ML20102B463
| ML20102B463 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | 05200001 |
| Issue date: | 07/10/1992 |
| From: | Duncan J GENERAL ELECTRIC CO. |
| To: | Poslusny C NRC |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 9207290035 | |
| Download: ML20102B463 (32) | |
Text
._
.u.e e
4 6*2-/#/
O GENodrw Energy l
-Date loJun'9L 1
I cger POSLvMY D NaC
\\\\\\
F.ax No.
To i
l This peye plus N page(s)
FY"m M/< OduC4 Mall Code 765/
175 Cunner Avenue San Jose, CA 95125 (408) 925 0,N [
Phone FAX (408) 925-1193 or (408) 925-1687 I
Subject A Bwn FR.A A>u al 4'IT prM Message Unblod pund /t.ti bN~J. Acend
.J Y m,i Tfk J 4 x d 5 ;: i f U lun Alrkk;l[.
i P/ena prsuuG fc pxc.rNr// rav'+aars.
i i
Tba shw// cas.2 7%"6E Gn %tr -
J or <> s e rf 7%g khoe & cerracf J%NJ IS mdf. sawn cv do ordr'ut c p < pra0%s,
i 9207290035 920710 3
A 4;806?3 ADOCK'052Og1 PDR
ARWR Tasks to wrap up PRA P A R DSER SSAR Titic NRC Cemta<t I
n e Next Date Actum Com men ts it em Se<tiwi Subtask GE Gm:2ct a a v
Assur n I i
e w
Fault Tree Updste (FT) 0-1 v
s n
n a
GE Prrm ted HPS
~
RPS Reliability Kelly Raftery fault tree to NRC
=
4/15. h i
r Resobed v
s NRC ?
ECCS Trees sent Ugwlase ECCS faelt.
- KcIly n
4 FI-1A teecs Raftery to NRC 5/8-a Ug= late tatance of Kelly NRC Deferred toJune FI'-1 B '
trees Krftery to alk= focus on more imtertant items _fl'rmided
{ to NRC 6/i<
e i
Initiating Eventa (LE)
S-?
' Defend IORV Kelly-v n
GE I. Use 0.1 in Stat requires uw freepseno Raftery -
requantification C.1 cvent/y(-ar.
' TBD 2 Refle<t 0.1 in SSAR tabic and scut c-6
~.
.4 C = Confirmatory item s = started 7
~
.S
= Saaff correctk>n v - discaped verbaity but not d<xumented 0 - Outnanding item c = complete with dwurnented agreement I
- Interface requirement swt applicabic 7/10/92 ne P = DSER page numtwr - no issue number n = Not a DSER seem Page I C.
ABWR fasl to wrap up PRA P A D5ER SSAR Title NRC Contatt I
n e Next Date Actien Com me nts item Sec tion Suhtask CE Contact 2
a v Actor ri l i
e W
' C-1 IORV succm criteria Kelly NRC fBD Review Rmmse Response sent to Ra nery NRC 4/14.
KeIly o < enrem O K.
v n v NRC TnD Reflect agreement in NRC auw agrees 51 n
Defend one trip per Kelly year.
Duncan SER.
I trip / year as i
ress.matne -
Ltem Rewbred
- 5. '
.c
- C' = Confirmatog item s = starmf S. - Staff correction v = discussett verbally but not dmumented O e Outstanding item c = comp;ete with documented agreernene.
1
- Interface requirement '
n = not applicabic.
7/10/92 P = DSER page number - no issut; number n = Not a DSFJt item -
Page 2
q
~
P A R USER SSAR Tide NRC O>nuct i
n e Next their
/.c eien Cor..ene n t s item Sn tion Suhtask G E G m tact a
a w
4ctoe n i i
e w-I e
v s
s NRC CE has prrwided O-2
. lod 11 A Evaluate support Kelly system failure on larson (Jan. 27) < haft material plant trign (IIVAC failere) and list of odser supgwart spem to l>e addre:wd.
GE agreed to i
'"E '". 3"8 t
add k sof senge AC or single DC Ims.
GE also agrmi to 4/9 sta!Y rquest to alw consWer loss yf TBCCW sptem and RPV.<ater Ic=ct instrument failure. Fur aties discussions (4/14) soy, gest all areas reso & d.
Calculation dr ferred try incop> rate in
,1 reston611 ration
~~
item PRA-l).
HNAI. Response provided to NRC i
6/15.
j t
C = Confirmatory item s = started S = Staff rocrecten v m-dkussed ver*oally hui not do.vincated
= complete with dwumented agurement 1
O = Outstanding.iacin
(
1 - = Interfare vergoirement
' n = not applica;.te -
7/IO/tJ2 P
e DSER page numtier - em icue number r.
- Not a DSER item Page 3 f
i.
P A R DSER SSAR l'itic NRC Gmtact I
'6 r
News D2 ee Acen n Com ments iten Sr< e tm Sot 4tast -
C E C m tata a a y
Astor n
n I i
l C
w l
?
Docuinent g.iping n
GE n
03 19D3.1.3.3 Analyte interfacing Kelly LOCA L a r= on uppde. 1 racit Sepasately Rniv SSAR text to Part of SSSR rebect no need ta up<taar in analyre responw-to item 0-2. rymw'-
gmmded 6/15.
NRC?
e i-(
6 i
i A
t
~
C = Confirmatory itern s - started J
. S =.xd1 conetti.n.
v = dkuwd vertraIly but not docurnented
= complete with dorumented agreement O - Outstanding itern
(
1
= Interface requirenwnt n = not applicaMc 7/10/4/2 P = DSER page number - no iwue numtwr
[
n - Not a DSER item Page 4
---=L
- m m
ABWR Tasks to wrap up PRA P A R DSER SSAR Titic NRC Gmta(t I
n Next Date Action Comme n t s ite m Sntion Sutaast GE Gmtact a
a v
Acecr n I i-i e
'w L,
.e t
CM I X.2.3.3 Outside containment Paita s
NRC ?
Rev.cw S/4 mate,ial Further 1.OCA Frederic k rapid feedbu k distuasion-held l
Kn e< ht requested.
4/ tex
. Vishu CE/NRC/ firuob tiaven, resulting in CE agreement to l'
Supplentent SSAR 19F._2.3S i >use neu s i:
f,om Al.WR KAG 2) clanfy cornhtion al peut abih6cs 3)
' ExP 2in how l
split fraction u
espandon i
fatt< ws.
