ML20126M472
| ML20126M472 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Limerick  |
| Issue date: | 06/03/1985 |
| From: | Martin R Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8506200350 | |
| Download: ML20126M472 (27) | |
Text
P -
prno g
ff sw g
g UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION L J WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 JUN 3 1985 fccket No. 50-352 FACILITY: Limerick Generating Station, Unit 1
~
LICENSEE: Philadelphia Electric Company
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MEETING ON STATUS OF UNIT 1 On May 24, 1985 representatives of the Philadelphia Electric Company (PECO) met with the HRC staff to discuss the status of Unit 1 of the Limerick Generatine Station with respect to readiness for full power licensing. A list of attendees is provided in Enclosure 1.
The presentation was mace by PECO (licensee) generally following the agenda ir. Er.cicsure 2. A summary of each of these areas follows.
hRR Items The licensee indicated that there ate r.o outstanding NRR items of revicw of which they are aware. The NRC Project Manager generally concurred in that assessment noting that there are several items identified in recent weeks by PECC* thot are under current review and are expected to be reported as resolved in SER Supplement Uc. 5.
The response to Generic Lettcr 83-28 was discussed with the Plant Manager r.oting that the post scram recovery procedures are already in place. The Plant perdirig flanager furtheralso nottd actions licensing that actions includt currently trainingunderway)at the plant in (a technical specifications (b) citar.liress maintenance and (c) attainment of excellence in operations. The Plant Manager emphasized that the housekeeping effort has been significantly upgraded in recent months.
Region i Items The licensee stated that they recently met with the NRC Resident Inspector and reached mutual agreement that there were no issues identified from that discussion that would impact full power licensing activities.
Emergency Planning The licensee's Director for Energency Planning noted that the full scale exercise for 1985 had been successfully completed on April 3, 1985, and that the traffic control issue as recuired by a condition in the ASLB's Third Partial Initial Decision of Mey 2, 1985, in the King of Prussia area had recently been addressed by the Pennsylvania Emergency fianagement Agency.
Durir,9 the neeting it was learned that the ASLB had issued an order regarding the emergency plar.r.ing evacuation issues for the State Correctional Institute at Graterford. '
h P
2
F The NRC steff clso brought to the licensee's attentien an flRC statement as recently included is, the Feceral Register on medical services for emergency planning.
LER Reduction Program The licensee sumarized their program aimed at improving operations to reduce the. frequency of events at Limerick. The licensee's presentation, as sumarized in enclosure 3, paralleled their letter of April P,1985 to the NRC on this subject.
The hRC staff (R. Wessman) stated that the staff's comparison of event f re.quency for the last several mertbs with the prior period showed that the recent rate of LERs is very comparable to the rate for a number of other boiling water reactcrr it t f.inilar stage of operaticns.
Security Inprcsentent The licensee's Assistant Director for Security sumarized recent corrcctive cctions taken on the security progran as outlined in enclosure 4 Thc licensee stated that the Linerick security program including harct.cre erc' trairir.g is generally based on the Fuch Botton plant program with scrc erhancements.
Water Supply The licensee sur.carize.c recent efforts to gain apprcycl for an alternate supply of suppluou tel cooling water for the sumer of ISE,5. The licensee noted that the ricxt sienificant event would be the r.eeting of the Delaware River Basin Ccnr.ission on May 29 to consider the PECO application for (a) substituticr. cf ('issolved oxygen limits for ter@erature limits as the controlling parameter for Schuylkill River withdrawal and (b) cllocation of altcroate interin water supplies.
Continuing Use of PRA The licensee's presentation followed the outline in enclosure 5 sod provided a sumary and update of the licensee's continuing use of prcbabilistic risk assessment as discussed in their July 23, 1984 letter.
Low Level Radwaste The licensee's presentation followed the outline in enclosure 6.
The licensee is evaluating various espects of the issue including measures for controlling the rate of gencretion of low level wastes.
The staff noted that it is in the process of completing its intetit review of the Piecess Control Progran and will report the results of the review in Supplement ko. b tc the LEl:.
