ML20106D121

Response to ASLB 841018 Request for Info Re Cinching Down U-bolts.Advance Notice & Explanation for Basis of Expedited Schedule Requested in Future.Requested Info & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence

ML20106D121
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	10/23/1984
From:	Philips M BISHOP, COOK, PURCELL & REYNOLDS, TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC CO. (TU ELECTRIC)
To:
References
CON-#484-689 OL, NUDOCS 8410250005
Download: ML20106D121 (13)

Text

. ; r:: a

?mg-p .

'). RELATED CL42se; igg;g,; . CC'gTED October' 23, 1984 e

'8i F'T 24 A9 :07 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

-BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING' BOARD In the Matter of )

TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC

) Docket Nos. 50-445 and 50-446 O/

)

COMPANY, et al. )

) (Application for Operating (Comanche Peak Steam Electric ) Licenses)

-Station, Units-1 and 2) )

APPLICANTS RESPONSE TO BOARD

' REQUEST FOR INFORMATION REGARDING CINCHING DOWN U-BOLTS On October 18, 1984', Judge Bloch. telephoned Applicants requesting that they provide the raw data supporting Table 2 (" Observations of Tori;ues in U-Bolts")- in the af fidavit of Robert C. Iotti and John C. Finneran, Jr. appended to Applicants' Motion for Summary Disposition of CASE's Allegations Regarding Cin'ching Down of U-Bolts (June 29, 1984). While Judge.Bloch did not specify at that time a-date by which such information should be supplied, in the October 18,

!1984 Memorandum and Order documenting the call . (mailed by the NRC on October 19 and received by Applicants on October 22), Judge Bloch directed Applicants to

provide such information by October 23, 1984.

Applicants have been able to assemble such information in this short period and append it hereto. However, Applicants request that in the future, should there be some urgent need to provide information on an extremely expedited 8410250005 841023 l PDR ADOCK 05000445 9 pg Dso3

FL ,s

< s. ;f i Le:

. 'r t s O. 1

- ,Q ;, ,

\ .

s

.# Q i q.- -

2-  ! > .

. .\

e

~

- schedule,. Applicants;be given as'm,uch not ce as possible and .N soie explanation I

of- the b' asis : for the . expedited . schedule. * . "-

Respectfully submitted, l k

\

g h

$ 2 Malcolni- Hi Philips, 'Jr.

x .

5  !., , +

o, r

G '

. Bishop,,.Liberman, Cook, Purcell & Reynolds '

f '1200 Seventeenth Street, N.W. Q Washington, D.C. 20036 .

(202)S57-9829 .

} ,

• -

• y .

, s h

p j 9 l' 5

A s 4 4 v ie q

X s v 1 s -

-r ' ., 'y

.y i- *

,,.~

s 1 .

.N , E.

4 t

s s :

C (

, s

)

1

, t i

I

.s -

• - With regard _ to instant ' requests for. information, in that Applicants have  !'

yet to. respond"to CASEs answer on the issce of cinching dovo U-bolts, ' .

'the .urgen'cy of the, schedule established is ' unclear. "

t -s , ' N. . .as y 1  % /

p -

-1g I i H

, N

(.

~

.% ~ '

&.' N

{ i f ,% g. . . , . . _ , .- - - - ~ ~ . - -

e Building Henger Number Pfpe stZe Torque-Average (ft-lbs)

Reactor Building, HD-507-2 3/4 5

-. Unit 2 Reactor Buftding, HD-507-1 3/4 5 Unf t 2 Reactor Gufiding,. HD-964-2 3/4 8.5 Unit 2 Reactor Butiding, HD-995-3-102 3/4 4

- Unit 2

. Safeguard, Unit 2 HD-548-1289 1 5.5 Reactor Building, HD-507-1 1 5 Un f t 2 Reector Bu'Idtng, HD-551-RD-2-71 2 17.5 Un f t 2 Reector Building, HD-551-RB-2-70 2 20 Unit 2 Reactor Buflding, HD-827-25K2 2 4.5 Unit 2 Reactor Building, HD-827-23K2 2 8

. Unit 2 Reactor Buflding, . HD-827-24K2 2 10 Unit 2 Reactor Bu'Idtng, HD-827-28K 2 2 5 Unit 2 Reactor Buflding, HD-827-2 7K 2 2 5 Unf t 2 Reactor Bufiding, HD-827-26K2 2 5 Unit 2

