ML20082P168

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Affidavit of SL Hiatt Re Ocre Petition for Leave to Intervene.W/Certificate of Svc
ML20082P168
Person / Time
Site: Perry 
Issue date: 08/21/1991
From: Hiatt S
OHIO CITIZENS FOR RESPONSIBLE ENERGY
To:
Shared Package
ML20082P137 List:
References
OLA-3, NUDOCS 9109100216
Download: ML20082P168 (7)
v • d • e


Text

.

UllITED STATES OF AMERICA tlUCLIAR REGULATORY COMM1rC10!4 13efore the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the Matter of

)

)

Tile CLEVELAND ELECTRIC I LLUM 1!l ATI NG

)

COM P At4 Y, ET AL.

) Docket No. 50-440 OLA-3

)

(Perry Nuclear Power Plant, Unit 1)

)

)

)

AFFIDAVIT OF SOSAN L.

III ATT 1,

Susan L. Hiatt, duly sworn declare and say 1.-

I am a member of' Ohio Citizens for Responsible Energy, Inc.

("OCRE").

2.

I reside and own real property at 8275 Munson Road, Mentor.

Ohio, about 13 miles from the Perry Nuclear Power Plant.

3.

I believe that the operating licence amendment sought by the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company to remove from the Perry Technical Specifications the Reactor Vocael Material Surveillance Program - Withdrawal Schedule violates my right under the Atomic Energy Act to meaningful participation in changes in plant operations.

4.

In addition to representing my interests pro se,,

I authorize OCRE to represent my interests in this operating license amendment proceeding.

5.

I hold the office of OCRE Representative.

Article VI.C.5 of OCRE's Regulations enpowers the OCRE Representative to act on behalf of OCRE in any proceeding before the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

I am, as a duly authorized member and officer of OCRE, empowered to sepresent OCRE in this proceeding pursuant to 10 CPR 2.713(b).

g%dorf sh Susan L.

Ilia t t Sworn to and subscribed before me this

/

day of August, 1991.

4 9109100216 910827

/

PDR ADOCK 05000440 X

0 PDR

%ggsw _

f KATHLEEN A. SiKON

'iiotary Public '

Notary Public.$1 ATE OF OWO My Commission Cunirel NOV.12,1993 (Recorded in Lake County)

L I

2 CERT 11'IC ATI: OF SERVICl I certify that copies of the foregoing were served by depopit in the U.S.

Mail, first claan, postage propaid, this 23 rd day of Auaus',, 1991 to the following:

l

~

{

i i

Secretary of the Commiuuion g

ATT!J Docketing and Service 13 ranch i,

U.S.

liuclear llegulatory Comminaion i,,q Washington, DC 20555

,4 N3 e'

l Os i

c.

Office of the General Counsol 3,

U.S.

14uclear Regulatory Commincion

[

Washington, DC 20555 f.n u

Jay E.

Silberg, Esq.

Shaw, Pittman, l'ott u 6 Trowbridge 2300 11 Street, 14W Washington, DC 20037 i

~&

Sucan L.

liiatt OCRE Iteprecentative l

l r

h I

1 t

I i

i I

c i

~....

9IPqa Y

a 33950 f uletal Hexister / "ol. 50. No.142 / Wednesday. luly 24. tw1 / Notices ib lP I or the NtJett keratory Conmaiun.

Dated. july 15.1W1.

advised of any ch6nges in act.edule, etc Robert A. Capra.

Gary R. Qiuttethreat.,,

that t'1ay has e occurred

!Lrector. I'rmea Da,0cmte M D.uston of Chef. NacJearheactxs Pmm h Dated laly 1s \\mt

!%utist Pavects4 E 0"ga ef Lcsect

[ Fit Duc. 91-74h5 bled 7-rF9t. In 45 anil Gar) R. Quittschteder.

"A I !

t ed? @ 9t.B45aml r' eso coa neon

[fR Duc 9t t?5U F. led ?O 91. 6 45 smi

      • 3C*'***"

Advisory Committee on Reactor Safeguards, Subcornmittee on Advisory Committe-o on Fleactor Advanced Flesctor Designs: Meeting Safeguards. Subcommittee on Dlweekly Notice Applications and Extreme Esternal Phenomens; Meeting The Subcommittee on Advanced Amendments to Operstmg Ucenses 3

Reactor Destgns wdl hold a mettma on involving No Septuf6 cant Hantids August o.1W1. room P-110. 7CO Norfolk Conskforations Ee I

no r w il o d a e rg Avenue. De theada. MD.

' n August 7,1W1. room P-110,7900

1. D ack ground Norf olk As enue. Bethesda, MD.

He enure meetma wul be open to lhe enure meetma wul be open to pubbc attendance.

Pursuant to Pubhc Law f pt) r 415.

pubbc attendance.The acenda ict the The ogenda for the s.abiect meetma the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (the subject meetma sball be as follows:

shall be as follows: Tuesday. August c.

Cornmission)is pubhshics this rerular Wednesday. keust 7. um-no a m 1M30 an unul the conwsmn of kwnQ nonce. h m15 n. vised

      • W N

enbl the conclusion cf busmess 1he Subcommittee will review the 195L as amended lthe Actl.to require T}:e Subcommittee wdf discuss the modular hich temperature cas rooled the Commissmn to pubbsh notice of any 0

reartor (MiflGR) and the t ower reactor amendments issued, or proposed to be t

c r

mn u saia j! modulv l pglS\\f) issued under a new provaton of 6ection Otal statemena may be presented by nembers of the pubhc with the W.s sponsored by DOf.

