ML20095H225

Informs That Hh Brown,Kj Letsche,Lc Lanpher,D Kraemer, Ober & P McGuire Designated as Authorized Persons,Per 840817 Protective Order.Related Correspondence

ML20095H225
Person / Time
Site:	Shoreham File:Long Island Lighting Company icon.png
Issue date:	08/24/1984
From:	Letsche K KIRKPATRICK & LOCKHART, SUFFOLK COUNTY, NY
To:	Bright G, Johnson E, Mark Miller Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
OL-4, NUDOCS 8408280405
Download: ML20095H225 (47)

Text

_. r m_.___________._ .

+ 'L l ^, . -*~.- * " *$ ,-

, ih ei~ - -

4 Jh. , '*a.-

E k [ I- EUOCREESPONogucg 7

' , 1 ,. . jy ,

, ~2nwy , ._

.g _ .

yw

/ KUUCPATRICK, LOCKIIART, HILL, CrrarsT6Purn & PnILLIrs A P-men:P INCISDING A PROFESS 10Ed CORPOSAMON 1900 M Srazer, N. W.

. WASIIINGTON, D. C. 20036 s4ae anacxzZ1 AVENtTE TEI.EPHONE:(202) 452-7000 3600 OLIVER BL*1LDINO

• ^2:1, rzominA sam '^*****

coos)er4-eus Tzz.zm am m t I CkE'*5"t?"*#****

G .3 (4:ajses-esOo August.24, 1984

- . ...cr - ,,,

'84 ISO 27 Aii:31 (202) 452-7064 . r- -. ..

w Judge Marshall E. Miller, Chairman

• dL~

Judge Glenn O. Bright - - - -

Atomic Safety and Licensing Board _.

.Q d .~.b.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Judge Elizabeth B. Johnson Oak Ridge National Laboratory P.O. Box X, Building 3500 Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37630

Dear Administrative Judges:

Pursuant to the Board's request (Tr. S-91, S-94), Suffolk l County hereby identifies the persons whom the County seeks to have designated as " authorized persons" according to Paragraph 1(b) of this Board's August 17, 1984 Protective Order. We have indicated below each individual's name, address, and occupation, whether he or she was an " authorized person" as defined in the Brenner Board's Revised Protective Order Governing Access to Security Plan Information, dated June 9, 1982 (hereafter, June 1982 Order) (a copy of which is attached for the Board's'informa- -

n tion), and the locations at which the County proposes each person may maintain notes and copies of pleadings ~containing safeguards information, as provided in Paragraph 11 of this Board's August 17 Protection Order.

u First, we list the three attorneys, two secretaries, two Suffolk County police officials, and two expert security consul-tants which the Board ruled on August 7 (Tr. 2954) could have access to the security plan:

1. Herbert H. Brown, attorney ,

Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher & Phillips -

1900 M Street, N.W.

. Washington, D.C. 20036

. ., (

L/1 8408200405 040824 '

0 PDR ADOCK 00000322 "" L V S03 8 4 OCN

=g, , _ , ,, .~ m y,f-spwW , N v: 2:- c.ay.m r -vn .' en;ti _

s,

.+ d _

_ . - - g ,. r.. ,

ey i- . .~ a ;5.;y 3n y _. _,

L '& ~" A'W:Y Y '= 4 d' ,' .

~

GInurArnicx, LocxMART, HILL, CuRIsroruza Se PHILLIPS Judge Marshall E. Miller, Chairman ,

Judge ~Glenn O. Bright Judge Elizabeth B. Johnson August 24, 1984 Page 2

~ . ~

Was an " authorized pefson" under June 1982 Order, and

^'

signed Affidavit of Non-Disclosure attached to June ~ ~

1982 Order.

Location for notes and pleadings :

- Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher &

Phillips 1900 M Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036 Has signed Affidavit of Non-Disclosure in form provided by Low Power Board on ?" mist If, 192'!

2. Karla J. Letsche, attorney -

Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher & Phillips 1900 M Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036 .

Was not an " authorized person" under June 1982 Order.

Location for notes and pleadings:

s Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher &

Phillips _

1900 M Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036,

_~ ,

,Has signed Affidavit of,.Non-Disclosure in form provided m.- '

N -

by Low Power Board on August.16, 1984 ,-

. n

? ..."~~

l 3. Lawrence Coe Lanpher,~ attorney Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher & Phillips '

'19 0 0 M S treet ,' N. W. " .

y -

Washington, D.~C - 20036 _p h o .

..'.Was"an " authorized person" under June 1982 Order and j

signed Affidavit'of Non-Disclosure attached to June 1982 Order Location for notes and pleadings:

- .A1-  : .u l.

Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher &

7 1 ,; ,Phillips* (~ , 3. .

1900 M Street, N.W.

Washington,-D.C. 20036-

..,-..w - - - - - - - - ,y -e . _ _ _ . -___ ._r - - , --

D yQ, . a? ~

r"

~

__ j *I ^ '

o,

. q; f =:; ; ~ ~

f ':D

~

aw 4 E .s .er" , ,

4 g'

-. ,a'~ ,wg ; . . ~ - .g 4N%#( 7 '

- .* 4~ g- .' 1 #

KIREPATRICK, LOCKHART, HIn, CanzsTorunn & Pmures Judge Marshall E. Miller, Chairman Judge Glenn O. Bright Judge Elizabeth B. Johnson August 24, 1984 Page 3 Has signed Affidavit of Non-Disclosure in form provided by Low Power Board on'Adgust 16, 1984

4. Diana Kraemer, secretary' to Mr. Lanpher1/ -

Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher & Phillips 1900 M Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036 Was an " authorized person" under June 1982 Order and signed Affidavit of Non-Disclosure attached to June 1982 Order Has signed Affidavit of Non-Disclosure in form provided by T.nw Dower Board on August 16, 1984 (copy enclosed)

5. Sarah Ober, secretary to Ms. Letsche2/

Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher & Phillips 1900 M Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036 -

Was not an " authorized person" under June 1982 Order Has signed Affidavit of Non-Disclosure in form provided by Low Power Board on August 16, 1984 (copy enclosed)

6. Dep,uty Inspector Phillip McGuire Suffolk County Police Department Yaphank, New York 11980

. Was an " authorized person" under June 1982 Order and signed Affidavit ~of Non-Disclosure attached to June 1982 Order Location for notes and pleadings:

• J

.g-

• 1/ Mrs. Kraemer will likely never need to see the plan itself.

Rather, her access to safeguards data will only be in the context of typing pleadings and testimony.

2/ Ms. Ober will likely never need to see the plan itself.

Rather, her access to safeguards data will only be in the context of typing pleadings and testimony.

_?$2: f C S,% Ngggg o-yl 3u-w+ "%~'~'

~- ,~~

w m..u m:, .

Wksw.n. y ff MI

.y-.

' ge

• % - : .a. .

,4 , .

p

'Y@$W3T W .=:p&belb%k.l Q ~ : p;;,l- [ __ &' "., , '

' Q

': 3'-

EtmurATwicx, LocxMART, Ext.I., CuntsToruza & Pnzt.I.res Judge, Marshall E. Miller, Chairman Judge Glenn O. Bright Judge Elizabeth B. Johnson August 24, 1984

.Page 4 Suffolk County, Police Department Headquarters 7 _

Yaphank, New York '11980 Has been sent Affidavit of'Non-Disclosure in form pro-vided by Low Power Board on August 16, 1984. Executed copy will be filed with the Board when it is received.

• +7. - Deputy Chief Richard C. Roberts Suffolk County Police Department Yaphank, New York 11980 Was allowed full and complete access to safeguards information regarding Shoreham by LILCO as of July 7, 1982, based on affiliation with SCPD. See Suffolk County's Notification of Additional Person Having

' Access to Security Plan Information, dated July 21, 1982, Signed Affidavit of Non-Disclosure attached to June 1982 Order. ,

^

. . _ _ w,

' ' Location for notes and pleadings:

Suffolk County Police Department Headquarters Yaphank, New York 11980 Has been sent. Affidavit of Non-Disclosure in form pro-vided by Low Power Board on August 16, 1984. Executed copy will be filed with the Board when it is received.

8. " BrianM. Jenkins

+ Director of Research Programs * ' ~~

wm - ' MRand' Corporation - m ,

6 - 1700 Main. Street

• 90406

" ' Santa Monica, California

.m .

~

lWas an

" authorized person" under June 1982 Order and

~

. signed Affidavit of Non-Disclosure attached to June 1

~

.1982 Order Location for notes and pleadings (See June 1982 Protec-tive Order at 4):

r: The Rand Corporation 1700 Main Street Santa Monica, California 90406 M As noted in the June 1982 Order at page 4, this location' is

-3/

' ' "" (footnote. continued)

~

e h i A .3>.y M ~ _f; i

3* . i.}

^ o -

• ' ' " - 5 a... kn J gw .3 _

IIrarPATnICE, LocxnART, Htt.r., CitarsTorunn & Puni.rrs Judge, Marshall E. Miller, Chairman Judge Glenn O. Bright Judge Elizabeth B. Johnson August 24, 1984 Page 5 Has been sent an Affidavit of Non-Disclosure16. in form Executed provided by Low Power Board on August is copy will be submitted to the Board when it received.

9. Richard E. White Formerly, Special Agent in Charge of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, Sacramento, California 2751 Lacey Lane Sacramento, California 95821 Was an " authorized person" under June 9, 1982 Order and signed Affidavit of Non-Disclosure attached to June 1982 Order ,

Location for notes and pleadings (See June 1982 Protec-tive Order at 4):

NRC Regional Office Walnut Creek, California 4j Has been sent an Affidavit of Non-Disclosure in form Executed provided by Low Power Board on August 16.

copy will be submitted to the Board when it is received. ,

Attached hereto, for the Board's information, are copies of resumes for Chief Roberts, Inspector McGuire, Mr. Jenkins and Mr.

White.

Suffolk Second, fo'r reasons discussed more fully below,

~

County requests that the following officials of the Suffolk County Police Department be designated as " authorized persons" as defined in the last sentence of Paragraph 1(b) of the I ow Power Board's~ August 17,-1984 Protective Order, asWe they willare members each ofof

" appropriate law enforcement agency." have the the individuals listed below execute an Affidavit of Non-Dis-closure in the form provided by this Board on August 16:

(footnote continued from previous page) storage and review an NRC approved facility for the maintenance,

• of safeguards information.

< A/ As noted in the June 1982 Order at page 4, this location is an NRC approved facility for the maintenance, storage and review s.

of safeguards informa-ion.

'O

. M* T

' * ~

h. ,

? --

7; :c - '

s.*:3 x .. 6 -  %. .; ,y ,.~ v KraxPATnICK, LOCKHAnT, Hui, CuntsToruzu & Punarrs Judge Marshall E. Miller, Chairman Judge Glenn O. Bright Judge Elizabeth B. Johnson August 24, 1984 Page 6

.g. 1. Commissioner Dewitt Tgeder Suffolk County Police Department Yaphank, New York 11980

2. Lieutenant Thomas P. Compitello Commanding Officer, Emergency Service Section Suffolk County Police Department Yaphank, New York 11980

3. Assistant Chief Joseph L. Monteith Suffolk County Police Department Yaphank, New York 11980

4. Deputy Inspector Michael J. Turano, Jr.

Suffolk County Police Department Yaphank, New York 11980 Commissioner Treder's predecessor in office, Donald J.

Dilworth, was an " authorized person" under the June 1982 Order.

Commissioner Dilworth has since retired. Because Chief Roberts and Inspector McGuire report to Commissioner Treder, it is neces-sary for Commissioner Treder to be free to discuss the details of that plan and the work being performed with the officers who are accountable to him.

Lieutenant Compitello was an " authorized person" under the June 1982 Order and signed the Affidavit of Non-Disclosure

. attached to the 1982 Order. Chief Monteith and Inspector Turano were authorized by LILCO to consult on safeguards matters with counsel and authorized experts, due to their affiliation with the Suffolk County Police Department. See Suffolk County's Notifica-tion of Additional Person Having Access to Security Plan Informa-tion dated July 21, 1982. Lieutenant Compitello, Chief Monteith and Inspecto: Turano were witnesses on behalf of the County in the 1982 security proceeding. They have worked closely with Chief Roberts and Inspector McGuire on security-related matters and will. materially assist the County in being able to present its case. Since they already have had access to safeguards information, their designation as authorized persons in the instant proceeding will not broaden the number of persons with access to safeguards data. Attached hereto are copies of the resumes of Lieutenant Compitello, Chief Monteith and inspector Turano.

Third, Suffolk County seeks to have designated as an

" authorized person" an official of the County, which is the party-in-interect in this proceeding. The Code of Professional

.,  ? ,

s. L. , m um .~ - -

 ; __;,F'__,

r , e

• 1- --

y;~.

, m ,_ , , . ,, . . , .

]

E!HEPATRICK, LOCK 11AI.., IllM,, CIIRISTOP1rna 6e Piut.t.ms Judge Marshall E. Miller, Chairman Judge Glenn O. Bright Judge Elizabeth B. Johnson August 24, 1984 Page 7 Responsibility requires that counsel be able to consult with the client being represented so that the client's interests can be properly and effectively asserted by counsel. The authority to make decisions on the merits of a. case is exclusively that of the client, not the lawyer, and the lawyer is obligated to exert his or her best efforts to ensure that the client's decisions are made only after the client has been fully-informed of relevant facts. See Ethical Considerations EC 7-7 and 7-8.

Deputy Suffolk County Executive Frank R. Jones was author-ized under the June 1982 Order "to consult with the [ authorized]

lawyers and expert consultants regarding safeguards information on a 'need to know' basis; however, he (was] not authorized to have access to the documents which themselves contain safeguards information." June 1982 Order at 2. The County has recently designated Chief Deputy County Executive John Gallagher, rather than Mr. Jones, as the representative of Suffolk County with whom counsel should consult concerning the County's position in this security proceeding. Accordingly, we request that Mr. Gallagher be authorized to consult with the authorized attorneys and expert consultants regarding sa'feguards information under the same terms as those set forth for Mr. Jones in the June 1982 Order. Thus, Mr. Gallagher would not have access to any documents containing safeguards information, but would be free to consult with counsel on a "need to know" basis regarding critical decisions in the County's conduct of this case. An Affidavit of Non-Disclosure in the form provided by the Low Power Board on August 16 has been sent to Mr. Gallagher and when an executed copy is received, it will be submitted to the Board. -

Fourth, Suffolk County requests that Gregory C. Minor,' a i

principal and consultant with MHB Technical Associates, 1723 '

Hamilton Avenue, San Jose, California 95125, be designated an

" authorized person" who is' authorized to consult with the author-ized attorneys and expert consultants identified above regarding safeguards information on a "need to know" basis. The County does not seek authority for Mr. Minor to have access to the LILCO security' plan itself; however, Mr. Minor, as an expert concernin'g the technical aspects of plant operation needs to be able to consult with security experts and counsel so that the County may conduct discovery, prepare testimony, and otherwise participate in this security litigation which concerns, among other things, '

the potential impact of the design basis threat upon the safety of the plant's operation. For instance, it is essential that the ,

security experts be able to consult with Mr. Minor to obtain his opinion on whether a particular security threat would have the potential to result in radiological consequences. In such con-

= 3 -= - z. 3 yy

, it.1; ,,, S 3 *- -

nt v A -

8

. -,,i3 n ,hL: ;a  ;; . ..  ;, .

