ML20107H458
| ML20107H458 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Perry  |
| Issue date: | 02/20/1985 |
| From: | Edelman M CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING CO. |
| To: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20107H461 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8502270162 | |
| Download: ML20107H458 (10) | |
Text
,
?
n L
-J g
P.O. Box 5000 - CLEVELAND. oHlo 44101 - TELEPHONE (216) 622-9800 - lLLUMIN ATING BLOG.
- 55 PUBLICSQUARE Se?ung The Best Location in the Nation MURRAY R. EDELMAN vicE PRESIDENT February 20, 1985 NUCMAR PY-CEI/NRR-0192 L Mr. Harold R. Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S. Nuc1 car Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Perry Nuclear Power Plant Docket Nos. 50-440; 50-441 Emergency Plan OM-15A Revision 4, SER Outetanding Issue No. 19
Dear Mr. Denton:
Enclosed are three (3) signed originals and thirteen (13) copies of ReviPlon 4 to the Perry Nuclear Power Plant (PNPP) Emergency Plan, CEI Report No. 0M-15A.
This revision incorporates the clarifications to Revision 3 which have been submitted by letters dated August 20, 1984 (PY-CEI/NRR-135L), October 28, 1984 (PY-CEI/NRR-0149L), and January 16, 1985 (PY-CEI-NRR-170L). This revision also includes the changes in the PNPP Site Organization since Revision 3, and lessons learned from the series of drills leading to our recent emergency preparedness exercise. At ached to this letter are the comments received from the County and State officials addressing the draft Appendix D of the Emergency Plan which was included in Revision 3.
The enclosed pages replace in entirety those currently in the plan. This revision is in a format designed to keep current the license application and the Emergency Plan.
We believe that the information provided in this Revision 4 to the PNPP Emergency Plan will resolve SER Outstanding Issue No. 19 dealing with onsite emergency planning for PNPP.
If there are any further questions, please feel free to call.
Very trul yours, hs k
Murra R. Edelman Vice President Nuclear Group MRE:nje
{o 4-(')
Attachment / Enclosure cc: Jay Silberg, Esq.
h h John Stefano (2) k 8502270162 850220 J. Grobe PDR ADOCK 05000440 F
j UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the Matter of Duquesne Light Company, Ohio Edison Company, Pennsylvania Power Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, The Toledo Edison Company, Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 & 2 Dockets Nos. 50-440; 50-441 CERTIFICATION OF SERVICE This is to certify that a copy of Revision No. 4 to the Emergency Plan, CEI Report No. OM-15A for Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2, dated February 20, 1985, has been served on the following Federal, State and Local Officials, by deposit in the United States Mail, addressed as follows:
A s
Federal Activities Branch Honorable Robert V. Orosz, Mayor U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Village of North Perry Region V Office North Perry Village Hall 230 South Dearborn Street 4778 Lockwood Road Chicago, Illinois 60604 North Perry Village, Ohio 44081 Ohio Department of Health Mr. Arthur Warren, Chairman Attn: Radiolog) a1 Health Program Perry Township Board of Trustees Director 4169 Main Street P.O. Box 118 Perry, Ohio 44081 Columbus, Ohio 43216 Mr. Jim Williams Mr. Dale Wedge, Director Nuclear Prepare / ness Officer Geauga County Disaster Service State of Ohio Di. aster Services Agency Agency ODSA, Adjutant General Department 13281 Painesville-Ravenna Road 2825 West Granville Road Geauga County Safety Center Worthington, Ohio 43085 Chardon, Ohio 44024 lionorable Laurente Logan, Mayor Mr. Terry J. Lodge, Esq.
Village of Perry 618 N. Michigan St.
4203 liarper Street Suite 105 Perry, Ohio 44081 Toledo, Ohio 43624 7-s
!v
4 1
j
'{
~
- vm
- U j
Mr. Michael Wheeler, Robert Retzler, Director j:
Emergency Coordinator Lake County Disaster Service l
AshtCoula County Disaster Service Agency j
Agency 39 Fairdale Street 1
25 West Jefferson Painesville, Ohio 44077
}
Jefferson, Ohio 44047 i-i l
i
}
i i
I j_
Mutra R. Edelaan 1
Vice resident Nuclear Group k
i N
4 i
t i
I i
1 i
i i
(
L i
i i
i i
a i
4
- -. - r, e.. v,. ~- ~ w w.v n e m w~,.,
..-w.