I
JUN 3 1985 Training'and Staffing The Limerick Plant flanager's presentation followed the outline in enclosure 7. The current organization, the provisions for development of the plant staff, recent Unit i nilestones and the startup test program were discussed.
Sunnary The licensee sunnarized by stating that portions of the Test Condition 1 l startup test program have been completed, that sufficient water supplics are stored on site to conplete the Test Condition 1 program and that upon receipt of a full power license they are prepared to proceed with the Startup Testing Program. -
Mf v1 nicned byr Robert E. Itartin, Project Manager Licensing Branch 110. 2 Division of Licensing
Enclosures:
As stated i DISTRIBUT"0N (GespatrJe LBi2 Reading Kl4artin Wh11 9or a Cual PNL [ff;'>
h.
RMadfn L DL: Bf2 W8utler ,
1 D /3{ /85 05/3//85 i
l
r-Training and Staffing The Limerick Plant Manager's presentation followed the outline in enclosure 7. The current organizaticr., the provisions for developn.ent of the plant staff, recent Unit I nilestones and the startup test prograra were discussed.
Sunr.ary The licensee sumarized by stating that portions of the Test Condition I startup test program have been conipleted, that sufficient water supplies are stored on site to conplete the Test Condition 1 progrant and that upon receipt of a full power license they are prepared to proceed with the Stertup Testing Program, gh 71 -
obert E. I'.ertin, Project lianager Licensirs Branch lio. 2 Division of Licensing Enclcsures:
As stated
I P
l fir. Edurd C. Eceer, Jr Limerick Generating Stcticn Philadelphia Electric Conipany Units 1 & E cc: Troy B. Conner, Jr. , Esquire Ir. harvin 1. Lewis Coi.r.er and !!ctterbahn 6504 Bradforc Terrace 1747 Pennsylvania Ave,l'.l!. Philsdelphia, Pennsylvania 19149 i Washington, D. C. 10000 Zori G. Ferkin Frank R. Romano, Chairman Assistant Counsel Air & Water Pollution Patrol Goverrer's Energy Council 61 Forest Aver ue 1625 N. Front Street fr.bler, Pennsylvania 19002 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17105 Federic M. kent: Charles W. Elliott, Esquire County Solicitor Brose & Poswistilo, 1101 Eldg.
County of Montgomery 325 fl. 10th Street Courtbeuse Easton, Pennsylvania 1840%
Norristown, Pennsylvct.i6 19404 Eurerc J. Bradley lis. H.14ulligan Philadelphia Electric Ccr.;pn> Lin.erick Ecology Action '
Associate General Counsel 762 C;uu.n St.
'J201 Iwrket Street Pottstown, Per.r.s31 vtria 19464 Philauelphia, Fct.nsylvania 19101
- lir. Vincent Boyer fir. Karl Abrahair Senior Vice Presicent Public Affairs Officer liuclur 0pcritiers Region I Philadelphia Electric Company U.S. tiuclear Regulatory Comission 2301 Market Street 031 P6:k Avenue l Fl.iladelphia, Pennsylvania 19101 King of Prussia PA 198U6 14: . Suresh Chaudhary Thomas Gerusky, Director Resident Inspector Bureau cf Etdiction Protection U.S. f.1 clear Regulatory Comission ' Dept. of Enviromental Resources P. O. Box 47 5th Floor, Fulten Far.k Elcg.
Scnttega, FA 19464 Third and Locust Streets
'h6rrisburg,' Pennsylvania 17170 Janes Wiggins, SR. h.1.
U. S. fiuclear Regulatory Comission F. O. Ecx 47 Sanatoga, Pennsylvania 19464 I
I
7 Sugarman, Denworth & Hellegers Director, Pennsylvania Emergercy 16th Flcor Center Plaza Managenent Aguicy 101 North Broad Street Baseraent, Transportaticr. &
Philadelphic, Fer.risylvania 19106 Safety Builoing 1:4.rrisburg, Pennsylvania 1712C Robert L. Anthony Angus Love, Esq.
Frierds of the Earth 107 East Main Strcet Delaware Valley florristown, Pennsylvania 19402 103 Vernon Lare, Bcx 106 t'oylan , Pennsylvania 19065 Martha W. Bush Helen F. Hoyt, Chairna.