I' resistance cuefTrxients and dI* (t) wene determined.
Sulenittesi 4/77 a
l Preliminary NRC review ir.dicates isem reanised 5/4.
Additional items dmcussed T
63 Iis.uien to oypaw Mudy submited 6/4.
~
C = Confirm: tory item s = stasted S = Staff conettion v - docussed verbally but oct docun.ented O. = Outstanding item -
( = c-3mplete with doc.umenrrd agreetnent I
- Interfac requirement
- n = not applicable 7/10/'M
? ' = DSER page nssnber. no issue namt.cr
- n = Not a DSER item Page 5 I
~
ABWR Tasks to wrap up PRA P A R DSER SSAR Title NRC Contut I n e Nest Date Action Cma men.s itern Sectbn
- feb ask CF Gintact a
a v
A: _or r: 1 i
e se L
L I-i' 19 9 Ccefirm site loss J Kelly
's v
n.
Applicant ation SSAR text AC, other site Rafter y Ite rn_ resolved, gwemded to NF(
6/30.
specifit parmekn Succesa Crkeria (SC)
(
c v
NRC ?
RcCect dosure in FSER Artced SMR
.G2 AThS Su<ress Kelly Cri+sa to psevent B uc hh*4z ts catment is adequate at San o xe d.tnage.
Jeme ifo2 rnec tin g.
Documentation submitted 4/2/M I:et:s Rexhed ATWS RIIR Sur. cess Ktfly c c v-NRC ?
Reflere dosure m FSER Agreed SSAR n
SGI Criteria P.uchhoir treatment is adequate at San Jose I/92 meedng.
Documentation submittrif 4/2/92. Item Rewhed C - Confirutatory item s = s:arted S = StafTrorietion 9 - discussed verhlfy but not documented O = Outstand ng Rem c = compicte with documented axecement I
= Interbce reeguirernent n = not appikal_4e 7/10/92 P = DSER page number - no issue number e = Nct a DSER item Page 6 i
..x n. -
ABWR Tasks to wrap up PRA' P A R D5ER
.C'J=7
'fitte NRC Cont.x I
n e Next ihre
.v th n Cnennents
'i t e m
' stirm Subtad GE Cente r
= z
- Acim t.-"
n f i
e l
- n 19.9
' RWCU as DIIR Ketty NRC Minor design modi 6 cation.
SG2
- Sucrets (ACRS)
Pa r:diso Keiry. P aradiso l
diwussed 5/27 Iktails prod.ded to iRC 6/4.
tNthw i COL a< tion iten-
. submitted to
@C ri/Sey Failure Data See item 0-5 Justif coramon cauw hetty
- C-3 f
failure data Frederidr i ->
I...
l I
I 14'.
[-
-- s - staned l'
C L '=' Cc,firmatory item.
v = dinmed verhany t>at not docunented I
S'
- Staff coerc< tion '
c - complete with documented agr:enient O.. = Outs:anding itrm 7/10/92 l
I-
- Interface requirement '
n = not appliable P.'
- DST.R page nurnber - nc-'iseue number.
Page 7 ri e Not a D5ER iteen c.
=
l' il lI l{I IJ1lil x
2;
-+
l ' '.
}
- 3
,~
2 8
9/
e 0
ga 1
P
/7 F,
y y
n A
Cfi dt I 3 C R Ct u u Co o
pmR o
k t
P n
t G
ga neN d s
R s
t t
/ s n
d 0 N
y u
i t
s n
m5t,df n
yf I(
e e3 t
s q
e o ?. E p met /
et i
t s e5 n t
nus r e
e Gah.di5 4seaoe Ant m
a?
c pn n r
t eimI wC i
i r
y,u h n
hMs n p R ).
m rd gqt d v
ct R e
ah on c on ueid es o5 hwciSN o
Fa-r wat s at 1 C
t dn ee tnm ee R
mer s
A5 ug i
ca m
S o
e n
d de t
i i
t t o n' f
tn ne i.
e m
E d t
o Gv m
uu' e
b l
u bc o
c yo t
e e M
nd s
a c
Tr A
A b he I
i t
rib R
ewa P
v c
e d eil t
p a
eep
?
st p u
D ds pa eu p
r w mt t
r C
ar o o a
o s 'd c n t
t r
xt R
E w
ec N
G
- x==
NA s v cr o
t Revi'w s
ks Ar aI a
aT PI a" R
W tc B
ae t
A nx ot y
A n
r C
y k-te -
l Ct l fe a~
RE KR NG re e
b m
tav o
le q
n v
e ee 4 sd e
a ua us ias s
k aci i
s r nh o
a t
oa n
r t
t s
ymo n-tu f
r e
eS t
i r
mp uop m
me -
lt e
meb T.
Jca erim m i
t i
nt e
y>i uut rkgeqni enr eR ot tari gE rdeaS n
o 8
mr n c pD Ri r oaa t
0 Ac GctfrRa 9
s Se n#t eEt 1
SS oa ut So n
= = - = - =--
Se 5
Di 4
CSOI Pn t
rkI(llf,ll
,l
.. - ~ _. -. ~.
.~ -. - ~.~.....
ABWR Tasks to wrap up PRA P A R DSER SSAR Title NRC Cr ntact I
n e Nex t Dzsc Ac tion Coen r,e n ts item S w son Subtad GE Crmtact a a v
A c a c, n 1 i
I C 1A fustify Kelly GE n
Int; ode new values en Arrion plan test /rnaintenance Ra ftery requanuficat on: test dixussed with data analpis and maintenan<c NRC 3/?4. T/M r
unavallability unavadabilities
- j. -
will 1.c in<rrase I fc-GE TIID Retkct in SMR u tility flexibdity.
E(Es. RCIC RIIP unasailability will be talten as 2%
l Item Rewived C-13 CDr.ensi+ivity in Kelly CE TBD New request by outage times, Raftery after NRC Mention sinnertiance intervals G/33 no risange m d sie =
established 7/15 BWR surveilla nce internal.,
therefore sensitivity not investigated.
04s' Tables Jusufy RIIR. IIPCF KcIly GE TBD renect jus:ification in Justification 19D.G2 pump failuir Rafterv SSAR_ -
gwoverted 4/Is and-3 probability Raftery to Kelly.
j' Justiiscation W
accepted by NRC.
