ML20085N476
| ML20085N476 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Vogtle  |
| Issue date: | 05/17/1995 |
| From: | GEORGIA POWER CO. |
| To: | |
| References | |
| OLA-3-A-034, OLA-3-A-34, NUDOCS 9506300205 | |
| Download: ML20085N476 (10) | |
Text
,
' ^
_J /
l 00CIET50 ~N USNRC GPC EXIIIBIT 34 1
AUFDENKAMPE EX. II 1
[NRC TAPE 75 SIDE A)
'95,, i'l i. 2 @ --
9 2
/
VOICE /Cood morning 3
voleE: Good morning.
OFFICE OF SECRETARY 4
VOICE: Good morning.
00CKETING & SERVICE BRANCH
/
5 VOICE: Good morning, j
,6 VOICE: Good morning.
7
[ Pause.)
f
/
/
8 VOICE: Good morning.
p'
/
9 VOICE: Good morning.
10 VOICE: Good morning.
/
11 VOICE: Okay, Unit 1 100 percent reactor power.
12
[ Inaudible) average for last,.24 is 1128.
Current hour is
[Inayd'ible). Average [ inaudible) 13 1150.
10,100 BTUs.
14 connectivity on the staa's generator is about.32.
/
15 We current 1y' have the RAN [ inaudible) 120 LCO.
16 The 14-day report should be worked on today. We just added 17 another LCO [ir. audible) maintenance.
[ Inaudible)'and it 18 should stay on line. We had several instances last night of 19 the LCD [ inaudible). I got a recorder booked up to the 20 sonitors trying to isolate what the problea'is.
21 I guess IC has an [ inaudible) out on Loop 4 that's 22 due today or they were found during the,' night that'll 23
, require my taking a look at that, whether it's' just a'due 24, date or a late date.
/
25 Now we're [ inaudible) on the run' back, on the O
ffJCLEla REGULAICID COMMIS$!CN s o-y a y-ow i Docket uo Sa 129-et4-1 Oba! Exh No. 68f 11'- 3 4 in th rnaar cf Cr FC et al-Staff EfmFdo 5-App 4 m V
Tu TNED s-Int rumor REfCTED Conig C?r Cor,t:ae;r ogr o y _ f 7 - q 5-0"!er W'
z
,q J M k m,oa R0purter C. A%
9506300205 950517 PDR ADOCK 05000424 C
6
/
1 Vo! cts
[ Inaudible). And recal scae feedwater.
/
2 V ICE: They've got an under-power ev4nt.
l
/
l 3
VOICE:
oh*, an under-power event? on Unit 2i
/
/
,.fInaudible).
/
/
4 VOICE:
/
5 VoICEt, No, this is Unit 2.
,/
6 VOICE:
[Inaudib1 J.
/
/
/
7 VOICE:
' dell,/
e e, I gues Gus was making a stink
/
i 8
on getting the cal?
Is that right on Unit'17 May/
be they
/
9 went over/ and [inaudiWie).
/
/
/
/ VOICE:
[ n/ audible).
/
+
/
/
/
/
11
/
VOICE:
want to e ock into/that.
Ita on th's Therewa/
/
s 12 screen for Unit s a feedwater cel issua.,
f 13 VOICE:
[Inaudi e).
/
14 VoI E What?
/
15 VOICE:
[ Inaudible). /
e f
Zirite fouwb op
~
~
~
i 16
/t.N
- ridt, they :'
- L__,
out e cal, er g
17 somethin. Somethirig like that.
s4s/FORNKA WC
/
18 7
Woscas,[Inaudib1's).
4 19 4M untess/ You did
, 20 SA
[ Inaudible) Un 1.
/
4
/
/
/
21 jf 4 M ite2de s oka Did ypu get at powered up?
I 22 (6-d
^ = -- - - --i :- ' ^
)r's eN rw percukr g4..
/
/
23 g4 /7 eah.
Y may t to take a lo k at 2*
" in.
