ML20116G431
| ML20116G431 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | South Texas  |
| Issue date: | 04/26/1985 |
| From: | Gutterman A HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER CO., NEWMAN & HOLTZINGER |
| To: | Bechhoefer C, Eva Hill, John Lamb Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#285-782 OL, NUDOCS 8505010490 | |
| Download: ML20116G431 (9) | |
Text
,
W1 4
hg%
NEWMAN Be HOLTZINGER, R C 1615 L ST RECT, N. W.
WASHI N GTO N, D. C. 2003 6 wi Au E. n AE=.sn.
00CMETED E..tu. E.O.,. A.,N ES JAcm R.NEwWAN sonN E.* ottrim.E.sa.
g vkeg 'AmE[nAo 2O2 - 95 5-0 6OO
$ANCvE eItc((n "
".[A. BOu nNI.HT, J R.
MERLE w. F ALLON*
J Paul M.RECE STEVEN R FRAN72 M "l' i '.,*,'E, April 26, 1985 '85 APR 30 NO:46:v"L"f'"oSE.
david POWELL 00u.LAS6.OREEN oEBORAM L. MAwalNS oaITUS ouY"Na".
0FflCE OF eECRETARy
%*[,",2*u",'o*l',"A, 00ChETWCi A SEBVib.
nEviN s. uPSON sA=ES e.vAsiLE MICHAEL A SAUSER 3
g{y david g.na$niN E
P.O LLEN
,e LDJ.SLytmMA,e THOMAS A.SCMMut!
JACOLYN A.SIMMON S JOSEPH E.StussS espCHAEL F. HEALT
' ADec. W A.
posEnt s wMett ROSENT LOWENSTEIN Charles Bechhoefer, Esq.
" "*" *i', A *," ' "* ^"
O, C Chairman, Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Dr. James C. Lamb, III Administrative Judge 313 Woodhaven Road Chapel Hill, NC 27514 i
Ernest E. Hill Administrative Judge Hill Associates 210 Montego Drive Danville, CA 94526 Ret Houston Lighting & Power Company, et al.
South Texas Project, Units 1 and 2 Docket Nos. 5 0-4 9 8 and 50-4 9 90_.-
Dear Members of the Board:
Subsequent to Applicants' April 19, 1985 letter trans-mitting various documents to the Board and the parties pursuant to the Board's request in its February 26, 1905 Memorandum and Order (Memorandum and Order), two additional documents within the scope of the Board's request have been identified.
Those documents are (1)
Excerpts of notes of the July 27, 1981 STP Management Committee meeting by C. G. Thrash (typed and handwritten versions); and (2)
Excerpts of draft and final minutes of the September 12, 1981 meeting of STP participants (both dated September 22, 1981).
'h 501o490sp426ADOCK o g 8 Q
~.
NEWNAN O Hotcrz:wonn, R C.
Charles Bechhoefer, Esq.
Dr. James C. Lamb, III Ernest E. Hill April 26, 1985 Page Two The referenced documents are attached, and we apologize for the inconvenience.
In addition, in Attachment B to Applicants' April 19 letter, seven documents within the scope of the Board's Memorandum and Order, but withheld pursuant to protective order in the Houston Lighting & Power Co., et al. v. Brown
& Root, Inc., et al., litigation were ffsted! ~ Applicants indicated, in EEaE letter, that they were applying to the court for authorization to release the protected documents.
On April 22, Applicants filed a motion with the court requesting that the documents be released.
The court has granted the motion and instructed Applicants to prepare an order for its signature and to obtain Brown & Root's con-currence with the text of the order.
Applicants are preparing that order and will provide the documents to the Board upon its execution.
Respectfully submitted,
& // W 1 ~
-~
Jack R. Newman Maurice Axelrad Alvin H. Gutterman Steven P. Frantz Donald J. Silverman 1615 L Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20036 Finis E. Cowan 3000 One Shell Plaza Houston, Texas Dated:
April 26, 1985 ATTORNEYS FOR HOUSTON LIGHTING NEWMAN & HOLTZINGER, P.C.
