ML20082R453
| ML20082R453 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Wolf Creek  |
| Issue date: | 12/08/1983 |
| From: | Simpson J CHRISTY, W., SALAVA, M.E., INTERVENOR, SIMPSON, J.M. |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8312130170 | |
| Download: ML20082R453 (9) | |
Text
_
e F
00CNETED USNRC UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
- $3 g g gj'.37 NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION OFFICE OF 3ECRETAs v Before the Atomic Safety and LicensiEc[BSkkch ERv;r:r, C
In the Matter of
)
)
KANSAS GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY, e_t a_l.
)
Docket No. STN 50-482 (Wolf Creek Generating Station
)
Unit No. 1)
)
INTERVENORS' MOTION TO ADD CONTENTION AND WITNESSES 1.
The Intervenorsi Wanda Christy and Mary Ellen Salava, ask that the Board include as an additional contention the following:
"The emergency planning zone for the plume exposure pathway does not include the town of Waverly and the Waverly Unified School District No. 242 schools located in Waverly.
The city and that part of the school district should be included in the plume exposure pathway emergency planning zone."
In support of the motion to add that additional contention, the Intervenors state as follows:
(a.) 10 CFR 2.714 (b) permits the admission of late filed contentions if certain conditions are met.
These conditions are set forth in 10 CFR 2.714 (a) (1) and have been adopted by Nuclear Regulatory Commission Appeal Board in Duke Power Co.
(Catawba Nuclear Station, units 1 and 2),
ALAB - 687, 16 NRC 460, at 466 (1982).
Additionally, this board has recognized that the Duke Power Co. case is the 8312130170 831200 PDR ADOCK 05000482 O
PDR I
e standard to determine if additional contentions should be admitted.
See Memorandum and Order Ruling Upon Intervenors Objection to Prehearing Conference Order, dated May 5, 1983.
The Intervenors have met these conditions for the reasons specified in this paragraph 1.
(b.) The Coffey County Plan of November 1982 included the City of Waverly and the schools in that city in the emergency planning zone.
(c.) The City of Waverly is only 11 miles from the Wolf Creek Generating Station.
See the attached page 0-5 from the September 1983 Coffey County Plan.
(d.) The EPZ as defined in the September 1983 plan comes right to the city limits of Waverly.
(e.) The town of Waverly has a population of 700 people.
See page O-3, November 1982 draft of the Coffey County Plan.
(f.) 270 children attend the schools in Waverly.
See the November 1982 draft of the Coffey County Plan, page 3-44.
(g.) South winds are the prevailing wind in Coffey County in the months of March - November.
Waverly is almost due north of the Wolf Creek plant.
2 i
(h.) A substantial number of the children attending schools in Waverly live within the EPZ as it is designated in the latest draft of the Coffey County Plan.
Because of this, parents will likely assume that children will be evacuated as part of the evacuation plan.
Therefore, in order to avoid confusion, the city and the school district should be in the Emergency Planning Zone.
Additionally, the residents of Waverly will perhaps assume that they are in the evacuation plan.
Therefore, to avoid confusion, they should be included.
(i.) The Intervenors did not file this contention at an earlier time because the city and the part of the school district in question were previously included in the Emergency Planning Zone.
If the motion is not granted, there will be no other way to protect the Intervenors' interests.
By granting this motion, the Board will permit the Intervenors to assist in developing a sound record in this matter.
Additionally, the Intervenors' interests will not be represented by any other parties in this matter.
2.
The Intervenors ask that the Board permit them to call one or more of the following individuals as witnesses in this case:
the County Commissioners and the Emergency Planning Coordinators for Franklin, Allen, Anderson, and Lyon Counties.
In support of this motion, the Intervenors state as follows:
3
(a.) In the September 1983 Coffey County Plan, Franklin County, Lyon County, Allen County, and Anderson County are given and have, to some extent, accepted duties and obligations under the Coffey County Plan.
The dutics and obligations of these counties and the County Commissioners and the Emergency Preparedness Coordinators of the respective counties are set forth in the September 1983 plan of Coffey County in Appendix J and in letter agreements included in Appendix D, pages 3-10.
(b.) The duties and obligations specified in the September 1983 plan were not included in the November 1982 Coffey County Plan.
For that reason, the Intervenors did not ask that the proposed witnesses be included on the list of witnesses in the Prehearing Conference Order entered by the Board in this matter.
(c.) The proposed witnesses have very significant roles in the emergency plan for Coffey County, and it is essential that the Intervenors be permitted to call one or more of them as witnesses in order to present a complete record in this case and in order to support various contentions raised by the Intervenors about the registration and sheltering of 4
)
. s evacuees after they leave or after they are taken from the Coffey County Emergency Planning Zone.
Respectfully submitted, A.L 18. O Ubhn M.
Simpson Attorney for Intervenors 4350 Johnson Drive, Suite 120 Shawnee Mission, KS 66205 (913) 384-9144 Dated: December-8
, 1983.
i a
[
I I
4 5
d--+-
tr-y-
-,-y<m9w yyey-ee+-
g--9+-
y-pp.,, -
yw
--m 5
e-7--.-,9--
l' e
ossos 1 q'
/t),
cowa" i
-~*-
j 5.'. f 4
r d
3
/.I "M*4 O/n
..w
- 3 p
.4 a
ao us so r
/
3 l
f J'u l
l f
3'. {'W
/
o t
=
- 3IMN el Nk!f..
..M : d lW @
!!! \\
4 6
1
].:.
- g
j!j l
)
~
r.
-I
/
- a[ l' :
i;I
).:.
suar yf
.g+.
L
- in
> G aa s.
\\
,J. gs -i.:k%.j
.fl..
s I
+
< :.1.. j..
y*
z
- .; ) :1 0
_. A, I
.. Q G,;,y itw%p; ra s n s
,E.
.r
.,.,,,,.4 q
. i 0)...i
- L j%
]
i U
i
.. %iiN
[ {:!j j
[iN "'::
l N
rvvw.-: i: :
t
.,f l
!!!/4:?
~
- }
'g*Lr:Y N Q
i wwi
- t.
C.M
- Il...
" 'l....
,i
- / f "aa %,h
.. :e tas i,w
. * = 'e l
'f.
- . d.f
-. ~
.:.f -.....m acouoso~
..s':
'[:l c
?
-F -+--.:-----.-
. sesrexis
-- --.9
^
j,. j
)..,..
[...j...f ;
p.. A.. 3......;....p 1
3 e..
..g.C-A
.+.
p'i'.
. E. 2,.m
.'3!E.Ir u !
m, N._ _ *c..
- J 1
V
,.r.J iii:
+:
..... _.. +.........
1, s
i i
L:ii~'
M._@..
_ q13
- 4......... + -.+ m,
h y
I
.l-.,:.
s.
x :- ) :: :::t :
k.~
- p..... }
l
\\..:,. -l..
,....I..a.
N[e. 4 c J.{.u [k
- 3?
.l ~ ~ :. :.
t :<
4?...- J:hsp:1.:.N. M W.e:. C :.f.
...+,...;.
- v...b.s 4
m.x
- p
- 4....;....+....;....,
.q y7-
-==
- *1,:: :: tY :.k;O...;sl' f<h
,,,M,
- s.. w,,.
.O, asoT,' '.,. i:
c.ar y
.w 4 7 g :c3
- 7.
- 3..+... 3... 3....
i
. J.:i.d*>ekst
- i i.....:....+...+l..4 i i
....'+...+u. I i i. -!
i
- c.d..
<!il:i.idD j :% ^L..:.:
iii y.i
'p
.+x..a t
.s. ;
.I
":.. e ::".:::
- ..,....+...+...+.,..t....A...-:
- l.:. : 1......g.: q., Q a:.t.,:: ::.: g.::
/ *
..,g::
l
\\
t:
. - t..
.c
- .N.h:) 40 v :8 h : !' +
f' ::!;..
a~
_a
. -: t :JJ:
e l
(
g.
f:y
-...+,
- 4. +4.e +.
q :c : I.;s..:: ; :.:.
e a
j :'
3
.9 i....g
. 3...
- t :
r- :
A
.:.. stv.
I P :
- .. s
. e....
- s..."1 -
, 4::. ",.::
II
- -.- m:. -':.:: fP " '.-
.: 1 9
A.*
l' L~ :
'W.a yj,siU..V..
6 qn p
=Y Y&lo
- .,..4..+...J..!............+...A....
,P, 2
.t I
.....f,...;
I..
1 a
.n's l
J.
7 g.- +.. +
A.
I 3
a..i M
T I
M e
. - a. -
+ -w r,.._
acooso '
3
. +
/
cou r.
Fsf<?>
~
FIGURE 0-1 EVACUATION ZONES AND SUBZONES N
LEGEND f
EFFECTIVE 2-MILE EPZ
,) (
mx x i i EFFECTIVE 5-MILE EPZ
)
i Rev. 2 i
i EFFECTIVE lO-MILE EPZ 0-5 9/83 t
l
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~ ' - ' ^ ^ - ' ' ' ~ ' ~ " ' ~ ~ ' ' ' ~
~ '
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of
)
)
KANSAS GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY, et al.
)
Docket No. STN 50-482
)
(Wolf Creek Generating Station,
)
Unit No. 1)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE This is to certify that copies of the foregoing "Intervenors' Motion to Add Contention and Witnesses" was served by deposit in the United States Mail, first class, postage prepaid, this 8th day of December, 1983, to all those on the attached Service List.
bl. be
-Mbbn M. Simpson DATED:
December 8, 1983
UNITED' STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY. COMMISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of
)
)
KANSAS GAS-AND ELECTRIC COMPANY, et al.)
Docket No. STN 50-482
)
-(Wolf Creek Generating. Station,
)
Unit No. 1)
)
SERVICE LIST Sheldon J. Wolfe, Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Dr. George C. Anderson' Docketing and Service Section Department of Oceanography Office of the Secretary University of Washington U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Seattle, Washington 98195 Washington, DC'20555 C. Edward Peterson, Esquire Kent M.
Ragsdale Assistant General Counsel General Counsel Kansas Corporation Commission Missouri Public Service Commission State Office Building - 4th Floor P.O. Box 360 Topeka, Kansas 66612 Jefferson City, Missouri 65102 Dr.~Hugh C. Paxton Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 1229 - 41st Street U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Los Alamos,.New Mexico 87544 Washington, DC 20555 Myron Karman, Esquire A. Scott Cauger, Esquire Deputy Assistant Chief Assistant General Counsel Hearing Counsel Missouri Public Service Commission Office of the Executive P.O.
Box 360 Legal-Director Jefferson City, Missouri 65102 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Eric A. Eisen, Esquire Jay E. Silberg Birch, Horton, Bittner & Monroe Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge 1140 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
1800 M Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20036' Washington, DC 20006
,,,,_n,n.
.,.y
,.._v._....,-
Service List Page 2 l
I Alan S. Rosenthal, Esquire Dr. John H.
Buck Atomic Safety and Licensing Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Brian P. Cassidy, Esquire Thomas S. Moore, Esquire Federal Emergency Management Agency Atomic Safety and Licensing Region I Appeal Board J. W. McCormack POCH U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Boston, Massachusetts 02109 Washington, DC 20555 l
_ _ _ _ _ _ _