ML20087F901

Forwards Tables Defining Nuclear Plant Experience of Shift Supervisors,Senior Operators,Reactor Operators & Shift Technical Advisors

ML20087F901
Person / Time
Site:	Callaway
Issue date:	03/13/1984
From:	Schnell D UNION ELECTRIC CO.
To:	Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
ULNRC-764, NUDOCS 8403190269
Download: ML20087F901 (7)

Text

env.

s 4

,s.

UNION ELECTRIC COM PANY

-+

1901 GRATIOT STREET ST, Louis, MISSOURI M A, LING ADDR E..s

", i *f,",",""

March 13, 1984

.r. to ?.."..*o'u'",.....

Mr. Harold R. Denton, Director ULNRC-764 Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S.. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555

Dear Mr. Denton:

DOCKET NUMBER 50-483 L

.CALLAWAY PLANT, UNIT 1 OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE The Utility Group on Operating Shift Experience met with the NRC Commissioners on February 24, 1984 to present a plan for assuring that cll new plants would be started and operated with.a proper level of experience on shift.

A portion of this presentation dealt with a method for evaluating the nuclear-related experience of key shift personnel.

Attached for your information is a set of tables whichJ defines the nuclear plant experience of our Shif t Super-visors, Senior Operators, Reactor. Operators and Shift Technical Advisors.

The~ tables are based on the experience categories, weighting factors and maximum time credits proposed by the Utility Group.

Please note.that qualified shift advisors must be used at Callaway to satisfy the " hot' participation experience" requirements of the Utility Group plan.

Very truly yours, Donald F.

Schnell DFS/lkr

' Attachment cc:

Mr. Hugh Thompson, w/a Mr.fBruce Little, NRC Resident Inspector, w/a

/f i

-.-ma,ir--

~rwN-7

_y y>vy-w DATE ON 'b OPERATI*ed SHIFT EMPERIngeCE PLAIIT isAstE C A( L MLe aY c

UTILITY U N e a. n GLGtT9us-

' JGE TITI28 NI?T D U Y 4~

1. 5

@.L. DATE Aftet 20 1951 seUCLEAR POIft) PLA4ff EXPERIE80CE roR OPERATIIIG SHIFT POSITIF40S (If0TE 1)

E3ffER DATAs

, M000TNS/9EONTils I afEIGHTIIsG PACTom NEIC8tTING MAXIMUM TYPE OF EXPERIENCE FACTOft CRl:DIT 1

2 3

4 5

6 7

0 9

10

1. SAME TYPE CosetERCI AL Sho 1.00 Boo LIMIT

~

~

2 OrteER C0pueERCIAL Sho 75 eso LIMIT

~

1. SAME TYPE CoastERCIAL 8h0 1.00 No LIMIT 9L

~

4. OTalER CopeMERCIAL Ro 0.75 seo LIMIT

~

5. BaAVT (MILITARY) NUCLEAR 36 96000THS IN/f t J4(

"[I #

(Ro, ENS. Econ, PPteS) n.50 D,(o (f

L 10 tater).

0.25

/

$$. EIMULAToR 12 MONTHS' 2/lO h0 1

(REFERESICE PLANT) 5.00 (12 MONTuSI.

2 2

Z

/

iO

/O O

O (SIMILAR) 3.00 (9 900NTHS)

[l86 I [ff 35 I II 3 I b

I O

7. SOUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIFTE Oel SHIr? (ONtl PLAffT) 24 MONTHS

/S[//.2f f

E 8

(LESS THAN I 1/2 YEARS PRIOlt To F.L.)

0.75 (12 MONTHS)

(MngtE THAle 1 1/2 YrADS PRIOR TO P L.)

0.50 (12 MoseTHS)

/s/ f ic/(

2MgL 3Nt T.

pg gg/9 p)y F[4 Y[4

/Y 9/Y

!3

/Y 4.

