ML20118B596

Forwards Results of Evaluation of Licensed Operator Requalification Exam Conducted During Wk of 920824 & Summary of Exam Results.Some Operator Retraining Needed Re Performance of EOP Immediate Actions

ML20118B596
Person / Time
Site:	Beaver Valley
Issue date:	09/03/1992
From:	Sieber J DUQUESNE LIGHT CO.
To:	Bettenhausen L NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
Shared Package
ML20118B590	List: ML20118B596
References
NG2VPN:7144, NUDOCS 9210050194
Download: ML20118B596 (17)

Text

..- - - . - - - - - - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - - - - - --~ .

t f i en a ey Vvser tast< ors

%,pe nw.n pA mna >.

l 417) 593 '2M som t u ntn

Vice hetodent Nackar Omp September 3, 1992 l

NG2VPN: 7144 Mr. Lee H. Dettenhausen

! Operations Branch Division of Reactor Safety U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Conunission Region 1 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA 19406 i Referer.ce: Beaver Valley Power Station, Unit 2 Docket No. 50-412, Licensed NPF-73 Licensed Operator Requalification Examination Report Dear Mr. Bettenhausen The purpose of this letter is to provide the results of Duquesne Light Company's evaluution of the Licensed Operator Requalification Examination conducted at Unit 2 the week of August 24, 1992. A summary of the examina'. ion reiults is provided along with individual results for each operater examined. These examination results indicate that the 3eaver Valley Licended Operator Requalification Program is satisf actory overall and that some operator retraining is needed in defined areas.

! We will take necessary corrective actions based on the examination l results. A list of areas needing general training emphasis is attached, l and is being used to enhance the operator retrair.ing program.

l l' In our view the revised examination process continues to work well.

The NRC Examination Team interacted effectively with Beaver Valley personnel to administer the examination.

t 1

. Af 9210050194 920923 PDR

~

ADOCK 05000412 V ppg .

- . - - . . - . - . . . ~ . - . . - - - _ . - . - - - .. .- . , - . . . - ..

. 4 4

Lee H. Bettenhausen September 3, 1992 NG2VPN: 7144 j Page 2 If there are any questions regarding our evaluation of the examination ;

or our corrective actions, please contact Mr. T. W. Burns, Director-Operations Training at (412) 393-5751, or Mr. E. Chatfield, Nuclear Training Manager at (412) 393-5710.  ;!

Very truly yours,

.t -

ctAk7 <n J. D, Sieber +J Vice President, Nuclear JDS/TEK/mnm Enclosure cc: MR. T. T. Martin, NRC Region 1 Administrator Mr. L. Briggs, Chief Examiner Mr. A. W. DeAgatio, Project Manager l Document Control Desk I

i t

l

( , 'I l

- .....>,..,_J

- ...._,,,.._.;...a~..._L.-...___.,,..._,._.-,m.,,.m_,._,,._r..,.s=.,--,,_, ,,,,J.-, . , , , - .-_,---.~.~

l

)

i l

DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 74 - AUGUST 20, 1992 The following areas were identified as needing additional training emphasis in the Licensed Operator Retraining Program:

RCit1911 EXiUn The Emergency Plan definition of REQUIRED SHUTDOWN.

Elant Walk-through EXan -

The function ot' a 120V Vital Bus inverter tracking rectifler.

(iipu_lgto_I EKan Communications - operators taking actions without supervisor knowledge, repeat back of orders and/or failure of supervision to acknowledge operator input.

Cc.nmand and control - operators provided suggested actions and supervisor response was slow, along with failure to ask clarifying questions, supervisor distracted from setting expected priorities.

The following areas were identified as needing additional training emphasis for certain individuals:

The proper performance of EOP immediate actions.

