ML20126J062
| ML20126J062 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Summer  |
| Issue date: | 04/15/1981 |
| From: | Knotts J DEBEVOISE & LIBERMAN |
| To: | Bursey B AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8104230563 | |
| Download: ML20126J062 (6) | |
Text
.
u y-DEBEVOISE & LIB ERM AN 1200 S E V E NT E E N T> 5 ? 8 E E ?. N W WASHINGTO N. O C 2 0 0 36 saw....u.r.ma" 208.
7-. soc
.wa.o= L....=
,......c.
6.
....s.....s,...s.
so........,,...
c............s.
April 15, 1981
.. u' *-
. o =
L g
.AN,0.. L ne., MAN
..u...s........,.
....u.....
.IC M s.. ble,. h k
sOM N.
..O.,0 7y
..Maam.. no.im
.o....onoo=v.
.*6. c. oua.
- s. as eC M A.b u.. A..f, M C M... b L, se N
.t u 6.a..
so-2.6....
- s. ~.... w..
..s.........s..
2
.......e.....
61991 ' r M
g Apg 1
.e.,,
.~ u.-
s ej)
.....r.9831 so...
,J/
sw Mr. Brett Allen Bursey
/g' Route 1, Box 93-C Little Mountain, South Carolina 29076 Re:
South Carolina Electric & Gas Company, et al (Virgil C.
Summer Nuclear Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-395
Dear Mr. Bursey:
As I indicated at the prehearing conference on April 7, 1981 (Tr. 384), the reference to the ACRS transcript of March 13, 1981 which I promised to send you is pages 427 through 429.
For your convenient reference a copy of those pages (as well as the cover sheet and first page) is enclosed.
By copy of this letter I am also transmitting copies to the entire service list including the petitioner.
Sincerely, j
S
'N dt'-
Joseph B.
Knotts, Jr.
JBI/pv
.d 3
Encl:
As stated.
91.
2)
I[
cc:
Service list Q h/o,,pl 81042305(o3 G
)# @ Z30
~
NUC!. EAR REGU.ATORY COMMESSICN
'/
/,.
,f./.)
j i.
t*E.!,{'r,f,%
r I
's,
l l'V' ly)
'6
". s.:
w' us..q.,! 7 m "M
aup s m
.: J af%
I Q..\\
Igg c,,
o
/v f ^.
c,/s/j W.
- Y'Y 3 de Mat::2 cf:
ADVISORY CClLv.ITTEE ON REACTOR SAFEGUARDS l
?
251st GENERAL MEETING j
i CATI: Maren 13, 1981 PAGzs:
335 - 563 AT:
Washington, D. C.
i l
e I.
m I
s
-r i
f..
', \\.
.i. $
.4 r/,*/'.
i N
i.
4
?
'f.
f.
O
{
/ f*
.uBERSOX REPORTUG m
s d
4,
- ~~
4 0 0 '71:T.~ia Ave., S.*4. ~4asni..g.=n, O.
C.
20024 i
s
'p Talach==s: (200; 554-2345 9
L l
!anson/r&t 335 l
i UNITED STATES OF MiERICA 2
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMt1ISSION 3
)
a 4
ADVISORY CO!1MITTEE ON REACTOR SAFEGUARDS 5
251st GENERAL liEETING
=
H I.
6 R
2 7
Roon 1046
,~
1717 H Street, N.W.
E 8
Washington, D.C.
a dd 9
Friday, tiarch 13, 1981 i
h 10 The Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards met at 11 9:40 a.n, pursuent to notice, Dr. J. Carson liark, Chairman',
y 12 presiding.
13 ACRS MEtiBERS AND CONSULTANTS PRESENT:
- 1 8
\\
E J. Carson fiark l
14 Paul Shewmon 2
15 tiilton Plesset i
Chester Siess g
16 Stephen Lawreshi w
Myer Bender p
17 Dade W. Moeller g
William Kerr M
18 tiax W. Carbon Harold Etherington h
19 William W. Mathis M
David P. Ward 20 Jesse C. Ebersole Harold W. Lewis 21 David Okrent Jerry Ray
~
22 t* DESIGNATED FEDERAL E!:PLOYEE:
23 I
Paul Boehnert 24 l
i I
25 i
, k. w, = *
- l I
ALDERSON REPORTING COMPANY. INC.
l
8 t:7 1
White 'cth said at the c* :e e Of the discur.cien en seistic r
1 2
margins tha t they were s a ti s.'ie d with what the ;;;11 cant had 3 reported.