4 Item Resolved.
- " l C - Confirmatory item a = started 7,
5 = StaIIcorrection v = discussed vertxany but not documented O ' = Outstanding item -
c = compacte with dc.comented agreement
+
I
= Interface ecquirernent n = not applicable 7/10/92 l
P - DSER rage nun.!>cr - no assue numter 4
4 n = Not a DSER stem Page 9 i
i e
.c m
. ~
AllWR Tmks to wrap up PRA P A R
~DSER SSAR :
Tit e NRC C4.ntact i
n c Next Date Actior.
Corr ments item Sation Subtasi CE G.ntact a a s
Ac. ar n I i
e W
i
- O-!! A 19.10 List systems not pare. Palla NRC t%bmitted to T y NRC a* Sette of certified design, Dunun
[1Rtc on 6/T7.
-. significarit -
m assumptioen, assumed reliability GE IBD Ugxiate SSAR Level 1 FRA and Sul equent Related Stadkm (FRA) l n
n CE apprruuh 5-!!
Fire waer tredit Kc'ly v orTet tism Viswe sw a re n conservative. Dre water wiu be in RAP and as applicable in accident managemen t.
No other action needed c
-hm Resobed Reg.zantify 8:-vel I Kelly NRC ?
Tahutir results n-PRA results (bac Raftery wut t, NRC PRA-5/?2: CDFin
.I A-case) inetiator and auident <tama.
_n1
. Add compashon to Kelly CE after Provide osmparison New requesa tir PRA-operating ~ BWRs,
. Raftery 6/30 NRC. supgerts c are a F S E R A.2.!.1 IB why sequence 7/15 vnti compare to frequensies decrease Grand Gulf.
s = started C s Confirmatory itern.
v = discussed verbalhr tut nos docuanented S-
= Staff correttion O. =. Outstanding item c = coenplete with duumented agreernent I
= Interface requirement n = not apphcable 7/10/92 DSER page number - no issue number Page IO P
e n - Not a DSER item
ARWR T:ris to wrap up PRA P A R DSER SSAR Title.
NRG Contact I
n c Ncia 11 ate As tion Cmu me n t s item Section Sutdask CF. Owme t a a v Actor n I i
e w
i
.s
, n Study of efTcts.4 Ec:iy GE TBD. Prcmde results -
Provvie eesults if PRA-2 iv.trumentation out Ras tery After needed so of service 6/30 suppmt rech sgn c.
?r 4
1 v
NRC Results step as 0-18A I evel I uncertainty Kc'1y CDF. will v.<w be a n alysis
. Ra
-7 P*l%2"I through analyns. Ite m was late due to work os. Flewxt P R.8L New date I
?
= 3/19.
r i
O-1 I initiating Even EcIly Address as pa v untertainty
<4 iten O-ISA
{Subuutted t>[ih v
NRC General l
I 15 19K PRA input so
~ Kelly Reliability _ Anurance Ianon agreenient reached o how r
to pre mi
+
mput peeride-6/15 (llalance submitted 6/29 t
- C. = Confirmatory 5:em s = started S = Stafi corm ion v e discuwst vertWty but not dcrcuenenicsi e
O - Outstanding item c = completc wir+ A~umentet! agreement 1
= Interface requirement n - not applicable 7/10/92 l'
- DSER page number - no 'ese number n - Not a DSER item Page 11 i
~
_ -. m d'
b n-I' t
ABWR Tasks to wrap usp PRA-t:
P.
A R I':
DSFR. SSAR-
~ Tiele. _
'NRC Contact I n
e: ~ Nemt Date Action Cornments E
etem : Sc< tion
- Sultad GF.Consaa i
a-v- ' Attar l
'- t n
}.
e I
.s.
2.:
-- ~i a
NRG' Prehminary
- n-19.8 Du nca n.-
. PRA-3 su!>nkss4 5/30.
r F
f Balate<c.
submitted as -
-r" RMR test 19.
- i on 6/30 g
t 3
9 e1 N-CW THD Refiert in SMR M% ctwnplete
-{
C-?2A. 19.7
-- PRA as a design tool Kelly.
Umncan draft proved
- t 4/7. NRC tap goodc Item NRC
~ l re$cIved. 100 L' compacte l
respone sent to NRC 6/21 Picit-i
~ e up rema'm'mg items under 0-
?!B.
r-e 7
Y
__h 4
I'
.'I
'{.
h-
.'s 2
+
1.
. i c
c,
i _.
N:~
j s._,.
4 o
.i.
- ,:, - p 4
-.C ". ConGrenatory item; u
. s = started 7 ;
[.
5 ' 1-- Staff correction -
^
v = decussed mbally but um docwnentesi j
O. = Outstanding item t = compikte d.th dc<umented agreement i
4
'L--
! "= Interface fertuirevent'.
n = not in;yliuble
7/10/92
- f
-' P : = DSER p. age neml;er..:.1 % e number.
2 Page 12
. n = Not a DSER item -
t
~
i 4
M
+cg
.g
.h.
~.
.~
. ABWR. Tasks to wrap up PRA' P.A R
- DSER SSAR Titic.
. NRC Contact i" n e Next Da te. ' Action Comments stem. Sec t><m.
i~ Sebtain.
. GE Contact a a e Actor n E i
e w
L 1
' 4723
_19. !!
. PR A f iresights
' Kelly '
CE 6/30 Outline of New item, 1
rnan.gement cl<nurt addcti en 3/?3 l
D tancan l
Jisne 25 staff deadline.
meeting.
i Narratswe 15,
relating - how I
PRA was used.
e-
! including how T
s_veral DSER esems were addressed.
Probatdy CE addreces by
- additions to 022A respo_e_ $r.
Csulnnuted as]
SSAR eettion I 19.13 on6/29. )
J
.~
.c L
l :i_
.y, p.,
s = started -
G " J Confirmatory item.
. v = dhrtissed verba!!y but not documented 5.. c- &aficorrectksn c.= completc with documented agreement O ' = Cuteanding item.
7/10/92 n = not applicable -
, I: = Interface re<3uerernent.'
P'
= USER gge number ' no iuue navnher Page 13 n - Not a DSER iwm '-
.m.._
- .2,-
^
P A R DSER SSAR Tide NRC Crmtxt i
n e Next Date Ac tion Comme n t.
