ML20087D967
| ML20087D967 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 06/01/1995 |
| From: | Wilmoth M GEORGIA POWER CO., KOHN, KOHN & COLAPINTO, P.C. (FORMERLY KOHN & ASSOCIA |
| To: | |
| References | |
| OLA-3-I-MOSB-36, NUDOCS 9508110247 | |
| Download: ML20087D967 (41) | |
Text
,
~
ul4"fp-yzif}z5:.-btnO:'
"E*' i AfQ$ f4DSAA~?bb '
f 4O Exhibit - ,paQe - ' of :
i DOCKETED- 1
'USNRC :
' f~~N 1
August _8,1994 1 D L .... - -
I UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 15 J1.14 A10:08- -l NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMWfdd 0F SECRETARY :l DOCKETING & SERVICE' e
+ ,
Before the Atomic Safety and Licensine Boar & RANCH i
) ti In the Matter of ) Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA-3 ,
) 150-425-OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY, )
etal. ) Re: License Amendment-
) (Transfer to Southern (Vogtle Electric Generating ) Nuclear) _- i Plant, Units I and 2) ) l
) ASLBP No. 93-671-01-OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY'S RESPONSE TO !
IffrERVENOR'S SEVENTH REOUEST FOR INTERROGATORIES t
I. INTRODUCTION .
Georgia Power Company ("GPC") hereby responds to Intervenor's Seventh Request ;
for Interrogatories to Georgia Power Company, dated July 25,1994 (the " Seventh Request").
A number of GPC's responses state an objection on the ground that Intervenor continues to seek information which is outside the scope of discovery established by the Board's ;
t ;
Memorandum and Order (Scope of Discovery), dated June 2,1994. Based on stat'ements by Intervenor's counsel at the July 29,1994 Status Conference'(Tr. 554), GPC interprets the i Seventh Request as a request for interrogatory responses only, and not as a request f r f
!. j i documents. ~i'
'l II. GENERAL OBJEC110NS -
i.; l A. GPC objects to Instruction D of the Seventh Request (pp. 2j 3) whidh requires !
, i GPC to provide detailed information with respect to each document referred to in any of the l
1 9508110247 950601 l PDR ADOCK 05000424
[NT WI b
., ,,,,-.a., n ,w-- -e e-,-
,H, .
O j w
I c
o . '!s.
j.'
N:
N' y O
4 -s 8h ( h*
1s a
n x f
$s 3 sEW_5 bN$ $
hN w
5%
h 7
s 89 h D
t@hj!fge e n c O
4ElksillhE l
{ . .
Exhbit ,page' of -
l A
! .. . _ _. interrogatory responses._ Given that Intervenor is intimately' familiar.with most of these .
documents, GPC objects to providing detailed information about those documents on the i grounds that it would be unduly burdensome and oppressive.
B. GPC also objects to Instructions E (p. 3) and F (p. 4) of the Seventh Request which require detailed information concerning every oral communication and person referred -
{
to in each of GPC's responses to interrogatories. Compliance with such instructions would be unduly burdensome and oppressive.
C. As a general matter, GPC objects to Intervenor's definition of " Licensee," ;
" Georgia Power Company," "The Southern Company," and "SONOPCO," and ' consequently to interrogatories which request information known to "GPC" as defined by Intervenor. I Intervenor defines these terms as including every agent or employee of GPC, The Southern . !
Company, and/or SONOPCO, past or present, their counsel and all their respective agents, servants, associates, employees, representatives, and private investigators, and others who 1 are or have been in possession of or may have obtained information for or on behalf of any '
of those entities. As a result, Intervenor would have GPC conduct an investigation as to the knowledge of every employee, agent or representative of each of these companies and indi-viduals. Such an investigation of each ofIntervenor's interrogatories would be unduly burdensome and oppressive. Without waiving this objection, GPC has endeavored to respond to Intervenor's ir.terrogatories by making a reasonable inquiry of those individuals who GPC believes have material information related to these requests.
D. GPC generally objects to the identification, or disclosure, of those communications and documents which are subject to the attorney work product doctrine or A 2-U s
]. l r
(
_ . ~ - . . ,
Exhibit _ ,page of' Q
jg_ the attorney-client communication privilege. GPC has been defending actions initiated by _ _
'Intervenor since mid-1990. In addition to this proceeding, such actions include (1) NRC inspections, an NRC Office of Investigations ("OI") investigation, and an NRC enforcement action respecting those allegations lodged by Intervenor in the Hobby /Mosbaugh Petition related to the diesel generator statements issue, (2) three separate actions before the Department of Labor, (3) an investigation by the Department of Justice, and (4) an inquiry by a Congressional Subcommittee. GPC's legal counsel has been heavily involved in the defense of these actions and, as a result, has generated a large number'of documents in preparation of such defenses. It would be oppressive and unduly burdensome and expensive for GPC to identify each and every one of such documents which are subject to either or both of (1) the attomey work product doctrine (i.e., they were prepared by legal counsel in fm anticipation of litigation and their disclosure would reveal the mental impressions of legal
( >
counsel), or (2) the attomey-client communication privilege (i.e., communications from GPC to its legal counsel made in confidence for the purpose of obtaining legal advice and counsel).
III. RESPONSES TO INTERROGATORIES
- 1. (Burr, Stokes) GPC objects to this interrogatory to the extent it requests information on the 'Vogtle emergency diesel generators ("EDGs") from January 1,1990 to present on the grounds that such request is overbroad and seeks information that is outside the scope of discovery established by the Board in this proceeding. Without waiving this Exhibit ,page of s.
)
_ objection, GPC has attached a table that provides the information requested for 1990, 1
through August 30,8 in chronological order.
2.a. (Bockhold, Burr, Burwinkel, Horton, Kitchens, Kochery, Stokes) The review was based on activities conducted by I&C technicians, plant equipment operators, system engineers, and maintenance personnel under the overall direction of the Vogtle General Manager, Mr. George Bockhold.
2.b. (Bockhold, Burr, Burwinkel, Horton, Kitchens, Kochery, Stokes) GPC is I unaware of source documents that were inspected or reviewed.
2.c. (Aufdenkampe, Bailey, Bockhold, Kitchens, Rushton, Ward) GPC is unable to determine who drafted the quoted statement or knew the information was transmitted to the drafter.
,m 3.a. (Duncan, Hobbs, Kitchens) VP-2466 (Alnor 7200U).
V)
/
3.b. (Aufdenkampe, Bailey, Bockhold, Kitchens, Rushton, Ward) GPC is unable to determine who authored the quoted statement.
3.c. (Aufdenkampe, Bockhold, Burr, Burwinkel, Horton, Kitchens, Kochery, Stokes)
GPC is unaware of any documents (other than Intervenor's Deposition Exhibit 44, Bates No.
46072) that were relied upon to conclude the instruments were faulty. GPC believes Mr.
Mark Briney relied upon the Exhibit 44, notes and that the conclusion was based on the fact that the dew point measurements for all eight air receivers were outside the acceptance range 8 - Raced on the Board's August 8,1994 Memorandum and Order (Intervenor's Seventh Set of Interrogatories), GPC has limited its response regarding the information requested to August 30,1990.11 at 2.
TT 4
\ l v
Exhibit ,page of l at the same time (which was contrary to previous measurements). GPC is unaware whether or not this conclusion was independently verified at the time.
4.- (Coursey, Burr, Hobbs, Kochery, Stokes) No.
- 5. (Coursey, Burr, Hobbs, Kochery, Stokes) No one currently employed by GPC who would reasonably be expected to possess such information recalls ever seeing a jar of fluid which came out of a diesel trip line.
pp,,,,j
, en W.'
- 6. (Kochery) See GPC's Response to Intervenor's Fifth Interrogatory and Document J
Request, dated July 29,1994 at 4 (response to interrogatory no. 7).