109 of the Act. This provision grants the t uncurrence of tr.e bubcommittee Orni statemeras may be wennted by Comrmssion the authonty to issue and Chairman; written statements will be members of the pubhc with IFe make imr.iediate!y effecuve any o ncence of the Subcommittr e amendment to an operstmg license upon acu pted und made avadable to the Chairmrin: wntten statements will be a determmation by the Commission that Committee, RecuJmes wdl be permitted vruy durma inose sessions of the accepted and made available to the such amendment involvt no sign ficant me eting w hen a transtnpt a bemg icpt*

Committee. Recordings wdl be permitted hazards consideranon. notwithstanding and questions may be aned enly by only dunna those cessions of the tha pendency before the Commission of members of the Subcommitter,its meeung when a transcript is tseing kept.

a request for a hearmg frotn any person.

< onsultanta. and staff. Persons desinng und questione may be asked only by This biweekly notice includes all to rnake oral statements should notify members of the Subcommittee sts notices of arnen6meots issu.d. or the ACRS staff member named below a, c nsultants, and staff. Persons desiring proposed to be issued frotn july 1.1W1

!ar in advante as is pract cable so that to make oral statements should notify through july !? 1W1.The last inweekly aptiropriate ar*ancemerits can be rnade.

the ACKS staff member named below as notice was pubhshcd on July 10,1931 (f.0 lhting the Inteting, the Subcommittee. far in advance as is practicable 60 that FR314?.7).

along with ary of tht.t consultants who appropnate arrangements can be made.

Noh Of Consideration Ofissuante Of may be present, may exchange Dunns the met tmg. the Subcommittee. Amendment To Facility Operating

~chmmary sitwa restatdag matters to

. dong with any of its consultants w ho Lkense And Proposed No Sttnificant

! e considered cir:ng the balance of thn may be present. may cubanse llazards Consideration Detemunation nwonc prehminary view s regardms matt < ra to And Opportunity for ifearttry Ihe bobcommittee will then hear be considered durma the baknce of the

resentations tv and hold dacussions meetma.

The Comnussmo has made a pmposed with representataes of the NRC staff.

The Subcommittee will then hear determmation that the fouowmg "m titirlear maur.try, their respecove presentatwns by and hold discussions ameruiment reque sts myoh e no t ;nsultants, a na other interested with representatnes of NRC staff, their smmficant harards considerauon. Under

ersc na terarumn tras review, tonnultants, Department of Energy and the Commasion's reguiabons m to CFR hrther infJrmahon regardmg topics thett contractors, and other mterested 50 92. this means that opersuon of the

' > be dacuued. tae scr.eduhna of persons regardmg this review, f acihty m accordance with the proposed messmns open to the public. wnethcr the further mformation regardma topics amendments wou!d not (1) involve a neetine has oien cancelled or to be discussed. the scheduhna of egmficant mcrease m the prooabihty or renheduled, tie Chairman a ruhng on sessions open to the pubhc whether the consequences of an accident previously recuests far the cpportumty to present meetmg has been cancelled or evaluated, or (2) urale the posubdity of rai statements ar.d the time ailotted rrscheduled. the Chairman's ruhng on d new or different kmd of accident from

'nerefor can be cotamed by a prepaid requests for the opportumty to present any accident previouoy en aluated; or (3) iettate ca.1 b the Descated Federal eral statements and the time shotted mvon e a sigmficant reduct:on m u Ofl.ciuh Mt E1.1o G. !ce (telephone therefore can be obtamed by a prepmd margm of safety. The basis for tha l

MIN 41Pjl t enveen 7 00 a m. and telephone call to the Descated Federal proposed detummat on iur ratn 615 p m. P." sons plannma to attend this Official Mr. Medhnt Ellef tawv amendment request is shown oclow.

I retmg are uqec to contact the above h lephone 301/492-turl) between 7.30 The Commission is sukme pubhc l

u med mdivi.iual ene or two d;n s a m. and 015 p.m. Persons plannmg to comments on this proposed etere the sttecied r.cetmr to be attend this meetmg are urged to centact detenmnation. Any comments recened n

.dtned of ans cnanees m scnedule. etc.

the above named andaidual one or two withm 30 days after the date of at may tun e mrren days before the scheduled meetma to be pubhcation of thh notice will be l

2

1F

-v l'ederal Resister / Vol. 50. No.143 / Wednesday. lule 24, iteJ1 / Nutices 33951 l

t onsidered in makma any fmal nature and estent of the peutioner e If the final determmanon is that the determinanon. The Comminion will not troperty financial. or other interest in ame.ndment request tavolves no normally make a hnal detenninetien the proceeding and (3) the possible sii;mficant hazards considerauon. the unless it receives a request for a effect of any order which may be Comminion may issue the amendment heunne.

entered in t'ie proceeding on th1 and make it immedicteiv effective, Wntten comments may be submitted petitioner s interest. The petition should notwithstandmg the request for a by mud to the Regulatory Publications also identify the specific aspect (s) of the hearme. Any ht' arms held would tale f ace afterissuance of the amendment.

l Uranch. Divteion cf Freedom of subject trattet of the ptcreedmg as to Ir.formahon and Pubucations Semces, which petitioner wwhen to intervene.

if the f naldetennmation is that the Offke of Admmistrauon. U.S. Nuclea.

Any person who has h!cd a petition for amendment involves a siamficant Ruralatory Ccmminion. Washington.

leave to intervene or who has been ha atds consideratmn. any heannr held DC :nS5. and should cite the admitted as a party may amend the would take plato t.elore the tauante of tiublicahon date and page number of I cteuon without requesung leave of the any amendment.

thic federal Register notice. Wntten floard up to idtcen (15) days pnot to the Normsily, the Commission wdl not comments may also be delivered to first preheanna conferenco scheduled in asue the amendment urul the Room p4:3. phdhrs Dulldine. 7320 th. proceeding bt tut h on amended npirattun of the aday notit.e pt riod.

