ML20095J544

Forwards Rev 0 to NEDO-32288, Scaling of Sbwr Related Tests

ML20095J544
Person / Time
Site:	05200004
Issue date:	12/18/1995
From:	Quinn J GENERAL ELECTRIC CO.
To:	Quay T NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned), NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM)
Shared Package
ML20095J546	List: ML20095J544 ML20095J554
References
MFN-272-95, NUDOCS 9512270160
Download: ML20095J544 (3)

Text

.

/j@@kyd 5 E M y , , '.' , @ his;!Mh!fis$$dh@gg +1 p j@j![i7Sig$aJfTMS%$jf,6i@tgjg

-w. -

& # h4 . de,-m - +%

ff h h h/9k ' kifhki h.. M#ff khp

$ gg n

g gr [;p;[k hh -

s , g g g g g g g fjgg g g g g p g y

.g

'jfkh +MW:${i4seggpWqghgoissad,41gggt QYNI hydk y; [hkhljlkkf$kik[khhihh  !$

j "WE $hh l(h( Q 2.

~ wb Ebg hy gx ..fj Q gy N gghgfj5 r;.

~

$! N h h , , i?

• EfihjhQf#@@TMk}fh/@#

}; $$ .

!@h8dNM $ib$NN

$ 34{j# g Mdkf$ fNiI hsk $$NA hN h dh$

g^ %*i[js]j$$g$[$fI{$I[j@${p1n{,Agp%7{dM sh kjk

.(1 yph .

yfj bf $$$f@f$$$iyhigy@ f * ~?$vds!k[$j[NII'ifN[ly% %5)6 @j$

, (

"" R$kkuggghsdh ~u aW ~ 1, Y # ,

5:

p4Gl MW my g.:  % M%%; 0,MWo a ym 9512270160 951218 n A r jW4 4 M PDR ADOCK 05200004 1 M @w - 46df +ned!

w%). )fid@ *d@#mqp%

36 A PDR -

g $ 4 sp sd @n' }g@pi v

IRQ{((hh lkk@7 f

O GENuclearEnergy NEDO-32288 Revision 0 DRF T15-00011 Class 1 December 1995 Licensing Topical Report Scaling of the SBWR Related Tests 9

SBWR 9-

n aannsa.

A PDR

S GENuclearEnergy YM and$8W 7Yustn Yen k165 San Jose, CA 95125-1014 408 9251005 (phone) 406 925-3991 (facsimile)

December 18,1995 MFN-272-95 Docket STN 52-004 Document Control Desk U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Attention: Theodore E. Quay, Director Standardization Project Directorate

Subject:

SBWR - Transmittal of Scaling Report Revision, Scaling of SBWR Related Tests, NEDO-32288, Revision 0, dated December 1995  ;

Reference:

1. Letter MFN 097-94, P.W. Marriott (GE) to DCD (NRC),

Transmittal of SBWR Scaling Report, dated 8/16/94.

2. Letter MFN 166-95, J.E. Quinn (GE) to T.E. Quay (NRC),

SBWR - Test and Analylsis Program Description, NEDC-32391P, Revision C (Proprietary), dated August 28,1995. ,

3. Letter MFN 169-95, J.E. Quinn (GE) to T.E. Quay (NRC), SBWR

- Test and Analysis Program Description, NEDO-32391, Revision C (Non-proprietary), dated August 31,1995.

4. Letter MFN 167-95, J.E. Quinn (GE) to T.E. Quay (NRC), SBWR

- Test and Analysis Program Description Supplement 1 -

Discussion of PIRT Parameters, NEDC-32391, Supplement 1 (Non-proprietary), dated August 28,1995.

5. Letter MFN 170-95, J.E. Quinn (GE) to T.E. Quay (NRC), SBWR

- Test and Analysis Program Description Supplement 1 -

7/^ g, )

y

l l

MFN-272-95 December 18,1995 Page 2 Discussion ofPIRTParameters, NEDO-32391P, Supplement 1 (Non-proprietary), dated August 31,1995.

6. Memorandum to John T. Larkins (ACRS) from Dennis M.

Crutchfield (NRC), Draft Safety Evaluation Report (SER) on the Adequacy of the Technical Approach to the Testing and Analysis Program (TAP)for the Simphfied Boiling Water Reactor (SBWR)

Design, November 25,1994.

7. ACRC Thermal Hydraulic Phenomena Subcommittee Meetings, December 15 and 16,1994, and January 10, 1995.

8. NRC/GE TAPD DSER Meeting, January 9,1995.

9. 417th ACRS Meet i ng, January 12,1995. ,

10. Letter MFN 018-95, J.E. Quinn (GE) to R.W. Borchardt (NRC),

Approach to Achieve Closure ofItems Related to the GE SBWR TAPD, February 14, 1995.

11. Letter MFN 191-95, J. E. Quinn (GE) to T. E. Quay (NRC), SBWR

-Transmittal of Scaling Report Revision, Scaling of the SBWR Related Tests, NEDC-32288P, Revision 1, dated October 1995.

This letter transmits the Non-Proprietary version of the SBWR Scaling Report, Scaling of the SBWR Related Tests, NEDO-32288, Revision 0, dated December 1995, for your review. This report presents a scaling study applicable to the SBWR-related tests. The scope of the study includes a description of the scaling philosophy used in the tests, a description of a set of scaling laws which are applicable to the test facilities, and an evaluation of the test facilities with respect to the scaling of the important phenomena and processes identified in the SBWR Phenomena Identification and Ranking Table (PIRT). The study demonstrates that the experimental observations from the test programs are representative of SBWR behavior.

This is the non-proprietary version of the report previously transmitted by Reference 11.

References 2,3,4, and 5 are the related SBWR Test and Analysis Program Description (TAPD) documents which reference this scaling report in Appendix B. The level of scaling information necessary to respond to the requests and comments from the NRC and ACRS

MFN-272-95 December 18,1995 Page 3 reviewers became too detailed for the programmatic TAPD and was moved from the TAPD to consolidate and improve the presentation of the subject in this document.

Many scaling questiant, and issues were identified in References 6, 7, 8, 9 and 10, and responses to them have likewise been incorporated into this document or Reference 11.

If you have any questions regarding this report, please contact John Leatherman of our staff at (408) 925-2023.

Sincerely, h k k -. h b9 James E. Quinn, Projects Manager

Enclosure:

Scaling of the SBWR Related Tests, NEDO-32288, Revision 0 (Non-Proprietary), dated December 1995 cc:

P.A. Boehnert (NRC/ACRS)- [7 paper copies w/ encl., plus E-Mail)

- I. Catton (ACRS) - [1 paper copy w/ encl., plus E-Mail) ,

S.Q. Ninh (NRC) - [21 paper copies w/ encl., plus E-Mail] l J.H. Wilson (NRC) - [1 paper copy w/ encl., plus E-Mail] )

l

)

i I