Ditads stem ' : Section
% btasa GE Contatt a a v A(tor
+
n i
e e
w t
t-F
(
c s NRC agrecs on 0-20
\\%
Shutdown risk. Fous Kelly sulxaskt Viswe swa rr re 24 hous mission time.
.NRC
?
<;ent to NEC 5/8.
r, Tal.ie.
1.
ABWR design 19.Ql.,
, features NRC ?
Sent to NRC 5/8.
"lables 2.- Res w of past 19QR-1, -T shutdown events
$bmitted to '
[
NRC ?
NRC 6/30.
- 3. Deoy heas removal reliability Submitted to NC ?
NRC 6/
.4_ Other tasks.
t 4
ia 7,
4 C. - Confirmatory ' item.
' s - started S = Sc:df correction v = discussed verbally but not dewumented
- c
' O = Outstanding item.
c = complete with documented agreement I
= Interface ret [uirement o = not applicable 7/10/92 P.
= DSER page riumber - no issue numic n - Not a DSER item I%ge 14
~
e 4
4
.,s J
l 1
1
[
P. A' R
i
- DSER S SSAR
.Titic '.
'NRC Omtact I o e Next Date Action Comments f
~ item Section '
- Suhtask '
C E O mtact a: a v
Actor n
-t' i
t c.
?
.w i
t:,
Ta.
t i,.
j Osher Analyses (OA)
- O 12 19M -
Fire ?RA =
Kelly c c 5
NRC 6/12 l'rovkle results of No major items -
- ,_.i review to GE -
nrnted. Date
. Ra f tet7 slipped frun
(
4/15 Maxwell /
C-n, Ketty dr3 cussed 3
quewens 5/27.
t La wrence.
Livermere
-i.
renew next.
L i
J.9 -
19R
' Insernal Flood Kell'y..
n.. s NRC.
Prirride rapid feedback! Approach outhned 3/24 McSherry
/Cokcek San Jose.
i Partial draft t
prended 6/r.
tbcussion held l
6/9.
'l y
benisted to NRC as I
Appendix 19 1
(on 6/30.
.c 3
3 t
o_i t.
i a
3,
- .C =- Coc.firmatory. item -
s = started 51 = SadT correction -
v = discussed verbally but nu docatnented :
O ^ = Outstanding 11sem :
c _- complete with documented agreement -
41 J - - Interface-requirement n = not appkrab8e -
-7/IC/92 P = DSER pqge number. no issue numt er ~
~
Pageis n Ty Not a DSER'i:em 1
m
+,,
,..w
~,.,.
.c
. ~
P ABWR Tasks to wrap up PRA P A R
. DSER SSAR Titje NRC Cnnta< t I
n <
Neue Date Ar6on Com mena
's c er.
Set tion Sot 4ut CE G etu t 2
a v Astor n I e
4 w
f I
t l
i llumme Factors in PRA r
t C5 These isems are.
Plan (Subtasks 0-7.
addressed by tfw -
A.II. C. D) hased 04 follwing ' job on NRC/CE O-9.
subtasks:
phone caII 3 0-10 brch 92 and I discussions 23
- 3 Manh. Ta.sk E
- I was added later.
t 1-5 I-G I-7
~~
C - Confirmasory item s = started S-
= Scaff correction -
v - discussed verbally but not documented
. O = Outstanding item.
r = complete with dernmented agreement I
= Interface treguirement n = not applicabis -
7/10/92 P = DSER pay,e numler - no ivue num%r a - Nos a DSER item-'
Page 16
2 7
T 1ABWR Tasks to wrap up PMA
,2 j
P A-R-1 NRC Getatt
'I.
n
.c Next. _ nase. Action
' Comments l
DSER. SSAR (
Mitic -
CE Gestart a
'a r - Attor f
Litem. Secdon
.. Subtask _
n :1 i
e w
t 3
1:
Beckner
.v.
-NRC
'.?
Date s!qqwd s
r A) PrWde a hst of.
- Frederi<n from 6/ t. L# 6/30
[
references /generil tr> foon en task,
[
c rrwtb<A used to 3.
p-c 6
i determine all failure; B.C, is.
[
+{
probabilides :
' /5ubmi med to
+
Reference to CESMR '
I RC 6/26.
PRA is axeptable.
f-R) Conduct tevel 1 :
._ K elly' lv -
NRC: 7 Irwrease
_j sensitivity study' Rafttry sevnrivity r ange
' ~
if hard to i
d d<<ument r>urce
-l of number.
.t
&ns:.mry study
[
t submeted June 5
j..-
y 1.
y
-CE Document in SSAR'
.19 0.7.7
~
fDenrip6 ms )
I i19D,7 G ;
'.C) Ikvctop ;
L Ke117
.v NRC ?
l,
- dewrip6ons for m<wt' Duncan -
[.submittedjooc IL
.I
~
. signi& ant l actiens,
as,sart ofitern B 4
i:
, for input to tontrol
[respome.
__j.
]
room design ie.
provide. s.ine.
1.available br operator #
P--
acdon &:-signals that
.I,-
i-
. the opentor relics y; !
F L on., Freddes input to -
~4 control room design".
'& EPGs
~- <
t:
. C = ConGematory item s = started -
2
' " 5 = StafT eorrecdon
' v = discussed verbally.L.c not ddcumenard -
l 0 - Outstanding item c = ceniplete with documented agreemeet _
_j 2
.I Es Interface ' requirement -
.n e not applicable 7/10/92
]
}
' i P ' = DSER page number - no issue nemtier Page 17 n; = Not a DSER'irem -
r g
I-j 4
. a m
,1-__'__
,y
~
ABWR Tasks to wrap up PRA P A R DSER SSAR Title NRC Gmtart I n e Nest th:e Ac tion C<*m me n ts
+.
item. Sec tion a ~ Subtasit GE Omtw a a, Actor a i i
e w
D) Provide more NRC ?
References specific references few p3ed June i operator actions l as part of item fi
. identified as r-sponse sigt ificant based c.n sci stivity study.
Relerences should include tr.ble 'amt i
page numbers in references.
Alternatively, use a wider range in perfor ming - the senssuvity study.
E) Add comparm
~
contribution to CDF E/30.
FSER A.2.1.2 compare / to date-NUREC/CR-operating RWR.
7/36 55271.ahlic mindy is ter caw.