The Emergency Plan classification for an ATWS.

i

BEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24 - AUGUST 28, 1992

.EXAMINATLON EUMhlW BISPLLTS. EAC_JLJ_TX HYALy_ATORS. ]

1 SIMULATOR: F. Schuster i 8/24/92 1 Crew Passed Manager Unit 2 Operations 8/25/92 2 Crews Passed L. G. Schad simulator Training Supervisor PLANT WALK-THROUGH: i 8/26 -8/27/92 12 Individuals Passed T. E. Kuhar l Licensed Operator 1 Training Supervisor R. J. Brooks Senior Nuclear j Operations Instructor - j T. Gaydosik ,

Senior Nuclear

-Operations Instructor

- R. E. Kahler H Simulator Instructor l l

WRITTEN:

8/28/92 12 Individuals Passed T. E. Kuhar Licensed Operator Training Supervisor A. Cannizzaro Assistant Nuclear Shift Supervisor R. E. Kaar Simulator Instructor R. J. Brooks Senior Nuclear Operations Instructor OVERALL: 12 Individuals Passed 3 Crews Passed

- +-pNy -w w- $- p ' 7**b--*' '

- - - _ . - _ - . _ . -. . . ..- . . -.- - . - - . - . ~ . . - - - . - - . - . . .. -. . - . - _ _ -._ . ....- . -.

DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, 1992 JEDX_V_lD.llhL! . A JPE_HUEDER TbSK QESTJOL1 QUES _ TION 2  ;

2CR-007 SAT SAT 2CR-025 SAT 2PL-005 SAT SAT 2PL-062 SAT 2PL-065 SAT UNSAT l

2CR-046 SAT 2CR-511 SAT SAT 2CR-060 SAT 2PL-004 SAT SAT 2PL-037 SAT OVERALL GRADE 1 97.5% for JPMs PASS WRI_TIEN_t SECTION A 100%

SXQTION B 100%

OVERhhh 100% PASS BIMULATOR: INDIVIDUAL PASS

_CREM M8_S. .

e-,

W T e- g-'. z 1-1 -m y -

F w-*-w'm F - f- r---m. - -w --4 _ + m - .-- -'a---- -* - 6

_ _ _ . . _. _ ._ _ _ - _ _ - _ _ . . . _ _ _ _ _ . . _ _ . . . _ _ _ = _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . _ _ _ . __

l

\

DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 l REQUALIFICATION EXAM l

.TUGUDT 24-28, 1992 '

JNDI?]DNhhL , 13 RN_NUNDE!t TABE RUMTlgNd QMLBIIOR_A 2CH-007 SAT 2CH-025 SAT SAT 2 PI .~ 0 0 5 SAT 2PL-062 UNDAT SAT I l

2PL-005 SAT

]

2CR-046 SAT. SAT 2CR-511 SAT 2CR-060 SAT SAT 2FL-004 SAT 2 PL-O'a 7 SAT SAT l

OlERMdcGRhDM1

_ 97.5% for JPMs yASE MRI.TIRN1 HUGTJ_ONJ 96.2%

SEC_TJ ON_Q 1001 QYERALL 98.1% PA8_B SIMU.hhTQlli J NDJ.VJ D#hL FILSA c3RH EAs_a

._. ._ -_ .-- . -. . _ . . _ . . . . . - . _ - . . . _ _ ~. . .

- _ - - = . .._ _ -- . ._

BEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, 1992 XMD121Mhi 1. t C JPM__NU_MDJ_B TA S_E_ _ OUESTLON._1 Q~UESTION 2 2CR-007 SAT 2CR-025 SAT SAT 2PL-005 SAT SAT 2PL-065 SAT UNSAT I 2PL-011 SAT 2CR-046 SAT SAT 2CR-511 SAT 2CR-060 SAT 2PL-004 UNBAT SAT 2PI-037 SAT l

