ML20099C919
| ML20099C919 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Clinton  |
| Issue date: | 11/14/1984 |
| From: | Victor H ILLINOIS POWER CO. |
| To: | Parkinson G BECHTEL GROUP, INC. |
| References | |
| F-0966, F-966, NUDOCS 8411200116 | |
| Download: ML20099C919 (6) | |
Text
7= _ _
j
. j FW96 L.
L40-84 (11-14)-L' -
l
~
-8G.150b~
~
-lLLIN0iB POWER COMPANY Mm3 l d <" ] - custos ROWER STATION P,o. BOX 478. CUNTON, IWNots of M7 V
- t-November 14, 1984-N h
~
i:
L; f
Mr.~ Cordon L. Parkinson Bechtel Power Corporation Fifty Beale Street San Francisco, CA '94119 Dear Mr. Parkinsons Enclosed is S&L's response to Observation Report Number 17. Rev. O.
This response has been reviewed by Illinois Power.
Sincerely yours.
'/}
f H. R. Victor
- Manager, Nuclear. Station Engineering DW/Im 4
cc: See Attached Distribution List 5
9 n
4 i
h J
\\
F *A'e:mial
~
FDR
p.-l
' ' 2 qqf 7, W--
., ' pf" j.'. f 7
'[{:;
',;N.
- y' -
-j
=a
- l.
My bit Q i.4
}
,g f
. A G"[l; s
m u, q;g v L; ~
-;/ j U"
% :M a
'4 x
'4l
- t :f
- _of g,
)jy
+ '
}
,a,y b
.th
, y,,
~
c
- wm
.t
)R y up, '..
trg y n
L n
~
s x
pg b
a san om s 3imint; L
7 3^
( -1~ ;4 1
'5 2 3 02M E M31.5 n g
- v u.?. -' ~2 Nl
m n'
k,
' q; p % e m
- r.
m '.
m gf i
] ? *pa" "a"*
~
?~
~ M 3,w..
m fe[C.' Mt.04'84 '
J sts.see.? pee ' '
.g t'.issh 40.*800e$
i o
'4 e
,' d e 1 ase.seate '
t a
- -' j QLtwa-9.o.ae..seet1 3 J v y.,,
y Y
~..
'Y I
.. ~ ~
~
T Date al ; November 2 F 19_84;.. <
Q
.g 4-3 7
LProject>No.;4536-51, -531
~ "
,G
- b >
.L; 1
- c. y,,f i
,~
SIllinois; Power Companyi 9' a a; e
~
Clinton PoweristationJ-Unit'11
~
U
.J.
= Independent'DesigniReviewf
~
~
?
Observation:and>HesolutioniReports' M6 y
m 4;
j x.'. ' p i,
r Mr. J.9D.~Geier N
' Assistant to Vice President?
N
- Illinois Power company.
500 South 27th StreetE Decatur,-Illinofs.62525..
0
^
a
Dear Mr. Celer:
Enclosed-is a copy cf the below; listed Resolution Roports with' thos
^
?a proposed resolutionf(Itemd'5Jand=6) completodlby Sargent &!;Lundys m
Resolution.noport Nuah r 17, Revision 00 We are also enclosing'a copy of the corresponding Observation Reports
-for completonoss.
Please review our proposed rosolution and, if you~ concur, sign Item 17.
of.. tho Rosolution' Report and forward the report to the independente reviewer.
Also, pleaso return a copy of the signed Resolution ~ Roport to Sargent & Lundy for our records.
-i
.Yours very truly,-
x.m. v %q.
y -.
R. C. Heider Project Manager
.- RCH:nd.
Attachment - all recipients D. P. Itall.
E. B. Branch d.;R. Victor B. A. Erler
- r. A. sonnoonboro foriainals)
W. G. Schwarts L. E. Ackmann/W. A. Chittendon L. R. Stonsland
~W.
G. liegener H.
S.' Taylor E.'V..Abrahan R. A. Witt R. X.iFrench R. B. Johnson
" iJ. !!.. McLaughlin
'M. J. Showski
- H. M. Sroka D. K. Schopfer 1
fy f a
~
ap
= -
L a z.g.
.x
/
p%pM S:S
~ CLINTON. POWER: STATION.-
f,.
~
l
. Job 15478-003
'4
-0BSERVATION REPORT
. File No.
17 '
File Revision No.
0 Date October 13. isse
..p
-1.. Level 1 classification of 0bservation:~
1 Not significant to safety.
'T Additional information required *See'5, "Recommsndatihn.for resolution"
[Significant to. safety, send to Level 2 Committee
- 2.
Structure (s), system (s). or component (s) involved:
Shutdown Service Water:(SSW) System, Active valves 3.
Description 'of Chservation:
There is a discrepancy' between a design document Attachment to' active valve specification Form 350-8, and FSAR sections 1.8 and 3.9.2.2.2 regarding conformance to Regulatory Gui,de 1.48.'
i y
FSAR Section 1.8 states that operability may be demonstrated by a detailed deformation analysis or by seismic testing. FSAR Section '3.9.2.2.2.
comits to analysis accompanied by testing. Form 350-8 allows analysis'or.
testing or a combination of both..
~ O 4.
Significance of Observation:
i These sections of the FSAR may not have been adequately coordinated and reviewed to accurately reflect the design document confomance to Regulatory Guide 1.48.
5.
Recomendation for resolution (optional):
SAL should provide an explanation of why this discrepancy occurred and an' assessment of its safety significance.
1 6.
Signatures:
-A '8 h ///
'"'%PANR1'!"
m
. (,,
1 0238C t
- * #-Ho e a D4+ e 9
w e4 e-g y.,
,3 g
-w.smm.<.----,er
g:
.y a >
CLINTON' POWER STATION Job 15478-003 RESOLUTION REPORT File No.