. Roteter Bu t iding, WD-827-29K2 2 5.5 Unit 2 Reactor Bu!! ding, HD-507-107-R2-2 2 4.5 Unft 2

l e l l

Building Hanger Nusber Pfpe Sfze Torque-Average (ft-lbs)

Reactor Bullding, HD-507-121 2 5.5 Unit 2 -

Reactor Building, HD-507-108-RB-2 2 7.5 Unit 2 Reactor Bufiding, - HD-507-105 2 4.5

" Unit 2

~

Reactor Buf tding, HD-507-109-RB-2 2 5 Unit 2-I Safeguard, Unit 2 ;

-CS2-202-402-S52R 3 22.5 Reactor Building, CS2-079-410-C42S '3 12.5

' Unit 2 Reactor Bufiding, CT2-053-444-C62K -3 12.5 Unit 2 Reactor Bufiding, CT2-053-444-C62K 3 10.0

. Unit 2 Safeguard, Unf t 2 ' CS2-318-700-553R 3 15

Safeguard, Unit 2 . CS2-014-401-552K 3 25 Safeguard, Unit 2 CS2-920-703-S53 R 3 20 Fbector Building, OD2-046-404-C56R 3 9 Unit 2 Reactor Building,- CC2-207-420-C53R 3 26.5 Unit 2 Reactor.Bufiding, CT2-053-402-C62S 3 25 Unit 2 Reactor Bufiding, W32-001-416-C4t J 3 22 Unit-2 Reactor Building, WP2-001-426-C46R 3 30 Unit 2 Reactor Building, D02-109-433-C43R 3 21.5 Unit 2

.a o

Building Hanger Number Pfpe Size Torque-Average (ft-lbs)

Reector Building, WP2-030-422-C46R 3 30 -

Unf t 2 Reactor Building, - CS2-079-411-C42K 3 25 Unit 2 Reactor Bufiding, CC2-190-401-C52 R 4 25 Unit 2 Reactor Building, MS2-150-450-C5 2K 4 25 Unit 2 Safeguard, Unit 2 AF2-096-410-S33K 4 35 Safeguard, Unit 2 AF2-103-441 -S5 3K 4 20 Safeguerd, Unit 2 AF2-099-419-S33K 4 12.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 AF2-099-419-S33K 4 30

' Reactor Bufiding, S12-306-425-C42K 4 33.5 Unit 2 Safeguard, Unit 2 AF2-102-42 3-S53S 4 23.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 AF2-102-422-S5 3K 4 52.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 B R2-018-415-S43R 4 50 Safeguard, Unit 2 BFC-018-417-543K 4 33 A- Safeguard, Unit 2 CT2-021-405-532K 4 44.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 WP2-226-429-S36R 4 35 IL Safeguard, Unit 2. .WP2-226-414-S36R 4 22.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 WP2-225-439-S26R 4 21.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 . Wo2-226-407-526R 4 40 Safeguard, Unit 2 S12-044-431 -S22 R 4 28 Reactor Bo f i ding, CC2-193-424-C52R 4 41.5 Unit 2

Butiding ' Hanger Number Pfpe Size Toroue-Average (ft-lbs)

Reector Building, CC2-193-423-C52R 4- 15 Unit 2 Reactor Building, MS2-151-442-C52K 4 13.5 Unit 2 Reactor Bufiding, . N62-151-419-C52R 4 40

. Unit 2 Reactor Building, MS2-151-440-C52K 4 27,5 Unf t 2 Reactor Bufiding, NG2-151-411-C52R 4 7.5 Unit 2 Reactor Building, Sl 2-306-425-C42K 4 25.5

. Unit 2 Reactor Building, Sl 2-306-42 3-C42 R 4 60

Unit 2 Reactor Building, Sl 2-306-401-C42 R 4 35

- Unit 2 -

Reactor Building, ~ S12-306-421-C42R 4 22.5 Unit 2 Reactor Bufiding, VD2-053-403-C46R 4 12.5 Unit 2 Reactor Building, Sl 2-306-402-C42 R 4 27.5 Unit 2 Reactor Building, 512-306-418-C42R 4 50

-Unit 2 Safeguard, Unit 2 CT2-021-404-S32R 4 18.5 Safeguard, Unft 2 CS2-326-410-556R 6 24.5

- Safeguard, Unit 2 CS2-326-401-S56R 6 22

. Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-790-9.35 6 42.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-790-9.351 6 25

o -

.: ? 1-

-Butiding Henger Number Pfpe Sfre Torque-Average (f t-Ibs)

Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-790-9.352 6 25 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-790-9.353 6 ' 35 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-790-9.354 6 20 Safeguard, Unit 2 R)-790-9.355 6 20 Safeguard,' Unit 2 FP-790-1051 6 20 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-790-1052 6 35 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-790-1151 6 22.5

' Safeguard, Unit 2 - FP-790-1152 6 10 Reactor Building, CC2-246-419-C53R 6 10 Unit 2 Reactor Buftdtng, CC2-246-423-C53R 6 10 Unit 2 Reactor Bu?iding, 512-171-401-C42R 6 52.5

- Unit 2' Reactor Building, 512-101-408-C41 R 6 75 Unit 2 Safeguard, Unit 2 CS2-063-416-S22R . 8 17.5 Safeguard, Unit.2. CS2-063-417-S22K 8 35.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 SI 2-037-402-S22R 8 42.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 RH2-056-401 -S22R 8 55 Safeguard, Unf t 2 FH2-028-403-S32R 8 15 Safeguard, Unit 2 . FP-810-125 8 57.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-810-12.55 8

, 40

' Safeguard,-Unit 2 FP-310-1351 9 17.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-810-1352 8 22.5

.~

Bufiding Hanger Number Pfpe Size Torque-Average (ft-Ibs)

Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-810-14S 8 31 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-810-115 8 27.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-810-10S 8 8 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-810-9.5S 3 28 Safeguard, Unit 2 FP-810-9s 8 51.5 Reactor Building, Sl 2-087-406-C42 R 8 40

- Unit 2 Reactor Building, S12-097-409-C42 R 8 70 Unit 2 '

Reactor Bufiding, S12-087-405-C42R 8 55 Unft 2 Reactor Building, Sl 2-088-410-C421: 8 46 Unit 2 Turbine Bufiding, HD-2-055-407-T45S 10 to Unit 2 Turbine Building,. HD-2-055-409-T45S 10 21.5 Unit 2 Safeguard, Un?t 2 CT2-011-403-S22 R 10 21 Safeguard, Unit 2 CT2-012-410-S22K 10 37.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 CT2-083-418-S36R 10 83 Safeguard, Unft 2 CT2-083-417-S36K 10 57 Safeguard,-Unit 2 CT2-017-440-S36K 10 31 Reactor Bu11 ding, Sl 2-010-403-C46S 10 20 Unit 2 Reactor. Bu t i ding, S12-015-409-C42R 10 45 Unit 2 Reactor Bufiding, S12-103-403-C42 R 10 37.5 Unit 2

e O

Bullding Hanger Number Pfpe Sfze Torque-Average (ft-lbs1 Reactor Bufiding, Sl 2-103-403-C42 R .10 72.5 Unit 2 Safeguard, Unf t 2 RH2-058-402-S22R 10- 50 Safeguard, Unit 2 RH2-058-402-S22R 10 47.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 RH2-058-401-$22R 10 62.5 Turbine Bufiding, HD-2-318-404-T45 S 12 48.5 Unit 2 Tu'rbine Building, EX2-030-404-T45S 12 26 Unft 2 Turbine Bufiding, 002-042-439-T150 12 57.5 Unf t 2 Turbine Butiding, CO2-042-4 38-T150 12 85 Unit 2 Turbine Bufiding, HD2-318 -401-T455 12 65 Unit 2 Turbine Bu!! ding, HD2-323-403-T45S 12 41 Unit 2 Safeguard, Unf t 2 CC2-159-407-553R 12 87 Reactor Buftding, RC2-115-430-C56 R 12 40

- Unit 2 Turbine Building, EX2-002-401-T45S. 14 19.5 g - Unit 2 i

[

. Turbine Building, MS2-098-402-T45S 14 95 Unit 2 j~'

Turbine Bufiding, TW2-099-402-T350 14 47.5 Unft 2 Turbine Butiding, EX2-004-401-T45S 14 57.5 t - Unit 2

. Turbine Building, HD2-044-402-T35S 16 27.5 Unit 2 f.--

r L

L i

- , , , - - , . --, ,v. , - - - . . . . . - --

.s e

Building Hanger Number Pipe S12e Torque-Average (f t-lbs)

. Turbine Building, HD2-045-405-T35S 16 125 Unit 2 Turbine Building, HD2-009-401-T35S 16 75 Unit 2 Turbine Building, VD2-072-402-T35D 16 112.5 Unit 2 Turbine Bulld'ng, HD2-045-401-T15R 16 69

-Unit 2'

. Turbine Building,-.

