ML20087G319

Forwards Tabulated Results Re Review of Operating Shift Experience for Facility

ML20087G319
Person / Time
Site:	Clinton
Issue date:	03/09/1984
From:	Hall D ILLINOIS POWER CO.
To:	Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
L-0982, L-982, NUDOCS 8403190398
Download: ML20087G319 (6)

Text

b -}

ILLINDIS POWER COMPANY L-0982 IP CLINTON POWER STATION, P.O. BOX 678. CLINTON, ILLINOIS 61727 March 9,1984 Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U. S. Nuclear. Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.'

20555

Dear fir. Denton:

.In. response to an industry working group recommendation, Illinois Power Company has completed a review of operating shift experience for the Clinton Station.

The results are tabulated in the attached tables.

Personnel have not yet been designated for assignment ae Shift Technical Advisors (STA) and therefore data is not yet available for STA operating experience.

Engineers with college degrees will be cualified for STA positions and assigned to each shift.

Illinois Power Company will hire shift advisors as necessary, but hopes to minimize the need for these in-dividuals by hiring and/or by providing hot participation at operating plants.

S*

er

yours, i

. Hall Vice President JRP/ psf attachments cc Mr. Hugh Thompson Director, Division of Human Factor Safety Mr. Donald F.

Schnell Union Electric-Co.

C)d) !

8403190390 840309 PDR ADOCK 05000461 A

PDR I l

, DATA.

naren o.

two*

ortaATina suir? marrassucs r: ant mane Cli^ ton Power Settion g UTs uTT 1111noi3 Power

,l j

ao, TITta Shift Suoerv4= arm

^

twors 23 c.L. oAft Y-- = ry 1986 puctaAa eqE B fLANT EIrERIENCE

^

[

roR OrtRATING POSITIoMS (ISOTE 1)

ENTES DATA:

noWTWs/MoNTWs X MEIGNTING PACTop uricuTina nAxinun TTrE or EartpftWCE rACTOn CREDt?

I 2

2 9

0 3,

1.oo ro Lanr7 30/30 0

8/8

'O O

O

1. sAns TTre cosseene:AL sao

2. oruca coseanc AL sao

.75 no unt?

O 0

0 0

(;

O

1. sans TTes cossernerAL no 1.00 no un 7 0

0 6/6 0

18/18 0

4. oTus2 conssenc AL no

~$l c.75 no unt?

O O

O O

O O

5. mAv7 intuTAmT) noctzan

~.I M nouTus 0

62/31 0

6/3 48/24 120/36 (no. mus, soon, cruss

/$e.50 tormen

. o.25 48/12 4/2 54/3.5 76/9 0

12/0

^

4. sInuLATop 12 pecesTHS terreatucs PLANT) 5.00 (12 noserus) 0 0

0 0,

0 0

(sintians 2.oo to nouTust 3/9 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6

7. NuCt2AR PtANT ExrERIEleCE on sNIr? (OIRI FIAgr?)

24 teuleTMs (LESs Tuan a 1/2 Tanses ratosi to r.L.

,o.75 412 seoerTus:

38/12 26/12 24/12 24/12 36/12 44/12 (soons TuAm 1 1/2 Teams razon To r.Lp 3 o.so (12 seouTuss o

o o

'f1_..

n n

9 seamTus 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2 he.50

s. ucumsto etAssnoose TmAxussa Ano sxAn gange pgappy)

..... -.. j O

9/6.75 0

12/9 1/.75 0

9. PAnTICIPATIost A? OrtRATING PIAlff 0.75 12 IsaseTns i

to. orura nuetzAn FIANT exesarence o.25 la peowfus 68/12 38/9.5 88/12 38/9.5 62/12 13/3.25

11. comoucTInc L2ctu$r TnArmswo c.25 9 scontus 0

0 0

0 0

0 l

12. oscars (suctueraruc. ArrLizo sestuct on 2/b 90/9 45/45 2/6 42/4 40/4 rausvALenT) 12 noem $

eBACHE14RS DECREE)

(12 fooNTMS)

( ASSOCI ATES DECREE)

(4 ruur.irvS)

TOTAL uucLeast etaseT xxecassucz 83 71.5 70.75 57.3 97 64 NOT PARTICirATJoN EXPEW1CNCE Tine. 20s run/pria twas) 96 45 58 sTARTur. SHuToown tycS/Not YES YES YES nONTHS ON shirt 30 14 18 NOTE 1 Srr *1MSTRttCTIONS FOR USE OF NuCLEAll POWER PLANT EXPERj rNCF FACTORS r'*

pFCK ONF. CF THE FoLatadit1G e i

ortRArlNG SHIFT POSITIONS (OL ArrLICANTS'*

Q a.

