ML20101K514
| ML20101K514 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 12/19/1984 |
| From: | Doroshow J, Jordan W CHRISTIC INSTITUTE, HARMON & WEISS, THREE MILE ISLAND ALERT, UNION OF CONCERNED SCIENTISTS |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#484-834 SP, NUDOCS 8412310377 | |
| Download: ML20101K514 (11) | |
Text
---y-4 S:
h kNEEkbNk
(
UNiit0 #TAffs Of A14EffA hWLtAM kt4VI Aluef O*t19910W htf 0hM YbM AlfWIII #AttYY AhD tif thstMi htiA#P in the twlttet et MtYkOf6blYAN 60t#0H C0NiAhV I
(+ Met has %@=i4% #P
)
(fotift #***F4 (thf 6w Siil# lelend Neleef
)
en haehi*e*6tl
- tatten, tient be.16 6
!5HOLLJL(!!iWLLLAL1h!1tYikstEMils ey its sidef et my 11, less
- **. sos es Anw*t 19, 1964, the bestd f ut*4 that W9 end 1HI A weld te lese int *f v&P9f s en the trainihy 1 H 98# e4 fellW st N$b 1.
Afa its erf*taf* if4+e*4 ta f,4tely erf4t*
tbk PisBt IB eFE9144E?F ellh (F# st rienm 4 Pf6Eeddf*, j4filEdlifly in *EFI efep 61144f1669)
F*skut*(Fweef4 tete {Ffwiinall8HsfellsFlp f *8 t! k h N sF4 DiafeE le sbility la e4tulp 9teista (Fw p entf 1&lhJ*dhsd
):
49e 6tU ( f 6t* fly f *tinFed 18 the a:f bblW lh its tielhthw if eif e laahtitl&9164*f F*lly h64/Hf Li (ba s p >Eini t%twf, if+ (iE*ns the h afa, et ihm Ap p 4 6 (+ 4 f d f is Afk the Ubiik ibelehAlbid Inf if 8 P4h*ikakht and idil*4*htstien'81 1F* (1418164 tibif e (f81afI( Stelip d Fy (Fulf beH k+1of16hE6 4h4 nit it+1* 4 (8 (+pMit (bk lEl8feillt-6 *b4 V41H H Hkeke*9fy fHf *8le F pf4tthB Bf 1N{rtyg E&l&
V - ()
4-_a sem.- - - --
t thS f;.
i+ tFe w*f4 term have the attf8 triste entitude is=#f s tw if dleihy tiegf A+i N th*y evil &ve it is stimettvet A4 A f ** wit et YNI A'# #tivM*ive t*f tielratibe in the fileEhear 54414f em M4 finite WM het leben the im6d (H develeri6t th* Ed#e en the listalE4 (Hus4.
While 1MIA has teftleitAt*d 46 neh et testi&lve it het est hee Able 18 da es 69ttleivatly te tet* th leed 69 tis l#twet fer enten it -46 bu e 4*hlyndt*4.
W s AFA TNIA have datestn 4 W 1864 lat*fveset statut
- W id to EheEi*e8 in etest te ivil*Et 14 E91f*st enteetlen.
64u4 96+8 l
these ditte*ntense WW #941NIA believe thet it le een reuible l
te HF# lhe4 int #fve68f tietus eR the leswks d4 bist%4 el+ves l
18814s4, hiEEW TNih hes (Fedshed 66 DV8f Al dihEIF6% steHkh sF4 IsetW41 P866tf e it W4914 t# iktf EfflhtB (9 shelyH id sh less iM$fV6E9f FB ell 81 the (the>M sh hinted hp thW F4 side but (8 hev# THIh set 861944 FM [4f tiEWldf 6 9(M9 Hf thitifelsf tsElW4%
..ite m m,m,m W,.
