ML20101M925
| ML20101M925 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Farley  |
| Issue date: | 07/01/1992 |
| From: | Repka D ALABAMA POWER CO., WINSTON & STRAWN |
| To: | Bollwerk G, Carpenter J, Morris P Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#392-13068 91-626-02-CIVP, 91-626-2-CIVP, CIVP, NUDOCS 9207090082 | |
| Download: ML20101M925 (7) | |
Text
_ _ - __ _ _ - _ _ _ _.
,/BO(oW L
WINSTON & STRAWN wemm
'6NHC reiwrn.cx w a w onnew m 4400 t smrtT n w
.su cu a sus-v- seni,e u s u a an ec 2000s3se:
.m yi sm FE3vif 1202' M i SW'0
...,n,x,-._,
4 (202) 371-5726
^~m July 1, 1992 G.
Paul Bollverk, III James H.
Carpenter Administrative Judge Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Atomic Sai ity and Licensing U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Board Washington, D.C.
20555 Washingte,
D.C.
20555 Peter A. Morris Administrative Judge 10025 South Glen Road Potomac, Maryland 20854 In the Matter of i
ALABAMA POWER COMPANY (Joseph M.
Farley Nuclear Plant, Units 1 and 2) b pocket Nos.:
50-348-CivP: 50-364-CivP ASLB12 No. 91-616-02-Civ?
Dear Administrative Judges:
Yesterday, Alabama Power Company filed its " Response to the Board's May 1, 1992 Order Regarding Proprietary Information."
As noted therein, Attachments D and F ware copies of facsimiles.
In both cases the copiec were in fact made from second generation facsimiles.
I have now obtained copies of the first generation facsimiles, as provided by the vendors to Southern Nuclear.
These copies, enclosed, are slightly clearer than the copies attached to the Company's pleading.
Very truly yours, N
Q David A.
Repka
~
counsel for Alabama Power Company
Enclosures:
As stated cc:
Service List 9207090082 920701 PDR ADOCK OS000348 g
G PDR Jy g,
w~-
e ATTACIDiENT D
-u
2,.t G 6ba; az:LedcCsicr1ER Fkoiccis,'
~
-~
~
p.a ALA 92-596 WestinChouse:
Energy Systems ax m o
Electric Co@0 ration P e r P m m m is2 m i
June 26, 1992 Mr.JJ. D. Woodard, Vice President Ref. 1:
ALA-92-662 6
Nuclear Generation Ref. 2:
06/25/92 Telecon Southern Nuclear Operating Company-with W. R. Stewart-P. 0.-Box 1295 and D. Repka Birmingham,'AL 35201.
Attention:
Mr..R.-W.' Stewart SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING COMPANY J0$iPH M. FARLEY NUCLEAR PLANT UNITS 1 AND 2 PROPRIETARY'INFORMATION
Dear Mr. Wodard:
Mr. McKinney's letter.to me 'ited May 4,1992, identified four documents for which the Atomic Safety Licensing Board had questioned the need to continue proprietary treatment. Attached is a Westinghouse affadavit which states that the four documents continue to be proprietary.
Please contact'this office if-you have any additional questions on this-subject.
Very truly yours, WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC CORPORATION fO J. A.-Knochel, Manager Alabama Project
/ daw Attachment u
p j-L:
l ALAE 96:eew 920626 f:
J,, _,, -,
u_
. - - ~
.;2 25. % ; cLQf+ng&i.Go;tC5
~
P3
\\
m W8EtlDgh0US8 Energy Systems in 355 Electric Corporation
"*0"""
"23" June 26,1992 To Wnom it May Concern:
Westinghouse hu reviewed and usessed the proprietary nature of the text and informulon in WCAP 9885 (and supporting documents), WCAP-7709L, WCAP 7709L Suppleme and WCAP 9157. Westinghouse has concluded thu all information continues to be pr His usessment is predicated on the factors set forth in 10 CFR 4 2.790(b)(4). Westinghou expended considerable effort to develop the design information and the test results contained in
- WCAPs listed above. The information contained in the WCAPs could not be easily others. Hus, it represents a competitive advantage which requires protections allowed under 10 CFR i 2.790(b)(4)(v).
Information extracted from the aforementioned WCAPs by Franklin Research Center and inclu Freklin/TER equipment environmental quallfleation review of equipment item numbers 11
- a f, i, j),13 (pages 5 a 1),16 (pages 5 a-f, I, j) 18 (pages 5 a j), 21 (pages 5 a k),27 (page 5f) proprietary and may be relused.
