ML20085N600
| ML20085N600 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 05/17/1995 |
| From: | AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| To: | |
| References | |
| OLA-3-I-MOSBA-5, NUDOCS 9506300255 | |
| Download: ML20085N600 (10) | |
Text
?
F AdoST36 - 5 I
of If
,page-o
.9 A 7; JUN -6 P2 :33 DOCKET t G SER/1 BRANCH Soutaern Electric S stem o<
Per~ormance Pa Piar Survey 1990 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Dxtet No.
25-A-
Offcial Exh. No In+ f in t.1e m3Mr of 6 PC
- 4 nl.
Staff IDENTIFIED Apphcant RECEIVED Intereact 7
REJECTED Contg Oftr SONOPCO"Pr~oject U""
v70mdE?Is Og
~pvrur en ao ir'nannaam PDR
' Exhibit _E-,page 2 of'.lE
~
V0GTLE PPP SURVEY FEEDBACK r
(
PLAKEV06TLE SEE
SUMMARY
TAB:
None of the overall dimensions were positive; however, all either improved or remained the same since 1989.
POSITIVE FINDINGS:
THE 1990 PAY PLAN (PPP):
1.
Has been explained to me in such a way that I understand it.
WITH REGARD T0 G0AL SETTING IN THE PPP
~6.
I understand the corporate goals used in the PpP.
- 21. Accomplishing my individual goals contribi!tes to the achievement of our organizational goals.
IN GENERAL:
61.
Increasing competition represents a majrr threat to our company.
- 64. I would like to continue working under some type of performance pay plan.
NEGATIVE FINDINGS:
THE1990PERFORMANCEPAYPLAN(PPP):
2.
Is Dat having positive effects on the company's perfomance.
3.
Is nat having a positive effect on my work habits and performance.
4.
Doesn't offer enough money in the incentive portion to make it work.
5.
Will n21 appropriately compensate me for my contributions.
l Voctie had a good payout. Why dit the people-feel thfr ny7
(
Did the large numbers of people rated in the top two blocks have an affect on this? They might have believed they were going to receive a 15-20% incentive increase.
Inflated performance ratings apparently hurt.
i i
i 3
- Denotes items of high interest 20-Jul-1990 4
Exhibit I, page). c&l C V0GTLE PPP SURVEY FEEDBACK O
WITH REGARD TO GOAT. SETTING IN THE PPP:
7.
I don't see the connection between my individual goals and the corporate goals.
8.
My manager has n21 asked fr my input in understanding the results of last year's survey.
9.
My P.*P incentive payment was nat based on my job performance.
- 11. The PPP goals of my organization are more difficult than the goals of other organizations.
13.
It is n21 possible to achieve our PPP organizational goals at the top level'. (5~ level 'of performance)
- 14. Work groups inside my organization do ng1 cooperate in accomplishing our organizational goals.
- 24. My individual goals leave out important aspects of my job that are difficult to measure.
- 25. As a result of having individual goals, my co-workers are less willing to help e:e other.
- 26. To reach our 198'." organizational goals, people made decisions which will hurt m/ organization in the long run.
- 27. Accomplishing my individual goals is beyond my control.
- 28. As circumstances change I will ng1 be able to change my individual goals to make them more appropriate.
NY 1990 INDIVIDUAL G0ALS 00 HQI REQUIRE ME TO:
c I'
('
- 29. Be more flexible in dealing with my customers, supervisor, and co-workers.
- 34. Take intelligent risks.
MY MANAGER / SUPERVISOR !$ HQI EFFECTIVE AT:
- 35. Treating all employees in my r,roup fairly and consistently.
@ De-onstratino a strono beligf that chances ooina on in the company are necessary.
^
rww3ui;W ud rewarding peoite based en ne+r-my 8'.
Encouraging and environment o en communications.
(li. Gi v iuv..e mur...wiuiMc:t. e w.d = %.
orm my job.