KINKPATRICK, LOCKHART, Hrt.z., Citatsrorunn & Purt.z.res Judge Marshall E. Miller, Chairman Judge Glenn O. Bright Judge Elizabeth B. Johnson August 24, 1984 Page 8 sultations, safeguards information may need to be revealed, although we, of course, will seek to keep that to a minimum. Mr.

Minor has signed the Affidavit of.Non-Disclosure attached to the June 1982 Order. In addition, a copy of the Affidavit of Non-Disclosure provided by the Low Power Board on August 16 has been sent to Mr. Minor and an executed copy will be submitted as soon as it is received. A copy of Mr. Minor's professional qualifica-tions is attached hereto. Any notes or pleadings containing safeguards information will be kept by Mr. Minor at the office of Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher a Phillips.

Final,lg, although the County does not seek to have a fourth attorney authorized to participate in these low power proceed-ings, we inform the Board that Michael S. Miller, also with the firm of Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Hill, Christopher & Phillips, is an " authorized person" under the June 1982 Order and has signed an Affidavit of Non-Disclosure attached to the June 1982 Order.

Mr. Miller was one of the primary attorneys involved in the

• security proceeding which took place in 1982, and has had contin-uing involvement subsequent to 1982 in matters arising out of that proceeding. Pursuant to the terms'of the June 1982 Order and the Affidavit of Non-Disclosure which has been executed by Mr. Miller, it is anticipated that he will continue to perform that role, and, insofar as what happened in that proceeding may be pertinent to what happens in this low power proceeding, Mr.

Miller may be called upon infrequently to consult with the three counsel identified herein as authorized participants in this low power proceeding. However, since Mr. Miller is now engaged in the emergency planning case before Judge Laurenson, it is not y anticipated that Mr. Miller would be available to become active '

in the instant matter.

s. "

Sincerely, A

• e Kar a J. Lep che Enclosures cc: Fabian G. Palomino, Esq.

Donald P. Irwin, Esq.

Bernard M. Bordenick, Esq. l Docketing and Service j w.

l

h 'T '

7, 3 . f.s.T% m- m. ,ui ,.n. ea, . . mi . , .- se = MS ~a#.

m T.

r. ..

-. Av. M(. i .,

., s . . . ._ _ ,

. s. . . . , , ,

~, '

N.vg cA-a sehr;y.rg g.773D'STA*ES OFsAMERICA f * f, ' '

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION EEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD -

Before Administrative Judges:

Lawrence Brenner, Chair =an Dr. Ja:nes H. Carpenter Dr. Peter A. Morris

.r SERVE JUN 151982

, )

In the Matter of )

} Docke'~ No* 50-322 O*L*

LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY )

(Security Proceeding)

(Shoreham Nuclear Power Stat _4cn, )

Unit 1) ) June 9, 1982

)

REVISED PROTECTIVE ORDER GOVERNING ACCESS TO SECURITY PLAN INFORMATION On January 14, 1981, this Board issued a " Protective Order on Security Plan Information" permitting access to the Shorehar. ,

. security plan under specified conditions. Since that time, the Board has modified its original order en several occasions. In order to (1) clarify who is per=itted access to Shcreha= security inf or=atic'n , (2) revise the conditions governing that access, t.nd y , ,, .. . . _

,(.3) reemphasi:e the importance .- n of holding .~

protective data in con- ,

,  ;, ~,.

fidence, the Board has issued this Revised Prctective Order. I:

supersedes all previous security protective orders issued in this proceeding.

Auth6rized persons who have executed an Affidavit of Non ~

Disclosure in the form attached shall be permitted access to

.pretected security information (hereinafter, " safeguards informa-

, tion ".) , upon the following

, w condi:icns: ,

yy $ > 0 -

. L, p w vy> n y' -

L

,.a -

n n,,s ;

n=x - , - - .. a. - - *

,%f_q_ 'm , - - Lf.

s m , +

ig~ ,

~ . -

,_ ,o

__ s. v._ j_. n.

,.. . I (

e .

..:,- ~ m.; . .: = ,. s. -

y- -

(- ~ 2.

1. Herbert E. Brown, Lawrence Cce Lanpher and Michael S.

Miller, as counsel to Suffelk County, and Brian M. Jenkins, Richard E. White, Marc W. Goldsmith, Donald J. Dilworth, Philip McGuire and Thomas P. Compitellp,, as experts / consultants to the County, are qualified in accordanc'e with the requirements of the Appeal Board's decision in Pacific Gas & Electric Companv (Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2) , ALA3-410, 5 NRC 139S (1977), and subsequent orders in that proceeding relevant to security plan informatien, and may have. access to safeguards information on a "need to knew" basis.

2. In addition, Ms. Diana Kraemer and Ms. Amy Pinto, secretaries to counsel for Suffolk County, are autheri:ed to type pleadings and other materials which may contain safeguards information. Mr. Frank Jones, Deputy County Executive for Suffelk County, is authorized to censult with the above-named lawyers and experts / consultants regarding safeguards information on a "need to know" basis; however, he is not authori:ed to have access to the documents which.the=selves contain safeguards information.

3. Counsel and the experts / consultants who receive any pro-tected (safeguards) informatien on behalf of Suffelk County (in-cluding' transcripts of in camera hearings, filed testineny er any other dccument that reveals safeguards informatien) shall maintain its ccnfidentiality as required by the attached Affidavit of Ncn-Disclosure, the terms cf which are hereby incorpera:ed inte this

~

protective crder.

~ ,

pp _ . . = 2 .. i g . . m __ .__i . ._ m .t . ._, . g

- , , .. . . . .- + - .

44 a

4. Counsel and~the experts / consul ants who receive any protected (s af eguards ) information shall use it solely for the purpose of participa: ion in inatters,directly pertaining to Suffolk County's security contentions and any hearing that may ba held or any further proceedings in this case directly involving i ,

sccurity matters, and'for no other purposes.

5. In order to keep the service list as limited as possible and thus to reduce the possibility of materials becoming lost or misplaced, copies of documents will be formally served on each Board member and only on the following who shall be considered

" lead counsel" for servien purposes:

Suffolk County: Michael S. Miller LILCO: Anthony F. Earley, Jr.

NRC Staff: ,

Bernard M. Bordenick In addition, copies,of documents shall be served upon Chief, Recoids Services Branch, Division of Technical Information and Document Control, Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington,'D.C. 20555.

4 Seivice shall be accomplished by the means dascribed in paragraph'll of this order, except each outside envelope 3

shall be marked " Personal and Confidential".

l

6. There 'shall be a limit ei two transcripts per party fer cny proceeding conducted on the record in which safeguards informa-tion is disclosed or discussed. Parties shall not photocopy these transcripts without the express prior approval of the Board.

7. At the conclusion of this proceeding (including any nocessary appeals), the person designated to ma:.ntain the efficial NRC filo of dccuments shall ensure that extra copies of documents to be kept during the lifetime of r.ie plant are destrcyed.

wm s, ,

a ,K , R : x ne,rs , , An

= _ , ,- _ , _ -

in:~y.,:,rnc x n , _ ,.

. n ., "

z .:

3, .?.

J. , .. ( , _ s .

. ( .,

.:- -~h t.

^J : E& w :) - Q

. N : %% 4. & ~; . - -r

8. Any individual in this preceeding who has reason to suspect that documents containing safeguards information may have been lost or misplaced, or that safeguards info ~ation has becene available to unauthorized persops, shall notify the Board pronptly -

1

^

of those suspicions and the reasons for them.

9. The County's counsel and experts /censultants may review

. safeguards information at.a location made available by the NRC Staff in Silver Spring, Maryland, or at a facility on Lcng sland t

to be provided by LILCo. In addition, (a) any nc es which desig- t naued Suffolk Ccunty representatives have made frem their review

- of the safeguards information, and (b) copies of pleadings con-taining safeguards information, nay be maintained by the following

y. . 2 l

authori:ed persons at the following locations:

Richard E. White: Notes and pleadings to be kept at:

NRC Regional Office ,

Walnut Creek, California j ~

t Brian M. Jenkins: Notes and pleadings to be kept at:

1 ,.

~

The Rand Corporation ..

1700 Main Stree: ,,

H:

. ~ . *

~

, a ' . . Santa Monica, California 90406 / ,

Herbert H. Brown Notes and)1eadings t: be kept at:

Lawrence Coe Langher , Kirkpatrick, Lockhart, Michael S. Miller: h.. 4 11, C.u..,.4 . s top he ,. & P$4,,4.s r 19 0 0 M S treet , N . W . "i .

Washington, D. C. 20036.

. ,1 ,

In addition, permissien to create notes and pleadings *- ' a afere-nentioned locations is hereby granted. >

~ ,

5 %= .

- Designates an NRC-approved facility for the saintenance , i storage and review cf safeguards infernati:n.

n.c . e w .

- m.~p ;t. - ~ c ; _; -s-;;;,. _

8 msnm

W ;/ . 4-w.w.w%lp

.f kh ; ,

>x,m;mem gy

~

n~, _m; --

_~ _. . % .m

. ' Jf:_'g j

. . , . s _ .-

( .

} *j ' 5-! .

., 4-l .N,$ . *

{ ~~ k , -

.?' --. 'c ' . .

10. Suffolk County and its above-named autheri:ed repre-

.sentatives, in .,<eeping sareguarcs . n:ormat on a: :ne amove-designated locations, shall take such protective measures and crocedures.necessary to satisfv.i fu,lly the specific requirements of 10 C.F.R. 5 73.'21. Such protective =easures and procedures are as follows:

a. The bu11c..ine.s 2.n whicn the sareguarcs in:ormation e .

(i.e., notes and pleadings) will be =aintained will qualify as controlled access buildings in that they are-either attended around the clock or locked at night;

b. The safeguards information, when unattended, will be stored in a locked security storage container, such as a steel filing cabinet or map cabinet equipped-with a locked bar and GSA-ae.reved c ccabination cadlock. .

Access to the securitv. storac.e container will be' positively controlled by use of keys or other comparable means; and

- r c. h n i_,e

. in use, the sa_,eguarc.s in:or:ar on w ..:..:. me under-the sole cont cl.of:an authcriz.ed individual. 1 .._

^

11. With' respect to 'transportati'en of the safegua-ds informa-tion'in question, procecures w1_y_ .xe u:1_31:ec wn:.cn ensure ccm-pliance witu.

. regu_,atory requirements.

epec:.: ca, , y , documents x

containing sa:eguards :.n c o .~. a : 1 c n , wnen transmittec outs:.ce an l

authorized place of use or s:crage, will be enclosed in twc sealed  !

s l envelopes or wrappers, with the inner envelope er wrapper cen-n

~ '

. w _,_.< ._; ..c, ~m.e ..a=e ' a.."A- .= d d_- .= .n o _' ~ ; .e . _4 T. .. c '..d e ~_-= M_ y _* e. .~. ' .=.r. . A. c._-k=A

1. ) e on both' sides, top and bottom, with the words " S AFIGUAROS INFC :.".A 0:: . ' '

~. , _. __

a, . -- c p u::. +c .. ~>-.z- ...-w..._ -

e . p. _ .

~~ % . ., ': R *g ? . . . D^ 'a: - : %> ~ *' ' lJ - s: '

.(

-- y .e O

-pf- 9. :3 . - Q" ' - .

s .;2 m.s .u, e o u * .". e . v e .' cy " e o *

. W'* = "y .*~ e '" *~* # ' '-- ^ ^ "

• a # .*. ~ . ' '-" . * -

w-..- -.".

d

~-*"-..#- -e -d ** C4'y#***'

,a.me a .-A EC'c,.ess, W4 n'-

4.o

, 4 ;;n-- , ; C . .

-.. -- -. -, c- - -

~

n' e CnC._. w .e . -

4

-..--we e: A ne ww .

-,4..s

--- sa#ec.u= #s .4..#c. = 4^..

w.

.c e e : -.= s --4 ."o --=-de . - -- - . . 4

"e transpor:ec. .ny reg:.sterec. or certir'ec ma:, or by c:her courier methods or hanc. cel.very wh:. ..cn ensure that a receipt :.s octa:.nec.

to vers...:y ce_31very or

.s.,y an : nc:.v:.cua_, auenor:.:ec access pursuan:

to 10 C.F.R. S 73. 21 (c) . Anv authorized individual transc.ortinc.

tn.e sa eguarcs in,ormation in quest:.on W:.11 re instructec to re-tain the documents in his perscnal possession at all times.

T.

. TS S O C r.D.r.P r D. . .

n

.~.

\

M'y t.% ..t_ s . "

m Lawrence Brenner, Cnairman June j 1982 Eauppauge, New York Amu -

sp W 1h f * 'W-5 ** . i s

N 3

$. A h k*

,C 6

l l

t 1

~ . ; . )s __ __ --

.w ~- - _x.

.l' m.r w .,--* , 4 % ,"- ?gy - -

., i, 1[y).((, . J M.#~

. , , 4,. ' p3.7ra .

r.

['

f e;; i , . ,

,, 1

"l.' ^ 4,'

i. '<*~$ s

.- i e - 7[.'.- * ' -

-E m;=

~

'A ^ - ~

u

• Ts. -- nwmyq -

p s ym ar

.m.-

s e.

I NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSION

.areOer

,. .- .. -t. ? n' "_ O.M..T C A.P.r*t v. .'. *3 7 -_ C v.'A TN.'C- 3C,'. s.D

)

In the Matter of )

)

LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ' '

) .

)

Docket No. 20-3.,2 0.L. . )

(Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, )

Unit 1)- )

)

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-DISCLOSURE Io r beine. dulv. swcrn, i state: _.

1. As used in this Affidavit.of Non-Disclosure, (a)

" protected information" is (1) any form of the physical securi:y plan for the Applicant's Shoreham Nuclear Power Station; or (2)

- an.v in,ormat on obta nep- cy v:.rtue or. these .croceec..:.ncs wnlen . . .

is.

not otner.c se a matter or pubile recorc. a n c. which dea,s witn. or .

describes details of the security plan; (b) an " authorized person"

_ .is (1) ,an; employee.c' the Nuclear Regulatory Commission entitled

. to access-to crctected information; . (2) a- persed who ,Uat the r;r"

~

invitation of the Atcmic Safenf and Licensing Board (" Licensing

~

30ard"),chas executed atcopy of this A'fidavi:; (3) a person

• e m o. l o.v, e d 'b y L o n c. Island Lic.htinc. Come. an.v , the Ac. c. licant , and

- r a ..

O authorized by it in-accorfance with Commissicn rec.ulations

t. o have access to protected information, er (4) counsel fcr Long a

Island Lighting Com=an".

• 1

..2.u.I sn-a1. nc : c sclose protectec :.n orman:.on to. anycne. -

s

,a

.4

'- .,e

" , ..--e .y t .J. . . . ....e--

w .4, e-e :e- -

e-e, . ...'p. ., =- e s - .' .a - - .

