ML20081C802
| ML20081C802 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Fermi  |
| Issue date: | 03/09/1984 |
| From: | Jens W DETROIT EDISON CO. |
| To: | Harold Denton Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| EF2-67-767, NUDOCS 8403150021 | |
| Download: ML20081C802 (22) | |
Text
I l
Wayn) H. Jins tear bhat ons Detroit i
Edison "=***"C*
March 9, 1984 EF2-67,767 Mr. Harold Denton Director of Nuclear Reactor Regulation U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555
Dear Mr. Denton:
Reference:
Fermi-2 NRC Docket No. 50-341
Subject:
Operating Shift Experience The members of the Utility Group on Operating Shift Experience are providing our individual experience status at the request of the Chairman, D.
F.
Schnell, of the Union Electric Company.
A summary of Detroit Edison's operating shif t experience is attached using the same format as the other members of the Utility Group.
The data is based on an assumed operating license date of June 30, 1984.
Edison will be using shift advisors to satisfy the " hot par-ticipation experience" requirements.
The qualifications of the identified Shift Operating Advisors (SOAs) are also provided. The SOAs are being trained on Fermi-2 systems and operating procedures and will be taking the examination for an SRO license on Fermi-2 as arranged with Region III.
The operating experience data has also been summarized in a format which more dramatically shows the level of equivalent nuclear operating experience on each of the operating shif ts.
Though Edison does not commit to more than the Technical Spec-ifications requirements of two ROs and SROs per shift, it is clear that additional depth on shift is available.
We con-sider this very appropriate for this stage in our operation.
The minimum nuclear operating experience per shift, per ANSI 3.1 (1981) guidance for two SROs and two ROs totals 72 months.
An analysis of our equivalent nuclear operating experience tabulated per shift indicates that the average shift (consisting of two SROs and two ROs) has significantly more experience than that specified in ANSI 3.1 (1981).
f e
a
Mr. Harold Denton EF2-67,767 Page Two Since most of these operators, engineers and advisors have been working together for over two years, and have been anti-cipating shift assignment during plant startup, we do not expect any difficultics in their functioning as an effective team under the strict control of the Nuclear Shift Supervisor.
Furthermore, because of the high level of morale and support from our staff in the past, we do not anticipate any signi-ficant attrition over this year during startup and initial operations.
In my letter to Mr.
B.
J.
Youngblood dated December 16, 1983, transmitting the previous Nuclear Experience Survey, I took pride in the talented and qualified operators and staff selected to operate and manage Fermi-2.
We continue to believe that we have assembled a well qualified organization capable of operating Fermi-2 safely and efficiently.
Sincerely, cc:
Mr. Hugh Thompson
[hk2 Mr.
P.
M.
Byron Mr.
M.
D.
Lynch
Shift 1 OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE Page 1 of 1 1
COMMERCIAI.
NUCLEAR NAW NUCLEAR EXPEFWENCE EQUIVAIENT I
WJCLEAR EXPEfuENCE EXPERENCE SIheLAR TOTAt.
RO/SRO DEGREE WMULATOR Om TS BWR PWR ON EOOW S
No Limit 36 9
12 24 9
9 12 anowgp Pie ce 4
152 46 3
17 15 68.5 3
3 58 15 40.5 NASS SRO E"
g SRO 42 56 3
16 15 63.5 36 36 3
8 15 49.5 O
Karnik 84, 27 38.5 NSO D. Pierce 60 12 1
34 6
8 51 NSO Ratncke 12 84 5
30.75 NSO 4
STA (*1) g TOTAL 4
381 3 'r 7 16 34 155 8
75 406.75 I
1.0
.75
.75
.5
.25 3.0
.25
(*2)
.25
.5
(*3)
N TRE! M MONTHS NSS - Nuclear Shift Supervisor
- 1 For data see STA Summation Sheet l
NASS - Nuclear Assistant Shift supervisor
- 2 Less than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.75 i
NSO - Nuclear supervising Operator More than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.50 STA - Shift Technical Advisor
- 3 Bachelor of Science Degree - 12 months Associates of Science Degree - 6 months NOT 3-5-84 I
,ll l,
50 75 s
T E
sh N
C ddht EE N
aat n La E
5 5
oono A T R
5 2
5 2
LLom 1
N=
E m
U1 P
f Q
X 0
6 7
6 0
5 5
tll 6
o E
E 4
7 5
4 6
7 5
eee2 3
euu1 -
hFF 1
S
- e oo e
e nt t er g
o eg a
irrre P
t o o gD E
a ii e E
)
mrrDe R
2 3
mpp c
4 1
u en 8
.E
(
S ssce rrni 5
Aaaec T e ei S 3
S yyc Sf T
N e%%
o O
M 9
5 5
5 5
5 5
i11 f N
t os 5
1 1
1 1
1 7
nn e
EPT aaart S
thhoa at tli d
ec G
seh o 4
rsrcs 9T oeoas FLMBA
- X 9
5 N
12 3
2 E
DO E
C CNE T
I NN
)
R WA 42 8
1 6
7 0
4 6
2 E
E OL 5
4 1
1 1
4 P
RC P
1
(
X AN E
EEI LR T
C E F
UP S
I NX R T E N 2
5 l
E mA i
1 S
L 2
OP G
E N
I M
T
,E A
C O N MoE RE 0
I 3
3 3
3 3
5 R
1 P
E 9
3 O
PXE R
EH 8
5 2
4 0
9 5
2 T
2 7
7 3
6 6
2 O
M S
r 6
SW o
3 s
WP i
E. p O W 6
0 1
8 5
v "E
RO 5
2 7
4 9
r 1
e D
pr E
uo St R
a N
E 5
rt r H
of er 7
T si p o O
t ihOs LA i
vS i
I EE-m r
gv C
R i
5 et nd R X W
L 7
pniA eR P
uas o
Stil tO A N
sva C E 0
ti rc LC R
6 6
f sei W
3 3
1 ispn A4 s
hAuh 1
S S c r
e rarT T
aea el et ID l clf Ep cuci R E O
L uNuh CW O
R O
)
A 2
MO R
S R
O 1
T N
NS S
S R
un O
s l
(
T S
m t
mA S
h 0
A SOA X
f S
A T
AST i
M y
N S
NNNS h
S l
.,i 5
l P
?. ?