Deputy City Solicitor Administrative Judge Municipal Services Bldg. Atemic Safety & Licensing Board 15th anc cFL Live. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comissicr.
Phildelpina, Per r.sylvenia 19107 Washington, D. C. 2C555 David Uersan, Esq. Dr. Jerry Harbour Assistant Consumer Advocote Administrative Judge Office ci Cuisur.er Advocate Atomic Safety & Licensing Board 1425 Strawberry Squarc U.S. huclear Regulatory Comissici.
Harrisburg, Perrtylvcnia 17120 Washington, D. L. ELEEE Steven P. Hershey, Esq. Dr. Richard F. Cole Comunity Lcgal Services, Inc. Administrative Judse Law Center !? orth Centro - Povry Bldg. Atomic Safety & Liccrtirs Ecara 3701 !! orth Board Street U.S. Nuclear fe901atory Comission FLiiaceiphia, Pennsylvania 191t0 Unshireton, D. C. 20555 I;r. J. T. Robb,115-1 11r. Sper.ce U. Perry, Esq.
Philadelphia Electric Company Associate General Counsel illi l'crl et Street Federal Emergency hr.agu:ent Agency Philadelphia, Pennylsvania 19101 Rcom 840 500 C St., S.W.
Timothy P. S. Carapbell, Director Washington, C. C. 20472 Department of Er:ergency St.rvices 14 East biddle Street Ocst Chester, Pennsylvania 19300 6,
,El; CLOSURE 1 ATTENDEES PECO ARC
- V. Boyer H. Thompson it. Cooney T. 14cyak G. Leitch R. Bernero J. Robb J. P. Knight R. Kankus T. Speis K. Keindorfer D. liatthews A. Diederich J. Rutberg G. Hunger R. Martin R. Scholtz A. Bournia D. Honan R . . He ssr.a r, W. Alden S. Black G. Lauderback- ,
J. Spinelli
- h. Wetterhahn (Conner & Uctterhahn)
Others B. McCormick
- h. Darcis B. Rosenberg, LEA
- Sone were in attendance for portions of the necting I
l
E N c t o t u a s 2.
AGENDA FOR LIMERICK FULL POWFR LICENSING i MEETING AND OPERATIONAL READINES.;
BETHESDA, MARYLAND 2:00 PM - FRIDAY, MAY 24, 1985 Presentation by Philadelphia Electric A. Introduction and Overvicw V. S. Boyer B. Status of Major Licensing Components ,
- 1. NRR ltems J. T. Robb
- 2. Region I Items G. Lauderback, Jr.
- 3. Emergency Planning R. A. Kankus C. Areas of Special Attention
- 1. LER Reduction Program G. A. Hunger
- 2. Security improvement R. J. Weindorfer
- 3. Water Supply V. S. Boyer
- 4. Continuing Use of PRA A. R. Diederich
- 5. Low Level Radwaste R . 'd . Scholz
- 6. Training and Staffing G. M. Leitch D. Conclusions on Readiness G. M. Leitch DFC/dg/051L8501
(
._ER REDUCTION PROGRAW e Adverse trend repor"ed by Sution Manager to senior management and Nuclear Review Board in December 1984 e Events investigated for root causes by n
both plant stuff and Independent Safety g Engineering Group (ISEG) e o
e Recommendations for addressing root E causes made to Plant Operations Review
. Committee and Nuclear Review Board g
.by ISEG in mid-January 1985
- e. Corrective Action Programs developed in three areas:
Personnel Modifications Programmatic
(
CORRECTIVE ACTIONS -
.. . 1 . w. '
~