4 o n . . a e -:--

- = v ' - . s ' ;-

- e e .. . ; s .. a' c a e^

. * .. -.' .= r u' ' ' - - = ~ o ~ '. _c ' ~-.* . ' s : - -c =- = c' ' . . c .

x --

.m _ , . - x - s. m n P -- . : - es smer wm r.. a z ww -

rm_ wa=5.g; : ' - " - " ' - - - -

pic -- ----m-

. n. ..,.,...~..n.

.w y, a w. , . m s.s .-. ..,._., ,

?- > .

_ . - 4 , m. ._

^t ,

c 3~ mS4f( .4W =- -e. g:- q --. ~w -

saf ecuard Orc:ected information in citten form (.includine. anv portions of transcripts of in camera hearings, filed testimony or any other documents that contain such information), se tha:

it remains at a_,1 tries unc.

g _

.. . a --

er the centrol o:. an autn.orisesi person s , .

and.is not' disclosed to anyone els'e. It is understood that any secretaries having access to protected informatien shall have such access soleiv. , .for the . cur.cose of necessar.v tv.=inc. and other support services. Further, Mr. Frank Jones, Deputy Suffolk County Executive, shall have access to protected information only in the manner authorized in the Board's June 9 , 1982 Order entitled

, " Revised Protective Order Governing Access to Security Plan Information."

3. I will not re.croduce any orotectec. :.nformation .a.v any. .

means witho b the Licensing Board's express approval or direction.

It'is understoed, however, that pleadings which are necessary to

.ce prepared in this proceeding can be reproc.ucec, provicec tna: . .. . .

each ccov t.u.e r e o :. :.s maintaine, . . . .

n con:1cence as rec.u. rec.uov tne

3 card'.s .,..

protectivee-order: described hereafter. .;So long as I possess o -

pro tectec. 2.n_,ormation , L s ha_, _, continue to take these precautions until-further order of the.,-Licensine. Board. -

. +.-

I shall sim1_,arly sareguar, anc noic in con: cence any 4 .' . .. .. . . . .

8 _- , - g. - - . - -

data, notes, or coc.ies of .crotected informatien bv means cf the .

folicwing:

c I

(a)- Except as 0:herwise permitted in the Scar _d's l

[ June - 9 , 1932 Order e:ititled. " Revised Protective Order Governing

~..

3 l 7.ccess tc Security Plan 7 . formation," my use of the prctected l .

t t

information wla .ce made at a rac1 1: 7 cn .cng u .s_.anc te .se mace

. nn .- -- -.- . ~y gy ; y mg g- - - -

.1 L :' ? ~ ~"t: . .c p &  ;" *w ~' J kj ~ _ -

+ -

. ; k w .e 4 pp.. w . k u m . n f g ,=

W > -

e-*~ d ' .

1 Silv'er Spring, Maryland, made available by the NRC =-.=.3 -.

(b) Except as otherwise permitted in the Scard's '

I June 9, 1932 Order entitled " Revised Protective Crde-C-cverning Access to Security Plan Information," I will keep and i ,

safeguard all such material in a. safe to be provided by Long Island Lighting Company or the NRC Staff, after censul ation with Long Island Lighting Company or the Staff, and to be 1ccated at all times at the above-designated locations. i (c) Except as otherwise permitted in the Board's June 9 , 1982 Order entitled " Revised Protective Order Governing Access to Security Plan Information," any secretarial work per-formed at my request or under my supervision will be performed

. c.

'at the above locations either (1) by a secretarv. .=rovided b.v Ehe

~ .

Long Island Lighting Company or the NRC Staff authorized in ac-cordance with paragraph 1(b) abcVe, or (2) b_v a secretarv. of av.

cesicnation wh.o has been autnerizec bv the Scarc. to c.errorm sucn I

wark. .~ .. ..-

.w

&,  ;(d) will-Necessarv tvcinc and recreduction x: ecuiemen.=t.

- - - - ~

w

- m.,  ; . - -

l She furnished bv Long Island Lighting'Cc=pany and the'NRC Staff' A

I l

,. when secretarial work is perfcrmed at the .LILCO cr Staii odfices.

5. I shall use protected information only for the purposes o: . - .:

c----  ;--a-- :L:o., .:..agu a s. ---

a'--

e~-..'v.

e - a - ..- 1 c. ~~- - .%

- -- ~ ' = o ' >.. W- a. . ~ ' ' =

l security contentions and any hearings that may be held er any l

further proceedings in :his case dealing with security plan ssues,

_ 'and for nc:other pcrpose.f  ;

" v Ig

-1

+

We

+,,-e , n--- ,-rv,- --,- ---------,,y , - - - - me , --a w ---m-, -

+o-yt-e--

g__  ; w

=_

,m

, -u.

_ w x _ w r ~ .-

v

.e .

D._ -

4.

n.# . . ...., A c.

At the conclusion of this proceeding, I shall account to the Licensing Board or to a Cc==ission empicyee designated by that Board for all the papers or other materials (including notes anc .cac.ers r reparec..o.v me .

containine. .crotected in_,ormatica in =v -

possession. I may either destr'oy the papers which do act need to I

.u.e saved (such as unimportant no t'e s ) and certify t.uat action :.n - -

l l

writinc., or for c.ac.ers which need to be saved (such as transcriets; '

may deliver them as provided herein. When I have finished using the protectec in:ormation the.v contain, cut in no event later t.aan .

the conclusion c:. tn. .is croceec..ing

. incluc. .i n e. an.v necessarv a.ccea. s ,, ,

A, sn.a _3 _, c e _31ver t.yose papers and mat eria_, s tnat were not cestroyec

~

to the Licensing 3 card (or to a Commission employee designated by the Board), for safekeeping during the lifetime of the plant.

7. I make this agreement with the understanding that I will not corroborate the accuracy or inaccuracy of information obtained outside t.ls .croceec nc. v. u s i n e. protected . n:orma 1on gainec through participation in matters directly pertaining to Suffolk County's security contentions and any hearing that may be held or any further proceedings in this case dealing with security plan issues.

. - . . -:. . s

.e....e. - _.u.e,_

a.._ , - s..c - ~... o _ u a._n_,

, . _ . . ,. . _._a

.a da.v of- 1982. .

k' b.e J'  %

k- - .. ,

lW e . r- , . ~. _

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Before Administrative judges Marshall E. Miller, Chaiman Glenn O. Bright.

Elizabeth B. Johnson

)

In the Matter of )

) '

LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-322-OL-4

) (Low Power)

(Shoreham Nuclear Generating Plant, ) .

Unit 1) )

)

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-DISCLOSURE I, AG% MR.N= N , being duly sworn, state:

1. As used in this Affidavit of Non-Disclosure, (a) " protected information" is (1) any form of the physical security plan for the Applicant's Shoreham Nuclear Power Station; or (2) any information obtained by virtue of these proceedings which is not otherwise a matter of public record and which deals with or describes details of.the security plan; (b) an " authorized person" is (1) an employee of the Nuclear Regulatory Comission entitled to access to protected information; (2) a person who, at the invitation of the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (" Licensing Board"), has executed a copy of this '

Affidavit; (3) a person employed by Long Island Lighting Company, the

- * ~

'# 1 'W s > .

2'

• 33 r- '

~. ,

w

[g

g-AQ.u-- -;-9.; . 779. b.4 g 3.:px m m-~w y g g;3-  ;

. , w r,. .y n- g- n.;;. '

_, __r..  ? >

-r l ' N.

• Li. -Q' . , ,

_rA ,

.' , x _, - -

%n+%

@ f S ?*' r is :: % $i W 7'T1.f G Ylt' B

', _ X

?_y7L " - 3;. :

Applicant, and authorized by it in accordance with Corsission regulations to have access to protected information, or (4) counsel for

.% .- c, Long Island Lighting Company.

2. I shall not disclose protected information to anyone except an authorized person, unless that information has previously been disclosed in the public record of this proceeding. I will safeguard protected information in written form (including any portions of transcripts of M camera hearings, filed testimony or any other documents that contain such information), so that it remains at all times under the control of an' authorized person and is not disclosed to anyone else. It is understood that any secretaries having access to protected information shall execute Affidavits of Non-Disclosure and shall have such. access solely for the purpose of necessary typing and other support services.

3. I will not reproduce any protected information by any means without the Licensing Board's express approval or direction. It is understood, however, .that pleadings.which are necessary to be prepared

~ in this proceeding can be reproduced, provided that.each copy thereof.is.- ,

~.

e maintained in confidence as required by the Board's protective order described hereafter. So long as I possess protected information, I .

shall continue to take these precautions until further order of the LicehsingBoard. #

.. +-- -

-s

4. I shall similarly safeguard and hold in confidence any data, notes, or copies of protected information by means of the following: e

' ~

+ ~

,, -r ~ .w

,~

ppin m' ~

y -ijn  : _ - Q.  : .j u

? hO h,hrgi kn.x=.cd,r[.f'@{ , J. .r- . g ug , ,. :g I

l (a)' Except as otherwise permitted in the Board's Protective Order entered August 16, 1984, my use of the protected information will

~

-- . . .. 1 be made at a facility on'Long Island'to be made available by Long Island

' Lighting Company or at a facility in' Silver Spring, Maryland, made available by the NRC Staff.

(b) Except as otherwise permitted in the Board's Protective Order entered August 16, 1984, I will keep and safeguard all such material in a safe to be provided by Long Island Lighting Company or the NRC Staff, after consultation with Long Island Lighting Company or the-Staff, and to be located at all times at the above-designated locations.

(c) Except as otherwise pemitted in the Board's Protective

~

Order entered August ^ 16, 1984, any secretdrial work performed at my

~

request or under my supervision will be performed at the above locations either (1) by a secretary provided by the Long Island Lighting Ccmpany or the NRC Staff authorized in accordance with paragraph 1(b) above, or (2) by a secretary of my designation who has been authorized by the p.g. - .

~

Board to perfom such work.

.a n -

(d) Necessary typing and reproduction equipment will be

r. ,-_ - .

~ .

_ furnished by Long Island Lighting Company and the NRC Staff when

'~

N~ secretarihl' ' work js performed at the LILCO or Staff offices.

c_ . ~ PL s 5. I shall!use, protected information only for the purposes of participation in matters directly pertaining to Suffolk County's N f(M k k lv'I security contentions and any hearings that may be held _ or any further s

/

u .

s'J%

'~

~#~

l 's

.&:~ . ,

< /

g 4

R9)

P ,%s,.. - .,w[w W "....;~:_ a ,.,p.,; W . M W r . . _ . . . , , , . , . .

&W : "% JW. QldW. . s i ' .

~.- .,

(.. _

w *

,. . n.yg. . . .x, .+ n. g

' E E~ ~N' N

- Q& rk . hlWe

• L l ~ ~

proceedings in this case dealing with security plan issues, and for no

(

other purpose. ,

.- \ ,

At the conclusion of this proceeding, I shall account to the

~

6.

Licensing Board or to a Comission employee designated by that Board for all papers or other materials (including notes and papers prepared by me) containing protected information in my possession. I may either destroy the papers which do not need to be saved (such as unimportant notes) and certify that action in writing, or for papers which need to be saved (such as transcripts) may deliver them as provided herein.

When I have finished using the protected information they contain, but in no event later than the conclusion of this proceeding,(including any

, ..x.-,. . .

necessary appeals), I shall deliver those papers and materials that were not destroyed to the Licensing Board (or to a Commission employee

~

designated by the Board),'for safekeeping during the lifetime $f the plant. .

7. I make.this agreement with the understanding that I will nots, -

73:c ,

corroborate the accuracy or inaccuracy of infomation obtained outside '

_ _ .. Zi .

this proceeding by using protected infomation gained through ' ~,

participation in m tters di ectly pertaining to Suffolk County's t'd -

n. p. - ,

f ( f. h i

g.,,,~ #- .g.,,'< *'y e

' . r.4 ., ,

b'

+ "a e _

. . ee e y. . o 9?> ,,. _ws,  ; ,4 ,,

k.J*"

~ . . -

M

+ W- -

a . ..

c

e. < , -

.3._-

.e ,1;y;

+. - ;% .- . .p ...

.3-

. <_ ~ -

. u ; .p .

~;a. ,. ,

. 7, -- ,- ,

_ % m

R3 - : a ;~ C ;: r"",.., -

-2 + > za.  :-, :' == -

~= , . = w: aw security ceatentions and any hearing that may be held or any further oroceedings in this case dealing with security plan issues.

i ,

% )  %

Washington, District of Columbia Subscribed and sworn to before me this .

N N ay of bu 0Augh , 1984

\ ]n/k N>m')!

(y My commission expires: July 31, 1986

_w ..

%4,,,

t ,y

<  ;.*j; .

g.-

p;*

m-

'y'#n

y sse,w. i:--= vi m a gyu- n.:;

m m %: 7 .a1 g ; x.. :w n ;.x. m y.m . , 4- .

zwm w -a.. n a p, .~ : w ... , ,.

,y;,n b

-- ? -

, .. c . . , c z--

w '~

..;. w .. . .. . _ .

n,.;  %. > ' A.

'$  ?  ? y' "*^h ,

A. E'; ~Y - ?- q'

~

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Before Administrative judges Marshall E. Miller, Chairman e . iGlenn O. Bright

~^ "

C Elizabeth B. Johnson

)

In the Matter of )

)

• LONG ISLAND LIGHTING COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-322-OL-4

) (Low Power)

(Shoreham Nuclear Generating Plant, ) .

Unit 1) )

) . .

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-DISCLOSURE

- . - .w. ,

I, _b crn jrs 9M , being duly sworn, state: ,

1. As used in this Affidavit of Non-Disclosure, (a) " protected information" is (1) any form of the physical security plan for the

• Appl,1 cant's.Shoreham Nuclear Power Station; or (2) any information , g-

_obtained by virtue of these. proceedings which is not otherwise a matter..

~ '

- of public' record and which deals with or describes details of the.

_. security plan; (b) an " authorized person" is (1) an employee of the _.

^

Nuclear Regulatory Commission entitled to access to protected' , _ .f

+... , ' ' ~ n . .. .

~

infor'mation; (2) a~ person who,~at the invithtion of t,he Atomic Safety and Licensing Board (" Licensing Board"), has executed a copy of this Affidavit; (3) a person employed by Long Island Lighting Ccmpany, the

• ... ' ., -,,_, g+n ,.

I l-

- - -.y

Gd %fg, 7;4. grcm ='

.ppvm u 3.~ _ W.WM-W:.3 p y_u Mg.s___y, nn... w:.. wek a my . .a.= . m;' u. e.

y . , .

+2 n> .