66EbidlFilys W# AF41Hf h F6VW thht th $8sf4 6464lw th# las4 iMelveF6f inus en telle,qi l
La htblin Ns as lead lHbf MFhf bB thF itse## hista 4 l
hEnves ja AthlhH TNih es (kad 16tefW hbf NH the (Hilewi61 ftdirlshue#l
- Th> EhMfeHtFfs lhte* f stys Wh4 4ttlth4F# el $ 6Hilk f 8vt+6*lHe thf F4MiWht a68 IFil>ASMhtlHB Hi UN (fAl6thi (f6jfsM l
{
y
._2
_,,nm-m--
-~
~ ~ -
oz.
= Adegweev and Fit +fivty of dimelpitedly actione (Anon by Islevet** In fwaree** 18 the eh*Ating laeldveta af faldted translag tellutes.
= Fettelen et fallwive af dettel*Melen twiated to the isn9** f al**d by AhAh=173, an f evealog by the i
hietely et the len9*H et Yhtwe Mlle 181664.
):
Felait efeat **WstEntien OV TNIA en le69*# covered t y WB bhwie 1MI A E8VWEB distihet peintt tweh de IF46Viddele othef then th8s# d4df #et#d by WN.
I W6 654 THI A **peet that thle eitieseh will f enuit in W8 964*f tshing the vest F4)efity of the ef ess=>niemit?Atina, while YNIA will F4f tiespete with festeet to the few lenues en whteh it has be4 sese oprett994ty to fee 94 Diseussiefit that W9 efid 'lHI A heve h&4 th4(este that thef e le vefy little eveflep l*tk*rft thelf Appfbeenkt, eithewgh et fla*# they ed4fe## the AAsw insWwe, AM ts6's (64946 heve been 61sted by the FOAide h(/
fesp* elf 911y Aut4Ritteds j% i m a A w /if, -
w = n c /,,s.*s
- J8sEEN IWf6hhes WillihM,Pa Jeldshe III Tf,* Chf istlO lH4tif His Oh WiiHs W isse 6 J0rliAh Illt tief th Capitel sis
- 001 e #tfeels fieWe
&4albif98, beUs 19603
- 9ite ild 0-C.
30004
( j t))) IWfs9106 bis h h ih9 t hfl e % 00
(#03) ilh=1 tut 1HIA tof Ns (etodi
(+e*atet 1%, 1964 l
r 1
l l
Deesaba r 19, 1984 UNITt0 87ATr# Of AMkRICA
+ '" j g; r.
HUCLKAM NKOULATORY C MMId810N 4 i,
htf0RM TitM ATMIC CAFKTY AND LICENetHO #0AFD 7' l
l In the Metter et
)
)
MtTP0f0LITAN FDisbH CWPANY
)
boeliet No. $0=289 er
)
speatert Romand iThrow Mi tta telefid !!uele At
)
on Man 49ement) 5t At ton, Unit 149. 1)
)
fitiful ATimypf_TpAtulho tyt:2t!gt; in older to **pedite the restert heartfiy on training issues aful to obviate the need for itCa to call a nwater of witnesses, UC# and Lleenske stipulate es followns 1.
Llenn&6e stipulates to the authorittelty and adminaltillity of the following doeweents, whlen include ela documents on which UCd liitendt to rely in (to ceme=in=ehief s 1.
July 14, 1944, final emitif tention statement of r..
Freuer ten, conelettny of e one pa9e Peeorendum and four bena=wtliten LAyps Gated August :), 1944.
ifteviously identitled as tantbli ll0. ) to thw Letonitioli of lif.
liuktil )
2.
tv419At ton of lit. frederlek stated #/11/40 et thes bottom of the tirbt pays and eenstatiny of two pages.
(Pf wviously identitlud at the tirnt two psyan of linhibit lio J (9 tte I 96:0ellion of lif. lin wt oli e l 1.
Lvatustion et fit. Frederlek dated 4/12/40 et the bottom et thu tirat payu Anei connietifi9 of two peype.