LICENSED CIASSRonM TRAltlIIsG AseD EXAM 0.50 9 MnNTHS (OtfN PLANT)

1. c/

rsh

/o '% - ' '/ s

9. PARTICIPATION AT OPERATitIG PIApfT 0.75 12 MONTHS

83. OTHER NUCLs. Alt PIAst? EXPERIESICE 0.25 12 MoltrHS

[

2-

!T b

7Y

41. C00sDUCTIIOG LICENSE TRAINIIOC 0.25 9 MOSITHS

'e

~

.12. DEGREE (ENGINEERIDIG, APPLIED SCIENCE OR E')UIVAIIstT) 12 NONTItS (RACHEIDRS DEGREE)

(12 MOffTHS) l h

3-

!b

~

(ASSOCI4TES DEGREE) 16 0000f?HS)

TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIE30CEs 4 { g g*

gg

• ( (,,, 'J T )Q7 gg NOTE: Time spent at oper-Hot SARTICIPATIDIS EXPERIENCE ating plante as shown in this section must be classi-TIME

• 20s PNR/n9R tNxSi G

fled as " Observation

(,

n ETARTUP & SHUTDONN (YES/NO)

Training" since we cannot Y"'

YJ4 Yes Yes Yeo document that trainees par-

,g,,,,,,,

~

ticipated in control room 71 activities in accordance NIr7 Post [oS CHECs ONE w TNE rol.IoNING:

with the definition of '* Hot 4

oP rI o

Lc Participation Experience _.

i D

A

(

{

r t

y b.

Shif t advisors w!!1 probably be required, at least for some shifts.

O c.

Do not plan to use shif t advisors unless same unforeseen circure-stance arises.

DATE MN C M b

Nb

' OPERATING SNIFT EXPERIggKE PIAIIT MAME C at t AbJ AY

-UTILITY LI Arte n eI u ve*# s JOB TITLE ]gN/F (3*

t

@.L. DATE ONe' 20 (9D (NOTE 2)

NUCIEAR PONE 2 PLANT EXPERIENCE FOR OPERATING SNIFT POSITIONS (NOTE 1)

ENTER DATA:.

M00f?NS/Mn8tTNS X efEIGNTING FAC'IoA WEIGHTING MAXIMUM TYPE OF EXPERIENCE FACTOR CREDIT 1

2 3

8 6

7

'0 9

10

8. SAME TYPE COpetERCIAL SRO 1.00 NO LIMIT

-===-

3. OTHER COpgeERCIAL SRO

.75 NO LIMIT

~

==

~

3

1. SAME TYPE COpetERCIAL RO 1.00 NO LIMIT

~

'. 4. OT10ER COfeMERCI AL RO 0.75 NO LIMIT

5. NAVT (MILITARY) NUCLEAR 36 MONTHS

(,0 (r0 40 (RO, ENS, E00et, Press)

G.50 60 (OTHER) 0.25 M

A O

go "o

D

4. ElseUIATOR 12 MnNTHS 2!/ O 2

2 10 (REFERENCE PLANT)

S.00 (12 MONTHS) 2-2 o

fb O

o O

O O

(SIMIIAR) 3.00 (9 MtseTHS)

7. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIEleCE ON SNIFT (0808 PLAlff) 24 MOleTHS i Z/')

g s/,g_ gi #5[,. gf h 11 h I I!i (LESS TNAM ! 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.LJ 0.75 (12 MLNeTHS) gg g

f e/ C' L &/(,,

treQRE THAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.4.)

