Text

Intervenor Exhibit I-MOSBA-256,consisting of Ltrs Re a Mosbaugh Concern Conversation W/Listed Individuals
	ML20100B736
Person / Time
Site:	Vogtle
Issue date:	09/15/1995
From:	; AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:	;
References
	OLA-3-I-MOS-256, NUDOCS 9601220277
	Download: ML20100B736 (26)
	v • d • e

NUCLEAR (EGULATORY COMMISSION

~Mb

[f - [b&

DocketNo. 5N24/425-OLA,f _

EXHIBITNO. I* T

~*

h-

[

In to rnatter of Georola Fw Co. et H., Voctie UnHs 1 & 2 htaff O Apfrdic Mnte:venor O Other d

identified g Received O Rejected Reporter.fD r-L' R

/,c 14 r witneee goc egeco 3

oamo a L

cf3 0^1 20 P 4 :41 I

0FFICL Di SECNI/l$

g seaem gCCKET!NG /.

J ' d'-

a BRANCH

.l O

W z

I gi;i 4,:

m Co s-G

-CW l

K MC a.>2 l

M l

l I

f t

m i.

q

....,3 i

f 9601220277 950915 a

PDR ADOCK 05000424 0

PDR i

e D

i D

b J *_

.a_.m.3 A.

_s

._s

.J

.m-6a...

a

-4 a

4 4

4 6lI9f90 auw www yAn. el4 R s~yd-v6

)R aL u-w 17 a

a y 4 n:s a

p s g wq~s/e,

.- w w

u g$'-c JM M A fM 24 y l

n 2

n J 4}"li;&;i y j

=.. _..

. = -

l i

I

.e

_w.e.

i

---n s

n A

e4 41 4

-e b

I l..

h 6

chu%

GOL_Q4s!Adl&zdq 4

& t et, y

, s 4 p s g w - _ ;

s sa,<

~,:6 p -

~>Ad hm

'26 A4

- E

.3 d L t. f M A g ;).w A A Q

_dL

(.m Adg y k ) w M % W -

r, n

_ e y w al u s t-1 A fn k ) a., l, / b Y 2 A *i

& V f &gs Li-.iw A,*

--,a s;a

~ od,4,L J M i ?

v'7 7 /b ' Ad4,, '.

a R / L r:

/

i

,ce

-g,- 4/ h u j g_z/

o*& A< L h g az 4 y m _ # py a s -c w a.. _ u 4 s a a d

wqs % dW n

J MlA AaJympMM ~7 4 c

A;.aLau

$z&JA./K1LLLL Ml~

A o

A, M L J &g w,,ii u s

IL e9,1 z

.A K & s i ~ J ~ or.

9 6

_u

.a

...,a a-a.-

i W

r A

%W' J,1p /~/

esA.

e g

W4 4-p _ w p +," " w p " ' _ --

M W ^ r?

_AM A__'

N M ~ s#

m w

vw l

- '?

3h An Od d u_

l&

% A M -tid' A

% % d#

AE,M (d w sA &

I ym *~ s a a w g& M K Afd as 9~ 3t s s, _ y y A my -

Efv

. _I L

s

=

I i

W T

e 0

..~-..

.nn.

n..

f

- ~ -.. ~

._ agra- ---

N'

-<en e

-m e

- - ammisale==.

======4+%.

O

- -.. r&_v' J hat'M u

al'.

~

-svat-a Aray mA mea sqAq~an 94

/ n ~_ a 7

a &M J'7. '. A-

~

N us

~

L SfC, d'

W4 eeis t s

% e p, h9wu****

,w m%

MNN

, sus..

96 e>+

- W&9M&M _

==a

4

-e.L--_

u A

a-J 4

4

=.

T-h e

t-7-4 N%

g%uw f CFMd74;drj x3H3 gel 4

24 u-vwdui f f -6CJ dj A( wi a w y +4 L d A A un y

& a n a ~ - p& ' z rd 4

A M.