- c '

hp- h h ; N,. ~ EQy, i,u [ " . +

k',0 . D-+ es 5 E wha 9 '[ .. ,% ] i. y"

.. Y 2.) s J.-W ; i7 M p' Applicant, and authorized by it in accordance with Comission

~

regulations to have access to protected information, or (4) counsel for 3' ",; , 2 -

r  ;;\

s Long ~ Island Lighting Company. '

2. I shall not disclose protected information to anyone except an authorized person, unless that information has previously been disclosed in the public record of this proceeding. I will safeguard protected information in written form (including any portions of transcripts of in camera hearings, filed testimony or any other documents that contain

+ -such-information), so that it remains at all times under the control of an authorized person and is not disclosed to anyone else. It is understood that any secretaries having access to protected information shall ' execute Affidavits of'Non-Disclosure'and shall have such access '

solely for the purpose of"riecessary typing and other support services.

3. I will not reproduce any protected information by any means without the Licensing Board's express approval or direction. It is u

understood, however, that pleadings which are necessary to be prepared 1,+ ,. . . . :. . . -

in this proceeding can be'Feproduced, provided that each copy thereof'is

~

~

maintained in confidence as required by the Board's protective order

~. ~ x.y 5 ,

l described hereafter. So long as I possess protected information, I e: A . ..

shall contin,'ue to take ~these precautions'until further order of the

~

J. .

~

-Licensing Board. -

- g ...

, _ m.- ,

_- 4; I shall similarly safeguard and hold in confidence any data, notes, or copies of protected information by means of the following:

~-

m i

<W

> ~; h ,

, ,iu ... t

_s-a "

l .Q'y w

% W. .,

_c

fij% ,

n?;pnQ:MCs.-f;Qsygp + + ;,vm Qn+ O & : ? QQ;n;zC7%.wfi? . .,

. .* y  ;- , f.- ,,s.. a .m -, _, ,,

, m

,L.WWQ , -ha "w w

' K. 'j%Zi, k -Q bl i W >~A ]4?(* %[ +-

@ 4=dr 2.- w- LA '

(a) Except as otherwise permitted in the Board's Protective 1

Order entered August 16, 1984, my use of the protected information will i

, a be made at a facility on.Long Isian'd to be made available by Long Island ~

Lighting Compan) or at a facility in Silver Spring, Maryland, made available by the NRC Staff. .-

(b) Except as otherwise permitted in the Board's Protective Order entered August 16, 1984, I will keep and safeguard all such material in a safe to be provided by Long Island Lighting Company or the NRC Staff, after consultation with Long Island Lighting Company or the

- Staff, and to be located at all times at the above-designated locations.

(c) Excepf as otherwise pennitted in the Board's Protective

m. . 3. . ,

Order entered August 16, 1984, any secretarial work performed at my request or under my supervision 'will be performed at the above locations either (1) by a secretary provided by the Long Island Lighting Company or the NRC Staff authorized in accordance with paragraph 1(b) above,.or (2) by a secretary of my designation who has been authorized by the 4,

- c n _ 7 7 ,

Board to perfonn such work. ~""

n . w :v , ys ~

.,(d) Necessary typing and reproduction equipment will be 4;.

furnished by Long Island I,ighting Company and the NRC Staff when

+ . .

~ ~ ~'

secretarial _ work"is'perfo'nned at the LILC0 or Staff offices._

. _ ,5. I.shall use protected ,infonnation only for the purposes of - ,

participation in'm tters di ec y pertaining to Suffolk County's !.6 <2 k 4) .

security contentions and any hearings that may be held or any further b Q' '

M f'

.  ; ~ e

+

• J '

}.a _

4-i-

l

fGh . gw 5:+gs Q;;x 'j f : Q 32f'-

c ;a,. by: mWW55&W:f%.TM% *  ;

. ~. . .. & . x ~ ,. .

de m n.:: .

%s .n y ,. ~: -

1 . . .

Q l-%26- jgh%;gf J + swn

e tyi - Wi?::' ~ *w' + -ik ; %

proceedings in this case dealing with security plan issues, and for no

'other purpose.

a fn p 1 M $ '.

o ~. w~

6. ' At the" conclusion of thi$ proceeding, I shall account to the

~

Licensing Board or-to a.Comission employee designated by that Board for all papers or other materials (including notes and papers prepared by -

me) containing protected information in =y possession. I may either destroy the papers which do not need to be saved (such as unimportant notes) and certify that action in writing, or for papers which need to be saved (such as transcripts) may deliver them as provided herein.

When I have finished using the protected information they contain, but in no event later than the conclusion of this proceeding ,(including any necessary" appeals),'I shall deliver those papers and materials that were

~

not destroyed to the Licensing Board (or to a Commission employee designated by the Board), for safekeeping during the lifetime of the plant.

7. I make this agreement with the understanding that I will not a . - m .. . .. .r

~

"corrib' orate the ac' curacy or inaccuracy of f riformation obtained outside

. +

, . .. g '

"~

'this procee' ding by using prote'cted information gained through

• participation in matters directly pertaining to Suffolk County's M

.i' _

+ w yc :w ,g. I

_ A

~

m , :3 42.,:; M:' Y. . , . _

, _ g.,[

.4,-. ...

Y e,g , , -

+dw-Di

v4" wfm.;2Q. .f b A&Gi4A WtkW ,-

w.y

'-- " s =~h*W &2l - ht:23f.2t

7. g - e

_e . . . .

,. ,u .w n. m . ._

.. n n ~, , g g .xs, 7. , .4 gya.:- .

1 . . . -. .

u -en g. .

av. _ ., 3 95:

1 1

l security contentions and any hearing that may be held or any further proceedings in this case dealing with security plan issues.

n ,

s Subscribed and sworn to before me this -

8 '

day of , 1984.

SA f

~ . . . . . . _ _ . .

---.-__.._._---<-.31,L, .,

9.E v.m -%a' s -&M .s-y,

, a s. -

, s. , - a

• 4 '

h+- **4'"_.. 7[W p

t.m- ,

4- 2. . . . . ,

l

.* +-

4-

~,

). . N 'f, M.; . 77. =^ h.2 - - C -'

^

', x. _

4 y4 Y t.

I L

,i i *

, Y-

-h -

m ., &- -

W ' h

^'

. s

N $ $ $b h Y i h b t": - ,

A!' Y&'$; S?*G:EWO T " i.

n. .m > -- y "A???kWP - -

s- . .e ,

. ..%,w ie e 4 . A > .. yf  ; .A. J, . .

e, *

~ w ,. = ~ 1M + a - v AaW'?. ^'T'

,X .

k -M \

,NP;1h$y%_T.VgJ , - G y.~$6_'iTV M .%.?".'R' ICHARD C. ROBERTS Suffolk County Police Department Yaphank, New York EDUCATION: .. -

...BA Degree,. Criminal Uustice . -

Southhampton College, Lohg Island University ~

Southampton, New York .

AAS Degree, Police. 5cience State University .

Farmingdale,, New York .'.- ,3 .

FBI National Academy . .

Quantico, Virginia .

Successfully completed several in-service training courses, including Criminal Investigation School, Police Supervisor School and executive development seminars, conducted by my employer, the New York State Chief's of Police Association, the FBI Training Division and the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services.

A g g 4 e-.,,,w

. p'- ,

o

.. EMPLOYMENTi' May 1956 to December 1959 u

Criminal Investigator .

Distr'ict Attorney's Office County of Suffolk, New York Conducted investigations of major crimes and _,

indictable offenses, assisted in' trial prepara-

. . . tion and. performed related investigative activities.

- .~

~... - ,,  ;

January 1,1960 to Present l

r; - ~,_' Inspector .c s .. L " ' ' '

i _

Suffolk. County Police Department Yaphank, New York ~7 m" ~ n .. . .mW Ts?~a meinber 6f a Department with 2,600 sworn officers

~' '

j and 8,00'. civilian employees, have been assigned to supervisory and managerial positions with = progressive levels of responsibility. Performed duties at Squad, Bureau'and Division levels, managing personnel engaged l in patrol' activities and the investigation of'all classes of crime.

9 .

-r .=.y +

.m

~ ,

Performed duties as a Precinct

• Commander, respon'sible.

l -for the performance of 235 sworn ~ officers and other ,

--g - . - - , - . . - , , , . . . , , - .,..----._--g ,w-.,--.m. ,,,.-------.~..-,-.,m, -

. . . . ,,-,,,,-,,,.,,--,,.r-- -,-+--,------,-----,r

kin # _ i., x . .w z V,v x~1-I . ?.Q- _n ._. . <h .;r yMiyJl%.wM. fas .u, e.gcg.;

. fr. -

2 .,a..

- - .% n. .

1.g, . , . - . . ,3 ,

, -=_,  %, '

,.c;~:

w . .. -

t . .); % :rs . 44 P

% f g ,. q;4 g  ; Qg, , ~; L  ;+

-Q - -

j_,

auxiliary police personnel. Area of responsibility .

incl _uded managing law enforcemant activity in an area 170 square miles with -a population of 235,000.- _

Developed sk' ills as a supervisor, planner and aAministrator during twenty-six (26) years as a professional law enfo; cement officer. J

~

Participated in developing and implementing special

~

. tactical' response plans for policing municipal

' facilities and industrial complexes, including'the Shoreh'am Nuclear Power. Station and Parr Meadows Race

• Track . .'.,

Coordinated police and security activities with '

facility and contract security groups representing large shopping center. complexes, industrial sites and government facilities.

Presently assigned as an Inspector with the Office, of the Chief of Patrol, Suffolk County Police

. Department.

AFFILIATIONS:., , _. .~. _

New York State Association of Chiefs of Police i FBI National Academy Associates National Sheriff'.s Association American Society for Industrial Security

• O' F 4

- ,- av

1. ' a b* ** g 3g,, .

'Y , _ ,

• I 1- t, ,,

.A-7s 4s. .

s .

I . "l.' 'a

• 4 g4.,- 'a' *M#' = *?+ ,

q __9 -?p,

^ kl?  :

cr -

n i

't t

. ),'+E e ,

, :.m . . - x; .v~.e 4 .m + -

n . y

. *~ T.'-

• ,e l.

. : y.;tn.m .>,~ m ~- --

,, . . . , n i R *: O . . Y,aa, L Q .[ .nr:;. h & n g,-z., " s .~4ml,wyw - b;_k . y Ot&=p 5'. _ ,jQ 777 ~ -

p Q ~ _. - - -

+n,o y%p<w 4,. gn , s 3.,=

. Nt..l0N$[. c.-  :% , Nb %".} , . . ~ 3 j.L,_ ^. & - ^ ~ ~ ~

. m w , POLI CE ^DEP ARTMENT COUNTY' 0F 'SUFFOLK. NETYORK ~~" ~

aERw,L ccRRES?c. E:.CE

" ' - - -= ' =/3/82

~

TO: Police Commissioner Donald J. Dilworth .

con To:

FRO : Deputy Inspector Philip ~McGuire C.O. Special Patrol Bu.reau, Cc= mand 6400 p>ECT: -RESUME OF SERVICE ,

.NAME Philip McGuire DATE OF BIRTH 'May '15 , 1934 ,, .

ADDRESS 3.2 Thornhedge Road

• Bellport, New' York 11713 .

TELEPHONE # 516-286-0933 The undersigned was appointed to the Babylon Town Police Department on August 1, 1956 and served in the capacity of a patrol officer and desk officer until the inception of the Suffolk County Police Department on Januarf 1, 1960 at which -

time..he.0as assigned.to the First Precinct.

Af ter performing patrol duties and administrative duties at the First Precinct, the undersigned was promoted to Sergeant in October, 1963 and assigned to the Second Precinct.

He was reassigned to the First Precinct during 1965 and then promoted to Lieutenant in January,1969 and performed the duties of a platoon commander, supervising the activities of a l ,

squad of approximate .w 1yx70 men. ,

~ . , , .

In May, 1972, he was promoted to_ Captain and assigned as l .

y' ', - -the Executive Officer of the First Precinct, he continued in W that assignment after having been promoted to Deputy Inspector

~ in January, 1974.

-. a-

'IniJanuary,~1975, "

the undersigned w s assigned as the

- Executive Officer of the Legal and Inspection Bureau. until e February,,1977 when hetwas "

assigned as an assistant to the Chief of. District. >,- ~

In February, 1979, he was assigned as the Ccmmanding Officer I of the Special; Patrol Bureau and remains in that assignment to this date.; .

7, 2 This assignment entails the administration and. direction

"' of the' Emergency' Service-Section, the Aviation Section, the s+- Canine'Section, the Crime Scene Section, and the Courts Section.

e

, . - - -,y _. .-._, _,,e .__y_ . . . , . . - . .,y-.____,_,-,__----..y _ _ - . _ _ _ - , ,_, , , - , _ . , ,.,-,_.-.__.-_-.__.y- _

Tle<.2 ac,.,

p - .

aw .w. n,-G, .u.A

~ .

c

?

% /., u..

m :n.'6 %.. ,, ,

fE- %. .r m-:

~ , - _ W- ny -

4.:1.-

w 9 .

r . J. .u y t' ,

• _ g- , .

7> ,

--.l ye ar S p . 2 .,. y u 5 _. ' - N T-% '

w, . ~~

Police Commissioner Donald J. _. Dilwo'rth'" '5/3/82

The I:mergency Service Section personnel are issued special weapons and equipment and are trained in detection and disposal of explosive devices. This section would have

. a major role in the defense and protection of~a public utility installation within the County.

It is also conceivable tha would be deployed.in a mission ,tofthe this Aviation type. and Canine Sections The undersigned,h.as attended'various schools and seminars dealing with police operations, ethics, investigations and re-lated subjects given by the F.3.I., the IACP, New York City .

Police' Department and the suffolk . County Police Department.

Respecully submitted,

.90 ,

Philip McG' tire , Deputy Inspector Ar 7 C.O. Special Pa*Jol Bureau Command 6400 PMcG:if n e

N e

D 9

se n. "t '.--a fy jf

. 4*

s 4 ,

~

4',W'

- ,4_ g , p e

9

,4 4es

, r .

s + ' 6g

• e e e 9

, , n wm =m..a : . .m. w-.

m~ . ., w_ , -

ym.wne.m pax.

wwn ww=w.7 ,. %- w . 2 .s:.y

~

m. an,. vu n <

m.. . .. .. .

m -~ , . 4..r ce<g Af - Pr,ofessio.n. .al ; Unalifications - of . .. -

n ;s ,.+A. .;n .

n.v

.9 w. . .c , ,.,,.. .. , .

- . + .~k , .2 % M.. s 4{ <J.y~ 7.%C ' ' ' 10 V

~

5.

'$ t .

Od.- -I 'D' --

l t #'+t_'* 'M.J' G p~. nM4 En. -d "e-- e

.F -

BRIAN-MICHAEL'JENKINS

~

Edu atica ,

.. University of. California, Les Angeles , . . .

". 3.A. , 'yine Arts (1962)- - - -

University of Gurnsjuato. ' Mexico (1962) .

(.u :..v ers ity o., ., a n. . .tornia, .ics Ange tes M.A. , History (1954) -

i ,

P University.cf San Carlos, Guare.ssla .

'(1961.-1965) - -

U .ivarsity of Califernit, I.os Angeles Cocpleting disser:ati== i: History (1975--)

Professional Exnerience *

• Director o_f Resesrc'c Prorrs= (1979 := piesent)

Si= e i:s Loceptics in 1c79, Brien Je: kins has di=ec:ed :he o regrs= of The Rand C6rpora-Security and Subest,ienal rica (San,ta M mics, California). Confli,  :, Recognizing the growing i=pertsnce of the.se phe=====r, Rand established the pregrar .

