ML20099G206

Applicant Exhibit A-54,consisting of Finding Repts Dtd 761029,1130 & 770505,identifying Item of Noncompliance Re Two Welds from Beam to Clip on Beams 232B7 & 23239

ML20099G206
Person / Time
Site:	Limerick
Issue date:	05/07/1984
From:	Both A BECHTEL GROUP, INC.
To:
References
OL-A-054, OL-A-54, NUDOCS 8411270159
Download: ML20099G206 (4)

Text

- - _ - ._

5

• A  %

.\ . .. 3p.-- nev's.sns

. . Ygp; 7 sx m .,a

^

FTNDING RA.ODTf -

m-)

Linerick Units 1 5 2 V f.-  % .

TYPr: O -nit O unvsittaaer G Ird< NaC

. ,'r.

• 1. ,,,,,.,

. A ati;r assuaan=c, [ N:a Q::nnscTiveacticsat:o. ,'

Sechtel Power Cc p.

M I:e= of N ncenpliance riime ::=tiasta C.K. Seceet - P cj ect Manager 4 arrtzrxers

., s. ISSUED TD Bech:e1 P wer Corpora: ion *) 1{,.1'71 *"d 7 3 74 r.0RGANIZATION i.THOSE CCHTACTED T. Alten - K. Bishop gG 1(1976 U p, A,;tcy.: 0T i.io en : arrrunix : :mifraia ,

~

te. FINDING test zu: arnats:: 2::sti:xit surris is arasan) ,

Two welds from the beam to the clip on beams 23257 and 23239 in uni: 2 on Eley. 257 were both incenplete and unaccep able and were =ade with the aid'

of a broom stick handle attached to the s:Inge "to res.ch the joint to be 3 .'

. welded; which is contrary to AWS section.3.1.2. ,- ,

Further, inspection surveillance records' indicated that thes'e, beas ~

I connections were inspecte.d.- .

N gt .

a

. / /%-

. i

& ' t+

p.

ncC: O S. -

namn

. .e g - - (N-U p 4

. tocr 'en b

- Q55A%@iscgy

- . ,x p tt. DISCUSSION p:r Ann arrrarx: Acnitionat carris is agains) W 3echtel issued NCR No.1950 identifying the non-conforming condition.

t:. RECOMMENDATION cu s aus arnarset x=iti:xu. surtTs as at::ina) . ,

. 3411270159 840507

• PDR ADOCK 05000352 PM g . .

et as agitate: cast scrxfirin A. Both Inspector 10/27/76 3.N . 033  ::: ...

, .206

..__ ~ ,,:, g ::

T:TLE Caft 7 't nalst I.. v se sus entics

DrNT Firs .

utur Tift: 3Afr A 7011e7 - N _m . L P.L. Scuk --

is:urs n / @ Fwm _ Site QAE 10/29/76 I'L3 *623

/ waur t i tt. t nts ete.1

/ _-m

a.4

. .. . 44 .

,, .

• y. k-?r.10 ' 8 ty':. 5/75 Ej"' k 9 sut:T 2 er

-(, , .

2

, 3, , , , , , ,

N-093

/m (m - .

FINDING' REPORT k'E9?=Derick uni:s I s 2 V ':f~

. DEC 10 h-_/c cm "'""

auun un...n ii. 50RRECTIVE ACil0N TAKEN TO Ti 101.VE FINDING {$l't" ' "u', l ' ",n;, , , ,, , n ,3

1. Issuance of NCR 1950 to ach.owledge the nonconfoming c:rlditicu and to aco,uire dispositioning to correct sa=e. -

2. A Reinspection of all other work perfo=ed by the'particular inspector who accepted the welds in cuestien was ace::plished wherever accessible. , .

le f/ffff/ Ti m W rY W /9fD *//ff7l70*

2.}ks Y <,$/4% 4 /& **

%TC*f% b,.m "

f st.co n0wo ' ?- ,

ACT!BN TAttN If I *% ACitCM YEllrit" lA/ '

R&st _saft ,

unut - gatt .

v .

. is. CURRECTIVE ACTION TAKEN TO PREVENT RECURRENCE C'""'""""**

asstrismat sattis sa stester:3 .