'17 File Revision No. O Date October 19,1C 1.
Resolution by Level 1
Internal Review Comittee 2.
Classification of Observation:
a.
Not valid (see continuation sheet) b.
Not significant to safety
- c. T Additional information required d.
Significant to safety 3.
Program resolution is:
a.
Closed item
- b. T Action to be taken by Reviewee 4.
Review Comittee signatures:
/
/6hf M R..h 1 M A h, fh"%h-s# -
A,274 Reviewee proh(sed resolution:
/
5.
- a. Description of proposed resolution:
(See Continuation Sheet)
- b. Basis of proposed resolution:
(See Continuation Sheet) 6.
Reviewee response report signed by
/0/3ll24-Engineer Date #
I
'N^ r -
[t !!
t s
Manager Date f
f
!/V//
/// / 3/ If 7.
Illinois Power Co. Review :
~
~
i Datej 0238C
=-
3-y b
hjg
. 'u ll
- 9 y _,
gg' n
s y
y f
y
.u
~
CLINTON"POWEQTATION'-
. ~ ?i Job 15478-0G3,.y 4
q g an
's 76 RESOLitTION'REPf)RT.
.'., ^
, A- >
(continyation shjM)
,y f* /[;'
~
17-File No.
-File Revision No.
00-
?1 -
Date Nu m
1 3,
p A reviulontto.the FSAR'Page 1.8-55 and.Section 3.9.2.2.2 will be initiated Tel reflect the fact that opera 61).lty. requirements for all' safety-re).ated' active components duringa seismic event will' be assured by Qualifi'dation tests and/or anhlyses.. The FSAR pre-sently states'," qualification? tests-and analysis".whereas it'should read " dynamic' tests and/or'ana-lysss."
This is-in agreement with'our proced,ures and standards (References
~
it 2) and, thof discrepancy' in the FSAR are 'due to.a typographicali
,f error,
,A
/
'x w
g 7..
There is. no safsty significa'nce; to,d proceduies and standards.
this observation since-the^q'ualifi-cation is performed using(controlle.
j.7 -
j
.(
References:
- 1) 7 MAS-CQD-2.4, Chocklist for Dynamic
~
~
Qualification of Mechanics 1 and fElectrical Equipment l
- 2f Standard" specification for Dynamic Qualificati n Criteria for Nuclear.
9 l
'. Safety-Roldted' Equipment, MSS 6.2-D l
This'in the same-issue as OR #07.
s 6
l 7
s p
v#
O 4
I 5
W o#
t a
j 0007C v.
y q
- l?
[
y:
m lm,;
x
.x, ~
,, +
g~ x x.g__
s w:
q f ap g, ;y, Q s v.
'9 M,
y
,,4
' '/F-0996 O [.'_ ~
~
r, wb
< L40-84(11-14)-L:
9:
4
~
- 'l8G.150bi
-H u, --
e r
-j
-Clinton Power. Station:
l
.. ~ _
1Independ$nt Dksign. Review 5 4
'~l'
- Standard Distribution 1Listt
~
3 N,
Qi
!Disectorof,N=1--tBeactorj.Re lhtion%
1RichardJ[ Goddard [Esq.n R
s
~AttisOM.itehumassir2' Loffice 'of :thej Legal; Director y s
ticen5ing Branch'No.
2-.
L U. _- S.l Nuclearj Regulatory Cosuaission ;
^
^-
D.
- 20555;
' NDivision of Licensing
. Washington,7.C.l N U. S.= Nuclear: Regulatory Cossaission Washington,-D.C. f20555
. Don Ecchisoni Director,-IllinoisLDe' partner.t ofi James-G. Keppler,.
. Nuclear Safety-.. a g
! Regional. Administrator 1035 Outer: Park Drivel, R' Region III-Springfield (Illinois;;62_704j>
~
'.U.o S.' Nuclear Regulatory Cossaission '
~
.n 799' Roosevelt Road
'Alled Samelson,'Esq.:
.Clen Ellyn, Illinois 160137 Assistant' Attorney General'!.
Environmental: Control Divisio'nE
' Byron Siegel=.
Southern'RegionJ
.Clinton Licensing Project Manager 500 South'SecondLStreet, i
Mail; Code 416.
' Springfield,: Illinois'D62706J U. S. Nuclear' Regulatory Commission' Washington,.D.C.,20555; Jean Foy Spokesperson,1 Prairie Alliance.
p
{
. Fred'Christianson.
~511 W.-Nevada
. Mail-Code V-690 tUrbana,. Illinois 61801e NRC Resident Office..
l-Clinton Power Station'-
Richard Hubbardt
[
R.R. : #3, ~ Box 228 =
MHB Technicar Associates-Clinton, Illinois,61727 1723 Hamilton' Avenue;
[
Suite K1 4
James L. Milhoan
- San ~ Jose,. California 195125.
.Section Chief. Licensing Section Quality Assurance Branch Gordon L. Parkinson:
-Office of Inspection and Enforcement Bechtel Power l Corporation Mail Stop' EWS - 305A Fifty Beal-Street =
0 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Connaission P. O. Box'3965
' Washington, D.C.
20555 San Francisco, California 94119 Y
- Richard C. Knop Roger Heider
}'
Section Chief Sargent & Lundy Engineers Projects'Section 1-C-55 East Monroe Street
}
U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Conunission Chicago, Illinois 60603 799 Roosevelt ~ Road j-Glen Ellyn, Illinois 60137 p
to
\\
+
j ^'
.,t,
?
.\\
+
g
...