& POWER COMPANY, Project Manager 1615 L Street, N.W.
of the South Texas Project acting Washington, D.C.
20036 herein on behalf of itself and the other Applicants, THE CITY BAKER & BOTTS OF SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS, acting by 3000 One Shell Plaza and through the City Public Houston, Texas 77002 Service Board of the City of San Antonio, CENTRAL POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY, and CITY OF AUSTIN, TEXAS cc:
Service List
5 Excerpt Within'Scopa of Board's itnqus5t ~
~~
" ' ' " ~ ~
Notes of July 27, 1981 STP Managemnnt Committ:c M sting s
Ex. 1 1 Pipe h,s r 3 Conduit Sep work prograssmed &
Isol. Valve cubicle 3 IVC prob.
proceeding 4 Tna E.L Q re P&C 5 Am 3r 'J etill with us. - will be longer hold up CT. Supp 6 Paint & C etc (Yes - Thompson) 7 Quadrex review O milti bolts Vendor Control prog 9 VCP release sys 10 NCR poston Q during disc' of item 6 - Paint & C
- what doing to correct?
when
?
seed to salterelli Barker erelli discussed J AMl bik D
se
- subj panel to high rad level
- economic, not licens, prob
- post TMI Eawks re diff coating sys in RCE
- long story why*7
- test may show OK
- worst case result f
- blast off a recoat re Mech Aux j
Poston - repeated O re when
- Eawks = could be 30-60-90 day period we expected test sample to be OK (Mue11aer explained half of panel OK - half blistered) are our stos too conservative?
(9:45+1 Williass salterelli - thinks we can left7 analyse our way Thomp out out of it.
f 9507-950 Gibson explained
- 16 hr weekday sched on coating
- ? weekdend on blasting CO Q
- when blasting to be complete (Eawks - Oct.)
Thoop said mech to begin in Oct.
[9:55)
Barker - Item 7 Quadrex (exh. 9) have rec'd S&R response re plan of action RLQ - any glitches?
Barker - many problems.
Goldberg - prc, gram runs thru '32 Poston - let's bear about main one salterelli - computer code verific
- have contractor hired to verify
- expect to complete by and yr
- a paper prob.
[
- good engr prge to verify
- but for some reason wasn't done in past (on some?)
Outside pipe brooks Work sched -
EVAC don't expect gg maj preb unless major glitch encountered 00480
[
Excerpt Within Scopo of Board's Rsquast s
Notes of July 27, 1981 STP Management Committee Meeting Poston - are there any real serious prob areas.
Salt - list is of but. IL=a.
that could have serious effect
,,gg (blow out of water)
- what we're trying to avoid 8
taking out of design seg, s
von R Q - what report to WRC Computer code verif Shsendsag later removed EVAC (1004 and) soldberg -
Design out of sequence
- outside pipe should have been designed 4 years ago.
. - functional environment of eq. will have to be re-studied (some eq may have to be re-qual.)
salt - hopes to have all Cab Tr Supp designed by aid '82.
- large bore pipe design is critical item.
(may have to take some risks of redo) poston - won't you run into conflicts even w/ model?
Salt - will have angre on site.
Bawks - can modify 13')C9 End]
I poston 0 - Bow did this happen?
Salt - lack of coord between i
I toch disciplines.
- we found things a year ago that Ousdrex found I don't know this year ( poor tech.
b h they didn't interface) consider pipe rupture outside contain -
won't try Some to explain sites Barker re Illti Dolts - tests show can use l
RL Q - sow long on hit list (since last Fall) sopes to have off list in 2 mes Salt expl. programmatic rather than materist defic prob.
[1014) sarker re vendor eentrol prog release sys
- based on report yesterday we think we're getting the control we need - haven't found any ites that has to be redene.