.Wif aik Avenue. Dethesda. Mariland pet tion rnust sabsfy the trecifiuty lloweser should utruntantes dango from 700 a.m. to 41$ p.m. Copies of requinments desented above, '

during the notice I(ned t.ut.h that failuse wntten rammente received may be Not later than hiteen (to) days prmt ta to act in a timely way vauld result, for nample. in deratma cr t.hutdown of the rsam:r.?d 61 the NRC Public Document dm fird prei.carine ccnferent.e fanhty, the Commistinn may issue the Room, the Gelman Duilding, m01, teneduled in the prormting, a petitioner hcense amendtr.ent before the Street, NW, Washington. D C. The hiir; shallIde a supplement to the pention in p requests fet hearms and petitions ivt intervene w hit h naat mclud? a hat og nturnuon of the aaday nnure pened.

f ass e to intervene is discussed below.

the contentions which are sought to t=e prowded that l's final determmation is that the emerdment mvnives no 91, the licensee muy htigated in the matter. Each to'ntention fq,Ily August 23,1 a request for a hearmg with tespect raust consist of a speubc statement of mmhunt hazards consideration. lbe fmal dt termination wnl consider all to issuance of the amendment to the the tenue of law or fact to be raised or subject f acdtty cperatma hcense and controverted. In addittort the pelationer pupe and State comments received Letorn acdon is tab cn. Should the any person whose interest may be Aall proade a briti explannuon of the Comtnini n take this act on,it wdl affected by this proceeding and who bees W the contention and a conctae publish a notice of issuance and provide wishes to participate as a party in the statement of the aHeged facts or espert for oppodundy I r a hcanna sher roceedmu must (de a written petition opinion which support the contentmn -

issuance, The Commission expects that or leave to intervene. Requests for a and on w hich the petitionet inte nds to the need t take this senon wdl occur heanng and petitions for leave to g,1y N poving the contenuun at the

"'"D"""4 intervere shall be filed,1n accordance heatma. The petshoner raust also A request for a hear'eg or a petition with the Commission s Rules of Wde nimm m h ph or b' ave to intervene mat be filed with Pra: Scc for Domestic Llocasing sources and documents of which the Proceedmus in 10 CPR part 2.

b"#87 I

"* " I "*

petitioner is aware and on which the Nuclear Regulatory Comrnission, Interested persons should consult a c*irrent copy of 10 CPR 2.714 which is pouhoner intends to rely to establish Washingtrm. DC 00555. Attentioru atadable at the Commission's Public Mose fads or npen opmion, WHuonu Docketin ; and Services Uranch, or may Document Room. the Gelman llutidine, must prode sukent information to be dehvered to the Commission's pubtle e w that a genume dispute exists with Document I nom, the Gelman Dutiding.

ma L Street, NW.. Wa shington. DC the apphcant en a matenalinue of law ma L Street NW., Washington D C., by

0555 and at the f.ocal Public Document or f act.Contenuons daH be hmued t Rocen for the parneular f acihty involved, the above date. Where petitions are if a request fer a heanns or petition for matters wahin the stere of the f!!cd dunna the last ten (10) days of the amendments under considersuon.1he leave to btervene is filed by the above notice pened,it is requested that the date, u.e Comminton or an Atomic c nienden rnust be one which,il proven, petittoner proreptly so inform the Safety and thensma Doord, designated would entitle the peutioner to rt.htf. A Commission by a tolftte telephone call by the Commission or by the Chairman pend net who fads to fde such a to Western Union at 1400015
3*ioo lin of the Atomic Safety and Licensmq suppkment t hith satisfies these Minoud 1. Moo) m MNL The Western Dourd panch wid rule on the request n'quirements with respect to alleast one Union operator should be given and/or petition and the Secretary or the contenuun will not be permitted to Datagrnm identificanon Number 3737

. desuma'ed Atemic riafety and Licensma pwticipate es a party-and the followmq messaae addressed to Ibard willissue a nouce of heanns or Thore permitted to intervene Lecome (Probu Dhettor): penucner's name und a apprepnate order, parues to the proceeding. subject ta any telephone numben due peution was As required by 10 CPR 2314. a I,mitations in the order granting leas o to muded; t ant name; and pubhcauon d

petition for leas e ta intervene shall set interwne, ar.d have the opportun:ty to date and page numbtr of this rederal l

forth with paruculanty the interent of participate fully in the conduct of the Register nonce. A copy of the petition i

ne ; enHoner in e.e procerdma, and heanna, mcluding the opportunity to

,hould also be unt to the Office of the j

i aw that mterest rnay be affected by the present evidence end cross.examme General Counwl.11S. Nuclear Msents of the proceedmg.1he pet tion witnesses-Pegubitory Commissicn Washington.

thnuld speubcady explain the seasons if a hearms is requested, the DC 00555, and to the 6ttorney for the l

wny mtcrvennon should be permitted Commitsmn wdl make a final hconsee.

i ath particu!ar reference to the deternunstion on the inue of no Nonumdy hiings of peuuona for lease fallowma f actors: til the e

. of the sigmhcant hazards (onsideration.1 he to intervene, amended pentions, petitioner s ncht under l'

to be final deletatnanon wdl serve to decide supplemental puntions and/or requests made a party ta the proc.wme
12) the when the heanng is held.