Containnr. nt Event Tree, sCET)
S4 Sa2fT essmates extra - Kelly '
c s CE n
CE witf rAe ucdit for item Rewfved credit for vent in Bahhola '
vent in Tel 1 T
Class 11 internal requantification event 2nd scismic sequettcts C. - Confirmatory item.
s = started
- S - Staff corr tion v = dis <ussed serbally but not dosnmented
~
O - = Outstanding item 6 complete with documented :.greement
! ' = Interface requirement n = *ent applic2 hic 7/10/92 P. = DSER p. age number - nu issue number n
- Not a DSER ' item Page 18
.. _..,... ~..
H, b
ABWF Tasks to wrap up PRA
_p c.
P A R DSER S&AR Tit 3r" NRC Gmtact ~ l n e. ~ Next Ihte Ac tion Cornn cnts Subunk -
GE G>ntact :
a-a - *. Act >r i?
..it e tu Scotiosi
+
n-I i
je e
g..
r p
J.
)
- O 13 neaunent of. Orwell
-;.wetwell bypass in :
1CETL: Trus item is
. addressed Ivy two sub
~ tasks:
i-I-
k i:'
L A) Design basis
. Kudrick.
Tracked J seniitivity. stualics Saxena segurately ty Kudric k/Sa xena
[CETs modified.
B) Descrmine if Palla/
n n
LErs need to <hange Rud rick
- Qtem rm4ved.
. to addsess trypass?
- Buchholz E s Palla Ec c c n n
n:
Item rewived.
. O.17B Modify CET for
? severe accident phenc Buchhniz individual issues
" I considered in uncertainty analysis. O-18.
~
. L.
- Backend Analyses (RA) -
i
+
l'
.e -
%8 y
4 g
je - ;
C j = Confirmatory ite:n ;
- s = started -
~
~f-l2 -
~
f.
- S T= StalTcorrectior.1 v = discused verbally but nce documented s
~
l-O' = Outstanding item i
.. c -- coenp1Me with documented agreement 7/10/92 I' ~=. Interfme reqcirementl n = not applicable P':' ' ' DSER page ' number ? no issue numler
=
{?
! n. = Not a DSER item i Page 19 7
4
~
4
% o'%
r s-ev s
,w-emse 6-
'.+e'
-nc~s n
-..x
.-----a-&~+
w
-.-----~x:--.n---
. ~.. - -. - - - --
~
r
[
a
- e O
/.., ~
b
-'e s-e s
..ws, y
.r.
,o -
q e
4 a
c.
P A R D5ER SSAR Titi NRC G,ns2< a i e
p,< x.
Da te Action Conn me n t a
]
ite ro Sec tion Sobeask GF; Ca mtact a
a -- Actor p
n I P
t c c GE ThD Reflet t in 5%AR f orludes n
taf Rcanalysis of Rag (hi u nce rtarnty BA-1 iner-w.ed thickness Liu treatment.
drywell head:
Analysis ufrimate ca.alility submitted 4/24.
SSAFF u}=iate j
afo y,fons
- tu&cdj'aa gueru L, NRC i
quessam m e rmaued ti/26,
.. n 19E Service fewt C Bagchi c
c G.
TBD Reflect in SiAR
' Should go in ll A 2 d t.curnen tation IE
.ume place as t00% MWR A aaly sis j
submitted 4/24.
1 SSAR upiate after questions rem'ved.
NRC 7
AMree safety factor Ba<ed on 6/8 i sue medvg item ms reu>lved
, by sut; tasks A1;C/
Q 'tmiowf-
~
c
,o I
s - started C = Confirmatory item v = divuw-d verba!!y but un documented S
2 SoJT rorn ctir n O = Outstanding item c - compleic with docurneated agccement
.I
- Iniceface requireroent n = not app!irabic 7/10/T P = DSER page numt,: r no iswe numtm Page 20 e Not a DSER itent n
4
$ m.
)
[. -
T i
>'i 2
1 9
2
/
e 0
g 1
a
/7 r
a
. 20 l
)!
K 8
nss S
3
)
i
. O e
C i i t
n R
/
e K
mG s
cJ-y i
Mlnd C a6 t
t l
u n t
or r mad Jo t
A rd t
i t o s
t s ns a(
u f en ee uen id i
l e
t a
s e u p m. 2 C i n
mi m
klie r uh e e
c a
r yd ih 9 Rr
/oC~Ds o
um l
m d gv2s l i c
/
r ciY l
e 2 Nt xb a w. g t
i nQ A pA B t
n. S. a o
ua e/y a
r s
u r
a Ad4 C
KBs6 se i
t d n I
ee nm t
eee ccg 1
. a 2
s s
t i
t c
y d d s
i c
m l
i a
t b
on na a
. ne m
tu u n
w w
bc o
ie e
o~
i y
it lnhe v
v t
d e
e t
- ibl A
A R
i I
t R
ewa P
v c
e eil t
5 dt p
a
/
ee p sl p D
6
.d r
s pa t
eucmt t
p r
r aeo o ar o.
C C
C C
G tsd( n w
ho R
R R
R R
. ===
tA N
N N
N c 'n o
s v t
Rev;eW s
ks
- Ana, c
t B
2 t t c A
mta
.f e
s k l l
l o
o o
G w..
i i
c
~i h h
h h
h CC dc g
g c
lah rh r
c ah i
c u
u t
l RE ue e
a aa au i.
i NC Kf l
l Bl Pn
'I fi l 1 r
e b
k s
e s
m F
ip o'
kd, D
G w
u' i
0 ladh nie i.
n 5
i e
f e
- n,
o n as e!
or c
e'e g
i s
. f e
u id e bt e
l r'
t n
a og i
u~
> s t
mt a
p s
t n
r e
d s d
.k ml i
ei e
a u n e
l r
dl s
e mi di g'
p R )t o
s r mt e
i t
c ng s(
e a
v ur m owol mG in
.b a
n.
n ~-
t r
u e
i a es r
yDi.
f o
e leS Deps P d h Ol bi e
r nn nP p m
me t
e m u
)f no ct e
r ape e
meb t
v i
)
)
ie c
im T-Ai4 s Boan C!c Fv uOS s e t
e r n i
i J
niuut t
e ye qoi e
nn6ge
( nr e R, n.
a ei gI R o..
mnr droS n
d r ua u gD e F. a
=
A f
i rt rR -
t f
s S c nT t,
R 'm
= *
- 4
- 1
' =.