V d d -o q

uw"'

A,, 2 2 J

& < M s' m

n D $1 V - <-

A

.w/d A m a>M wdd' M -4 v -

nr.a A Lt A a.atA.

a s(ud WJ,Ma usa ot q /e a<wl We a%f su4

- w s g *y a

- a w a ~ &w s r

c43 &w a~l.At J nM a f4 wu4J4 Ja a J,

--w A y & ~6 /e udd fwkad".

m m es

~ ~y'fa u ma as.p a wau e

sa Az J A n m6 & y,yS m aam Isid f 4 m e6 A ~6A&p c d a a ~ / m ^t

u/2 wea uLE /

b AJM u f

y m

c -

Lma

}9 ka 4 h 6 J.w w 4

&B A f A L a~f u <.

& s u m < a( 4 v ' & a ~ s u p a N f Aa a

uuA 2t f -4 w.as

4

--k

_-s3

--A 4

m-a 4,,

=M' s.-

s e

.i-s>-A e-,-a-4

.Aw2--e

.m a4e a

p+

a u

a-e b

O

~

As f 3 -06 s x/ -s 6scu A A.12 06ut J 4 9 %&by p' y

<~pd a

y A

u n ac a p wu o

s m w-a a,w su p.sau-a aapa sa m;4Q4 &vJ-rA ku l

h A.

A y

-4

-6 &

a a, M

,fu

q. 4% ue, asme a, m J,s a dky A~l A k MJ A cetV l

a x c s, a a rs a

/f f

8A M b

W&

a n@ @y M

f i

- zs au pa u w

- +9 mp e s.

asyn a

~

~t4aa 4.p&.

g4

-4 A m.

s A

c. _

a w~

M -4 ce.

a m.=-

J.

A 4

__mAA-4

__a t.__4 w+,

4 4

bW Y i

cmJ2 A aun/ (.hu w96 m MJ ntq% % & n cud

@< a. f 9

a ama>

~

M

'sA u s. as M.

c9s e

- % j'-46 p ~

pt d Gula m.

M MzKJ' Of % W

~

~ a pu ax, tdo'.4 g h.

s~s x

.~a w

a m:

-w w zw &e J

?

- 17 asa # G.A' 4 M e ?

4 ya a n=6 M d~Z 14, g at a ?

-y n=6 A adh m M ?

d 4 -66 m.Awa Q A w y & ~4%. y c~.~-t~~4.

a s p m - nee - p A,&.

A.

~ ftu A+

MM a~/ M9 m edtd,'r

~,,

.~

. ~, = _

. ~.,

_=

^

~

l

-~

l

-f a2e6L.6-eu 9-a, w y a

~ p 1 4 = z,;c -a 1

-c u g h

% p -6 4

% 4 w " + k e

-,~ t& e w r/' % g 4-a an o w

6 L.4 %. Q M,a %Ap&&.

Wd a y szs p* m,Wa' n- &

J TC r~a de~4 4h

~g p s u m 6.

S k i. J &

Am J

ww.

94 & ~ y

,s zz r 1

A/AJm2didI m

u w a b la M a a

x

@9,,p.sy s p.,% u.

W W -4 4 a

y aa, 6 a

A g.A _aq 7

wa s n y-(4tL % L,c#a A 4, Abhu, uM )

Gk k wu deuud d W f I?

I g-5N A

M de M f M

n 16 L (Ak & w A m14) r M a. -d -66 L uef M p. (5 M zri &,H /~<1 %

L A

s ' A -#a dau4 y 4

cL m

a f w-G aa a

,a n LaMJ' p,?

1Su a M k n

@ 416 L 4 A

M M A % 46 Wac i

aa

. G. <. w e. d r.;/ z % -Ace e x es a n

& nc, l

J L <x AA g C s r <e.)

&n A p es a

o6 -s e c

a. p zs -

Ag

("/p 7 ) m o44uf aA

.n 4

A JJ A,M_ JJ Iukkl 24 Id Q.O

%d v " 4,( w A iy' -66 14

b+

an M n.at/

JD 7

a~

g m ak p

- cun ph k a M.q Lzaa A zzr dJ.a Mg 6

L -b6 y dJ,.6d we a an2/

A-W

-6LL6Adv6ny%g A

M 6

pu fm Axa&

as n aid A, zu ac.

si a

~Oh O ?

ea-xceJaMia a A.