Shift 3 OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE Page 1 of I cOnasERC4AL NUCLEAR N
EQLNVALENT W NUCLEAR EXPERENCE IGJCLEAR EXPEIENCE EXPEfENCE SM EM M 8AO DEGfEE 3asts.ATOR ROEws EXPERENCE OTHER OWN COPE)UCTDeG SPE sd EXPERENCE OTHER PLANTS PLANT LEsnsE BWR PWR OTHER g ypyg Tm
[ow"go#
No Limit 36 9
12 24 9
9 12 3
8' 3
58 15 40.5 NSS SRO Lightfoot 84 3
58 15 61.5 NASS SRO N
SRO Whited 3
17 15 28.5
?
r NSO RO i
s Powell 42 30 3
16 15 57 NSO RO sic 42 52 18 46 Brtdley 35 96 6
40.5 STA (*1)
TOTAL 4
129 349 15 185 75 330.25 W BGledG 1.0
.75
.75
.5
.25 3.0
.25
(*2)
.25
.5
(*3)
FACTM TSE N MONTHS NSS - Nuclear Shift Supervisor
- 1 For data see STA Sununation Sheet i
NASS - Nuclear Assistant Shift Supervisor
- 2 Less than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.75 NSO - Nuclear supervising Operator More than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.50
, STA - Shift Technical Advisor
- 3 Bachelor of Science Degree - 12 months Associates of Science Degree - 6 months NOT 3-5-84 2
i E
TNEL N
L A E
5 5
A T R
5 5
2 5
2 N3 E
UT P
0 8
6 3
9 8
3 8
8 Q
4 6
5 5
4 3
3 3
3 E
2 1
g 9
5 5
5 5
5 5
1 1
1 1
1 1
9 4
8 7
5 1
5 3
0 4
3 E
2 5
1 1
2 CN EW S
O H
P S
T X
N E
2 O
1 M
M E
BT 9
3 3
3 3
. 3 3
R E
4 5
3 9
7 0
8 4
3 5
0 2
G 6
8 R
T AE O
1 EC LN CE 6
UW 3
NU WP X
AE 0
3 5
3 5
2 6
0 6
6 4
1 6
6 N
R EH T
O
",o t
i m
R R
i s
w L
m P
o N
Rw 4
s "m
G O
R O
R O
y L
NO R
S R
0 O
yO n
r A
HT S
S eR tR eR o
z e
T
[
k t
r f
l s
e b
O GC BA N
r lS n
e i
t n
d i
T aS lS iO lO rO rO hO lO rO WF m
lS aA lS aS hS aS oS aS eS a
CN HN FN PN TN HN JN VN TN e
u s
1 l1j 4
1 4
l
Shift 4 OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE Page 2 of 2 COMMERCIAL NUCLEAR N
EOLMALENT AN EXPEFWENCE part F4R EXPEfE30CE m
TCTAL DEGREE
(
m sRO aman ATOR TadE DR8 CLEAR PLANT N
OTER OWN l
CONDUC N N
EXPERENCE l
LumpseE BWR PWR OTHER OTHER PLANTS PLANT MAXadMM CREDff No Limit 36 9
12 24 9
9 12 ALLOWEp STA (*1) 4 1
TOTAL 4
314 450 18 126 90 415 WBINSNB 1.0
.75
.75
.5
.25 3.0
.25
(*2)
.25
.5
(*3) s FACTOR N
TadE N hsoms NSS - Nuclear Shift Supervisor
- 1 For data see STA Summation Sheet NASS - Nuclear Assistant Shift Supervisor
- 2 Less than 1% years prior to ruel Load
.75 i
NSO - Nuclear Supervising Operator More than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.50 I
- 3 Bachelor of Science Degree - 12 months Associates of Science Degree - 6 months 4
NOT 3-5-84 1
l 1
l TWE NA UCN LP 2
E 5
5 T R R 5
5 5
7 7
A E N3 f
E P o
7 2
0 9
5 7
6 2
T L X C E 6
/-
4 4
4 2
3 3
4 1
UN sga P
M 2
1 E
D M.G ET d
N 9
5 5
5 5
5 6
aNR 1
1 1
1 1
TET PS G
89TCU 9
e p
O C
ECNE T
MA N
4 7
5 8
6 6
2 7
6 8
I 2
R L
5 4
4 3-E P
PXE SH T
S T
NT N
F X
N 2
I E
O A
1 H
L M
S OP M
GN I
E T
R E C
R O N T
NT A
R AE LR 9
E 3
3 3
3 3
1 P
uE d P O
eX S E R
E 4
6 9
2 2
0 H
8 6
2 6
4 5
R T
AE O
EC LN ll 6
CE S
UN sW 3
N E YP wF VX Ep 2
6 3
4 2
8 OW A E 1
4 3
4 5
N ROD E
R NO EH T
O NE t
i R
H m
i S
W RE P
L A
o Il E
N LC R
a W
4 s
p s
i R
D O
k L
O E
R O
s O
5 W
R S.