- WTrs' eve party will mark coupletion.
Barker re NCRs
- some tied up w/ Am Bridge.
i l
asked Salt if he wanted to say anything more about any item (Wo)
$1129 1
RL wanted disc of turnover now vs last year wasn't it ""f),4 last year 00481 Salt -
- turnover Salt - in last 6 mos no key tarnever
~
'.s.Ti C...............................................~.....'.......~..oi.....<
Excerpt Within Scope of Board's Request Notes of iluly 7, 1981 STP Mana'gement Committee Meeting 9 && [es4.9
& fg f
- -- k
-.f
.,a l ^e y,
. 4 ee 3, : x < -
y/,
A&
-J v
L h.
s p, U,+:t*L U
"Y
?-
M
- - -~ 1,. s. 1
.-r.u_g&
p/
n.
n-e:xm ff
^
g I
M es
/a u--.~..
.. m
& f W = ?.
. hy
~~,
Y
^
i W- _y
't-o, l
\\
(fb-La Nw d&
g
.g, __.. m.
g_Qg H^
t
~ ;,9.. -
w r o,
w.
1-
,,,..i.
y v..
... _ _..,. f..
.,Q /h h--.- -
..f.
" b r g & * - Y
. ~.
_.......vg==
^ - &w -
0,.
_ h #0f
- Whq 31136 n~------
.-wm,,,n.nnn.-
m,.w,,,.
em a mn.
(
Excerpt Within Scope of Board's Request Minuten of Ssptember 12, 1981 Meeting of STP Participants l
Re Discussions among STP participants September 22, 1981 regarding replacement of Architect /
Engineer and Construction Manager i
r At 1:00 p.m. on September 12, 1981 the following i rcpresentatives of the participants met to discuss this Cubject City of Austin, Messrs. Nancock and Pokorny City of San Antonio, Messrs. Poston and von Rosenberg CPL, Messrs. Range and Muench NL&P, Messrs. Oprea, Goldberg and Jordan
)kMessrs.NewmanandCowanandthewriterwerealsoinattendance.
Mr. Jordan began the meeting by explaining that the 3CEOsoftheparticipantshadwantedmembersoftheManagement Committee to meet with RL&P today, prior to the meetir.g of the CEOs and members of the Management Committee with EL&P on September 15.
Mr. Jordan offered to stay as long as the persons Mr. Jordan.
present wished to stay to get any questions answered.
cxplained that Messrs. Oprea and Goldberg would describe the cnalysis procedure and then that he, Mr. Jordan, would explain the decision ML&P had made.
Mr. Oprea outlined the presentation to be made by IjMessrs.Goldberg,NewmanandCowan,concerningproposalanalysis, licensing and contract problems, respectively.
Mr. Oprea Cxplained briefly the procedure that had been followed in request-ing proposals snd also explained the meeting which he and Mr.
Goldberg had rectitly had with Messrs. Syphert and Collins of the MRC's Region IV office in Arlington.
Mr. Oprea reported that the MRC was leaning in the direction of a decision that the Quadrex report required a 55e report by NL&P on an " engineering Control breakdown" under criterion 7.
At 1:16 Mr. Goldberg began a discussion of the following
- 3 documents which had been passed out by Mr. Oprea:
L Exhibit A.
A page entitled "IV. Criteria for W Evaluation and overview of Proposals" g
Exhibit 3.
Request for proposals, dated July 24, F 1981 (five pages)
Exhibit C.
August 24 letter to Sechtel Exhibit D.
August 18 letter to Ebasco Exhibit E.