e PERSONNEL Letters and Group Meetings Simuator Training Enhancement Requalification Training on Actud Tech. Specs. and LERs Discipline Operator Excellence Program o MODIFICATIONS Riey Temperature Switches Reactor Building Pressure Sensors -
RPS Inverters Special Outage -
O PROGRAMMAllC Prompt investigation Prompt Review Special Daily Review of Control Panels
~
Control of Peop'e in Control Room -
Specid Frequent Review of Control Room Logs
SUSPECTED UCENSEE EVENT REPORTS CUMULATIVE TOTALS '
15 0 -
'I' E
g 100-j x
g Legend e a Personnel
. o E so_ a Design y e Procedure
- o Other 2 A Total LERs o x Total SLERs 4 4 - ~ ~ ~ , , m m , w ,4 m m Weeks Since Ucense Received
ENCL o t uR C h PROGRAMMATIC IMPROVEMENTS OF SECURITY FORCE PERFORMANCE AT LGS o Increase the YOH Manpower and Reduce Turnover of Personnel l
I o Increase Security Awareness Level Through Training and Instruction o Increase Security Awareness Level Through Continued Performance Analysis i
a S
=A
SECURITY IMPROVEMENTS o Increased the Number of YOH Personnel o Improved Working Conditions 1
o Improved Training Program o Added PEco Supervision o Additional Performance Analysis o Added YOH Supervision 1
ENCLDCUAE 5
~
ORGANIZATION ENGINEERING PRODUCTION I I I I I I PRA MAINT & : '
INDEPENDENT USE GROUP :
SAFETY o ENGINEERING GROUP (ISEG)
SYSTEM ENGINEERS "
PLANT OPERATIONS 7
i
PRA MAINTENANCE & USE GROUP e DOCUMENT ORIGINAL BASES o e UPDATE PRA
- BASELINE ,
- PERIODIC e EVALUATE MODIFICATIONS e EVALUATE TECH SPECS e MAINTAIN /USE CODES e DATA ANALYSIS
- PRA TRAINING e STUDIES / ANALYSES 5
. . l l
l e
l ISEG e EVALUATE OPERATING EXPERIENCE e LIMERICK e OTHERS e IDENTIFY / REQUEST PRA STUDY e ASSURE PRA RESULTS REFLECTED IN
- PROCEDURES
- MAINTENANCE e TRAINING l
6 1
~
t j
i l
TECH NICAL BASES fl e SCOPE e MEASURE e DETAll
) i l
l l
1 8
l
__ r.t
.z . s. .
RESULT e PRA INTEGpATED WITH ORGANIZATION e RESULTS REFLECTED IN
- MODI,FICATIONS
- OPERATIONS
- MAINTENANCE
-TRAINING e PRA MAINTAINED UP-TO-DATE e PERIODIC RE-EVALUATION OF BENEFITS e
13
-__m.s- _ _ m . .-- .-
O Exctoru w lo
@ T C C L T o *
"O
- O8 m T ro T L -
T C 4 >
C T OO t
C 4 C L
! o
- C ea Cp m C m V Gm
-
- O-m C T X e e C OC S E O o O e #
C-O L L e C Q s O OL O @@
@ 7 e ** '0 k L T 3 t o
- L m O Q e 0U * **
, a 4 # m-T a 3 C O @1T C D E m 8E C CD E W- -o i
- e. . . m3 O*
9
! V 2 T C L J "D o t
CD 4 l
l 1 - - - _ ._ __ _ _ .
"U :)c) "O
@ q) @
T 3 "U
- - -t
> > e
$ I o $ o T g3
- L g3 L -*
m O C O. O O- #
O C y o y o !
-s o E m M L l
] N
--e w
- L
-e
] L e
-e Q. m
.c l
.-. C .g em y c m m*
- L e C I c w 3 I C O O g *
- g C S
- O C Q. C C
- O C E ao e
- O g c
- O C . C E o EN o
C.) * , , 0-w g OW g -
O o e c e u
- l U) 3 L m L . L C g n 0 n
- O o 01 l L e g
- 4 g 4 4 4 c o c e 4 g -
i
- O g @ g O @ G m l M , O U1 , N 01 01 C g W D g -
0 0 O
, L , L L L g i o e i o oO y
- y *
- S
, -M , -W WQ 4 *
- 4 .
- 3 . .
- W W 4
! I J Q i
G m 01 C m C O
- L ** "
- O * .71 O
m "
O h -
- a.