OJERN:L GRAD _El 95% for JPMs ESEE KRI.T.TMNl SECTLON A 92.3%

ECTIONJ 99.5%

QVIRALL 96.0% FAga SJMLATORl INDIVIDUb_L FASS CRER PASS

l DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, 1992 INDIXIDMAkt ,

C IPK _]IUjiDJ R Tb8Y QUEB11ON 1. QMR U T]_0_N_R 2CR-007 UAT 2CR-025 SAT SAT 2PL-005 SAT SAT 2PL-065 SAT UNBAT 2PL-011 S A','

2CR-046 SAT SAT 2CR-511 SAT 2CR-060 SAT 2PL-004 UNSAT SAT 2PL-037 SAT QVERT.LL_GRADR1 95% f or JPMs PADR WRIT _ TERT _s2 c T oF J 92.3%

.sgcTJ_ON_J 99.5%

OVERALL 96.O% PMS GIliULAT.OR1 IlipIVIDUAL P3SS cREH Pass

i 4

DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, 1992

]

INDIYJIRMALl . D LPJLEUMp1B TASK QURDILOR,J QEDTION 2 2CR-007 SAT SAT 2CR-025 SAT 2PL-005 SAT 2PL-065 SAT 2PL-011 SAT SAT 2CR-046 SAT  !

l 2CR-511 SAT SAT 2CR-060 SAT SAT 2PL-004 SAT 2PL-037 SAT SAT OVER_hhk GRADE: 100% for JPMs PABE l

WRITTgNl SECTION A 88.5%

HEQTION D 99.5%

OV_ERhhL 94 1% PAaa SIMULATOR 1 INDIVIDUAL PASS CREW PASS

. -. .~ . ., , , .-, -- . - . . . - - . . - .-

l

\

I DEEVER VALLEY UNIT 2  !

REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, 1992 INDIlIAUAht . E

.J_EM_RUMBER ThDK Qi[ESTION 1 QU_ED_ TION 2 2CR-007 SAT SAT 2CR-025 f'AT 2PL-005 SAT SAT 2PL-062 SAT 2PL-065 SAT UNSAT 2CR-046 SAT 2CR-511 SAT SAT 2CR-060 SAT 2PL-004 SAT SAT 2PL-037 SAT l

OlEBAkh_._GEZLDPd. 97.5% for JPMs PA88 WJ3IREN_t DECTION A 92.3%

SECTION D 94.2

-}VERALL 93.3% EARR 81H2LATORI. INDIVIDUAL PA8_H CREN PASS

DEAV3R VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-20, 1992 INDIVIDt!hLL , F J EM__HUMBER TASK QUJSTION 1 QMESIIAt{_2_

2CR-007 SAT 2CR-025 SAT SAT 2PL-005 SAT 2PL-062 SAT SAT 2PL-065 SAT _,

2CR-046 SAT SAT 2CR-511 SAT 2CR-060 SAT SAT 2PL-004 SAT 2PL-037 SAT UNSAT OVERALk_GRADEL 97.5% for JPMs RAS S_

WBJTTENJ_N SERTION A 88.5%

fLECTIO_N_Il 100%

OVERALL 94.2% PASS SIMULATOR 1 LNDIVIDUAL RASS CREW PASS

- ...-- ..--- _ ._ _ = -. . .. . _ . - ...-_. _.-._-__-- - - _ _.. . .

i

• j i

DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, 1992 IHpl1XP%ht .

G JPM_)f.UMDEB TAS_K ___ Q 1LE S T I O N 1 QU_ESTION 2 2CR-007 SAT FAT 2CR-025 SAT 2PL-005 SAT 2PL-065 SAT 2PL-011 SAT SAT 2CR-046 SAT 2CR-511 SAT SAT 2CR-060 UNDAT SAT 2PL-004 SAT 2PL-037 SAT SAT

_OJERALL GR3pE: 97.5% for JPMs PASR HRIITElil SECTLOlLa 96.2%

8ECJ1QH_Il 87.0%

OVERALL 91.5% PJLSB

.BJ_M_UJL ATOR : INDIVIDUAL P_AS.S C_R_EW l' ASS

= .- + _ _ m.m... __ _ _ _ _ . c.--..- . m-, , - , . , _ m._ _ _ _ _ . . _ y - , _v--