- 41. Helping me, in a positive.tay, to understand how the PPP works.
- 42. Getting my work group to function as a team.
- 43. Convey.ing the resul<ts, he/she expects of me.
- 44. Comunicating about organizational goals and my role in helping to achieve them.
- 45. Giving me the authority to make decisions I need to make.
- 46. Taking the right action with poor performers.
l,,(
l
- Denotes items of high interest 20-Jul-1990
Exhibit _.1,pageI ofli l
~
V6GTLE PPP SURVEY FEEDBACK (v~h IN GENERAL:
47.
I am ng1 paid fairly compared with other employees in my company who do similar work.
- 48. Employees are agl rewarded for acquiring new skills.
Are people told in performance feedback sessions that they have some developmental needs and they should improve in certain areas.
Then, either management doesn't provide developmental opportunities or reward the acquisition of new skills?
- 49. Written informatien en the PPP has not helped me to underst7nd the
[O y es are afraid to voice an opinion management does agt wan 5 2'.
There are not ways for employees to formally participate in solving problems for the company.
- h. People in my organization do ng.t trust each other.
- 55. Unnecessary change is occurring within our company.
in-- nt is not succortino the chances coino on.
@ The officers of my company are att aware of the problems at mp l evel.
E7 When I make suggestions for imorevement. I am ionored.
l
(.
@ Ther s an 9000 up and down comunications throughout th
' make the PPP work.
59.
I w'as ngl given the training I need.-
60.
I was agl giving training in how to 1'rective goals.
- 62. Managers did nat use last year's s' vc data to improve the anaration of the organization.
[* h >I'am afraid to voice an opinion thatlify'manewcaCoesn't want ea-66.
I do nat understand how my base salary increase was determined.
WRITTEN COPf4ENTS:
POSITIVE:
People liked being judged on merit and the money.
NEGATIVE:
They didn't like the lack of fairness and favoritism of the allocations. They felt the goal quality was poor, too trivial, too easy to achieve, and too subjective.
P
- Denotes items of high interest 20-Jul-1990 6
1
Exhibit S,page 5 of l
~
f l
w e
e M
~3 N
O O
g-a E
5 e
m e
m M
e S
e g$
J C
a:
N x
sad
.a e,'i.
ee e
'e w
{A v.y (4
a a
Q m
m f
N
.h
.p.$ '
l
- jdme h
[^
-4
- -.gk:: ess se se
. {3 4
-e s se 7p w s.e se
,,. g es se
.th eme.
1
=
em v,a.(p M.g <>g
> ; /-
em
- g-
-t,#i
.,.9.>
aw
- 3. %
em p.: :.
^
s w q e.
.f4 me g
}
g e6 6 ';J g ge g en xWS g en
,5 : W S g 44 X.c; 4W tt M mg M
e 3
p ee
(?.
g ap Q p
wQ
^WW
- = 0
- >ek eQ O
e "w
- x 4
" w*
."E t."M
- ~
as
- 4. ;.
6 m "w
.E
-;%,. NF e-Jr'4%N' I:3ffM
^ lg+:. *=
d0
..3.,. 4m.*
v p aw fah g
w Q
g j
MOMj f:M:p3 f..
yp;M f
$6gf!
gy$pd'
[Tw
@lP' m *
&g
,ha 3
f1;M4D e
S'sM T
seqGN 4
- nq ce
.m:&.
v4 wo van I.
Otb W
.3 - -
h (M
M ?>Yp Y
E DMD.f
'tMN w
g ID$Ei!
i$$$
IkN Nb
$8lI3 4$d5
~$$
9}8
'D lO O
%;l}
Y.l$
w;ff
\\ch:SW
?&SA 5
s.%
m 4
- - Q. M.$
MW y24'$
.pd7 i
Q' f"'4
% 3 t #;dw.