- 8 L 0
a g
c - m O m
- a C **
o ~
n L
- t.-
c O e O E G m e e #
o C C m m '
L c 8 3 8 #
- O O L O e o G c " O
- m O) m e a D .
- m "O 3L L 8
~C +*
e C Q y .- . O Q a O O3 O c o ec O* 3
\" 8" LM O c cc E CL ~ +a O
- g i L
m e c e a mJ e 3: ** *O C "U 8O< O O*
"U EOO G UC i 4 c .
- C * * !
o O y J l
l
) ' ,
l: , ;i, ' ! l l lll 1 l
- . - ~
y t
i l r o
i t c n a r y ef o g m t o s eR c l n gV a o o a x p n i n m h t a o o c _
p m c cr e O l o t W i xt n R / W oc o R V
V R ba i _
8 /p t rm a d d e k eo r e _
v c dc e c _
o o ar n n _
r c ee a i _
pb rp c v a
m hu n d _
I B Ss I A
y - -
/ ') .
MANAGER G. M. LEITCH 10/1 -
PLANT SUPT PLANT SUPT OPERATIONS SERVICES Ih ,
J.F. FRANZ J. W. SPENCER k n
20/9 17/10 &
o 5
.R OPERATIONS TECHNICAL CHEMISTRY HEALTH. MAINTENANCE OUTAGE g ENGINEER ENGINEER -
PttYSICS. ENGINEER ENGINEER J. DoERING P.J.DUCA J. S. WILEY R. W. DUBIEL J.B. COTTON J. P. LAW
~
Q 13/7 9/4 33/0 13/0 15/0 2/0 ADMIN ENG REG ENG J. A. BASILIO C. R. ENORISS 1/0 12/0 LEGEND : YEARS OF -
NUCLEAR EXPER ENCE / OPERATING BWR EXPERIENCE
w LIMERICK GENERATING STATION PLANT OPERATIONS STAFFING o OPERATIONS ENGINEER - SRO LICENSED AT l PAPS & LGS o ALL 5 SHIFT SUPERINTENDENTS LICENSED
& 4 WITH PBAPS LICENSED EXPERIENCE A 6th LICENSED SHIFT SUPERINTENDENT IS GAINING EXPERIENCE o ONE WITHOUT PBAPS EXPERIE'NCE BACKED UP WITH PECo SHIFT ADVISOR (PREVIOUSLY SRO'S AT PBAPS) o 9 SHIFT SUPERVISORS LICENSED WITH 4 MORE i
TO BE TESTED IN NOV 1985 o 50 LICENSES' 12 SRO ENGINEERS.15 SRO OPE'RATORS 23 RO OPERATORS
~
o 7 STA'S QUALIFIED o TOTAL LICENSED OPERATOR EXPERIENCE:
76 YEARS OF HOT OPERATING BWR EXPERIENCE e
f
-^ --
y w
LIMERICK GENERATING STATION OPERATOR QUALIFICATION STATUS o LICENSED OPERATORS o 27 SRO LICENSED OPERATORS & ENGINEER o 23 RO LICENSED
. o NON-LICENSE OPERATOR S .
o 12 PLANT OPERATORS (MOST ARE RO'S) o6 ASSISTANT PLANT OPERATORS o 18 AUXILIARY OPERATORS 1
o 6 HELPERS o SHIFT TECHNICAL ADVISERS o 7 QUALIFIED .
i a
l I
i N J 1 L_--. .
m LIMERICK GENERATING STATION l 1
UNIT 1 MILESTONES l
DESCRIPTION . ACTUAL RECEIVED 5% LICENSE & START F/L OCT 28,1984 i
I,5 COMPLETE FUEL LOAD NOV 131984 ,
INITIAL CRITICALITY ' DEC 22,1984 COMMENCE TEST CONDITION HEATUP TESTING DEC 30,1984
- ESTABLISH INITIAL RATED P'RESiiURE
- & TEMPERATURE JAN 14,1985 BEGIN L.E.R. OUTAGE JAN 31,1985 COMPLETE L.E.R. OUTAGE, CONTINUE
- HEATUP TESTIN,G FEB 18,1985
, , COMPLETE L.P. TESTING & BEGIN L.P. OUTAGE MAR 04,1985-COMPLETE LP. OUTAGE & START TESTING MAR 291985 1
- INITIAL GENERATOR SYNCHRONIZATION " -
APR 13,1985
.. . : .e .
l ~ . u,% lal4;f^Q - -
COMPLETE POST-LOW POWER OUTAGE TESTING APR 17,1985 d
w-, -, - - , , . - . - - - - - - - , , . ~ , .- - ._ , , _ ,
~
Vj ~
[ .