(PipVieunty itinallfled he th.* in At two payne of UNhibit fa. I to the bajoeitlun of fit. fip wt on. )
4.
tvaluation of P!f. Pf edef icit d Ated Jen. 3 },
1901, di the Lottos of the tirbt pAye and turisistiny of thf un payen.
IPf avlo481/ 161*ntifica en tuhlbli 09. 4 to the bel o# 1 t iori of fit. f>wton.)
2-5.
Employew Change of Status form for Mr. Frederick dated 3/8/8J in the upper lef t cornar of the firat page.
i consistiny of 11 pagen.
(Proviously identified as Exhibit No. 5 to thu Deposition of Mr. Newton, except that Licenson has added appropriato pagua to the exhibit i
to assure that it la complete and accurate.)
6.
HilH Consultation W1th OPU Nuclear Managementi Prlotity Concerns of Licensed Cporator's at TMI-1 and Oyster Crook and Suggested Action Steps - rinal lleport, Paul r.
D' Arcy, Ph.D and John R. Sauer, Ph.D., Ma rch 15, 1983.
(Page numbero added by UCD.
Markings on pagna 1, 11, 15, 21, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 32, 34 woro placed on the document by UCil.)
7.
Memorandum f rom Paul D' Arcy to Dob Arnold of May 17, 1903, itse CPU Nuclear - TH1-1 Porcuntagon, and accompanying statistico.
C.
1:mployeo Porformanco Review of II.M. Olivo dated both 10/19/fij and 5/15/04 in the uppor right corner of thu first pago, consinting of 5 pagon.
(Proviously identified as the first fivo pagon of Exhibit I;o. 2 to Mr. Iluk ill's Deposition) 9.
Memorandum of June 8,1904, f rom II.D. Ilukill to Pilo,
!!ub ject I)1mouncions with Mr. fl.M. Olivo - (1hif t Oputations foreman, THI-1, consinting of two pagon.
(Proviously identiflod au thu nixth and noventh pagou of Unhibit 2 to the Duponition of Mr. Ilukill) 10.
Memorandum of Juno 14, 19(14, from li.J. Toolv to ll.D.
Huh ill, tiub pet i W.
Olive, conniuting of two pagon.
(Proviously identified an the lont two pagos or Exhibit 2 to the Dopobition of Mr. Ilukill) 11.
telloyne Por formanco 149 view of II.K. Olive dated October 25, 19112, in the upper right corner of thu first pago, i
consistiny ot 4 pagon.
(Proviously identiflod as the titut four peyuu of 1:xhibit No.1 to Mr. Ilukill's coponition) l 11.
Employco f or formanen lieview of II.M. Olivo with no dato 6n the f ir nt pago, dated 10-19-01 on thn laat payo, consisting of 4 1ayeh.
(Previount/ identified an the nocond tour pagon ut Exhibit Io.1 to Mr. liuk t11's r
Deposition) i I
l i
l
! 13.
Employee Performance Review of H.K. Olive, dated
\\
10-19-83 in the upper right corner of the first page, and 10/17/84 on the last page, consisting of 5 pagen.
l (Previously identified as the ninth through thirteenth l
pages of Exhibit No.1 to Mr. liukill'c Deposition) 14.
Employee Performance Review of II.K. Olive, dated 10-19-83 in the upper right corner of the first page, and 9/7/84 on the last page, consisting of 5 pages.
(Previously identified as the nineteenth through twenty-third pagon of Exhibit No. I to Mr. liukill' a Deposit ion) l 15.
Employeo Performance Review of II.K. Olive, dated I
10-19-83 in the upper right corner of the ficut pago, with the words "3rd Eval. Reviewed on 10/1/84" in the contor at the top of the first page, consisting of 5 c
pagen.
(Proviouuly identified as the twenty-fourth l
through twenty-eighth pagon of Exhibit No. I to Mr.
i liukill' n Doposition) 16.