(s* o or /)seg urrus.p) 25 rgs watext
-7
- _ um s rm.r; ru oitut s ru
\\
i i
I i
7
?d/
S/tTG i
1 MLA1-wetee:
- ba tabulation of the t'-
~' : - i. I i
ff'.* NE AD Tb KAM mJ a.JI TM T/YT /EC4ADJ f,lg[ &
i 2
think I got them all.
^T---
^ m: ;
Some of then aren't ]
i 4#.**## 8,E M C# D ",fn'au*dible1.
3 64 tex i 7 Apis /c, 4
vo! :
[Inau le).
5 ICE:
[
udible).
6 VOICE: Do you ve any id why it we here?
i 7
Vo E
[I dible).
s VOICE ou know, metimes wp inaudible) t at
[inaudibd)/
ther oap) icular [1,na ible) o his 10,/
/ VOICE: Ja'ih.
/
VOICE (/ [Inaudi e).
/
11' 12 VOICE: Du t wasn't,-[ inaudible
/
j 13" VOICE Yeah. Itr'was blowin the --
14 V CE: In t4e directio
- I could see -t' hat it
/
15'
[inaud le).
/
Right<*,,
'/
../
i 16 Vo!'CE:
1
/ VOICE:.,r[naudible) th noor.,,
de [ inaudible)" /
./
/
18 VOICE: It was.{fnaudible).
was switche#[p-inaudible}[
/
1 20 voIRE's You cou144a put it closer but it4as 2
inaudi
/
'/
./
22 voIC I think that,was probabl.an inadvar 6t
~
2
[inaudibi turned on.
Maybe it was sosre' body's i to ible)understg,youklnow dible/)
24
[1
/
VOICE: I don't kn
/**
2
)
4 I
1 31 1
(TAPE 75, SIDE 5)
Sc wxAr Dw rca rawx ? 1*krp4rs*J 2
// M statcE: 4 i --- - ^ ^ ^ t - i e-good.
4 3
7(r4 Statet (Inaudible). //vN f pr urfs 4
JL M m M
A kc~~
.5 9
d[k inoset: ;jys"' : _ ^ agree with wha f
5
__1-;. car ror 6
/**% meset: This is the best data there is.
This is a 7
combination of multiple portions of data. There is no E
better data -- this is better than any single source of 9
data. This is an integrated data.
g,,,4f
[dA 1e02ct.: It sounds like ther satorial '!-"*-)
10 4
M 11 JJ&- /N 7"Nr 4E4 h 4NtteR3 These are not logged in the ContrC1 room 12 7 hear f-13 log.
These are not logged in the diesel log. +femend4 Met i
14 you couldn't tell initially, but this is my interpretation 15 of what actually happened, having talked to Kenny.
l 16 totees Those are the ones that really concern me.
17 IIM tatet That one ought to concern you. That one is ought to concern you. That one should concern you. That 19 one.
In fact, there's a lot of them.
I mean, these are 20 obviously real live problems, okay? And there are problems l
21 with the features that we're investigating.
22 VOICE: [ Inaudible).
23
/,x, gettes.: But as far as I can tell, th t i a o
24 a list as exists, and a better list than -- well
' - - ~
4-25
-i I
^ 'i f ones that aren't in the log.j g
DNES 7"NMf CONCEsw ME) TMr$ r i
i i
4 I
4
,,. -. m
-e
,w.
-,-,-----om--
r
32 I 7' wivt O 1
/ % 1toscsJ Yeah. h 4bothereeg se :ks that thirigs 2
aren't in the 109 3
70 Wosct: I don't understand this
['-
4 VOICE:
(Inaudible).
5 6: I thought that was a (inaudible).
6
[*ientet: That's a three-minute run here.
7 p wee *** That's another thing that bothers se a 8
little hit -- taking credit for these one-and two-minute 9
runs.
10 74
-90$cS But it did run.
11
/L ef N Did it?
12 74 4 40289:
Yes.
13 06 ite'AS.:
Why would we run it for three minutes?
14 db itOscts Anything that is a blank, any -- these --
15 anything that has a number in this column is a start and A*
w W n Y eY, wspy 17 34 geset tiemand4hL*t shut it down and restart it.
g 18
/% 1t02c8: That's part of the logic testing.