= s:ndr so: en2y terr =ris but civil violence and non-

~~

': rsdiz$1tl =cies of in:ernstic al'ccaf1i== ns =e11.' Tae

~

• r v' .progra=,s gotis are: z= prev =g u.ndersta===g or ,ie phencee:a .. . .. .

ans pua.,1= po,.1:y .,ssues asse: z e., vino :.ne=, .ceveacp ng a

~

body of theory that spans the co==en ele ents of this ser of issues, and providing geverr.sent officials eith a bread u.mder-standing of .:ht: thacry. Tc:: gh its reper:s. he s affs'

.- discussions with governr.e : cfficials e and Icsric.cuy to - -

.Cc gressional co=:i::ees, the p:cgr== bas s1 ready ::de consid-erable pregres: in seesing t'esa goals.

r,:x;.o .  ; vt~

m  :: - -  ; ,, , ,

.,. , pas prog %...ra= d . -sure :.or; .y.r ..,- ..e.ut=s

.s resps:si,o ,ie . , rer coordinst-

'- ~

e.

,m.ting all research projects, acting as ;1iaisos eith the sysns=r- -

ng agescies. .nandin. . eg research fr.nc.s, recti =g p.eed..:.:.ncs ena

(  ; - - 9udgets. ==nitoring the progress andicuality of verk. recruit.-

. 'ing res earch ~ stzfi, a=d representim.e .th: p r.o. g.re.= _r e the ,edia. *

,[ > 4l.. 9 .a .

, Associe:e Det> art:inf Zend (1976-1950) '. * '

b2

- ^As Associate Eead of Tne. Rand Corporaticr.'s Social Science ..o_

~

s >

Depart =en:, Mr. Jenkins cas resp::sible for ad:inistrz:ive .

du:Ics that ca::ied out depar .nental policies, par-icu2 arly as Jahey concerned the hiring, pro. crion, and personnel can:ge=ect of social sedence researchers verhing fer prog: =s in the Nitional Security Research Divisien. His dutie's included a::s=ging and cceducting perfere:nce appraisals and technical

.m 7 ., m reviews _' of re;>=rts , allocating f unds .f er caterial and ::avel ,

. 2 r:m= ~.g e.= e nt s.. 22, . coordina::..ng depar =-e t p:cgra: acterse-tiens.

• l 4

4t*

> n ,7,qs. . ; g:; gr._ ,4 4 g# .

y~-*

/%y D

, _. ,^

.Q ' D'7 :g .f

'v; .- i w*7 . i ~

c d . ,_.. NND.'. . . , _ ' C, 9, Mr._ -.N .;

- Cc-.fcenen Dirne or .(legay L .

• m. . r- ~

e

. ,,s. - . . . .

- . d .an . 5.i , .

..t. ,y-

-_ / mwqw , .

.w . . . .

~ -'

.In Saptachkri1950,4r=Ja.dtihs ' ciirtetcui and-coerdinnc I=:ernatio:a1 Cenferen:e en Terrorise and Ic::-kvel Conflict, ..

hested by The F.and Corp: ration and spensered by the Depar:.-

=t=:s of 5:ste, Justice, and hergy. The pu.p se of the conference cas to review what was 1 earned about the phenerenon of terroris= in the 1970s and to explore its likely fut.nre i course. Based on his research c terrorise and his pcr icipa- i tien in cera than a decen' inter =ational ce=ferences on the subject, he direc:.ed prepa. ration of the agenda, including dis-cussion :opics for the seminar groups and scenaries IHefor sisothe siculaticas 'In which the cbnferees participated.

cosrdinated all aspects of ths' conference and organized the results of the seeinsrs and si=ulandens in:o a report to be and

... -- . . .. . . is s u e d in 19 51.

The conference was attended by scrernst=:

military officiais, corporate execu:ives, and scholars fren 13

. naticas and .th_e... Uni..t.ed Sra es . ..

I t

. Research P-oi==

Leeder (1972 to present)

~

h in: crests vere

. Prior ,tc 1972, ".r. 7e'niins' nnjer researcprimarily the car in Indo-I.zi'in L=cdics and Southeast Asit,

'- china.

Since 1972, Mr. - Jeru. ins has engaged in research, pub-lication, and public dialogue on terrorism and other for=s of Icc-level c==flic that threaten na:.ional security and inter-Ec has acted as principal investiga:ce or national stability.

projen: leader ci nunerous Rand studies sponsored by various A= rang these projects have been:

a .,gova:2.=ent agencies. . .

• A stucy ef the- policy ,and tscries for dealing with politi-cal kidnapings and other crreris -crested hostage situatic=s.

> . . . . This study exasined the .probles, of hos. cage seizures, recen-s:ructing selected .csses in detail, evaluating alterns:ive '

policies, and =3 king reco:=endations for policy of Scare andand bargainihg the

- - +

rac: des. It was sponscred by the Depar:nsn -

-- Defense Advanced Research Project Agency (1972-1976).

x

• An. -.examinatica

..a.

of. current trends and potentialities in -

(

-- in:ediE:ichal terrorise, includin,g nuclear cri=e (Sponsors:~ .

• Tae Departnent of Sta:e and th'e -1.av hic 7c'e= ~ """ enc ' ' Assis:ance *

( -Administration, 1976-1977). ,.,

ne laws, jui8.icial"deci-1 - _e An ex=N ica.cf Ibe guidelines effects tha: ' nave on tuvast.igazion, .c

- - - S -- -

.sions,:and depstre*nts)

~

L

• preventios,' and prosecution cf(Sponscr: terrorist Tne andI.sv reisted criminal Eferce=an:

~

. q ac:ivr.:Ie5 in the L*nited 5:stes <sf V Assistance Ad=inis' ration, 1979-1980).

A study :o reni:=r terrorist and other cricinal' ac:ivities Judics:: ens of increased danger to nuclear vespcas and freilities JSpessor': ~ce Deftas,e NucIcar A5ency,1979-1950).

'ic:

i l

~

4 X w.ps. . x. . ~q ,.,

~ . .

,, Y .r>

.;.o.. . . i .-n

• 5..  ; y.n.a.,<

... . <s'-p.

. . ..:. ~.. . . w. . n. -. 7:4.e. p -: m.j p...: n. m.w:

p ums r.m ~ :,.. c...q,n 1.t m.. . . . v n.

'r . y .. ..yc.. m.v u..-. -. , _ -

. . + 2. p; . . , 4. 4. f ., m, ,n .n.

4 gg.

..;. . p. .

wf;; .

. ,49 . s u,.

- a m

.d. .f o i crudy cf tha 1975 =ilithry collapn cf South Viar=a= .

.- e- b: sed:m e.xta.siva inforvici.s of der q S=uth Vietnarese cill ~ ..;

tary ec=anders and senior civilien efficials (Sp=nser: Ace Depar: cent of Defense, 1977-197S).

• An extended exa=ination of -he passible rc:ivations, resources, dedication, skills, and likely actions of pot.ential terrorist a.nd other cr-;=inal adversaries ei ~d.5. nuclear pro-grae:s, includes censideration of the m:al processes of indi- '

vidual terrorists and groups to discever what characteristics ,

and vulnerabilities they have tha =igh: help security i .

planners defend against various possible for=s of assauld on nuclect facill:ies (Sponsor: Sandia laborateries , 1975-1950). '.,7. .

C -

c. -

• A s:udy of the experiences and concer=s of U.S. corpora-  ?;[

tions in high-level terroris: environ =<=:s abroad, illustra:- ,

ing the problers th.cy and t. heir representarives have f aced and .,

are likely to fece in the future (Spcaser: Tce Deper:. cent of C a rce, 1979-1980).

• A study of terroris: in the U=ited St.z:es , i=cluding iden- 7 ~.

tification of existini groups in the country schose r. :ivatiens and capabilities =ight cens;itute cri=inal and ter:0rist 2'.-

threats (Sponsor: Tne Etnd Oc pors .ica,19EO). ,,'.

s.: -. .

Censultant (1968 to presen:) p ~ ..

, . -.e -

Mr. Ja * *,e acte _ as censultant to Tne Resd Corpora. tic: while d ',. -

he was a ce=ber of the Long-Range ?lanni=g Task Group, MACV, -

y -

Readquarters, Saigon (1963-1569) . He is preset:ly c::sultss: '

to the Nuclear. Regulatory Co=rission.

. . i .

- --M-Meer c.-Sm4f, c. -4'A62.e.I.ME.)_- - . . . _ . . . . _ _ _ , _ , _ _ _ _ _ _ _ , . __

Assigneents ,c Co==issioned as I.ieu er. ant in the A=y Reserve, 1962 Eeper:ed for active.du y, 1966 ... .-

Served with the 7th Special Forces Group i= the Do inican Republic,19e,o.

Pre =cted to Captain, 1967 Served with the 5th Special Services Or:dp in Vierne=, 1966-1967 Left active duty, 196S Special Service and Training Paratreeper School'~^~-

C "e=ber of Special yorces (Green 3erets)

• Defense Language Institute at Monterey (Vietna=ese)

I "O ,9 g

• em y

3 f g

• W e . $ $ .

.x y~ gp. _ - . w ,- , . . , ._.

.{g..p n .f., 3 ; 9.g g ...._.-..m _,

4

- ". - . . . , . , [

v-

.V -. > w =. .

. "u . .

?- 47.x . , . ~ .

u.

e....,- . -

---s - .

i

.Prrticinatien _in International Ccnferences and 'Nerotinzions .

?.r. 'Jehkins has been aneng those instrnsenta-1 in creating- an ..

- internatienal ce=: unity of sebola.rs, cilitary leaders , and l goverm:ent officials conceined with understanding and resp:nd-

.ing to terrords: and c:her for=s of subnations1 conflict. He has participated in c,any interns:ional conferences, including:

The Cenicrence on Resesrch Strategies for the Study of

.Inte==a:ional Po'litical Terror, ism (Evian, France, 1 ,

.May 1977) ,%

The International Scientific Conference on Terroris= ,

(Berlin, Novenber 197S) ,

Tne International Serina.r on Proble=s in Poli:ical Terroris= and Counter-Terroriac (Tel Aviv, July 1979)

In Sove ber 1960, he was the on3y Ancrican participan: a: the Council of Europe's Conference en the Defence of Deoacracy Agains: Terrorism in Enrope: Tasks sad ?roblens . The Council's Political Af f airs Co--i :ee invited hi= as an expe_:

~

to speak on "Public Rascriens to Terrorist."

Mr. 3entins has also served as a =eEber of the t'.S. delega-

- - : ions i= official bi-lateral talks with France, the United ung=o=, ang ganegn.

Professienal Or anizations/!ionors Fulbrigh: Tellowship, University of Sa=. Carlos,' G:atecsla (196".) ,

Research Grarte Fellowship, Pan. Arerican Union of the Org2niss:ics of Americzn Sta es, Guace=ala (1965)

Recipient of Ivo Bronze Stars and a Vietnar.ese Cross of Gallantry

- - ~

(1966)

Recipient. of the Ar=y's. highest award for Outstanding Civilian "

C Service, awarded.ior service on the Planni=g Group (.T.'+-(1971) r

m. .

Publications Ecbassi.es_ Under Siege:

_A Revie.I _o_f.1,5 E=hassv

_ - Takeovers, E-1980, The Rand Corporation, R-2651-EC, forthco:ing. ' "

. The. Tall of. South Vietna=: State =ents br Viet=ceese Milirarr and .

~

Civilian Leaders, Crane, Russak & Conpany, New York, 1930 (cosu-i nored).

Terrorfs= in the United States, The Rand Corporation. P-6' 7/+, .May

~ '

..1960. .

.ar e me eng

& r _

. g ee s ,

. . . . 1 M' .T*Murs2.%Y. :c;==num.m.z 9s *.ns~:ny:v.aesw- =' ';* '

m s.m,. m ay. O f ~' K f.Ll.%w$.

f. g.q;s7 g:.m,. w :: a.,y.u4,a.gq M. .g n@.. i-XL (.%.s  %. -

e, n.

n -

.~,

m, .c. yn n-.

..s qc.

ee>

. c. .

.a gs,

_s

(~.

.. u

.., w;, .n i--c..

V a.. ::n ,_.w 3- . .. _ . x,a.p m:;g -

s_,.

m-; .. .-

,u. 4' -

P'N * *Mo:Yrstions and ?ossible Actiens of Petential Cricinal Adverstries .

of U.S. Nuclear Procra=s , Tne RanTCorpora:ic=, R-2.554-SL, Februar.v "'

1980; . Executive Su=.s v, R-2550-SL/1, February 1960 (cosurhered).

The Censecuences of Suelear Terrorise, Tne Rend Cerperati=n, P-62sa, .-- August 19f9. -

The Terroristi,lindse: and Terrorist ?,ecis '-ninc: Teo Areas M .

Iznorance,._Ane aano Corpora: ion, P,-c3.*. 0, , s.une 19.,9. e s w"w. , _ , , .n ~

.y.,,.  ; . um - - ..+ -

x +u. . ;% . .

\ .

International 2errorise: Trends and Potentia 11:tes, Tne Rand Cer-

- poracics, P.-6217, ?.'ay 1976.. ,.

.. . .. . A : rib.utes of ?ctential Cri=inal .A._d.v_ersaries _ofNuclear

. .U.S_. ,

Progra=s; Tne Re.nd Corporation, R-2225-SL, February 1978 (ccau- - - - - ..-

tbcred).

N bered Ifves: So e S:sristical Observations fro:: 77

.. ---...Internatien 1 E=s:sge Incidents ,. T..he R..and._C::v.e..r_s..t. i. e. n,...P-39.05. ,.. July. -

1977.

.U 5_, .

Precura:lon _for Tu:ure Lev.:-Level Conflier, Tne Rand Corpora-tics, P-5530, July 1977 (coautbared).

ne Poten:ial for Nuclear Terrorise, The Rand Corpora ice, P-5576,

??ay 1977. .

. - . . , s. . - w~ <

. Attributes for Perential f.dversaries to U.S. Nuclear Prorrs=s, Tre

.. ...Eand.. Corporation, R-2225-SL, October 1977. . . j Hostage' Survival: .*

Sm== Prelicisa v Obseivations, ne Rand Corpora-  ;~

tion, P-5627, Ap:dl 1975.

trill Terrerists Go Naclear7, Califernie Se=inar en Ar _s Con:rcI and Foreigs Policy, October 1975. ".

. .. 2nw - .- "i .

4- '

'- ~

2

+ : Cinte:-.arienal Terreris=i' ~ A Chrenoiers , '. . .1963-1974, one nand Cor- .

. , ,, pore:lon, R-1597-DOS-ARPA, April 1975.~

.- .m . . ..:2-g g --e . -

r

'Inte naticnal'Terroris=:- 1 Ner 'i:>de of Conflict, Crescent. Publica-t:o=s -January 19 o .

- " e b.