^ ~nm,
- LR y.y.;g.,
W OM y% 0%
si
. f%onn m
[
fyr een
{l?Lyp A om o
m a
s:om m
',p e
I L.^
.. pi se
- Mknas se
.ge em
,,8;se se ey$ ee se 9=
w A*h, 5:e:ee em ric%.-
'if I T..*:,(>
4 O
J'J4
- "g (W es e a"rWq es p+-
em s---
w ee r:
g, e
e ee g en a
BE en g44
': BE g 44 9WS g en
- W g an ntW GQ x
W bQ e
e
-y
.; W W eQ 4'B W
>Q i,WW NO
-. O W Dp a
E *- A
< e'e E na
- =
<Mw
,FE.Ee Na E M4
- te E N&
- 9E ML m'.S. w T
e w
.' u.; w w
w g
w s-aw w
- w w
ee
-g 6
"4
- s'.
o s
Z K
==
4 z
warieg g s
?
G aegwggg angar g g e wetg g g gggggg ge ne g g v b es m e w B e ts en en N M*NMW
- b W " D en M et Pt o w P2D.S W - 0 4
- M M
MMP 94 W D e **
. M *"
46 4 * *"
M M *" e
^
~
O e
mM,
,
- rg *
,, l3%
. 9 c :4
., Q#9
- ya
. 7.
".N2
%.9*
O l.?.yd w
.s
< 'tl}
?!b
,f.k
+i":&
N:h.x b 4
A
'N ena
,Tb w taa U( ena and
.,.e-Olad as4 I. ~ [ I: tea tea ame
- > 4 aan w m aan sen
< s asa saa
- M een aan
, *,( w
$ans tes O
w aan
,,.4:&. m: ess W
u.., e gg g a,n. g g s g g
.bg g
e.e
.'N'."
g g 6C 0 88 7 G 0 0 GWMQ O og 6~WO C
ha v.y e 4 g
d '~w O Q
, ens ec an d (
ma 4
- am ;, ha d ans n w(
(
L 4 4 W.
w am, eh s
am. 44 f
ne se me
==
, ~
. es..
en 4
.m et, e4
.. e4
- m se e
w em ee
' esa we se
.W D G O O
~,O O
k O O 4H
, %, O O
- :n O O g
.we t ~.4.- n
~
g s.,
4
.J <
0 w ins >
> ii4 >
F.s > i.a >
> ;:- > eis >
. > w > i.s >
om > iia >
si.e_t.i.
EI.aw 4
g
.e w s u.J w e II.e sw.st.e!.!.
aw
.4 w g
l il
= lit w E El it
.e..
O
=J.J a* >
J oe k
.J.J oe >
.J.J o= >
.d.J M >
.J d ee p g
.A W GSMOW M O EA S WWOM M 93OW
- @ N en o en 49 WMQM k
wt w
as at m
ne:n 8
W
> =
8 e,
-).=.s
,k,, e
,k,,
y DC 3C J
sI A
I.
GAS w
z J
5 !-
O s_gg
(
a ;
l s
e b
g !
E I
~
no
m.
G
~
^
m PPP SURVEY RESULTS ITEM OS: IN QENERAL. I AN AFRAID TO VOICE AN OPINION THAT MY MANAGEMENT DOESN'T WANT TO HEAR OWEASIISTION Pueff VoGTLE / SONOPCO NAY 1990 JUNE 1909 la M
NSM (af tt00f Af 5P0mst MSPomSE MANAGqR
((S ^
IEthN..
70 - D - @P'%k-#d' fl$NM M @ @h g i % S 0
SL I
b/
.1 k
5 17 DISAWtEE
'LAGREE 12%
SLI M LY DI 53%
71%
STRONGLY DI$AOREE 8%
(POSITIVE)
Y *
- NS
_ S fs
(
y
?n l
(0'9{ pf}0%'.
