ML20126D246
| ML20126D246 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Trojan File:Portland General Electric icon.png |
| Issue date: | 03/22/1980 |
| From: | Rosolie E NORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL ADVOCATES (FORMERLY COALITION |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8004230020 | |
| Download: ML20126D246 (4) | |
Text
F
'kN
- /
.s s. : >.2 s.. w s,.-
m:. :3. 7,..
DOCKgyga
,. s 3
- a...........
..,,,,,..,.t,..
USNp.
..... g c., a.
- e..... s.
3.
op MhR 2 51980y:
og.
__ s ee of tbs 6
Doct.ating& Q Bra
.) <
~,
.,c.
g
? >. r ". ". ". o. 50
.s.'s r
- v, %.. "., [. n. 7
, ').
N
' t.
.f L.
.~- _1..
)
[
'. 71 3. ! [ 1d i n g "
- d '. * ". a
~.
s.
.4.,. a..*a...
s e
a.,3..=.,...3...
r e.:.
.-)..,,,
e q.
-..;.s........,...s
.- o 3. e
.g b.
.., - p.. n, e d....
,, s.;.,.
.L.
3...
i....
7
.-s p
,,c,c. on. c,....,...,. s,. _..,.
- i..,.
- 4. 1. 32 s..
4
....4
..,.,.a.
.3 4.12
.,..a...
~..
"'?-a ib'
'ver. i f all c:jr em.-.s.
.-.!=
'.11 ev i e.
a t e.i ??. a.in i t s
-e,..
- a. y. 4. 3.,. 3,en v i,.,. 3
- 4.,..
,,......... 4. p.,.e..,
s.
4
.. y..
- 4.,..,
c(,.
.+
.s u
ro".Sc..S.
.0-..
.-* 1 a ' f
's\\
~. s. g u.o g g t. g
- c. v. 7J,..,.
- . n..
c.
.s a
.. v... s..,
. s.,
s.,
a.
3 o
- s.. :.,,
i t l n i' S.. tr.,. S O TO CC ed 4. r...
.
- 1.'
\\' e., ) v.t 4. 5, f o. r.. 4.o. ;,,.
a....
...e
.n, 3.
.....,.4.a.....LL.,,
s,. t.,a.
s...
... 3 " #. g g. Op (..,.,,. 9.. 3 a. e...
,.,....,.g.1 f
,.. 3 7.
4, 3.s., e,. 4..4..,.. L. e...
- c y.
I 4-
.: ao ' -111e'i.
his conclusion la he on
..o a.;s ;.;;: ions: th at t h.3
. :2510 $ r'.1. in 11 Certain p4: Hin an-1 th? c0115 ire
- '!GCd in S 0el snien would be triequate :.o pro ect the bcr.coner.:.
3-):5 of these c. =u p-e
- inn, cannot be made Fiven the r5-orr' in tis cm.
9":'.on 4.3
- n t'is se<.!.-
1: ~..n - i 3. 4
-'.1:
.c am* wnod stru;tur9.s r
w:11 be ased in certa!- arns.
- : sc - <. 3.ra u - ' s t' n!;ctures will ie re.nvet for fire protectior. and in 0:hers they vil'. > allo ind to re.ain.
In see this as a contradte. ion.
.., i
- n... t. o n s..,.., -..,,,,.
2 -.....
e :,.
..., o
...,..s
...a swo every hour.
- 'h ere i s no i !i ct.t i s-sha :Sie persin will be, i.e.
- .apo rny employne,
O p.c.*31oy ee. 9c ri., 1 :ard.
hother prubl.n in tr.bs section is no evacation is done to aswes what the consequences would be 1: a fire occarre<!.hile equipment was l
l ocinn. noved, especially in the %ble breading aoon ind in particular 1
's r' A'l 1
~
ese.w:1 bi r* nl.u:!c -w - ru ro ca.
""are
'.e ci. n or d 1 8 () 0 4 ~ygJ u. nom
,A 1
i
e this section and others that the most favorable conditions are assumed to be in place.
From. this we go to the viewing gallery area and the removal of the stairwell.
It is' our understanding tha: the viewing gallery is to
~
serve a particular function during emergency situations.
Its function will increase as a result of TMI Lessons Learned. :;owhere are these two considerations taken into consideration.
Section 4.5 Once again it is a case of assuming the most ootimum condi-tions.
Section 4.6 Except for Plate 8 thic section assumes the most favorabic conditions.
An example is under section 4.7 1 where licensee addressed the unlikely event of ourside louver being impaired by and' earthquake etc.
We cannot help wondering why such an evaluation was no: done for the installation of the plates.
'Section 4.13 The final paragraph of this section is nothing more than double talk.
At one point it says the safety related equipment will remain qualified but goes on to say that the conclusions just drawn are contin 6enet upon "the completion of the review... "
15-16-1 ('a) Mo.
15-16-1 (b) same as response to interrgoatory 12-4.
15-16-1(c)(i)Same as response to interrogatory C12-4 15-16-1( c)( li)
Inadequecies in protecting safety related equipment are mentioned in interrogatory C12-4.
le would repeat that in the majority of cases only the most favorable conditions were considered.