for beurmg wdl not be entertained I

I f

,n,,. -,. - --,,, - -, - -. -

y

~

q s

1 1

f D952 Fed:ral Regist:r / Yol. 00, No m / WedneWav, lulv M 1!at / Notices W

Mont a detertmnahon t>y the

! etween the PMMS. statmn prot edates

\\LTlDN sta! cme nt "a" and n;akts 61 ' b ' ar.J 6

m
taion. the presiding othr er or o e n suo drewmse and tec hnu al apet da atwns o riew AUnUN statement "a"is addrd Ir.e

'esidmg Atomic balety and 1.!Lrname E*WW*'""""""***'

' #*" d 8 " #N *

  • M'
  • F attrL that the petition and/or reuurst 7 nu m and 6 W adnJ W WeM d h um me mannuuns is na rmm W si c hnu al bpnifn atwris It ere pre no holare s.not tratde m ul er.sure that tte monora v J l>e trunted hated upon n Wa mesoriated with the t hanges r!$r ste de as adalde to ceteCl an at tide nt dant a unt mg of f attors sprof.ed in 10 Ll,R q geogn g,os atuJ'nts upded h 'te Q 1 emuw M M Wrt is e aqw a

. ~14! a 41 W H s I and 2114(dl.

uwes

, e ar ntes or probabday of a f uei e or t.ttiher detsde wnh respet t to tos ne pn. posed L.hanse to I AMJ.

  • anants ac udent.

' un. u r the appbcation fer Mti A'llON Rl mas es H.e let Lnu al n e preposed (lante to reawe a rmmum

+n mne nt uhath is anadable fut pm a 1 prof a ahone consaient mth ow ne" r Der el bolts to hoid the eqmpment t au h mptu non at the Comnussmn s 1%nc u,or uatruna ntatwn o airni M.

sut in u.e domed posamn daru g core

! atu waite and l echnic al bpet da imore lat umcht g. morn. the Ge; man gladdaN' ocranuns e nsures that the containment j

e d m m' or M L C'> 'I M

.J L Mreet. NW, % ashington.1) L i J m asuu isted wah Note 2 in 'Iuble 4 31

' wndan won be snaintained Tt.e le in ne nd at the lxal pubhc dot ureent tuom

,-ad everpower trms set at M m and 1M m reuured to t-e torqued to wnbstanct the te parta alar f at thty u,wh ed

.urd power. T he new his has irte srt et tu s9ess on na hat: h foHuw mu a loss of t' e 4

a ;9 44 S A M TU 69 vi and Im t rated a r e test terros allDHRl ssstem in Connet tir ut i.ankee Atomic Power

m rt t he amdent enah ors muume u ut staunumn w ah the ef fect of a *We Company, Dod et hn. 50 213. lladdam

" e eu rm er inp is in C.bwed ta t.e mtdown earthquake 1%M Rs m ul ence Neck Plant. Middleses County, nnhin a of the stead > state power irut

%st it e hau h duur is t losed and sec ured

,g' Conner tu ut p.r to es ent inmat:on Hrmosit a the le M wing u.e c untan.rnent a leak t$ht bamer lble vf un!erdwent trqual &nt H UW'Y'***d"'*"

I *

  • U ' ( ""M *"" "
  • V*N' UM f
  • r.nK nes assurnpnons omt e itene were

.ci t ana.tng at t ident wid nut be unpat ted

.q

'.,,vsi rm*, on vf ame'n' evn! rr" wred for the o;J NF. 'It e propm d on. e o, t ontamrnent burmt wdl be irtat t.

  • M.yc still reqmtes ar1 os e* pow er (Ep w;4.n
} g pygg, sed t hange to bCRs 4 9 81 and Le prepard amendment h ul t nacce
  • eM o M renmena meemo t t3 4 9 fi :1 deletes o e regorement that O e MIR

' e t An'nIng 8M twr.s of the I r. hr a

' c i e rmoned ~!%s U e propee ni t t-c cr g, % 9 g m y p pg ag,4 r( tht a t}ian %

es t at imput t the ( ennee'

.H o or

. UN r@ sed belause tuosirig Dowrt c

.' '41 1. W a ble Coraroi

' wtsty t I the Main Mum b.nc luent

,+ mrerm nts are a tunttion of t.me frem

' m mtdiet gr trol N nd I we tmn. L, ns S?cem ii"*

utdon ud mhne weier temperature 14 'l 1. T.Me 4 31.

l y"tnd kod n '0""a

  • d "d Na d'"J "

i liR Dewrain af Orsio rpm. espetially dunta I""Dj "H"U ^'"* *

! e winter. t Ould (nuse cuessive cmng of

' [he i L.t.h is not Cletted h (Le proposed 1/4 51.1.CCS kbn stMM-La u t a tt t ; yun or,'.qu al to J.u. I. a' O D e FLS Also dunna trudlocp operanor.s.

j 4 g

' E" 4 b h mene an bl AS f auowma a LOC A and must t e Ibwrotes roulJ result in sorteurta and

' J / 4 7 6. I. ire Su; Treason M Mets t,.nudbscrdy N 0.nsso w em Wir or entramment n the RilR pump suc hon e 3/4 7 9. I'redw stor isohition Vu es i orrec t posihon Valve ID TV ;m is t+ms m h coud hable tt'e purnp hemonta th.s u 'I al,lc 336.

remosed Imm this table omte H f N ears a rewannent w d not impett the I

I 3/4 9 2. Instrumentation Nn < ontamment pressure omrial rather &mn

""*conen es of a loss of DilR betuose tFe

. 3/4 9 4. Contaminent Ibdd.ng an SI AS and is tested as a t antamment b unal bredd abon deftruhun of MODI
6 l. netrations ainahon u.h e unact lednu ni bpec ifaatma