dR wO O
n A
T O
nS m
nS eR R
i a
T "m
C o
o o
l s
a e
y m
O t
A s
rS m
a i
m n
l d
T F
S Wm""
f N
O u
nS t S sO rS vO iO iO lO oO D
i I
E eS sA aS oO aS rS lS eS oS T
h m
HN ON HN KN DN TN KN KN GN S
a E
O ne L
P g
,l
- i 4$
. = _, _ - _ _ _ _ _
Shift 5 OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE Page 2 of 2 cmasRCsAL NUCLEAR TRANNG EOLAVALENT NUCLEAR EXPERIENCE paars FAR EXPEfuENCF EXPERENCE SIhsLAR TOTAL popsno TWE DWCLEAR PUUv7 POWHON OTHER Oted k
N EXPERENCE LEEpmE SWR PWR OTTER OT}ER PLANTS PM
-- cR-r No Limit 36 9
12 24 9
9 12 ALLOWED STA (*1) l i
i l
i 1
i l
TOTAL 4
195 333 16 215 81 385
~
1.0
.75
.75
.5
.25 3.0
.25
(*2)
.25
.5
(*3)
N TBE! N MONTHS l
NSS - Nuclear Shift Supervisor
- 1 For data see STA Sununantion Sheet NASS - Nuclear Assistant Shift Supervisor
- 2 Less than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.75 NSO - Nuclear Supervising Operator More than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.50 STA - Shift Technical Advisor
- 3 Bachelor of Science Degree - 12 months 4
Associates of Science Degree - 6 months i
NOT 3-5-84
Shift 6 OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE Pags 1 of 1 M
NAVY NUCLEAR EX NCE EOLNVALENT xm l
EXPEFWENCE N
TOTAL DEMEE RO N nasagyog Om TS BWR PWR OTW 3
i, ALLOWED
-12 No Limit 36 9
12 24 9
9 1
Stedler 3
15 55 3
15 15 53.75 NASS SRO t
l t
22 76 3
4 15 48.75 Haitzenrater NSO SRO
}
4 Palmer 6
66 3
21 15 49.5 L
NSO RO 1
t
- l Lcubenstein 36 66 3
9 15 57.75 NSO RO Snyder 18 84 5
33.75 NSO Trcpp 108 36 6
40.5 NSO s
Given 84 36 7
35.25 i
NSO i
STA (*1) j TOTAL 4
205 467 15 36 125 75 359.75 l,
WBGMNG 1.0
.75
.75
.5
.25 3.0
.25
(*2)
.25
.5
(*3)
FACTM N
TmE N MONTHS NSS - Nuclear Shift Supervisor
- 1 For data see STA Summation Sheet NASS - Nuclear Assistant Shift Supervisor
- 2 Less than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.75 NSO - Nuclear Supervising Operator More than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.50 i
- 3 Bachelor of Science Degree - 12 months Associates of Science Degree - 6 months j'
i, '
NOT 3-5-84 4
i
STA OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE Page 1 of 1 COMME N N ALENT NAhEE NAVY NUCLEAR EX RIE NR EXN EXPERENCE SansLAR igyAt EN M/SRO ssMULATOR TE NUCLEAR PLANT Om N
RO.EWS EXPERENCE COpeuCTNG SPENT M EXPERENCE OTHER PLANTS PLANT TRNG.
No Limit 36 9
12 24 9
9 12 ALLOWED D:ng
.25 47 4
12 30.5 STA Hrupt
.25 86 4
12 32.75 STA McCracken
.25 46 4
12 30.25 STA Ohlsmacher 48 12 3
33 4
12 62.25 STA Tibni 3
85 4
12 41 STA TOTAL 48 12 6.75 297 20 60 196.45 1.0
.75
.75
.5
.25 3.0
.25
(*1)
.25
.5
(*2) g
_E" TREEN MONTHS
- 1 On Shift within 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.75, STA - Shift Technical Advisor Other plant experience
.25
- 2 Bachelor of Science Degree - 12 months Associate of Science Degree - 6 months NOT 3-5-84
l!,!
II
!1,I l
Il 50 75 T
s N
sh EL ddht 5
5 5
5 5
5 aat n LA A T 9
oono MT C
8 2
0 0
7 6
LLom X
8 5
4 4
4 2
m E
ll 6
1 ee2 uu1 -
f FF o
- e oo e
1 tt ereg e
rrre g
)
o o gD a
2 6
2 ii e P
1 2
2 2
3 rrDe 1
1 1
(
pp c
4 g
en 8
ssce rrni 5
aaec eeiS 3
yyc Sf T
5 5
5 5
5 5
5 6
o O
9 1
1 1
1 11f N
os nn e
aart hhoa t tliec seho 5
srcs eoas 9
2 LMSA 1
2 E
4 6
6 8
8 8
6
)
8 1
C 2
4 4
5 5
7 2
N E
(
C E
N IR S
E H
T P
3 N
X X
E E
2 5
O 1
2 M
T F
W I
H E
S S
G T
N 0
I 9
T 3
3 3
3 3
5 1
3 A
R E
P O
R 0
5 0
3 2
E 3
R T
AE O
EC LN CE 6
U 3
NRE YP 8
5 VX 8
7 t
r A E 7
n e
N e
e d
n n
i e
g t
n R
E 5
n E
N i
H 7
r s
T O
e nr t
p oo i
5 u ri s Eg P
R m
S eti r 7
eave X
i WP L
t nrre ni e e n o
a g p pi N
t nOug n
R 0
sE S n i
t E
W M
s snanl 1
ssns Aot oa O
i si c R
- titi eE S
asan
. rsrh GNM t eAec D
t O
L pp pe W
p O
R O
O A
HT uO OT nO ku R
nS R
R T
GM s
S cS tS o
nS S
O B
_ f aL NA0AO.T f
L e
s s
o T
. E.
F m E.
a.
W mA b
t i
t a
x s.
n a
rt u.
s E. O. S. E.
E e
t es q E.
r O.
e S.
o E.
s S
y b
r l
OA 1(
,Il li
<lf l[llllI-
,l l
A l
,l
SOA OPERATING SHIFT EXPERIENCE Pege 1 Of 1 COMRCIAL NUCLEAR N
EOtAVALENT m
^
EXPERENCE IRACLEAR EXPERENCE EN M
TOTAL DEGREE RO/SRO TOR M
IAACLEAR PLANT r
N OTER OWN N
E EXPERENCE UCENSE SWR PWR OTER OTE R PLANf3 PLANT
=X CR-T ALLOWED No Limit 36 9
12 24 9
9 12 Duda 72 60 4
12 98 SOA SRO
=
James 10 4
105.5 96 SOA SRO s
Jolley 192 8
4 200 SOA SRO 96 24 4
12 128 How2rd SOA SRO 84 24 12 24 48 4
126 l
.3 i
i, TOTAL 540 48 12 24 108 18 20 24 657.5 WBGNNG 1.0
.75
.75
.5
.25 3.0
.25
(*1)
.25
.5
(*2) pgy,
!N TNE N WONTHS SOA - Shift Operations Advisor
- 1 Less than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.75 l
Hore than 1% years prior to Fuel Load
.50
- 2 Bachelor of Science Degree - 12 months Associates of Science Degree - 6 months l
NOT 3-5-84 i
8 1
DATE 3-6-84 Prg2 1 et 1 OPenA73,,c SHIFT sErz7tE3ses PLAuf pApes Farr.i 2 Shift Opersting Advisor UTILITT Detrait Edison
.ros TITsas 6.L. oats 6 4 84 im n
,,=u,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,c, POS OPenATIIBG sNIPT PosITtoIIs (note 3) serfsn DATAs fooIFTNs/MONTils a afs!CalTIssG PAcron sisICitTIIIG MAIIseUM TYPs OF sIPsetENCs FACTOs CRFDIT I
2 3
4 S
0 7
8 I
I8
- 1. sAns TTPE casessac AL sao 3.se soo Lapt?