HD2-044-406-T15 R 16 69 Unit 2 Turbine Building HD2-044-405-T15R 16' 72.5 Unit 2 : -

Turbine Building' FD2-314-401-T455 16 72.5 Unit 2 Safeguard, Unf t 2 CT2-013-414-S32K 16 126 Safeguard, Unit 2 CT2-013-418-S33R 16 67.5

Safeguard, Unit 2 S12-076-404-S22K -16 25 Safeguard, Unit 2 CT2-025 -405-S22K 16 85 Safeguard, Unit 2 CT2-025-405-S22K 16 95 Safeguard, Unit 2 CC2-031 -406-S4 3K 13 117 Safeguard, Unit 2 CC2-068-407-S33K 18 57.5 Safeguard, Unit 2. CC2-068-402-S33S 18 35

' Turbine Buflding, Fw2-001-408-T45 R 20 65

- Unit 2

' Turbine Building, Fw2-001-408-T45 R 20 108 Unit 2 Turbine Building, VD2-073-402-T35S 24 85 Unit 2

g Building Hanger Nuster Pfpe Size Torque-Average (ft-lbs)

Turbine Bufidfng, FW2-004-401-T35S 24 35 Unit 2 -

Turbine Building, FW2-004-402-T35S 24 34 Unit 2 Turbine Building, FW2-009-404-T35S 24 43.5 Unit 2 l-Turbfne Bufiding,- _HD2-068-401-T15S 24 67.5

. Unit 2 Turbine Building, EX2-009-405-T45S 24 40 Unit 2 Turbine Building, 002-032-403-T450 24 30

. Unit 2 Safeguard, Unf t 2 CC2-028-412-S33R 24 62.5 Safeguard, Unit 2 CC2-028-412-S33R 24 65

-Turbine Bufiding, MS2-033-001-T44S 26 22 Unit 2 Turbine Bufiding, HD2-016-405-T35R 30 112.5 Unit 2 Turbine Bufiding, 002-010-402-T450 30 105 Unit 2 Turbine Building, HD2-016-404-T35R 30 89 Unit 2 Turbine Building, EX2-012-402-T45S 30 55 Unit 2.

Turbine Bufiding, V02-071-402-T3gi; 40 61 Unit 2 Turbine Building, YD2-070-403-T350 40 82.5

r Fr -

. i-UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE'THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In'the-Matter-of )

TEXAS' UTILITIES ELECTRIC

) Docket-Nos. 50-445 and COMPANY,'et a1.-

) 50-446

- ~ ~ ~ )

) (Application for (Comanche . Peak' Steam Electric ) Operating Licenses)

Station, Units 1 and 2)- )

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

'I-hereby certify.that copies of " Applicants' Response to Board ~ Request for Information Regarding Cinching Down U-Bolts",

in the above-captioned matter was served upon the following persons by express delivery (*), or deposit in the United States mail, first class, postage prepaid, this 23rd day of October, 1984, or by hand delivery (**) on the 24th day of October, 1984.

• • Peter B.EBloch, Esq. . Chairman, Atomic Safety and Chairman, . Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Panel Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission .

Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555

• Mr. William L. Clements Dr. Walter H. Jordan Docketing & Service Branch 881 West' Outer. Drive U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 Commission Washington, D.C. 20555

• Dr. Kenneth-A. FicCollom Dean, Division of' Engineering **Stuart A. Treby, Esq.

Architecture and Technology Office of the Executive Oklahoma State ~ University Legal Director Stillwater, Oklahoma 74074 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Chairman, . Atomic Safety 7735 Old Georgetown Road and Licensing' Board Panel Room 10117 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory

' Commission.

Bethesda, !!aryland 20814 Washington, D.C. 20555

c.

-t.

Mr. John Collins ** Ellen Ginsberg, Esquire Regional Administrator, Atomic Safety and Licensing Region IV Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission

611 Ryan Plaza Drive Washington, D.C. 20555 Suite.lOOO Arlington,. Texas 76011

• Mrs. Juanita Ellis Renea Hicks, Esq. President, CASE Assistant Attorney General 1426 South Polk Street Environmental ~ Protection Dallas, Texas 75224 Division P.O. Box 12548 Lanny A. Sinkin Capitol Station 114 W. 7th Street Austin, Texas 78711. Suite 220 Austin, Texas 78701

(

1)Y ,

William A. HorinU cc: John W. Beck Robert Wooldridge, Esq.