4 IS e 4
Di C
0
.GSOI P n t
w
I r_
,i l
a
?p s '
m 2
2
'1 2
/
e 0
g 1
a
/7 P
'f lt J.
f o
0 y
n %.
at t
t n
3 n
n o
w )S a t/
h s
i i
/
c t
e a6 a
t 6
a o c t
s s
u ht d dd he e
r d
t i
s i.
n nd a
e s
c e
r e s
r t t i
m mi ae namai t
s t
ns t
t s
m ay u
l mWien_ s b e a hr m
um f
c f
o ob Ea u
en c
Ds
~
Gt
< ~ -
pS S a ae s
t g{
dn
- e. e a
nr e ce mr' ug c a' od de t :
on' ne m'
t uu n
bc' o
yo it dd a
A
^
xhc t
i t
R rib wwa P
dteU e
t eep p
a u
d sl p t
I s pa eu mt t
p r r aio o r
t i
C C'
a sdcn t
r xh R
w e c f
= =
NA N
N s = cn o
t r
R e*iet s
k s
. a2i c
(
a I
t PI ae c
(
(
R W
t~et ll t
d'n A
nn
.h r
i oi a
o Cm h
h h
CO
,h ah an l
l c
r l r RE au lau au NG~
Pi P!
PB l
r' e
.b
.m t
s u'
?
n m'
n
.h' e
r s
y am i
n~
e e
s t
u' r'
t pe U,
n' e
s ~
s i
t t
a'.
r'
. k f <
a c'
u oy t
c n'ty o
i i
s m
t n m
dr o
oi l
S c!
rd Cr
.n-u ie c
4 g
t r
m'mebm e' i
t o I
c eo C
)i
)
t e
~s NG C
Ai" i : erim m 1
n 1
t t
ni u u te t
yo qni riet ge c nr eR taei gE m r d 'e a 'D ir r i 4 o r c p oaa i
1At ei ct f rRa SA' nnt eEt f
s SS o a ut S o Ct OIn S
DN R
Ei 5
6 ai ' - =
=3 n
S te-
,1 1
I i O^
0 C5O_1 Px r
r't xi s
,l'
j i I
4
,t ys(
, - ~
M
..e 7
3 9
2
/0 eg 1
a
/7 P
e e
n
,/
4
. 5 u<
c d
b t
u e
S o
n,.
s ed dn dn 1
o o
/
i//
i s
r y
gw hh t
c vh S
a46 Mt i
s p
t p
t af i
e n
a o
q d
nd. h
.t t
l e
u inn. s s s 6 w 6 e
ec c cd n i s aid e 2
e 2 u
n :t umtee e
dde s or r /
r /
n i e 5
5.
n um mw pm i
a i e
r y n
ivt cl h e
a<at m m
m l
t; c
m e,
obs;uo l
rl rl r
ip o
denn e e
c, a
te r
r ep <a
{%-
r#
Du6Aac nr I
t uaMb bI c I
C t
dnee nm t
eec ms u g' a
n x
e d o
de
- d t
t ar a on wt ne n
m t
e e i bc' u u n
dir u yo n
o i
r d
c l
t e
l o
a e
s A
A n
n Pd h he l
t rib R
ewa v
c P
5 eli p
te 1
.dt a
/
ee pp u
D n
n n
7 dnlpa eu mt p
aco o r
r r
a o
C sd c n t
ts R
t
- = = =
w ec n
n N
Q NA n
s e c n o
t v
v Rev c*
c e
s k
s Anai r
c c
c r
aT P1 an c
r v
c RW e
B mt A
s z
z e
s s a ir l
t ta hl oti a
o o
r
/ i o'
c Cw h
.h h
.h h
C G lau F',
PB Fr PRf ah
- h an ah l
tt c
r l
c lsr h i
d c l
t t
E au lao au la uu' JiNC PI l
l t
l i
e' r
s
.b is c
o i
an f'
r p
sy u
1 u
l t
s 0l e
t s
a a
a
_r e
r r
n id.
a 0n e
o n
e e o f
a t
c v
u.
_u s
i e
mt i
sy y
s.
i, s
si l
r e y
.s r
nti e
r
.i k
t rf e
el o
i3 r'
n s
e f y e
s CC k
v ea t
i n
r;
, a
. t t
a r
rt a R' e h.
Dr e.
n b
T t
u c
et n.
y u
a Pt S
SrW fi.
c e
n cS ti i
f m
n e
.dl c
s e.
pB
!t a
aA 4 e.
D+U t
mrb 1 n
) r e
i oC a
)
)
m m O-Mf U
A H p r
i s
i e
otiuut yc t
rig < ni ot r e eR c: r t
rde,E e!
g a
S n
mrnc pU Ro r c aa s
fna i
At ct f
r S (c nf ts f
eEt us s e.
SS o a n
Ct OI nN S
R'
. = = *=
Em N
S e
-.A 1
I i
I Dt
- 0. 7 0
C' SO1 P r.
h t
f!L, Jl'
.. P 1
AEWR Tasks to wrap up I'RA P A R DSER SSAR Ti4!c tiRC G,otact i
n c Nex t I)2 te Ac tinn Comments
.ite m Sec tiort Sul-tad GF,Catta<t-a a v
Actor I
i ft r
S.) - Detailed Palla v
5 s
NRC submitted 6/
CCI/ Coo! ability Buc hhoir tirgers%ty analysis
[Conix cred in I
?
T) Cavity ilnor arc 2 NRC omlaMIity (etr), item 7 of Buchnn!2 uncertainry 4/13/92 At'R5 feuer l. analysis.
Qbniued 6/3 h>iwuned 6/12. )
-G) Detailed bypau l'alla :
NRC Stan agreed l
i:n(critainry arialysis Huchhciz.
~
methods and remits renonshie.
I Q_bmitted 6/3]v p
(-
l l
6
.w
~
. Drywell Sump'
?
CE 7/30
- Sped n
84-3
' coolahdity j
CLil
, - started C = Ccafinnate y item v i discussed verbally Isut ac: documented j
S ~. = SutT corre<tiem t~
i c = com;Jete with docurnented agrecment O : = Outstanding item 7/10/tn
< Interface rettoirement '-
n = not apoticable '
- P.
= DSER page number - no kmc number Pme24 n s Not a t;SER item.