Shift advisors must be used to satisfy Phe " hot perticipatiO4 NOTE 2 INCI.pDF ALL SHIFT SurFRVTSORS (55). $NIFT sRO'S. REACTop OPERATORS (ROI owperience" requirement s of the uts lity plan.

AND SHIFT TECHNICAL ADVl$0nS (STA).

b, Shif t advisorg wi}) probably be required. et 1033% for SOpe Bh8IIS.

4

.i..

wa a v.

a wo.s.

. opsnatino snart smeanismcs

q

~. Sheet l'tf 2'

'es,nerr unns Clinton Passar Station 4

~

~

- erFILITT '1111ania Pouer,.

4 Joe TITtse

,'Am=4=*==* thet* ~ ~ ~ = 4 =" :

NU

@.L. Dats._ J --ev 1986

,,eg,3,,,,,,,,,,,,, g,,,,g, cg.

.g

. rom opsahTING sEsEF positions (Nofs 1) sIffen DATAs nDWWEs/IeWITMs a usIcMTING raCTon

'N[usIGleflHC sLUlfutNI s;

TVPs or zMPantsenes

'"t racTOn -

casot?

1 2

3' 4

5 6

T S

9-18 l.oe ~

1. sases Tvre casessac AL sno

~ *'

1

'no LanIT 0

J0 0

0-0 0

0' 0

0 i0

.y

2. orusa cassuracinL sno.

N 175

' mo Lase T '

Ca 0

0

'O O

O O

O O'

O g

O O

O O

O-0 0'

O

-- O n

1. saser TTPs cassesaciaL no 1.se.

.no tant?

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

e. ovusa cessesacinL no -

• es.75

'no Lin T s

yt

• ""$n[

Ne'*p* n

' I.n.5o O

108/36 60/30 84/36 80/36 52/26 54/27 30/15 30/J5

.6/3.

E tornsap o.25 24/6 0

0 0

3/0 9/2.25 3/.75 5/1.25 60/15 60/15

s. sinutaTOn 12 nosmos taarsnuisce rLasst)

's.oo (12 seoimes) 0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 O

(sintaan 3.oo to nournst 2/6 2/6 2/u 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6.

2/6 (Less Tisan 1 1/2 Tsans pasosi To r.L.)

' o.w (12 nossreis 18/9 15/7.5 24/12 44/12 20/10 36/12 27/12 20/10 32/12 24/12

7. muetsan plant exPenssises oss smar? tous PLnnel 2e manns assons vnase 1 1/2 Tzans reson To r.L.

o.5o (12 senerrnst 0

0-0 0,_,

0 0

0 0

0 0

4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2

s. Lxesuseo c assmoost venturns ano suase o.5o e nouTus 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2 0

0 0

0 0

town enanT 27/12 0

0 0

0

9. PhnTICIPATIoll AT oPenATIIIG PIAsIT o.75 12 seosmas to. orisca puessan riaser sneennessee.

o.25 12 seosmos 9/2.25 10/2.5 36/9 11/2.75 11/2.75 25/6.25. 10/2.5 36/9 14/3.539/9.75

11. coescucTsuc Ltcassse tanteissa 0.P-e seosmos c

0 0

-0 0

0 0

0 0

0

12. ozenes sencruerniac, aprLsmo science on 2/6 0

30/*

49/5 2/0 0

4/12-42/4 70/7

• /11 rausvatenT>

12 noemis tiacurtons occures (12 seosmis:

(AssOCipTES DECnEE) 16 u. s) 43.25 52 62 63.75 56.75 54.5 62.25 47.25 60.5 58.75 ToraL wucts.An plant expenssisers 1907 PAwTicIPATIrles EXPEw!ENcE TIME. 204 pwn/sren twets sTAMUP 6 f HUTDOWN iTES/N9I 4

s00NTHS ON SHIFT 1

1 1s0TE 1 sEr.