1 J
4 uculd mise nc-a that with re;ard to SS.".E.0, we 5 have a letter from Dr. "hite which indicates strongly the l
I 6 staff vants te get it hacA tc;sther tc try te make the I
7 progr.5.m :cre relevant.
6 Well, we have cf the crder cf ten sinutes, ".
j C.h..'. 4.-
.$.n,.* e '.. e-1 c '.' r..>..
'e"..a d.a.v - ' -
c,
.ee5 o
s a.
10 "I.
?.AEM:
I have a couple ef very s:all l
11 questions.
We heard frc: Dr.
.Y u r;n y this ac ning e n th e 12 pcssible re servoir-ir.iucei :a;nitude.
"e also hear.1 since 13 t he n tha t even if that ha;;ened, the cargins vculd leck 1s a.#
e e.
'n eve...
'... *. =.
.e -..
.e.e c a
.a.
- ca
" e.- v.
- c. c s a.
15,. g a 4., e c-
.g 4...se
- 5.,. 1 4 y,.
e
~
e--~-
---c--,
e
....e
......e-
<-c---*-
-c
-uG, 5.r
....e.
. e.....
4 e,. -
v-c 16
--g.w..
.6,.
3,....,..
4e 4.4 r---~~on 4
vy..gy
-,a
..e 17
~~
v--
~~ --
-r.
18 r e =. s o n =. b l e, er is that outside hir ran;e cf consideration;
-s---g-,
- ctaega e g'
ast* sea C**
c '-
19 an' gg +he a c +~ ~" g e g4 -E
-s-e 6-
'.*...4 P..'.. u *
..*, 7
.e t '.. s.
- '..' *. Q.e.
.s
' S. *.' c.
,. < 4.
4 s.
gg
.r....
a w.
a1 S
- a ". ?.
l
.a..;..
a 4 ;...r. a g s.
..n...,
w
.. g. k...
- C a.. S '. c. -
w
.C"-
r.
g
,2 first -uestict..
23
- v. :..
- v. (t t.. r. : v.
T..4..>..
g.6. e.
.4_e.
eg.
+ h e.
w.
74
...4
,. 4
...4 a.4.....s
...i, r.
- t..es
....e..<.,
4.
t...
....c..a
.r....w..,
...v e.r 4..e.:c.,.. =.c.
..... r.,pg,.y r
r.
L..s.........
............ u.r
... e
....,...,..e...
4..
t 8
t
. w t
I u2s l
.,,n e
t' realistic -- is *.hr.:.* h a t. y ou a r e =skine?
l 2
? ?..
A ?.X :
Alcne with that.is the fact that they i
P 3 have ms: gins to':ae a thing that at ' east c.5 and ;erhaps i
t i
l 4
larger, un*.ess it is very, very c1cse
?
5
- 13. %U?:RY:
Ycu he.*e me. I just de net knov i
6 P
6 anything about ths.
7
%3. " A FM J Are 702 4e-'
- q. ::=..
-. y oy.=-.'-~~~c i d e s 4.7 s----
eg7*
.. r e
e S
r I
s
' ?.. EA?K:
Segpcss yc tell us what ycu examined, i
10 a n.d *hes-.. '...- *. * '..'..
.e
..' v.. t
..-'.=.-*.'y v=-l.'
'. e *..* u e ', u t
- 7.. *.
i 11 relevant.
g...,-
e; - s 4 g.ag,-..,-a Yen-y :. =. 1.
12
. -~.. - -
13 Tuestion.
3
.'..'..k.
=-
'...-=..-d.
.'.' '..'. 4 v.
has a d
.. : v..
14 1 =,
5..: *+ ". =. s.. o *.
..c
. _1 c e e, + '. =.