'"quuce tr1e escrare reactor cuolent 3 / 4 9 ft liet.idual I h at llenn al a nd 4 6 3 h*(' lhi8 $ 8h' '8 8"Crd b) "naner upersNa tu t.c below tof f and theref,re D * " * "I b '" IR" ' * " '"'

  • 8 "" d "

"M""I"""""*

' * *"""" h P

C dant 1;M treulatwn

. L,410.,.. I,h sits Test and To hnu al Spec ifa anon 4 51 is ri m.nJat aJiusnas tte Ovweste apprepnately in d memw VaM.: m MOV1 M :

dion. remonna dos renturement w e not flM1.5-1/ 4

  • 6. I are hu;tren n.n or Wu WdW W TAltl14 51 to tellet t a

.mpatt e e t onsequern es of a f set hanans

' =tems und ilASTS-3/4 9 4-rn ent mMdMwn wtuch tunes thne c uJent ntamment Ibuldmg l'ent trations unses to a lose on an blA5 f dlom me a lhe pro;,ennt thange to the rencior tr.p j

T hese ( L wes ute ( orret tmta t a i UCA. *!csong these s m a rs prm uh e arenter u tpomt in L CO 310 N b) frorn an to in t !

)

ilm veta rt h 13 and are a ssurant e that they w al be utde la perf orm F. \\1lD Titl.RMAll'OW LR maa rs tne mmattata e in nature.

W se safety f anthons. hmre these proposed

.e,pomt c onsateet with tbc r.ew NIS As R:sa Orpxpased na s >gmkent

' nams e not affn t tne i tib. n. moic to a ussed at me. the new NIS was pies mm im!$ n'rsn/erothm de ten.mn f.

Wonn as safa 4 Whans Ihus Hine rniewed and apprmed m Amendment Na I *P"*"

0"""""""*"N#

Unenra ac inp setptunt does not negatm iv b remared by 10 CI'll 50 91(al, the

"' " P ~ #

"P'" 'h' (""**"'nt M M pmba tuhh of d e enwe has provided its anoh ns of d e-anah red amdent Matn Denm lane 19ent Control Rod laettmn, meo no smnt scant harurds ne prepmed thange adde AcilON pun,3.esm llew. Control Rod mth:trawal msiderahon, w hich is presented c,nement "c" to t CD 3 7a to nuow 31.mp W Ne d or Ukd Mp Wrtop Atudents

.l P MlW-peranon when a Inatn feedw ater igolahan g

g L 5 on e a ogrofu. ant mc rene in t' e notor operated s ah e IMOV) a moperatae

,g

, g gggg g ggg,,g,,

' n: !.tv or i ensequenr n <d an + s t M

tn uied 0-e MOV Or un assor m!cd

,3

... an u r ident prn mush anamed r

  • , u na a nah. red Gw r. stream manual aohihon s eh r is obsed I1VE!LI A NCE RI.QUlM M}h 711 ? 1

[Le het of rnanual immahon s ah es has bet-n I b "* * *

413 2 os case 3/ 4119 base oern aJJed ta T AULI 3 74 tlc proposed darme F :trea to 41.311 and 4131 ;

t, n;!ow.1 iciop operatism w Len a tr.airi i ' ' ' ' " ' 4 " I* ' '

" "## *8

' I 3 I 'I g n 1 t hy f or r onnisteru v and t, a 6 -

fi edw ater iso lahon MOV a mcorred4 do* s n sa.n w ch $URVL11LWCl mt m4at t the Main $ team Lme lhtak and i!J; ta ' 41311" und ' 4131."

1 C4 71 MLNT 413 2 on i ne 3 / 41 ::

te rn Geocrator '! or Rupture m um ni "M" u es wW nuwam c onsioent s ana I hrs, s c u n's he e t+cn moJ r n.h.smn w nh $UR 413 0

,TV111L\\NM R1 QU$LMENI 4 51 ' 1I or.no see c

4 5 r a j the % ord "und ' n Med Mw een " e r.onud for 31.u p eperatmn t h a M,,

e y a; r g H e w oid ' aJiatntent ' w ch

, mNeed ( henge d +s not Wpa; t ae a nu a and deient u 0:e w orcs '

at s ta u t a r.a t u; ^ and' %nuo"to (. e e intent 01 the tequirement

. mequentes or ; ro% tuiqv of Une un4n

, met m e.s oui t tun IfM Id l andl'iH

.imenriatdc thankes to lLe f.re put,g stridents.

t M IIU MIIMSb IN IM" aR (l'Midered sei ! an en nnn iTu nrunn vea n r

!Le ; mposed c ! r ur to I n nrm.d

+ ntarM ( Lanen and prmide corwent s 4 I ni are [ rf p incu 10 pr.a n. e ( w.4;4kr s

' pet if e; a!400 3; 4 9 2 res i6rs (* c rbtrent W lh r.c w : s rrp'in er in p setpNh's R -

k

t s

f Federal hsister / Vol. bn. No.14: / Weditesday. luly :L wat / Notices 33fA 2 I

l s G uide (RC) IM. llevtston 2. and Generte N/(C Acfmg l'ttwct Diret for: Susan designet No pimal thenue are beu1r maun m ne innt, the addition of a icumicai i

Lettet t>B 11 guidance. The retinod P T Fhankman

@eubcab a to f utuue smfu.aten el sau hmtts also considered a te etsluattun of Southertt Cahfortfa Edison Company, et

usitmns inid t.ut mvohe any reuuttion m a the iow tempetututd on erpretsurtration ab. Dodel Noa. 50-361 and l'D 3G2. San margin t.f safety. TtJs lethrucal spechtauon protection sy stem (1. TOPS) setpoint.