In addition, Supplements 1-4 to the letter from Alabama Power Company to the NRC, dated 2/2 were reviewed. Information contained in Supplement 1 (proposed solution for the Rosemount and Supplement 4 (proposed solution for the Gems DeLaval transmitten) is not proprietary to Westinghouse. Information marked as proprietary in Supplement 2 (proposed solution for the Barto Lot 1 and 2 transminars) and Supptamant 3 (proposed solution for the Foxboro Model El1 (MCA and E13DM transmittars) continues to be proprietary to Westingbouse for the reasons cited above, Peter L Morris, Manager Strateglo Safety and Regulatory Issues
/c!d l
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 26"1 day of h 1992.
V Ya $.
dAL Notary Public cunmemm LDfWu! M NPCE. NOWy M Exfres 905
... a. _. -
l' l
mm m mg m_m
~
l 1
1 I
i ATTACHMENT F I
e b
l t
I i
?
i i
b t
f E
9 L-.-.--
. l
7JFI5a' n.,; ; 3. :na.O vAmvE ENM ;EPT TEL NO 912017es3174 g323 pai l
l Au.omalLc Switch Co.
Hanover Road, Florham Park, NJ 07932 Facsimile Cover Sheet To: R. W. Stewart Company: Southem Nuclear Operating Co.
Phone: 205-8(8-5640 s
Fax: 205 868-5002 From: John R. Shank Company: Automatic Switch Company Phone: 201-966 2244 Fax: 201-966-2624 Date: 06/25/92 Pages including this cover page: 2
~
Comments:
Attached is a revised Affidavit in response to B.D. McKinney, Jr.'s June 24,1992 letter, Sincerely,
<d
/
x John R. Shank
/je
s
.;Tg;ds;'vt T4;14 Dm5CO M.vd M NPT
- L NOn 9120178531*74 tt323 P02 1
Automatic Swild Co.
a m.t... m.. EWE f t.onn AM PAmt. NEW JER5ty 07932 e 5eu ess-acoorn v. iata,344 87ss 8en-ess asas s'flDAVII CDWCittlWG A!/TCHAflC $VIICM COMeArt (A$CO)
PROPt.f f &ef St>0018 AD$=21678/1t, elv. A A.@ Age.67366, Riv.1 Autenstic twitch Compeny (ASCO) eeporte AU 21678/f t, tev. A orus Aot 6T368, sev, i are cenelsered by ASCO to to proorletery. Seth rooorte sere presored et considerable saperse to AECD e>d conteln oetelled tecmical inf orsetten eAlch, if previoso to our concetition, could result in 66tstantlet harm to ASCO's cogetttive poeltlen.
speelficetty, these reporte conteln detailed technicon inf orset t on conesmine orelen pereestere, perforsunce puremeters, meterlate of construction. setheos of c ene t ruc t i on, o.m t i f i c e t t en methode,
o,ellfication precoues, wellflection test reevite, Atco laboratory copetinities, reces==enood oorwice
- evels, and asintenance receamendations. This inforestion le of the trpe that would custonee-be considered proprietary by a cenpeny like ilCC and is not evollable free petic sources.
Autoestle $ Witch Ctnpeny (ASCO) eleo considere any excerpte or egemerles f rest these reports idtich conteln technicet inf ocustion concernirg pestyn perspentere, pe*former.:e per meters, meteriets of a
construction, seethoes of construction, :pslifiestion mothede, cNallfleetten procedJree, saallf tcetion test results, AtCO taboretary cepeellities, recessmended service tevels, and meintenerre recommennettens ta be proprietary.
This peeceletery designetton specifican ty incLtssee Franklin sesearch Center Ewipeent trwirereental ovellfleetion soview (FRC Project No. C5257, Assignesent No. 13, Test me. 509,
$18) end other slalter documente.
These reporte and ASCO auseerles or eacerpts free theos reports which centeln technican infonsetton concerning coolen pareesters, performerce perameters, esterlate of construction, methose of construction, gaeL{fleetlen methode, emllficetten proc eskarea, oaellfication test reeutte, ASCO 1sheretery espeel(ltise, rscansenM eervice LewLe, and asletenence rocassmenetstiMe heve eLweys been scneidered proprietary by ASCO, have alweye had a controlled distribution lleited to those who have e legitimate need for copies and have always corried restrictione en their reproduction and circulation.
As such, in etweence with the provielers of 1D CFA Part 2 section 2.790(e)(4), these reporte end all essgeerles or encorpts f rost these reports chich contain technical Informatten concernine deelen perameters, performones pereentere, estoriels of construction, methods of coretruction, czaellfication methods, quellfleetion precedures, cNetificetton test results, ASCO taboratory espedititles, recenmended service Leve,, ord saintenence recosemordettone should not be rete sed to petic casein includine the Nic P2Lle Doctements soon.
.- -n, o Terence L. Johnson Dirvetoe of ligt irg Volve Erwineerire Depe'rteent this Af fidevil hoe been 5 mom er,d s@ scribed to i-before me this 5th day of Jurs, ll42 p.~
mm
- -m NY COMM!$330ll DMRES OCT,21,1992
.