4 DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, 1992 INDIVIDUALJ. 11 JPM NUMDER TASK QUESTION 1 QLLESTION 2 2CR-007 SAT 2CR-025 SAT UNSAT 2PL-005 SAT SAT 2PL-065 SAT UNSAT 2PL-011 SAT 2CR-046 SAT SAT 2CR-511 SAT 2CR-060 SAT 2PL-004 SAT SAT 2PL-037 SAT OYERALL_GRhD_El 95% for JPMG _P_A S S_

HR_I.T_TENJ_ SECTION_h 96.2%

SECTION_D 96.3%

OV_ERALL 96.2% PASS SIMULATOR; INDIV_IDUAL PASS cREM P_ ASS

DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, 1992 INDlVJRUATd , I l

LPM NUMDER TASK QRESTION 1 QUESTION 2 2CR-007 SAT 2CR-025 SAT SAT 2PL-005 SAT SAT l

2PL-062 SAT l i

2PL-065 SAT UNSAT 2CR-046 SAT SAT 2CR-511 SAT 2CR-060 SAT 2PL-004 SAT SAT 2PL-037 SAT OVERAIJ, GRADM 97.5% for JPMs _P388 WRITTENJ RECIION A 84.6%

1. E_CLION D 92.3%

OVERALL 88.5% PASS l

. SI.liULATOM .INDIVIDUA_L PASS

b. b.

DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, la92 INDIVJDUALi . J

_JULN.UMDER 'thU r, QUES.TIOR_1 QUKSYI_OtL2 2CR-007 SAT SAT 2CR-025 SAT 2PL-005 SAT 2PL-062 SAT SAT 2PL-065 SAT 2CR-046 SAT 2CR-511 SAT SAT 2CR-060 SAT SAT 2PL-004 SAT 2PL-037 SAT SAT OVERhLL_GRADEl 100% for JPMs P A 8_B_

ERIITENi 8EC119N_h 84.6%

B_ECJJON D 100%

OVERALL 92.31 PASS BJMULAT9RL IND_IVIDUAL PASS CREW PASS

.. - - - - .. ~ _ - . . . . . - . _ . - . . - . . - . _ _ - . . - . _ . - . . - . _ _ ..

0 DEAVER VALLEY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24-28, 1992 INDIYIQUM1 , K JPM_RU_MDER TASK QUES.T_ ION 1 QU_ESTION 2 2CR-007 SAT 2CR-025 SAT JAT 2PL-005 SAT 2PL-065 SAT 2PL-011 SAT SAT 2CR-046 SAT SAT 2CR-511 SAT 2CR-060 SAT SAT 2PL-004 SAT 2PL-037 SAT SAT OVERALL_ GRADE 1 100% for JPMs PASR HRI.TTEH1 HRCT_LON A 92.3%

H.ECTION E 94.4%

OXERALL 93.4% PASS HIMULATOR__ .I_NDIV_IDUhL PASS

. CREW P28_8

.+

DEAVER VAL 7/EY UNIT 2 REQUALIFICATION EXAM AUGUST 24 28, 1992 IRDI_YJDUALI L JJPM_EUMBER _ TAUK QUJE B_T_I_0_N_1 QUESTIOI.i_R 2CR-007 SAT SAT 2CR-02S SAT 2PL-005 SAT SAT 2PL-06S SAT UNSAT

{

2PL-01) SAT q 2CR-046 SAT 2CR 511 SAT SAT 2CR-060 SAT ',

2PL-004 SAT SAT 2PL-037 SAT OVERALL GRhDEL 97.5% for JPMs ph88_

HEITTEfL BECTIp1LA 96.2%

SECTION D 96.3%

QVERALL 96.2% PASS BIMUIATOAL INDIVIDUAL PASB CREW PASA j i g