ML20095F006

Forwards M Gonzalez-Cuesta Memo Re Assessment of Risk from Seismic Errors in Design & Const,Per 840810 Telcon

ML20095F006
Person / Time
Site:	05000142
Issue date:	08/13/1984
From:	Okrent D CALIFORNIA, UNIV. OF, LOS ANGELES, CA
To:	Deyoung R NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE)
References
NUDOCS 8408270142
Download: ML20095F006 (8)

Text

._

UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, LOS ANGELES UCLA h, J },

ampKEtr.y. D4 sis. tavlNE Los A%CF.LEs al) Ea%IDE * $4N DIEGO + SAN FR4%C15CO 4

$4NTA BARBARg 1ANTACRUZ t

MECIIANICAI. AEROSPACE AND NUCLEAR ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT '

SCllOOL OF ENGINEERING AND APPLIED SCIENCE LOS ANCELES, CALIFORNIA 900M August 13, 1984 Mr. Richard DeYoung Director, Inspection and Enforecement EWW359-U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20555

Dear Dick:

This is pursuant to'our phone conversation of August 10.

Manuel Gonzalez -

Cuesta, the Ph.D student who is working on trying to assess the contribution to risk from~ seismic errors in design and construction, is preparing a brief memo to me describing his information needs in order to estimate the reduction in fragility corresponding to some reported deficiencies.

I mentioned motor control' centers on the phone. He may also. include a few instances of battery racks.

He is trying to finish up by November so an early response would be.very helpful to his schedule.

A copy of the Gonzalez memo is enclosed. His phone number is on it.

His mailing address at UCLA is the same as mine:

5532 Boelter Hall UCLA Los Angeles, CA 90024

• 1 hanks again for your help.

Sincerely, M

avid Okrent p"l Chairman DO:cde Attachment poxo.

8406270142 840813 PDR ADOCK 05000142 l[/,

p PDR s

u-.

pon:

Dr.

OktEMT t

(2.I'.5) 82.5 - 8316

)

Fce.a :

MAe,v4 c C,o.tz A L E 2.

TeL.

C RE..

I hlFORNAT/0.U ArEE.bs.D For C uALuATro.L/ of El ECTRIC A L.

EQUIPME. AJT AAICHot%A C.E

.DEFictiNCo t $

THE '

PURPOSc O f-Tt4 8.5 EVA LUA T/oAl 13 To DCTitzMIAJE THs crus t of AnCaor bolt. (ca. omin. FASTE4LL DEutci)

LCAbtNG UNDie Ar>

.SSE

-For

.sa4E defic oEN ANcuacAll coni. t c,URATICAIS fcusw

/A+ THL PAST.

IM ChDE/L Te De THIC,.

boTH THL SPtctric ELicTRIC A L EQUtPMENT CtMilA CTilllS TIC.5 AA)D THL DcTAL LS OF THE OE.FI c IL MT ANca@wc AAE niiDED.

l Tnt zEcairep soutenEUT cHAtzA criaasTics Ani:

t.

CAbeNiT DmEDSIOUS :

04EIGHT, WIO TH, OL77H.

I 2.

.D ISTRi bCTED AMO CONCLA2TDATL). LUEtc.H TS FD R.

CAboMET, tuTLRN AL costsua4TS, /4/.sctLAutaos

^

HAADs >Aa E.

.T.scLUDL ConCEMTAArtO LJi/4HT ll t.dcATroNS.

.1 g

}

Oc. ELsi, TOTAL

(,ULIC,H T AMD. CEMTER OF GOAutTY LocATroM.

3.

Pos t Tron of-EQa PHEUT in T*+E Pt-AN T.

E

.. THESE DATA CAM usuALLY BL FovND IAI THE cAccoL-i A7104 SHELTS i;on.

ANc40RACL ALLuALUAYloA/.

.QT oAtg.y, I

(T (poOLD ho1T HELPFUL

.70 06TAta TMSSL

~

1 l

cALcutArrou 5HLETS,

AS 0 011_ tvALUAT/oM CONGars CF StMILAR.

FollMULA TioNS.

l

?

C

?

I

f i

WITH EEGAkD To THE DEF tCIENT hANCHORAC,l CONF /4URA TIONS, Tnt FOLLo n ac,...briA Artt AJEEpth. :

~

I (1_ AucHoDAc,6 DETA ic. _ :

_PLAo of cAasu1An SASE

.. CMAAAMEL.

_AMD.

CA055. SfCTdCAJ FOR._ B AS.E. -70 Flocit.._ AucuotAGE,

.St+owi44

.ui NUMBZR. bf AAI)

. LeCA T/eA/

CF BOLTS

/D THE. 02tGIN 4L

.. CONFo 4 4/AAT/dN,

.b MdvLD M-. TAIL 3 ON THL Oco G s M A L CoWFl40/2AT/dAl SE. Mor. AVAlLA6LE,

AA) iSTytATE _ _ OF TML

.PEtcluTAc.E on nt.sstAsk on. LA ctsNG ScL7s

.-.- -. - - - AMD.