72 96 192 96 84
- 2. ornsa cmsessactAL sao
.7S mo lam 7 18 18
- 1. sAMs TVP: CopWIssCIAL no 1.00 Is0 LIMIT
- 4. OTHan C m eCIAL so S.7S 900 LIMIT S. IRAVT EMILITAmT) IIUCtAAR 34 peoIITMs (luo. stes, soole, Prels) 4.54 (orusal 0.25
- 6. CINUIAfon 12 MONTHS (marsIWuCs PIAgrtl 5.90 112 MONTMsl (sIMIIAnl 3.99 (9 MONTHSD
- 7. muciaAs PLauf asPentenes oss smart scuse P:Asert 24 nonfies 7.5 6
6 (Lass TuAm a 1/2 TsAsis PnIOn To F.L.)
9.75 (12 squerrwS) 6 (soons Tienes 1 1/2 TsAms Paton To r.L.)
s.Se (12 suosmes) e.Se e nosmos 2
2 2
2 2
- s. Ltcassso,c,,A,,s,s,mansi Tanguino Amo s Ass gown
- 9. PAm?ICIPATION AT orgamftslo PIAffT 3.7S 12 Isoumes te. OTNsa IIUCLsAn PsAIIT ssPentEHCs 0.25 32 HoIFFIIs it, conoucTaus Lacamss TaArmino e.2S e seosmos 32,esons: tauctussassio, APPLaso scsames on z3UIVALaseTI 12 geoemis asAcuzions soonssi (32 seawTus) 12 12 (Assoc ATss escasan is seosmes TorAL isuctaAa P: Asst asPsassences 98 105.5 200 128 128 mor PAmTrerPAfross esPsarsucs Tins e 2et was tuss, 250 333 665 416 368 sTAavvP a seUfooun (Tas/zol yes yes yes yes yes 72 96 192 120 108
,,,,,,,,,a,,,,,,,
nova is ses = ssTaucTrome ron nos or uUetsAs Pousa P:AerT ssPshrssses rAcrosis rewt cuses aus or -3ss Potammersics oPseAfteIG sIIIFT PostTIOWs lOL APPLICAffTel' D
e.
shift advisore mise 2 be essed to setlefy the 'het porticipation giors 2s lleCLuos ALL sNIFT sUPssWIsOas (sel,1sIPF seO's, asACTom OPseAfons (1101 eePertence* requiremente of the utility ples.
Aseg sutrT TsCuntCAL AowtSOM isTA).
O b.
shif t advisore w111 probably be required, et least for some ehlf te.
- e.
- oe not pies to use ohlf t edelsore unlese mass esferessee cirew stance ertoes.
t 4
6-84 DATE cvenATasec suf rv enre trmCe Prgi 1 of 1
[
PLAss? rwee Farni 2 Plent M migtment Staff l
UTILITT Detrcit Edison Jos TITtze
@,L. DAfg 6-30-84 asuctzAn PCset a PLAw? CxPs:stseCE rom openATInc sufrT rostTtoess twoTe t) zwTem ontas secesfushoosmos a watcarteeG PActon tsEtcIsTt 30G nAx!Must TTre or expen:suCe PACTom CarntT I
2 3
4 5
s T
e e
to
- 1. SAME TYPE CosWEBactAL spo 1.00 Iso LIMIT
- 2. syrteER CIlsWWaCI AL spo
.75 NO LIMIT
- 1. safe TTPE CossetectAL hp 1.00 1e0 LIMIT I
- 4. OTWSR CtBWERCtAL po 4.15 too LIMt?
- 5. leAVT testLIThatt seuCLEAR 3s geouTus 36 tRO. Eas5, Bouse, Pfugl 4.50 (OTW:Ill 9.25
. 4. stnutATOR 12 seoseTus
^
(nsrzasasCs pt.Asr?)
5.ee sta soouTust t; tut tant 2.ee is peosmes:
9 9
9 9
9
- 1. auctzAn PtAssT esPenteiscs oss seirt (Owns PLAset 24 nouTus 12 12 12 12 12 tizss TnAss a 1/2 Tensis PntOn To r.L.:
e.75 sta seosteest u
u 12 12 12 tesons Tusas a 1/2 TsAas PatoR To r.i..)
s.se sta snowfust f_7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 2.5
- s. LICEnsur Ctarsnoose TastatuG Amo sarwe e.s2 o wastus
[
tonen 7tAsrre
- 9. PAmTICIPAftaus AT OPERATIIeG PLAss?
8.15 12 peouTMS
- 10. OTIIEJ IsuCI4AR P AseT sIPE9tEIRCE 9.25 12 peoustus t1. CraecuCTIIIG LICfESE TRAINIleG 0.25 9 nosefus g
1 12.' DecptB (EssGeNEEntle0, APPLIED sCIEleCE OR t w iv4Lew?:
12 seosmos 12 teaCurtons escares (12 seoemes:
12 12
.l' (AssoCIAfss neances is peoemest t
88.5 52.5 40.5 '40.5 47.5 total souctsaa plan? surca:Ence:
I 180f 4ssf!CIPATICIe B7:MERIENCP TIsa a 20% MtstAria (vus) sTAKTUP & 5;M.TOpeII (Tts/Im2) le0NTtis Ole seltf7 j
IIUTE se sEE *stesTIBUCTIOle3 FOR tasE or getCLEAR PCMBR FIAle? RIPERIEleCE FACTORS FOR L;tgCg Ques OP TWC FOLIAtstleGs OPERATIseG seIIFT PostTIOces (OL APPLICAssfel' tesCLuot ALL SNIFT surtavtsons (sel, seltFT Sno's, IIEACTOR CrtitAfons (110) @
a.
shif t advloore emot be used to setlefy the ' hot participation Aue SWIFT TEC3seetCAL ADWisOsts estA).
esperience' requirements of the utility plan.