A a a ~s - A n ' ] Li E ~f idad w~a M-w-

4 h a n-~af.

cG6 y - # pn.,-

achda'6 24 & A m

- w w'gss

?

a

' ll f -6 6 n d.

Mm da.a.a a

suA Jsd

-%~n AJ f L 'L

, n,

ac4 J p d.

an e

d asa 6d' a m-uul Ze4.$c9uA n7'A

&y & % w -

d

, m-IRA' w&

p k

' A / d a p-4 e h k l n -

i l y wib( ~bQ G A.

4-e-

w#--

++Mt

'-L

~*---*4-'4L-

-de--- * ---4-h14e-aa4-4 4

4th-&s--h.e4 4a 4_..m._,Jwsam.e eAm,_

.2__-_sm 4

_4 F

d

N w.h6 t

e 4

/

{

WM n

.ed.s}

wrde a aa.d'= 7

^%

da m a LMA x%Am l

b6 -nec. us,J ! ' M a und' & g od a

al' W

< i n.8ee J. A ale 2de AJ A M Y4n A

v i

l efu/

A dc Rt.-4us w h p % 14 A

s:e c n a s.,

d5M A/AC Aduad}ed -~aad d/

/n 4 A~

ll f%

m l

a& ' 'gA A%

-sc

~u m as e, a a-aul en y M ldlw d'i% f A L

' l Y dEu YI &fccasuh W Su mLc4 y Q nu f-GwMjJ

~p ym * <- ~D, M-Q~

y, y-;4 PAA 6 A '

0 $ nar c h -cle w l 1lt /#AA ide 3 nu m A a fd +c & ' T w. A %

/

j

m.4 A

.L i

e-Ad.4J

%f e'.1#

s A-A m4J Jm 4

44

..,34am4-+-

4-6->Ja.

4m t.AB-4 1Aa'-

-E A.

AC

-- 4

=

a 4

i 5

l i

bd I

4

.,tf M

'24V

/

M_

A

.m.W4u,

9A ww /-6Mne l

4nbMhsg-qu&l i2 A Af ~z4.4LA A

%.MAQ'/dAAl-.

u&

' cAu L

w.

r4<9

[

. d w ss....-AmAw 4

^ ' -

W I4 V

l a

k Ai.vna % p.m.

i Ada wrad'A Q.

l A sk A 6 M' n.AmA m y p

/g du(mvMAy+.. _

h a-61k ~~.

s 6 - u 2: 2% m e n

f ps f MALL g g)se%

(.

c}a~&'/A:A-Q2 a~/s yad 6. ~Jd A.hm 6s;4) 4...

an nw ns ai A s-- A c4 ~3.f 0%.~~ G4 e>sse q+v as) 66 mu -

' 4<-ses a m m-&el &.un,m' W.&A. Afa e, A e aea p u a m isua LM 9%AA fu a fnnJa./d p

D-atvG a:n ts919y.

a +4 7

ak,vu % q u y n ~w Me

h

?!

d

sa -md quw'a-ag g,g,

f4hc CcEm 9

& 75 4-M' & ga d /d 4~0 ddm hzf#m26 f4 g' 4.

r M

l

a-,w

-W--

W s

2 h

_.-A-4 a.s_..._.

m.

u 4

a--4

-a 1a.

l f

9

. p x-j a = =y csgua

- c 2 d/hzdw.

--a.n-3 m y/s n y u s s e_-

2 AQ JW Mxd f/,I nA 16 dL h p..

suAWaf 6 rad

& GW p. On &dk m

&L 5'k % asbd/2% y &&ky h ~Sm.$da $p.

2/Mu, led

" m dC/l' W/' pus. 1kW sNf-._.

1

,A s

,%46,d l' " m rdL64_n

-se.um d*

Wed -

-. X ad/c Gd.4

-n A n ss A Ley',

4 2

.sswa. m y A

,f df e

w a 4 a,r.