Upgrado Program for !!.K. Olive dated July 23, 1984, l
conniuting of 7 pagon.
(Proviouuly identified as Exhibit tio. 6 to the Doposition of Mr. Newton) 17.
Memorandum dated May 19, 1983, f rom II.D. Ilukill to Filo, cubject:
Interview with D.D. Mayhow.
(Proviously iduntified an Exhibit i;o. 4 to the Deposition of Mr.
l Ilu k ill) i 18.
liomorandum dated Juno 14, 1984, from D.J. Pink to T.U.
i;orman, Subjects Lump Sum Payment Payroll Chuck for David b. Mayhuw, Emp. I:o. 6422.
(Proviounty iduntiflod au the first page of Exhibit t;o. 5 to the Doposition of i r. Ilukill) 19.
Memorandum dated August 3, 1982, from D.I). Mayhow to I
II. D. Ilukill,
Subject:
Two Wook Cuuponnion Without Pay.
[
(Provioucly identiflod au the fifth page of Exhibit tio.
5 to the toposition of f:r. liukill)
[
t 20.
linmorandum dated August 3, 1982, f rom II.D. liukill to D.li.1:ayhow, Gub ject:
Two Wook Hucponolon Without Pay.
i (Provluunty idontified an the oixth through oighth pagon of Exhibit tio. 5 to the not.onition of Mr. Ilukill) 21.
Wr itton Examination Cu rtif ication Cover Choot dated Jan.
14, 1983, for John J. M 1ub.
(Proviounty idontifiod an tho firnt page of I:xhibit i;o. 3 to tho cuponition of Mr.
l lion u) f i
4 t
+--
, i 22.
Written Examination Certification Cover Sheet dated May 3, 1983, for John J.
Wa lsh.
(Previously identified as the second page of Exhibit No. 3 to the Deposition of Mr. Ross) 23.
Written Examination Certification Cover Sheet dated 3/8/84, for John J.
Wa lsh.
(Previously identified as the third page of Exhibit No. 3 to the Deposition of Mr.
Ross) j 24.
Written Examination Certification Cover Sheet dated j
1-14-83, for Jay E. Moore, J r.
(Previously identified as the first page of Exhibit No. 4 to the Deposition of
~
Mr. Ross)
I 25.
Written Examination Certification Cover Sheet dated j
2/2/83, for Jay E. Moore, Jr.
(Previously identified as the second page of Exhibit No. 4 to the Deposition of l
Mr. Ross) k 26.
Written Examination Certification Cover Sheet dated 2-11-83, for Jay E. Moore, Jr.
(Previously identified as the third page of Exhibit No. 4 to the Deposition of J
Mr. Ross) 1 27.
Written Examination Certification Cover Sheet dated j
1/25/82, f or II. K. Olive, II.
(Previously identified as the first page of Exhibit No. 5 to the Deposition of Mr.
Ross) i
)
28.
Oral Examination Cover Page dated 3-14-84, f o r !!. K.
olive.
(Provioucly identified as the accond page of Exhibit No. 5 to the Deposition of Mr. Ross) 29.
Oral Examination Evaluation cheets for D.
E.
Smith for tiarch 19, 1984, conciating of 12 pages.
(Previously identified an Exhibit 3 to the Deposition of Mr.
Leonard) 30.
Oral examination sheets for Jay Mcore, dated 3-26-84, conointing of 12 pages.
(Previously identified as Exhibit 1 to the Deposition of Mr. Rons) i 31.
The RO-1 Annwer Key, GPU Document Id. 0639D, created l
02/22/84.
I 32.
The SRO-3 Annwer Key, GPU Document Id. 0644D, c rea ted 2
02/22/84.
33.
Mr. Kelly'n handwr itten noten, conciating of 7 pagen.
(Previounty identified an Exhibit 1 to the topocition of Mr. Kelly) l 4
6
s
.., 2.