- 7. (Burr, Holcomb, Kochery, Stokes) GPC notes that the interrogator,' incorrectly quotes the April 9,1990 Confirmation of Action letter. The quoted portion should read
" internal inspection" not " initial inspection." Based on this clarification, Mr. J. B. Holcomb performed the inspection and Messrs. Ken Burr, Paul Kochery, and Ken Stokes witnessed the i 4 inspection. None of these individuals recalls observing residue in the receiver. However, GPC is aware that Mr. William Shipman, who was neither an inspector nor a witness to the !
inspection, wrote in his personal notes from April 11, 1990, that the April 6,1990, intemal 1 inspection of the EDG 1 A air receiver revealed " light rust film on welds, light oil film on I i
bottom," but it "showed no degradation." Bates No. 015115. l
- 8. (Burr, Holcomb, Stokes) GPC objects to this request to the extent it seeks ;
l information concerning any inspection ever done on the air receiver on the grounds it is I unduly burdensome and overbroad in that it sees information which is outside the scope of discovery established by the Board in this proceeding. Without waiving these objections, the l l
only internal inspection the EDG 1 A air receiver was subjected to in 1990 occurred on April p v
I Exhibit ,page of
( '.
- 6.' Based on Mr. Shipman's notes (discussed in interrogatory 7 above), GPC believes that a w ./ - -
light rust film may have been found on the welds and a light oil film may have been found on the bottom of the air receiver. GPC has previously produced a copy of Mr. Shipman's notes and the maintenance work order documentation associated with the April 6,1990 inspection. Sss GPC's Additional Response to Intervencr's Fourth Interrogatory and Document Request, dated July 29,1994, at 5, and GPC's Additional Response to Intervenor's Fifth Interrogatory and Document Request, dated August 8,1994, at 2.
- 9. (Duncan, Hobbs) Vogtle Procedure 00208-C, " Control of Measuring and Test Equipment," states that measuring and test equipment ("M&TE") found to be out of calibration "shall be tagged or visibly identified as nonconforming and removed from service until adequate corrective measures have been taken." E at Step 4.2.7. Vogtle Procedure
, 20230-C, " Control of Instrument Shop Measuring and Test Equipment," states that
" personnel using M&TE shall be responsible for ... reporting any malfunctions or suspected malfunctions to the Instrument Shop Supervisor . . " E at Step 4.1.2. A " hold tag" is affixed to the M&TE when calibration is due or otherwise required. E at Step 4.4.2.
Calibration checks are performed in cases where the calibration of an instrument is in doubt l
or the normal calibration interval arises. E at 4.12.3.
- 10. (Duncan, Hobbs) A review of the M&TE Traveler associated with the instrument identified in Interrogatory 3.a. indicates that it was removed from service on Apn16,1990, I and was not used again at Vogtle.
I1. (Bockhold) Following start no.136 on March 24,1990 and prior to start no.137 on March 27,1990.
/3 b)
Exhibit ,page of ,
- 12. (Burr, Stokes) GPC objects to this interrogatory on the grounds it is-l'A.[ f - . _ ._
unreasonably cumulative and duplicative in that it seeks information already provided to Intervenor. See GPC's Response to Allen L. Mosbaugh's Third Set of Interrogatories, dated June 10,1994, at 38 (response to interrogatory no. 6, (Bates Nos. 064383-064422)) and GPC's Third Supplemental Response to Allen L.' Mosbaugh's Third Set of Interrogatories, ,
dated August 8,1994.
- 13. (Sheibani) GPC objects to this interrogatory to the extent it requests information on the Vogtle EDGs for the 1991 time frame on the ground that such request is outside the ,
scope of discovery established by the Board in this proceeding. Further, GPC objects to this ,
request as it would require GPC to perform additional research and analyses which Intervenor is able to perform himself. Without waiving such objections, with respect to the information requested for 1989 and 1990, copies of the Outside Areas Operator Rounds Sheets are available to Intervenor for inspection and copying in the Atlanta offices of GPC's counsel. See GPC's Response to Intervenor's Fifth Interrogatory and Document Request, dated August 8,1994 (response to document request no. 3).
D 7-
l:
i Exhibit-----,page of_
o . Dated: August 8,1994
~
la *
.l
. Jaines E. Joirier John Larnberski TROUTMAN SANDERS t Suite 5200 -
600 Peachtree Street, N.E. :
Atlanta, GA 30308-2216 -1 (404) 885-3360 Ernest L. Blake David R. Lewis .
SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE .
2300 N Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20337 -
(202) 663-8084 ,
l Counsel for Georgia Power Company i
i P
e e
O 1
-E.
, , ~ . . - - , . - , - , . . . . .
c
(% [ f%
N '
O .
DATE EDG .
A-CAUSE STANTF F 8 Root C AuSE C-SMILARITY D-TTPE ROOT CAtt5E E-CORRECTIVE ACTION ASSEEEMENT PfRFORMFD 01/03190 1B EDO TRLTED DUE TO EE AKNQ SENSOR WA5 1 90 110 UN ENOWN PREE8URE SENSOR ON Rt0HT DISCARDED Pftt0R TO PER DC l 540004 &
BANIC TURBOCHARGER SPECIAL REPORT t 90-REPLACED T11E LEAKtNO PRESSURE SENSOR INVESTIG ATUN OF 01 Ol(24t90 2A FAILURE MECHANISM EDG DO NOT START 2 90434 INITIALLY UNABLE TO NO IDENTIFY CAUSE. LATER PER DC 2 90-0011 &
SPECtAL REPORT 2 90 NCREASED Alft START VALVE Ct.EARANCE OteCE_
DETERMINED TO RE ROOT CAUSE WAS IDENTiflED.
INADEQUATE O2 CLEARANCE OF Tite AIR 01/26/90 2A START VALVES EDG OID NOT START 2 90 089 INITIALLY UNABLE TO YES tDENttFY CAU$E. t aTER PER DC 2-90L0011 &
REPLACED AIR START Dt9TRf8tfTOR FILTERE, DETERMINED TO Bf SPEctAL REPORT 2 90- INCREASED SUptVEILLANCE FREQUENCY.
02 INADEQUATE INCREASED AIR START VALVE CLEARANCE ONC CLEARANCE OF THE AIR Root CAUSE WAS IDENTIFIED.
02/T1/90 2A START VALVES UPON CloslNG Tite EDO INmALLY DELIEVED 2 90LO41 BRE alter, REACTTVE LOAD HO PROBLEM WAS DUE TO PER SPECIAL REPORT 2-BECAME YERY NEGATIVE AND 90 02 SWITCHED TO REDUNDANT BRIDGE CIRCUET AND_
FAILURE OF THE G ATE COULD NOT BE AEUUSTED REPLACED THE GATE FIR 980 MODULE. VENDOR 11RINO MODULE ON THE TEST!NO FOUND NO PftOBLEM wtTN THE GATE NtIDGE CIRCudF IN FIRING MODULE. LATER. REVIGED THE SERVICE. LATER PAR ALLELINO PROCEDURE TO Rt00CE DETERMINED TO BE PftOBA8illTY OF P9CKIP90 UP NEGATIVE REACTIVE IMPROPER PARALLILING LOAD ON BREAltER CLOSURE. PEftSONNEL WERE OF THE EDO WITH THE TftAINED REGARDING THE REVISED PAR ALLELING GHID. PERSONNEL PROCEDuitE.
03/20f90 ERROR.
1A
_1-90 139 EDO ETARTED IN RE6PONSE TO SEE EVENT I EPORT 4 NO LOSP. THEN T1 TIPPED PER EVENT REPORT 1 03/20/90 tA 30$03 AND NUMEG-1410 SEE NOTE I EDO STARTED IN RESPONSE TO GEE EVENT REPORT l- 90 03 I M 140 LOSP. THEN TRrPED YES 90-03 AND NUAEO-1410 PER EVENT REPORT 1. SEE NOTE 1 05t2 t f90 18 90LO3 EDG DID NOT START DUttsNO FUEL SUPPLY LINES 1 90 120 YE5 FIRST MA94T. DUN FULLOWING WERE NOT COMPLETELY PER 5MCIAL REPORT 4 18 MONTH 94SPECT10N 91-01 NONE {THIS CONDITION SOMETNES OCCURS FULL. THESE WERE FOLLOW 1NO TH15 TYPE OF MAINTENANCE DRAINED DURING ACTfVITYl l 03/21190 la MAINT. ACTIVfTitS E00 DED NOT siART 1 90'121 Furl SUPPLY LINES YEs -,.