~
' L - {[
MSdh)Fi + 3%'iO$E.f
'#495NSI$iT$N i
M, h..
k{ AMA23%' ~ UkWGATtVE)f$A 4-Mi.dd.%)$Msf M a8
,w SLItMTLY DIJAGREE 10%
DISAGREE 30%
51%
STRONOLY DI$AOREE 11%
(POSITIVE)
QASES18%p (QE6$ p:g ;t10% d11%D g.? Wit " f 1Ai: J@ggif"MMPQph 3
_@g4;4E%8&e:W'...
$6TNBAL NS EXEMPT g
UNMM4 j
af47%#
l AsgL3mqf)3 Estisdr4 umssonst AM (pageAt sit Ad M w ia s.wu m er gjo SLIGfTLY DI) AGREE 15%
DISAGREE 27%
53%
STRONGLY DI$ AGREE 11%
(POSITIVE) eb NkENi[I,bfd NtNi-[tJ.qq)Nfs i{N M.!T jj!Zij(?pl-bd{EN h['bbsh!hbk b,,.
NONEXEMPT 6 STRtBIOLY ' 4EE -uTrA Q > c R3%D.
j@&6 l.
s7 SLIWffLY DISAGREE 11%
DISAGREE 18%
39%
STRONGLY DISAGREE 10%
(P05tTIVE) pmaReaa gw # m&d Miesv
{NM4fti&N6!MyjEEsf F#MA @'f
+ em@J -
Si !B
.Mf isiiisi tea R unOewN ewa dh w s1%~
a MtLteddlMtNMMJ Wfiteti.?dlle EIEEMsW<,-
to SLIGITLY DIgAGREE 11%
DISAGREE 5%
37%
STRONOLY DISAOREE 21%
(POSITIVE)
@@g ' Alth9@$y$jffgA NaaReaceMj "Eten% 1x.wypR Q1s%i Mfft00ggLi' a,i s%
,lwd[d" T "~ '
BdGM m
{sp s
i TOTAL m
jig $$
p<m' 5
T(IES& M est i
- 18LIMDAWtt#bddh
$d 20% v M
l D fdiddAA 331 SLIGHTLY DISAGREE 12%
- ar DISAGREE 25%
48%
Q i
STRONGLY DI$ AGREE 11%
(POSITIVE)
D) to (D
R
m--
.__._.-..~~-....;-_..
.._..m_.~_..__._......_m-_
C O
s
^
i PPP SURVEY RESULTS ITEM Set IN GENERAL THERE IS GOOD UP ANO DOWN CODGEUNICATION THROUGHOUT THE COMPANY (LEAD /INVOLV)
ORE 4Rel&T104 Y
PLANT V0GTLE / SONOPCO MAY 1990 JUNE 1989 f
( AllttMit
- 11 POW 11 tilPOR$t MANAGER II fMe? J:2
,? M.
. - JYS 5 % +
MM j45's:qysMc~ m-y AWtt Pl*3 F>I? ti; O,
'.cg'~ l 9%i;
'Tff%7 4 M QL gym 4%Qp933dIb-Q '
f@1SLIy,IAN$tFN.,W
?d W WE.
-(POSITIVS)S A.Wi413 mmAIP0ttflvti r 17 23 I
l i
V
)
SLIEMTLY DI) AGREE 24%
13%
i DISAGREE 18%
88%
35%
78%
STRONGLY DISAGREE 47%
(NEGATIVE) 30%
(NEGATIVE) f hlisifai, ttiR:
~
61 F7 Y1%M^.A%
1.
S A
- . 0%
rt SuRv y>
l l i:1% n
- 10E G&..eny
'!@WlM
- h:+ %m'r$% Q bM11%,.7% R#dd(P0tITIVE).'.90 103
?M.A M g
+
- s
(%
Gs4 0%
'(POSITIVE) LER6 SLS SLIEDfTLY DI'$ AGREE 31%
17%
DISAOREE 27%
90%
30%
89%
STRONGLY DI5 AGREE 32%
(NEGATIVE) 43%
(NEGATIVE)
,.14%Dz J^YML ^;%MN k' h31G;a:g.,%. 9 nj s.
j!1%Y 'c ESTNNALYi eiT%. =r:N 1% z 3:LJ-NS EXEMPT 13d W k quitg T W W W A N & t^ 'duld 3%.
bs A
SU t(Postitvelhec Ame%WNPosITIVE)'
tit 118 DstteffLVe Eubw SLIEMTLY DI) AGREE 14%
15%
DISAOREE 33%
88%
30%
87%
STRONGLY DISAGREE 38%
(NEGATIVE) 42%
(NEGATIVE)
ASTRONGLT M EE.; @s,
4 0%.