A training class was held 10-25-76 for' re-indoc :ination and '

. re-orientation in the various aspects of accep:arce of cenpleted work,

• l reviewing or inspection criteria and ulti ate responsibilities .

for weld inspections with all personnel in attendancs from both the QC and field welding groups.

pcm Dier:nk -tm z sr .p&&W M "

6xm.mu ms+s .

/

action ruta.it b // 77 c A tinx vinir:Enj W/ #N m

/?

.... s... ...t ..t.

i

~

tr. P.E. AC0EPTANCE OF CORRECTIVE ACTION -

i ~

W

• D itsstvts rimar= .

U C:!PTA8LE (Sit SMEET 2 or 3). ,

l m

/. stf/ T3 tt g4 satt- -

L! ffvPStaat gst CMTfL st3CL3710N (/ / -- -

tar.4 s t v. s

s. 2 s8 2-

.nyes.tns ,h)lr,' g e9er: 1.e

. .r .

.. .  : . ausses ??-00 *4

- .' '. f rt., a -

tr I ~4 w7ktn '3 yL

= *- c :UqT-

• 2 T4..O t. . t TJ.. t. ... I &.)

"Il *.*:*. .h.

v~ SI .. d.y % i t.-

gr 8: 4'i*T L sg gas.ct

~'

i.'i!J'(nl';W-fkno.

. P..;,,.SCH U!i-w r t i,.,.t . tv-r == icerei.:r in:: ve is :=sts: a er:vrac:r - s.:. . :r.r -r .

g

.s a

Jjl.o/.7 ,. I *< ! .\

. .. s n. .

ti .

8..:e KRO fi=di n-the.t-generated 4.h!.s N0?., :.as-rep 1.ie4 so.a=f. Sea-MECEiVED L .

. M- . ' -

1.

reference to further c~--"--ts by 3echtal ?oua: CoF:r.1:k:s - -

lGj..'. r .

,.*..?"'-

' . ' ' . , ~ - ..

2. 'c~ is E"E sh::1d reflect th:se f :ther co 't=ents refefe=,ie. d 1..h.e.<p*:qv..e - f. -. u..:u., .

.h'<n N0' de'.doewr:nY :r/ esiric/;/.: mf):// * &2 7it:-

'N "'O M '~4an: M a e of y ai/ e,de.a.,L.:. .

O A* ic% 4Whf .ud.

. .ppii-dW Jy A - -

4f d we /ef .r,;,,,,,,.e, ,

a .

Q'. .

nMha s . y- w - + +

. . a:.a n v.s. z ,- / v.1,. ? sis (I

v, '. .. .. . .

san .

st . uit .

i

(. .

se:::::= n :=cris as scentato -

7 si. REYlSED CO?.3ECTIVE ACil0N test A.: iirest' .

~ .. . . . - .- - . . ,

-[.*,' .

?Ci'.-246 Aared 12-17-76 s:ates that a=y veld thati requires the use oFveld .

~

. ' ' .ex:eni. ion hb1de'rs vill be identified ani! approved by. the I.ead Staff Field . ,

. Weld'i=g F. ginder prior to c:sa.

T..is' require =s-: is being incorporated is' the lates: revision of Job Es1e -

.. .G-16 "". eld?nz" . . . .

. i.

~ . . -

' ~

. ,a""'* . ,

/

/ }.- #/NI acts:n statu i. M f[# !-)-) acticx tra.

• • 't n., J.R.Raine'y .(.d r. pt sa.

.. . . . * : t i .r '"'

l a* : 7 C 6. -:- - w l a,."i p>

\-

((. ,  :: P . r.. .'*.tr

• - . .* . . :'. O T . V i

, 3 res m rs c:s:im: ,

,o

- _ , .g/p ,8- ,

~

O r .mriaru .:r atrat te urt: 3 - er si c g n /- J .c:.92. s

. .. . - - . . . . <<. s s ,s,.B.7,:.s..

S .2.~2.%.:rca,+---

=n --

-7 ""2.

.. .. 7,- __ _ _ _ . , , . _ _ , _ _

- - - .~.- ._..2._ _ _ , , _.