[ WERE NOT COMPLETELY PER SPECIAL REPORT 1 51-01 MONE ITNIS CONDITlON SOMETIMES OCCURS i~f FULL.1HE5E WERE FOLLOWING THS TYPE OF MA9(TEN ANCE W i DRA!NED DUntNG ACTIVITY) 03/21/90 IB MAINT. ACTIVITIES STOPPED EDO DUE TO LOW Oll OPERATOR Dt0 NOT 1 M 1E3 ND PftESSURE. LOW TURSO. OIL ALLOW ENOUGH T9ME PER 5PECIAL REPORT t. NONE PRESSURE & HIGH FUEL Ott FOR CAUGES To $1-01 bD)
DWftRENTIAL PRESSURE STA94 LIFE l
' 03121/90 1 M 124 IB EDO STOPPED TO FURTHER OPERATOR OtD NOT YES E
MVESTIGATE HION FUEL OfL ALLOW ENOUGH TME PER SPECIAL REPORT 1- NOME flLTER DIFFERENTIAL $1-01 l __
FOR OAUOES TO 03t22190 19 STAtnttrE 1 90 132 EDO TMPPE0 Wtit1 H10N TEMP. stNSOR CAllSRATION YES 9
LUME OfL At#8UNCIATED ERROR PER SPECIAL REPORT 1- SEE NOTE 1 I
910 t l
O O O .
DAff EDG A-CAUSE 8 ROOT C AUSE C-SPALARITY D-TYPE ROOT CAUSE E CORMCTIVE ACTION STA8T 8 8 A SSESSMENT PERFORMED .
03/23f90 18 EDG 1RPPED WITH LOW SENSOR CAU9 RATION YES PER SPEQAL REPORT 1 SEE NOTE 1 194134 PftteSURE JACKET WATER ERROR 91 01 APR80NCSATED Strt4/90 IB OPERATOR STOPPED EDG SENSOR CAUBRATION YES PER SPECIAL REPORT 1- SEE NOTE I 1 90-134 AFTER RECBVING 990H JACEET ERROR 9l-01 WATER TEbe. TRP ALARM WITN NORM AL TEfr.
03l3040 1A Tit EDO TRIPPtn DUE TO ONE SEE COLUVN A CAUSE ND NONE REPLACEO VENTING TEMPE'RATUltt SENSOR.
1 6 14C tem @ERATUIE SENSON FOR THIS START.
VENTING AND ANOTHER
- SENSOR Lese BEING
, DISC 0feECTTD FOR TESTNG.
( Ttet IS FURTHER DESCIUBED IN 1 NUREO t4tO.
( 04fl2/90 2A EDG DID NOT ST ART INITIALLY UNABLE TO VES PER SPEC 1AL REPORT 1 INCRE.ASED AIR START VALvt Ctf AR ANCE ONCE f 2-90055 DENTIFY CAUSE. 31 05 ROOT CAUSE WAS IDENTIFIED.
! INADEOUATE I
CLEARANCE OF THE AIFt START VALVES DETERWNED LATER.
OlfE3f90 IS {
EDG TRIPPED SNORTLY AFTER SENSOR CAllSRATION YES PER EVENT REPORT # 1 SEE NOTE 1 i 1 96150 START ERROR 90 07 & SPECIAL REPORT 190-04 f 05/23f90 18 EDG TfttPPED DUIWNG SENSOR Call 5 RATION YEB PER EVENT REPORT 81 SEE NOTE I 1 90 157 TROUBLESNDOTDIG OF ERROR 3S07 & DC 1990256
, 1 0. i . . mv,0 ,Aav.
l m. i .
1 106 )
08/19f90 1A EDO DID NOT START FUEL RACKS TAPED NO PER DC 190-0278 & OtSCOVEftED AND REMOVED TAPE AFTER NEMT t94187 DuReee FAINTING LER 19014 START ATTEMPT FAILED PROCESS 0011 9790 1A EDG OID NOT START FUEL M ACKs TAPED YES PER DC 190427e & DISCOVERED AND REMOVED TAPE 1 90 100 DURtNG PAtMTING LER l-94 14 PROCESS 07705/90 tB EDG DID NOT START INITIALLY UNABLE TO YES PER SPECIAL REPORT 1 INCfttASED AIR STAftiVALVE CLEARANCE ONCE -
1 94191 IDENTIFY CAUSE. 9005 ROOT CAUSE WAS IDENTIFIED. DEVELOPED INADEOUATT PROCEDURE TO FUNCTIONALLY CHECK CLEARANCE OF THE AIR ST ART VALVE &
y DETERMINED L ATFM. w 07/11190 2A EDG DID NOT START INillALLY UNABLE TO YES PER EVENT REPORT 2 INCftEASED AIR START VALVE ClJEARAPdCES D3F 2-94087 IDENTIFY CAUSE. 9406. DC 2 940087. 4 Att A EDee. DEVELOPED P9toCEDURE To
, INADEQUATE SPEC AL REPORT 190- FUNCTIONALLY CHECK DN pef 0000C basis.
CLEARANCE OF Tt*E Ain 05 l
START VALVES DETERMINED LATER.
gm j 07f19190 IS l EDO WAS STOPPED DUE TO PR09LEM wtTH NO PER OC 1940297 & REPLACED VOLTAGE REGULATOR y.
1 94104 KVAR SWINGS AT FULL LD AD VOLTAGE REGULATOR. SPECIAL flEPORT 1 St.
CNLY AT 990N LOADS t
01 I B
o I
s ._
)
Q Q [D-L )-
DATE E00 A-CAUSE .
B ROOT CAUSE C-Edu!LARITY START E F O. TYPE ROOT CAUSE E-CORRECTIVE ACTION AstEss&ENT PERFON 07/19#90 18 TROUSLESPtOOffNe PREV 10475 PROBLEM wtTH YES 1 96199 FAILtNet ' PER DC 190029F & REruMO V0tTAGE REeULATOR VOLTAGE REGUL ATOR. SPECRAL REPORT 191 I
Sere 9#90 ONLY AT teGH LO ADS 01 1A EDO STOPPEO WY OPEAATOR l 8619e MALFUNCTION WITHet uMUeOWN DUE TO RVAR OPl8CES PER EVENT REPORT 3 REPLACEO TM VOLTAGE MOULATOR TM VOLTAGE 9411, DC 1960338, &
NGULATOR. ,
SPECIAL IWPORT 190 3 TE8WesALS WERE 08 SHORTED DURING TROUBLESHOOTING WHPCH CAUSED FUMTHER DAMAGE S Ht9tTDeS DETUUmfATION PftoCess certDfDO 1A SPtitES OCCUfWED DURING 1 96342 MALFUNCTION wtTHos YEE TROUBLESH00TveSRUN PER EVDIT REPORT 1- REPLActD Tit YOLTAM REOULATOR THE VOLTAGE soit REGULATOR.
TERMIN ALS WE RE SHORTED DUNNG ' ,
TROUBLESHOOTING WH!CH CAUSED FURT;1ER DAMAGE INHl81Tp00 !
DETERMereATlON '
j PetOCEst l 5-
. E up NOTE 1: t!$
3/20/90. CORRECTIVE ACTIONS ASSOCIATED WITH THESE TRIPS ARE DIS . SENSORSREPLACED AND/OR RE.
A ON A. WARDIN RESPONSE 70 QUESTIONS RAISED BY THE BOARD IN ITS JUNE 9,1994 E IS MEMORAND E
l
. AUG-09-1931 15:02 -W P* -VCGTLE 904.!C TO *ILA P.C2 1 I
l serras eraras or amanza Exhibit ,page of-sonsm a marvu eaar comausszas O_
, 1m==e= = wwu a-- r e ameney urn um --;-
-- namen i
Za the Batter of~ !