Unoite Nudest Generating Station, l'rdt oil decreene the potenual for vene i

&ases forproposed mi significant Nos.2 and 3. San Diego County.

      • buntnent and wtil strenstrcn the vg reanors absbty to tnanntatn the turrent

[

barottis constderutton deterrnmot:on:

w I

As required by 10 CI'R 50 9)(a) the maron of safety.

hcensee has prvvided its analysts of the DJte c/ omet dment t'equests! lune sit The NRC staff has reviewed the hisue of no significalit basards M1 Mensees' analysts and. based on this

[

tonsideration, which is ntesented Descr@fmn olamerunnent trquestr mvm at appents that the three i

The proposed annendments wdl revis' standards of 509:lel are tuttshed.

beluw; Thete thennes to the Techrutal Techrutal Spect!kations 3/4.52. 'tCCS 1hertfore, the NRC staff proposes to I

$peutications un accordance mth to ut Subn stems. Tos Greater Thott or Equal determine that the amendment requests fMt. Isase tican eselasted to determme d the

.o g,(P )*" and 3/4 8.3 "Contamment I

h d'

epertuou of the facility m accordant, w Ge Isolattuu Valves." A surveillance I

the proposed Amenditerst watdd, rement to vettfy the position of the l.#a/ /'uhhc Do,umenf Iloom

[

U involve a sieruf6 cent increase in the contammetit emergency sump isojation h

n Main labtary,liniverstly of r

probabdity et consequenres of en student s als es and the emergency tate coohng Cahfornia. P.O. Itos 19557. tryme.

I rreemuely evalueted or I

't Create the pombdtty of a r,ew or pump and containtnent optay purnp

( abfortus 92713 (bflerent kind of acudent from any randerd mird flow % altes every Iwelve hours na y

4

)

ce ntuated, or being added to Technical Sper.ibcatior Atta Lsymie. Southern Cahfornia j

presmustfte a signdicant reduction m the 1/ 4 5.2. Valve abenment clartikation is Mnon Gmpan m Box m 31 int o

    • r8* nl **IttY added to 3/4 tt3 for the cot initunent Posernea1Cah ma 91770 j

Re<au.uiation of hoatup/couldown brws emergency sump 5 nives hsted in Tub!c NWtumi &redon lames L, Wr unma appeuved NRC rnethodolon ooes not

,3101 and uddressed by the survedlante mettese the ptvt abahty et contenuentes oi dmg auded to 3/4 51 An Acuon is Tha Cleveland Electne liluminating un ecudent. New htmte eenetaied frciri hetnd added to 3/4.$2 tu trnoke Com;unny, Genterior bervice Company.

approved tuethodology do not reduce the manon of safety, Techmcal Specificalton 3/4 0.1.1 m the Duquesne Llaht Company. Ohio Edison D6enon el educahon tnate tal that a n;ure event contatrituet)t inteattty is breathed Company, Pennylvania Power r

i meopriately docultiented outside of Basts fct /wposed no stemhcant Corrpeny, Toledo Edison Company, t

Technical Evenhcal on does not t f fet t the

.Laza/T/s considerotmn determmotmn?

Dodet No. 50-440. Perry Nucicar Power entdeter he reymred by 10 CTR 50 91(a), the Plant. Unit No.1. Lake County. Ohio

{

utensees have provided theit analysts of Date c/ omendment request I

i a en a ddferent type arcadent.

the issue of no signthcant hatards g

Iteduuns the L1015 setpoint protects ts, Appendia G lumta and prevents kilR consideration, which is presented j

r overpressurtsatzun. A setpomt reduction below!

  1. cuription of omendment request!

[

reduces the consequences of an

1. Wul opershon of the (muity m The proposed tbanges would revise the

[

overpressurisanon event bet ause nuusation accordance with ttus prepoted change l

is stuunted eather. This results in a smaliet involve a significant increase in the Techmcel Specificauons (TS) for the 4

thallense to the RilR s) stem and reduces the probabd.ty or consequentes of an omdent Perry Nu : car Power Plant. Umt 1. to rrobabahty of fadure. lieduuns the L10l$

previously etaluate tf

>toude new teattor vessel pressure-

[

a uptunut does not cause a di!!erent kinJ uf The required valve potations are not bems Mmperature htmts, recalculated using et nent. Timee custa.s au.eptance tritens t hanged. The system as beses og ersted as W.%rmulas of NRC Rettulatory Guide

te stdl enet thes e is no reduttion m a enrrion designed No physical chanees are bema W Rensmn 2. as requesRd by NRC, f

isafety.

maoe to the plant lie addition of a techrucal Genenc Letter (GL) b&lt in additmn.

,f A.idluonal restittuona ensure no s.nsie rteuht auon to require ten 6 cation of valve movertent operator setwn w di resuit in posiut.no wdl not mvoNe any merense in the the proposed changes would rernove the runs m cuon due to St The LTOl$ setpomt prubatnhty or consequence s of an acndent reactor vessel malcital survedlance i

eased on possible eness truettwn and heat prenously evaluated. Since this techrucal program withdrawal schedule from the siecuan cases is adlusted to sneet eutma spen 0 cation wdl dettes se the potennal for T Ss and would relocate the schedule m i

auaTearce criteria.1terefore the

. s elve nusehentnent the probatHhty or-the Perry Updated Safety Analysts tonnertuences or probabdity of an awdent consequem ee of an accident prevmusly Report (USAR)in attordance with NRC we not meressed, a new accident is not naluated will be decre sed.