Y f. . ; , W,

,w '

' 14 4

". .Eith Technolorv. Terrorise: Tne .I=o_se.:. of New Technol. ore on . - -- .

-Loe-Level Y:osence, 4ae Rand Corporation, P-5339, January 1975. -

, =  :.e. ,

n.w

, M .. M . w . rze.

A-> ~ -: n .

.+ +  %. '

^

.S.hould Cercerations _3__s .P..re..v. ented frc .Paving Kanso=7, Tne Rand Cor-poration, P-5291, Septe=ber 1971.. .

International Terrorise: A Ne.: Kind of Verfere, Tae- Rand Corpora- as tion, ?-5261, June 1974 -

.~.2, a.y... -

, . , -  % . . ::= .. . s v e .w. u.n . -w.u n a .. W m . . .:.; .- ..

.c....... ...

.r....,~..

-r e x.

- Y l

> ..s ,. . u., . . :::= . . .

r. : x ::. m .. ..a -mw , - -

. . ~

m y,-mm ,_ _

_n.{+ ,n, m_ m ,c:a.e.a.py-- - w in_m. _.. - , _ . ,9 u.

y ..z , .

.x_;; .. x ,x;+ y g ,,,,_.,A; .-._-.y ~,:y  : .c,.s ,:

4

,_..m . _. .

m

~, .

• . _m ., , s: n .

> ,;,' - '?- ..;371disra vc:=us .Ge.=en:l .Jh >.2.ellenae. nf I*rban Guerrilla Larf2:6-~

. ~ . "-

' ' *. ' ' " Tns Rand Corporation,7-3282, . March 1974

- An Urban Straterv for Guerrillas and Gover=ents, Tne Rand Corpora-tion, P-4670/1, Augus: 1972.

"3 Reure for the Insrv te Esceoe" -- Ranoi's vie: cf the Ceasefire .

We Rand Corpora:ica, P-3012, .r.ay 1973. .

Giap and the Seventh- 5=n, Tae Rand Corpsratic=, P-l.551,1972. -

- . .? r,. I m Vhe the _N_ orth 1*ietna=ese V_ill Keee Tichti:2, Tne Eend Corporation, P-4395-1, 1972. . - (

l

~

Tne Enchanceable War, Tne Rand Corpernien, E-6275-2, November 1970.

\

\

i

. 4

. i

~ -

.:n *

' ' " ~

., $5#-

['. .

\

t 1

1

.g ,

+..

2. .._ ,

r .

r -

9

. e, r .

. 4 N.: :- c.% : >cc ,v_ v.; .v .;..<m ruuv_e .. . . c . .<.w:r. .t.wr.:.;c3 c.re .,.,.e.: . . :.r.m  : n.,.,: c,: us.;.::v <

s. w; a. a.. ,, .w __,,/,

. , w_ms_ ei ss,a-rser_

,.~n..., -

b... .

o . ,~ ,- ,

' . ;& N .44..J e tyk *g d*wt.MtWiSs.A ' ...a;?, ' ,

.. Y' ' 4 * ' -UW r ., s k.

n .- ..  % %% 'k ,: $e '

+-r

,c.'.,,, 11 Lac:;y T ano . N,,, - / .

y; , . .

a. '.a s?. S cr.amento;,'

~

95 821 /'r- ' - < s . . .ce-s r.&E iN . h. .. p m a

' Phon.e: '(California

~ "

916) ~, .4S8-3521 ~ ~ '

~ Home d

- , 1- ,

Profsssional Excerience: -

1976 - 2/27/80 -

Special Agent in Charge,- Federal Bureau of Invastigition,, Sacramento, California. )

Direction and managenent' of FBI ad-ivity in 34 of the 58 counties l of California, operating-through the Central Sacranento Office and  ;

9 auxiliary offices.

4 _ _ x

( ,

~

Eight. months of 1976 -- Inspector, FBI Headquarters, Washington, D. C.

m 14 months 1975-76 ' -- Assistant Special' Agent in Charge, m^

Federal Bureau of Investigation Salt Lake City Division f

-- Supervisor, FBI Eeadquarters, Washington, D. C.

1969l- 1975 Funcf.icns were in ad=inistration and public relations, and included

- me'eting with Government officials, media, dignataries and the public; preparation of scripts, articles, speeches, and research and FBI official correspondence. Functions included supervision of 250 jersonnel .- j,, _.- - -

/ . .

x ' i

. ,- ,~.

1955 1969 -- Special Agent / investigator, F3I, Illinois, Maryland and Delawart Junior Of ficer, United States Air Force

~

1952 - 1954 -

M. .:, .- a. ~w - .. .

s.~[

• N, ' ' '

,,:a# # -  ; -<

'1950 - 1952 - Guest Relations, National Broadc.asting Company,

. . -:D New York. City & a y.

.-- 1 -

1950. - 19 52, (concurrent) ' -- Broadcaster, WFUV Radio, New York, N. Y.

7 w- ..

's, General' service announcer, including l-

.7 - -

? news and public interest programs.

. . . _ 1b ... . ~'1 .. ,g,g;gr.

.. , ~ .

l r I

a

' *I

-d

'Y'A e

.f g- t. f & ys .M

~ N [fi f L ,. . .

L, ,

e f s

./

?

t l

..e RICHARD Ir MEITE ,rp% W,im 99:g m m m., a.. , ~.,_.. ar m A - w+m - - 4Kgh..t y - .-

i we w . .

~ -

+  ;,' .  ; ,

. m?['.,% ditional Sccurity lxocrience:

- . , - - ,_ .- ,. , A . -w.-ws- -

41) ~ During"25 years of service in $3.,,,,~e FBI, actively engaged in

~

numerous security, radical, espionage and sabotage investiga-tions as the case agent, assisting agent, supervisor and observer.

2) From 1962 to 1969, was the liaison FBI Agent with the National

• Security Agency.

3) From 1972 to 1975, was a Supervisor in the Files and Cermunica-tions Division of FBI. Headquarters which maintained the I

criminal and securitylfilesifgr.the FBI.

4) From 1975 to mid-1976, was the-Assistant Special Agent in i Charge of the Salt Lake City _ Division and was pr h ily responsible for supervising all the security investigations '

in the State of Utah.

5) In 1971 and 1976, was an Inspector's Aide and Inspector, respectively, and one prinary responsibility was to inspect a large nu=ber of FBI Field Offices to ensure their security

. cases were being properly handled.

6) As an Inspector, Assistant Special Agent in Charge, and Special l . Agent-in. Charge, was actively engaged in the FBI's " Crime Resistance Program" whereby the FBI would conduct surveys to i determine whether Government and. commercial facilities were secure from theft, sabotage, espionage and radical interference.

While Special Agent in Charge of the Sacramento Division,

. supervised this program directly. .

7) While Special Agent in Charge of the Sacramento Division, was responsible for all security matters in 36 of the 58 counties

, in the State of California.

1 i 8) Prepared emergency plans for'the F3I and participated in emergency exercises and SWAT exercises pertaining to emergency I situations.

51E s ~r = # .EW- + . >

! Education: .y 4

' - 'T ,

i ^

-r

, _ University of Baltimore, Baltimore, Maryland --

ABA Degree in "

i . Accounting - First Honor Graduate

• t l Fordham University,"New York, New. York -

AB in Communication Arts.

3

~

.+ , .

, Prior NRC Testimonyi Testified on behalf of the Honorable Edmund G. Brown, Jr.,

! Governor of the State of California, as expert witness on i security matters in the Diablo Canyon (Docket Nos. 50-275, 50-323) proceeding, November 1980.

x ._

- a 'e .

- - - - - - - -----.-.--g9 _- --- . . - - - - - - - - - . - --w 9g ,q-, m - , - . - + g- a es- w -m-e--w-re--q-p-g- y + y y,er----*-T1ex-y

.gg Ygkw R a d Q :; i .3 f f .g ;~; g @ g?_a.5 KT_3..: 3, 3wyn. .. ,= 3. w ,_, x , 4, 4.sy 9

p tN e.

%+. 2.*ir  : ~ . N]. p[' , , .

.g% ..

_, , y ,

47-

. . . m. 7

.~ ~

A $.,i. m.5N.d)g [50 ~

,I

. POL.m.CE.,..DEPARTHENT.

.~.w y y ..,m -u C_.0UNTYg0F . - -

SUf 7 p u~

ma FDLK; NEW YORK_

-. ai. c .

INTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE

-TO: Deputy Inspecto'r Philip McGuire DATE: 5/3/82 C.O. Special. Patrol Bureau, Command 6400 .~

FROM: Lt. Thomas P. Co.mpitello. CDPY TO:

C.O. Emergency Service Section, Command 6450 Commissioner D. Dilwcr~

llBJ E CT : RESUME , ,

% ~ . . m. S h -

a,,* _

\

.-NAME - . Thomas,P.Compibello

. ADDRESS - 28 Riverview Avenue '

11769-

.Oakdale, New York DATE OF' BIRTH - Nov'mber e 23, 1935 SOCIAL SECURITY-t' 130-26-1560 MILITARY SERVICE - U.S. Army November 1954 to November 1956

- - Service 4U551331166 EDUCATION - Amityville<High School . 1949 - 1953 N.Y. Institute of Technology - B.S. Criminal Justice a

DATE OF. APPOINTMENT.- July 1, 1957 .,

DATE OF RANK -

Sergeant - October, 1963

- Lieutenant - July, 1971 PRESENT ASSIGNMENT - June, 1980 - Emergency Service Section as Commanding Officer JOB RELATED TRAINING

=

RLL July,'- v.

M lz :' a v. '-e ..

September;"1977'- F.B.I.' National Academy - 110th Session . ,

~ ' '

. : ,L . , . ~ , .. . 4 October, ~~1980 - U.S. ' Army Hazardous Devi %- s School (Bomb) 'Redstone

)

Arsenal,L Hu t:sville, Alabama - Certific ti* T as bomb technician yq February, 1981 -1. Hazardous. Materials a, n ;eral Emergency ,

Training Center, Emmitsburg, Md,.

.a

1. January,11981; ,Domb' Squad Commanders Seminar, F.B.I. Academy, _.

Quantico,'Va. ,.

June, 1981 - Hazardous Materials II, Federal Dnergency Training Center, Emmitsburg, Md. ,

January, 1982 - Bomb Squad Commanders Seminar, F.B.I. National i;= ~, Academy,,Quantico,-Va. .  :-. s+

4 N --

p Respectfully' submitted, M k e ~p % /.x A k W

~ Thomas P. Comnitello, Lt.

' 6! #.- A < c' d /, (' . o 6Fec@rM$LService Section j

.g.#p2 =..

..,. .q py. .p .w - 13:3. -

3 , . 41g yq.gy ~4. ~ -3 ..

a3

% m um,;,,,,yon _

2-3w- y^. _

- x y

,c

,.g...w-

- :% 3,,5,., 4 3_ ,,_,,,,,4;g (;

% g g

..m p ;; ,

. ww,y.. . ,gy zg

. g. = u _xp .n m .

.n. w- ev..n.., DA.n,: n scrn: uecember

- . a,.. ..,a su.

> AFctrzec 2 c n. .. .:ccren

-- .Eccellen: Eecith S'. ISOs,Zbs.

' ^

Ei]CATICi?: . Ihnhattan Coilece .

2.3.A. in\ Economics, June 23 1962 M.S. in ticr.cgemen:. September 1.1979 Certificfte.frcm the ucran Institute fcr the Study of

??OFESSIOW.L ^ T?). IRING: ,

Juvenite De.lin.~.aencyI St. Lc.: ence University: June 22EE Certificate in Narcotic Lc:: Enforcement, Tne U.S. Dept.

of Justice, Druc Enforcement A6rtinistrct *cn, March 1975-Gr~' mte. F.B.I. Ectienci Accie L, thrch 1975 (200th Session) .

Certificates frcm varicus Ecu Enforcement Schcois

. sponsored b.u, the Su.'. .'olk Count? Police Depcr: men:.

The Neu fork State Chiefs of ?clice Assoc *c: ion.

.Jhe Federci Eurecu of, Investigation, cri che American

Academy for ? ciessionci Lau Enforcement.

E'2LO!!!E'.": Suffcik County Police Department. !cohcnh Avenue.

~

icohank.Rev Icrk Li950 June 19di - October 196S ?c_trolm_an: Perfor-ed cLis c' zhe duties o.f this ;csi icn includinc .s'act pc:rci. desk dutu cri Sec:cr Car Assign- -

ments.

,w

- ^ Cc cher 1555 - Januar~y 1957 O:Tietective: Juvenite Aid 3urecu : '2esyc'sible n 'f.cr inves:-

C

.- n.c..cr nes snvosv n.c:. ersons uncer ne c.ce c s ers...cre.scrinc cases' 'cr presen don in idiu. Ccur:.

.~ -

- w w .'  %,s.c.c . .

+ . w, . ,

Lard advisinc the Ccunty A::crnev cn the disocsiticn -

of

~~. - - -

- :nese cases. Assc resycnsi.06es ,or per;.casc nspec::cn

. ,.g cf public places frecuented by ycung pecpie (Licensai

.r&

4 h~i?remises, ?oci Eciis, etc.} cri tching enfcrce en

' action chen 1.'crranted.

u . y w .- . .

tective: Fifth Scuad - Responsibie fcr the investigc:ie

. .icnuary:22S7 : thrch 19ESl

- ~ , *

• of cil felonies and cericin misdemeanors cu.....::ted uichin the crea of the Fifth Prec*nct. Du:ies included sching statements from compicincnts, defendants cri vitnesses c ave as ceve . sn.c ecas> concuct,.ng cr:me scene searcnes making crrests sand cre.varinc caser <'or Grand Ju.ry .preser

'" ^

tation.

?, . -

f ~

w ,

.e. L. _. . . .

' netective: . Crininci Inteiligence Sc m', (A 22 =enber unit

. :.l' arch 1252 - 'Acril 1960 ~

~is~igned c to the cf. fice c'..the Chie'. of :etectives) -

?espons.. c le :fcr :ne ccm: s c .cc:a

.. .- .ctson anc ancius. .

ccncern.n; :ne n*.s:cr:es ass cza:es. .- cue ~en:s 2:c.

cf perscns :':::n cr ns:cc:ed to : cue can';ec:icnc ::i:1.

a.a - ~. c- -

s. .

.:.. ~

. .. .h : ocge ,,

• W ~ %; diW.?.u.,,.L . '

,s

.. ,. . ., DP -

J '"

.,y .. - .,

.s. ..n-  : ,. + m m . .. - . 1 .

& .. Sip 2C.

N grit ~'T: 59 scnt 'd > &.-y. h t:ctiv3 Cri=i'~~~

Diligence' S:uci' , -

.u: es .notucc.,Oos:.:::. - -

cn:. e:.e t :n..c su: .:e ,:.cr.:e .

as .;e.,

. e::ensive rep::: uritin:. ..

.  :: c. css.:.c.s:n vith other Feder:2. S'.::2. Ci:y and ~:::i Lc: Enf::ce-ment fcencies.