- 3aoekst moa, so-424=eL1-3 encanza morsa cournarr, e d. !
i a
s o-4:s-ou-s i
- ass Liseams amendasat-(vegtle Electris samarattag Plaat, s (vransfer to 4 Daita 1 and 2) :
l Southers arealear) {
ARE37 NO. 93-471=OLh-3 I Ayernavre ey g _ _ e. Reyn:- a ---
i I, John G. Auf d*** -
p , being duly sworn, state as fo11cvst 1.
I sa currently maployed by southern company services as Design Tema Imadar, Vogtle Project.
- 2. !
I an duly authorised to verify Georgia power cuerpany's Response to Intervencr's seventh Request for Interrogatories,-
specifically the responses to 2ntarrogatory Nos. 2.o., 3.b. and .
I 3.c.. ,
1 i
I hereby certify that the statazants and opinions in such response are tr.:e and correct to the best of =y personal knowledge and belief.
hYR to .
G.Aufdpmaps '
Brorn to; and subs;:ribed betare am tt11s . Y g .
day of August, 3.994.
.t i
otaxy p kkte d
,My
,. ,acumission e c:mes W N GIea t
I W e6
- M S en e
- - .~ .
AUG-09-1994 14: 10 : ~r. . F 6 EEFG4."C TO TSLA P. m
.. l arvan searns or-asumsca Exhibit ,page ' of .: _ . l messans massurant centraszou l
(~j. === = e-= mea-o - ,r - tr.. _ _ r y..,, , !
v- .
j 2a the aratter es ,
esonsza passa causamr, a n. i n ex t vos. se-4:4-or.n-a 1
.s so-4:s-ar.m-s , ,, l
~s .
(Tegtle Nicotris Seaarating Plaat, s ne Lissase amenement Units 1 and 2) (Tremster te ,' ..- l
- southera puolear).
~ ~;',
s
. asLas no. es-sn-ota- - !
1rprnavre or sawns 1. uner.sv .
t I, James A. Bailey, being duly sworn, state as follows:-
1.
I am currently suployed by southern Nuclear operatlag company as Manager-Licensing, Vogtle Project.
2.
I sa duly authorized to varity Georgia Power company's. ,
... Response to Intervanor's savanth Request.for Interrogstories,
- 3 ' ~
l specitloally. the responses to Interrogatory Nos. 2.c. and 3.b.- 1 i
I hereby certify that the statsmants and opinions in much i g {
response are true and correct to the heat of my personal
. i knowledge and balief. l 6
1 -
/ James A. Bailey /
sworn to and a ;
before me this 041 bed day of August, 1394. !
YM.b4 Notar
- k. !'y ;
masw.y 4ea4- Public
.--#w..
M d
r l
. 1 e
s !
TOTr4. P.07 4
I
. ~ . . -.-- - .. . .- .- --.
L
~ AUG-es-1994 14:09 **31 ~ She-V0GTLE EMid IC ' 70, TSLA 8. C5 IDc1ED STATER Cr Ahmarc 4M MN. commas C2khibit ,page .
of -
annur var Amwc nA*uf Avn ucmcrwe moian
,. 1,, . -- --
La the Master er GEORGIA POWDL COMPANY, at al. I Docket Nos. AN24 0LA4 I
- "LW M-
&cstle Electric Geasrating Plant, Re:IJeanse Amhd '
Umbs1and:D t
(Transhrle Southers Mucisar)
~ t i s'
ASLBP No. 93 d'710LA4 AFFmAVIT OF GmBf:T BOr*IrenTh fB I. George Bockhold, k.. being duly sworn, state as fbuows:
1.
I am currently amployed by Southern Nuclear Opermaing %,"?y as Ges Manager, Nucinar 'Ischnical Support.
2.
I are duly authoriand to verify Georgia Power Company's asspones to '
Intervenar's seventh Request for Imstragatories, Wh"y the nsponses to t!
Nos. 2.a., 2.b., 2.c., 3.b., 3.c., and 11.
I barsby certify that the stataments and opinions in such asponse are true a cc:roct to the best of my personal kr.owledge and be2ef. i o ,,. m u. -
Ik -
)
Sworn to and subsenbod '
beibro me sids (day of Angast,1994r - , t I
ur_,
My con. .iarpires:
naission :
w-- m ...... ,,.... !
1 1
.=======
1
{
Ari-08-1?9.: 11:17 FR31 SF-V0GTLE ENG4.*C TO .T M P. C
... . l l
-)
August 8,1994 - :
UNrniD STATES OF AMERICA x ._ ,
Em RNN NSION:xhibit w m. Ae. '- sc. w t - .% - - ~ 'page . Of
.i i
) -
. In ths Maar of )
):
Docht Nos. 5042MILA 3 !
) 504;tS OLA-3 ,)
GBORMA POWER COMPANY. )
et aL i
) Re: IJaanas Amandament
) @annsfer m Southern i (Vogtle Elecede Decendes ) Nucisar) i
- Mant, Units ! and 2) ) . - '
} A5ul? No. 93 671-01 OLA-3 . 1 APPIDAVFf 0F EIqfNETH S. EURR l I, xannath S. Burr, being duly sworn, sans as Ja!Iows:
I
- 1. I am cunearly employed by the Southern Nacisar opendag company, as -
l senior Projem w , Nuclear Malatsaanos and Support-Vogtle. '
- 2. ' "
I am duty an9=wi=ri to verify Georga Power Way's Response to > !
Intervenar's Sevemh Raquest for Insurrogaaories, WA-"y the responses to L.-% h i
Nos. I, 2.a., 2.b., 3.c., 4., 5., 7., I., and 12.
i I henby eartify that 'the statements and opinior.s in such aspanas are tms and correct l to the best of my personaJ knowledge and bellaf. I
.x k s. B ,e i
Sworn to and subscnbad bdors as this1 day of Appst,1994, l i
AM > '
Notary Puhtc. ,
R'*"= I *h spires * ;
en - - ...q. ,
i i
1 i
, ,, , ... .: . i s
TOTR. P.83 ,
17:20 LAM
.AL.G..-09. an.1994 - U]E,, g D,* c.._.20.-333-3900 P,05 '.
4048 5. . 706 026 3589;s 3
. Exhibit ,page of O-- - - .
_Uurtso s2Aras or AMIEZch~ -
( NUCLEAR REGUL1 TORY:OCDDR2SSION smpene een teamrve sawmer mwn tras arms == ==
l- In the Mattar of 3.
samassa Persa ecosraur, 21 al. Donket mes. so-da4-esa-3 3 0-425- cLa.s
-(Yogtis Blestrie seaerating plant, -me: License ammadment units 1 and 2) :
s (Transfer ta t southern muslaar)
ASLIP WD. 93-571-OL&=3 xyvffmyre er enntns c xamy I, Charles Courney, being duly sworn, state as follows:
1.
I am currently employed by Georgia Power company as Maintenance superintendent,.Vogtle Electric Generating Plant .
2.
I an duly autherised to verify Georgia Power company's Response to Intervanor's seventh Request for Interrogatories, .
specifically the responses to Intarrogatory Nom. 4. and 5.
I hereby certify t. hat the statsmants and opinions in such i
response are true and correct to the best of my personal knowledge and belief.
Charles courney b' .
k Sworn to and subs bed batore me this .
4
- ~#...
.M'M' fin i - - ..
- Romand Ommy. Geogi, f J;i..