Isoft to b.
shif t edelsoro ut:1 probably be required, et toast fer esme shif ts.
O c. 'Do not plan to use ohlf t advisors untese ecuse esaforeseen circurr-stance ertoes.
T un
oATE 3-6-84 oPERATsua surr? ExPERiescE Pc821 of 1 Pla057 unset Farn. 2 Shift TzChniC 1 Advisor trrtLITT Detrait Edison J0e TITtz:
(NOTE 2)
C.L. DATE 6-30-84
,,,,g,,,),
roR oPEmAvsma snar? Pos T Uses tuorE II EstrER DATA:
muerrush x wEscuT sec rm HEICMT1HG MAXIMUM TTPE or EvPER EseCE FACTom cREo 7 3
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
to 1
- 1. sAseE TTPE CasseERCIAL spo 1.ee eso LaMtf
- 2. orNER COBWERCI AL Spo 75 Iso LIMIT
- 1. SAME TYPE CosetERCIAL 8t0 1.99 MO LIMIT
- 4. orWER C(seMEllCIAL B0 0.75 MO LIMIT
- 5. Ia4WY (MILITART) BeUCLsAR 36 MONTHS 24 (110. Eies. 500W, trust 4.50 3
(OTNED) 0.25
- 4. SIseptaTOR 12 MONTHS (RErEReeCE Plants 5.ee 112 pouTust
(; ns aR 2.ee to founfus)
.75
.75
.75 9
9
- 7. NUCLEAR PIaer? EIPERIBsBCE 010 Suf r7 (ONII PLAerF) 24 900NTMs 6
6 6
6 6
(LESs Tlease 1 1/2 TEARS PRIOst TO F.L.)
0.75 (12 feONTHsl (1e08E TeeA00 1 1/2 TEARS PRIOR TO r.L.)
8.50 (12 880NTMs) 2 2
- s. LaCEnsto c AssR00s: TRAtusses Amo BaAn o.se 9 noemes 2
2 2
~
Ouse piaerts
- 9. PARTICIPATICII AT oPEPAT!NG PLAef?
9.75 12 De0NT10s 9.75 12 9.5 6.25 12 to. orieEl IfUCLEAR PIase? EEPERIENCE fG.25 12 m
- 11. CONOUCTileG LICEIIst TRAINING S.25 9 De0IITMS
- 12. DECREE (EseC'peEERIIsc, APPLIED SCIEleCE OR WJUIVALENT) 42 feOBffits esAcmetops oEcRett (12 Moorrust 12 12 12 12 12 (ASSOCIATES DEGREP)
(6 feONTHSD TorAL uvCamaR Pian? EsPER EleCE O 30.5 32.75 30.25 62.25 41 1107 PARTICIPATIGIe EXPERIElect T188
- 20% Pepp/fPfR (WilS)
STARTUP 6 sNUTWinte (TEs/IBOI leowfus ou sutr?
10ert le sEE
- mstpuCvtOus r0R Ust cP wUCLEAR PousR Flaerr EnPERIEuCE rACToms roR CutCa one rr TuS roLLowtuce OPERAfleeG SHIRT PostT1080s (OL APPLICA0ETSl*
shift advisore must be used to settsfy the
- hot participation 11078 2:~
IseCLUDE ALL sNlrf SUPERVIs0RS (sSI, SNir? SRO'S, REACTOR OPERATOfts (810) @
e.
esperience* requirements of the utility plan.
Asso sutrT TECnef1 CAL ADVISosts (STA).
b.
shif t advisore w.11 probably be required, et least for como shif ts.
O c. 'Do not plan to use shif t advisors tantese some esnforosome circum stance ertoes.
4 g.,
Pzgi 4 cf 4 3-6-84 ongE
,,,,,, g,,
PLAer? HAseE Farmi 2 UTILITT Detr*it Edicon Joe T171a: Nuc1**r suDeret.in. Onerator tuorE al 6-30-84
@.L. DATg
,g, roe OPEAAT181G SNIPT POSITIoses (sooTE 1)
EsfTER DATA, MONTNS/MoNTNS E OfEICIITIt0C FACTOR esEICIITIIIG MAE f Muse TYPE OF REPERItalCE PACTOR CREDff 1
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
18
- 3. OTHER COMMERCIAL 390
.75 eso Lint?
- 1. SAM TTPE CopetERCIAL RD 1.00 NO LIMIT
- 4. OFIIER CosetERCIAL 80 9.15 NO LIMIT 3
18 9
36 p
H mowTuS
- s. uhWT anIL.tT.ARYM. E s. 0 UCtaAR.
PP.S tofuBR s.25 16.5 16.5 21 21 e, cassutatoa 12 seoutuS spErEREnct PLAseft s.ee sta seossvnS (Sansaam:
2.ee to nontuSp 9
9 7, NUCtaAR PLAer? EEPERIBIBCE 000 SNIFT (0MII PIN 8F]
24 nD4THS 12 6.75 3.75 4.5 5.25 taass TuAss a n/2 TEasiS PRiost vs r.L.:
e.7s (32 seowTnSi 1*5 (noRE TuAn a 1/2 TEARS eRioR To r.L.:
e.Se 112 noemeS e.se 9 nouTuS 7.5 7.5
- e. LICEu,st,o,C,,ia,,S,h, acuss TansminG Ano sEAn go,
9, PARTICirATION AT OPERATIIIG PIAff?
8.15 12 pacerfnS 9
- 10. OTHEJ ISUCLEAR PLAfr? BEPERIEleCB 0.25 12 peolefuS
- 81. ColecuCT110G LICENSE TRAIIIING 0.25 9 peostTNS j
- 12. DECREE lENG'setERING. APPLIBO SCIBleCE OR EaulvALEuT) 12 seosmeS teAcuttmRS DECREE)
(12 seowfus (ASSOCIATES DEcRass as
..-83 TorAL muciaAst Plaser REPERtEnca' 49.5 57.75 33.75 40.5 35.25 Ilof PARTICIPATICII EXPERIEWCE TI M e 29% PWR/F9A tesBS)
STAllTUP & SNUTDOMIO ITES/NOS pecert1BS tse SIIIPT
.. ~..
geofE le SEE *IseSTRUCTI0tes rost USE OF NUCLEAR POWER plant EEPERIEleCE FACTosts 6 5R CIIECE Oste OF TWE FOLI4nfileGs OPERAflIIG SWIFT POSITIOles 100 APPLICA8ffS)*
Shif t advloore must be used to setlefy the ' hot partic!Petten IM-LUDE AA Sutr? SUPERVISORS (SS), SWIFT SRO'S. DEACToft OPERATORS (RO) @
a.
esperience* requirements of the utility plen.
poets 2:
AND SHIFT TECIRetCAL ADVISORS ESTA).