• INSTRUCT 10NS FOn USE OF AUCLEAn POlsEn plant EXPEntENeg FACTORS FOR CHFeK ONE oF Tus FOLLOWING i

OPERAf!NG SHIFT POslTIONS (OL APPLICANTS)*

a wOTc 2:

Inctime ALL sutrT surrnvrsons assi, snarT sno's, nEACTOn OPEnATOnS ino' C a.

shift advisors must be used to satisfy the

• lect participation experience

• requirements of the -etinity plan.

nuo snart TEcnntent anvisons estan.

O i>. Sat's ad= ara vit t Probably be required. at least for some shif ts.

3 M

" ' * * ' " - " *'~~*~ *'

• 2 year degree plus 54 hours6.25e-4 days <br />0.015 hours <br />8.928571e-5 weeks <br />2.0547e-5 months <br /> l

i

+

1 1

l 1

1 4

n r-..

mT6 es.sIcts o. 19o4 OPERATING saIr? EXPERIsNCE PsaNT MnME ClintOn PoweE St' tion '

Sheet 2,ef 2 UTILITY 1111noi, Power JOs TITIAN Assistant Rhtfr c--evt=ar

("

$ i e.L. DATEJnuary 1986 PONE [P m EXPERIENCE Nr l

FOR OPERATING SNIPF POSITIONS (MME 1)

ENTER DATAs - RONTNS/peONTNS X ISEIGNTING FACTOR U NEIGNTING MAXIMUM TYPE OF EXPERIENCE

'h PACTOR CREDIT 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 I8 I'

8

)1.00 NO LIMIT 0

1. SAME TYPE COsseERCI AL SRO

2. OTHER COpetERCIAL $110

.75 NO LIMIT 0

%. SAME TYPE COpetEIICIP.L 100 1.00 NO SIMIT 0

' U.75 NO LIMIT 0

4. OTNE3 COMMEltCIAL RO O

- M

5. NAVY (MILITARY) NUtt. EAR 36 MONTNS (Ito, Ets$, EOOW, PPN*.)

UkG.50 0

(OTNER)

'O.25 52/13

s. SzMulaTOR 12 MONTNS (REFERENCE PLANT) 5.00 (12 MONTHS) 0

(;IMILAR) 3.00 (9 MONTHS) 2/6

7. MUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE ON SHIPT (ONII FIAllT) 24 MONTNS (LESS THAN 1 1/2 TEARS PRIOR TO F.L.)

0.75 (12 MONTNS) 24/12 (NORE TH'.W 1 1/2 YEARS Pit!OR TO F.L.)

0.50 (12 seONTHS) 0

8. LICENSED CIASSROOM TRAINING AleD EXAM 0.50 9 MONTNS 4/2 (ObME PIANT)

O -

9. PLRTICIPATION AT OPERATING PIANT 0.75 12 MONTHS M /9.5

10. OrnE2 NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIEseCE 0.25 12 MONTuS

11. CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 MONTNS 0

l

12. DEGREE (ENGINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR EQUIVALENT) 12 MONTIES (sACnEtaRs DEGREE)

(la MONTHS, 2/6 (ASSOCIATES DEGREE)

(6 r.vuei rv5)

TOTAL NUCLET' PLANT EXPERIENCEt 7

HOT PARTICIPATION EXPERIENCE TIME = 20t PNR/srem (NuS)

STARTUP & SHUTDONN (TES/NO)

MONTHS ON SIGIFT NOTE 1:

SEE

• INSTRUCTIONS FOk USE OF NUCLEAR PONER PLANT ENf'ERIENCE FACTORS FOR CHECR ONE OF THE FOLLOeflNG:

OPERATING SHIFT POSITIONS (OL APPLICAMTS)*

O a-Shift advisors west be used to satisfy the

• hot partic!PetlaR NME 2:

INCI.UDE ALL SHIFT SUPERVISORS (SS), SHIFT SRO'S, REACTOR OPERATORS (RO) esperience" requirements of the utility plan.