% Q 1%E -
NONEXZeePT
,e
<. e rAemst %
~$
6 su e t0% ' N o 4 w 4% 7 e2050
[5SLI Y$
SEEdhdi M ' s t7% L T(POSITIVE)hFf-bitBE.i~ Cra(POSITtVE) c 98 84 4
i SLIGHTLY DI AGREE 17%
15%
DISAGREE 29%
80%
21%
80%
STRONGLY DI$ AGREE 34%
(NEGATIVE) 43%
(NEGATIVE) l
, m.
D.d 4.s s
5',8%'CiJO @_ ^
JU M i, 4 UteGCWN
@m.STROSALY; y EE G at.
V -l7j o%,
-.;..c.
...m C
nO4j. J:M15% C >
f
%y-
$ m@ iS% e'?C(POSITIVE)i
!0519
$ AMER W b a $ g h d.t 0% i au 6% -
X(POSIT 1WE)djd iTSLI9fTLY@a W EEiosad=
18 3e SLItMTLY DI5 AGREE 30%
23%
1 DISAGREE
~
39%
94%
28%
85%
STRONGLY DIEAGREE 17%
(NEGATIVE) 33%
(NEGATIVE) a
.t: Q[y g WMOlk@t )E DSTi10ELj htthy JM% m uch&@
RAanta ny{A m k [N: f 4,0%.'
m TOTAL 1;
M53dit%'36f5$(t.
332 387 x
WMAks%Smi tS%k
- v! s%
POSITIVE)i i
diSLttfILMA4tttfh8dR Wdd1% C" 2(POSIT!Vthi.W S l
SLItHTLY DI LAGREE 21%
iS%
n-DISA0REE 30%
86%
28%
85%
STRONGLY DI) AGREE 35%
(NEGATIVE) 41%
(NEGATIVE)
Q 4
t t
t 1
D 1
su i
(O 4
(D J
9.
4 i _.
T R
O O
V V
V t
PPP SURVEY RESULTS ITEM 54: IN QENERAL, PEOPLE IN NY ORGANIZATION TRUST EACH OTHER (RESULTS) 04samu altem PLANT V0GTLE / SONOPCO NAf 1990 iJUNE 1989
'"sno'u"r '
carssey nasronse misronse mata a
misnam me ists NANAGER
?STRONGLY:A4PEEI @
.. 10%
^ 981 C. M N WE
-:F4%NNMEd?N04 i 77
%AGREEE W 4 M N A
& 36 0
%l295%MO n 630% &!/hh(5 W W M @&-
iSLIGHTLNMitttd On:
$4%
- (POSIT!VB)?nd POSITivt)2d 17 23 n
SLIG4TLY DISAGREE 12%
9%
DISAGREE 24%
41%
22%
43%
STRONQLY DISAGREE 8%
(NEGATIVE) 13%
(NEGATIVE)
-y v
<3y-e
+.. >
+3.>g FL SUPV
[$TRONOLY BE t,...