.n:.-:
BWes#v 21.1ma j ;;,. -
4 *: t y._ ; .m
-re mas s 3 -
E -J. gy
. . _. 5'./_
% ,M.%_,
3 k n o-a.s..1994
^2,mr non r1 E H;
E e..101-8E5-3900 P.10 gg g ,- g gg ggg;g r j Exhibit ,page OI i _ _ . _ axIess stavas or axEazca . -- - NOCLERE RSSUEATORY COMMISSION. EBrenn emw temrTe wawmer anm Lrewma nn unavn
.In the katter og a
- Donket 3ps. Sp 434-aLn.3 5303431 PtMrER CONFANT, 3131 t SD=435-OLA-3 i (Vogtle 31estrie sentrating Plant,.: Re: Lisease Amendment IInits 1 and 3) 3-(Temaafar to t Southern Nuslaar)
ASLIP Wo. 93-571-OtA=3 Arrinnere or urennut. s. n w aw 2, Michael D. Duncan, being duly sworn, state as follows: 1. I au currently employed by Georgia Power company as Instrument & controls supervisor, Vogtle Electric Generating ) Plant. 2. I a:n duly authorized to verify Georgia Power Company's Response to Intervancr's seventh Request for Interrogatorias , specifically the responses to Interrogatory Nos. 3.a.,'9. and 10. I hereby certify that the stataments and epinions in such response are true and correct to the best of my personal kncrwiedge and belief. sm' Michael D. Duncan ~
)
before me thisSworn 1 today and subsp *ribed _ v A
.. ~. ~
my ~ocanni .. . . supi : Ar. 194l , v -
..c c* . .
w m me n'nw omsg'.o e /. ..:: av ennu m mm o W rts. m e f "/ : w; . -t;:' .1~.\
=: : -
. ~c =
r
$2 ,.%iw.:. < r2. .,a. 5si .5 5I
. 5
",.h p ,, -S p ./ -
. p ~-~ . . . -
4
-v -- -
s
E
,ALG-05-1994 17:29a FRCr s.rt".l.E TECH, SUPPCRT TO - ~ 9 *-404-G85-3900. P,83 ~
. +
#c18 c f 841tf) . 44' - g-g4 ; 1:gjpg ; gggy 3,, , , 7pg gp, gg,;g g
. f, %i Exhibit ,page of-b/ M27ED STATES OF AMERICE
~
Evoz.Bak masar.araar ocarssraz. B2Pown enn menute eswney are treewarve annun Za the Matter of a 3 830RSIA POWER CONFANY, at 31 a Docket Nos. 59-434-GLE-3 s
,SD-425=0ZA-3 (Yogtle s 1Elettric Samarating Plant, I Ret Lissase Amendment Uni's mai 2) 1 (Transfer to s Beuthern amolear)
ASLB7 NQ. 93-572-OLR-3 arrrnsyry or wrewswr- L. monas
, Michael L. Hobbs, being duly avorn, state as follows:
1. I am currently amployed by Georgia Power company as Instrument.& controls superintendent, Vogtle Electric Generating Plant. 2. t I an duly authorized to verify Georgia Power company's - Response to Intervanor's seventh Request for Interrogatories , specifically the responses to Interrogatory Nos. 3.a. , 4. , S., 9 and 10. . ) I harsby certify that the states. ants and opinions in attch response are true and correct to the best f my per nal knowledge and belief.
.f 1f h, <.d .g isichael L. Bobbs Sworn to and sub bed before me this day of An
) et'l.199 4 . /
/fdAU -
/
- - ('. :.- D'~
..\
kgho I t
- -. - .c 2
- 5. W. ** * ? *m si;
\ $).c . */
~ . Tl
- y . *
+ ..
r_'f.' . q, .;
$.oS ~
5-4ii PN e 4348..,5...384-655-3900 1P.64
'{
706 B28 3088:88 i
- Exhibit ,page- of 3
1
. UNITED STATES OF M(3 Rich
~~ ~
EUCLEAR RESULETORY 00antISSION -{ ggggan www 1*ouve ann a hwn r.To--. m manen In the Matter of : \ i 8303821 POWER CtINFANY, 3.131 a
- Doeket Nos. 80 424-OLa-3
- : Sp=438 0LA (Yeetle Blestris samarating naat, s:
Re Limessa Anemensat: naits 1 and 3) : (Temaorer to 1
- southern Nuclear)
ANL2P N0e 93=s71 OL&et arrrnavre or 3.u.YoM wer= _ 9f 9
\
l loc.cr4sY 4Y I, J.B. ".;1avisa, being duly sworn, state as rollows:
. 1.
I am currently employed by Gearyta Power company as . Mechanic, Vogtle 21setric Generating plast. 2. I an duly authorized to verify Georgia Power Company's Rasponse to Intervenor's seventh Request ter Interrogatorie s,
.specifinally the responses to Interrogatory Noe. 7 and s.
' I hereby certify that the statanuants and opinions'in such l response are trus and correct to the best of my personal knowledge and belief. \ i i 1)$ aw m ,orn to and subscribed
- g. . . ~. -
.r. .e e s _a da '
My 1,. ion i s s_ Bf, 9 96 s - an eme
.Y .'.a ^. :.::. %;
f ' -~ % - f :s 5 ;.
.' E .
~~~
. " . , "l :a
* @l i
'~ ~ ~ ----
~
y E ,. ,
-~- ~- .
,1, N~ '., W:....
._..~.-
#"= - - - - _ _ -- . _ _ __ -- e m r
- p. .-. .
, etw4 :4:es e v-wou w tc To TS'" " * *'
-1
. Exhibit -,page of L UNITED STATES OF ABGitICA
^ ' ~ ~ NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIRRION . -
urwnne twe Atome n, . i AND urem anAan ' ! la the Matter of . GEORGIA POWER COMPANY,a 31. : Dockat Nes. _"" * 'MA4 354tsOLA 3 i (Vestis Electric Geomrudas Plant, Ras IJanasa Ammedment ' Valls1and2) 3 (Fransfer to . ; Southern Nuclear) - ARLEP No. 9347101A-3 ! AppenAvfr nF MarsrArr W. W6-YuW _ _ . I. vi% W. Ennan, bains My swom, stats as fblIows: ' t i
- 1. )
I am causady employed by southam Nuclair opmadng Wa u PzWest Managar - Nudsar TedrJcal Services. 1 I am My anthadasd to vedly Georgia rPower "7ay's Rasponse to - Intervenor's Seventh Raquest for Intrao=~i==, specifically the respacaca to Is' Nos. 2.s., 2.b. and 3.c. I hereby cettfy that the safemmts and opinions in sucf: responas are true and con to the beat of my penaral knowledga a .d belief.
. m .
6 I J kN J - L Micnaat W. Marian Sween $ and A4socibed befoso res this d day of August,1994
- w
- My canudsskarespires:
t~ - 1 l e w----..m . - .- .-..---,m. . , , - , , , - - . - - - w -- , . _ , , . - - _.c.m-,,-
gg,Y .jf7
- 74It$I(( 4c4e .. oss2sses 7
/N LTITED ST Exhibit ,page ]
- oz. - ..ATES OF -r AMERIch a -
tatene yrt 19entto si, ri awn ttca--fue manen . In the 1 tatter of a SECESIA POWER CCBCPANY, Ak gl. s Doaket aros. so-424.otA-3
. 8 59-425=0!A-3 (vegtle 31estrie semerating 71 tat, Res Lisesse EmanA= eat Unita 1 mai 2) t
- (Tramatar to
- Southers 3ruelear) a 132.37 3ro. 93-871 084-3 Apyrnavr, er v.y. xvc=---- -
I, W.F. Kitchens, being duly sworn, state as follows: 1. I am currently employed by uservia Power company as Assistant General Manager - Plant support, Vogtle Electrio Generating Plant. 2. I an duly authorized to. verify Georgia Power Company's Response to Intervanor's seventh Request for Interrogatories , specifically the responess to Interrogatory Fos. 2.a., 2.b., 2.c., 3.a., 3.b., and 3.c. I heraby certify that the statements and opinions in such raaponse are true and correct to the best of my personal knowledge and belief. l M fa t a w it. F . Kitchens sh Sworn to and subscribed before me this (* day
- of A t, 994.'
//)En .,
N6tary
' LLC Q" Ny
- issipn
.7JIv e2eS I i
~~
- l Y , e :..* ' .. . .*.*~ Uf.: .,,
**=b.h -
[ E h .b s . .
~
$ e. .
