ML20081C412

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comments of Jf Doherty on Des (NUREG-1026).Statement Must Clarify If,In Analysis of Environ Impacts of Postulated Accidents,Any Credit Given for Applicant Compliance W/Any TMI-related Requirements.Related Correspondence
ML20081C412
Person / Time
Site: Braidwood  
Issue date: 03/07/1984
From: Doherty J
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To: Stevens J
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
RTR-NUREG-1026 NUDOCS 8403140040
Download: ML20081C412 (2)


Text

.

r--[ U $ n D

t IlCUJ"'D c~ r 2.-

A.'

'.'DENCE March 7, l?SA co.t gg7tr

w. twu

.v.....-_... 0_7 u v...,'

..u.w., _n v.

3 ' '. r..;.. *v J~ m'e.m _ v.

m (DsCz~"a~R 1933)

~n...

~~

m -.

sm.

_v c

'84 MAR 12 P1 :40 ns. Janice c,.. crevens Division of Licensinc

, Fr...,,r T SQvh.

w

m.. a U. S. Iluclear Berulet0r7 C or.is :io n 00CiZimG

'dashinrton D. C. 20555 ERANCH

~

John F. Doherty, of 313 3unmit ?.v e.

Brighton, Mass. 02135, contents as below on the D2S (I!UR5G-1026),for the Braidwood Station. Units 1 & 2, Dochet 50s. ST 50-456,h57 COMMENT DOHIRFi 1 In Aopendix C, at tage C-6, the following statement is made "To illustrate: A sinrle codel 1030-::de L'dR ooeratinr at at an SO,'S caoacity. factor for 30 rears would be pred5cted to induce between 3.5 and 5.7 cancer fatalities in 100 vears, 5 7 and 17 in 500 years, and 55 and 60 in 1000

-years as a result of releases of raion-222.d H7 concera is that the DES has not c::cletely described the fuel cvele intact in Anpendix 0.

The concern is not impact of the coara: ion of the clant to the reneral public.

Snecifically, the 333 should contain a statenent of:

a) The ranre of number of non-f atal concer injuries induc ed hv fuel cycle raion-222 for 7 ovidiar fuel for the BraidwoodStation) Units 1

& 2, fSr its orojected cap-acity factor.(304 and licensing period (43 years).

b) The rance of number of non-fatal birth defects induced by fuel cycle radon-222 for nrovidin-fuel for the acityfactor(S0a) Units 1&2,foritsprojectedcap-Bratiwnod Station and licensing neriod (40 years).

C v.,.. -v, n

- r n z-,n,v.

2

=a sa On Face ; 96 of the Stitemen;, it says, "The lower limit o r the run: e ecu'.i be eero because chare ac" be biolo cal mechanisms that can renair Camace caused by radiation at low done ani/or 10se rates." (Ohc discussion is of risk of deaths from cance- {ue to en"Osure to nicnt radioactive materials, etc.)

Thic statemen; is 8403140040 840307

.PDR ADOCK 05000456 O

PDR 3

e 1

a n m......,, c v v.- u... s J.7 J,....,

. DO.a.m.

m.,.,v. 3.t. :.J,,.

]. a,_,.,u,s.. Du (.,;;,v,..,..,.R,:983 c :. 2 al:

.u anc,

unsannorted by referenr.e, or docunentation, and this Comnentor

':nc is but' one item doing this.

The Statement should be altered to.nclu.le what-backs this nosition.

n~

. um, r Dn:n. yu.,v.

vv.

v.

The Statement needs to clarify if in the analysis of environmental impacts of oostulated accidents any credit was

-iven for Applicant comoliance tith an r of the T:-:I-related recaironents of IIUREG-737 " Clarification of TMI.iction Olan Recuire7ents".

Thank you for the opoortunit-t: c 0== en t.

(...)

p

/

/

.AfV tb John 2. Doherty J

t i

1.

1 l

r-k t

t 1

[