GL DIS 1, Assor;ated changes to the I

t renied or is a rnarem of safety reduced

.~. Wdi opersuon of the fac:hty in Ibes are als9 proposed.

i The NitC staff has reviewed the acordante with this proposed chanue cevate i

bcenstie's analysis and. based on this the pombibty of a new or different kmd of Basis fer pmpowd no sigm/irant edent from any saident preuously harcrds considervimn determmeliotr

(

review. It appears that the three

" "I"" W As requued by 10 CD150.91(a), the j

standards of 10 CTR fiO 9 Ic) are i

causfied. Therefore, the NRC edaff

[$[

m,P,$'j$ "'[,

bconsee han prowded its analysis of the l

[

    • "I"
  • N"M Proposes to deterintne that the desc.ed. No physical chanets are beina consujetation.The NRC staff has cendment request involves no made to the plant. The addihon of a tertnn; revmwed the hcensee's analysis attainst l

esmficant hazards consideration neubcat.on to rmunte venficauon of udie he standards of to CI'R 509?lc).The Leca/ M//c Document / loom pouuons wiu not create the pombibiy of a

'*w "r dithmt kmd of acc. dent from any stall's review is presented below; f

'ecatmn Rothester Pubhc Librury.1u Tha proposed chnngre do not involve buth Avenue, Rochester New York amdent premudy nahintest i Wdt operetton of the f acmtv in

.t peruficent (twrease in the probabihty g ggg

" '""'d ""' ' "" 'h 0'"P d 'h"'*

  • or consequerires of a previously i

A riarriev for licensec; Nicholas S.

Reynolds. l.ltr. hop. Winslott A StraEn.

[f

  • e unluatr o accident. because the revised i
ressure temperature limit curves are iW L Street. N W., Washmuton O C.

The tequired vah e posmans are not bemu deterrnmod in nccordance with 10 Cl R j

ZOM r hanent The svetem to ben operated as i

h i

13 W red:r:! Hewister / Vol M. No.142 / Wednesday. luly M.1tml / Nobres d

' art u A:;endices G and it uung the Te( hnical bret ihronon f! S) N ( tun ti o.

Wbronsin Puhuc Senue Corporation.

A onservua e methods dear.ribed in NRC 3dm:mstratn e Controls " for 11 e Ib ket No. 50405. Aewaunte Nuticar

&nerie 1-4 ner M 11 and NRC Dms i.eue Nuileur Power 5tatmn Powor Plant, Kewsunee County, Regulatory Guide 1 to Revmon / These milNPS) to and fleutuhty and ainv Wlunnun

  • evned ( u.es will establid a ytin alent t tnrwes in d.c c umpismen of the it f.mre t t r servatn e 1.rnits im reac tor Statmn Rniew floatd. In told;tmn some d " #""# #*#

s etel pre 15are as a fum tian of

eutun tules within 15 6 0 w ound be 1 % a s suNa runted by h tti t d.ned

'emm ratae durink tr.c hrst n ) ears of own ed to reth t omanunnenal

!"# N

  • liet uve t i power (Toratmn. I he t %nces.

Ih sctrr en e/ vmendment tewest-

' Hor u ta q s i the nun cular:t e t ainu!c Ihis requet.t proposes amendments to jw (g j..my fy p _,g g

w ithdr -th ai e hedule trorT) the 1 S to the

'he ken auflee hur le ar Pow e r l'larit

m 7,,,, n. gj, m, g,9 f p f...,

, y.,

USAR m aaordance wnh GL 9141. is u M mmred h m U R 'O W U e I k NI'EI I "fl'*"I h CC I'C "I'""'

P

. ately aa.nistrative t haner. NRC prior

. nu e Mt g rogideu a and ta of de F ' ' I " ' " * I * " "I ' "" d ' U V ' I'"

1pprov.d a 6tdl not.euary fcr any m 'ofno k d MMds m enge rerstdinir NRC Leneric INier br*e t i N n bethde thcli.

Ihe etct( wd thanges do nc t trea'e

, ; w3.Mm e h n mm W J h W N6. Ihs !vt;er ru. In weh neric

ui# m n u,g g.,,,t the tm ;samt e N and beneric issue 14 whu 5
  1. pehay of a tww or d.iferent kin 1

' anges arvi d, amoned e.a a nWa et I "'"' " f * *M'pe ra ted r e M s A a f at r ident from any ac udent prniousiv uards r onourratmn does not e ul tm ause end blink t ahr relialnhty and 6

+ valed :etause the prot'osed pernmn of de idNps Un t N nar 1. :n ndditmaallow tt mi erature i

i hat;tm Q r at invohr any c har nes to r r omam e w m thne t t eres wd a crpret t,ure potet tion. The proposed I bnt rm onents not do they introduc e Lt mee a swn.fgant im one m the c menQrents molude testnctmns or. the 4

w imw rredes of operation. Tl e plant i " $10') W en u udent yn mum

t. wit p[,11nat tive reactor r oolant s dl be otc aird with.n the revud d

' M *d"10" * *' N' mneir s or punp. hmitirW (orihtions for operuhon yratu e ; reoure h~uts, w tA h w!!! be

" * " "C " '" ' b ' P"' " ' " M ' W " 'd r

of 9 e prersuract power +perated reh"I

'. 'o "r e# " " "

h *'" P *^

ternunen ei a more rt noen am e s 1:s l 5 e 0 s A es IPORVal ami assounted bloc k

" innt t. I he it locatmn i.f the s sh e S. und operabdity requiren.cnts of gg

.g g,

m eiliam e r apsule withd.uw al tne hv. temperature overpressure m n g g m,, 3 g ; g.,

y theduie is an dnurustrata e < narme

. n.mmed tu r use rm m.ters or protet hon (L10Pl s ys tem.