5 o s a se v. - . =
*<=r,-
.. 'I eY 5 /.h TUTA., P.82
_AU,G,-09. .-
. .,.1994- - 17:31 N ;.' e.e7 to
' '7.~.4U.*.<4 M 493,;,5,...u-ses-sses I 706 825 3889** 8 Exhibit .Page of-()- - . _
wwrtzo srArts or Ammarca
~ ~~ ~
i Nucz,anx Azovaroar courrssrax naraan ren na=,e =.n.er are ur--=1-. l an... 1
)
i za the matter of : 830BSEA POWER ctnEFANr, At 41 : oostet wes. so-4 4-au-a i
~
. s9=43s-OZA=3 '
(Vogtle Electris Generating Plant, : Re License Amendment Dmits 1 and 3) : l'Fransfer to southers Nucleer) i j asLap No. 93-s72-osa-3 aryrnativ e, sm-r. m. wr-----v Z, Paul M. Kochery, being duly sworn, state as follows: 1.
! an currently empicysd by Georgia Power Company as i
Engineering Supervisor, Vogtle Electric Consrating Plant. 2. I an duly authorized to verify Georgia Power company's Response to Intervenor's seventh Request for Interrogatories , specifically the responses to Interrogatory Noe. 2.a., 2.b., 3.c., 4., 5.. 6., and 7. I hereby certify that the sta .a.% 'ts and opinions in such response are true and correct to'the best of my personal knowioage and hellef. j a. v Y T
- Paul M. Kochery /
sworn to and subs bed before as this da of August 1994. S DFW Public N My en tre
- hr /, 119 WW e, s
~
; ~.;i<.: ' E r * .9 q -
- - . . . . \]L 5 '.E lurr , ..
?]_; -
~___-
.AU.G..-08.
. .. 17,:29 FDO*
.1.?.94 ,
r*TLE Tech. SUPPORT TO . 9 *-424-395- M P,82 _ c.84 i Tsu1AM : 4048. ,5. - 7CS #25 3686;r 2 l h Exhibit .Page OL i UNITED STAT _ m . . . _ES OF AMERICA - .. masotr Pre mestvc aivETY in LTE==siYrs annah j 2a the matter of :
- -t 5303014 7DfER COMPANY, 31 A1. : Dookst som. So-424-oL4-3 {
- e 5s-415-OL&-3 l (Tegtle Electric generating Plaat, ne Lisease Amenaisant
- Unita 1 maa 2) s (Transfer te !
j
- southera 3ruslaar)
", g . j 1
ASL37 NO. 93-571-OL2=3
*[, ,
t myytnivn er Dam, n. nesnya I, Paul D. Rushton, being duly svern, state as fo11cva: 2. I am currently er. ployed by coorgia Power compa.rry as ! shift superintendent, Vogtle tiectric Generating Plant. 2. I an duly authorized to verify Georgia Power company's Response to Intervencr's seventh Request for Interrogatories, specifically the responses to Interrogatory Nos. 2.c. and 3.b. I hereby certify that the statenents and opinions in such response are true and correct 'to the best of my personal kncviedge and belief. l l& Paul D. Rushton
--x
~
sworn to and subscribed before as this FS day .
$h~
..t.r .
"' ", ,'",."C**Rc -r. , in /
ggah,v.sr
T.. '
/
( =:.4
., J .*.
- i R.'*...
; +:
1 1 5
- . n. 0. .n :- 4 5*. -:,'. *Y -
- O -((
-? ?
i
.* d?
~s ~% r;* .,~}/ .
'[,.^*' =- ~-= - . =
i
~, _,._
I 1 l
, A.G-09-1994 17:31 FROM 8/'~TLE TECH. SLPoCRT TO ? * .134-685-M P.06
--,--+-"-e o- o ; 1:ssvu ; 4045 .5 -
706 523 3888:s10 d --- Exhibit .Page-51rITID STATE 8 QF 1XE12C1 NUCLEAR 13GUIATORY COMMIS8 ION nureen een 1=orre m1F a = Arn tre h ermo a m *w __ In the Matter of a t escueIa 1PotrIR coaorAarf, .31 a],. Docket 3ios. 80-484-CLk=3 8 50-4at-OLE.3
- s Le Ilestric Generating Plant, 3 Re: Lietase Amendment (Transfer to Ets1massi t
- southers 3ruelaar) !
ASL37 RD. 93-671-OLA-3 1 AFFYBav2P OF wwwMr asi1m wT I, Mehdi #heibani, being duly sworn, state as fellows: 1. I am currently a= ployed by Georgia Power company as i i Engineering Supervisor, vogtle Electric Generati.w Plant. ' 2. I as duly authorized to verify Georgia Power Company's Respones to Intervanor's Savanth Request for Interrogatories , specifically the response to Intarrogatory No.13. I hereby cartify that the stataments and opinions in such respones are true and correct to the best of my paracnal h.nowledge and belist. [ , [ h}f / I AeKdi Shelbani
- Sworn to and subs bed before me his y ofAyat 1994 DrsAsK note Publiv' v '
' " # V J " h %" ' -
W _/###48'1g..
- ~,',:j... I ~'..$**
~ ,
I! ';. <.'.' -. ~
' ' ~?s%
iW IEi \
;* -: i tj i
. s. . < .
- v9 .; :
' ..;g;. g ..A 3i ? - . - - -
\
~ . . . -
M HB9-19,94
-m. ir e . *se 17:31 FROM- 'r"LE TECH. SUPACRT '
we TG 9 * .104-685-3900 P.00 - e-gg ; 1:3;pg ; 4042 5. .
- 70s 825 35se:st) e Exhibit .Page CI---
{ UNITED STAT 38 0F AMIEZCA arecLama R3832AroILY coxEZ88ZON i { 2atoom enna smouve anweer awn nas-nse nom =p ! Zu the Matter of a I t esameZ& 79FER clatPAarr, .3131. t Doeket 3res. 80-4a4-cLA-3 l I 50-425*0LA-3 (Yogtle zientris Generating Plant, s: Re Liosase Ammadment Unita 1 mas a) : (Truasfer to 8 asuthera 3rustent) t \ ASL37 3rD. 93=673=08.&-3 arrinarrr er b-e n c. sia a I, Kenneth C. stokes, being duly sworn, state as followns ! 1 1. I am currently employed by Georgia' Power Campany as i senior Engineer, vogtle Electrio cenerating Plant. 2. I an duly authorized to verify Georgia Power company's Response to Intervener's Seventh Request for Interrogatories , j specifically the responses to Interrogatory Nos. 1., 2.a., 2.b., ! 3.c., 4., 5., 7., ) 8., and 12. 4 I hereby certify that the statements and opinions in such responas are true and correct to ths best of my personal knowledge and belief. 5snneth C. Stokes \ 8vorn to and subs before as this Lg bed day Bethey j MkLtc 'M , , . . , MY Nj[an ..: .1: :. -
,ipp1 j; ~:j
. :.~~,c > .,}>\ *
.-. s . ,s
. -; e
..A e i'* U ., G .
. ',wy * ;**/..-f .yy,r
***e_.-one , -- . . .
I
l i AuG-es-1994 14:es 'FROM 9r-utst.E ENG4.!C- TO N #*0# Exhibit ,page of- l 'O _ 1 r ,r ra oP4M >c.
~ - ~
NUCIAAR REGUIXIORY avusmerrw Mabme tha A'
- taAssw emel7 a' r *'"
)
h the Matar of
- ) Docist Non. $W '" A.-3
.) $N254LA.3 .
GBORGIA POWER COMPANY, ) J et al.
) Re: Lloenas A h i
) M to sambarn (Yostle maatric Gesadas -) Nacisar) ,
Plant, Units 1 and 2) )- l
) AEI2P No. 934714142[.A-3
)
APPFDAVIT OF L1tWI!t A_ WADD I, Imis A. Wani, having Smt bem ddy sworn, bamby depam and mate a i
- 1. -
I am employed by Southern Nudsar operadag e'my as Manager, Nucll 2. I am dey authoried to vidfy osargia Power my's Resp == m Intervanor's Seventh Raquest forIntermFavMme, spoolfgaHy the resp 2.c. and 3.b. , f I hereby certif that the statements and opinions in such ;p are true and co
.j the beat of my persecal knowledge and belief.
b. sworn m d me imis A. Wani beibre une this { _ day : of August,1994. m, , e A dww i Micomadsslan supbec > 7/n
' = T .14 9 '7 .
i m 1.1. , O- .
