ML20092K721

Forwards Page 7 from Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law on Contention I-42.Page Missing from Original Submittal. Certificate of Svc Encl

ML20092K721
Person / Time
Site:	Limerick
Issue date:	06/22/1984
From:	Mulligan M LIMERICK ECOLOGY ACTION, INC.
To:	Brenner L, Cole R, Morris P Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
NUDOCS 8406290035
Download: ML20092K721 (4)

Text

90 olunerxek eco nogy acn,on o

BOX 7G1 POTTSTOWN, PA.194 G4 (215) 326-9122' v:TEr USMC

'84 JUN 27 P4 :17 3

v.

Junc22yh 3S:aaES_

1 B Rt.NCH Lawrence Brenner, Chairman Dr. Peter A. Morris Dr. Richard F.

Cole Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Docket #50-352 U.S. Nacicar negulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20555 RE: LEA Findings of Fact a t,d Gentlemen:

Conclusions o f L a te on 1-42 LEA hereby transmits page 7 from the conjes of LEAs Findings of Fact and Conclusicus cf Law on I.I A Contention I 42 (Environacntal Qualification of Elcetrical' Equipment).

A conference call tcok place this morning betnen the NRC Staff, Applicant's counsel and LEA regarding ihe f.; e t that the conies hand delivered to Washinnton D.C.

on.inne 21 on th.

above referenced su' j ect matter were missing page 7.

At that time, LEA d : rea dy t ra r. -m i t t ed this page to the parties. liowever, dm to the tine constraints that g

other parties have to respond tc th,se i n d i n s n: Fact. Li \\ is sending i

copy by Express Mail to avoid any t'n 4.s i t i c del vs.

a We sincercly apologize for any inconvenience that this m a :. have eaused I

f any of the parties, particularly the NnC Staff, Annlicant and the Board, ie tt Respectfully subnitied, il E.'

/

E JL*7 cc: Ssrvice list (cnclosed)

MAUREr.N ttULLICA!:, LA V.

PRESIDENT E

also enclosed: Int errogat ori ca to PEMA

{h on admitted "O f f-s i t e"

=

Emergency Planning ( LE,. )

r E

=

r B406290035 840622 E

PDR ADOCK 05000352 E

G PDR E

E 1so 3

=

ai 4

7 13.

However, the

'E' classification refers to Class

'10' electrical equipment, which is safety related equipment. Mr.

Stanley then stated that it was his belief that the combination of the 'E' -designation and the

'4F' designation encompasses the scope of the new rule under 10 C.F.R. 5 50.49. Tr. 9571, 9572 (Stanley) 14 Page 3-9 of the Quadrex Component Classification Program Rules defines category

'F' and provides further discussion in sub-sections 3.6.1 through 3.6.4. which refers only to accident nonitoring equipment.

Mr. Thompson testified that the Quadrex Component Classification Program (CCP) Rules included 'important to safety' equipment under the

'F' designation, but was unable to provide a reference to any other information in the report that indic.ated that category

'F' related to anything other than accident monitcring equipment.

Tr. 9573, 9574. (Thompson) Tr. 9598, 9599 (Thompson)

There has been no conpliance with 10 C.F.R.

S 50.49 if the Applicant has failed to made a thorough study to determine what cquipment is_important to safety other than accident monitering oquipment. Section 9 of the Quadrex Component Classification Program (CCP) Rules. includes no discussion of equipment that is inportant to safety.- Tr. 9566 (Stanley). Mr. Stanley's reference to page 9-4 of the CCP Rules (9567) corresponds to the table provided for F

~

g comparison purposes on page 24 of Applicant's testimony. Tr. 9571 (Boyer) Although the testimony states that category

'4F' electrical aquipment is considered to correspond to 10 C.F.R. 8 50.49 (b)(2),

cross-examination revealed that this refars only to accident monitering

~

equipment. Tr. 9573, 9574 (Thompson)

Q a

.a.

=

~

n,

[.t' CERTirICATE OJ_ JU;a V,i,C E y,

a'.h c' I hereby certify that the following information way4segggp P4 :

"pon the following parties by first class mail, postage 17 prepaid, with Express Mail Service to those on the service list beside whose name appears an asterick (*):

rf _ -3_,- 1;u W. i;; J 4 g

=R:Hcy LEA's First Set of Interronatories on "Off-site" Emergency Planning Contentions to PEMA Transmittal of " missing" pa ge *7 f rom LEA Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law on Contention I-42 p) Lawrence Brenner. Chairman - (2)

Administrative Judge (c) Ann P. Hododen, Esq.

U.S. Nuclear Regula tory Office of the Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission W2chington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 w) Dr. Richard F. Cole

(*) Benjamin Vogler, Esq.

Administrative Judge Office of the Executive Legal Director U.S.

U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Nuclear Regulatory Commission Commission Washington, DC 20555 W2;hington, DC 20555

(*) Troy B.

Conner, Jr.,

Esq.

3) Dr. Peter A. Morris Conner and Wetterhahn Administrative Judge 1747 Pennsylvania Ave., NW U.S. Nuclear Regulatory -

Washington, DC 20006 Commission Wachington, DC 20555 Philadelphia Electric Company Attn:

Edward G.

Bauer, Jr.

Docketing and Service Section VP and General Counsel Office of the Secretary 2301 Market St.

Phila., PA 19101 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory C;mmission W2Chington, DC 20555 Thomas Gerusky, Director Bureau of Radiation Protection, DER Atomic Safety and 5th fl, Fulton Bank Bldg.

Licensing Board Panel Third and Locust Sts.

'U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Harrisburg, PA 17120 Commission W2thington, DC 20555 Spence W.

Perry, Esq.

Associate General Counsel FEMA Atomic Safety and Room 840 Licensing Appeal Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory 500 C St.,

SW Commission Washington, DC 20472 Washington, DC 20555 Zori Ferkin, Esq.

Governor's Energy Council P.O. Box 8010 s

H i

u g, Pk17105

~

i a5 L _ _. _

Jay M.

Gutierrez, Esq.

Robert Sugarman, Esq.

U.S.

Nuclear Regulatory Commission Sugarman and Denworth Region'l Suite 510 631 Park Ave.

North American Building King.of Prussia, PA 19406 121 S.

Broad St.

Phila., PA 19107 D,irector, PEMA Basement, Transportation David Wersan, Esq.

and Safety Building Assistant Consumer Advocate Harrisburg, PA 17120 Office of the Consumer Advocate 1425 Strawberry Square

, Esq. / M eg pj,,., g Nid)

Harrisburg, PA 17120 Angus Love, C

107 East Main St.

Norristown, PA 19401 G r e ;,o r y C.

Minor Robert. Anthony M illi Technicai Associates 103 Vernon Lane 1723 Famtitan Ave.

Moylan, PA 19065 San Jose. CA. 95125 Martha W.

Bush, Esq.

Timothy Campbell Kathryn S.

Lewis, Esq.

Solicitor's Office Chester' County Dept.

f Eme r ge r.c y Services City of Philadelphia 14 East 111ddle Street.

Municipal Services Building w'e s t Chester, Pa. 19380 Phila., PA 19107 Steven !!crshe'/, Esq.

-conmunity Legal Services 5210' Chestnut St.

Phila.,.PA 19139 Marvin I.

Lewis

6504'Bradford Terrace Phila., PA 19149 Frank Romano 61 Forest Ave.

Ambler, PA 19002 Joseph H.

White,III

-15 Ardmore Ave.

-Ardmore, PA 19003-

)[

Md&&fn M

June 22, 1984-L[A MAURCCN MULLICAN.

V.

PRESIDENT w