AND SIIIFT TECHNICAL ADVISORS (STA).

O b.

Shirt advi=ar==itiPrababir 6' r*1=Ar'd, at 2..se ror snitts.

r, ea,...

.i.-

Q

- ~. ~ ~

.iri-Au n.; sHart tv r~srNcr

. Sheet PLAuf uAME Clinton Power Station '

~1 of 2-uTILITT Illinoil Power Joe T TLE:__CR0

&L. DATg January 1986

'pausa PL nT ExrrritNer m

g

- Pop opSRATING MSar? POSITIONS ("f ffr_ I ENTEP DATAs

' NHs/nO'dTHs X WElcITING FACTO)

b* WEICHTING MAXIMLN TTet oF.EXPER!LNCE 4

racTOn CRrDIT 1

2 3

'4 5

6 7,,, o to 3.o0 NO Lin 7 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0

1. sass TTre connenc AL smo

.y

.t. ornsa casserac3 AL sao W'.

.75 Na *. int?

O O

O O

O O

O O

O O

%, s.oo no Ll"37 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 o

n

1. sans TTrr conncnc AL ro 0

0 0

0

4. orusa connenc:AL po.

t'.f/f*o.75 wO Lini7 0

0 0

0 0

0 t

"y ^ n.so 16/8 6/3 0

7/3.5 7/3.5 72/36 3/.5 6/3 36/16 82/36 36 MnNTH3

5. navT tm1LITApT) mucLEAR too. zus, zoou, erws:

torutal c.25 27/6.7550/12.586/21.5 52/13 56/16.5 26/0 71/17.75 50/12.5 0

0

e. sinu A nn

- 12 MONTH 3 tearsneuer PLAnti s.oo

2 nONTiiS) 0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

,2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 2/6 Lin:LAnt 3.00 to MONTHS:

(Less TnAN a n/a vzAns pasosi To r.L.)

o.75 e32 MnNTHS) 15/7.5 16/8-10/5 24/12 16/8 15/7.5 13/6.5 16/8 32/12 19/9.5

1. NUCLsAR P: ANT 3XPERIElect oI6 suurT toMM P:Agrr) 24 MONTHS Enoms Tuan 1 1/2 rzAns enzon To r.L.:

o.so (12 MONTHS >

0 0

0

0..

0 0

n 0

O n

e. Liesusro cLAssnoon Taarniac Ano exAn o,5o

, MONTi,5 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2.. 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2

• {

toNN PIANT) 0

- 0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0

e. PanTxcarATson AT opraiATresc P: Asst o.75 32 MONTHS

. orNE3 NUCLEAR r: ANT EXPERIEleCE 0.25 32 MONTil$

9/2.25 1y3.25 1/.25 6/1.5 7/1.75 8/2 5/1.25 IL/2.75 6/1.5 9/2.25

. conDuctino LICENSE TRAININc 0.25 9 MONTHS 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

19!2 30/3 0

2/5 70/7 0

18/1.8 38/3.8 21/2

12. Dec tz truc Nerninc. ArrLito serrucz osi 3303VALL T) 12 MONTitS (BACHELORS DEGREE)

(12 MONTHS)

(ASSOCIATES DECRFE)

(6 MnNTHS) tot 4L uucLcan PLANT EXrtsitruce:

32.5 36.75 37.75 38 43.75 60.5 34 36.05 43.3 57.75 HOT rARTICIPATION FXrrPirNCF TIME

• 204 rwn/n'#R (wt(S)

TARTL'r 6 SHt tTIONN (VTS/NO)

MONTHS ON Stilft NOTr 3:

St s

• lci tort t'H". Fisp U$r ol' Nut LF.AR l'(wrtr FI A'.* a% pe'tg.r l'AiTI'FS f7 '

c,,6. h iWI DF THF f rH.1/1 WIN 4 t tvrtt A t tis >. Till t'T l'OF IT ton'1

.it. AITLl4 ANTS t *

{--] a. Shift edYtha*rm Post 84* use.1 in ut e s f y t he ' hot parttenpattoh NOTE Jt I NCi l'It All Sil15'T Stel'FPVISelt't (SS), SHIFT FRf**S.