'b Murray R. Edelman who, being duly sworn, deposed and said that (1) he is Vice President, Nuclear Group of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, (2) he is duly authorized to execute and file this report on behalf of The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company and as duly authorized agent for Duquesne Light Company, Ohio Edison Company, Pennsylvania Power Company and the Toledo Edison Company, and (3) the statements set forth therein are true and correct to the best of.his knowledge, information and belief.
lu Murray R. Edelman b
day of b R L N A.I' Sworn to and subscribed before me, this 1985
/
l V
V JOSEPH C. 5ZWEJK0W5KI Notary Public, State of Ohio. Cuya. Cty.
My Commission Expires July 14, 1986
..Q.. y,a
@ nun::11 af $6dr.
DISASTER SERVICES AGENCY %w e};
~
gP';i.
LA oma Or 9e Y
'Y O
39 FAIRDALE STREET
=
PAINE 5VILLE, OH10 44077 Phone (216) 3s2 6281 ALBERT E. STEWART Est. 361 Duector March 26,1984 The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company P. O. Box 97 Perry, OH 44081 Attention: Mrs. San Dugan
Dear Mrs. Dugan:
Having reviewed the Evacuation Time Study for the Perry Nuclear Power Plant es proposed by HMM Asscciates.
I offer the following comments:
p) s Section 1 v
1.2 The Perry Nuclear Power Plant, hereafter to be referred to as PNPP is located the Village of North Perry, a political subdivision within Lake County, Ohio. The plant site is located along the southern shores of Lake Erie. A site vicinity map for the plant is included as Figure 1.1.
The Plume Exposure Pathway Emergency Planning Zone hereafter referred to as the EPZ is the geographic area surrounding...
Figure 1.2 Suggests 1olidouter boundry line to show EP2.
Section 2 2.3 Third paragraph, suggest - it is assumed that the permanent population sector will evacuate from their places of residence and that all househalds having more than one vehicle will use only one vehicle.
Fourth paragraph suggests - additional explanation is needed by reviewer, does the plan assume this position or does it specifically warrant it?
2.5 While NETVAC has been used in previous hearings with success. Has it's findings p
been proven in actual situations?
LJ.
1:
C'* i Section 3 J
3.4 Table 3.1 Are their twenty-three (23) households in the City of Mentor, within the EPZ?
3.8 First paragraph - Should not County be changed' to Counties?
3.11 Is Figure 3.3 through 3.5 consistant with Warning Maps being developed and other criteria?
3.14 Table 3.2 As a matter of comment only, where are these Medical / Jail Facilities? Sub-area (E) Headlands State Park, has on certain Holidays in the past, saw as many as 60,000 to 80,000 transients.
Section 4 Table 4.1 Reviewer feels it is wise to remove Lakeland Coramunity College from Primary Reception Center. The JPIC is located here, other I.ake County locations can absorb the load.
4.19 Figure 4.3 Check width of Roadway?
Section 5 iV) 5.2 Initial Notification The land portion of the EPZ surrounding the Perry Nuclear Power Plant will have an Outdoor Siren Notification System, with Public Address capabilities that surpass requirements and recommendations yet remaining consistant with NUREG-0654/ FEMA-REP-1 Appendix 3 guidelines. This system will be used by County officials to Alert and Disperse Emergency Information to the population, i.e., Evacuate, Shelter in place, Turn-on their radios and television sets for additional information, all clear.
Pursuant to NUREG-0654 guidance, notification messages will commence on the designated television and EBS stations prior to the activation of the Siren /Public Address System.
Within fifteen (15) minutes the population, within the EPZ of the plant, will have been given an informational or instructional message regarding the emergency.
5.2 Second paragraph - I sure would hope so.
5.3 Very conservative estimates.
5.4 Permanent Pooulation, second paragraph - Suggests removal of (and local) emergency preparedness officials.
Transient Population, Suggest removal of (and local) emergency preparedness officials. Discussions with County emergency preparedness officials.
5.5 Suggests removal of (and local) emegency preparedness Officials. Discussion with County emergency preparedness officials.
/]
V.
g
.w-
,.-------,,.,,w.-
,w
. (_ _
\\
\\
3.8 The Priority Treatment ERP denotes traffic support at all intersections.
Section 6 6.20 Suggest word change - Remove manual and add Physical Traffic.
Section 7 7.1 While I do not agree with this approach, let it stand if it has b6en successful in other hearings.