~ . ~ . .. . -
e i
p: , -
)
f$_:-l r
. -l , q Exhibit ,page_ of-
' {
-]- ;
xf . . .. _. . _ _ _ . . . -_ ,_ . _ .- . . . . ~ : UNITED STATES OF AMERICA : NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION - i
' D fore the Atomic Safety and Licensine hard '!
)'
~
-In the Matter of. ) Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA i
)- 50-425-OLA-3 l GEORGIA POWER COMPANY, ) _
et al. ) .. Re: License Amendment ' '
). - (Transfer to Southern .
(Vogtle Electric Generating' ') Nuclear) i Plant, Units 1 and 2) - ) .
- i
) ASLBP No. 93 671-01-OLA t l
CEx 111 ICATE OF SERVICE ' L I hereby certify that copies of Georgia Power Company's Response to Intervenor's i Seventh Request for Interrogatories, dated August 8,199_4, were served by express mail. j upon the persons listed on the attached service list this 8th' day of August,1994 Thomas L.- Penland, Jr. .
. TROUTMAN SANDERS -
Suite 5200 - i 600 Peachtree Street, N.E.' 'I Atlanta, GA 30308-2216 1
.t
.(404) 885-3471 i t
I O ! l I l l
1 Exhibit ,page of UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of GEORGIA POWER COMPANY,
- Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA-3 gt al.
- 50-425-OLA-3 (Vogtle Electric
- Re: License Amendment
~
Generating Plant, * (Transfer to Southern Units 1 and 2)
- Nuclear)
- ASLBP No. 93-671-01-OLA-3 SERVICE LIST ,
l Administrative Judge Stewart D. Ebneter Peter B. Bloch, Chairman Regional Administrator Atomic Safety and Licensing USNRC, Region II l Board 101 Marietta Street, NW U.S. Nuclear Regulatory ) Suite 2900 ' Commission Atlanta, Georgia 30303 i Two White Flint North 11545 Rockville Pike Office of the Secretary Rockville, MD 20852 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (j) (~ Administrative Judge James H. Carpenter Washington, D. C. 20555 ATTN: Docketing and Atomic Safety and Licensing Services Branch Board 933 Green Point Drive Charles Barth, Esq. Oyster Point Office of General Counsel Sunset Beach, NC 28468 One White Flint North Stop 15B18 Administrative Judge U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Thomas D. Murphy Commission Atomic Safety and Licensing Washington, D. C. 20555 Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Director, Commission Environmental Protection Two White Flint North Division 11545 Rockville Pike Department of Natural Rockville, MD 20852 Resources 205 Butler Street, S.E. ' Michael D. Kohn, Esq. Suite 1252 Kohn, Kohn & Colapinto, P.C. Atlanta, Georgia 30334 517 Florida Avenue, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20001 Office of Commission Appellate Adjudication One White Flint North 11555 Rockville Pike Rockville, MD 20852 l
** t ~
l Exhibit 16s&A
,page- of __
\
,( UNITED. STATES _OF AMERICA- . _
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Before Administrative-Judges: Peter B. Bloch, Chair Dr. James H. Carpenter Thomas D. Murphy
) ,
In the Matter of )
) Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY ) 50-425-OLA-3 21 AL., )
) Re: License Amendment (Vogtle Electric Generating ) (transfer to Southern Nuclear)
Plant, Unit 1 and Unit 2) )
) ASLBP No. 93-671-01-OLA-3 INTERVENOR'S SEVENTH REQUEST FOR INTERROGATORIES TO GEORGIA POWER COMPANY I. INTRODUCTION
,y
)
(~/ Pursuant to 10. C.F.R. 52.740b, Allen Mosbaugh hereby requests that Georgia Power Company (hereinafter referred to as "GPC") answer the fellowing interrogatcries in writing and under oath, and produce any documents requested herein that have not already been produced. II. INSTRUCTIONE A. .If you cannot answer a particular interrogatory in full, after exercising due diligence to secure the information to do so, so state and answer to the extent possible, specifying and explaining you inability to answer the remainder and stating whatever information or knowledge you have concerning the unanswered portion. B. Each interrogatory is a continuing one, and should be gs supplemented as required by 10 C.F.R. 52.74 0 (e) . I O
)b b
n - n i Exhibit ,page of -
- c. If you claim that any information which is required.to
~
, s
'be provided'by y'ou~inyour response to any of these interrogatories.is privileged or immune from discovery:
- 1. Identify the portion of the interrogatory to which such information-is otherwise the response;
- 2. If the information is a document or oral communication, identify the document's title or the oral' ,
communication and state the general subject matter of the document or oral communication;
- 3. If the information is a document or oral ,
communication, state the date of the document or oral communication.
- 4. If a document, identify its author (s) and the 7- person (s) for whom it was prepared or to whom it was sent, I \
\s_/ including all persons who received copies;
- 5. If an oral communication, identify all persons !
present at the time of the oral communication:
- 6. State the nature of the privilege or immunity i claimed; and
- 7. State in detail each and every fact upon which you base your claim of privilege or immunity from discovery.
D. In each case where you are asked to identify or to state the identify of a document or where the answer to the interrogatory refers to a document, state with respect to each such document:
- 1. The identify of the person who prepared it; 2
t s.s/
+ - - -
e
=
Exhibit .,page- of:
- /Nd 2. The identity of all persons ~who' reviewed or '
, 1. a; i
.. . . - - -., , . . . . ~ . .
approved it; .;
- a. .
3.- .The identity of-the person who signed it, or over , whose name it-was issued;
- 4. The identity of the addressee.or addressees;
- 5. The nature and substance of the document:with sufficient' particularity;to. enable'the same to be ;
identified;
- 6. The date of the document; and
- 7. The present location of the document and the identity and address of each person who has custody of the '!
document.
'E. In each case where you are required to identify an oral.
~
communication, or where the answer to the interrogatory refers to an oral communication, state with respect thereto:
- 1. The date and place thereof; ;
I
- 2. The identity of each person who participated in or- -
heard any part of the' communication;.
- 3. If the communication was by. telephone, so indicate and state'who initiated the telephone call; l
- 4. The substance of what was said by each person who i participated in the communication; and. -
- 5. The-location and the identity and address of the custodian of any document (including any mechanical, .
magnetic, electrical or electronic recording)'that recorded,
- summarized, reported or confirmed the oral communication. N i
I
;f 3
'k j
Exhibit ,page of _ F. In each instance where you are asked to identify or t
)
' state-the-identity of a person, or where the answer to an ~
interrogatory refers to'a person, state with respect to each such person:
- 1. His/her name;
- 2. His/her last known business and residence addresses and telephone numbers;
- 3. If an individual, his/her business affiliation or employment at the date of the transaction, event or matter referred to; and
- 4. If a corporation or association, the business or activity in which it was engaged at the date of the transaction, event or matter referred to.
III. DEFINITIONS
,( 3,
(,s/ A. As used herein, the terms " Licensee", " Georgia Power Company", "The Southern Company", "SONOPCO", "ycu", or "Your" and any synonym thereof and derivative therefrom are intended to, and shall, embrace and include every agent or employee of Georgia i Power Company, The Southern Company, and/or SONOPCO, past or ; present, their counsel and all their respective agents, servants, associates, employees, representatives, private investigators, , and others who are or have been in possession of or may have j obtained information for or on behalf of each person listed in any manner with respect to any matter referred to in these j 1 interrogatories. 4
./'~N ,
j $ '
\,_/
o a Exhibit ,page of l 3xH B. As used herein, the term'" documents" includes any r i () -- - writtenr recorde'd or graphic matter, however' produced'or reproduced, of every kind and regardless of where located, ; including but not limited to any summary,: schedule, memorandum, i note , statement, letter, telegram, interoffice communication, - report, diary, desk or pocket calendar or notebook, daybook, appointment book, pamphlet, periodical, work sheet, cost sheet, . list, graph, chart, index, tape, record, partial or complete report of telephone or oral conversation, compilation, tape recordings made by Intervenor, tabulation, study, analysis, transcript, minutes, and all other memorials of any conversations, meetings, and conferences by telephone or - otherwise, and any other writing or recording which is in the i possession, custody or control of the Licensee or any employees, representatives, attorneys, investigators, or others acting on his behalf. C. As used herein, the terms "and" and "or" shall each mean and/or. D. As used herein, the " Allen Mosbaugh" and the term
" petitioner" or "intervenor" shall mean Allen Mosbaugh, the Intervenor in this proceeding.
