ML20126H139

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Summary of 850207 Meeting W/Util,Ornl,Southern Co Svcs & Westinghouse in Monroeville,Pa Re Documentation for Pressurizer Surge Line.List of Participants,Design Rept Table of Contents & Load Combination Calculation Encl
ML20126H139
Person / Time
Site: Vogtle  Southern Nuclear icon.png
Issue date: 06/06/1985
From: Mark Miller
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 8506180261
Download: ML20126H139 (9)


Text

- _ . _

f  %

', UNITED STATES y g NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION y ., ;j WASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 S- 4 June 6, 1985

%, .....f Docket Nos.: 50-424 and 50-425 APPLICANT: Georgia Power Company FACILITY: Vogtle Units 1 and 2 i

SUBJECT:

SUMMARY

OF DESIGN DOCUMENTATION REVIEW HELD FEBRUARY 7, 1985 On February 7,1985, the staff and its representatives met with the applicant and Westinghouse at the Westinghouse offices in Monroeville, PA to discuss documentation for the pressurizer surge line. Participants are listed in Enclosure 1. Enclosure 2 contains background information and the Table of Contents from the design report for the pressurizer surge line.

The staff found that the design report did not contain a calculation ,

illustrating that minimum wall thickness was met. Westinghouse indicated that this calculation or a clear reference to it would be included in the final design report.

The staff also indicated that a section needs to be added to the final design report which describes how assurance was obtained that loadings (e.g., earthquake spectra) identified in the design specification (e.g.,

955211) were used in the evaluations to show that Code limits are not exceeded. Enclosure 3 contains a copy of the load combination calculation.

i The staff indicated that Westinghouse should also include in the final design report a discussion of the evaluation of:

1. Inclusion of out-of-roundness effects in fatigue calculations.

l

2. Coupling of piping systems in analyses.
3. Use of stress indices, if any, which are not included in the Code.
4. Use of combinations of generic systems analyses with Vogtle-specific analyses.

l 8506180261 850606 PDR ADOCK050g4 A

i

.. v

_2_

Also regarding the " Stress Report for Class 1, 6-inch and Larger Gate Valves," the owner verification sheet does not clearly indicate that the applicant had reviewed the report or if Westinchouse had been authorized to conduct the review of the report for the applicant. The applicant will provide written clarification on this question.

l hlAA Melanie A. Miller, Project Manager Licensing Branch No. 4 Division of Licensing

Enclosure:

As stated cc: See next page s%(',?

ge s ceT ws t

i

Mr. Donald Foster Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Georgia Power Company cc:

Mr. L. T. Gucwa Mr. William S. Sanders Chief Nuclear Engineer Resident Inspector / Nuclear Regulatory Georgia Power Company Commission P.O. Box 4545 P.O. Box 572 Atlanta, Georgia 30302 Waynesboro, Georgia 30830 Mr. Ruble A. Thomas Deppish Kirkland, III, Counsel Vice President - Licensing Office of the Consumers' Utility Vogtle Project Council Georgia Power Company / Suite 225 Southern Company Services, Inc. 32 Peachtree Street, N.W.

P.O. Box 2625 Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Birmingham, Alabama 35202 James E. Joiner i Mr. R. E. Conway Troutman, Sanders, Lockerman, Senior Vice President - Nuclear & Ashmore Power Candler Building Georgia Power Company 127 Peachtree Street, N.E.

P.O. Box 4545 Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Atlanta, Georgia 30302 i Douglas C. Teper Mr. J. A. Bailey Georgians Against Nuclear Energy Project Licensing Manager 1253 Lenox Circle Southern Company Services, Inc. Atlanta, Georgia 30306 P.O. Box 2625 Binningham, Alabama 35202 Laurie Fowler Legal Environmental Assistance

! Ernest L. Blake, Jr. Foundation Bruce W. Churchill, Esq. 1102 Healy Building Shaw, Pittman, Potts and Trowbridge 57 Forsyth Street 1800 M Street, N.W. Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Washington, D. C. 20036 i

Tim Johnson Mr. G. Bockhold, Jr. Executive Director Vogtle Plant Manager Educational Campaign for Georgia Power Company a Prosperous Georgia Route 2, Box 299-A 175 Trinity Avenue, S.W.

Waynesboro, Georgia 30830 Atlanta, Georgia 30303 Regional Administrator Nuclear Regulatory Conunission Region II 101 Marietta Street,-N.W., Suite 2900 Atlanta, Georgia 30323 l

r

. - . __ . .- . __ . =_.

ENCLOStJRE 1 PARTICIPANTS NRC C Miller D. Terao Oak Ridge National Laboratory S. Moore E. Rodabaugh Southe'rn Company Services K. Kopecky Georgia Power Company D. Hudson Westinghouse R. Morrison C. Ng C. Benton W. Guerin K. Chang T. Besterci C. Ciocca B. Bishop C. Stull l

A. Baumgartner T. Adams D. Roarty T. Matty E. Johnson l

l

Enclosure 2 I_ETTER DAIE DAIA (1) BW-3202 1/30/81 original Surge Dwg. (Rev. 0)

(2) GP-5052 6/31/81 Data Chrification (3) GP-5124 8/13/81 Jet Data Clarification Request (4) BW-3457 8/14/81 Revision of Jet Data

.(5) A ksSA-1744 9/10/81 Resolution of Jet Quest.