Aprit L2S9 - March 2272 Sercecnt: Fifth ?:ecina: - Du:ies included the direc: ... . . . .

supervicicn o,r 0 .vo..i. ce o.r., cers as ::-~~.ec :c .icot an:

- - matc pctrci in a 25 scucre mile crea; evclu::ing the . . .

perfor=cnces og. :n, ese o,;..;cers, s enyorc:.ng :ne Depc : er.:s

- a- -

Edles 'cri .?rocedures and ass:.c:ing control of police . . . .

. o.verc h.ons cur:.nc. a .c:.ven : cur oi cu. unen recurre:

to do so.. .

Varch 1972 - M:u 1972 . .

Detective Sercec_nt_: .iuvenile Aid 3arecu ~- Recycnsible for assionino cnd su=ervisina  : . .- 2 detectives in..a..tcur o>' cut.u. n. c.-cw....an: :::.tn. coun u.,-:::.ca respons .= d. 'u. .

Dudes _ included e= tensive report uritinc., evciu Mon .

of. personnel cri revieu o.f cil ?cdiu Ccur -

Cases ce cre su = sston to tam .s.u Ccart.

Fay 1972 - Jcr:acr.u 2374 Lieut. enc.nt: :hird Frecinct - Over cil respons **~*iitu

' or c Pictocn consistinc c.? C Sergeants cri 72 Police Officers. Du:ies in:Luded ass *gn:sent of cii personnai duris.~ c tour oi dutu. insvectinc versc7:nei fc fi: ness - - -

for ,.tu, n=nc . nc c .us,dcn cc=vic .n

. ts and ass:..-inc:

res; .msshtis.ty fc~ tne coerc,i.c pc:.:.ce =:.ss .cn :n :ne cosence c,, :ne Cv.....:nc. ..nc 0;. ..;:.:e: c: ::ecut .ve C,,.:..:cer.

+ .

a Januar.u 2974 - June 2276 Detective Lieutenant: Ecreadc Sc.uci - E:ecu:ive O.f.fice: .

o . :ne nz:. . .. .. . -.

.~esycnsso e .rcr n=.co%.c crug enJ cresmen:

n .m.u,,,o s t.r. Coun'g. su=. es sn :.ucec supery s.. ne seven . .

Detec%.ve ergeants an: .:....:. :u. ve:sc::.ves oc cn:. cu c.-

nree o?f:,.ce locations; c::ensive report :.::iting, review of Gr:r.d Jury Cases and car.suitaticn with mc~.bers

+ o.ss,.rne.y t.e. .es cc. .., cn y..c.. f...+,.

• n t:: .-

0,e +ne . .12s +,,:. .r . .. ,. ..g -;.,.e

~

Eurs.n tnss ass c.r.:ent ass s ec :n tn.e .Tcr.::.cr. or :ne

' ~ ' Long Isicri Dru.c En;' cree =en: Tcsk Fcice, a cc:per:Mue effort of the Drug Er. force =en: Ai--inis:r: tion. ..

Eev !::;;

~ -  :. S' ate Po..ssce, Ecsscu cn. Su~.. ..s . o ar. Ccunt.u _-o t sce pe.rc::-

- ments cri che District A:'c ney 's cf both counties

, ' ~ .

.to in'iitr:tc cni neu::alize high level drug cper: M cns

.on LAMc .: sl.Cna.

=

m.

January 2579 Dete::ive Lieuten n_:: - Cw....:nd*ng Officer Pers:nnei . .

.hne_s527E _ .. .. .

Bureau (n'emo:ec :o C ::c..n un le .n n1.s .=cs. Mon .n y". --

~

February 1977) - Repcrting := c Deputu Chief Inspec'er. -

. - Tne respons=.. = 1:.n.es of in:.s possucn :ncluc. d e A.~. . n.n:.s-trative Con rol of the 7.:.ccess ng of cii police and c vs tan erl: .umen' cr. .at. scants > .cre.scra:icn cri certi.r...-

cation of pcyrolls for a 3,000 member Depc:::ent, as t ett as commari responsibii*ty for the D-::icuge Reic:icn 1

t - Uns.: (Mec. ..cas :vciu: %cn Uns.' .:o t.n nsu :utec cur ng t

mu tenure) .The Personnet Investiga icn. Unit cri 'he . . .

"- C:ncata .n 's Uns.e. C'.ner cu n.es .ncluc.ec . is. .c son anc

~

Coo'rdination with the Ccunty icycrtment so' Civi: Servi:s The County E:ecu'ive 's Budge: C".' s ice cs ueli cs :he County rep:::.cn' cf Perscr.v.e* cri L:: r =eic'i:ns.

s. . . . . .. .. . . . .

e> g; .Q p JL '

., , R., .. .,,. f-

."'.,a,ue,.e.m;9*,{i[_, - s - m ~ .gs .m.s.A. -}Q.q

, Z.g.

-mx'.g

.pt.f/e.....s

• p. ; . ,.

_,p.

v

.g --m . . .p

. . ,~ - ~ u. ~ .. :e A

3-

' . . Tcga 3 - . - -. . , 4 u.

g::-y = a m : w. a;:. p t  : .yp .: 7,;;;;; 4 . g g n: a., r .. m gy; January 1979 to . January 1981 Decutv Inspector: Executive Officer of

. the Third Prec.inct - Overall Administrative-responsibility for a unit consisting ~of 257 sworn and 9 civilian persennel as well as 50 School Crossing Guards in an area with a population approaching 250,000. <

. . Duties include enforcement of internal

_.i dipcipline as well as evaluating the overall need for pol _ ice services and allocating resources to accomplish the police mission.

On site inspection of personnel, frequent liaison with Town and County officials, cooperation with Civic Leaders and-utili-

- zati'on' of Cc=munity resources are required.

January 1981 to Pres nt Inspector: Commanding Officer of the Sixth Precinct - Duties consist of exer-cising control over all members of my, Command. I am held responsible for the acccmplishment of the police mission through the effective administration and operation of my Cc.: mand including, but-not limited to, deployment of personnel, a discipline and efficiency, departmental

- property and equipment, comlaint.investi-

" gation, procedure. compliance, inspection,

• - etc. .

~

TEACHING EXPERIENCE: State University of New York A & T School at Farmingdale September 1971 to Present I have served as an Adjunct Instructor and Assistant Professor. In addition I have instructed periodically at the Suffolk

. _ m-

, .;- ~ -

County Community College since January;1976.

Areas of Experience include : Introduction to Law Enforcement, ~ Police ' Administration ,

Juvenile Delinquency, Criminal Invest.I.gatien and History of Law Enforcement and Criminal

'* g.-

4- n

- Justice.

~

~

MEMBERSHIPS: American Association of University Professes

. ,w

~

, Suffolk County Police Benevolent. Association s

- Suffolk County Detectives Association-(Past Financial Secretary and Treasurer)

Suffolk County Superior Officers Associatice Police Holy Name Society of Suffolk County i

r (Past Vice-President and President) ,

American Association for Professional Law

- Enforcement F.B.I.' National Academy Associates . -

- International Association of Chiefs of Poli New York State Association of Chiefs of Pol Patchogue Council 725 Knights of Columbus Sayville Yacht Club

a. x p :2 w%g . .eny _ s , ,-

- i' p.. g% ws .- sq;7:

m*pm p t gg r_c u: cwsap::g:

. aam e} _ _ A;tp;_~

jg m,y, l

o- .

3;. ,.

&YRg;; -

,-[

.. ~.

. . - ,y ,

33 _ , .

7 , , .3 -

MMhy,h %(-

k

,"h M p' a vN ,, d w # d i=ce x Resume of :- Michael J. Turano, Jr.. .

r I

PERSot4AL DATA: ,,

. Born: November 17, 1931 Married: Wife, Margaret

.. J .r ;. .g - 4@w ' % .

• Chi).dren:: Laura, Mich,ae1, Jeffrey,

" *? Richard and Scott -

EDUCATION: . .

Bachel'or of Science Degree in -Criminal Justice /Behavorial Science from New

- YorkeInstitute of Technoloev, Old

. West, bury, New York

• Graduate - F.B.I. National Academy, December 1976 (107th Session)

Certificates from various Law Enforce-

,, y'~ _.

ment Schools, Training Sessions and Seminars:

~

^

Suffolk County Police Department, Municipal Police Training Council, New 4 York City Police Department, Suffolk.

a County Executive Department, Federal Bureau of Investication John , Jav Collece ,

United States Civil Service Commissien ~

• State University of New York, United States Food & Drug Administration, New York State Traffic Safety Council, Tri-State Organized Crime Council, New York

, State Chiefs of Police Association.

s . EMPLOYMENT: " ;g - Q g y -

7

.m .JJune:1956~- December 91 59. m-r:- Smithtown. Police Department ...

, Patrolman: Performed various duties.in this capacity le foot patrol, desk duty,

• ; f" w 'iC. motor, patrol, etc. >

'Januarv ~1, 1960.- ,

NOTE: As a result of a public referandum

,* five _{5) Western Suf folk County Townships R 3a- @ , ,

along with other local law enforcement

, agencies formed the Suffolk Ccunty Police.

Department.

f January 1960 - October 1964 Patrolman: Assigned to Communications l -

Bureau. Duties including radio dispatching,

,y ..

complaint receiving , teletype operator, etc. .

^

l

> +. .;L

- ~ -

- - - - , - , - - , , . -,- ,,~--e ,w-,- ., .

a

+/aw@w_ .  % _76mm@pyrjydygg. ?AqW e~~ dwr %_- ' gp y ;4fg o .n

%.w vy

.j y . &

,y 7 y7; - %Paga,2_ s .--__ a _ .g gg yyyOg . p.; qp gp ggsp.gggy _

a.;.y s 3 q m .. % , A - t Octobeg 1964 - July 1965 Detective: Juvenile Aid Bureau '--

Responsible for investigating crimes involving juveniles (under 16 years of age) , preparing cases for presentation

- in Family Court and conferring with the County Attorney prosecuting these cases. Conduct periodic inspections of

& Jw

.ipublic places frequented by . juveniles, .ie

~

. premises licensed to sell alcoholic beverages, etc. and take enforcement-

. .'- actions whenever warranted.

July 1965 - January 197'O - Serceant: Patrol Division - Duties included that"of Desk Supervisor, Patrol-Supeivisor and, at times, Platoon Commander.

- Supervising 3 to 20 Patrolmen with respon-sibilities toward compliance with Depart-ment Rules & Procedures , training, ev,alua-ting personnel performance and direct involvement / control of incidents when required.

January 197 -

July 1973 Lieutenant: Patrol Divisicn - Overall responsibility for a Platoon consisting

- of five (5) Sergeants and thirty (30)

M ~

- w Police Officers. Duties included. assign- ~

• • " ment of all personnel during a tour of

~~

- duty, handling civilian co= plaints and assuming responsibility for the overall Police mission in the absence of the Commanding Officer or F.xecutive Officer.

July 1973 - February 1977 Captain / Detective Captain: Detective Division - Member of the Chief of' Detectives

, . o,.s ..

-n #' A .,. .. e Staf f._.. Responsibilities varied as. need

~

arose, ie' review of~ individual Detectives

., e # 14 q -Criminal Investientions , direct super-

- - , _ . .w+~-

.._ n. ~ ~ ' ' '

vision at scene of maj.or criminal ~ incidents w -until arrival ~of. Division Supervisor,

(- -

. c, ensure administrative and procedural

.,. o ...

compliance with Departments ; Rules & Pro-

," j~ T. ' cedures , liaison with District Attorney's Office. ~ Detective Division Training A. Officer with responsibilities for individual

. -:4..

e. . . .-

• training needs ,' developed in conjunction with Police Academy Staff , curriculum 4

for Departments criminal Investigation a School. _

(

January '1976' - December 1979 ~ Detective Captain: Detective Division -

q, ,

Formulated and commanded Departments M y i Hostage Negotiating Team. Responsible + f or selections, initial and monthly training of personnel, direct control of negotiatiens at scene, criticue of every incident by those members present.

L

QQ&ack. yQ j$.- o-Q;q q ;.Qg  ;.3 , .[3 g3&;9 Q3; -

p

%w ~ cr . <

. . kr ,

, . ;,. .e  : . y;t-hi?< .s v .,  ;. . :n ga 3 .: p .

gga%wr.. MM@,._

'jejp qy.N. _Am 4 7Cwww--:, num - w~

February 1977 , July 1978 Detective Captain: Detective Dibisien -

Ccmmanding Officer of the Narcotic Scuad.

Responsible for investigation of Narcotic Law violations in Suffolk County, developed liaison with Federal, State and local

- agencies including the' Long Island Drug

+

Enforcement Task Force, where I had assigned ten (10) Detectives and one (1) 2 Sergeant. Task Force was a cooperative

- ' effort of the Drug Enforcement Adminis-

. . tration, New York State Police , ' District Attorney's Office and County Police Departments of both Nassau and Suffolk

. Counti'es to infilitrate and neutralize high' level drug operations on Long Island.

Maintain files and statistics on known illicit distributors, transporters and addicts. Responsible for activity of forty-eight (48) Detectives and four (4)

Sergeants and a sizeable ready fund.

- July 1978 to Present Deputy Inspector: Patrol Division -

Executive Of ficer - Assist Commanding Officer, and in his absence, assume

..a m ..

.j, responsibility for accomplishing the.

~

Police mission through' effective admin-

. ' - istration and operation of the Precinct

- in all that it entails, ie personnel, community, tactical, etc. Assigned Precinct personnel consists of 217 Police Officers, eight (8) Lieutenants , twenty-

- five (25) Sergeants, three (3) Civilians and forty-eight (48) School Crossing

- Guards , encompassing approximately 190

-e - . pW.. ._

4 . . . .

1 scuare mile area andiservicing a populatic .

of approximately 220,000 persons.

+ ~ ~ - w .,

.m . .,

> ' , _ FRATERNAL ORGANIZATION Suffolk County Police. Benevolent IE.MBERSHIPS : Association -

w~,.

Suffolk County Superior Officers

- c.. - Assoc,.ation + "

~ ~ ' '

- Suffolk County Detectives Association Suffolk County Columbian Association Suffolk-County Police Conference Suffolk County Police Association l

! New York State Association of Chiefs of Police

• F.B.I. National Academy Associates e

+ . _s g 4 . .,$.. ,

l

-u > 1

_ _ _ . - - - - - - - _ . - - , - - - - , , - - - - - . . - , .,,-a- - -~ -- . -~-w,-n,.- - ,.- --,.,,,----w -,,,,,,-_,.,,,r-,-,,---,--,----.m , ,_-,--,.,,-wmme,,- ,,,,,,w.,,.-.g. , - - -

NNbfIissbMiSN5NMRN+N'N$$NE

, U h. , w . ;d e -t A~ ^

$ $ N J~ N M N N*-f M N 'SN N Y ~'

.T

' d N. - % 1.; :' . . ... . L a - 'i g  %

$:b}n [ $$d$ $ Ul: % li5 & Y N~YS $ W S YW; ~~ ' ~~

Sf" * 5

+

E PROFESSIONAL QUALIFICATIONS OF GREGORY C. MINOR S

m. m i ,

GREGORY C. MINOR --

MR3. Technical Associates .