19 J8 m
Yeah.
20
/ W 402CE: East control logic test.
They were 21 tripping it on the various sensors, I believe.
22 VOICE: (Inaudible).
23
)65 90308: Okay.
24 Am isoscas. Maybe I'll sake a copy of that for George.
l 7
25 I think somebody needs to do something about it.
I think 4
i
+
1 I
l l
4 k
+
f i
-.. _. _ ~ -. -..... _ -. _, _ _
1 some information is -- Aces 4Arr.
2 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
I 2
Vo!CE: -- inacen A$e.u,,_
4 7
V E:
[I dible) eting w
,,finaudibley
5 VOICE
[Inaud e).
,/
/
/e'
- ICE, 1.
VOICE naudib 8
CE: Iw
't invit 9'
VOIC are you ited [in ble).
10
/
VOICE:
[Ina ble) iny d, I thin I,d 1
VOICE:
got a o
all fr ordon.
12 Jinaudible).
1 VOICE:
h.
14
.Afr ICE: And I a phone e n back n
1 George wanted to t to you, a saf1f and San Cr n at 4:15 16 in his office 17
$m VOICE: He 1 king about"the droppe d,
and
, s"
- 18 N
's not inv
.in that /
/
1 CE:
[3nauilible).
/
20 48 voICV I don't knou/They're e nTused.
f
_/oICE : Okay./[ Inaudible se if you can do 2
v 22 a
ing.
2 M OICE:
In r know anythip.
p 24 VOICE:
4 you talk to ailey yet?
2 f,$m CE:
No, not y We're sti dible) in
53 1
VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
2
.40ZCE:
yee, we're going to [inaudiblei-copie -.
/
f Let ne'make sash extra copies.
/
/
/
/
p:qVOICEv, oka[/.
4 wasgoingto[iKa'udible).J,That's 411 I was going /
to do.
I d
'./
5 f
s
/
/
,y0' ICE: we1L, let me make a copy /for stoye's and 6
- eif, one to f31aey /
,f l
7 8
VOICE: [ Inaudible) two pa/.
ges.
/
VOICE:
" audible).
se varetr rinaudib
~
(34fAK IN f*AfrNg)
~~~
11 Ai H:- -
- we oox*r we 9 0e n~nr.7 f( 3 % r2OrLOCA 12 4 moses: Tell as where the problems are.
Is this c
13 the probles side or is this the problem side?
14 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
15 fr$ iseseeJ !s this the problem side?
16 g y 1sosct:
No.
Does that say "Not logged in the 17 control loga7 18 JL Af m:
Yeah.
19 M 1R03CE: That's just the statement of fact, 20
-- ? -
^' TMJc Af4F
-jgnot logged in the control log.
But that's not a 21 probles [ inaudible).
22 jd' 903C8: What is the problem?
23
- st sozct: The problem is this. The problem is I believeg/e-Mes4eas fr4rrrrrwr MA.0C Th(were incorrect.Arp4 pix + piangs 24
-;4the NRC ^^ - - - - - "^t-34 25 Remember what we said? That was the COA response. COA 1
.I T
J I
i j
e r
e
,u-, -
,e,..---
,w--,
e n--
-r
-,,-n
54 1
response said --
2 VOICE: [ Inaudible).
1~Sr HMcM/A'f, f*MC h wezet: COA response saidg '
'E l-i-A and B 3
NAcMtA'E WELY 4
W was started 18 and 19 times respec since 5
the 30th, and there have been no problems ;'
' ' E ' 21
~ ~== h' ' '0 6
1 start counting back from that date, you go one, 7
two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten,
/
p 9b M e
eleven, twelve, 13 has a probles, 14 tripped, 15 - ''='_
H 9
probles, ~ -
A w, ;); tripped, w-whatever,- :.p., f e *b/c-> y J
fil:-
Eb j
10
[ Inaudible).f.97 sted
- 7., J# j,,,4 il rf[
Soses:
" Q '%.,.ig",%li? a..x '
h.