(6) GP-5485 12/28/81 Identifies Changes to (12/4 Mtg. Minutes) to Dwg's. & Jets (7) BW-3556 12/17/81 Rev. 1 tran sitted With Hand Markups (8) BW-3565 12/29/81 Revised Jet Loads (9) BW-4034 6/21/83 As-Designed Package 1X4DL4A17, Rev. 7 i

l l

l l

2.

SURGE LINE SECTION 1 Microfilm Log

]

SECTION 2 Support Load Generation

]/ SECTION 3 Special' Component Qualification and Additional Work (Nozzle Loads, Etc.)

SECTION 4 Secon'dary Stress Qualification / Break Selection (Fatigue. Eq.#12, #13 Break Selection)

SECTION 5 Primary Stress Qualification (Eq. #9 Design / Faulted)

SECTION 6 Computer Solutions / Select / Combine (Dwt., Seismic, Thennal, Jet Etc.)

s SECTION 7 Modeling and UPDATES SECTION 8 BPC Initial Package /All Subsequent Packages /REF's SECTION 9 Final As-Designed Reconciliation l

l SECTION 10 BPC Final As-Designed Input l .

l l

l ,}

~

(*

  • Enclosure 3
  • - WESTINGHOUSE NUCLEAR TECHNOLOGY DIVISION -,

O . .

N PACS TTTLE 2.o. 9;

ec- , nn n u.. , .t . _ -

assA pm.J&c7 AwTwoA GATE ctg 3.sw cn.L3.av QA une, n.s 1. 977 /1 a<zM si I?n. d d /: '/'is, ATE

.... .. No. ..m. .

c - - s- ns a n u s/isp / A ... nA, '

O.wi Nian ..

. Goe6Me. locaa

. c.

bbab.a ceA was e t..

01 PomT n 1,5 Sm . .'

(2.) Po + tel + 1ose i 6 w ,. =* i ss m e,. t.5 sg .

1 (4') -\ k (3') Po+ \ct.JTl + [6L$cnitt int 16 +-(SSEi.,/z 4 F C. e . (D ' '

9 .

)* OWs0

(+) P,4 L owr +,_(b.cc ule t ser217+ (.ssdj A 3.osnj ,

    • .'M C0(,t')C1) r -

(s) Pe+ h 6ca( + l.leT3 4 3.CSM ,

(6) Pa + l.0WT +.1am A F.C .

0] Farisus em\m&l.a

~

l . (,o h % \coJ sc4s de%1 iv bedsme~tE.-

N. d.,.ie.by.J. mw. .vt a m v.s+ 4. E. o .

-tbc gie sno / ~t.c .. cat 75 O

(Q c2 bHu s3.cs, Pw&"e ouwt.1t mh Go C,b*)3' sh 6 3,cs n 9 a'e h(c&c6crt.Ej? & .

e R E v. A g v. Aufnom oAftcasc.sv DATE CMat 3. sv QATE No. DATE WESTINGMouSE 70 mas 582133

~ ' ~

~ ' * *

-~

WESTINGHOUSE NUCLEAR TECHNOLOGY DNISION i .

Aln-554 -/ M2 PAGE

( TIT LE

(' cea kun % nnouwus PROJECT AUTMOR DATE CM K'O. S V DATE CMK"D. S V 3 O. 7 OATE ucc n.1 d))n s islii .V ? "-*Mn onov, s.o. c uc.no. < siwe no.

wsw-\M iskh m ,t Po = te9 Pressu P,3 ope =+iq Pce e- - - .

twr= b.A g ht -

t.et = m

% oo k. Loep L ee a di9 1 wat. a- - - h a.

h4[IThk?D Ik MU- - k h oubk. \q ei14 boofcen) l cop

  • PG s twax w L&c A duplaema.1 eaw UE.

(( h braokenf lq d hbpomem loop deTs.= wxim MT I andw 4 o A Je74 6=m 4 % a n a k e h l g . ---.h ,, .

NEMM  % ^^ t ok MD M N OWbsmee.w -

4 bW loop bAswdes JET 3 w wwxme der \swd q b e Voe. h %

W. hw g ef hbrzokaw toop Ms ar4: Jer i  %~ hgh e_q \, a F. C . h + = 4 h @ M k li m b C r ge* )

a g y, AUTMOm DATE CMK'D.Sv DATE CM K'D. 9V DATE s g g y, ,

No. DATE UUSSTINOMOUSE pored 882130

. , . _ . _ . _ _ _ - , _ _ , . . . , . , - . , . . , _ _ . , _ , _ . _ - - _-, ..-,__-m.__.. _ _ _ _ _ - . _ - - - _ _ _ _ , - - . , - , , , - _ . , . _ -

v

.A j

MEETING

SUMMARY

DISTRIBUTION

(( NRC"PDR~

N I6(5]"IE W * "4/^425

""" ~~~ E !?

Local PDR NSIC PRC System LB #4 r/f Attorney, OELD E. Adensam Project ManageN. Miller Licensing Assistant M. Duncan NRC PARTICIPANTS M. Miller D. Terao bcc: Applicant & Service List '

e i

l 1.

l

. _ _ _ . _ . _ . . _ _ _ . _ . _ , _ _ _ . _ . _ , , _ _ . . _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _ _ _ . _ . . . _ _ _ _ . . . . _ .__.