O b.
Satre ad teor =staterobabir b= res=8 red, et i t for es e emitte.
O e. 'Do not pleR to use shif t advloors unless some unforeseen cirrure-stance erlees.
6
oATE 3-6-84 Fage 3 of 4 o,g,,,,,,,g,,,,,,,,.;.,,,,c, PtAspr stAME F5rmi 2 vrthsTT Detroit Ediron Nuclser Supervising Operstor
.50s TITt2 e.L. oATE 6-30-84 su TE al
,,,,,,,,,,,,,3,
,,,,.I En rom oPEmATIIBG SNtFT POSITIOIIS (NOTE 19 gwfEg OATAs fe0grfMS/MONTNS I tfEICMTigeG PAcyo, esttCIITIIIG MAX t feUse TTPE OF ESPEAIEleCE PACTom CREDIT I
3 3
4 6
T 9
Io I. SAME TTPE C0sosEsICtAL Smo 1.ee slo LIMIT
- 2. OTIIER CopWW9CIAL SWO
.75 000 LIMIT
- 1. SAME TYPE CopostaCIAL 310 1.ee 100 LIMIT
- 4. OTHER CopgeERCI AL SuO e.?S 100 LIMIT 33 30 3
21.5 17 21 29 11
- 5. mAvT (MILITAaT mUCLEAR 26 M0wTuS torutas e.2s 2
6 16.5 7.25 15.5 10.5 7
19 tao. Eus. E0ow, PruS) e.Se
- 4. s:mplafon 32 escemis inrEnsisCE PLasrep s.ee st2 esowfust Elsna' Amp 2.ee 89 enautust 9
9 9
3 9
- 7. muCLEam PIAIFF EEPERIENCE CII SWIFT (Obel PIAarr) 24 MONTMS 3
2.25 6
12 4.5 12 5.25 4.5 6
2.25 (12s3 TuAm 1 t/2 TEAn$ prion To r.L.
e.7s (12 MusefuS 12 7
iseosE Tilass 1 1/2 VEAn$ Patop TO F.L.S e.5e (12 Sens!Tus)
- s. LICEnsto CtaS$a00st TahantnG Asm ExAss e.se 9 senerras 7.5 7.5 7.5 3
7.5 touse P:AerT
- 9. PARTICIPATICII AT OPERATIIIG PIANT e.?S 1 2 800157988
- 10. OTWE3 ISUCIJAR PtAs0T SEPEDIBIICE e.25 12 8e0ImIS
!!. CONDUCT!uG LICEless TRAINING e.25 9 feastTels
- 12. 'TCREE (ENGfteEER8mG. APPLIED SCIEBICE OR E30tval2se?)
12 gensmss (BACMElems DECptEl sta se0 071081 (ASSOCIATES DEGeEE)
(6 a,.
)
38 33.25 42 40.5 49.75 25 37.75 36 42 48.75 wTAL wuCLEAR Paasrl cRPERIENCBs NOT PAaTICIPAft(Es EIPEptEisCE TIME
- 2et pern/ireR subs)
STARTUP & SIIUTDOWN (TES/IIO) 8000r750 0I0 SII!FT geoTE 1:
SEE *IIGSTRUCTICIIS POR 4f88 0F IBUCI2AR POWER PIAlfT EXPERIE3eCE FACTons FnP CNECE Oues or Ties roLlattigeGs OrgnAfsleG SMIFT POSIT 10eIS (OL APPLICAsITSl*
Shif t bdvisore must twP essed to setlefy the 'thot participettee esperience* resguirements of the utility pies.
Asso SNIFT TECustICAL A0vISOAS :STA).
O c.
- Do not plan to esse ehlf t advisore unlees mues eenforeseen cirewe-stance arises.
s'
DATE 3 'e84 N12 d 4
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,7,,,,c, 08Asrr asAnt Fermi 2 Nuclaer SuperviRing Oper* tors UTIL TT Detroit Editon JOB TITLE:
E.L. DATE 6-30-84 asuCLEAR PCIIE2 PtJWeT EIPEllENCE POR OPERAYlIBG SWIFT POEITIONS (seDTE Il ggyTg8 DATAs MONTHS / MONTHS X afEIGNTIl0G FACTOR l
tsEICUSTIIIG MAftfeUM TYPE OF EEPEAIENCE PACToft CREDIT 1
2 3
4 5
6 7
8 9
IS l
- 1. Sasis TYPE CasseERCIAL Sao 1.ee eso Lint?
4
- 2. OFNER CosseERCIAL Sao
.75 Iso LIMIT
- 1. SAFE TTPE COIWEERCIAL RO 1.4e Is0 LIMIT
- 4. OftBER CopeKsRCIAL RO e.75 110 LIMIT
- s. mAvT th LITAevs nuctaAR H noerrnS 5
21 21 17.5 31.5 2.5 21.5 2.5 6
(No. Eus, 800er, PruS R.se 21.75 7.5 13 18.5 4.5 25.75 7.25 16.25 15 torwER:
e.25
- e. SteiusATom la noem $
. sRErERosCE PIAser) s.ee (32 enournst u tan s. hip 2.ee q9 nowTuS) 9 9
9 9
9 9
9
- 7. muCtaAR PLAser EzPERieuCE Oss satrT tones Ptaser) 24 nowTus 12 12 12 4.5 3.75 8.25 3.75 2.25 12 (1258 TIBAss ! 1/2 TEARS Phl0A TO F.L.D e.75 (12 fe0NTHS:
.5 anoRE TuAss 1 1/2 TEARS PRIOR To r.L.)