5%
. MlW: QUmi f $4%b $1 its o
L;j 4te%g.fp(40%"'@: L t
iAGREE @ t A W Ug_h 12%-
341% L % gs..
a dla4%dkA POSITIVE) A ; b et 104
.a 5LieffLYiAGREth4Ah m 231 - -(POSITIVE)nwei SLIGHTLY DISAGREE 21%
10%
DISAGREE 18%
59%
14%
54%
STRONGLY DISAGREE 22%
(NEGATIVE) 23%
(NEGATIVE)
'3STRSALY EEff $
..d.db gy{$**y 3%' f $ 1 4 W Q p 4 %
Q ' j$1 k M fp/314%;s" b;W1 ;:
NS EXEMPT JAGREEWTA P 'i ys-g
- 1(POttTIvf) h..
- 49Nb/mtl$
401 4% b' M
J
^
<rn 4 3LIeffLYt AWittu id A tc%i' 6(P0t TtVt) a 111 120 SLIGHTLY DISAGREE 17%
13%
1 DISAGREE 25%
60%
(8%
51%
STRONGLY DISAGREE 187 (NEGATIVE) 2d5 (NEGATIVE) e
- 2Y[^
2N 31% se k' ' I[*f#d "13%!l@fV411:gr4M%bhgMfS fSTRONGLY %m. c <t
.! 3%
EE NONEXEMPT we
' AGREE w p
/M
, s,5% - -
i, ;gg g
e.
)
3 SLIWffLY : AeftEE m MG
-;22%
.(PSITIVE)
Gd Ms $95 kn4(posit 4VE);is s.
es so s
SLIGHTLY DIEAGREE 15%
11%
DISAGREE 23%
Snh 20%
59%
STRONGLY DISAGREE 31%
(NEGATIVE) 28%
(NEGATIVE)
..,, @;.,. w % j,#p,.
Y m*
, z.,
n gn.
w.
U*NOWN f.$TRONGLT.... -
EE:
^
' 5% '-
MQ...
2 21%gg.Qp3dM M dw eng ' gN POSITIVE) M E
23% i 43%d 5 &
,..-.s 4AGtEE! O fE.d E
-h
% BE 0:hh e
NSLiefTLY A4ftEE:9.. %
111% i
'(POSITIVE)!sadi M1130%4 w 19 40 SLIGHTLY D15 AGREE 15%
15%
DISAGREE
~
37%
79%
20%
58%
STRONGLY DISAGREE 26%
(NEGATIVE) 23%
(NEGATIVE) i
' Ai 7357fE@ @@i ci27% F mod @h TOTAL
- STRONOLY. AtytEE 4%
.a
- m ^ $lt%i485M48%f$U a.
.1-EE fAmtEES< a 7i e
'.12%.
e824%W1GkP051TIVEk%dP!
.iSLIGHTLVJAW EE':/O h L21%3 J(P05171VB)TsInd 336 377 E
~
SLIGHTLY DI 5 AGREE 17%
13%
DISAGREE 23%
63%
18%
54%
STRONGLY DI$ AGREE 23%
(NEGATIVE) 23%
(NEGATIVE)
O) to to (D
i L
k KE M
yxES~
u L
s s
3 2
s 3
9 2
]
t a
3 e
2 0
3 t
1 i
o 3
o 4
7 0
1 2
i 9
t 8
3 t
i
,<4 J4
~
)
)
)
' k
.i
)
.9 Y:i
%l I
J:
.).
)
~l
- u. l V
)
)
E E
E E
L E
E
>SE E
E E
V V
- hi E
UM T
-MI V
V
.V V
,V V
JV V
V V
O E.%T rI CI I
V I
I I
I I
I I
I T
sWt N
- T T
T T
T T
T
_.%S %G
%S %G v%S %G L
t A
T T
A I
A I
A gm0 I
I A
M 4_u%u %G t
A t %G
/
t 5 %G
> 7O 3E 0E 10 0E D
s SO 4E 4O 0E CiP u$P t
8N 3E 7N
%(glP a
A e
s
.[W(
&S(h iM 3iP 8N
- 1P SN P 9N 8N n
(
E t
(
k
(
1.(
(
o
(
t
(
gg(g t
L r
(
i M #
r
+ -
Wkr s
(
E t
pg6
,. 5 a*
N e
ge d
jag m jgE v.