05 AGRANS Folt THE.-.. PRESL+)T C0AIFHaveA rt&A)

....W004 D. COMPENS AYL 202.,THIS..-

' 2..._ bCGTtN4__ CHARACTians rics 1.

48Li, TYPL, AND i

NAT&2 /A L _... SPict i:l CATioMS _ _ eda. _ ANcHo/L Eoc.7S, _ _ _.__

a i

~?

.. _QL,

..oTHER FA576tJrNG

.DENicts __,

5

,l i _7_. U _._ _

__l_

i i

3. _ _W ELDiM4_..DETAi L. :._.

IM_Sosf._' CASES, tud CDrN4.

l

(

... I N 5 7i AD _ OF. 50L.7tN %. 15 THL -. DEFICef.NT ITE M. -

t.

Fo/L._Tt+ESL,..- Paawbl--. wtLD -- S8 2 L-o L.& NG TH,.. - -

AMb.DIA4 Rafts 5 flo w s 2 5.

4.0c A rto p,_..

,. ~

b e

t

. - -... T ue..spicoric. estces oe. eas.iipneair ip n Aca. ecAxir-

~

i FEIL... k)H t c n. 73lE

. INFeAM A T't o A).

. to __ des t tts O._ Ares i

DLSCRestb

/M._. Tut. FO LLewlNCw. ATTACHHtNTS.

4.ie.

p..

m 4-

.'m s

i f.

.e aa. mp-m..

-..me-...ee a

m...-..m.

et-e-_ma.=-e..

..~~m._-.=.-.

~ ~

f N

i L_ _

ATTAci-#n ecT' 1 i

c T.

VAIUKEE 90wc Pt 4NT RE.FEREncEs :

~

l l.

OLP TOPIC E,6 El AkcuoeAca of SAFiiy-q RatATEb ELECTAlcAL EQUIPMENT.

2.

OSNRC cd.77fA 70 V4EC DA7fp JA4 1,(980, 3,

YAEC LC 77s l TO OSNRC OATEO

.)GLv 9, t980 WYR 80 -73.

l s

Alc.V E OA THE E LE c7A (CA L.

EddsP/*LNt 4vcao244g FQQ.

YAAJV bl ADavl LJ224 tNGsNil/L2D fo/L SilSMic LCA D S,

WL LOQULP t t x, E Tu G E.7 AD Eb7tMRTL Fo (L TMlitt CAPACIry.

%2/1 THr.5 PutP6SE,

OATA FQ/L TMd

/AS 7A N C E.1 OF E LEc7RfCA L EQJipM E UT /S I

DES ItLF D,

. o.us KittESiuTsuG A

s<io2.s r cAs& An?

l ANOTHEK An AOLDAc.E case.

IL). ADD I Tred,

THE SAT 7 &b t.$

w2kl FouvD.70 r

bi 3tLF 57ANalMG

/N THira RACKS.

PL.E ASE,

l PACVIDL, tNFdLHAttCU 04 7HL

. bATTit y AAcn l

CONFIGvCA TieAl AMD hkTTERY CHAR A CTipts7/cs, FRaM WHICH tal C40 EUALU YE TML POSS e bt Li ty of ovlR.TURNiN4,

DISLCD4rNG, 04 CO LLAPS L 05 78L f

a oRICraAt BArr2Af f s.

j AORES$ AMy Gals 7/0MS To PfAM UEL GoM Z AL E 2.

(2:3) 8 2. S - 2 11 4

, - - - + - -

-,,-,-,.y--

.e-c--,,,ye3w------

-w.,-3

,------...---a, e-,.

.m_ww----,.---wm2-w-

-- +-,-.

e

ATTAcHAtEAJT 2

I r

{

E.

3AAI OA)bFAE

(.J.v; r 1.

REFERLDCLS :

ls 3EP. TOPIC B.6

Id AncMotAGL OF _._ SAFiry.

AELAYLD E LLCTA Ic A L. E G01PrtEMT, I.

K. P.

SAS K IM,

SCL LETTE12.

TQ u.s,U R.O DATLD MAttc H 2.S, t 9 5f l.

I QJIPts t.A)7. Fo!L wit ocH

. DATA ARE.ULLOiD :

. ~-.

I.

. 48 0 V_.3W6TCHGEAlt.

CABIN E TS d 1, 2. or 3,

IDSNTIFt&D

.AS I tf.H S.

2 AND. 9 JN - ALSL AZ.A)ct 2

_ ZF. PosstBLE

.cSTAN. CALCULA rte.V.. A la _.5 - A - O I

..p7.

II-IS Ano.

1-11.. -..

_. 2.

THVARTtAs..Nos.

l.1, on.' 3,. C OEM TIFUD At o

i

,A

. inn 29 su-az+sacNcs. 2...-..TF_ fossos t.e, -.

i osre w AtcutarioN Alo. _S - A - b L p..s9-z s. _.