s.Se (la seouTust 9
- s. *.ICENSIS CIASSROO90 TRAIntuG Asip 3EApl e.Se 9 squemes 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 (CasN PIAfrr)
- 9. PAffflCIPATIOle AT OPSRATIIIG PIAftf e.75 12 peouTuS le. OTWE2 HUCLEAR PIAlt? SEPERIEseCE e.25 12 pealeTIIS
- 11. CONOuCTIIIG LICENSE TRAINIIIG e.25 9 ge0NTIIS
- 12. 08 GREE LEI 8G'IBEERING, APPLIED SCIE 8eCE OR fQutvaLENT) 12 genef7HS (SAOGEtXHIS DECRSE)
(12 pgagmeS)
(ASSOCIATES DEGIIEE)
(6 u u.5)
MAL puC 4AR PIAser sarERassICE:
56.25 28.5 57 46 40.5 56.25 53 49 38 33.5
=_
8007 PARTICIPATIGIf EIPERIEleCE
- ME o 2et PerR/sr*R (waSi JARTue a SmuTocues (TES/nop VJerTieS 010 SIIIrT TE 1
SEE *IstSTRUCTICIIS FOR USE OF IluctaAR POWER PIAest EXPERIEph2 FACTORS FOR CisECE OseE OF TIIE FCLIAbflIIGs OPERATIsso SsBIFT POSIT 80MB (CL APPLICAIITe)*
N a.
Shift advisore must be eased to mattef the
- hot participation TE 2:
ItsCLunt ALL SNIPT SuPfRVISORS (801, SHIFT SRO's. REACTOR OPERAfosIS (Rol esperlesere*.equiremente of the utill y plea.
Asso SMIFT TECupstCAL ADW1SOAS (STA).
O b.
Shif t adotoore w111 probably be required, at least for some abitte.
O =
a= aat Ptaa== i=== =ma r= **'s ar= =at======= isar re ee en re -
stance artees.
e
tate 3-6-B%
mi1d4 o,,,,,,,,a,,,,,,,,,,,,,,c, Paser mAnt Farmi 2 yr:LaTT Detroit Edixon NuC1scr dupervising Operstor goe ggy,,,
e.L. DATE 6-30-84 tasME 23 rom optaATimo sg:PT Pos TsonS tuoTE t)
EarrEn DATAs seagrrnS/peaseries X wEIcnTIIeG PAcron eIElollTIIIG mAIIMUM TYPE or EarterBasCE PACTom Caro 7 1
2 3
4 s
s T
S e
to
- 1. sAnt TYPE CossetaCIAL sao 1.ee aso LIMIT 36
- 2. OrIIER CasosaCIAL Sao
.75 Iso LIMt?
- 1. SAsE TYPE CosseESC1AL Ro 1.9e Ho LIMIT
- 4. OTWES CENWERCIAL 90 0.75 too LIMIT
- 5. mAvT insL:TAmT mUCLEAn M seostrus 36 21 18 30 6
10 35.5 24
$,, ' """"' "I
[
7 O
14 9
21 3
21 18.75 18
.5 12
- 4. (IHtf!AToR I2 fooNTHS entrEssisCE Ptserrs s.co (32 noerries (2:n:LAns 2.se to seawTust 9
9 9
3 9
9 9
- 7. auct.Ema P: Asst EsPEnteesCE oss Smar? sown PLAstra 24 noemes 12 12 6
12 4.5 3.75 12 12 7.5 3
(1258 TRA00 1 1/2 TEARS PRIolt To F.L.D 0.75
<!2 3eDDITH5)
Issoot TmAss 1 1/2 TEAa5 Pasos To r.L.
e.se (12 mosefus 4.5_
- e. t Causro CsAssacous Tm4:stt:s Aso saAss e.5e s seosrrus 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 toues P:Asrrn i
9 PAf1TICIPATIoM AT oPEA4 TING PIAlef 8.75 12 MisTtIS l'
IIE2 IIUCLEAR FIAleT SEPE93BIICE 0.25 la snowfus 8.5 11.
~ MIIEG LICENSE TRAINIIBG S.25 s ponerTNS 2
87 l CREE IsleGiuttatesG, APPLIED SCIsleCE om EQUIVALENTI 12 feastfits (SACMElems DECREtt (12 noNTHS)
_ _(AssoCIA?ES DECREE)
(6 u. s) tras usuCsaan P: Ass? EsPtnIsssCE' 64.5 63.5 49.5 38.5 51 30.75 57.25 46.5 60 75 r
100T PANT!CIPATIolf EIPERIENCE E o aos Pue/ yen tunSI ARTUP 6 SNUTDotne (TES/ Iso) seoseTNS ott SIIIr?
"'rt I s SEE *IIISTRUCTicIIS FOR USE or IguCIAAR PoMER PLAfrF EXPERIEleCE FACTORS FOR CieECs os 5 or TIBE POLI.otfIIIGI ortnArnteG SaltrT PoSITIous (ob APPLICAIITSl*
E e.
shift advisors must be used to settery the ' hot perticipetten
/r8 2:
IIsCLUDE ALL SWIr? SUPERVIsoAS (SS), SWIFT Sao'S, HEACTolt oPERAToms (1101 esperience" requirements of the uttlity ples.
AleD SNIr? TECIINICAL AovtsoRS ISTAl.
b.
shif t advisoro witt rrobabtv he required, et least for same phitto.
O e-
== aat **== to use shift advisore unlese some emiforoceen cireure-etence artees.
3 # - 84 Prgi i cf 1 Dave opga,,,e,,,,,,,,,_,,,c, Pgasyy ganseg Farmi 2 Detrait Ediaon Nuc~. ear Avsistrnt Shift Supervisor pr:LITT Joe TITLES
@.L. DATs 6d usuCLsAR Pons 3 Plass? f,11PE2IssP"J rom oPanaTina surrt Pos:Teous thurs il essTs3 DATAs seDemes/seoNTMs s WelGNTIssG PACToR essIcesTIssG seAsiseUst TYPs or asPsatzesCT FACTom casDIT 1
2 3
4 5
6 T
a t
to i
I. eJuss TTPs CassesaCIAL sao 1.0e eso Lan 7 4
4 4
.t. ornsa CinesseCIAL suo
.75 eso Lan 7
- 1. sAns TTP CasseseCIAL a0 1.ee eso a.IMIT
- 4. ofessa Coset"mCIAL po e.75 eso Ling?