.~..-,_.e
- e e.."..'..
.c c =.
. 4. s.
... c.g,.
.a.4 t o.
~c.cq.dca1 ec4e-5 4
- - - ' a s - '
7-
-7
=-
n y : -.:.
tu-
-~c 17 18 con te xt.
"e rav the f.;;11 cant ;:erent t '.* u - g r a ; h where he
. z.
0 0,..-.c
.s-s.
. z..a. - a.
- a..,.. u..,... o. p
- 4.
O s a <.a
..= ~
1 c.,
/4"*=
C8
- * * * - - 1 = C *- e
-a--,d 8
- J -w.
53934.ad*- :: '
m r--
20
- +
"a"* ' S 21
- 7 e a e s ** d ' e - = " a ' and ** "=-* 2
-e 6 E f
a e e. c. e.
c
.a. a n g s A.m.,. n a..
+
- k. c n...a.
- a. :
.C se c.a..G a
.q
=
a
...t 6.
ge s..
.e
- e. e.# s-. e
.e c c a. v'.. =..-. -. e d..'.e.=.... '. e.
. k. e ~ ' a.. u.
s.. s w.
n3 5 _'.e
- "
- C "o v.'. *
- e-
~.~ #. :..*
.58
...e.. g :.,.
.w
- g.. 3.a
.~.
.n 74
,.-. 4..
4
.s
- s........
.a.
s.
.c.
e.,.
- 4..
p..- r = c.. s : r. g. = r., -..
3.,,
a s. ~
g.....:..r
.e
.~c.
-.- e.,.... s.
,t c29-1 I guass the first questien, the one that Dr..'. a r k 2
posed, was dc you have any problem with his choice of 3 distance or size of local earthquake?
.v....
.u. n e.. : t.. v.
..s_
.a. 4, e.=..d
..*.a.
.#.' u. c.
.h. a.
- a. " t up r
4
..w...
v I
5 there, he thcu;ht the ma;nitude 4.5 earthquake was at least 6
4 kilometers from the pla n t.
~.,.
- s. o..
.e s 4.
w-
- v. h ;.. v..
- e.. C..na.
4.
~,.. e,
4.
.n.
. s 6
V C L'.' '. '. a.
...a
.e.s. w *..a SCt
.e
..c-.c.
9
- v..... y :
.y.
1.
..,; e.
4 42 10
.eC'"Se V C "- + d
-r
- C e- " * * * ~1 E " E P* a -' ec
- 0**b w
" V8 e
.wa
> 4
.e. a V a. - v.
." *. ". e. e n a h.' e 11
- v. :...
v.. g.;. ;. u.. v.
~ s. 2..
4
...A 12 ass;;; tion.
s.. :.. : y m ey 13
- v..:.
L _.
q.... 2.=..03 y C,J
.r :
.* * : 1
.ua,
.3 a
s...
g m.,
14
--+
r--
n
.r.
- . c.
"a '.e.e.' '.' '..' '. V.
- *. s ' a. c. ".
- C c.% c. 6 15. - s.
8.-
- 3.. -. e +4 '..' C 7.
- *. ' ~ *, -
r..
w.
v s-*
as e--ry w.g.b'gs
,e--
g*
16 g.
yo.
ap.9
.w3....
.s 4
- s
-v
-s j7
- e....
- v. (' a.,; ". y g
- 4
.w.
..v v;:v
- -a
..g3
.w, e..2 16 my; g.
-s 3
."e-
'--e
' 7-
'e a"a *'e*e a *7 ";
19
.mO O.6..s e
.s c.. e../ M... C.m..e.
v 3...
v-~^;t.
..w,.
4.
w
.o' ygg.bm.
21
~*
~~- --- ' "-'" "
'"~~
a'-
d 4..
i##--a c"e "" o
'.. c'.
.5.' c 5.1 s
..w
. x,,.., -'-
e.
..o ee 22 23 the C: -ittee should be svara.
v '. u :.
3,...a
.c
.6, ree.
e-
.s,.
24 s.,..
s...-
., 5
....:..,......_.,,..v 4.......
4......a...
.a
.............