As for the listing of all safety related equipmen; we are still in the process of cross-checking the SER with responses to the other inter-'
4 rogatories.
In this matter it would be useful to have a list of all the safety-related equipment -- basic information not availcble to this party.
C17-5 (a) No
3.
1 nse to "interrogatch C12-4
~
C17-3 '(b) Dre as res C17-5 Co) (i)3.vne as response to ir.terro?,atory C12-4 "17-5(e)(li) 3ection '4. 3 -- sce response to 'interror,atory C12-4
~
S*. tion 4 5 -- see respoEse to interrogatory C12-4 sectii>n 4.5 -- u. der this section on noise and vibration we feel that
. both of tnese items can be resolved by a committment on the part
,e do of the NRC Staff inspectors to closely monitor the situatioa.
7.. -
+
x,. r...
<.+
have two' concerns riot mentioned in the SER.
yirst is the effect of noise in work areas on the ability of workers
?
a.
and operators to respond to alarms.
Secondly, the effect of vibration on instrunents used to monitor reactor operation.
a.
n 1
- . e: -
c,, e: r.-
.,o.
t Date! this day Respectfully subr.itted,
- p% (/n1:%cw:.ru the 22st of Mar:h, 1930
/
t,uggne Rosolie, pr> 3 Coalition for Saf:.'ouer O
4 p4 8h.D N 9 m
=
4 9
- _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ --___- 7 NUCLEAR REGULATORY CO:0!!SSIOli 4~
//
.g S"g DEFOPI 'TI!E I.TC:!IC S A*'?"".'
m "
-.....c
". e.
.=n y + $ 7p g 4 SELATED CORRESPO'RDEM 6%.., u? htay (6
A.r,'
Ir. the I!atter of
}
4
$' N
)
C,,
W O
PORTLA: D GE.' EF.AL ELECTRIC CC :PA::Y,
)
Docket ::o. 50-344 N'
el al.
)
F-(Cor. trol Building Proceedir.g) s.rojan !:uclear Plant)
~
)
CERTI FICA 6: OF 3ER'/IFE
' ~~
~
l hereby certify.that on March 2 2, 19 90,. "Ci?SP RESPO SES TO ';RC I';TER*tSG AERII3 He,SE T'r., SET 'mREE," has been. serve i. by placin:; true copies of sai i io. c.ent in the '1 S. mail, first class, postage pre-paid, to the parties I
listad below:
..' O.
Marshall C. ". iller..'E d.S f.hnir6an ~
Atomi.c S'afety and Licensing Board
~
Atomic 'Sa f e t? anJ ' l.icen.s in 1:..eu d
,, Pancl' U.
S. flu c l o c r' F..c u.l g t iry.0,un c.i r,3 i e n :.
L'.. S..
- ae ;,r a.; ult ; e.. Coi
- : mis s ien Washington, D. C. ~20555 Washing.ca, p.
C.
Ir. M 5 1 Dr. Ecnneth A. :::Collem, Dean
./.t omic Sa f e t. On:! Licencin;; Appeal Divir ton of En;d n,;e r inn,
Doord Archit5cture and Technology U. s. ::ae :cc: n.c,ultit ry Commission Okishcra State 1:n:versit:.
Wa s h in:j t un, D.
C.
2 0.E 5 5 Stillwster, Gklahoma 74074 D i ch ar 1 5 :. ;vi c?
500 l'ac! fic Buildin.-
Dr. Ilugh C. l,uxton
~
- "' # I ll 1229 - 41st Street Los Alcmos, !!ew Mexic.o; 97544 l',.' rt l and"'('
'17 "in 4 Joseph R. Gray, Er.r;.
i nn,e r
- 1. -
n.<a, Counsel for !!P.C Sta f f Lo. c. n s t.. i n, :.c r.n n, ;,.i, !. A r.e l r c d l.I. S. !!uc ! car Regulat ory Cc::enission Suite 1 :l /.
Washington, D.
C.
20555 102 5 C s:.nce t i: u. Ave., :.
4.
'Ja s h i nt.t e n, ifC. C.
2uOM.
Colute.bia Coun,ty Cour thouse Law Librar:
!;in a ".11 7 "' " ' "r
'o$
Circuit Court Roor:
Po rtl ~u.
g j i i ;. ' 1 ' c~ '. '>. 9 7 '1 's St. licleno, Orce,on 97051 r' i " e. ' Esc.
Doche*ina and Serv 2ce Section i
' ~~
Office c.y the S.e c ret a r,a.
Beimeville ru ter Adaintstr: tion U.
S. !;ueleat Renu ! a t i.'r v Cor,mi n s i on P. 0-J ' ',,'
- "X.
Washington, D. C.
,, 0., 5 '5 Po rt i cnd, Cr<u' on 9,/-so i
l%:uld
r.nn En;. (!GF.)
121 ;.'. 311-on.
' o r t l.w !, o r, 0 7.'0 's
'4 Dated this day, the 22nd of '! arch,
/
1930, Portland Ore 6on.
-- i-g]
ury n s'. o:/ t i.', pr,s ns.
..1 i r hon r,,
r.,i,....
_, _ _ _ _ _ _,. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ - - - - _ _ _