ML20083F122

Forwards Util Application to Suspend Antitrust License Conditions.W/Svc List

ML20083F122
Person / Time
Site:	Perry
Issue date:	09/25/1991
From:	Mary Spencer SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTS & TROWBRIDGE
To:	Bechhoefer C, Bollwerk G, Mark Miller Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
References
CON-#491-12239 A, NUDOCS 9110040077
Download: ML20083F122 (3)

Text

-

}$931 SHAW, PITTMAN, POTTs & TRCWBRIDGE

...........m o. o..e,....c.. a c, e....,,

2300 N S'at t'. N w

''**

• C

• 37

"[ ' ~.:

' '... o.. e, e t

..,.'.Y '.' _l'/.'.'...,

.:.....c.,....,

-u.

..2..us, 2 :a....,

.3..

2:2 J3 3 s gg3 3~s

-.ac. e s s.t :ca September 25, 1991 VI A FEDER AL EXPRESS 51arshall E. Miller, Chairman A tomic Safety and Lic0nsing Board Panel 1920 South Creek Boulevard Spruce Creek Fly-in Daytona Beach, Florida 32124 VI A \\1ESSENGER.

Charles Bechhoefer, Administrative Jucige Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 4350 East West Fighway - Room E-413 Bethesda, Maryland 20814 G. Paul Bollwerk,111, Administrative Judge Atomic Saf ety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 4350 East West Highway - Room E-522 Bethesda, Maryland 20F14 Re:

Application of Ohio Edison Company to Suspend Antitret License Conditions (Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Unit 1),

NRC Docket No. 50-440 A Gentlemen:

I believe that at last Thursday's Prehearing Conference counsel for Ohio Edison indicated that we would provide the Licensing Board and all parties with copies of the correspondence between Senator Metzenbaum and the NRC, which we had located in the NRC's Public Document Room. Accordingly, enclosed are those documents, as indicated on the attached index.

Sincerely yours, y[

A Wi NF Margaret S. Spencer Enclosures Samuel J. Chilk (via messenger; w/ enclosures) cc:

Service List (w/ enclosures) 9110040077 910925

)

PDR ADOCK 05000440 I

-M PDR

- SH AW, PiTTM AN,- POTT s & TROWB RiDG E

. m.,u...... u :. o,.er m m.ac..e.....

SERVICE LIST Joseph Rutberg, Esq.

David R. Straus. Esq.

- Sherwin E. Turk. Esq.

Spiegel & McDiarmid Steven R. Hom, Esq.

1350 New York Avenue, N.W.

Office of the General Counsel Suite 1100 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20005-4793 Washingtor., D.C. 20555 Mark C. Schechter. Esq., Chief Kenneth L. Hegomann, P.E.

Roger W. Fones. Esq.,

President Assistant Chief A merican Municipal Power-Ohio.

-Janet Urban. Esq.

Inc.

Transportation. Energy and 601 Dempsey Road Agriculture Section Post Office Box 549 Antitrust Division Westerville. Ohio 43081 Dep.irtment of Justice 555 Fourth Street. N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20001 James P. Murphy, Esq.

Philip N. Overholt Squire, Sanders & Dempsey Office of Nuclear Plant 1201 Pennsylvania A venue, N.W.

Performance Post Office Box 407 Office of Nuclear Energy Washington, D.C. 20044 U.S. Department of Energy, NE-44 Washington, D.C. 20585

- June W. Weiner, Esq.,

Chief Assistant Director of Law William M. Ondrey Gruber, Esq.,

Assistant Director of Law William T. Zigil, Esq.,

Assistant Director of. Law City Hall, Room 106 601 Lakeside Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44114 Reuben Goldberg, Esq.

Channing D. Strother, Jr., Esq.

Goldberg, Fieldman & Letham, P.C.

1100 Flf teenth Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20005 D. Biard MacGuineas. Esq.

Volpe Boskey and Lyons 918 Sixteenth Street. N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20006

~

- ~

,,_.,n

... _. _ _ _ _ _ _._. _......._.- _ _...~. _._ _.

Documents'Found in NRC Public Document-Room u

1.

Letter-:from' Senator-Metzenbaum.to Thomas Murley (March 1, 1988)

. 2 '.

EDO Principal' Correspondence Control (March 18, 1988)

- 3.