I c d W u m.u % & J y a,;

n M FAa4 m d

(Kh;;W

&Mde$$A L e

-f

% Act n+ - yp & ~ m,n p

& pd m 1

A ~ l L Lu, y y

- msLwd m"n aak

% ay,m a w ydm w

1 a swcr. Ca W & c'N d ' &

. sus w/u nb un db A~/d& 1 dm /f 3l M :a 4 ~ J,a, a a Cu2L A e p i J da' Ac n w ~

-m.-

a u

a4 i

,u_.masa1.

w a.2 An,,,. _,.-

,4w g.

ya s.

a,,

y_,sy ane_s u,a xs.-

?

j e

%st e i

< < wasesu a g _

R kr j~.us' m.G cuJo n g' 4% ~

m f i f A J d y) n u 4 d d s.

aJpp (#

cbrR w ga/.

ad f 4tsc J.

sk a3 m%,nenn y

de

~:vra er w

/s-mH ct,nz

',?s2Adn. W/r 2%

p '%

? a n w ~'

Q~

m, 4fL W aa

~

n k.

AJLa &

9M 4 fa m. MW -r $r a ff t

d & th a

% & g(y 2 4 L 6d

$y n

6 4

y uu aa xe 4

o-m

u a

aw u4As--.._m Jm%

J..., _-

ag

-- i._

4m#%A A

.m A._Am1 4a__.A.

s-an6....4 a

_a4 a.

p.4 O

4 l

wM wa/75 i

dn L &

i sw,c r,

ne an of S M

s CW

~

cJ u a

1, 4 a as w)m>4s/.wa5' & L

+70 Jr.i 6st 1

<J M L wi4( /__u, eoAo4ro i

d(J

' W6 n /ef &

aua0uD Qa6JaD-ald s & & c & d) & &a & 4d'f e%AR au646 adam;sdsf s

dd uhus A det) a

/

c'!/

&s i

b 6/who c

e 1

1 1

a 4

4 a

..*.=,. u 4

s-e wa e

h of "& h *

,,-v uqv a W ^

.b A"WAA T49 S %

f rLi

n. 4 J.Xa JJ AL

} = p)-

"&M HA Ag s u us Li u alm m,,1auar$ Me $s &a= :, - m 4 4 we') A z6 A n

f & !~.a, 4 4/A % % 4.lg W

v.nt 9 M

W

%gm Mu = w. Q

^l

..ps

~

i j

w=

s.eoer

\\s 4

4

... ~

.a p

,-A43.a 2

.m e-mm

.mm h

e 1

t L

eau n w J yu

~,i x

+

ax

~;MTNI_DY0 1

- a.p w Luu.uay am 4

am

eu. w px dyY90 DATE:

i
~
i
- TELECOPY TO:
EA/
cbV
/
i TELECOPY NUMBER: AREA CODE (2(A1
(? 77 - 7Mf~~ '
TELECOPY. VERIFICATION NUMBER: AREA CODE (
) R 8-2./ ~7/r>4 i
4 l
TYPE OF TELECOPY MACHINE:
NUMBER OF PAGES ATTACHED:_
3 i
j THE SENDER IS:
betz $rrm/
l SENDER's FAC NO.
2-f26-fd/4P/7 l
LOCATION OF SENDER:
T-d/71T Aw r4
~
TELEPHONE NUMBER OF SENDER:
P CP/, -/VK' t
i COMMENTS:
Oa,nos~d A I
.l 5
t L
d i
, e i
g.
I July 6, 1990 I
PLANT VOGTLE TECHNICAL / MANAGERIAL / REGULATORY CONCERNS I.
FAVA MICROFILTRATION UNIT A.
System was purchased, installed and placed into operation in a
process which bypassed all applicable commitments / requirements.
B.
System is located in a building which has had an inadequate safety analysis with regard to containing a potential spill.
C.
Combination of
'A' and
'B' above results in an installation with inferior (regulatorially excluded) materials (i.e.
PVC) in operation in a building with questionable capacity for containing spills.
Of particular concern is a line rupture which could spray against building walls.
D.
Plant management, the PRB and General Manager in particular, have responded in a non-conservative manner by allowing the continued operation of the system.
Specific issues involve a
PRB vote when the main dissenting member could not
attend, excessive GM participation in PRB actions leading to intimidation of members, unreviewed safety questions being identified and not being adequately addressed prior to votes to operate.
II.
DIESEL AIR QUALITY A.
Due to operation with unknown and potentially high dew points, it is unknown as to whether the diesel xnerator air systems have experienced condensation a..d,
as a result, therefore have corrosion products (particulate) in the lines which may jeopardize reliable operation.
B.
In response to a generic NRC letter dealing with diesel air quality, the plant submitted a
response which included a statement that we operated with a dew point of 50 degrees F or less even though we have measured values in excess of this number.
This took place about one year ago.
C
. u.
ej up s,,,
i wi i
- ~ -. -
t s
?
00Ni0i m i
i VOGTLE ISSUES Page 2
~j i
III. CAL-CON SWITCHES A.
The manufacturer issued a 'Part 21' on these switches and.
j the plant failed to take timely action.
j B.
Plant may still not have made an appropriate -response on reportabilities.
An LER is involved.
I IV.
DIESEL GENERATOR LER A.
The number of successful starts for the diesel generators i
included in an LER was not correct.
Plant and corporate management took too long to correct this problem.
i B.
Logs of these starts are not easily understood and there is a lack of knowledge on procedural requirements in this area.
V.
PRB/ MANAGEMENT - GENERAL f
A.
The PRB does not act in a consistently conservative-manner in areas of safety and reportability.
Examples l
given were two issues on missed surveillances where the PRB found them to not be reportable and the NRC ultimately issued violations.
Resolution of dissenting votes by PRB members is not pursued as far as it should j
be in certain instances.
B.
When individuals and/or the PRB errs in judgement, the 1
corrective action taken to preclude further occurrences j
is not clear or decisive.
i l
C@Wi
[
PRD M
WP 4Wi i
me n.
dip iI g
i
i s
.e a
.A 4
. ~+
0 6
.,xe a s p an m &
(s. c/d/ A di m-dk tLapd6. >f J, of 1%a.
c W 'L w J2 le cL.
u.
bR aw M/GM ct9' di At aJ.Aw> M '.-
ttc' &ftcLA c(seki ura A &d'
~a. AL wa 6
_2 w /w
~
awl-b6 SAR
& cal J.Q A rd
-(&
A cat' x 2a, su sua 7
~~cy n oe a~t & aL A
~
nia m,>u L 4 -t4 w y 1k adL(
v4 iLu'(s Azs 4~;
y V<JJ & A Ana~- dd24 afL
(a Cu L C n
.d4 ve %w
&4 n/
a Tr L 6
d / vi M
4
, = &' sw' ~'t A 'w'$b s 4J au s.
s,_mu
- A,y /. 4 D a & 7 r g ' A
.~
~ rA sa As p 6L 9x d ik LJ ni+J M t & d z4 r.
M dy' m
,dlL - y. M aC/ a 7:
u d t4 L
a's ud 4+
u. ~C6 h.t alvea i
to lM,
i bM sb e.-d Y sM #6 u21~ (3~
no
i 4
1 N
N MI J
g.
l4
. A uf.~a:L n
m
.+
aa 4
ma A ~p/&&s~,42 D*J~/
6 M
(s
<M n.e d'
ae
%dga A -V mu i
u h
s,
,~ +,
ww
+
M=
e F
-= aan.e. =
eien..
b w -
e i
.l 4
,1
+
?
4 e-
+.--.----~m.- - - -
..+wa a
u
+
1
/
W h
n a s saa y
4 W c'uk ewaa%,X k
PLe' S J %
be E
s w i.. 6 c~dw ri J vu 7
4-maa di Aed ed A
e.n b l m -dt. w u /
d, lA u, a,c 4 a mu& %
.:.=
aqL & M,wap,26 sec 4 2: m--.
cal ym A-J L G d a D d'
np' 'Q, pgG ~LA Q-# 2% a u
a,y
%,at J a %f n as uuu a u.
L M
&,6 4
a.
cuit ' QMM O/ ch' ~ kJr/a %
owu.
c~/A a' * 'F mL-k J&
4 J LAu. A As add' M y 44 D as
. xL yaA
.41 -,J /u J 4,
%f 9:G wJ ~+
cdid 3
s a s f y y a -, sgp / - f +. 4 r o s'41 y
ab a-aw
~2d by y'4 M Jq p L ~et rs s a q a 4 qu a
fwq 4'h]an'pa a
pp a-AJ u n n 1) a v a saw i
wil.
n d a.

- o s --------

ML20100B736

Text

Navigation menu

Search