E. As used herein, the term "date" shall mean the exact , day, month, and year, if ascertainable, or if not, the best-approximation thereof, including relationship to other events. 5 i 9
E Exhibit ,page- of F. As used herein, the term " person" shall mean any i- _' -- individual, partnership, firm, association,- corporation or other government, legal or business entity. G. As used herein, the term " detail" and the phrases " state in detail" and " describe in detail" shall mean that you are , requested to state, with specificity, each and every fact, ultimate fact, circumstance, incident, act, omission, event and date, relating to or otherwise pertaining to the matters inquired , of in said-interrogatory. H. As used herein, the term "NRC" shall mean'the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, an agency of the Federal Government, and any and all offices within the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, including NRC Staff, NRC Office of Investigations, and all their respective attorneys, agents, servants, associates, j N is ,) employees, representatives, investigators. IV. INTERROGATO?.*ES
- 1) In respect to all analysis performed prior to any I hearing held in :his proceeding concerning any trip, failure or probleml experienced by any of Plant Vogtle's diesel generators.
(1A, 1B, 2A and/or 2B) between Jan 1, 1990 and present, provide the following information: a) S: ate the cause(s) or suspected cause(s) of the , failure, trip, or problem; 1 1 As herein used the term " Problem" is used as in the April ! 9, 1990 Corrective Action response letter. l i 6 l
/~'; ; !s/ l l
I Exhibit ,page of_ j- b) State whether the cause or causes were determined ( ).
^' - -
to' constitute the " root cause" for the trip; failure or problem; c) State whether the analysis indicated any similarity with any other failure, trip or problem experienced; d) State whether any form of " root cause" assessment was ever determined; I e) State whether any corrective action was taken or ! planned.
- 2) The April 9, 1990 COA states on page 3, No. 4, that "GPC has reviewed air quality of the diesel generator air system including dewpoint control." With respect to this statement.
respond to the following: a) Who was responsible for conducting this review; I b) What source documents were inspected or reviewed; A k ,). c) Ecw was the information transmitted to the drafter of the COA.
- 3) The Apr;'. 9, 1990 CCA on page 3, No. 4 states that
" initial reports of higher than expected dewpoints were later attributed to faulty instrumentation". With respect to this i
statement, respond to the following: j a) Identify each and every piece of faulty equipment believed to be responsible for the higher than expected readings; b) Identify the author of this phase; c) What documents were relied upon to conclude instruments were faulty; Who relied upon this information; and, 7 (D V
~'
7 u x . y p- <
..g -
*1 V o w :.? Exhibit ,page s of _
-4 What form of verification was conducted to determine-the accuracy p ..___. _
of.this information;" ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~
'~^ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~
- 4) State'whether any engineers, managers or. technicians p
observed-water " pouring out" of; any ' diesel - trips line (s) . ! _ 5)' State the identity of any technician or. personnel who: b
- ' Esaw a jar of fluid which came from' a diesel trip line.
6)~ Identify any personnel with knowledge of water in the: K diesel starting air system'or the diesel air receivers. For each o such person state the sum and substance of their knowledge (including how-they obtained it, who they learned--it from'and anyone-they told of-it.). l
- 7) State'who witnessed and performed thel" initial {
inspection of one air receiver on April 6, 1990,"_ identified in
., the April 9, 1990 COA. For each such person identified state
-} whether they observed any residue in the receiver.
- 8) State the date and time the air receiver identified in interrogatory 7 above, was ever subjected to an internal inspection. With respect.to each'such' inspection state:
-l a) What residue was found; b) Whether any water was located; c) Identify any-records of each'such inspection.
- 9) Identify all procedures and requirements contained in .
the MT&E program or any other program that must be followed when
-a piece of test equipment, specificallylany ALNOR, EG&G or any other dewpoint. necessary. equipment is:
a) suspected of being out of. calibration;
-\
[
j- - ,
** l .l
- l{'. , _
', ,7- .. g. . ,
; .- - x ) :
5
' Exhibit' , page _. of _ .:
*4 b) out-of calibration; h-t a . .
c).~_ suspected of~beingifaulev: ' d) determined' to be faulty. 4 10); istate what, if any, action required under any procedure
' addressed in interrogatory 9'above, was taken with respect to Cry. ^
. piece of test equipment suspected oflbeing~ faulty in the April 9, . '
-1990 COA.
- 11) With respect to. diesel generator 1B, state'the~ start '
number, date.-and timi when "the bugs" were worked out'according: { to Mr. Bockhold. I
- 12) State the date and times dryers were out of service in 1990. Provide information as to'what records were maintained.and i
- a. summary of information contained in those records for the year
,_ 1990. If no records exist or.are maintained, then so state.
- 13) state all factual information contained in any outside' l i
operator round' sheets concerning. moisture.or water when " blowing - 1 down" any diesel air receiver from June'1989'to June 199* U Respectfully submitted,
!f5.}',.f;1y'j',hy?hb e ,
)
Mary J,{ne Wilmoth KOHN, KOHN &.COLAPINTO,.P.C. , 517 Florida'. Ave., N.W. . l Washington,' D.C. 20001-1850 ! (202)234-4663 i
- 1 Attorney for Intervenor l
i DATED this 25th day of July 1994. inter 7.gpc. 9 a r www z y q -9*rWM --'T"'TF+T 7>
- o ,
t
. . -)
Exhibit ,page of - UNITED STATES OF AMERICA [' s,s - _. .- - - - . NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
- ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING. BOARD
) f In the Matter of - ) -
); Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY ) 50-425-OLA-3 l 21 AL., ) i
) Re: License Amendment !
(Vogtle Electric Generating )- (transfer to Southern Nuclear)
. Plant, Unit 1 and Unit 2) )
) ASLBP No. 93-671-01-OLA-3 '
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that Intervenor's Seventh Set of . . Interrogatories to Georgia Power Company has been served this ; 25th day'of July, 1994, by first class mail upon the persons listed in the attached Service List, with the exception that-it was served by hand delivery as indicated by "*".
'M "
I ' J.01 - * :m ' . ,'t .ih i , By: j; ,i l Mary Jarje Wilmcch, Esq.~ ~D ; x KOHN, KOHN & COLAPINTO, P.C. 1 517 Florida Ave., N.W. Washington, D.C. 20001 (202) 234-4663
~
~
1 1 I 1 i_ ,_
Exhibit ,page of-UNITED STATES OF AMERICA G- NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD -.
)
In the Matter of )
) Docket Nos. 50-424-OLA-3 GEORGIA POWER COMPANY ) 50-425-OLA-3 31 AL,, )
) Re: License Amendment (Vogtle Electric Generating Plant, Unit 1 and Unit 2)
) (transfer to Southern Nuclear)
)
). ASLBP No. 93-671-01-OLA ~,
SERVICE LIST Administrative Judge Peter B. Bloch, Chair Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Administrative Judge James H. Carpenter 933 Green Point Drive Oyster Point Sunset Beach, NC 28468 Administrative Judge Thomas D. Murphy Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Charles A. Barth, Esq. Office of General Counsel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 John Lamberski, Esq. Troutman Sanders Suite 5200 ~ 600 Peachtree Street, N.E. Atlanta, GA 30308-2216 l
- Ernest L. Blake, Jr. I David R. Lewis I SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & i TROWBRIDGE 2300 N Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20037 2 l O
~
Th
... ., s
._ ; .. x .
1
. _ . +
2-. Exhibith,page of ; office'of the Secretary l
. . . . _ ___.--Attn:-Docketing and-Service - - ~~ - - - - - - - - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - - ~ "~
j U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
-Washington, D.C. ;20555?
l office of Commission Appellate ! Adjudication l U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 l 301\ cert.lis l i i l l t I l i 4 i 3 i i
-m- m. .-- . . - _ _ , . . - . . , _ .}}