.Seven undated drafts of letter from Victor Stello to Senator Metzenbaum' 4.

Letter.from Victor Stello to Senator Metzenbaum (April 4,

'1988) t

+

04391257 mss. R

,c.

9 1'

e

' Md W WrTEDeaAUM TM Eg',,*a'o l

=!0:"'"J'a:iir,,c.,

I i

comant ru m t e me.cu, Enittd statts senate

,===.,:=,,

WASHINGTON. DC 20S10

""$[(,77'*"

March 1, 1988 t

Mr. Thomas E.

Murley Director of Nuclear Reactor Rt.gulation U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

20555 Dear Mr. Murley I am writing in opposition to an application submitted to the NRC by the Ohio Edison Company (Application to Amend the Perry Operating License to Sitspend the Antitrust Conditions Insof ar As They Apply to Ohio Edison Company, Docket No.

50-440A).

It is clear that Perry's costs have risen f ar beyond projections made in 1976 when its owners decided to build the plant, a f act which ohio Edison admits in its application.

I do not believe, however, that Ohio Edison and its partners should be allowed to escape the consequences of an unfortunate business decision by holding municipal power systems captive to their increasing rates.

If the Ohio Edison request is approved, residential an i industrial customers in 21 cities would be faced with dramatic rate increases.

This would be extremely unfair to the residents of 22 townships in Ohio, including Amecherst, Beach City, Brewster, Columbiana, Custar, Cuyahoga Falls, Gallon, Graf ton, Hubbard, Hudson, Lodi, Lucas. Milan, Monroesville, Newton Falls, wiles, Oberlin, Prospect, Seville, South Vienna, Wadsworth, and Wellington.

The fact that nuclear power has turned out to be substantially more expensive than other power sources does not obliviate the need to protect mu7icipalities from monopolistic practices by the owners of nuclear plants.

In fact, I would argue that the high costs of nuclear power increase the importance of antitrust protections.

If Ohio Edison',s request i s approved, it will *emove the natural enarket pressure on the utility to keep its rates low in order to retain and attract Ohio Edison should thus be held to the original terms customers.

of the Perry operating License.

9

. [V V 9004130409 990404 Q

[Lll S,hll( @

ADC% OW PDR u

Mr. Thomas Murley March-1, 1988 Page Two i

i i

I appreciate your consideration of my views on this matter.

Very sincere y yours, 1

l

/

W Howa rd M.

He zenbaum Uryt ted Sta tes Sena tor

/

j HMM/ba I

l o

S e

e

e, p.y UfetT10 STAft.S

(

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

[

t enMHausTos(c.c. seems i

d a a:U ((j hg,h i

g k

r U

. r...-

jy EDO Pft!NCIPAL OORRESPONDtsNCE CONTROL DUE: 04/01/08 EDO CONTROL: 003503-FRON:

DOC DT 03/01/8 FINAL REPLY:

j SEN.HOWARD M.

r:ETZENSAUM TO:

MURLEY 88 PRIDRITY 88 SECY NO: 88-219 FOR SIGNATURE OF EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR ROUTING:

DESC:

STELLO CONCERNING PERRY NUCLEAR POWER PLANT TAYLOR REHM

.) ATE : 03/18/98 DAVIS l

ASS!GPED TO: NRR CONTACT: fiURLEY MURRAY l

r SPECYAL !NSTRUCT!ONS OR REMARKS:

COORDINATT,WITH DARRELL NASH AND OCC.

NRR RECEIVED: MARCH 21, 1988 W N:

, DRSP: &_ T -": s

)

l IRR ROUTI!C:

PtJRLEY/SNIEZEK nIRun.1x

!%RTIN GILLESPIE MOSSBURG l

ACTION i

DUE TO NRR DIRECTOR'S. TL BY &< 29: Alf i

e k

t

?-

0FFICE OF THE SECRETARY CORRESPONDENCE CONTROL TICKET PER NUMBER CRC-88-0219 IDGGING DATE: Nar 15 88 ACTION OFFICEt EDO AUTHOR:

H.M. Netzenbaum AFFILIATION:

U.S. SENATE LETTER DATE:

Mar 1 88 FILE CODE: ID&R-5 Perry

SUBJECT:

Opposes appl by Ohio Edison Co. to amend the Perry oL to suspend antitrust conditions insofar as they appl to Ohio Edison ACTION:

!.ppropriate DISTRIBUTION:

RF, OCA to Ack, Docket SPECIAL HANDLING: None NOTES:

DATE DUE:

DATE SIGNED:

SIGNATURE:

F7ILIATION:

- Rec'd Ott. EDO

• 'I 0 ?.* e 3-T Tet t

e 5

g [g--40 Jte J lt

%e Honorable Howard M. Metzenbaum attiaan Subcommittee en Energy Regulation and Conservation United States Senate Committee en Energy and hatural Resources Mathington, D.C..20510

Dear Mr. Chairnan:

-l to pleaserd to respond to your Marcn 1,1988 letter to Dr. Thomas Murl4y expressing your concerns over the Septsaber 18, 1987 application sutefited by Ohio Edison Company (Application to Arend the Perry Operating Licenst to Suspeec the Antitrust Conditions insofar as They Apply to Ohio Edidn Company, Docket No. 50-440A).

I wish to thank you for-your thcaghtful coevusnts pursuant to the Cossnission's on going review of the above sentioned proceir'oing.

Your i

coseents have been most helpful and will be considered in the ' aff's review of Ohio Edison's license ameneect application.

A copy of our review of this matter will be forwardeo to y _ ts concerning this r office upon cosolecion.

If you have any questions or additional cose matter please oc not hesitate to call or write me.

I woulo again like to thank you for your interest in is matter and assure you that we will give thorough consioeration to your omnents in conducting our review.

Sincerely,

/

j

/

J Victo.- tallo, Jr.

Exec ive Director 1

f Operations DISTRIBUTION:

/

Docket Files NRC POR'w/cy of incjdning Local POR E00f003583 EDO r/f TMurley/J5nierek '

0Crutchfield GHolahan KPerkins TColburn Fkreutzer FMiraglia NRR Mailroom P0111-3 r/f TMartin FGt11espie DNotsburg AThomas CThoses VStello PM/P b 3 PD/PDilM ARM /PPMB PTSB AD/DRSP Offica:

Surnase: TColburn/tg KPert1 W.

AThomas CThonias GHolahan Date:

.3 /.AN88

/s/88 4 /.//88

/ /88

/

/88 j

Offica:

0/DRSP ADP D/0NRR EDO GPA/CA Surname: DCrutchfield FMiraglia TMurley V5te11o

/ /88

/ /88-

/ /88

/ /88 -

/

/88 Date:

b b][(

i

The Honorable Howare M. Metzenbaum Chairman, Subcasmittee on Energy Regulation and Conservation

.Uniteo States Senate Committee on Energy.and Natural kesources Washington, D.C.

20510 7

i Deer Mr. Chairman: '

I am pleased to respond to your March 1, 1968 lette to Dr. Thomas Murley expressing your concerns regarcing the Septeeiber 1,1967 application sub-mitted by Onto Edison Company (Applicttion to Aav the Perry Operating License to Suspend the Antitrust Concitions insof r as They Apply-to Ohie Edison Com.pany, Docket.No. 50 440A).

I wish to hank you for your thought-ful cosments about the Cosmission's on-going r few of this proceeding.

Your comments have been most helpful and wil be constoered iti the staff's review of Ohio Edison's license amendment a 11 cation.

A copy of our. review of tais utter will f orwarded to your of fice when it 15 complete.

If you have any quest s or additional cossents concerning this matter, please do not hesitate t call or write me.

I would again like to thank you fo your interest in this ratter and assure

.you that we will give thorough co ideration to your..cossents in conducting our review.

Sincerely, Victor Stello, Jr.

I.xecutive Director for Operations 015TRlbuT10N:

Docket Files hAC w/cy of inconing Local-PDA ED0f 3583' EDO r/f-TMur/ey/J5niezek DCrutchfield GHMahan KPerkins TQ61 burn PKreutrer iraglia NRR Mailroom P0l!1-3 r/f-TMartin FGillespie DMossourg AThomas CThomas-V5tello

• SEE P Y!005 CONCORRENCE Offf e:

PM/P0lll-3 PD/PD!!!.3 ARM /PPMB PT5B AD/CPSP OGC Su

*TColburn/tg

• KPerkins

'AThomas CThomas Gholehen Da 03/23/86-03/23/88 C3/23/88

/- /88

/

/88

/

/86 Offfce:

0/0RSP ADP D/0hRR EDO GPA/CA Surneae: 0Crutchfield FMiraglia TMurley V5tello Date:

/ /88

/ /88

/

/88

/ /88

/ /88

'g t.

U%ITED STATES E

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION nas mo toes. o c. sones

'o.

• e 9

' The Honorable Howard M. Metzenbaus

~

Chairman. Sube w ittee on Energy Regulation

' and Conservation

. United 5tates Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources Washington. D.C.

20510 Deer Mr. Chairman:

I as pleased to respond to your March 1.1988 letter to Dr. Thomas Murley empressing your concerns regarding the Septasser 18. 1987 application sub-sitted by Onto Edison Company -(Application to Amend the Perry. Operating License to Suspena the Antitrust Conditions insofar as They Apply to Ohio Edison Company._ Docket ha M-44aAL7 f -ith en **ah yaa far y~ r thet-e r-t! ri n ; i;.e C:

sion" un yvin, se, b d ;%;; ;,,x;;; tag.

Your comments have been most helpful and will be considered in the staf f's t

i o Oh o s license pp1}ca, tion g ter 11 he forwarded your of t1eeMn A copy /currevie/of it i lete.

1ryou have any g stfons or additi al comments cancerning th matter, ples(e do not hesitate to call or wrWa me.

(

bmould ;;;t.; lite ^.e C.n.i ia fu ;t-4* 7;;t it thh ett: en:/;55e e

,L. G; = z'" gie tYn;t =n;t A7st-, se,er e_ _ _c.ii in ~ tieg nr n; f =.

l Sincerely.

I Victor Stallo, Jr.

Executive Director l

for Operations h k(

& w t wh~f a

ru m u Jv4L phena.n d.pehu.A M ~wdak, 1

W 9% un C

s

'.,.t

. :. i... '..,

j

The Honorable Howard M. Metzeneaum Chainman Subconstittee on Energy Regulation and Conservation Unitec States Senate Comnittee on Energy and natural Resources Washington, D.C.

20510

Dear Mr. Chairman:

I am pleased to respond to your March 1.1968 letter to Dr. Thomas Murley expressing your concerns regarding the September 18, 1987 application submitted by Ohio Edison Coseeny (Application to Amend the Perry Operating License to Suspend the Antitrust Conditions Insofar as They App'y to Onto Edison Company. Docket No. 50 440A).

The Commission is actively concerned with maintaining coroetition

-. _ If ;

___:M..

..:__:' in the electric bulk power services market.

Your comments have been most helpful and will be constoered in the staf f's review of Ohio Edison's license amef*ect application.

If you have any cuestions or additional comments concerning this matter please do not hesit. ate to call or write me.

Sincerely.

Victor Ste11o. Jr.

Executive Director for Operations DISTRIBUTION:

Docket Files hRC POR w/cy of incoming Local PDR ED0fD03583 EDO r/f TMurley/J5ntezek DCrutchfield GHolahan KPertins TColburn I

Ps.reutzer FMiraglia WRR Ma11roce Polli-3 r/f TNrtin FGillespie DMossburg Afhamas CThoses VStello

• SEE FitEV1005 CONCURRENCE Office:

PN/PDill-3 PD/P0111-3 ARM /PPMB 75B,

AD/0RSP OGC Surname: *TColburn/tg

• KPerkins

• AThomas CHolshan Date:

03/23/88 03/23/88 03/23/88 g P(j88

/ /883/[81 Office:

D/DRSP ADP D/0%RR EDO GPA/CA Surnase: DCrutenfield FMiraglis TMurley V5tello Date:

/

/88

/ /S8

/ /88

/,/88

/ /ef

+

,1

1 The Honorable Howard M. Metzenbaus Chat:3an, Subcommittee on Energy Regulation anc Conservation United States Senate Committee on Energy and hatural Resources Washington. 0.C.-

20510

Dear Mr. Chiirman:

I am pleased to.espond to your March 1.1988 letter to Dr. T>omas Murley espressing your concerns regarding the Septoster 18, 1987 app!fcation submitted by Ohio Edison Company (Application to Amend the Perry Operating License to Suspeno the Antitrust Conditions insof ar as They Apply to Ohio Ectson Cosipany. Docket No. 50 a40A).

The Conantssion is actively concerned with maintaining competition in the electric bull power services market.

Your comients have been most helpful and will be constoereo in the staf f's review of Ohio Edison's Itcense amenoment application.

If you nave any questions or additional comments concerning this matter, please do not hesitate to call or write me.

Since rely.

Victor Stello. Jr.

Executive Director for Operations 0151RIBUTION:

Docket Files WRC PDR w/cy of incoming l

Local POR E00#003583 E00-r/f TMurley/J5niezek DCrutchfield GHolahan

KPerkins TColburn PKreutzer FMiraglia l'

NRR Mailroom PDl!!.3 r/f L

TMartin FGillespie l

DMossburg AThemas CThomas VStello

• SEE PREV!OUS CONCURRENCE Office:

PM/PDill 3 PD/P0!!!.3 ARM /PPMB PT58 OGC Sername: *TColburn/tg

• KPertins

'Afhomas

'CThomas GHolahan '8Vogler

.Date:

103/23/88 03/23/88 03/23/88 03/23/88 yb 188 03/75/88-

',./.' s ADPk*lia D/0NRR EDO GPA/CA l

Office:

FMirag TMurley V5tello Surnase:

field p /

88

/.//88

/

/88

/ /88

/

/ES Date:

4

,/

The Hoeorable Hourrd P. Petrenbaun United States !<n6te

-Washingtons D.C.

70510 Oear !cnator Metteebaum:

/

1 am pleased to *espond to ynt March 1. 10P8 letter tt Lr. Thomas V ley espressing your concerns regarcitig the Septeet>er 18. 1967 a pp l i t.a t ip'n suteitted by Ohio [dison (cer/any ( Application te Arend the Perry Operating License to Suspend the Antitmst Condittors 'Insof ar as They Appif to Ohio Edison Carpany. Occhet ho. 50 440A).

The Cces.ission is actively corcerned with maintaining corretition in tre t lectric bulk power servir/s market.

Your cornents have been rest helpful ano will be constoered,Ifi the stJ?

review of Ohio Ect$on's license amenorent application.

4 4,'yr u ha ve a ny cuestiotis or additieral commentt concerning this Nttet, f

• ease do not hesitate to call or write me.

f

/

Sincerely.

/

/

\\ictorStello/Jr.

[necutive Director for C$eragiotis O!*TR18UT10h:

M.ket F iTeT~ kPC PDR w/c) (1 incoming 1

Local PLP ID0f0055P?

El'O r/f TMurley/J5nieze6 0Crutchfield CHolahan FPerkins TColbura Ft.reutzer FMirstilia j

'WRW Mat 1rece PDill-3 r/f TP.a rtin FGillespie j

i IAossburg AThoses CThomas V5te11o

• SET PR(VIOUS CONCURRENCF Office; FM/PDll).)

0/PDll!.3 ARM /PPr.8 PTSB Ac/(*5P LGC Surnase: *TColburn/tg/* KPerkins

• AThomes

'CThomas

• GFolahan *FVogler,

Da te :

03/23/P.P. /

03/?S/88 03/??/88 03/?3/86 03/25/05 03/?5/PJ,

/

\\

Y

Office:

D/DPSP/

ADP D/0NRR EDO GPA CA

/

Surnare:

'Ecry(chfic1d

• FY t ra 9 1 a 1Murley V5tello 1

03/?F/ 4

/

/88

/- /88

/ /rf

'jff5/FA

'Date:

./

9

+

/

.,.r.-

Th3 konorable Howard H. Mettentalm i

United States Senate Washihgton. 0.C.

20510

Dear Senator Metzenbaum:

I am pleased to respono to your March 1,19ES letter to Cr. Thomas Murley expressing your concerns regarting the Septecter 18, 1987 application submitted bf Ohio Ectson Company ( Application to Amend the Perry Operating Ltcense to Suspena the Antitrust Loncit. tons insef ar as they Apply to Ohic Edtcon Company, Docket No. 50-440A).

1he Comission is actively concernee with ewintetning conpetttion in the electric bulk power services market.

At the present time, the request f or the arendment to the Perry License has been pubitshed in the Feoeral liegister and the pertoo for co<ments will empire on April 6,1988.

We have received several cocinents so f ar inc1cating opposion to the requested amendment.

Once the period for coreents has passed, tne staff will review all comments and constoer tree along witn the request.

A cetemination will be trade by the staf f to either grant or deny the arenonent recuest.

At that ttee a notice of the stof f ceterminatica will De publisned in the Federal Register and an opportunity to request a tearing will be provicec.

Your cossments have been mst helpf ul and will be considered in tne staf f's review of Chio Ecison's license amenoment soplication.

If you have any cuestions or accitional coments concerning this matter, please co not hesitate to call or write me.

Sincerely, Victor Stello, Jr.

Executive Director for Operations Ol5TRIBt! TION:

Docket, Hies f.PC POR w/cy of incoming 1.ocal PDR E00#0035P3 EDO r/f TMurley/J5ntezek DCrvtthfield GHolahan KPeriins TCoiburn PF reutzer Miraglia NRR Ka11 room P0ll!-3 r/f TMartin FGillespie DMossburg AThomas Citomas v$tello

• SEE PREVIOUS C0hCURRfhCE Office:

PM/ PDi l 1 -3 PD/P0ll'-3 ARN/PPMS PiSB AD/DRSP GbC Surn4me: *TColburw/tg

• KPerkins

• Aihoe.e s

• 'CThomas

'CHolanan

• F.iogler Date:

03/23/88 03/23/88 03/23/88 03/23Nb 03/25/B5 03/25/Po

/ /)W(

EDO GPA/CA I

• Office:

D/DRSP' ADP Surname: 'CCrutchftele 'mtraglia JMurley v5tello Date:

03/25/88 03/28/86

} fp

/ /88

/ /88

AFR 4 1938 The honorable Howard M. Metzenbaum United States Senate Washington, D.C.

20510

Dear Senator Metzenbaum:

I am pleased to respond to your March 1,1988 letter to Dr. Thceas Murley expressing your concerns regarding the Septeeber 18, 1987 application subettted by Ohio Edison Company (Application to knend the Ferry Operating License to Suspend the Antitrust Condittens Insofar as They Apply to Ohio Ediscn Company Docket No. 50 aa0A).

The (cmaitsien is actively concerned with maintaining competition in the electric bulk power services market.

At the present time, the request for the amer @ent to the Perry License has been published in the Federal kegister and the period for corrents will espire on April 6,198F.

ke have received several cossnents so f ar indicating opposition to the requested arendment. Once the perind for corrents has passed, the staff will review all conenents and consider thee along with the request.

A determination will be made by the staff to either grant or deny the 4 men (kent s equest.

At that time a notice of the staff determination will be published in the Federal Register and an opportunity to request a hearing will be proviaed.

Your cocents have been most helpful and will be considered in the staf f's review of Ohio Edison's license amendment application.

If you have any questions cr additional consnents concerning this matter, please do not hesitate to call e-write me.

Sincerely.

Ori g 1.md :i r.::M ty l

Ja cs ;,r t slu Victor Stello, h.

Executive Director i

0904130404 890404 for Operations l

DH ADOCK O go 4

DISTRIBUTION:

Doctet Files NRC POR w/cy of incontng ED0 r/f Local PDR ED0#003583 Jiaylor i

EDO r/f TNurley/JSnierek TRehm DCrutchfield GHolahan ABDavis KPerkins TColburn JMurray Prreutzer FPiraglia CA hRF Mallroce PDill-3 r/f SECY-88-219

% rtin FGillespie I

DMossburg AThomas CThomas-VStello

• SEE PREV 100' CONCURRENCE Office:

FM/PDlII-3 PD/PDill-3 A M/PPMB PTSB '

AD/DRSP orc i

Surname: *TColburn/tg

• kPerkins

• A s

• CThec.a s

• GHolahan *BYogler Date:

03/23/88 03/23/88 03/23/P,P. 03/25/B8 03/?5/88 EDO',

GPA/CA ADP ey VS To Office:

D/DRSP*

Surname: *DCnJtchfield *FMiyaglia i

Date:

03/25/88 03/28/88 03/30/88 3

/88

/88

,t

-~

l l k The Honorable Howard M.' Metzenbaus

_J

-Chairman, Subcommittee on Energy Regulation ano conservation-

' United States Senate

__Constittee on Energy and katural Resources Weshington.: D.C.

20510

DearMr.Chiirman:

I am pleased to respond to your March '.

1988 letter to Dr. Thomas Murley empressing your concerns regarding the Septester 18. 1981 application submitted by Ohio Edison Company ( Application to Amend the Perry Operating License to Suspend the Antitrust Conditions insofar as They Apply to Ohio Edison Company. 00Chet ho. 50 440A).

The Commission is actively concerned with maintaining competition in ?.he electric bulk power services market.

Your cowents have been most helpf ul and will be constoereo in the staf f's

= review of Ohio Edison's license amenoment application.

If you have any questions or additional comments concerning this matter. Please ao not hesitate to call or write se.

Sincertly.

Victor Stello, Jr.

Executive Director for Operations DISTRIBUTION:

Docket Files WRC PDR w/cy of incoming Local POR ED0#003583 EDO r/f TMurley/J5ntezek DCrutchfield -GHolahan EPerkins TColburn

_ PKreutzer FMiraglia I

NRA Mailroom PDt!!-3 r/f

'TMartin FGillespie OMossburg

-ATFomas CThomas V5tello

• SEE PREVIOUS CONCURRENCE Office:-

PM/P0lllL3 P0/PDill-3 ARM /PPMB PTSB-OGC-5ername: 'TColburn/tg

• KPerkins

'Afhomas

'CThomas GHulahan *eYogler Date:

03/23/88

_03/23/88 03/23/88 03/23/88 y b 188 03/25/88

' " 'j; s Office:'

ADP k D/0NRR EDO GPA/CA Surnase:

field FMiraglia TMurley V5tello 88

/.//88

/ /88

/

/88

/ /PF Date: '

j/

i

./-

j i

ThelNocerable Howard P. Petrenbaun United States ! enate Washington, D.C.. ?0510-

- Deer'!cnator Metrenbaum:

/

/

1 apr pleased to +espond to yt.cr karch 1,19P8 letter tc tr. Thomas Myfley espressing your coriterns recarcing.the Septect>er 18, 1967 applicatiir, suteitted by Ohio Edison (corpany ( Application te Arena the Perry Gerating License to Suspend the Antit vst Cnnditions insof ar as They Applf to Ohic Edison Corpany. Occ6et ho 50-440A).

The Corsission is retively corcerned with maintaining corretition in tre electric bulk power scrvir#5 market.

Yevr cornents have been rest help /ul ano will t.e consicered ri the S t.a " ' ?

review of Ohio Ecison's Itcense amenorent application.

11,'yru have any cuestiotis or additicral comment'. f.oncernine this matie,,, ease do not besitate' to call or write me.

f Sincerely, 7

/

l l

/

nictorStello/,Jr.

Esecutive Of rector i

for Ctera tor.s DISTRIBUT10h:

R,cket Files WPC POR w/c) (1 incoming Local POP.

Efo#0035P?

TMurley/J5nterek

- El'O r/'

GHolahan 0Crutchfield grPerkiot TColburn Ptreut:er FNiraglia ifRR Mailreer PDl!!-3 r/f W.artin FGillespie l

.. [Motsburg AThoma5 l

/

'CThomas v$tello l

• SET PRIViWS CONCURRfitCI,/

Office:

FM/PD111-?

0/PDl!b3 ARM /PPr.B PTSB AD/DRtP

'LGC Surnase: 'TColburn/t i EPerkins

$ Aihoer s

'CThomas

'CFolahan *FYogler Da te:

03/2 3/P.P..

- 03/23/88; 03/??/88-03/P3/86 03/25fEF 03/25/F.P Office:

- D/0 PSP,

-ADP D/0hKR EDO GPA/CA l

Surnace: fLCry(chfield

• FPi ra t,1 t a 1Murley V5tello Date:

03ff5/FA 03/?P/FJ,

/ /88

/ /EE

/ /ff

/

/

/

~

~ ~ ~

e

- w m

m-s um.

l The Honorable Howard M. Metzenteum United States Senate Washington, D.C.

20510

Dear Senator Metzenbaum:

I as pleased to respena to your March 1,19ES letter to Cr. Thomas Purley empressing your concerns regarding the September 18, 1987 application submitted bf Ohio Edison Company ( Application to knend the Perry Operating License to Sustend the Antitrust Concit. tons Insef ar as lhey Apply to Ohic

[dison Corepany, Docket No. 50 440A).

lhe Cornmission is actively concerned with Nintaining Con. petition in the electric bulk power services trar6et.