~

1723 Hamilton Avenue Suite K

• San Jose, California 95125'

,- (408) 266-2716 EXPERIENCE:

1976 to PRESENT

' Vice-President - MHB Technical Associates, San Jose, California Engineering and energy consultant to' state, federal, and private organizations and individuals. Major activities include studies of safety and risk involved in energy generation, providing technical consulting to

• • ~ legislative, regulatory,"public ' and private ' groups' and expert witness is

~

behalf of state organizations and citizens' groups. Was co-editor of a

~

critique of the Reactor Safety Study (WASH-1400) for the Union of Concerned Scientists and co-author _of a risk analysis of Swedish reactors for the Swedish Energy Con =nission. Served on the Peer Review Group of the NRC/TMI Special Inquiry Group (Rogovin Committe'e) . Actively involved in the Nuclear Power Plant Standards Co:inittee work for the Instrument Society of America (ISA).

~"

~

1 1972-197'6-6 <[~ }; f^ l N '. [ 6,

. . m ,, - ,

- Manager, Advanced Control-and Instr'umentation Engineering,- General Electric p . Company, Nuclear Energy Division, San Jose, California Managed a. design.and development group of thirty-four engineers and support i ' personnel designing systems for use in~ the ceasure=ent, con'rol t and operation of nuclear reactors. Involved coordination with other reactor ~

, design organizations, .the Nuclear Regulatory Co=ission .and custo=ers,' ~

lboth' overseas and domestic.' - Re s pons ibil'itiie s included coordinating'and cianaging and design and development of control systems, safety syste=s, and new control concepts for use on the next generation of reactors. The position included responsibility for standards applicable to control"and instrumentation, as well as~the design-of short-term solutions to field problems. The disciplines' involved included electrical and cechanical engineering, seismic design and process computer contro1/ programing, and equipment qualification.

~

" ,e r '

1 e -

a

-R- _ -- _ __ _ --- -

.gy~ >ev yy ,

y;;;y g .-

g . p- .

,4:93g;

~

.Q.

-p y . . ,

. f+Qs -

an

'q ~. ,. g .~,.

11 .

Ag- c: ..- , - - .

,& (4 -

, 3 w ig py p;a;&n;%Q?4y ?sQ & y y

~

.g% M - ,=fi -4  %=-* y~fV, 1970 - 1972 -

Manager, Reactor Control Systems Design, General Electric Co=pany, Nuclear Energy Division, San Jose, California -

~

Managed a group of seven , engineers and two support personnel in the design and preparation of the detailed system drawings and control documents relating to safety and' emergency systems for nuclear reactors.

Responsibility required coordination with other design organizations and interaction with the customer's engineering personnel, as well as regulatory personnel.

1963 - 1970 Design Engineer, General Electric Co=pany, Nuclear Energy Division, San Jose, California

• Responsible for the design of specific control and instrumentation systems for nuclear reactors. Lead design responsibility for various subsystems of

~

instrumentation used to measure neutron flux in the reactor during startup and intermediate power operation. Performed lead system design function in the design of a' major system for measuring the power generated in nuclear o reactors. Other responsibilities included on-site checkout and testing of a complete reactoi control system at an experimental reactor in the Southwest. Received patent for Nuclear Power Monitoring System.

1960 - 1963 .

Advanced Engineering Program, General Electric Company; Assignments in Washington, California, and Arizona Rotating assignments in a variety of disciplines:

m... ..

s

. s- -

Engineer, reactor maintenance and instrument design, KE and D

'# reactors, Hanford, Washington, circuit design and equipment' '

o

.m maintenance coordination.

- Design-engineer, Microwave Department,.Palo Alto, California. Worked

^

oE design of cavity couplers for Microwave Traveling Wave Tubes (TWT).

Design engineer, Co=puter Department, Phoenix, Arizona. Design of core driving circuitry. -

~

Design engineer, Atomic Power Equipment Depart =ent, San Jose, California. Circuit design and analysis. ,

t Design engineer, Space Syste=s Department, Santa Earbara, California.

Prepared control portion of satellite proposal.

• _ r

.se ,

y -

p..

4 l

1

\

l dm

.:. w-we ' ~

~; w'~

, .., - e e., ~ ~

e. nW fr . G.W= e

~

. L Ja / x. ~ % %ww.er:zrv Wh. ~

+, p.

~

' .-  :. y.: .x .. . -

~..

f,. ! ];;gP 'n

, g mgk [ p . qi u p:- ~ T ,i m+ . ,.: Q Q j

- Technical Staff - Technical Military. Planning operation. (TEMPO),

Santa Barbara, California. Prepare analyses of missile exchanges.

During this period, completed three-year General Electric program of extensive education in advanced engineering principles of high'er mathematics, probability and analysis. Also completed courses in Kepner-Tregoe, Effective Presentation, Management Training Program..and various technical seminars. -

~ EDUCATION University of California at Berkeley, BSEE, 1960.

Advanced Course in Engineering - three year curriculum, General Electric Company, 1963.

Stanford University, MSEE, 1966.

HONORS AND ASSOCIATIONS Tau Beta Pi Engineering Honorary Society 4

Co-holder of U.S. Patent No. 3,565-760, " Nuclear Reactor Power

• Monitoring Syste=," February, 1971. .

Member: American Association for Advance of Science.

Me=ber: Nuclear Power Plant Standards Co=mittee, Instrument Society

~

of America.

PERSONAL DATA e , 31. . . . ,'- y- - "- ~ #" ~ ~ #

Born: ' June 7,.I937 '

. ~

~

~

.-  ?

~

Married, three children ..'

Residence: San Jose, California PUBLICATIONS AND TESTIMONY ..

.a

1. G. C. Minor, S. E., Moore, "Centrol Rod Signal Multiplexing," IEEE Transactions on Nucleaf Science, Vol. NS-19, February, 1972.

2. G. C. Minor, W. G. Milaa, "An Integrated Control Room Syste= for a Nuclear Power Plant," NEDO-10658, presented at International Nuclear Industries Fair and Tec,hnical Meetings, October, 1972, Basie, Switzerland. "

.Sz.  ;"'

I

• er'* 4 , ,

m s. . .-_-..

u.Ji m/ 21- E

%- 9 .M- ' '

1 2OIlh... '

A e?' m.

.m  %, -

- DL ' ' L . . .. , .

..v. '

l QRf- s.% Q % Q 'W '; - f j Qgy . 5;. 4 g ; . : . . .,6 3~y.

3. The above article was also published in the German Technical Magazine, NT, March, 1973. .

4. Testimony of G. C. Minor, D. G. Bridenbaugh, and R. B. Hubbard before the Joint Commigtee on Atomic Ener1;y, Hearing held February 18, 1976, and publi'shed by the Union of Concerned Sc'ientists, Cambridge, Massachusetts.

s ,

5. Testimony of G. C. Minor, D. G. Bridenbaugh, and R. B. Hubbard before

~

. the California State Assembly Co:m:ittee on Resources, Land Use, and Energy, March 8, 1976.

6. Testimony of G. C. Minor and R. B. Hubbard before the California State

- Senate Co=sittee on Public Utilities, Transit, and Energy, March 23, 1976.

. 7. Testimony of G. C. Minor regarding the Grafenrheinfeld Nuclear Plant, March 16-17, 1977, Wur: burg , Germany.

8. Testimony of G. C. Minor before the Cluff Lake Board of Inquiry, Regina, Saskatchewan, Canada, Department 21, 1977.

9. The Risks of Nuclear Power Reactors: A Review of the NRC Reactor Safety Study WASH-1400 (NUREG-75/0140), H. Kendall, et al, edited by

.- - G. C. . Minor and R. B. Hubbard for the Union of Concerned Scientists,

-August, 1977.

10. Swedish Reactor Safety Study: Barseback Risk Assessment, MHB Technical Associates, January, 1978. (Published by Swedish Department of Industry as Docu=ent Sd1 1978:1)

11. Testimony by G. C. Minor before the Wisconsin Public Service Coc=rission, February 13, 1978, Loss of Coolant Accidents: Their

~

^

. Probability and Consequence.. .

,12 . Testimony by .G. C. Minor before the California Legislature Assembly ~

Coccittee on Resources, Land Use, and Energy, AB 3108, April 26,1978,

'. Sacramento, California.

13. ^ Presentation by G. C. Minor before the Federal Ministry for Research

- and Technology (BMFT), Meeting on Reactor Safety Research, Mar./Ma: hine Interface in Nuclear Reactors, August 21, and Septe:ber 1, 1978, Bonn, Germany. -

y

14. Testimony of G. C. Minor, D. G. Bridenbaugh, and R. B. Hubbard, before

- the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, Septe=ber 25, 1975, in the matter of Black Fox Nuclear Power Station Construction Percit Hearings, Tulsa, Oklaho=a.

n. ,

,* , A *

• 9 4

i

NTanw .: ? sg' - i.g,e < rg. . .s m.f*i

~

~

~"

• g- ~ y%q%gy.

"Y s

., y  :. , -

.+ -

d ' ? ' ?%g. J- }&Q

.:+

3{l -

~

~ 15. Testimony of G. C. Minor, ASLB Hearings Related to TMI-2 Accident, .

• Rancho Seco Power Plant, on behalf of Friends of the Earth, September 13,_1979.

16. Testimony of G. C. Minor before the Michi'gan State Legislature, Special Joint Committee on Nuclear Energy, Implications of Three Mile Island Accident for. Nuclear Power Plants in Michigan, October 15

- 1979. ' s

17. A Critical ' iew V of Reactor Safety, by G. C. Minor, paper presented to the American Association for the Advancement of Science, Symposium on Nuclear Reactor Safety, January 7,1980, San Francisco, California.

. 18'. The Effects of Aking on Safety of Nuclear Power Plants., paper presented at Forum on Swedish Nuclear Referendu=, Stockholm, Sweden, March 1, 1980.

19. Minnesota Nuclear Plants Caseous Emissions Study, MHB Technical Associates, September, 1980, prepared for the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, Roseville, MN.

20. Testimony of G. C. Minor and D. ' G. Bridenbaugh before the New York State Public Service Co==ission, Shoreham Nuclear Plant Construction Schedule, in the matter of Long Island Lighting Company Temporary Rate e -r Case, September 22, 1980.-

~

21. Testimony of G. C'. hinor and D. G. Bridenbaugh before the New bersey

' Board of Public Utilities, Oyster Creek 1980 Refueling Outage Investigation, in the catter of Jeresey Central Power and Light Rate Case, February 19, 1981. '

22. Systems Interaction and Single Failure Criterion, MHB Technical Associates, January, 1981, prepared for and available from the, Swedish

.j  : Nuclear l Power Inspectorate, Stockholm, Sweden.

7 .. ~23.; Systems Interaction and' Single' Failure Criterion: Thase II Report,

/

MHB Technical Associates, February 1982, prepared for and available from the Swedish Nuclear Power Inspectorate, Stockholm, Sweden.

c24 Testi=ony 'of G. C.' Minor and D. G. Bridenbaugh on PORV's and Pressurizer Heaters. Diablo Canyon Operating License hearing befcre

!.~ ASLB, January 11, 1982. t

..~ '

y

25. Testimony of G. C. Minor and R. B. Hubbard on E=ergency Response -

Planning. Diablo Canyon Operating License hearing before ASLS, January

, 10, 1982.-

, a

..gj P' a 9 ,-

^

4l. .

nem mw.m.ma w w+ ..-

m~ p w w -=

M1 e . .L, '

~

26. Testimony of G. C. Minor, R. B. Hubbard, M. W. Goldsmith, S. J. i Harwood on behalf of Suffolk County, before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, in the matter of Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham, Nuclear Power Station, U'it n 1, regarding Contention 73, Safety Classification and Systems Interaction, April 13, 1982,

27. Testimony of G. C. inor a'nd' D. G. Bridenbaugh on behalf of Suffolk County, before the Atomic Safety and , Licensing Board, in the matter of Long Island Lighting cbmpany', Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, regarding Suffolk County Contention 11, Passive Mechanical Valve Failure, April 13, 1982. .

28'. Testimony of G. C. Minor and R. B. Hubbard on behalf of Suffolk County, befoue the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, in the catter of Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, regarding Suffolk County Contention 27 and SOC Contention 3, Post-Accident Monitoring, May 25, 1982.

29. Testimony of G. C. Minor and D. G. Britanbaugh on behalf of Suffolk County, before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, in the matter of Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, regarding Suffolk County Contention 22, SRV Test Progran, May 25, 1982.

30. Testimony of G. C. Minor and D. G. Bridenbaugh on behalf of Suffolk County, before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, in the catter of Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, regarding suffolk County Contention 28(a)(vi) and 500 Contention 7A(6), Reduction of SRV Challenges, June 14, 1982.

31. Testimony of G. C. Minor on behalf of Suf folk County, before -the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, in the matter of Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station Unit 1, regarding Environmental Qualification, January 18, 1983.

32. Testimony of G. C. Minor and D. G. Bridenbaugh before the Pennsylvania Public Utility Co= mission, on behalf of the Of fice of Consumer Advocate, Regarding'the Cost of Constructing the Suscuehanna Stea=

l Electric Station, Unit I, Re: Pennsylvania Power and Light, March 18, 1983.

33. Supplement $1 testimony of C. C. Minor, R. B. Hubbard, and M. W.

Goldsmith on behalf of Suffolk County, before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, in the matter of Long Island Lighting Co=pany, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, regarding Suffolk County l Contention 7B, Safety Classification and Syste=s Interaction, March 23, 1983.

n& s ,

l 6 9

e b

O

~w,,,- e ,.~

7__.

W -e -g  ;, -.

~

34. Testimony before the District Court Judge in the case of Sierra Club et al. vs. DOE regarding the clean-up of Uranium Mill Tailings. June-20, 1983.

1

35. Systems Interaction and Single Failute Criterion: Phase 3 Kaport, HEB i Technical Associates, June, 1983, prepared for and available from the Swedish Nuclear Power Inspectorate , Stockholm, Sweden.

i ,

36. Systematic Evaluation Program: Status Rep. ort and Initial Evaluation, MHB Technical Associates, June,.1983, prepared for and available from the Swedish Nuclear Power Inspectorate, Stockholm. Sweden.

37. Testimony of G. C. Minor, F. C. Finlayson, and E. P. Radford before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, in the Matter of Long Island Lighting Company, Shoreham Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1, regarding Emergency Planning Contentions 65, 23.D and 23.H, November 18, 1983.

38. Testimony of G. C. Minor, Sizewell 'B' Power Station Public Inquiry, Proof of Evidence Regarding Safety Issues, Dece=ber, 1983.

3 9 r, Testimony of D. G. Brf 3enbaugh, L. M. Danielson, R. B. Hubbard and G.

C. Minor before the State of New York Public Ser.cvice Commission, PSC Case No. 27563, in the matter of Long Island Lighting Company Proceeding to Investigate the Cost of the Shoreham Nuclear Generating Facility - Phase II, on behalf of County of Suffolk, February 10, 1984.

S e

g

' r

). .--

I .

w.  ;

-I .

s ~  :-

J " .-'

v I

+ ,

. . _ _ _ _ g; _.