Al-6 What are we talking about, Madison Village, Madison Township, North Madison?
A2-2 Again, reference is made to North Madison, there is no legal st'atus for this assumption, it is Madison Township.
Sincerely 4
LAKE DISASTER SERVICES AGENCY h~//
/ /
/ rector / Coordinator ert tewart Di i
mb O
l l
l
s
~'
~
County M Geauga D
-g (
13281 PAINESVILLE RAVENNA ROAD e GEAUG A COUNTY SAFETY CENTER r
(m
- .7A' cH ARDON, OHIO 44024 b.
- .d e.
DISASTER SERVICES AGENCY N
l k
PHONE (2161285-2222, E XT. 603
[
March 26, 1984 DIRECTO:
OEPUTY DIRECTOR DALEB. WEDGE RoNNIE N EGING Jan Dugan 10 Center Road R225 Perry, Chio 44081 Ref: Camnents on Time Evacuation Study
Dear Jan:
Page 4-1:
In all areas whe're it states that this is based on discussions with County and local law enforcenent and crnergency preparedness officials, I would like to state that we only had one meeting with Rt.!.
At that rneeting we only discussed what routes would nust likely be used for an evacuation and problens
~ wi th weather.
'Ihis produced an addi tion of Old 44--(North Street - Ravenna-Road). No other infonnation was discussed with these consultants.
(n')
Page 4-4: On southbound exits I do not understand 534 south to Route 166 west
\\d to Geauga County Reception Centers.
It would seen that once on Route 166, they sculd go to Route 528 and then south to the Middlefield Reception Centers. 'Ihe Chardon Reception Centers are primarily used for evacuees frczn Lake County.
Page 5-1:
I _do not fird any portion of the plan that defines the various weather conditions. During our meeting with Rhi, we indicated the probicms in
'Ihcnpson with severe winter weather. We would like to have a better under-standing of what they are basing their estinntes on.
We can see a change in the estimates of time.
Since working on the plan we have found special groups in 'Ihcnpson that should be addressed.
We have found two (2) canpsi t es, a group hczne and a day-care center for v.hich we have written SOPS.
I find no other problens in Sections 4, 5, 6 and 7.
Sincerely yours, clak&dd c Dale B. Wedge Director DBW/pl ADSAAA/B/5
CoENTY OF ASHTABGA O i i
EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY 25 West Jefferson Street Jefferson, Ohio 44047 I
I
~
~
Mike Wheeler Emergency Management Coordinator January 23, 1985 Jan Dugan Emergency Planning Unit TV 1 Perry Nuclear Power Plant PO Box 97 Perry, Ohio 44081
Dear Jau,
This letter is to inform you that after reviewing the Evacuation Time Study for the Perry Nuclear Power Plant with the Sheriff's Department it meets with our approval.
Sincerely, f d?r7&WY K. Michael Wheeler, Coordinator Ashtabula County Emergency Management Agency KMW/jf O
c, STATE OF OHIO ADJUTANT GENERAL'S DEPARTMENT O
. 2:25 west cRANVuE ROAD V
woRTHINGTON. OHIO 43085-2712 DISASTER SERVICES AGENCY AGOH-DS-NOO January 29, 1985 Ms. Jan. Dugan Cleveland Electric illuminating Co.
Perry Nuclear Power Plant P.O. Box 97 Perry, OH 44081
Dear Ms. Dugan:
My staff has reviewed the " Evacuation Time Estimates for Areas Near the Perry Nuclear Power Plant" (March 1984), prepared for CEI by HMM Associates.
The study is sound and should become an individual resource document.
The concerns we did identify do not affect-tha overall integrity-of the study.
However, we would appreciate your comments or further explanation on the o
following items:
- Page 2-2, Paragraph 1, Line 5: What are the site-specific characteristics
o
- Page 2-3, Paragraph 6: What is the source of the assumption that snowstorms would reduce roadway capacity by 30 percent during winter conditions? This figure seems low, particularly for the " snowbelt" counties.
Thank you for your time in resolving our questions. If our concerns need further clarification, please do not hesitate to contact me or the response supervisor, Larry Grove, at (614) 889-7157.
l Sincerlely,
/
/.
/ /
l$
/
1 *L
- j O i-(j,. e,
KENNETH B. COLE Nuclear Operations Officer ld AGN-0001 w
r a
_ _ ~
m n---
_,-m,---
- -