~

c lt A

l Aottess Auv aussrious To MAvuE L G on 2A t.,E 2.

. (1:sL8 2.5-8116 t

b i

ATTAC HMENT 3 i-

?

C

IIT, D.C.

CodK vm ts l e.' Z,

R.UEREnc5S :

h e

1.

LEl2.

8l-033 DATED Auc, 22, 19tl, e

2

9.. S. ham TER LE.7tE/L To usN2c D A 7sp SEPT 24, 1981 AEP1 MRC:

048GR 3.

G EDERIC LE TTEL 8l-14.

^f.

LEt2.82-041 orrep

.IONE I T, 1982.

?

r (i

E QUIPMENT fcR svH/Ct1 PATA ARL NEEDED :

b I.

600v fiorett.

co.urstoL cEnssh5 - un /7 2 Mc c AM - A on. O,

_ E.s FER Enct L,

2.

4 Ky S wiscHG GAR.

cASupE.rs / BostS, RnFthenct 2.

Tli AaSa c. 0L D,

oA UN/ 7.. i

~

T L C A, B, c, or D 6

i5 UNIT 2.

t f

1 FOR TSESE,

THE _ AnC#dAACh _. DETAll __/N RE/424Nc4 Z g

DO Nor PaavtOE ENo0G H /NFoAMA riod Fak THE t

CRI4INAL cohF/Gs/tA rte.Va 3.

VALUE cou7ect CEN7E/1

2. - AB V-A.

REFifhENci 9.

d k

l

+

3 ADDRESS Auv QUCS7 tons To M A u v s L.

coazA LEz.

h t

(183 )

815-8116 M

ATTAc 9hEMT 4 C

K.

PALQ VhkDi UN/7 d.

Rtssunucts :

s.

I.

IwAL

.DEFico EtuCf.. LVA LUATic U..ACPoar DER 85-84.

c

.DArze HAY /4, #984 2.

T u rgiu m DER 8V.

04rso FES G,1984.

C o

LQatnint..For umsco-t DA~rA age nELDzs :

}

9

.I.

HoTor..cosract ceuriks.

. i-E PH A. N33, M35 oc N-3 7.,

og 1..E _- P H S M34, M35 oc M-38

. PAcutDi.. A991 BAT 6 CHMNHL.BOLTwG DETAILS IN ' ADDIT ted TO THL. 0AoLS...S t40 W,0

. fr) _ QtEFGA2Mi 2.

s i

. i, i.-.. - -

O

)

h 4

.a t :

l l._..

4 l2 3

l5 3

I h

AORESS ANY QUtsTic)A)Q To l

s MANUEL Go.UZAL E2

_.. (183) 815 8716 l:

C l

k i

_.... _ ~

[;

l :~

i?

4

ATTACHMLNT S C

E.

N ottTH ANNA U,va r d.

i2.E.FEAdacE S l.

VLPCO L.E TTEL TO I s i,.

of-Fic t RSClop 'E.

c.

DATE#

DEd.

II, 19"/R.

E QUIPMEUT PCA LUHICH DATA /1 R.L AtELOED :

I.

ENERCeEMcy DIESE L G L AJE12ATOR.

i!ATTEA.Y AACK.

R.EMAEKS :

THL tapatnxArten ArsEDab Fait snos CA.cz is DIFFEREMT THAD THE or?L QUTLINED Fet2. OTH2tL PL.AMTS,

DU(L 06.1&c7svis ME 70 QATAlp SAD EST/kA7E PcA THL LeAOING cm) TnL 12Acn ELix2N TS, lA A5 k3E LL AS TO USE THIS JLA CoC _ COU/44 WE.A Y/ oA.)

4 I

l l5

.TO EVALUAYE OF9986c POSTO L A TLD.

defic tfA)CIE3 OTHLA i

(

j{

Yt4AA)

THL Quis FduNb IN Tt+L PLAAW.

k 50ft tnt 3E PJ9?dSES, QL AliED A'

SLT OF T1st svirH THE SATitAy RAcn DB2/GAJ DAAkJINGS, AL0ccr l

DIMEU$ tom 3,,

W & 14 H T 1, AMO MAY&2tAL Cl4 ARA CTA Rtssics NLCLSSAA Y.TD CAAA.Y OUT

.SE/S Mic. cA(.C UL A T/DodS.

IA) A00 s Tse*U, A DiscAttricA) of THE DIFfdkt NCE.S Discov624p

/AJ Toh AS -tuMST40cTLD

(%A C H, W l

Ct. GLSE.

T6+E HvMERicAL RE3vLTS Ob7A/42.0

/N THE C

^

RE Ev4LU AT/o.41, AaE ut.EDE p.

~

I AMktss Auv QatSTrons re :

l i HAkUt L C,0ntAL&L j'

(115) 81S- $4(6 l !

- -. ~. -

. -