0.50 (12 MONTHS)

I 9

$* b b[k P[f b/Lf b['/

((d/

-4/ _

h

'l

8. LICENSED CIASSROOM TRAINIIGG AND TEAM 0.50 9 MONTHS (ONN PIANT) f' 9Y o i.s//

o c/i

• s/,

i s/,

is/,

as/r s s/o o clo

9. PI.RTICIPATION AT OPERATIBIG PfANT 0.75 12 MONTHS n z I, C/2

's/ g

% s

13. OTHER NUCLaAR PIANT EXPERIENCE 0.2$

12 MONTHS

~~

1. -s

41. CONDUCT!IOC LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 MOff7HS

~

~

2. DEGREE (ENGINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR EQUIVALENT) 12 MINeTits 3

gg

[

~

I1 h

b (sACHELoRS oEcRrre (12 seONTHS)

+

~

~

(ASSOCIATES DEGREE)

(6 DFdTHS)

TOTAL NUCLEAR PLANT EXPEitIENCE:

g g-g g

g g

g g, g 6 M E: Time spent at oper-Hof PARTICIPATIOes EXPERIENCE ating plants as shown in this section must be classi-TIME = 20s PNR/preR (NES) fled an " Observation ETARTUP & SHUTDONN (TES/NO) b d-C 4

G C

h

/ r.

Training" since we cannot

'I

MONTHS Oss SH!rt Y'S

'yes Yes Ws docisment that trainees par-tiLipated in control rooIR

~ acfivities in accOrdance NOTE 1:

SEE INSTRUCTIONS. USE OF NUCLEAR PONER PLANT EXPERIENCE FACTORS FOR CNECE ONE OF THE FOLIERflNG:

With the definition of "Itot OPERATING SHIFT POS TIOceS (OL APPLICA81TS)*

N 'q NOTE 2:

INCLUDE ALL SHIFT PERVICORS (SS), SHIFT SRO'S, REACTOR OPERATORS (RO) 1 re pe t o the u y p an AND SHIFT TECHNICA ADVISORS (STA).

b.

Sh!!t advisormu!!!Probably be required, at least for sosmo shif ts.

O c.

Do not plan to use shif t advisors unless st ue unforeseen circu'e-stance arises.

2

'ai -E n i I-i i v i s s l j: u :a st

[,3][3 38g

.11. :

1

. t 8 W " al

!::8g7.12 4 *. a4g r.-

3 r,=v se,il:.:2a zs-a w n..: e kr.eO#.30:414 3

,t ii; 1li

=

t=1; i..

1. I '

'.!

• I s

-1

z. i

.=

n-is t.

'l s^ s 3 1i r i

.o g.

sl1 :

nt w :*

a h

tn h a I

l

• i\\ i li e n

~) l l I

i i-w n,.~a a

s r

3.

n ssaili P a

s C

oil w

r l

l I d. 4 4$s l

8 : g - a.

x a

e e

~

w ll *!= I U

s i b s f \\' l

\\ s d\\

l '. ' '. '. *

.\\

\\

t s

n wt is $ 5

. u

<. I I

-t l

l l w s - u~ s r

Ea-

. e..$_

e 1

l I

t hm e$h, 5 4 4

di 1,1, j,

a~

g M

E

_ I.

.li3 8

n e t 't 5 s s s-gg -l a a a a

-Mr g

I'. E 2.9 E *

:: *. ::::2 ii i.

l

>J e

gi il.... s.. s ;s se..; ; ; +.

((i

.. s 9a ::

u 5

e e

vI =s 1n 3

5 0

si i.I

'i sdd

=

._ai see!

l-I

.. -I g!i!

Ffi

_,,[

h.ii' 2

a,s

!t sg i nae a

nEs 2 M ?-

I!

I i a i %

s, a

! _E gi "a 8

11 c

5 4 I

, I 1l-l

.I 5$ 'E E33 Il !a n Hg l 2ge m

3 d

-2

- -l.

3

.ila

,J ga n i

i i l-g,ggl 1j ! p 1lgi ;

'!i is !s atl,j:is,l,i!gli8i en s

3 e

=

v 1 l:1 l-,_i_i. ____ l_,3 i.llp s

l

~

L i 2..+.=. -=.i

L:

,i.i,

,5 1

.1 L

E 1

i i:

3 a

a

.: g.; i

m.