At the present time, the rvuvest f or the anndment to the Perry L teense has Detn published in the Federal Register and the period for corments will empire on April 6, 1988. We have received several cocinents so 'ar incicating opposion to the requestec a wndment.

Once the period for connents has passed, tne staf f will review all ccanents and consider then, along with the request.

A cetermination will be n.ade by the staf f to either grant or detsy the arenoment request.

At that time a notice of the staf f octermination will be ?uMisned in the Feceral Register and an opportunity to request a hearing will be providec.

Your coasnents have been nnt helpful and will be considereo in tne staf f's review of Ohio Ecison's license anenoment ecolication.

If you have any cuestions or acottional coments concerning this retter, please do not hesitate to call or write w.

Sincerely, itctor Stello. Jr.

Executive Director for Operations j

DISTRIBUTION:

Docket Files f.PC POR w/cy of incceing i

tor.a1 PDR E0080035P3 EDO r/f TMurley/J5ntezek 0Crutchfield GHolahan KPerkins TColburn Kreut:er FMiragite hRR Mailroom P0111-3 r/f TM4rtin FGille5eie DNossburg AThorres CThomas V5tello

• 5EE PREV!OUS CONCORAFNCE Office:

PM/P0lli-3 70/P0!l'-3 ARM /PPMB PT5B A0/0R5P Gut Sverweie: *TColourn/t9 * (Perkins

• Alhoma5

• 'C1homa5

'GHolanon 'EVogler Date:

03/23/68 03/23/88 03/23/88 03/23/86 03/25/86 0?/25/Po

• Office:

0/DRSP*

ADP W

EDO GPA/CA Surname:

• 0Crutchf tele *FNiraglia Nrley VStello Date:

03/25/88 03/28/a6 j /p

/ /88

/ /88

tJ R 41%8 The honorable Neward M. Metzenbaum United States Senate Washington, D.C.

20510

Dear Senator Metzenbaum:

I em pleased to respond to your March 1,1988 letter to Dr. Thoras Murley expressing.your concerns regarding the September 18, 1987 applicatien subsitted by Ohio Edison Company ( Application to Amend the Perry Operating License to Suspend the Antitrust Conditicos insofar as They Apply to Ohio Ediscn Company Docket No. fC-440A).

The Comission is actively concerned seith enaintaining competition in the electric bulk p;'wer seWices marke.f At the present tire, the request for the amero.ent to the Perry Licerse Ms been published in the Federal kegister ano the period for coments will expire on April 6, lo8F.

ke have received several comments sn far indicating opposition to the requested arendment.

Once the perind for coevents has passed, the staff will review all comments ano consider there along with the request.

A determination will be made by the staff to either grant or deny the amen < kent s equest.

At that time a notice of the staf f determination will be published ir. the Federal Register and an opportunity to request a hearing will be previcec.

Your cocents have been most helpful and will be considered in the staf f's review of Ohio Edison's license arenesent application.

If you have any questions er additional ccanents concerning this matter, please do rot hesitate to call ce writt et, Sincerely.

Or I g 1.-M :l'= ed t y Jacia.ts N Victor Stollo, Jr.

Executive Director 8804130404 890404 for Operations DR ADOCK 0%4jo DISTRIEUTION:

Doctet tiles NRC POR w/cy of incoming ED0 r/f Local PDR EDO#003583 JTaylor EDO r/f TMurley/J5nterek TRehm 0Crutchfield GHolahan ABDavis KPerkins TColburn JMurray Prre"'zer FMiraglia c4 NRR w ilroos PDill-3 r/f SECY-88-219 TNartin FGillespie DMossburg AThomas CThomas VStello

• SEE PREVIOUS CONCURRENCE Office:

PN/PDill-3 P0/P0111 3 ARM /PPNB PTSB A0/DRSP Or,C Surnase: *TColburn/tg

• kPerkins

• A s

• CTherra s

• GHolahan *BVogler Date:

03/23/88 07/23/B8 03/23/PA 03/25/88 C3/?5/88 ADP R

E00' GPA/CA Office:

D/DRSP*

a ey VS le Surname: '0Crutchfield *FM1pagli Date:

03/25/88 03/28/88 03/30/88 3i

/88

/88

-