Licensee will not object to the admission into evidence of that portion of the November 7,1984, Deposition of Mr. Hukill starting on page 16, line 25, and ending on page 30, line 14.
Licensee agrees that if called as a witness, Mr. Hukill would so testify.
3.
Licensee agrees that it will not object to cross-examination of Mr. Ross as being outside the scope of direct to the extent that the-cross-examination addresses one of the following issues:
(a) oral examinations, (b) decisions concerning whether and under what conditions licensed operator training program participants may remain in the program, (c) evaluation of performance on the simulator, (d) selection of candidates to participate in the licensed operator training program.
4.
Licensee agrees that it will not object to cross-examination of Mr. I:ewton as being outside the scope of direct to the extent that the cross-examination addresses the issue of decisions concerning whether and under what conditions licensed operator training program participants may remain in the program.
For Licensee:
For UCS:
- 14. '.
Deborah u. bauser William 8. Jordan, III Date:
Date
. 7, December 26, 1984-__r!!
w '. '., f L awns UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION.- E.2 27 A10 :03 BEFORETHEATOMICSAFETYANDLICENS~IhG-BONRDh'/[/,,
8AACh
)
In the Matter of
)
)
METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY
)
Docket No. 50-289 SP
)
(Restart - Management Phase)
(Three Mile Island Nuclear
)
Station, Unit No. 1)
)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that the accompanying Motion to Change Lead Intervenor Status and Stipulation on Training Evidence were served upon the Board and the active parties in this_ proceeding during the hearing on December 19, 1984.
The parties on whom these documents were served appear on the accompanying Service List without asterisks.
I have today, December 26, 1984, served the asterisked parties on that list by first class mail.
III
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY
)
Docket No. 50-289
)
(Restart Remand on (Three Mile Island Nuclear
)
Management)
Station, Unit No. 1)
)
)
SERVICE LIST Administrative Judge Gary J.
Edles, Chairman Jack R.
Goldberg, Esq.
Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal Bd.
Office of the Executive Legal Dir.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commiss'on Wcshington, D.C.
20555 Washington, D.C.
20555 Administrative Judge John H.
Buck Deborah Bauser, Esquire Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal Bd.
Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1800 M Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20555 washington, D.C.
20036 Administrative Judge Christine N. Kohl Ms. Louise Bradford Atomic Saf ety & Licensing Appeal Bd.
TMI Alert U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1011 Green Street Wasnington, D.C.
20555 Harrisburg, PA 17102 Administrative Judge Ivcn W.
Smith, Chairman Joanne Doroshaw, Esquire Atomic Safety. Licensing Board The Christic Institute U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1324 North Capitol Street Washington, D.C.
20555 Washington, D.C.
20002 Administrative Judge Sheldon J. Wolfe Mr. and Mrs. Norman Aamodt Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal Bd.
R.D.
5 U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Coatesville, PA 19320 Wcshington, D.C.
20555 Administrative Judge Lynne Bernabei, Esq.
Gustave A.
Linenberger, Jr.
Government Accountability Project Atomic Safety & Licensing Board 1555 Connecticut Ave.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20009 Wcshington, D.C.
20555 Michael F.
McBride, Esq.
Docketing and Service Section Office of the Secretary LeBoeuf, Lamb, Leiby & MacRae U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1333 New Hampsnire Ave, N.W.
- 1100 Washington, D.C.
20555 washington, D.C.
20036
. Michael W. - Maupin, Esq..
- _Hunton & Willisms 707 Ecst Main Street P.O.
Box 1535' Richmond, VA 23212 Thomas Y. Au, Esq.
Office of Chief Counsel Department of Environmental Resources 505 Executive Houses P.O.
Box 2357
. Harrisburg, PA 17120
!h'.
'O G
e O9 e
9 0
t a
- 4 l
i
{
1 t
~ ~ _._ - _ _ -- --_,,_.-- - _ _ -.