L'"
4
P A R D:iER. SSAR Titt r-NRC Contac
?
n e Next Date Action Comments iteur Section
' Subudt -
3E Omtact a a -* Actor n i i'
e W
NRC Refied:t agtrement in NRC agrro S9 Rupture dhi Palia.
FSER.
ruptuse disk operati:>n tefore 24
' nuchhole ogx eatisen is sect hmirs r:ot coat failure toneainment failu r e.
It s Rewived -
h.h'Ts autxnined i 6/30 conuin infne ma tion.
w SI2 ATWS ueatment bv Palla NRC-Rc3c<t ofmure in FSER NRC agrees GF.
NR C..
Budalm11 appeunh cmtservatsve, no o her i cpacts n
hmjvsd I
R NRC Additior== (NRC)
NRG - Chapter 22 Severe Are.ident Ku irk k~
c."c-NRC' ?
Write sec tion.
FCI q.ic36ons l
C osore Itochholt cwpectc<L
' Inform CE er mere info needed l>epx-d that identified in'2/20 submit:21.
c w
s = started C = Confirmatory item S = Stsficoricction -
, e discus 6ed webal;y but not dexumensed c y complete with documented agreeinen 0 = Outstanding item -
7/10/tr2 I-
= interface rev]uirement n = not applicable-P-
= D5ER pag. number - no inue number Page 25 n = Not a D5ER item
.s,
- ',,, f,[.
w.
m S.
- *;., g.
~
- .4 g
, i
+
' ~
,. ~.
'IS A'- 'R Comments
'D$ER I:3 SSAR.-
Title.
' NRC Gintact
'I -.n i c - Next ' t ble-
.c sson 7
- isem %6ovi -
- -faibiash
=CE O,nskt
'a. - a. v :- Arnor n 1 i'
[~
e W
] [.
y r s-
.N RC-,.
- Acciderit ;
- 1Palla :
s c'
v ' ' N R s.. 76/5~
Early review is
[Qf
. ; g.
idve. -IINL Need more discunine] pos 12T managemcot.
. But filiati. -
review. in
?
[i'"
NRC action required j progress. : E/5;
^' NRC wants
. more, 4;
~n,
- 't
-o l:n NRG.
SAMDA Submit:21' Palla? -
. Need the dow.
l tame for l'I7 g
ls
'. 3 '
4
- Quirk
-i not
, req'd,L simplification.
+
y y,.
y 6/30s
[9
~
! eiem5r Analysis Beyond Deelgri Ease (SA).f S
N
= grJ 191g3 l :FdelismMy :
Kelly:
2; GEi
? Update SSAR
. NRC, CE have '
' agreed to I.T.g.
fc2Jparity,
J iu "
Ite m r o o!vral "
~
i
' See : Margins: Analysis 5 S4l-., i191L5-
- flat-bottrieri tankB Kelly
- v CE 1
- capacity.
- Ilu.
.i L (SA.2) a -
. p.,
.571
.1911.5-i 3 Diesel ghnerator :
Kr 11;...
~
v; JCE-
) Margins - Anatysi, L
- - cagacity; Du '
.: S-8 :
.191L51
- Electrical;espipment g Kelly :
- v ~
GE Margins ' Analysis;
~
C L. -
r,a. pacip "'
( Liu..-
21; y;s
?-s nearted ~..
.. g.
u ;.
4
': Gj= don!irinatory item
- v.= discuued verbally but aww documented ?
7 y
S i i = S sfT rorrection J 2.
c = comt ete with -locumented agreemena.:
J
- 016 Outstanding item l
-7/10/92:
4
> n = not applicable
.1 -...: e Interfi ce requirement :
P-n:a DSLR page' numler ino issue number Pare 26 ~
s7-.
- n s Not's D5ER item
-w
.. _ ' ~
p.
u.
~
e a-
/
=
~
I "
's
-,.3 ABWR Tasks to wrap up PRA -
~
L p A g
- DSER - SSAR--
Title
-NRC Contare I n e New t. Date Action Commer:es I.
- i t e m. Sec tion Suhtask GE Contact
'2 a ' v.
. Actor n 1 i~
e-W 4,'
... =
f v
CE Margins :asalysis..
Site specific PRA i-14. j 191L5-
' C<mfirm electrical Kelly
(
.- equipment capacities Duncan not required _
.in site 3pecific PRA -
Capwoues used in margins.
analysis will'. b
~'
- COL spplican W-( action. '
blW ?
r v
NI C
[ Addressed by -
K' j
f
' O 2 til 19 10 ;
z Scistni4 capacitics for... Pa ta '
R
. systen's not in; Duncarb SSAR text 19.10; submiurd 6/fL retti6cd deqigts -
9:
. S 10
- n -
Staff wi!I use 11NL :
Seismic PRA nct
[
f hazard curve :
. Kelly. ~
-~1-
- n n
I Duncan required.. Item.
+
~
' reso!ved e-n' Ln
- Not required, 4-Ilow to ceas se:smic] ! KcIly :
. --- H n
- n-
' SA 1 -
hasard uncertainties Durwan :
Item resolved
-y g
i1-10 19,9 JConiirm assumed:
. Kelly v2
-CE
[/ddressed b[ '
. scismic capacities J
- Dttocan -
- SSAR text 19.9,,
-' - farkt bcorporate in ;
Qbmetted 6/30f
.. design specs.
1 11.
.n:
Modify scismic PRA' K e lly...
' --- : - ? -- { n n:
Seismic. PRA not.
J to acccunt for soi!
Duncan:
required NRC.'
failures may. add.-ess by
' site licensing '
T*
. requirement 1:
- Item Resched '
N o
.- j '
Cl 3 C mGrmatory Litem -
s - started J.
" S w = Sta!T correction..
v = discueed verbally but not documented.
Of. vous.atanding item -.
'c = compicte with docurnented agreement..
L I '.,. Interface requirement n =. not applicable J
~
'7/10/92
- P :
- DSER page reumber - no inur number n ' A Not's DSER item '
Page 27 -
'a
.h.'.'s m..;..i..
e2 m.-
2.: -
~,,.,
P A 'R
~7 DSER " SSAR Tdle NRG Contact I n
-e Next - Date Arti<m
. Comments ':
~i'te m.. Sertion Su uasi
- CE Contact
.a
.. a - v A(tur n t i
t.