+WM s
j tf
?
j ga
'hG
- l.L W@E%%%%
/.
A g
L gs s
%E%%%
%%E%%%
E 9te86 t37476 V
p.at373 920338 4$t401 g7995 jd6124 lt23 E
$$x134 125 1124
_k Md 8@1 W%b
~
k 33 L
g 4
[
f ON
<6F Pjs 7;'+
hg0 iiM
., e Y
x O.
n$w M
4 i
j T
l 6[*d
%g'~
$g{de A
d
%hd jh kW$
+ Yb-i L
.'.gd f' MO gnS S
b N
h sA E
prW
- Is i
l
)
)
g;s E
)
!l
)
['h* i
)
)
l
)
E Qht E
S NE G$i E
fUE qh1 E
m E
E V
O V
V
$v V
V V
V V
i y
V
-dT N8i I
iWf I
R 4MtMi I
t I
I I
t T
I sT T
P q%S 8kt T
T T
T N
A T
dI A
0 I
A g 1 A
I A
t A
- d. %$
%G t %G
, N% S %G s%9
%G s%S %G
%G E
9
%e 70 3E H
9 t
9O 1E 3D 7E
>40 8E it O 9E A2P s
1P 8N e
tE F
7N r
sN
-'1P aN
,i P 8N m I(P 7N T
1 uo xtP
.Ml o(
(
f(
(
n(
(
(
>t
(
(
F Y
O A
e e(
s M
n E
R z
's s e LA m.
9 A
n%%%%%
%' *8 8 7 5 W
4 E.1 8
45t079 234018 eS4849 20e247
%e%%%
A 3 930 124 gs2%5
%:%i a2122 3
124 1124 124 115
,D
,bM M
.%d E
^
R 5
1 i
11 @
J.?N
,E A
J(
3 Y
g;4v
[hM nC N
pgm A
.?4
/a %
4N4 tJ g
Qb spb
. N1 P
yi iI QgWE M
i i5tE E 3
j E
E O
4 E
E E E
- .3 E E ice E ia p?CR ME E
C 2 aR 0R E
E E
E t
E E
E E
tWEG he E
4(
R R
R i%EG R
R R fD R
R R
EWEG t
G t
G Y
G G G E:
G G ENtG G EA A
M EA A
E iA A t
A A
A A E
A A h
, Sg 5
.E AW$
p MWMS:.5gj%AD S
m
$' S B'
S t
I I
f n
S
.g I'
I I
I I
I I
I I
iI e
D D D
AD D I
O D D D D t
?
.A D D T
~
e tl t
t t
YYEY kyYYEY S
LWbYEY T bYEY sHlLEL L kLEL Y
a L
R c
LFfTRG
,.Y YEY YEY LEL LEL ntTRG BPTTRG E
L LEL LEL stfHGN MR4HGN U
C S
TRG TRG G
I fRG Mg fGN NEHfGN i
I N
HGN g IGN iE#GAO bE9GAO F
D GAO t GAO cgeWAO OSGWAO S
tttISR sMtISR n
iRlISR RIIISR f
t t LLIT isLLIT stISR t
SISR LLIT TgLLIT TWLLIT E
F f
O 7 LLIT SSDS SASSDS tSDS tASSDS
$ASSDS R
3SDS (FN E
.. $Mh
. Q:4
- ae
$hM Ifi t
H T
O Y
CP E
L O
V A
N R
O T
T R
E S
P P
N M
N 4
U E '/
.A (P
E v
G E
S E
G X
X o
LA m.
A E
E N
L m
T f
N N
I T
m S
O O
oD M
h N
N w
T nG A
i P
S tV i
e S
areT P
M aN m
E sA n
T eL P
I P
,l-
.j
{
4
'i
1 i
e
, page l.O of-l Exhibit 5 s
t'
(
e e
a.
n n
=
n e
p i
e a
l 5
i
=
e-n w
e e
n e
e e
n g?
y:
X y
,,j i y.,1 5
,....M
, Y. -.