August 21 letter to Stone & Webster
& 6 003 1
I Excorpt Within Scopa of Board's Request Minutos of S2ptember 12, 1981 Meeting of STP Particinants.1 SOPtembar 27,195 hte Diccuccitna among STP participant 3 regarding replacement of Architect /
Engineer and construction Manager At 1:00 p.m. on September 12, 1981 the following rcpresentatives of the participants met to discuss this subject:
City of Austin, Messrs. Nancock and Pokorny City of San Antonio, Messrs. Poston and von Rosenberg CPL, Messrs. Range and Muench ML&P, Messrs. Oprea, Goldberg and Jordan Q Messrs. Newman and Cowan and the writer were also in attendanc Mr. Jordan began the meetin &g by explaining that the
= 4--
$5 CEO's of the participants had wanted the Manag, ment Committee to meet with NL&P today, prior to the meeting of the CEO's and hhMana entCommitteewithRL&P[r Mr. Jordan offered to stay as long as the persons present wished to stay to get any questions answered.
Mr. Jordan explained that Messrs.-
As Oprea and Goldberg " ' c if: S the analysis procedure and then that he, Mr. Jordan, would explain the decision NL&P had made.
Mr. Oprea outlined the presentation to be made by Messrs. Goldberg, Newman and Cowan, concerning proposal analysis, licensing and contract problems, respectively.
Mr. Oprea explainedbrieflytheprocedurethathafbeenfollowedinrequest-ing proposals and also explained the meeting which he and Mr.
Goldberghaq th Messrs. By rt and Collins of the NRC's Region IV office in Arlington.
Mr. Oprea reported that the NRC was leaning in the direction of a decision that the Quadrex ntrol report required a 55c$' report by RL&P on an " engineer breakdown" under criterion 7.
At 1:16 Mr. Goldberg began a discussion of the following documents which had been passed out by Mr. Oprea:
6 6 010 1
ED CORRESPO@M UNITED STTTES OF AMERICA DOLK TED U
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD 5 PPR 30 N0:4 In the Matter of
)
0FFlCE OF $EC tJ/in '
00CKETgt g W
)
HOUSTON LIGHTING & POWER
)
Docket Nos. 50-498 OL COMPANY, ET AL.
)
50-499 OL
)
(South Texas Project, Units 1 )
and 2)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a copy of Applicants' letter to the Board dated April 26, 1985 regarding production of additional documents pursuant to the Board's February 26, 1985 Memorandum and Order (with enclosures where designated) has been served on the following individuals and entities either by deposit in the United States mail, first class, postage prepaid, on April 26, 1985 or by air courier as indicated by "*" on April 26, 1985.
0* Charles Bechhoefer, Esq. (w/encls.)
- Brian Berwick, Esq. (w/encls.)
Chairman, Administrative Judge Assistant Attorney General Atomic Safety and Licensing for the State of Texas Board Panel Environmental Protection U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Division Washington, D.C.
20555 411 W. 13th Street Austin, TX 78701 (Monday delivery)
- Dr. James C. Lamb, III(w/encls. )
Administrative Judge Kim Eastman, Co-coordinator 313 Woodhaven Road (Saturday Barbara A. Miller Chapel Hill, NC 27514 delivery)
Pat Coy Citizens Concerned About
- Ernest E. Hill (w/encls. )
Nuclear Power Administrative Judge 5106 Casa Oro Hill Associates (Saturday San Antonio, TX 7,8233 210 Montego Drive delivery)
Danville, California 94526
- Lanny Alan Sinkin (w/encls.)
3022 Porter St.
N.W.,
- 304 Mrs. Peggy Buchorn (w/encls.)
Washington, D.C.
20008 Executive Director Citizens for Equitable
- Ray Goldstein, Esq.
Utilitics, Inc.
Gray, Allison & Becker Route 1, Box 1684 100 Vaughn Building Brazoria, TX 77422 807 Brazos Austin, Texas 78701-2553 (Monday delivery)
Additional copics to be hand delivered on April 29, 1985 where designated by "**"
-l
- Oreste Russ Pirfo, Esq. (w/ encl.)
. Robert G. Perlis, Esq.
Office of the Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Docketing and Service Section (w/encls.)
Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555
.C
!dM
' M A*
R
.