M ACT'5p f *f MT-W 46 'I p,g.e a cne e" s c Isss temerit s of she utslity plan.

ANI. Sill t T TfiHN it Al, AtW] Sof:*. (STA).

O b.

Shaft adve s.'rs wa ll erot al.l y se requa t ed, at least for some shafts.

y.

w. v. +m.

~j DerRATinn SHir? EXPEn:ENct Sheet'2 Of 2

~'

P: ANT NAME Cli' ton Power St~ tion

~

~

l ursLITy Illinoi) Power -

' 5' JOs TITLE:

CRO C.L. DATE January 1986 NUCLEAR PWSS' PLANT EXPE;IENCE (NofE 2) i g

POR OPSRATING NEIFT POSITIONS (*IOTE 1)

ENTER PATA:

MOlffMS/ MONTHS X WEICMTING FACTO;I N D k*A FACTOR WEICMTING MAXIMUM M

CRrDIT 11 12 I3 I4 I$

IO II TYPE OF EXPERIENCE NO lam 7 0

0

'O

2. sane TYPE COmERCi AL sRo y,JJ3..'1.oo O

O b.75

2. orNER CoMMERCI AL sRo No Lin 7 0

0 0

0 0

1. sane TvPE COMMERCIAL Ro 3.oo e LIMIT 0

0 0

7 0

0

4. orNEa COMMERCIAL Ro o.75 No Lin 7 0

0 0

0 0

4 S. NAVY (MILITARY) NUCLEAR I

M MONTHS

. ~,

o.so 47/23.5 48/24 73/36 60/30 55/13.75 (23. EwS. EOOw, PrNSI (orNER:

e.25 0

0 24/0 12/3 0

a. SIMULATOR 12 MONTHS (REFERENCE PLANT)

<S.oo (12 MONTHS) 0 0

0 0

0 (sIMILAR) 3.00 (9 MONTHS) 2/6 2/6 2 /6 -'

2/6 2/6

7. NUCLEAR PLAN' EXPERIENCE oH sNIPT (OINI FIAlff) 24 MONTHS

.(LESs TNAN n/2 TEARS PRIOR to r.L.)

o.7s (12 MONTHS:

38,,12 36/12 16/8 10/5 19/9.5 (MORE THAN 3 1/2 TEARS PRIOR TO F.L.)

' o.So (12 MONTHS) 0 0

0

0..

O

s. LICENSEo CtASSROOM TRAINING ANo EXAn o.so 9 MONTnS 4/2 4/2 4/2 4/2 g-1 0

toNN PLANT:

I

9. PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PIAsp?

0.75 12 MJNTHS to, orNE2 NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE 0.2%

12 MONTHS 18/9 18/9 2/.5 4/1 8/2

=

11. CoNouCTINc LICENSE TRAININC o.2$

9 MONTHS O

O O

O O

12. DECTEC (ENCINEERING. APPLIED SCIENCE OR EausvALENT 12 MONTHS 10/1 80/8 0

14/1.4 0

taACuELoRS DECREE (12 MONTHS)

(ASSOCIATES DECREE)

(6 MONTHS)

TerAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCES 53.5 61 52.5 42.4 31.25 P

HOT PARTICIPATION EXPTRIENCE TIME = 20% PWR/PPfR (WKS)

' STARTUP & SHUTDONN (YES/NO)

PK$iTHS ON SH!rT l

NOTE 14 STI *lNSTPUCT10NS FOR USE OF NUCLEAR PONER PLANT EXITittlNCF FACTORS IR CHFCK ONC OF THE FOLLnWINGt Ort'RArtNG Sitt rT POSITIluss (OL APPLICANTS)*

O a.

Shif t advisors unust be used to satisfy the " hot participation NOTE 2:

INCL. TITE Al,a, SHIFT SUPERVISORS (SS). SHIFT SRO'S. REACTOR OPF.RATOHg (Rn) experience" requireinents of the utillIy plan.

ANIS SHIFT TECHNICAL ADVISORS (STA).

t>. Shif t advisors will probably be required, at least for scene shif ts.

rm sw e.

,, i s.

. + <.

,h4+

.e

...'a~

• w

...,~.,M.

k-4 i

f