1 M *****'
13
,7 r3 meses:
[feeedtbie)Aoriginal tipel,*
T
,v effnndly f*T T*
i 14 AM #Dete ttumin*+4*4e+4 numbers together the first 15 time.
You know, you've got George's presentation, you've JEA 16 got the COA response letter, and you've got the IA8h-g 5gt NCNS 17 4868+* : [ Inaudible) the COA response letter 4
is
[ inaudible).
19 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
14, 20
-*a+eF*
"?--
" * ; the 1A diesel was started is 21 times, and the 15 diesel was started 19 times [ inaudible).
22 No f ailures or problems have occurred in any of these 23 starts.
+ 6sf 2f M I.
we 24 TFS.I"'
MOSCB:
^[ Inaudible]474<.sv a-r A **'
25 Ap m I?--
' ; 3.
i i
f 1
4 6
4 m.
i SS 1
VOICE:
No, no.
This is only B.
2
-w e I don't have an A 4 ^ -----~ i- -(
8df moscs:
[ Inaudible). The thing in question is 3
4 probably no failures or problems have occurred in any of 5
these starts --
/ W A N Y C/= rhcu~
6
/ 4./7 m starts.
3
'M
.iMg 7
VOICE:
[ Inaudible) didn't declare it operable e
until --
f Y'
_t.
9 A/ Nseecs: The second PAGE lo S K ip -tosee: -- the second t4a===+++r+=t you know.
O Failed to start the first time [in &t same t**
11 audible) Maintenance w
.r s aJ r 12 (inaudible).
[ Inaudible)4 ake credit for that time, t
ANd SAY Ne
.1_, f ailures or/Aedt t'Y1 MArr oc c.M4rA 13
_L'
^"t-1 14 7"X This s -'
g 4 S-J75 "d*a
~
15 31steSA This is your standard inadequate w
/.=/ /,.ne 16
_g_I;ofthe"'
" " fsilure to start every time, 17 right?
%s } a cn ol / kr> c4-ha..
18 36,*
40o548:
h 19 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
.5h /[ 55W 20
/% toget1 Two trips, onej riph:f t
21
^ -: T o or I
h..E fvv*
^
The 22 k m:
,1._ _ ^ " _' 1.. ; get it, down and ados:er.
23 j' - _ _...,, ( Oh*' l
'.F I
}
^
24 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
25 Sg/# eseecs:
[ Inaudible) h [ inaudible).
4
56 1
talks about comprehensive test a J563 2
program.
It=
- r 1-4those words.'4--- -' ' ' ' _ -
3 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
[*S'voscts (Inaudible) numbers.
It has the 18 number 4
5 and comprehensive test program. Thg was what corporate AND L
6 added,jthe way they doctored the par"up for final submittal.
7 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
h* Seeses:
8 It's i^
b
-~
d" fr I
9 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).8'[#b b -
'{yy ],'
10
/4N 1p03cs:
Yeah.
.,, M,
--A.
11 r*** 1soses: There's numbers in it.
12
[ pause.} (dAEAK /N 7A//N4)
IM. ed.sn. V 13
/4 //1toses: -fewm=# heart. George has asked you to work 4
with somebody,,tT M4 7 % y f 31g-A!4 r r 14 4 --
y,'-'c
__,_.. -----,_which I 15 guess would be
^
, rN4/V y ron es.
g ar/ W P 16
/AuA cAJNIIeRet Uh-huh./
h
,"o
$ge'd t /F 17 M W 9tters te===H*+=t that list is a good list.
4 18 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
19 7'#C.
30303: W.
jgov $9 20 AM WOSCE:
I'm go g to give the list to Kenny.
Rals--
YOM 21
f i Metput etnes$tasseddeute$ together and figure out what 22 the [iftsuddMe) number is.
f/[apb ineeese 1-
- ' ^ _ t'/s 23 24 VOICE:
[ Inaudible).
h 903 cts All righ 25 w,.
- s..~,s>
cens e, sier e) i a
?-
i-4 T
1 1
4 J
l
.