N1 wid I ne no clie(t on presious enumMions Ier a petiows nalustr.1 Adtninistratin e thanges are also

< c ident araivars.

< o i.ient are nin en t.$ es e,. pn me.1

repoted.

e 1he pror med rharan do r;ot ins olve mces to 1S rs n Fasis f.1/wnmd no sient/n ont

- antta et redettien m the mrein of Za.*et ura*e the peautatv of a now imd

! he n'tss!own h'nindicm

'alety beia.ae the resihrd prenture.

t I at v. dent p enoos!y n aluaird t rc tmse na As requhrd by 10 CFR 50 91(a), the cinperature units toraervatn ety

.. c*nt mn.ators are r trated '.o r ew b

er b o ided its analysis of the (count for reactor vnnel tr:adiatbn hanMam denen am h !r e made, no new bruc o no sigm irant hatart s i mbrittlement and are based on the~

." " 8 "'s n o w an m new ennahng

,ik,st NRL, ruidehnen in Revulato'Y r ampidanor a are leems unied t.y U n, r onsiderutmn w hith ti presented below:

i mm mn o hl Hem tot rooiant temp startma buido 1.tG Rniston 2. along with a tual outron fluenw data obtamed for Perry

b Not ueue the pos Mty of a 6fierent P"d"I"""U 8 I mt 1. T he reiocation of the surveillant.e

).nd of acuder.t from any acudent prennusly The pmpned thenge was teuewe d m

, vr.haated ber ause no au ident mastors are k' "'d a h" " "h th' 0N""h' *I 3 D N

< apsule wntdrawal nhedule is an i reated. No r. hance a m harda are, tonne.. or D' C I" "i"'w en sw hcant hazards cost.

mimuustra'n e rhance only. Therefore.

hir.t rr.arapubtnr.s are t cir e urined t y I b" I D"'d ' l' h" "IU ""

ite custire margin of r,aftty will be

%w po,pmed thantes to TS 0 0 U involic a swmtu ant mcrease iri the unntmne d 1 Lt inni!ve a e umfnant redut or n m a 3 '"M"W r4 onsrquenne of an un Ad lWed on "as review it a; Tears D at arrn of sair'v t,crause the S'abon I:niew

m umsey n aNaN l

IN,"is reqmrM m prnsumi J w Herk "" ) " "' P"' '

'"# 'P I" * "

I""""""'

w three raandards of M 021c1 hre l )ard w nl nri.nue to be (omtomrd of itafied' li erefore' the NRC staf f

< spumi esa superen personm i

., ropot.es to Cetermine that the wnh espertae in the risupLnts of r lent runont pmnh pnnn1nm asaw Mu e

..mendment requeel mio;ves no om,f a tiove. rnaa"enanc e, painnme.

f.ubre of the teat tor tresure vessel phe

'wnlin ant r:nards considerutton-r unoimal a nuuls. engmerone er d quahty O'*" I""'s of the LNpP LTOP erstem j

la al R * ! c DurcineN hoom neuranr e. T he o'her proposed t hanges are

""*"MN"*"*'*E""#

s.ru d.v shn:sustae m reture 4

m e between the anondary side hrat 4 Oth' 'I e *ry Pubhc IJhrarv. Z3 Mam S'nk and the rentint coulant sistem cold leg 8

S treet. Fern. Ohia 4 4081.

w a b h se than or equal to Itur F w hen a

.ltte er a hcensee:l1y Obere,

, n s

an on %,

rendor r oulant pump is started Tlus i

H M

Uq. hbne, httmun. Potts &

} Myos f niudes an additionel

.a br ake..,.Xx) N Stree t, a,..,

tlandards of 50 930l are satahd.

,utnan s1Nm e roMrol to er.sure that the

.. agge ut.m 1 W ort u E M f m,m s m

+ w we of m LIOP system is sansimJ AE < /c 4 r thm rx J J " "

,,mm ons,_ u,,,r,,,,a npmm&,

motvn no swmheant huaros

'"e a *"d """"' m ' u'a "* WP A PPr"*

  • 1oledo Edann Cornpany. L,entarmt r ansideratmn

" l* "" ""nnna tan kmns H igure ! S 31 Scrur.e Cweanv. crid The Cles cland M CI E DF / *U*CN RJ"'

a w id not t>e cu reded due to an energy w nent m mon, en pmposed < r aree U # O""8dV "I MCE 1E4%

I:lertnc Plununating Company, Dotket

'n rot inne nic tr.c probatuhty or

'.A 5d 116. Dms Hesse Nuc! car Power Doments Nanment. 2801 ILm rutt s squen ca d nn mu ident preuon hidhon !?mt NO.1. OttJ%a County, M

oDM

< NM t)hio

.itMrree f 7e /a envee-Gerldd

. em tm W ru e m kom en um Jed

# d '" N P"4ohity of a new or IA " m _ -nhent tr.m s!. m y 10.

1771 Barnoff.13 quire. Sha w. httman. Potts d lt owbriae. J300 N Stret. ' W.

]

[",y,[t z w u mm,mm v.}ewon. o Cmw md of arndent fmm s,e p,__ m,ma u nme l'

  • pt m m. amanam+ nt w mud rnise

'ir fl &

4

!)f,;e - } = tn '. Il m e.on

< eacd by meis,Fange rFe emposed B

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20082P168&oldid=4370292"