,. x..:
J 7.r qxi
~
- 4 ~
~
~..
p-f.-$eme Y
Y f
5.e on h
l vi e.e a u on
$G y
C g2 4@*
O G:
l e
>w nyt en
?
en en
,5 de z*;
$w L.;
m de ee e
%g
/s e=
e ve m
sw e
N w
c; we m
- g e o
e n
N y
O e
m
[1; 6V*
ljM'W:"I g
% g: 4 gfUE Q
s?
- C"'
NM" T,4"9%
e 5
3
.Mt
- M%
. yg
- gfg g.,.4 a
n
.,A.x.3 j.;gj
-q:gg.
- g -
wym
.g gs.
4, 9.p p m.x ;
WMW
.1 M Rfg 3;ge
,::9%
gmy
- M.t*
85.Ie.s.t WR,IMEC MJfC.E.N
W
.ie
< k.D
.sgg
- X:Q p' 6 p:.p IN2 i
h, b.,,
.fp
(
D l,
D. N Td Mtd3 7.
. ~Me 3.M
- Wd Yl.:
NM4 2.+N' W'*d g-A' 4 a
cVM TJM..P r-d h
- M st*8 Ind
" 4?d.?
fe,g
- $:.: -7 f.%
f!?
gg; Q?
('"
' ~
~
- y:fG n
hh,h HAM 2 Na
- w*
=
A 3,e
=
y
- @M g
- h$
a
- N e e%s y
%g
=
(
t
- M e.e pg
- f. $ '.
e
.e g
.e
.. :(B f,4 u;g e.e e.e VF;:r e
1", p.
6..
ee o
e.e ese
.t me c.% 3 es we"' > '
- ~A
~
e
$m L"
$m
".':n *
$m a
we w
d en e
6 W.
o.
e e
t so e
4e ao w=
n
.: s e
E
. i-w es e
ce w e.
gw w
w n,;w w
",,e
, Qy:n:<
.,.w w
w w
r v3w w
w g
g y
N-
+c l- - -
- ' I
'$$558 M5'NCBM
$5R #C
$'ECCM
~5.5 C#5
.;--.CC.M
.NEW C
.n.
i
~...
n.
.k
+m
%.1 g
1
. c.->
2 axg 8
?
'lib 02 15$
NA
~
o
- M:(h]
$9 M ;4^+.P iit %W
.yif
%[ %g
- Riff, N
a t e!9 e
- Njt.
8 k
i Afg
'pj M M'* g W 4
W Q,, w w i
ibl,. E W las
?.[
w w v.<
- 'w w
.s
- W<
- h: t tas 9%. b, W
,e w w c::p
..w w
W f'g, s. ans r-.., t w w
.e
$. p%
taa W
aw w
.. m,-j" m x wa
....c o
u. >.a w
' d ~sM N
GNW 68 '
- &C %eC NV m
j X
e
(
4 as - '
42 s'
- t-
^
t-c J.
A 4 4
.as. t *-
?'
t In s.
.e a
,, o a i
4 o o
,., o i
e e
.:m.w+o a o o o o u
m
., t.a m.,..
.g. w.
sw s sw sw
.J ans g
aw
+ p
.J w g
E M
w w.
w_.
ed.,n ee k
.J oe p J sm>
n d ee p r
.a w n Y
.a oe n i
g 2
iG mom
^9 WoM W MMoM WMoM t
e4 G W k
SmoM r
j g
kwat ad unf WW fMi;M Zi#
8 i
m l
+
m y I.
I.
a
.o 3
s,.
w.%
w-W (f) ens 5 2
x x
.J<
z
.a a
w r
a
(
ese ep
.J a
m 0, 5 b e t i
i 4
5 3 l
l e
n.
4, 4
w
-- -.. -... -. _.. - - -... _. -... -. -, -. _. - -. -. -. -, - -