DATE ~ lNJ1f t M N. lO N[

. OPr lATING S8 TIFT EXPERIENCE PLANT NAME O A1 L A i.0 A Y UTILITY ( _I su it ca Ets c 7tp r '

~ JOB TITI.Es iM MNM' OU8NNb (MGM 2)

@.L. DATE Afri t.20 19 6'(

gusCLEAR PONE) PIAss? EXPERIENCE FOR OPERATING SHIFT POSIT!Oses (NOTE 1)

EN?tB DAThe MONTItS/seONTHS x tfEIGHTIBIG FACTOR NEIGHTING MAXIMUM TYPE OF EXPERIENCE '

FACTOR CREDIT 1

2 3

4 5

6 7

8 9

10

1. SApeE TYPE CosetERCI AL SRO 1.00 NO LIMIT

~

3. OTHER CUfetERCI AL SRO

.75 NO LIMIT

-==

b SAME TYPE COpetERCIAL RO 1.00 NO LIMIT

~~~

4. OTNER CUBENEllCI AL RO 0.75 NO LIMIT

~

5. NAVY (MILITARY) NUCLEAR 36 MattTHS

'7 2 /

g%,s

&c.

(RO. ENS, EOON, PrNS) n.50 c.C 2'

~

(OrtBER) 0.25 0

2

6. tIMULATOR 12 MONTHS f4 g!.

g g

)

'I Z

6 6

g!I 6

O (REFERENCE PIANT) 5.00 (12 MONTHS) 2-gy (SIMIIAR) 3.00 (9 MONTHS)

7. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE Ot3 SHIFT (ONel PLAstT) 24 M000THS

• N 8 #

3d gy ahy 2 ir

~

13/2 35 (LESS THAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOst TO F.L.)

0.75 (12 MONTHS)

(peORE THAN 1 1/2 TEARS PRIOR TO F.L.)

0.50 (12 seuelTHS)

/I

4. LICENSED CIASSROOM TRAIN!I0G AND EXAM 0.50 9 M010THS 2.'

gg

~

(OldN PdA887)

{

~~

~

9. PARTICIPATIODI AT OPERATING PIANT 0.75 12 MossTHS

19. OTHE'2 NUCLsAR PLANT EXPERIENCE 0.25 12 MnNTHS

~

~

~

~

~

~

"'"~

~~~

~

~

11. CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 pe00sTHS

12. DEGitEE (EBICINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR EQUIVALENT) 12 MONTHS (sACHEthRS DEGREE)

(12 MONTHS) lt

( g,,

lg l 2.

lL lL l7 g1 l1 (ASSOCIATT,S DEGREE)

(6 MONTHS) m a. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE:

n.r Mas

31. z 5 17 17 l-/

97 1*r 25 4 g,5 NOTEI Time spent at Oper-Hor PARTICIPATinte EXPERIENCE _

ating plants as shown in

?.nz = 20t PNR/R'eR (NuS) fled as " Observation ng" dnce W CannM STARTUP & SHUTDONN (YES/NO) document that trainees par-s'.)MTHS ON SHIFT tiCipated in Control room

~

- activities in accOrdance

.ofE 1:

SEE *INSTRUCTIoss$ ro n irSE Or NUCLEAR POtfER PIANT EXPERIENCE fat l TORS FOR CHECE ODIE CEP THE FOLIX)tflasG With the definition of '*ll3C OPERArING SHIr? POstTIOseS (OL AePLICAsefs)*

Participation Experience".

FrE 2:

INCLUDE ALL SHIFT PERVISORS (SS), SHIFT SRO'S, REACTOR OPERATORS (RO) Q a.

Shift advisors snust be used to satist the *Iot participation esperience* requirements of the utill F Plan.

AND SHIFT TEOfMICA ADVISORS (STA).

b.

Shif t advisors will probably be required, at Isast for some shifts.

c.

Do not plan to inse shift advisors unless soses unfores.een cirrue.-

stance arises.