G"
? :.,
i GE agices to
---i- - n:
n n
I.17. 19.9 f Plant ealkdown
-Kefly pizn t walkdown Duncan per EPRI NP; by apnlicant (441 1
i.
1(fY13 feSOITfd 4ddressed by SSAR text 19.9.
4
~)'
7"-
submitted 6/30,
.1
.w-u, iJ Seismic PRA not y;
l:.
['
'I 13 '-
n.
Site specific: seismic.- - Ke fly.
--n n
n required. ~ NRG PRA by applicant.
.Duncan roay address liv.
Site liter. sing 1
t-requirement (Item Resolved -
- i.., Pa lla --.
. v:
FRC
?5
- Resiew 6/4 submittal.
Progxwl
,g I7Addtru p<acntial for :'- Kneche
. Rapid fectiback approuh L
, 19 '
19E.213.4 l penetiation,,.,
l
-isciation valve failusc.
' requested.
provided to NRC '
Dec. 91.Jn. 92
..Lduring seismic event ;
. Next:
. incorporate -
' seismic into-bypass studd
' Tevismn tobypass study ' },
j q
f.,...
m-
. ( submitted 6/4.
+i ' l J
~
.E.J
!?
A s = startt.d f Ci?(Confirmatory item :
vf d'acuwti verhalh but not documentedi G[--
J S S i StaK correcim c = complete with documented agreement (0 ; Ortstanding item -
o
- not spot' _able :-
7/10/92
'I
}-= Interface yequirement '
F
. P ' : = DSER page nurnber no issue number
- Page 28:
. n' % Not a DSER item -
- A
-Q_.
s-S-'
_m_
a.g b
--+.e.
8" L
W
~
i' A R DSER SIAR Tide NRC Contact I n
e Next Da te Ac tion Com me n ts
% tstask GE Cesnaari a.
2
.v Attor ite su Sectim n I i
e W'
CETs not nee.bl SS Correct the Kelly v
n in margens treatment of Vis h u analysis 4
firewa ter in Seismic
{mbmitted 6/26.
Cass il CET
- n Margins analysis Kelry NRC
?
Submitteel C/26, SA-T Fred e ric k including seismic l
capatisies for
[
applicant to I ches k (we.Wy U"U CE IBD Reflect margins analysis in SSAR NRC ?
Nw word =: '.%> HCLPF Protub!y no i
does a<34 become piactic21 innpart.
j i
design value.
l l
Achievable, isut not a l
requirement.
[
>~.;
\\,
- k Other Etternal LLuzarsh -
' s = started C = Confirmator-; item v = discussed vertsally but not documentni S = Staff corrertkan O
Outstanding item c = complete with documented agrecer.ent ~
= Interface requirement n - not applicable -.
7/10/97 P = DSER page number - no issue number n =- Not a DSER item ~
Pas;e 29
D
. ~
ADWR Tasks to wrap. top PRA P A R DSEit. SSAR Title NRC Contact I.
n e Next Date Artinn Commenet 4
item Ser si< m Sul task CE Crmtact a
a v
A(tor
'a' n I i
e w
m Site specific-d-sign Ke it y NRC 6/92. N?.C wi!! probably "Grandchik1* of
' l8
-n verification: c e tna: Du r.can address a, supple: sent SECY 016 due c
.qcumis, transpor ation to ST.R: Guidance to almutjene.
g hazards appbrant.
Classic design analysis alonc may be suf&ient.
$lf Probably no actmn ivy GE.
/
Interfaces (Cencral) (IN) e
] 19.9 Be sure PRA s
CE CE believes ?9.9 n
IN. 8
- requirements" and 19.10 addren 19]f instghts get inte this inue/
' Interface write up*-
Conaequente Analysis (CA) n.
No NRC feedhark on ' Palla NRC
' Reflect igreement in Pali. / Ca r ew:y CA-s
. site acceptability-Careway FSER dixuM 4/2.
Appendix 2A NRC agrecs.
- Item Rewived (Correcious L submiterd 6/29.
t CE THD Reflect corrections in
.i SSAR.
1-C - Confirmatory item.
s = started S
z= Staff cc:rct6on
- v - dismssed verkl}y but no documented n
O ' = Outstanding. item
' c = comgJefe with documen.cd agscement I. = Interface revguirement.
n = not applicabic 7/10/92-P = DSER page nu'mber 7 no inue number n- = Not a DSER item Page 30
.... -, _ _., -.... -. ~. - -.
~
--._r.
w ABWR Tasks to wrap up' PRA-l.
P.A R
DSERc. SSAR '
LTitle
- NRC Contact i n ^ c Next ' Date Ac tion,
' Com men ts
-ite m " Set tion Subtast
- - GE Contar s
-a
- a v Actor
., g d
.c W'
1 T'
..4 in.
- n Renett corrected
?
is n
n~
Carrection.
+
CA.2 CRAC/weat h er
.Careway made.
J_t.im.
t ik-i
~' trcatmept i41 rc1polved
~
\\
' consequesxc anaf ds,.
4 f
n-19E.3 New consequerne f alla ~
NRC.
f Need NRC-..
i[
- CA 3
analyds for PRA' Careway
- agreement on
/g
~
' CETs mid Junc.
1 to make this b
date $nhmitte7 U
6/30.'
--a
.n c 19F.3 -
- New cormsequence.-.
- 7.:.
.NRC:
--RcDect agreerrent
' Submitted 6/3]0 z
CA ; analysis for. EP72 Ca r e wa y' '
^FSER; s
" n'-
19P
- Appendix'19P (50.34f. Palla ;
iNRC' Submitted F/30.
- f CA-5.
ydcdgn mods); update;.- Knecht.L 1
8
~
1,.-
,}
~
.y n
-.s.
- C J Q-Confirmatory item -
Ja a started ;
1
. s. 3taircorrection ;
v-discusse,1 verha'ty but not tiocuwnted;.
- O+ <- Outstadding. item I.
L.= liiterfaie re quirement.
ic = complete withfdocumented a6reement :
n Snat appGcabic-7/10/9??
' o r
[y.
P $ = DSER page nurnbera no imic number ~-
, re y g Not a DSF.R item ?-
~ Pagt -.3 8 )
x 4-
i.1,.l r
NA -v <-d.
v -+N U
w' A '
L e-2
- *~
v
' ' ^ ' *
~