I y Il . .
ht - ll m 3 -
4gl s
}$
' ~~
3 l ". ; .m.:. ;
/
33 L I -
,- I I m "u d 4, g I
wi
- y 3 a -
p l . e -llll ll 1l 1 l '<
l ~
mu l
gE E
E .
ul d
- Il f l i I!
l m e #
l I-
.. se '. [
. . i
- e. ,L ^' * . *lt G- iri 5 I 1 .
,~
is l J
- I e g .,. s _l. % L 3
[
y3 t QA p 4 9 h y": 'Q)e;
_k . J i .,,
3 tu t ; .h '-
. . I,,- '* '[:'
- i 3e ll E i ) . . . . . . . '. . v -+
m l [ ,
4 wi
. la E E is I s e e a e e e a e e . . o i sse E' ,
t = '
- . g . a Y , M '.s.' $! r " I,
'dN 5 u?l-- ~
t T-~-- -' - - - - -
1 & _
I !
>_ w a
a EJ "g g *r-g
~~
+ "g g 4 4 P 2 C D 3 -
a r ':s = a= r a n "
t 53L = SES .e. 9 l i l R E M* ' t dE E 3i _ 6:
- l i mw - '
' sa _W 10 5 m i e - am 2 R:M "
E dE .'
r st 8 r- 5 as 2_ i 5 . g :
,, ,, 3 - - '
,,, h _* ' * -
i e g'_ . ____J,l;; " ,,,,
l t*
m S: $*
' i F L -
. A Di o,*
E D' I 6- 3' ag 3 ti 8 vn '
1
.g m 3
= {Du
., e e
Ba P
gM' W
~'
A 15
[E
- i I k*
2 ..Efl '
h" Ii as
- r M sRo it e W i "
J "en b E '< Ra - ""
W EE E J" "
' E i e8E .
E9 .E x 1 m .
e g
U8 Esr 8
.. ..w E a-E-"-
J un -
ru 4
)
P T{C !
gE E E i m W a 4 sc,3 . T SE I q@
m l ,
_a ,
e ---. ..- mgg --<= -- ---
rm =
3 ~
= l
. e2 't , -s ' l3 in E,J m l E
3:
6
'l iE t e
- 9 A:
W r er 3 .: '--- -' '- --'- --
5,us '
lg i l
j i t 3; rl :1 h
Se eeE!El E nea 2:3 R ni 0 2
5 3 .
e Je e g '
T. i i iE. I; wi .. I 3 t 1 3P-#SW m ..Ji
" -
- E g 'S a e ' 'I d i
a $ $40
't ele R Y l -
e @ dtl E $ E s*
Ar 2 i' R .Is . .. Ed "E "J . "5 % D' w m nF R ENT .as Ek _ E 9 '
g
,,t Wa s IE BB Bk ism
- 2 ,,
m E .
{ m Su
'T t 4 33 3 -
n .mL6 - 2 4 *1 E N
,, 3: 3 *NFrille v . . e g 2 **
- i lif S! i .
E e e D. I s E iE ,,
M - '. 6 '
eirW l 4 i
- E! C C I
a e -
b i
k h, h. h. .:
3 l *
. G y
U k i a
3 e
U a
4 l l J 3 i
e 3
5 l* tll -
3 g
g s og e
4 4
.. l.
a 4 J l E t a so . I E $ 3
=
a es e a - : -
2 o
- h' y EM E e i
- = =
- o
- 1 3 g . .
a be L g b 3 '
~ e w
2 wt . v 4 - m =
$ IS 8 3 e
If $ it' E E E k
= re
.. wi - - %
- - ._ .- _ _- .. ,