I

DATE M,a r ' 9 / 9 99 0,ERATING SHir? EXPERIns.CE -

PLANT MAME C M L WM UTILITY LIk a o mt b L aE C Tdt # c, Jos TITLE:

r* C d6 f 1.U rS

@.L. DATE A p pet 20 f'fST NUCLEAR PONE 2 PLANT (MPERIENCE FOR OPERATING SNIFT POSITIONS (NOTE 1)

ENTER DATA:

MONTHS /MONTNS X IfEIGHTING FACTOR NEICJITING MAXIMUM TYPE OF EXPERIENCE FACTOR CREDIT 1

2 3

4 5

7 O

9 10

• ~~

~

~~

~

1. SAME TYPE COsseERCI AL SRO 1.00 NO LIMIT

~'~

2. OTHER COMMERCI AL SRO

.75 NO LIMIT

1. SAME TYPE COpetERCIAL RO.

1.00 NO LIMIT

~

~

4. OTHE) COMMERCIAL RO 0.75 NO LIMIT

~

(wO

5. NAVY (NILITARY) NUCLEAR 36 MONTHS

{

g d.

(,,o/jo r

s E>

c.:, ENS, EOuN, PPNS:

e.50 r

y o

(OTHER) 0.25 ho o

O RENCE PLANT) 5.00

(

se p

p p

p o

o o

(:IMILAR) 3.00 (9 MONTHS)'

I[//

I S//'

F/4

/3/1

' 5//).

/ 'I 8/(-

7. NUCLEAR PLANT EXPERIENCE ON SHIFT (ONN PIJUGT) 24 MONTHS ff[//

/ F[gl

/ s[//

g

• g y

j go jo/ f 4/g (LESS TNAN 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR 70 r.L.)

0.75 (12 WNfTHS)

(9eoRE TWAM 4 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L.)

0.50 (12 MONTHS)

$/" g, y 4~7[Rf f[t.f l[

y (ONN PLANT)

+-

9/cf 9/nf 6/e/ %

W9 F/9 B/9 8/9 6/,f

8. LICENSED CLASSROOM TRAINING AND EXAM 0.50 9 MONTHS

9. PARTICIPATION AT OPERATING PIApff 0.75 12 MONTHS T

I I

Y

13. OTHE3 NUCLE.AR PLANT EXPERIENCE 0.25 12 MONTHS 3

~~

~

~

~

~

11. CONDUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 9 M0087HS q

$2. OEGREE (ENGINEERING. APPLIED SCIENCE OR E')UIVALENTI 12 MONTHS (BACHEIJDRS DEGREE)

(12 ftOttTHS)

( ASMCI ATES IEGREE)

(6 MottTHS) l TOTAL NUCLEAR FIJWrf EXPERIENCE:

NOTEI Time spent at Oper-8 tin 8 Plants as shown in NOT PARTICIPATING 6 EXPERIENCE this : sect 1On must be classi-IME

• 20s PNR/prtR (NES) fled as " Observation STARTUP & SHUTDOWN (YES/NO)

~

~

~

~

~

~'

~

~

Training sinCe We CannOC document that trainees par-MOe:THS ON SH!rr ticipated in contrO1 room

• acCivities in accOrdance r.oTE to SEE

• INS?PUCTIONS F USE OF NUCLEAR PONER PLANT EXPERIFJeCE FACTORS FOR CHECE ONE OF THE FOLIJDefileGs with the definition Of " Hot OPERATING SHIFT TIONS (OL APPLICABITs)

Participation Experience".

SHIFT SRO'S, REACTOR OPERATORS (RO) Q a.

Shir advisors smet be used to satist the " hot participation NOT33 INCLUDE ALL SHIFT PERVISORS (SS),

espe-w

• requirements of the utill y plan.

AND SHIFT TECHNICA ADVISORS (STA).

O b.

Shif t advisors will probably be required, at least for some shifts.

O c.

Do not plan to use shift asvisors unless some unforeseen circun-stance arises.

DATE S f /C r# V. IIIN.

OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIRgpCE PIAstr IRAfEE C*AL1AidaY UTELITTt]Aulu ELEt.T$ir.

JOs TITIRs' EA C 70$

S$1? A TO$ b

@.L. DATE A#en 20 19 94 ssUCLEAR POBfEQ PLAff? EXPERIENCE FOR OPERATIIIG SMIFT POSITIGIIS (8BOTE 1) ggtfER DATA:

MOIf7IIS/MOBOTIIS X teEIGNTIIgG Pac 9gg NEICHTING MAXIIeUM TYPE OF EXPERIENCE FACTOR CREDIT 1

2 3

4 5

6 7

0 9

10 i SAfst TYPE C008tERCI AL SRO 1.00 000 LIMIT

~

1. oTNER CUIWElICI AL SRO 75 Iso LIMIT 1 SAf4E TYPE CUBSEERCI AL RO 1.00 NO LIMIT

~

4. OTHER C0fteEftCI AL RO 0.75 800 LIMIT

5. NAVT (D.ILITARY) 10UCLEAR 36 MONTMS 72[/b (IID, ElfS, E0000, PPNS) 0.50 i

(OTitER) 0.25 6 EIMULATOR 12 000NTHS g

2[j g 2

2 (REFEREleCE PLAseT) 5.00 (12 feONTHS)

T-g.

o (SIMILAB) 3.00 (9 MONTHS)

. f. ;4UCLEAR PIAff? EXPERIE80CE ON SWIFT (01881 FIAlff) 24 fe0NTHS gg 3 2[sf fi[(,

b[h*

(LESS THAfe 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR TO F.L.)

0.75 (12 M00f7HS)

(NORE TNAfd 1 1/2 YEARS PRIOR 19 P.L.)

0.50 (12 MONTHS)

'Ifi8 N2+

e itCENSED CIASSR00ft TRAINIGOG Af1D EXAft 0.50 9 MOIITHS F/4 F/'/ V'/ *

(Ot#8 PIAfsT)

P. N.RTICIPATION AT OPERATIIOG PLANT 0.75 12 MONTHS 10 OTHE2 NUCLa.AR PLANT EXPERIEIP E 0.25 12 MOIITHS

~

/77 Y

l'; d3413CTING LICENSE TRAINIIIG 0.25 9 M000THS

~~

42. E REE (E30GINEERING, APPLIED SCIENCE OR E'JUIVALENT) 12 9403f7185 (sACHELDRS DEGREE)

(12 MostTHS)

~

h

~

~

(ASSOCIATES DEGREE)

(6 90000THS)

TOTAL NUCLEAR PIANT EXPEltIEseCE:

gg gg g ggg NOTE! Time spent at oper-soor PARTICIPATInge EXPERIENm ating plants as shown in this section must be classi-Time. 20s PNR/fr,R tNES)

LJ 4

44 q

fled as " Observation STARTUP & SHUTD0tsN (YES/Ign)

Training" since we cannot doctaient that trainees par-

,g,,,,,,,

ticipated in control room NOTE 1:

SEE

• INSTRUCTIONS ron uSE Or HuCLEAR PatfER PIAt4T EXPERIE1tCE FACTORS IM

'a'ctivities in accordance with OPERATING SHIFT POSITIOIIs (OL APPLICAseTS)*

citECE Cast OF THE POLimedthGs the definition Of "l(OC NOTE 2:

INCLUDE A1.L SNIFT SJPERVISORS (SS), SHIFT SRO'S, REACTOR OPERATORS (RO) O sh$ rt =d i ors==== 6

==-d 'a *** * ='r th

• hat parties =at ta=

Participation Experience".

esperience* requirements or the utility pl.a.

AND SNIrT TECHNICAI4 ADVISORS (STA).

O n.

Smirt.4ei.or. eiin,,o6 i, ne re,.irea,.*. t nor e. Air...

O c.

Do not plan to use sh{rt.dwisors unless some innforeseen circun-et.nce. rises.