
The undersigned will-pay' charges for' search. time and copying
. fees, as provided by:NRC regulations at 10 C.F.R. S.9.14.
If search and copying fees to.be incurred by the-undersigned will exceed'S500,.
please notifyfthe.. undersigned before this sum is exceeded.
Wa - expect to receive your' response _ to this FOIA request.-with--
-in' ten-(10) working days of your_ receipt.of this request, as required-
.under-the'FOIA'and as set forth at-10.C.F.,R. S 9.8.
Sincerely, Y'
./
Robert R.'
air RRB/lbw--
h
- h..
t L
'[j,.
L.-_