- 5. mAvT in LITAsT esuCtsAn 36 seoserns 28 30 7.5 tao, sus scow, Pruss e.se 8
21 6
13.75 torusas e.25
- c. sinutaTon 32 sconfus emersassecs Paasure s.ee (32 nowrus I; n: Lamp 2.co to noemess 9
9 9
9 9
9
- 7. =
- tsAn P aser ::PsateuCs oss sair? soun Praarra 24 nowfus 12 12 12 12 12 12 (Less TnAss 1 1/2 TsAns Patoes To F.L.)
0.7s (12 stoutisel tuoms TuAn 1 1/2 TsAas Paton To r.L.
e.se (12 suosmos:
12 11.5 12 12
- s. stCsusso CLAssmoon TnA stuG-amo s Ass e.se o pioerrns 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 (osses PlassT)
- 9. P'_RTICIPAT!ou AT oPshATIssG Plasst e.75 12 esusefses
- 13. f %sa HuCIAAR FIAsst s PsStsHCs e.25 12 seassTHS St.
'spuCTIssG LICsessa TRAIN!ssG 9.25 9 MoHTess
- 12. C3pse isHGTHusR$ssG, APPLIs0 sCIsssCs OR s3ulWALsNT) 12 nnestus isACnstans Oscassi (32 asowfust (Assoc ATss omonsst as seassfuss vrAL seuCazAn riaser sursassucss 40.5 76 61.5 68.5 44.5 53.75 t
esor PARTICIPATIoM s P:RisHCs A
15 15 15 71ses a 20t Pun / spen suus) sTAstruP a swufacum (Tes/esos yes yes yes 4
4 4
seouTus ou sutrv esors as ses *tustaucTrous rom oss or wuCLsAn PousR Plass? ssPsstessCs FACTons M CNsCs assa or Tils PoLlmstisGs or RATissG sesIFT PostTIcess lob APPLICAerrel*
IssCLuDs ALL sNIPT sursRVisons issl, seBIPT sad's. sesACTom or RATosse (ssol y e.
esperience* requirements of the ut!!!y the ' hot participation shift advisore must be used to setlef seofs 2s ty plan.
Asso sNIPT TsCNutCAL ADWIsons (sTAI.
b.
shif t edyteoro w111 probably be required, et least for same shif te.
O a ' a= aat Piaa===== =ht te ad t=ar= =a2=====mo==foreseea et re -
stance erlees.
4 5
9 A
t ir e
g D
3 84 regi 1 et i oPraATIwG snar? ExPc' EnCE PBAer? Isaa E Fur;:i 2 Nuclear Shift Supervisor terILITT Detroit Ediam
. sos TITS.Es
.L. DATE bDM IIUCt. EAR PC*E2 PLAerf CEPE"IEleCE FOR OPERATluf JufPT N f?IceBS {18trl 1)
ESITER DATAs MouTIBS/MoNTNS E ggEICIITipsG PACTOR IEEICIIT110G MARIseUM TTPE OF EXPERIEleCE PACTom CREDIT I
2 3
4 5
6 T
3 9
38
- 1. SAftE TYPE CUge EACI AL Sao 1.Se 100 LIMIT 4
+2. OTNEst COMBEACI AL Sao
.T5 aso Lint?
k
- SAFE TTPE ConseractAL 90 1.Se NO LIMIT
( ^;10ER CtBWEACIAL 90 9.75 000 LIMIT 5.
avT intLITARTI suuCLEAR 36 peoseTuS 36 6
ello. EuS, Boom, PPuS) 4.50 21 (UTieEmp 9.25 S.
7,UtAToa 12 stoNTa$
spErEnEnCE PuSrr) 5.ee (12 nouTust tilna tans 2.se is nouTuSp 9
9 9
9 9
9 7.
rs.EAn P:Asre EsPEntouCE one Smart tause P Asert 24 siouTuS 12 12 17 12 12 12 (tESS TIIAN I 1/2 TEARS Pet 0R TO F.L.)
0.75 (12 peoefTHS) 12 12 12 _
12 12 e.Se sta seosefus,
, esecaE Tuass 1 1/2 TEAas Patosi To r.L.
7.5 7.5 e a CEnsEo C AS$ noon TnatasuG Ano EnAsl e.Se 9 mouTuS 7.5 7.5 7.5 7.5 -
tomes P:Asers 9.
aRTICIPATIOle AT OPSRATIIIG PLAlef 0.75 12 MoltTMS IO.'. OfteE2 ISUCLEAR PIABIT SEPERIsleCE 0.25 12 MONTHS
- 11. CoNOUCTING LICENSE TRAINING 0.25 s suarfuS 12c ( T REE (ENG'feEERIIIG, APPLIED SCIBIICE OR EQUlvA1.EseT) 12 MONTHS toACnEtosis oECnEE s12 scournSi (ASSOCIATES DECRSS)
(6
.,u i Sl T07A8, puCLEAa P: Ant SmPEntsuCE:
68.5 40.5 40.5 40.5 67.5 40.5 Igor PANTICIPATICII BNPSatENCE TRIE
- 20% Perg/gren (uSS) 15 STAllTUP 6 SIOUTDoInl (TES/Hol 788 4
noortuS one SutrT se0TE 1s SEE *IceSTauCTtouS rom tsSE OF uuCLEAR PcifBR PBAlf? EXPERIENCE FACTons FOR CIEECE ONE OF TIBE FOLIAef tsIGs OPERATIIeG SetIFT POSITICtes (OL APPLICAAITSl*
INCIAfDE ALL SWIFT 9UPERVISOIIS (88), SIIIPT SRO'S, REACToll OrtstATORS (RO) @e.
Shift advisore usuet to used to settery the ' hot participation esperience* requirements of the utility plan.
ge0TE 2 Also SNIFT TFCuestCAL Atr*1SOltS (STA).
Q b.
Shif t advisoro w111 probably be required, et least for aces ehlf te.
O c.
- Do not pien to use shif t edeleet e unlese some unforeseen circurr-stance erlees.
b.k '
j4 I
l l
1